You are on page 1of 17

Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM

Superior Court - Suffolk


Docket Number

ER
COMMONWEALTH OF MASSACHUSETTS

SUFFOLK, ss. SUFFOLK SUPERIOR COURT

____________________________________
)
JANE DOE, individually and as Mother)
And Natural Guardian of her )
minor child, CHILD DOE )
Plaintiffs, ) CIVIL ACTION. NO.
)
v. )
)
TRANSDEV SERVICES, INC., )
THE MATCH FOUNDATION, INC., )
BOSTON PUBLIC SCHOOLS, )
CITY OF BOSTON, )
TRANSDEV BUS DRIVER, and )
TRANSDEV BUS MONITOR )
Defendants. )
____________________________________)

COMPLAINT AND DEMAND FOR JURY TRIAL

1. This action arises from a series of sexual assaults upon then nine-year-old Child Doe while

on her privately operated public-school bus. The sexual assaults occurred on diverse dates

over a period of seven (7) months and were committed by another student who was eleven-

years-old. The sexual assaults took place just a few feet from the bus monitor and the bus

driver on the ride home after school from the Match Charter Public School. This action is

brought to compensate Child Doe and her family for the suffering they have endured, and

will continue to endure, as a result of these sexual assaults, to hold accountable those

responsible for the safety of Child Doe and other students riding school buses each day,

and to prevent similar incidents from happening in the future.

PARTIES

2. Plaintiff, Jane Doe, individually and as a parent and natural guardian of her minor child,
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

Child Doe, resides in the County of Suffolk, Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

3. Plaintiff, Child Doe, resides with her Mother Jane Doe. Child Doe was nine-years-old at

the time of the sexual assaults.

4. Defendant, Transdev Services, Inc. (“Transdev”), is a foreign corporation, organized under

the laws of the State of Maryland, with a principal office located at 720 E. Butterfield Road,

Suite 300, Lombard, IL 60148, and a Registered Agent, CT Corporation located at 155

Federal Street, Sute 700, Boston, MA 02110. Transdev Services, Inc. conducts business

within the Commonwealth and maintains its usual place of business at 101 Federal Street,

Boston, Massachusetts 02110.

5. Defendant, The Match Foundation, Inc., operating as the Match Community Day Charter

Public School in Hyde Park, is a domestic nonprofit corporation with a principal office and

registered agent at 215 Forest Hills St., Jamaica Plain, Massachusetts 02130.

6. Defendant, Boston Public Schools, is a school district serving the City of Boston,

Massachusetts with a principal place of operation at 2300 Washington Street, Roxbury,

Massachusetts 02119.

7. Defendant, City of Boston, is a duly incorporated municipality of the Commonwealth of

Massachusetts, with a principal place of business at Boston City Hall, One City Hall

Square, Boston, Massachusetts, 02108. The City of Boston oversees the operation of the

Boston Public Schools.

8. Defendant, Transdev Bus Driver, whose identity is known to Plaintiffs via driver

identification number, has been withheld here for privacy purposes. Transdev Bus Driver

was the private, commercial bus driver of Child Doe’s school bus at all times relevant to

this Complaint.

2
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

9. Defendant, Transdev Bus Monitor, whose identity is known to Plaintiffs but withheld here

for privacy purposes, resides in the County of Suffolk, Commonwealth of Massachusetts.

Transdev Bus Monitor was the private, commercial bus monitor of Child Doe’s school bus

at all times relevant to this Complaint.

JURISDICTION AND VENUE

10. The Massachusetts Superior Court has Jurisdiction over this matter, pursuant to M.G.L. c.

258 § 3. Venue in this form is proper, pursuant to M.G.L. c. 223 § 1.

FACTS

11. Plaintiffs incorporate by reference paragraphs 1-10 of this Complaint.

12. Defendant, The Match Foundation, Inc., founded, owns, operates, manages, oversees,

maintains, and/or is otherwise responsible for the Match Community Day Charter Public

School.

13. In September 2022, Child Doe began fourth grade at the Match Community Day Charter

Public School (hereinafter “the School”).

14. Like many children, Child Doe took the bus to School. Child Doe’s school bus that year

was Bus Number B530 (hereinafter “Transdev Bus”), which is owned and operated by

Transdev, driven by a Transdev employed bus driver, and monitored by a Transdev

employed bus monitor. The Transdev Bus route included Child Doe’s neighborhood in

Roxbury, Massachusetts. Students were picked up and bussed to and from the Charter

School, located at 100 Poydras Street, Hyde Park, Massachusetts 02136.

15. On each Transdev Bus ride, Child Doe sat in close proximity to the Transdev Bus Monitor,

who was responsible for monitoring and for the safety of the Transdev Bus child

passengers.

3
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

16. On each ride, Transdev Bus Driver was also responsible for monitoring and for the safety

of the Transdev Bus child passengers.

17. Beginning in October 2022 of the 2022-2023 school year, nine-year-old Child Doe was

sexually assaulted numerous times by another student (hereinafter “the Perpetrator”) while

onboard the Transdev Bus. The sexual assaults occurred over a series of seven (7) months

and included numerous rapes and indecent assault and batteries. The sexual assaults all

occurred within a close proximity to Transdev Bus Monitor.

18. The Perpetrator repeatedly threatened Child Doe with physical violence if she ever reported

his sexual abuse.

19. On or about May 2, 2023, Defendant, The Match Foundation, Inc. became aware of the

sexual assaults against Child Doe. Child Doe disclosed the sexual assaults to two friends

who alerted staff at the School.

20. During the investigation that ensued, it was learned that Transdev requires this Transdev

Bus to have mandatory video equipment onboard; however, Transdev admitted that it

searched for video footage from the Transdev Bus and no video was located from the entire

period of sexual abuse between October 2022 and May 2023, despite specific request for

preservation in May 2023.

21. Defendant, The Match Foundation, Inc., Defendant Boston Public Schools, and/or

Defendant City of Boston were responsible for providing safe and secure, monitored,

transportation for the School’s students. The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public

Schools, and/or City of Boston contracted with Defendant Transdev to provide these

services. Transdev, an international transportation company, owned, and operated the

Transdev Bus on which Child Doe was sexually assaulted.

4
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

22. Transdev interviewed, screened, hired, trained, retained, supervised, and managed

Defendant Transdev Bus Driver.

23. Transdev interviewed, screened, hired, trained, retained, supervised, and managed

Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor.

24. Transdev Bus Driver was responsible for the safety of the children who rode this Transdev

Bus. Transdev Bus Driver was responsible for monitoring and, when necessary, managing

student behavior on the Transdev Bus and had a duty to monitor the children on the

Transdev Bus. This duty included visually monitoring the children by use of the tools

provided by Transdev, such as video recording, and multiple interior mirrors installed for

this very purpose. It also included listening closely to all that went on within the Transdev

Bus. Transdev Bus Driver is specifically authorized and required to stop the Transdev Bus

as necessary in order to intercede and/or prevent behavior that is, or could become, unsafe.

Transdev Bus Driver also had a duty to affirmatively report any concerning behavior to

teachers and administrators at the School.

25. Transdev Bus Monitor was responsible for the safety of the children who rode this

Transdev Bus. Transdev Bus Monitor was responsible for monitoring and, when necessary,

managing student behavior on the Transdev Bus and had a duty to monitor the children on

the Transdev Bus. This duty included visually monitoring the children by use of the tools

provided by Transdev. It also included listening closely to all that went on within the

Transdev Bus. Transdev Bus Monitor is specifically authorized and required to instruct

Transdev Bus Driver to stop the Transdev Bus as necessary in order to intercede and/or

prevent behavior that is, or could become, unsafe. Transdev Bus Monitor also had a duty

to affirmatively report any concerning behavior to teachers and administrators at the

5
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

School.

26. Transdev Bus Driver either knew, or reasonably should have known, of the repeated and

ongoing sexual abuse onboard this Transdev Bus. Transdev Bus Driver had an affirmative

duty to identify, intervene, and take steps to end and report the abuse as well as to take

reasonable steps to prevent it from reoccurring in the future. Transdev Bus Driver breached

this duty, endangering Plaintiff Child Doe and other children under Transdev Bus Driver’s

care.

27. Transdev Bus Monitor either knew, or reasonably should have known, of the repeated and

ongoing sexual abuse onboard this Transdev Bus. Transdev Bus Monitor had an affirmative

duty to identify, intervene, and take steps to end and report the abuse as well as to take

reasonable steps to prevent it from reoccurring in the future. Transdev Bus Monitor

breached this duty, endangering Plaintiff Child Doe and other children under Transdev Bus

Monitor’s care.

28. Defendants Transdev, The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and/or City of

Boston jointly and/or individually, were responsible for the training and supervision of

Transdev Bus Driver to safely operate the Transdev Bus while also responsibly monitoring

and supervising its student-passengers.

29. Defendants Transdev, The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and/or City of

Boston jointly and/or individually, were responsible for the training and supervision of

Transdev Bus Monitor to oversee and monitor the Transdev Bus in order to ensure the

safety and wellbeing of the Transdev Bus’s student passengers.

30. Defendants Transdev, The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and/or City of

Boston jointly and/or individually, were aware or reasonably should have been aware that

6
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

the Perpetrator committed multiple sexual assaults against Child Doe, but Defendants

failed to adequately and properly monitor the students on this Transdev Bus.

31. Transdev Bus Driver, Transdev Bus Monitor, Transdev, The Match Foundation, Inc.,

Boston Public Schools, and/or City of Boston’s negligence independently and/or in concert

with other Defendants’ negligence, caused Child Doe to suffer repeated sexual assaults,

including rapes and indecent assault and batteries, in addition to threats of violence, by the

Perpetrator, resulting in irreparable and permanent injuries that will impact her, and as a

result, her mother, for the remainder of their lives.

32. Plaintiff duly served full and detailed Presentment pursuant to G.L. c. 258 upon all

municipal agencies on May 10, 2023, but has not received a response within the time

provided by the statute.

COUNT I - NEGLIGENCE
Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Transdev Services, Inc.

33. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-32 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

34. Defendant Transdev as owner and operator of the Transdev Bus and by and through

Defendants Transdev Bus Driver and Transdev Bus Monitor, owed Plaintiffs the highest

duty of care compatible with the practical performance of all of Transdev’s duties, to

protect Child Doe from foreseeable harm as she rode the Transdev Bus to and from School

and to warn about dangers faced by Child Doe and other students.

35. Defendant Transdev negligently hired, trained, retained, supervised, and/or managed

Transdev Bus Driver, as set forth above.

36. Defendant Transdev negligently hired, trained, retained, supervised, and/or managed

7
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

Transdev Bus Monitor, as set forth above.

37. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Transdev, Plaintiffs suffered severe

physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and suffering, loss of

enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic damages. Plaintiffs,

and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such damages and will

require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance, potentially for the rest of

their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendant Transdev Services, Inc. in the

amount which will fairly and adequately compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees,

and any other relief as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT II - NEGLIGENCE
Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
The Match Foundation, Inc.

38. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-37 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

39. Defendant The Match Foundation, Inc. as owner/operator of the School owed Plaintiffs a

duty of care to protect Child Doe from foreseeable harm as she rode the Transdev Bus to

and from School and to warn about dangers faced by Child Doe and other students.

40. Defendant The Match Foundation, Inc. operating as the School, negligently hired, trained,

retained, supervised, and/or managed Transdev Bus Driver, as set forth above.

41. Defendant The Match Foundation, Inc. operating as the School, negligently hired, trained,

retained, supervised, and/or managed Transdev Bus Monitor, as set forth above.

42. Defendant The Match Foundation, Inc. operating as the School, also failed to warn parents,

8
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

or anyone else about the Perpetrator’s behavior.

43. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of The Match Foundation, Inc., Plaintiffs

suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and suffering,

loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic damages.

Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such damages

and will require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance, potentially for

the rest of their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendant The Match Foundation, Inc.

in the amount which will fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’

fees, and any other relief as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT III - NEGLIGENCE


Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Boston Public Schools and the City of Boston

44. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-43 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

45. Defendants Boston Public Schools and the City of Boston, responsible for arranging

transportation services for the School, owed Plaintiffs a duty of care to protect Child Doe

from foreseeable harm as she rode the Transdev Bus to and from School and to warn about

dangers faced by Child Doe and other students.

46. Defendants Boston Public Schools and the City of Boston negligently contracted with,

hired, trained, retained, supervised, and/or managed Transdev Bus Driver, as set forth

above.

47. Defendants Boston Public Schools and the City of Boston negligently contracted with,

9
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

hired, trained, retained, supervised, and/or managed Transdev Bus Monitor, as set forth

above.

48. Defendants Boston Public Schools and the City of Boston also failed to warn parents, or

anyone else about the Perpetrator’s behavior.

49. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendants Boston Public Schools

and the City of Boston, Plaintiffs suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries,

extraordinary pain and suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological,

financial, and economic damages. Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer

extensive and continued such damages and will require ongoing medical intervention and

counseling assistance, potentially for the rest of their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendants Boston Public Schools and

the City of Boston in the amount which will fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus

interest, costs, attorneys’ fees, and any other relief as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT IV – NEGLIGENCE – VICARIOUS LIABILITY


Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Transdev Services, Inc., The Match Foundation, Inc.,
Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston

50. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-49 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

51. Each Defendant-entity (against whom individual counts are hereby pled as “Count IV(A)”,

“Count IV(B),” etc.), independently and/or in concert with other Defendants, controlled

and/or had a right to control the contracting with, hiring, training, assignment, and/or

supervision of bus drivers and/or monitors responsible for providing safe transportation

services for the School’s students and for warning about dangers to students using that

10
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

transportation:

A. Transdev Services, Inc.


B. The Match Foundation, Inc.
C. Boston Public Schools
D. City of Boston

52. Defendant Transdev Bus Driver was acting within the course and scope of their

employment with Defendant Transdev under contract with Defendant The Match

Foundation, Inc., Defendant Boston Public Schools, and/or Defendant City of Boston,

when Transdev Bus Driver’s negligent conduct and/or willful disregard for the safety of

Child Doe caused Child Doe’s injuries.

53. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendants Transdev Services, Inc.,

The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston, Plaintiffs

suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and suffering,

loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic damages.

Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such damages

and will require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance, potentially for

the rest of their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendants Transdev Services, Inc., The

Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston in the amount which will

fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees, and any other relief

as the Court may deem appropriate.

11
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

COUNT V – NEGLIGENCE – VICARIOUS LIABILITY


Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Transdev Services, Inc., The Match Foundation, Inc.,
Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston

54. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-53 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

55. Each Defendant-entity listed below (against whom individual counts are hereby pled as

“Count V(A)”, “Count V(B),” etc.), independently and/or in concert with other Defendants,

controlled and/or had a right to control the contracting with, hiring, training, assignment,

and/or supervision of bus drivers and/or monitors responsible for providing safe

transportation services for the School’s students and for warning about dangers to students

using that transportation:

A. Transdev Services, Inc.


B. The Match Foundation, Inc.
C. Boston Public Schools
D. City of Boston

56. Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor was acting within the course and scope of their

employment with Defendant Transdev under contract with Defendant The Match

Foundation, Inc., Defendant Boston Public Schools, and/or Defendant City of Boston,

when Transdev Bus Monitor’s negligent conduct and/or willful disregard for the safety of

Child Doe caused Child Doe’s injuries.

57. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendants Transdev Services, Inc.,

The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston, Plaintiffs

suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and suffering,

loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic damages.

Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such damages

12
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

and will require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance, potentially for

the rest of their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendants Transdev Services, Inc., The

Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, and the City of Boston in the amount which will

fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees, and any other relief

as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT VI - NEGLIGENCE
Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Transdev Bus Driver

58. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-57 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

59. Defendant Transdev Bus Driver, the bus driver of Child Doe’s Transdev Bus and employee

of Transdev, at all relevant times in this Complaint, owed Plaintiffs a duty of care to protect

Child Doe from foreseeable harm as she rode the Transdev Bus to and from School and to

warn about known dangers she may face.

60. Defendant Transdev Bus Driver breached this duty of care owed to Plaintiffs, as set forth

above.

61. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant Transdev Bus Driver,

Plaintiffs suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and

suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic

damages. Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such

damages and will require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance,

potentially for the rest of their lives.

13
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendant Transdev Bus Driver in the

amount which will fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees,

and any other relief as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT VII - NEGLIGENCE


Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v.
Transdev Bus Monitor

62. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reasserts paragraphs 1-61 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

63. Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor, the bus monitor of Child Doe’s Transdev Bus and

employee of Transdev, at all relevant times in this Complaint, owed Plaintiffs a duty of

care to protect Child Doe from foreseeable harm as she rode the Transdev Bus to and from

School and to warn about known dangers she may face.

64. Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor breached this duty of care owed to Plaintiffs, as set forth

above.

65. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor,

Plaintiffs suffered severe physical, mental, and emotional injuries, extraordinary pain and

suffering, loss of enjoyment of life, and medical, psychological, financial, and economic

damages. Plaintiffs, and in particular Child Doe, will suffer extensive and continued such

damages and will require ongoing medical intervention and counseling assistance,

potentially for the rest of their lives.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, demand judgment as against Defendant Transdev Bus Monitor in the

amount which will fairly and adequate compensate Plaintiffs, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees,

14
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

and any other relief as the Court may deem appropriate.

COUNT VIII – LOSS OF CONSORTIUM


Jane Doe v. Transdev Services, Inc., The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools,
the City of Boston, Transdev Bus Driver, and Transdev Bus Monitor

66. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-65 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

67. As a direct and proximate result of each Defendants’ separate and independent negligence,

whether acting individually and/or in concert, Plaintiff Jane Doe lost the unimpaired care,

comfort, solace, moral support, assistance, society, and companionship of her child, Child

Doe.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Jane Doe demands judgment as against Defendants Transdev

Services, Inc., The Match Foundation, Inc., Boston Public Schools, the City of Boston, Transdev

Bus Driver, and Transdev Bus Monitor in the amount which will fairly and adequate compensate

Plaintiff Jane Doe, plus interest, costs, attorneys’ fees, and any other relief as the Court may deem

appropriate.

COUNT IX – SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE


Jane Doe, individually and as parent/natural guardian of Child Doe v. Any and All
Responsible Defendants

68. Plaintiffs hereby incorporate by reference and reassert paragraphs 1-67 of this Complaint

as if set forth fully herein.

69. Defendant Transdev and/or its co-Defendants, negligently, recklessly, and/or intentionally

lost or destroyed video footage from the Transdev Bus which would have shown the

interior of the Transdev Bus during times relevant to the allegations in this Complaint.

70. Defendant(s) was (were) made aware of sexual assaults that took place onboard the

Transdev Bus and, yet, failed to secure, retrieve, protect, maintain, and safely keep

15
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

evidence directly relevant to this matter. Moreover, Defendant(s) had been promptly given

notice by Plaintiffs and were specifically asked to preserve all video footage. Therefore,

Defendant(s) was(were) aware and/or reasonably should have been aware that video

footage of this matter was considered highly relevant to this action.

71. On May 22, 2023, Plaintiffs were advised that Defendant Transdev had searched for the

requested video footage from the Transdev Bus and none was located.

WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs Jane Doe, individually and as Parent and Natural Guardian of

her minor child, Child Doe, pray that this Court issue sanctions as to all responsible parties for the

spoliation of evidence, including but not limited to holding responsible Defendants in default,

striking defenses that responsible Defendants seek to assert, limiting or precluding evidence that

the responsible Defendants seek to offer, instructing the jury at trial that such evidence must be

presumed to have been helpful to Plaintiffs, or to issue appropriate sanctions or remedies that the

Court deems appropriate. Plaintiffs further pray that this Court issue any orders reasonable and

appropriate for further preservation, handling, examination, and/or testing of any video,

documents, or evidence relevant to this matter.

JURY DEMAND

The Plaintiffs hereby demand a trial by jury on each claim asserted, and on each defense

so triable, asserted at any time by any current or future-named defendants, and Plaintiffs make

further demand for attorney-conducted voir dire to the greatest extent permissible.

16
Date Filed 12/15/2023 10:07 AM
Superior Court - Suffolk
Docket Number

Respectfully submitted,

The Plaintiffs,
JANE DOE, individually and as Mother and
Natural Guardian of her minor child, CHILD DOE,

Nina M. Bonelli, BBO#: 698709


Alexander L. Zodikoff, BBO#: 698670
Keith Mitnik, Pro Hac Vice Forthcoming
Morgan & Morgan
155 Federal Street, Suite 1502
Boston, MA 02110
T: 857-383-4902
F: 857-383-4927
NBonelli@forthepeople.com
Dated: December 14, 2023 AZodikoff@forthepeople.com

17

You might also like