COMPARISON OF GIRDER DIMENSIONS

BEAM DIMENSION RESULT Max Moment EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS
MOMENT EXCESS
DESIGNATION FAILURE MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT Maximum Shear LENGTH
WIDTH DEPTH TOP BOT CAPACITY MOMENT 800x500 800x550 700x550 1000x550 900x550 700x550 600x550
(PASSED OR FAILED)
G1 800 500 PASSED 6.3
G2 800 550 PASSED 6.3
G3 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1128.89 564.45 950 178.89 178.89 766.125 6.3
FLAGWALL 800 550 PASSED 6.9
G4 800 500 PASSED 6.9
G5 800 500 PASSED 6.3
G6 800 500 PASSED 6.3
G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2297.26 1148.63 1500 797.26 797.26 770.012 10.5
G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
G10 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2238.47 1119.23 1500 738.47 738.47 779.462 10.5
G11 900 550 PASSED 7.0
G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2206.77 1103.38 1500 706.77 706.77 712.844 10.5
G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
G6 800 550 PASSED 7.2
G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
G29 800 500 PASSED 7.2
G30 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1265.66 632.83 950 315.66 315.66 656.397 7.2
G4 800 500 PASSED 7.0
G49 800 500 PASSED 7.0
G31 800 500 PASSED 7.2
G24 700 500 PASSED 8.1
G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
G33 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2056.49 1522.86 1500 556.49 556.49 762.047 10.2
G34 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2144.97 1830.52 1500 644.97 644.97 1109.603 6.6
CONTINUOUS

G35 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1907.01 1699.40 1500 407.01 407.01 1213.707 6.3
G36 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2977.66 2601.11 1500 1477.66 1477.66 1015.872 9.8
G37 1000 550 PASSED 7.2
G38 1000 550 PASSED 6.3
G39 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2099.85 1388.62 1500 599.85 599.85 622.653 10.2
CONTINUOUS

G40 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1795.16 1415.67 1500 295.16 295.16 741.576 6.6
G41 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2085.66 2004.07 1500 585.66 585.66 1000 8.9
CONTINUOUS

G42 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1787.46 1410.44 1500 287.46 287.46 693.290 6.7
G43 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1993.63 1630.95 1500 493.63 493.63 523.851 9.3
 G44 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
G13 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1848.94 1569.83 1500 348.94 348.94 663.210 6.6
CONTINUOUS

G14 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1819.90 1514.80 1500 319.90 319.90 812.119 6.3
G15 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2244.54 1605.68 1500 744.54 744.54 786.827 9.8
G16 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1823.35 1449.64 1500 323.35 323.35 785.853 7.2
G17 1000 550 PASSED 6.3
G18 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1761.14 1367.39 1500 261.14 261.14 1050.512 6.6
CONTINUOUS

G19 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2426.13 1785.43 1500 926.13 926.13 824.340 8.9
G20 1000 550 PASSED 6.7
G21 1000 550 PASSED 9.3
G22 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
G12 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2136.76 1731.62 1500 636.76 636.76 816.679 7.6
G26 600 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1311.98 1114.71 850 461.98 461.98 703.503 5.2
G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
CONTINUOUS

G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0

G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0
G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
G26 600 550 PASSED 5.2
G12 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2710.85 2282.22 1500 1210.85 1210.85 976.269 7.7
G46 800 550 EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE DEFL. 11.2
G45 900 500 PASSED 7.7
G47 600 500 PASSED 8.4
G47 600 500 PASSED 6.0
CONT.

G48 600 500 PASSED 6.0

G47 600 500 FAILED FLEXURE 857.47 444.61 700 157.47 398.418 8.4
G45 900 500 PASSED 7.7
G46 800 550 EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE DEFL. 11.2
MAX VALUE: 315.66 0.00 0.00 1477.66 0.00 0.00 461.98