Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Comparison of Girder Dimensions (30f-38f) - Girders That Exceed Column

    Uploaded by

    Jason toralde
    4 views3 pages
    This document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. It found that: - Beams with widths of 800mm or 1000mm and depths of 500mm or 550mm either passed or failed due to flexural stresses. - Beams that failed exceeded the maximum moment capacity and showed the highest excess moments. - Beams with greater widths and depths tended to have higher moment capacities and were less likely to fail.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    This document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. It found that: - Beams with widths of 800mm or 1000mm and depths of 500mm or 550mm either passed or failed due to flexural stresses. - Beams that failed exceeded the maximum moment capacity and showed the highest excess moments. - Beams with greater widths and depths tended to have higher moment capacities and were less likely to fail.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    4 views3 pages

    Comparison of Girder Dimensions (30f-38f) - Girders That Exceed Column

    Uploaded by

    Jason toralde
    This document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. It found that: - Beams with widths of 800mm or 1000mm and depths of 500mm or 550mm either passed or failed due to flexural stresses. - Beams that failed exceeded the maximum moment capacity and showed the highest excess moments. - Beams with greater widths and depths tended to have higher moment capacities and were less likely to fail.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 3

    COMPARISON OF GIRDER DIMENSIONS

    BEAM DIMENSION RESULT Max Moment EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS
    MOMENT EXCESS
    DESIGNATION FAILURE MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT Maximum Shear LENGTH
    WIDTH DEPTH TOP BOT CAPACITY MOMENT 800x500 800x550 700x550 1000x550 900x550 700x550 600x550
    (PASSED OR FAILED)
    G1 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1137.48 613.71 950 187.48 187.48 732.900 6.3
    G2 800 550 PASSED 6.3
    G3 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1306.72 674.86 950 356.72 356.72 620.002 6.3
    G49 800 550 PASSED 6.9
    G4 800 500 PASSED 6.9
    G5 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1239.12 619.56 950 289.12 289.12 648.565 6.3
    G6 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1146.22 717.88 950 196.22 196.22 467.532 6.3
    G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
    G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2447.83 1223.92 1500 947.83 947.83 800.507 10.5
    G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
    G10 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2421.82 1210.91 1500 921.82 921.82 827.797 10.5
    G11 900 550 PASSED 7.0
    G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2342.54 1171.27 1500 842.54 842.54 740.111 10.5
    G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
    G6 800 550 PASSED 7.2
    G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
    G29 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1232.44 616.22 950 282.44 282.44 628.580 7.2
    G30 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1376.85 688.43 950 426.85 426.85 692.795 7.2
    G4 800 500 PASSED 7.0
    G49 800 500 PASSED 7.0
    G31 800 500 PASSED 7.2
    G24 700 500 PASSED 8.1
    G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
    G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
    G33 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2161.88 1628.25 1500 661.88 661.88 588.833 10.2
    G34 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2384.66 2070.21 1500 884.66 884.66 818.805 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G35 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2173.64 1966.03 1500 673.64 673.64 1325.277 6.3
    G36 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 3185.27 2808.71 1500 1685.27 1685.27 1067.635 9.8
    G37 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1659.42 1340.59 1500 159.42 159.42 1018.687 7.2
    G38 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2052.30 1769.41 1500 552.30 552.30 991.399 6.3
    G39 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2236.32 1525.08 1500 736.32 736.32 653.849 10.2
    CONTINUOUS

    G40 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2063.45 1683.96 1500 563.45 563.45 834.441 6.6
    G41 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2243.81 2162.21 1500 743.81 743.81 1000.000 8.9
    CONTINUOUS

    G42 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1958.24 1581.22 1500 458.24 458.24 747.650 6.7
    G43 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2174.72 1812.04 1500 674.72 674.72 564.290 9.3
    G44 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
    G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
    G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
    G13 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2082.95 1792.41 1500 582.95 582.95 730.872 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G14 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2058.64 1753.54 1500 558.64 558.64 914.661 6.3
    G15 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2360.05 1721.20 1500 860.05 860.05 816.601 9.8
    G16 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2181.56 1807.85 1500 681.56 681.56 847.723 7.2
    G17 1000 550 PASSED 6.3
    G18 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1997.74 1603.99 1500 497.74 497.74 792.155 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G19 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2552.90 1912.20 1500 1052.90 1052.90 803.348 8.9
    G20 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1867.89 1466.04 1500 367.89 367.89 1106.837 6.7
    G21 1000 550 PASSED 9.3
    G22 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
    G12 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2662.18 2257.03 1500 1162.18 1162.18 990.136 7.6
    G26 600 550 PASSED 5.2
    G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    CONTINUOUS

    G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0


    G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0
    G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    G26 600 550 PASSED 5.2
    G12 1000 550 FAILED 3425.18 2996.55 1500 1925.18 1925.18 1200 7.7
    G46 800 550 EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE DEFL. 11.2
    G45 900 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1447.50 1075.82 1000 447.50 524.895 7.7
    G47 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    G47 600 500 PASSED 6.0
    CONT.

    G48 600 500 PASSED 6.0


    G47 600 500 FAILED FLEXURE 848.86 436.00 700 148.86 394.392 8.4
    G45 900 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1329.24 1036.01 1000 329.24 437.308 7.7
    G46 800 550 EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE DEFL. 11.2
    MAX VALUE: 426.85 0.00 0.00 1925.18 0.00 0.00 0.00

    You might also like