Professional Documents
Culture Documents
https://doi.org/10.1007/s42114-020-00179-9
ORIGINAL RESEARCH
Received: 4 May 2020 / Revised: 26 July 2020 / Accepted: 17 September 2020 / Published online: 26 September 2020
# Springer Nature Switzerland AG 2020
Abstract
Researchers and engineers have shifted their interest from synthetic fibres to natural fibres. These fibres are not only light weight
and high-strength materials but are also more economical than the conventional synthetic fibres. Moreover, the natural fibres are
eco-friendly and biodegradable. Banana fibre is a bi-product of banana fruit cultivation and hence abundant in nature. Banana
fibre being one of the strongest natural fibres can be used for different applications when reinforced with some binding resin.
Epoxy resin has excellent binding properties and is thus suitable matrix for composite formation. As it has been widely discussed
in previous studies that fibre loading or fibre volume fraction affects mechanical strengths and properties of natural fibre-
reinforced composite, this study is aimed finding the relation between the fibre volume percentage and the load-bearing capacity
of banana fibre-reinforced epoxy composite material by data-driven decision method. In the finite element analysis conducted on
the banana-epoxy composite, it has been seen that the composite bear maximum tensile load of up to 7956 N, flexural load of up
to 411 N and has hardness of up to 167.28. On the basis of this study, it can be said that due to excellent load-bearing properties,
banana-epoxy composite can be used for various medium to high-load industrial applications. The following paper also proposes
an analytical relation based on the regression model superposition of the results of tensile, flexural and hardness test simulation
conducted by finite element analysis software ANSYS 16.0 which was prepared on Minitab 19 software.
Keywords Natural fibre . Banana fibre-reinforced epoxy composite . Finite element analysis
1 Introduction 70% of that of steel but are even lighter as compared with the
synthetic fibre alternatives [2, 3]. Moreover, natural fibre is
Natural fibre are plant-derived fibres such as banana fibre, abundant in nature and thus is very much economical than the
wood, sisal, hemp, coconut, cotton, kenaf, flax, jute, abaca, synthetic fibres [4, 5]. Most importantly natural fibre compos-
bamboo and wheat straw [1]. These fibres when reinforced ites are green materials. These materials are biodegradable in
with plastic binder form a hard composite material. The de- nature and thus cause no pollution. Also, these materials are
velopment of synthetic fibres was seen as a better alternative seen as an opportunity to convert agricultural bio-waste to an
to the conventional forms of materials such as steel and alu- industrial commodity. These characteristics of natural fibre
minium. The synthetic fibres are stronger as compared with are drawing the attention of researchers and engineers [6, 7].
steel and even lighter than aluminium. The natural fibre com- Banana fibre is a type of bast fibre obtained by the process-
posites being comparatively less strong have strength up to ing of bark of banana tree. After the cultivation of banana fruit
in one season, the banana trees become useless; these banana
trees are now nothing but a bio-waste, and cutting down of
* Upendra Sharan Gupta
upendrasharangupta@gmail.com these trees becomes very essential for cultivation of new crop.
These cut down banana trees are easily dried and can be proc-
1
essed at minimal cost to convert it to raw banana fibre [8].
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Shri Vaishnav Vidyapeeth
Vishwavidyalaya, Indore 453111, India
Banana fibre being lignocellulosic fibre has various advan-
2
tages such as high low elongation at break, light weight, good
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Shri Govindram Sakseria
Institute of Technology and Sciences, Indore 452003, India
fire resistance quality, strong moisture absorption quality, low
3
density, high tensile strength and modulus. These qualities
Department of Mechanical Engineering, Shri Vaishnav Polytechnic
College, Indore 452002, India
make them a very sought for material for automobile and
Adv Compos Hybrid Mater (2020) 3:530–540 531
aerospace industries [9, 10]. However, the properties of fibre Vishnu Prasad et al. [15] conducted fine element analysis
composite have been seen to be dependent on factors such as on Banana-Jute-reinforced hybrid polymer matrix. The com-
moisture absorption, interfacial adhesion, porosity, compati- posite specimens are prepared with varying cashew nut shell
bility between fibre and matrix [11]. In other studies conduct- liquid (CNSL) % from 5 to 40%. 3D model of specimens was
ed, physical specifications such as fibre bundle width, orien- prepared using modelling software. The specimen of different
tation, layering pattern, fibre loading or fibre volume/weight geometries was subjected to tensile test both experimentally
fraction were found to influence the mechanical characteristics and by finite element analysis (FEA). The maximum load
of fibre-reinforced composites [12–14]. It has been seen that versus % CNSL characteristics of specimen with varying
the various strengths and properties of composite are highly composition was plotted.
dependent on either weight fraction or volume fraction of the Ravi Tumkur Suryavanshi et al. [16] conducted the FEA in
resin that has been added [15–18]. Laly Pothan et al. [19] order to determine the stress intensity factor of banana fibre
studied that increasing the volume fraction of banana fibre hybrid composite. Hand lay-up method was used for the prep-
up to a certain limit in composite improves the stress-strain aration of banana-cashew nut shell liquid (CNSL). The spec-
characteristics of fibre-reinforced composites. imen was fabricated according to ASTM D5045 of dimen-
Finite element analysis is a process of solving engineering sions 96.5 × 22 × 5.5 mm. For finite element analysis, 3D
problems in which a 3D model of a specimen is disintegrated model of specimen was created using modelling software,
into finite amount of very small elements using a finite ele- and the test conditions were simulated on the finite element
ment analysis (FEA) software. Various mesh shapes can be analysis (FEA) software. It is seen that with the increase in
chosen according to the surface structure of the specimen. The amount of CNSL, the fracture toughness of the composite
results of the analysis are calculated at the nodes of the mesh. decreases and the sample with 5% CNSL gives optimum
It is seen in the results of the literatures that the FEA model stress intensity factor.
was very close to the results obtained in the experimental test, Leandro José da Silva et al. [17] conducted the experimen-
and hence FEA model can be effectively used to study the tal and numerical analysis natural fibres reinforced
mechanical behaviour of natural fibre composites when there biocomposites. The composites of banana and sisal respec-
is symmetry and regularity of fibre positioning in actual com- tively were prepared and were used to carry out tensile test
posite [17, 20–22]. and scanning electron microscopy. 3D and 2D models of
10 125.58
20 194.07
30 264.9
40 334.63
50 402.73
prepared by hand-operated injection moulding machine. The and finite element method. Hand lay-up method was
finite element method (FEM) modelling was done on employed for the preparation of composites. The specimens
ABAQUS 6.14. The model was prepared using 3D represen- were prepared as per the standard ASTM dimensions of im-
tation technique. Various curves of fibre loading vs transverse pact and tensile test. The finite element analysis of 3D models
modulus/Poisson’s ratio/longitudinal modulus were plotted. of specimen was carried out using ANSYS software. The
Siva Bhaskara Rao Devireddy et al. [30] studied the effects experimental and finite element method (FEM) models were
of representative volume element and fibre geometry on ther- compared which came to be in fair agreement with each other
mal and elastic properties of unidirectional fibre-reinforced thus validating finite element analysis (FEA) model as suit-
composites. The composite model was prepared on ANSYS able for study of mechanical characteristics of composite
using representative volume element (RVE) model. The curve material.
of fibre loading vs longitudinal modulus/Poisson’s ratio/
transverse modulus/in plane shear modulus were plotted and
studied. Also curves were plotted to discuss the effects of 2 Materials and methodology
volume fraction on thermal conductivity.
K. Balasubramanian et al. [31] analysed the mechanical The E-B-E-B-E stacking sequence was used in compos-
characteristics of natural fibre composites by experimental ite due its good binding nature because of directly
10 90 125.58 1.633
20 151 194.07 2.178
30 218 264.9 2.256
40 305 334.63 2.873
50 411 402.73 3.118
binding to 4 sides of fibre layer thus enabling more fibre as 750 MPa and strength of epoxy as 54.6 MPa [32, 33].
contact area as compared with E-B-E composite where According to this the tensile strength of the fibre composite is
only two sides are in contact for a large bundle. The given by the equation (1), where, Sc is failure strength of
composite model was prepared in E-B-E-B-E (E-epoxy, composite, Vf is volume fraction fibre, Sf is strength of fibre,
B-banana) stacking, and the fibre orientation is 0 . The Sm is strength of matrix and Vm is volume fraction of matrix
thickness of each layer is calculated according to total (Table 1).
thickness × volume fraction/no. of layers (i.e. 3 layers
of epoxy and 2 layers banana). The specimen models Halpin-Tsai Formula: S c ¼ S f …V f þ S m V m ð1Þ
with volume fraction of banana fibre 10%, 20%, 30%,
40% and 50% were prepared on PTC CREO 5.0
Parametric software. The tensile test was conducted as
per the ASTM D638 (Fig. 1), and the specimen dimen- 4 Result and discussion
sions were 145 × 20 × 4 mm. The flexural test was con-
ducted as per the ASTM D790 (Fig. 2), and the speci- 4.1 Tensile test
men dimensions were 60 × 10 × 4 mm. The modelling
was done on CREO 5.0 Parametric, and the analysis The results obtained from the tensile test of various specimens
was conducted on FEA software ANSYS 16.0. The having different volume percentage of banana fibre ranging
Brinell hardness test was performed on the sample of from 10 to 50% were determined and tabulated below
dimensions 20 × 20 × 6 mm. (Table 2). The maximum load-bearing capacity and the max-
imum deformation under tensile loading on the aforemen-
tioned specimen were calculated, and the trend was plotted
on the graph in order to validate the trend with that of previous
3 Theoretical modelling researches. The specimen with 50% fibre loading of banana
fibre was found to bear the maximum load of 7956 N along
For the analysis of banana-epoxy composite, the parallel layer with maximum deformation of 1.2693 mm (Fig. 3), while the
composite is prepared. Both of them, fibre and the epoxy, minimum bearable load and deformation values of 980 N and
have very different strength properties. So, the overall strength 0.4003 mm were obtained for specimen with 10% volume of
of the composite (E-B-E-B-E) is determined with the help of banana fibre specimen (Fig. 4). The trend of increasing load-
the rule of parallel mixture taking the strength of raw banana bearing capacity under tension on increasing the fibre loading
Fig. 9 Maximum equivalent stress in Flexural test by FEM Fig. 10 Deformation in flexural test by FEM
536 Adv Compos Hybrid Mater (2020) 3:530–540
experiment shows that the flexural load increases when the fibre
loading is increased from 5 to 20%, the increase in flexural δmax ¼ 1:036 þ 0:06558 V þ 0:07857 V2 ð5Þ
strength on increase in fibre volume percentage or fibre loading
where δmax is the maximum deformation in flexural test (mm)
is in accordance with Halpin-Tsai model and can be confirmed
and V is the volume percentage of banana fibre (%).
from Khulsairy et al. [34] and Ramesh et al. [35]. Figure 11
shows graph from Shankar et al. [18] showing increasing flexural
strength on increase in percentage of banana fibre volume which
4.3 Hardness test
is seen in our results too.
The results obtained from the Brinell hardness test of various
The results of the flexural test were plotted on the graph
specimens having different volume percentage of banana fibre
using Minitab 19 software, and the points were fitted on a
ranging from 10 to 50% are tabulated below (Table 4). In
regression curve as seen in Figs. 12 and 13. It was observed
addition, the Brinell hardness number of various specimens
that the load-bearing capacity under flexural load vs percent-
was compared using the regression plot. The maximum
age volume of banana fibre curve followed an exact quadratic
Brinell hardness number of 167.278 was seen in 50% volume
curve of equation:
of banana fibre specimen, and the minimum Brinell hardness
P ¼ 51:20 þ 3:246 V þ 0:07857 V2 ð4Þ number of 95.085 was seen in specimen of 10% volume of
banana fibre in composite (Fig. 14). The results seems to be
where P is the load-bearing capacity of specimen under 3- very arguable since fibre composites are seen as hard mate-
point flexural bending condition (in N) and V is the volume rials, and increasing fibre percentage up to 50% usually en-
percentage of banana Fibre (%). hances the overall mechanical strengths of the composites and
Similarly, when the results of maximum deformation in so does the hardness; hence, the results seem very reliable.
bending for each specimen was plotted against percentage Also, the Brinell hardness values when plotted against per-
volume of fibre on a regression model using Minitab 19 soft- centage volume of fibre tend to follow a quadratic relation as
ware, a quadratic relation was obtained between the quantities shown below (Fig. 15):
which can be given as follows:
BHN ¼ 95:60 þ 0:3554 V þ 0:03588 V2 ð6Þ
Table 4 Results of Brinell hardness test where BHN is the Brinell hardness number and V is the vol-
ume percentage of banana fibre (%).
Volume % of banana fibre in composite Brinell hardness number
10 95.085
20 104.715 5 Conclusion
30 114.864
40 140.054 The present study was aimed to find an analytical rela-
50 167.278 tion between fibre volume percentage and various me-
chanical properties using data-driven decision method.
538 Adv Compos Hybrid Mater (2020) 3:530–540
The mechanical tests were done using finite element & Load-bearing capacity under tension seems to follow a
analysis, and the results of the test were validated from quadratic relation with the percentage volume fraction of
the previous studies which were found to be in compli- fibre by the regression model.
ance with each other thus proving the reliability of the & The maximum deformation observed under tensile load-
results. Following inferences were derived from the ing of specimen is linearly dependent on the volume % of
study: banana fibre by the regression model.
& Both flexural load-bearing capacity and maximum
& Increasing of banana fibre loading in the banana-epoxy deformation have been found to be quadratically de-
composite grove the flexural as well as the tensile strength pendent on fibre volume percentage by the regres-
of the composite until the fibre percentage reaches 50% sion model.
after which the strength starts to decrease which is evident & Similarly, Brinell hardness has also been found to have
from the finite element analysis and previous results. quadratic dependency on volume fraction of fibre by the
& Brinell hardness of the composite also increases along regression model.
with increase in banana fibre volume percentage up to
50%. Excellent load-bearing characteristics make banana
& The maximum load-bearing capacity under tension has fibre-reinforced composite suitable for average load util-
been found out to be 7956 N with deformation of ities. The trends observed in the properties can used to
1.2693 mm. study and optimize the properties of composite materials
& Maximum flexural load-bearing capacity of fibre investi- for future scope. The results seem to be compliant with
gated by finite element method has been found out to be previous studies done; however, experimental validation
411 N along with deformation of 3.118 mm. of this model shall be a future research avenue.
Compliance with ethical standards biocomposites reinforced with natural Fibres. Int J Mater Eng
2(4):43–49. https://doi.org/10.5923/j.ijme.20120204.03
18. Shankar PS, Reddy D, Sekhar VC, Sekhar VC (2013) Mechanical
Conflict of interest The authors declare that they have no conflict of
interest. performance and analysis of banana fiber reinforced epoxy com-
posites, Int. J. Recent Trends Mech. Eng., vol. 1, no. 4, pp. 440–
444, [Online]. Available: http://iret.co.in/Docs/IJRTME/Volume
4/Issue1/1. Mechanical Performance and Analysis of Banana
References Fiber Reinforced Epoxy Composites.pdf
19. Pothan LA, Thomas S, Neelakantan NR (1997) Short banana fiber
1. Bhattacharyya D, Subasinghe A, Kim NK (2015) Natural fibers: reinforced polyester composites: mechanical, failure and aging
their composites and flammability characterizations. Elsevier Inc. characteristics. J Reinf Plast Compos 16(8):744–765. https://doi.
org/10.1177/073168449701600806
2. Kilinç AÇ, Durmuşkahya C, Seydibeyoğlu MÖ (2017) Natural
fibers. Fiber Technol Fiber-Reinforced Compos:209–235. https:// 20. Rajesh M, Srinag T, Prasanthi PP, Venkataraovenkatarao K (2016)
doi.org/10.1016/B978-0-08-101871-2.00010-2 Finite element analysis of coir / Banana fiber reinforced composite
material. Int J Adv Res Mech Eng Technol 2(4):29–33
3. Xie P et al (2018) Bio-gel derived nickel/carbon nanocomposites
with enhanced microwave absorption. J Mater Chem C 6(32): 21. Hariprasad T, Dharmalingam G, Praveen Raj P (2013) Study of
8812–8822. https://doi.org/10.1039/c8tc02127a mechanical properties of banana-coir hybrid composite using ex-
perimental and fem techniques. J. Mech. Eng. Sci. 4(2014):518–
4. Alam MM, Maniruzzaman M, Morshed MM (2014) Application
531. https://doi.org/10.15282/jmes.4.2013.16.0049
and advances in microprocessing of natural fiber (jute)-based
22. Zhang J et al (2019) Solvent-free graphene liquids: promising can-
composites, vol. 7. Elsevier
didates for lubricants without the base oil. J Colloid Interface Sci
5. Zhang Z et al (2019) Effect of graphene liquid crystal on dielectric
542:159–167. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcis.2019.01.135
properties of polydimethylsiloxane nanocomposites. Compos. Part
23. Dixit S, Padhee SS (2019) Finite element analysis of fiber rein-
B Eng. 176. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.compositesb.2019.107338
forced hybrid composites. Mater. Today Proc. 18:3340–3347.
6. Kozłowski RM, Mackiewicz-Talarczyk M (2012) Introduction to
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2019.07.255
natural textile fibres. Woodhead Publishing Limited
24. Monzón MD et al (2019) Experimental analysis and simulation of
7. Liu S et al (2020) Synergy of plasmonic silver nanorod and water novel technical textile reinforced composite of banana fibre.
for enhanced planar perovskite photovoltaic devices. Sol RRL 4(2): Materials (Basel) 12(7). https://doi.org/10.3390/ma12071134
1–11. https://doi.org/10.1002/solr.201900231
25. Ramesh M, Logesh R, Manikandan M, Kumar NS, Pratap DV
8. Ramesh M (2018) Hemp, jute, banana, kenaf, ramie, sisal fibers. (2017) Mechanical and water intake properties of banana-carbon
Elsevier Ltd hybrid fiber reinforced polymer composites. Mater Res 20(2):365–
9. Puttegowda M, Rangappa SM, Jawaid M, Shivanna P, 376. https://doi.org/10.1590/1980-5373-MR-2016-0760
Basavegowda Y, Saba N (2018) Potential of natural/synthetic hy- 26. Ramesh M, Sudharsan P (2018) Experimental investigation of me-
brid composites for aerospace applications. Elsevier Ltd chanical and morphological properties of flax-glass fiber reinforced
10. Zhang J et al (2019) Alternating multilayer structural epoxy com- hybrid composite using finite element analysis. Silicon 10(3):747–
posite coating for corrosion protection of steel. Macromol Mater 757. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12633-016-9526-5
Eng 304(12):1–10. https://doi.org/10.1002/mame.201900374 27. Prasad V, Venkatachalam G, Rathi A, Rajakumar S (2014) Finite
11. Cruz J, Fangueiro R (2016) Surface modification of natural fibers: a element analysis of jute fibre made hybrid polymer matrix compos-
review. Procedia Eng. 155:285–288. https://doi.org/10.1016/j. ite. Appl Mech Mater 592–594:363–367. https://doi.org/10.4028/
proeng.2016.08.030 www.scientific.net/AMM.592-594.363
12. Idicula M, Neelakantan NR, Oommen Z, Joseph K, Thomas S 28. Ramesh M, Nijanthan S (2016) Mechanical property analysis of
(2005) A study of the mechanical properties of randomly oriented kenaf-glass fibre reinforced polymer composites using finite ele-
short banana and sisal hybrid fiber reinforced polyester composites. ment analysis. Bull Mater Sci 39(1):147–157. https://doi.org/10.
J Appl Polym Sci 96(5):1699–1709. https://doi.org/10.1002/app. 1007/s12034-015-1129-z
21636 29. Adeniyi AG, Adeoye SA, Onifade DV, Ighalo JO (2019) Multi-
13. Senthil Kumar K, Siva I, Rajini N, Winowlin Jappes JT, Amico SC scale finite element analysis of effective elastic property of sisal
(2016) Layering pattern effects on vibrational behavior of coconut fiber-reinforced polystyrene composites. Mech Adv Mater Struct
sheath/banana fiber hybrid composites. Mater Des 90:795–803. 0(0):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1080/15376494.2019.1660016
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matdes.2015.11.051 30. Devireddy SBR, Biswas S (2014) Effect of fiber geometry and
14. Pothan LA, Potschke P, Habler R, Thomas S (2005) The static and representative volume element on elastic and thermal properties
dynamic mechanical properties of banana and glass fiber woven of unidirectional fiber-reinforced composites. J Compos 2014:1–
fabric-reinforced polyester composite. J Compos Mater 39(11): 12. https://doi.org/10.1155/2014/629175
1007–1025. https://doi.org/10.1177/0021998305048737 31. Balasubramanian K, Rajeswari N, Vaidheeswaran K (2020)
15. Prasad V, Joy A, Venkatachalam G, Narayanan S, Rajakumar S Analysis of mechanical properties of natural fibre composites by
(2014) Finite element analysis of jute and banana fibre reinforced experimental with FEA, Mater. Today Proc., no. xxxx, pp. 2–6,
hybrid polymer matrix composite and optimization of design pa- doi: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2020.01.098
rameters using ANOVA technique. Procedia Eng 97:1116–1125. 32. Idicula M, Malhotra SK, Joseph K, Thomas S (2005) Dynamic
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2014.12.390 mechanical analysis of randomly oriented intimately mixed short
16. Suryawanshi RT, Venkatachalam G, Vimalanand SV (2016) banana/sisal hybrid fibre reinforced polyester composites. Compos
Determination of stress intensity factor of banana fibre reinforced Sci Technol 65(7–8):1077–1087. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.
hybrid polymer matrix composite using finite element method. compscitech.2004.10.023
Period Polytech Mech Eng 60(3):180–184. https://doi.org/10. 33. Indira KN, Parameswaranpillai J, Thomas S (2013) Mechanical
3311/PPme.8991 properties and failure topography of banana fiber PF
17. José da Silva L, Hallak Panzera T, Luis Christoforo A, Dur LMP, macrocomposites fabricated by RTM and CM techniques. ISRN
Lahr FAR (2012) Numerical and experimental analyses of Polym Sci 2013:1–8. https://doi.org/10.1155/2013/936048
540 Adv Compos Hybrid Mater (2020) 3:530–540
34. Khusairy M, Bakri B, Jayamani E, Hamdan S (2017) ScienceDirect 36. Santhanam V, Chandrasekaran M (2014) Modeling and evaluation
processing and characterization of banana fiber/epoxy composites : of tensile properties for banana/glass fibre hybrid composites, Proc.
effect of alkaline treatment. Mater Today Proc 4(2):2871–2878. Fifth TheIIER-SCIENCE PLUS Int. Conf. Singapore, no.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.matpr.2017.02.167 November, pp. 100–105
35. Ramesh M, Ananda TS, Aswin US, Eashwar H, Deepa C (2014)
Processing and mechanical property evaluation of banana fiber re- Publisher’s note Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdic-
inforced polymer composites. Procedia Eng. 97:563–572. https:// tional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
doi.org/10.1016/j.proeng.2014.12.284