Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • Comparison of Girder Dimensions (20f-29f) - Girders That Exceed Column

    Uploaded by

    Jason toralde
    5 views3 pages
    1) The document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. 2) Several girder beams failed due to exceeding the maximum flexural moment capacity, while others passed. 3) Beam dimensions of width and depth were varied, and the maximum moments and shears were calculated and compared to failure thresholds.

    Original Description:

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    1) The document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. 2) Several girder beams failed due to exceeding the maximum flexural moment capacity, while others passed. 3) Beam dimensions of width and depth were varied, and the maximum moments and shears were calculated and compared to failure thresholds.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    5 views3 pages

    Comparison of Girder Dimensions (20f-29f) - Girders That Exceed Column

    Uploaded by

    Jason toralde
    1) The document compares the dimensions and failure modes of various girder beams. 2) Several girder beams failed due to exceeding the maximum flexural moment capacity, while others passed. 3) Beam dimensions of width and depth were varied, and the maximum moments and shears were calculated and compared to failure thresholds.

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as XLSX, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 3

    COMPARISON OF GIRDER DIMENSIONS

    BEAM DIMENSION RESULT Max Moment EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS EXCESS
    MOMENT EXCESS
    DESIGNATION FAILURE MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT MOMENT Maximum Shear LENGTH
    WIDTH DEPTH TOP BOT CAPACITY MOMENT 800x500 800x550 700x550 1000x550 900x550 700x550 600x550
    (PASSED OR FAILED)
    G1 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1270.49 746.72 950 320.49 320.49 821.920 6.3
    G2 800 550 PASSED 6.3
    G3 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1302.99 671.13 950 352.99 352.99 631.223 6.3
    FLAGWALL 800 550 PASSED 6.9
    G4 800 500 PASSED 6.9
    G5 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1260.16 630.08 950 310.16 310.16 662.688 6.3
    G6 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1256.96 828.61 950 306.96 306.96 496.281 6.3
    G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
    G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2433.97 1216.98 1500 933.97 933.97 797.671 10.5
    G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
    G10 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2419.55 1209.77 1500 919.55 919.55 827.279 10.5
    G11 900 550 PASSED 7.0
    G8 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2332.04 1166.02 1500 832.04 832.04 737.947 10.5
    G9 1000 550 PASSED 7.0
    G6 800 550 PASSED 7.2
    G7 700 550 PASSED 7.0
    G29 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1232.59 616.29 950 282.59 282.59 628.549 7.2
    G30 800 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1380.74 690.37 950 430.74 430.74 693.747 7.2
    G4 800 500 PASSED 7.0
    G49 800 500 PASSED 7.0
    G31 800 500 PASSED 7.2
    G24 700 500 PASSED 8.1
    G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
    G32 1000 550 PASSED 8.1
    G33 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2154.68 1621.04 1500 654.68 654.68 588.834 10.2
    G34 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2394.95 2080.50 1500 894.95 894.95 821.753 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G35 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2204.98 1997.37 1500 704.98 704.98 1362.138 6.3
    G36 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 3140.24 2763.68 1500 1640.24 1640.24 1063.863 9.8
    G37 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1694.80 1375.96 1500 194.80 194.80 1058.905 7.2
    G38 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2055.57 1772.68 1500 555.57 555.57 1022.752 6.3
    G39 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2213.36 1502.12 1500 713.36 713.36 650.317 10.2
    CONTINUOUS

    G40 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2067.42 1687.93 1500 567.42 567.42 835.663 6.6
    G41 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2229.76 2148.17 1500 729.76 729.76 1000 8.9
    CONTINUOUS

    G42 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1937.99 1560.97 1500 437.99 437.99 742.059 6.7
    G43 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2140.75 1778.07 1500 640.75 640.75 556.744 9.3
    G44 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
    G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
    G23 600 550 PASSED 8.1
    G13 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2070.38 1779.84 1500 570.38 570.38 728.208 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G14 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2185.61 1880.51 1500 685.61 685.61 971.148 6.3
    G15 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2361.89 1723.03 1500 861.89 861.89 812.622 9.8
    G16 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2260.34 1886.63 1500 760.34 760.34 867.919 7.2
    G17 1000 550 PASSED 6.3
    G18 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1976.73 1582.99 1500 476.73 476.73 785.102 6.6
    CONTINUOUS

    G19 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2545.42 1904.72 1500 1045.42 1045.42 802.314 8.9
    G20 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1890.75 1488.89 1500 390.75 390.75 886.875 6.7
    G21 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 1773.13 1197.09 1500 273.13 273.13 649.653 9.3
    G22 1000 550 PASSED 3.7
    G12 1000 550 FAILED FLEXURE 2714.53 2309.39 1500 1214.53 1214.53 1005.453 7.6
    G26 600 550 PASSED 5.2
    G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    CONTINUOUS

    G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0


    G28 600 500 PASSED 6.0
    G27 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    G26 600 550 PASSED 5.2
    G12 1000 550 FAILED BOTH 3535.07 3106.43 1500 2035.07 2035.07 1228.928 7.7
    EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE
    G46 800 550 DEFL. BY 22mm DEFL. 11.2
    G45 900 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1449.57 1077.89 1000 449.57 525.853 7.7
    G47 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    G47 600 500 PASSED 6.0
    CONT.

    G48 600 500 PASSED 6.0


    G47 600 500 PASSED 8.4
    G45 900 500 FAILED FLEXURE 1319.63 1026.39 1000 319.63 435.055 7.7
    EXCEEDS THE ALLOWABLE
    G46 800 550 DEFL. BY 22mm DEFL. 11.2
    MAX VALUE: 430.74 0.00 0.00 2035.07 0.00 0.00 0.00

    You might also like