Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project Quality includes the way activities are performed behind the scenes, the
resulting deliverables, and the continuous cycle between them. In this course,
you’ll recognize quality methodologies, tools, and standards that support project
quality. This includes ISO 9000, Lean, Six Sigma, Kanban, and Value stream
mapping.
Quality Management
[Video description begins] Topic title: Quality Management. Your host for the
session is Barbara Waters. [Video description ends]
It is very common for the terms, manage quality and control quality to be used
interchangeably in everyday life. But in project management they are very
different things. Managing quality has to do with our processes and procedures
and the way that we perform project work. On the other hand, controlling quality
has to do with the deliverables or the product service or result we are creating
and whether that deliverable meets requirements.
Let's think about managing quality using the example of a restaurant. The
processes and procedures that we follow are often not observable by the
customer. They're happening behind the scenes. Are the employees storing the
food properly? Practicing hand washing procedures and preparing and assembling
the food consistently? These are all quality management related questions.
Notice we haven't asked about how the food looks or tastes. Those will be
questions for controlling quality. When we review our processes to ensure that
they are efficient and appropriate, and when we verify that we are all following
procedures, we are performing an audit.
Audits are used to assess our actions, and they are an important tool for
managing quality. Managing quality is somewhat related to prevention and
reducing the cost of quality. Managing quality includes taking the time to do
things right, training our employees and documenting our processes. In cost of
quality, all of these are conformance activities that fall under prevention costs.
These costs should be considered an investment that will pay off through fewer
defects and non-conformance incidents that can be much more expensive.
Let's go behind the scenes in a restaurant to identify the activities for managing
quality. Employees arrive for the start of their shifts. Perhaps they spend 10
minutes with the manager who reviews some of the important processes and
procedures with everyone to ensure that they are followed. This would be a
training investment. As employees are working in the kitchen, they periodically
confirm that food storage temperatures are correct. They also follow a visual card
that shows how food is to be assembled on the plate before being served to the
customer. These are examples of documenting processes.
At the end of a shift, employees break down all of the equipment for a thorough
cleaning and they routinely service the ovens. This would be an investment in
equipment. Finally, there is an understanding among the staff that steps will not
be skipped to save time or money and that the continued investment in
prevention is a cost that is well worth it. As we conduct audits and assess our
quality management processes, we may not discover problems or mistakes. Are
there still opportunities to improve? Absolutely, we can always take steps to
improve our processes using continuous improvement. While performing project
work, we should always be questioning the activities that don't add value and
work to remove or reduce those activities.
Excessive wait time between handoffs of project deliverables, repeatedly walking
long distances between workstations and under-utilizing employee skills can all be
considered wasteful. Focusing on the value added activities and eliminating
wasteful activities will result in more efficient processes. It is often the employees
who perform the actual work rather than management who can spot the
opportunities for improvement, because they know their jobs better than anyone.
In our restaurant kitchen example, the chef notices that she's been throwing
away a lot of produce at the end of each day. She modifies her standing order to
reduce the quantity of produce so less is wasted.
In another example, one line cook notices that he must walk around the other line
cook, every time he needs a certain ingredient that they both use. They decide it
would be better to place that ingredient in between them. Reducing the need for
extra movement in the kitchen. The dishwasher notices that there's some residual
food on the plates that requires washing them twice. By adding a pre-wash step
that takes only five minutes, the dishwasher can save 30 minutes by washing the
dishes only once. Continuous improvement does not have to be dramatic and
immediate. Improvements can be incrementally introduced into a process little by
little until a process is sufficiently improved. And I should mention that any of the
changes we make, as minor as they may seem, must go through change control to
ensure that the changes result in a benefit to the project as a whole.
Quality Control
[Video description begins] Topic title: Quality Control. Your host for the session is
Barbara Waters. [Video description ends]
Quality control has to do with the deliverables or the product, service or result we
are creating and whether that deliverable meets requirements. This is different
than quality management, which has to do with our processes and procedures
and the way that we perform project work. Let's think about quality control using
the example of a restaurant. This has to do with the deliverables and the
customer experience. Is the restaurant clean and inviting? Does the food taste
good and does it arrive in a reasonable amount of time? If I go to this restaurant
again tomorrow, will the food look and taste the same? What do the restaurant
reviews say about this establishment? These end user experiences occur when
the customer actually uses the deliverable.
Have you ever heard of a mystery shopper? That is a person who acts like a
patron of a restaurant or a retail store and then reports back to management.
They may be reporting on wait times, the manners and attentiveness of the wait
staff, the quality of the food, the cleanliness of the restrooms and more. A
mystery shopper is an investment in appraisal costs. They can provide valuable
feedback on items that need attention before they become non-conformance
issues in the hands of actual customers.
A health inspector is also part of the appraisal costs. The health inspector ensures
that the restaurant is conforming to quality requirements. If not, the inspector
can actually suspend the operation until quality is conforming again. As part of
the appraisal cost, the chef may also decide to taste every tenth plate of risotto to
make sure the rice is tender, but not sticky and that it is seasoned correctly. If the
chef notices a trend where the risotto is becoming too salty, she can advise the
staff to realign their processes to correct the issue.
If the chef decides to throw away a pot of risotto and start over, this is a bit more
expensive since it involves waste and rework. This is considered non-conformance
and an internal failure. However, this all happens behind the scenes and so the
worst type of failure, where the failure is in the hands of a customer, is avoided.
As we perform quality control, we may determine that changes are needed. Any
changes, as minor as they may seem, must go through change control to ensure
that the changes result in a benefit to the project as a whole.
The Quality Cycle
[Video description begins] Topic title: The Quality Cycle. Your host for the session
is Barbara Waters. [Video description ends]
In spite of our best efforts to invest in good processes and to invest in quality
management, sometimes there is a breakdown. Something has gone wrong with
our deliverable and we have to figure out why. Let's say that a customer has just
brought to our attention that their silverware is spotted and dirty. Of course, we
are embarrassed and we make every attempt to satisfy them by removing the
charge for the meal and asking them to give us another chance in the future. The
fact that this defect made it into the hands of our customer is nonconformance
and an external failure cost. We must act quickly to bring our quality back into
conformance where we prevent these types of defects.
Where do we begin? The best thing to do is perform a root cause analysis. What
caused the silverware to be spotted and dirty? What quality control tool can we
use to perform a root cause analysis? If you said Ishikawa or Fishbone diagram or
a cause and effect diagram, you were correct. We need to determine what caused
the defect of spots on the dishes. Is it a training issue?
Perhaps we have a new dish washer who wasn't properly trained and doesn't
know the dishes should be pre-washed before they're run through the dish
washer. Another possibility is that our equipment is breaking down. Perhaps the
dishwasher is not heating up to the proper temperature for sanitizing the dishes.
Did someone substitute our normal dishwashing detergent with something
different?
Using the root cause analysis will help us to identify and resolve the cause of the
problem. In a worst case scenario, what if our restaurant was experiencing serious
quality breakdowns in a number of different areas? This may seem hopeless, but
in fact, there is a very effective quality control tool that we can use. It will allow us
to identify and resolve a few key causes for most of these defects.
A Pareto diagram will allow us to identify the various causes of our defects. And
address those which will have the most impact on reducing defects. According to
the Pareto principle, 80% of the defects should come from only about 20% of the
causes. What does this mean? Let's say that we have one new employee who is
not properly trained. That employee could have an impact on many of our
processes. And therefore, the lack of training could be causing multiple defects. In
addition to this poorly trained employee, we may realize that we aren't doing a
great job documenting our processes. So not all employees are performing the
processes consistently. Again, this is a personnel related cause.
However, every process has normal variation where even the smallest number of
defects will occur. There will always be a few samples that fall outside the
acceptable tolerances. This normal variation is known as common cause and no
amount of investment or attention will prevent it. If you ever had two jelly beans
stuck together or flipped a coin only to have it land on its edge rather than on
either side, you have probably witnessed common cause. When no cause of a
defect can be found, it is helpful to know that common cause and normal
variation may be the culprit. A project manager should be able to determine the
type of cause after a root cause analysis has been performed.
Lean Methodology for Quality Improvement
[Topic title: Lean Methodology for Quality Improvement. Your host for the session
is Barbara Waters.]
Lean was originally developed in Japan for manufacturing and production but is
now widely used in many organizations. Rather than optimizing individual areas
through single improvement initiatives, the focus is on continually optimizing the
flow of goods and services throughout the various departments and ultimately to
the customer. Activities that add no value are eliminated. This includes waste as
well as the reduction of lead time from when a customer orders a product until it is
received.
Lean is a methodology that is used to improve the efficiency of processes and
quality of products and services through the elimination of waste. The
concentration is on the customer and their perspective of value in all aspects of the
process that deliver customer value.
Let's go through a quick overview of the four main stages of lean. Stage 1
identifies an opportunity where waste can be eliminated. In stage 2, we analyze the
current processes and design a new solution. In stage 3, we implement the design
for changes in the specific areas of the selected process. In stage 4, we
continuously review the results.
[Stage 1: Identification of Opportunity.] The first stage of the lean methodology
includes the analysis and review of a potential opportunity that can benefit from
improvements. Often, the improvement can be made by additional training of
employees as to how processes should be done. Since value is highly dependent on
the value perceived by the customer, communication may be required to ensure
that this is clearly understood. Even though this understanding is critical to identify
an opportunity, it should also be used to continually validate the costumer's
definition of value. Based on which aspects of the process the customer sees the
most value in and is willing to pay for, opportunities for improvement are selected
for further study.
[Stage 2: Solution Design.] As part of developing the solution design, an
opportunity for improvement that was selected is analyzed by observing the
process from beginning to end. In this example, the master schedule is
communicated to multiple processes [such as Develop Mail Piece, Compile
Names, Verify Credit and Address.] that are all involved in developing and
preparing to distribute a piece of mail. Individual activities are identified and the
time spent on each is recorded, as shown in days on this diagram. By
understanding all the steps, we can start to identify those that don't add value and
that the customer is unwilling to pay for. Those should be the ones that are selected
for possible elimination or reduction of effort.
[Stage 3: Solution Implementation.] In stage 3, we start looking at the
implementation of a solution. We've probably identified a number of potential
areas, but we need to determine which solution should be addressed first.
Identifying and prioritizing potential solutions that can be easily implemented and
also provide benefits can be done by determining the impact and implementation
effort required. These are often referred to as low-hanging fruit.
The goal of continuous improvement is to obtain near perfection. Employees who
have been directly involved in the improvements, including suggesting and acting
on those, are now ready to take ownership of their process. Using lessons learned,
team members will continue to generate and act on new ideas for improvement.
They will also be aware of additional areas that can be further improved in the
areas where they are involved. Being initially involved, they continue to find
additional ways to eliminate waste and areas where change will have an impact.
Having bought into this new way of doing things, they'll monitor the results to
determine if the improvements that have been made will be sustained.
Principles of Lean
[Topic title: Principles of Lean. Your host for the session is Barbara Waters.]
There are five laws that apply to both Six Sigma and Lean. And help increase the
flow of work while reducing waste and improving customer satisfaction.
The law of the market is the law upon which all other laws are derived. This states
that the customer is critical to quality and the highest priority. Without customers,
you have no business. All parts of the organization should ensure that customers
are continually satisfied.
The law of flexibility states, the time that it takes to perform a process is
proportional to the flexibility and ability of an organization to make changes. The
more receptive an organization is to changes and processes, the shorter the time
required for that change to be implemented.
The law of focus, states that 20% of activities cause 80% of the problems or delays
and is related to the Pareto principal. By identifying where delays originate, more
impact can be realized when that delay is then eliminated.
The law of velocity states that the velocity of any process is inversely proportional
to the amount of work in progress, or WIP. This is often referred to as Little's law.
The higher the number of unfinished tasks, the slower the process, and therefore
the longer the lead time.
And the law of complexity states that processes that are complex, add more non-
value and cost, rather than poor quality or processes that are performed slowly.
Complex products create more waste, as well as excess costs and work required.
This law is one of the important concepts that supports the values of Lean by
keeping products or services as simple as possible by removing all activities that
don't provide value.
There are four key concepts that highlight the Lean way of thinking with each
concept building on the previous one. Value must be defined by the customer, in
terms of expectations and perceptions, and what they're willing to pay for. Each
part of a process should be understood and those that create the value, identified
and optimized. It is important to have good communication with the customer, to
understand whether their needs are being satisfied, and to be able to change as their
needs change.
Understanding the value stream includes all activities and processes that are
involved in creating value for the customer, from taking a customer's order to its
delivery. This includes the identification of waste or non-value steps, as well as
those that provide value. This includes the suppliers, other areas of the
organization, as well as the customer, in addition to the internal processes. We
need to understand how to reduce or eliminate waste, and deliver the end result to
the customer in a shorter time. Even though I've referred to customer orders, this
concept can be applied to fulfilling requests for internal, as well as external
customers.
We want to move to where the customer demand creates the pull, or initiation of a
process, rather than relying on historical information or a market forecast. The
amount of wait time is reduced or eliminated as the successor activities are not
started until the predecessor has been completed. Stock on hand is reduced,
because we're not creating extra product just in case. But rather, just enough
product based on the need or an order that has been received.
The final concept, which is built on the results of all the others, is to strive for
perfection, which is the ideal product or service required by our customer by
continually improving our products and processes. This includes continual review
of the value stream, as well as the review of lessons learned from completed
efforts. And understand and apply those results to identify additional areas of
improvement. We need to understand what value we provide to our customers and
understand their changing needs. By continually reviewing and optimizing our
processes, we are better equipped to adapt to changes.
Six Sigma for Quality Improvement
[Topic title: Six Sigma for Quality Improvement. Your host for the session is
Barbara Waters.]
Six Sigma is a methodology based on Demming's plan, do, check, act cycle that
was originally introduced by Motorola in 1986. The Six Sigma methodology is
composed of five phases, define, measure, analyze, improve, and control. This is
often referred to by using the acronym DMAIC. This method is used extensively in
manufacturing and service industries to improve existing processes. But can also
be used to improve business processes of all types. The method comes from
statistics and uses a metric for measuring quality control. The metric chosen is
based on the concept that by measuring the defects per million opportunities,
processes can be analyzed, controlled and improved.
Defects per million opportunities, or DPMO, is shown by a bell curve graph and
used to compare the relative performance of a process against a mean. [The bell
curve displays. The x-axis represents the plus and minus standard deviations from
the mean. There is a lower specification limit and an upper specification
limit.] Using Six Sigma and standard deviations, we compare performance to
upper or lower specification limits shown on control charts. The bottom of the
chart shows the plus or minus standard deviations from the mean. To achieve a
level of Six Sigma or be 6 standard deviations from the mean, our process would
be operating at a 99.9997% defect free level, or only 3.4 defects per million. For
most control charts, two additional limits are identified. Upper and lower control
limits, which are set at a plus or minus 3 standard deviation.
Again, DEMAIC is the acronym for the five phases in the Six Sigma
process. [Define] The first is to define the scope of the study from the costumer's
point of view. [Measure] The second phase chooses the metric to be used to
measure and evaluate the current process. [Analyze] The third phase analyzes the
data and verifies existing defects, including the cause and effects of those defects.
Special focus is on identifying the root cause of defects. [Improve] Using various
techniques, improvements are identified and tested to see if they will reduce or
eliminate mistakes and improve the overall results in the improve
phase. [Control] The final phase implements control systems to monitor results.
When changes have been thoroughly tested, procedures are established to ensure
the improvements can be sustained.
One of the key concepts in Six Sigma refers to the transfer function. [that is, Y =
f(X)] The basic idea of this function is that output, or Y's, are depending on the
value of x or a function of x. If we consider the x's to represent inputs, then the
quality and value of the Y, or the output, depends on the quality of the inputs, or x.
Six Sigma uses this function to relate the inputs of a process to the outputs of a
process within an organization. Each process has a measurable output that becomes
the input for the next process.
The leverage principle enables teams to focus on continuous improvements by
improving outputs, by analyzing and making changes to inputs. A key aspect to
understand is that there are multiple inputs for our process, but some are more
important than others. Some inputs affect the output more than others, including
significant functional goals that directly influence an organization's key objectives
that matter relating to customer value. It is important to understand which activities
will help achieve those results.
The vital few versus trivial many is based on the Pareto principle, where 20% of
the inputs account for 80% of the influence on outputs. Once identified, we can use
a structured approach to analyze cause and effect relationships.
Other improvement tools used by Six Sigma methods to improve quality include
statistical process control tools, which help monitor the behavior of a process. The
most successful SPC tool is the control chart. These charts are often used to record
data and identify the occurrence of an unusual event. Variance and defect reduction
tools, including the seven quality management tools, are helpful in analyzing and
improving processes as part of a total quality management approach. These relate
to the analyze and improve phases of DMAIC.
Quality circles were first introduced in the 1960s and are normally made up of a
group of workers doing the same or similar work. They meet regularly to improve
work processes and conditions by identifying, analyzing, and solving work related
problems.
In summary, the key characteristics of the Six Sigma methodology include, it is
used in service and manufacturing industries. It's a five phase improvement
methodology that follows the DMAIC methodology, and it uses the transfer
function to relate the inputs to the outputs.
Quality Management and Continuous Improvement
[Topic title: Quality Management and Continuous Improvement. Your host for the
session is Barbara Waters.]
Value stream is a key component of lean, which identifies value, not just
efficiencies. It is the entire set of activities and resources that provide a product or
service to the customer. When waste occurs, the flow of the value is disrupted and
quality is decreased. The entire value stream is shown on a value stream map
documenting each individual step or activity, starting with the customer order and
completing when the order has been fulfilled. Value stream mapping not only
shows the activities that provide the value, but also identifies where waste is
present and quality improvements can be made. Even though value stream
mapping is usually focused on optimizing entire processes, it can also be applied to
smaller individual processes to improve quality.
This example shows both the flow of material and information from suppliers to
customers based on a daily schedule. A weekly schedule is received from the
customer from which the production manager creates daily production schedules
that are provided to the fabrication, painting and inspection departments. Through
the development of a value stream map, each of the three functions have been
analyzed. And the number of operators, as well as the cycle time, has been
recorded. The analysis of this current map can be used to determine where
efficiencies can be achieved through modification to activities as well as reduction
or elimination of waste or non-value added processes.
The first step is to determine which full process or single activity should be
analyzed. This depends on the types of problems or inefficiencies that need to be
addressed. The second step creates a current state map including all the activities
currently being done from the beginning of the process to the completion.
Including gathering any data of time required to perform activities, including wait
times between activities. This will help identify areas of waste and possible causes.
A process map based on improvements, called a future state map, is then created to
show how the system might look with waste removed and where potential
improvements might be introduced. The final step is to develop a plan that would
include the implementation steps required to change any existing activity or
process to reduce waste and improve the overall value.
Let's use an example to illustrate the steps. In step one, the project manager selects
the procurement process because problems continue to occur in the acquisition of
materials during her projects. She then creates a current state map of the
procurement process. It includes the duration of the steps in the process and
resources who are performing the activities. This also includes wait time between
activities, such as waiting for purchase orders to be approved. In her future state
map, she has removed activities or steps that do not contribute value to the overall
process. As well as shortening activity durations and wait times, especially where
requests sit in an inbox while the approver is out. She also identifies backups who
can also approve those requests. Once the new process has been documented, it
should be presented and reviewed by the appropriate stakeholders. And a plan
created, including steps to make the necessary changes, as well as implementing
new project management and purchasing procedures.
So in summary, value stream mapping allows you to identify obstacles or wastes
that are disrupting process flow. Value stream maps show all the steps or activities
involved in producing output, and you can use them to show areas where process
improvements will create value.
Key Principles of ISO 9000
[Topic title: Key Principles of ISO 9000. Your host for the session is Barbara
Waters.]