Professional Documents
Culture Documents
(Book 1 Summary)
"The Nicomachean Ethics" by Aristotle is about the idea of the human good.
explores
the nature of happiness
and
the ultimate goal of human life.
Aristotle also emphasizes that happiness is not subjective and varies from
person to person,
but
rather it is an objective state that can be achieved through rational activity
He argues that good laws are necessary for the development of morally
virtuous behavior, as they set standards for good conduct and provide a
framework for individuals to follow.
In this sense, the study of ethics is crucial for the proper functioning of a society
and the cultivation of virtuous citizens
What are the two kinds of virtue, and how do we acquire each kind?
According to Aristotle, the common principle that must be assumed is that there
are objective moral truths.
He argues against relativist or subjectivist views of ethics, which claim that right
and wrong are relative to a given society or simply a matter of personal belief.
Aristotle believes that ethical truths can be objectively true or false, and their
truth is not solely dependent on individual or societal beliefs.
This assumption forms the basis for his ethical inquiry and analysis.
In the case of virtues, what (two things) destroys and what preserves virtue?
If a person consistently acts in a way that goes against virtuous behavior, their
virtue will be eroded.
On the other hand, virtue is preserved and strengthened through the repeated
practice of virtuous actions.
one becomes temperate, and it is through being temperate that one is able
to further abstain from pleasures.
Pleasure and pain are also seen as indicators of states of character, with
virtuous acts being accompanied by pleasure.
The two opposites that virtues of character are concerned with are
excess and defect. (Hint: golden mean)
Virtue causes those who have it to feel pleasure and delight in doing virtuous
actions, while also enabling them to stand their ground against things that
are terrible without being pained.
Human or moral virtue, on the other hand, is concerned with pleasures and
pains.
It is through virtue that we are able to do good actions and abstain from
bad ones.
Virtue shapes our character and guides our choices, leading us to live a life
that is in accordance with reason and the mean.
What is the aim of Aristotle's inquiry? How does it differ from the aim of
other inquiries, e.g., physics or theology?
The aim of Aristotle's inquiry differs from other inquiries, such as physics
or theology, in that it focuses specifically on the human good and how it
can be attained.
Physics, for example, seeks to understand the natural world and its
principles, while theology explores the nature of the divine and religious
beliefs.
While these inquiries may touch upon aspects of the human good, they
do not have the same central focus as Aristotle's inquiry in political
science.
Workspace 'Workspace' in 'ENDSEM ANVI'
Page 6 (row 6, column 1)
While these inquiries may touch upon aspects of the human good, they
do not have the same central focus as Aristotle's inquiry in political
science.
He suggests that moral virtue is essential for living a good and fulfilling life.
Aristotle's summary of his account of moral virtue is that moral virtue is a state of
character concerned with choice, a mean relative to us, determined by reason.
Moral virtue is acquired through habituation and practice, rather than simply
through teaching.
It is a necessary component of living the best life for a human being and
contributes intrinsically to one's eudaimonia (flourishing or well-being).
Ultimately, the highest virtue is contemplation, and its virtue is wisdom (sophia).
For example, courage is the virtue that lies between the extremes of recklessness
(excess) and cowardice (deficiency).
Aristotle describes virtue as a mean or intermediate because he believes that
virtue lies between two extremes: excess and deficiency.
Workspace 'Workspace' in 'ENDSEM ANVI'
Page 7 (row 7, column 1) He argues that both emotions and actions can be experienced or performed in
excess, deficiency, or in the intermediate, and it is the intermediate that is
considered virtuous.
For example, courage is the virtue that lies between the extremes of recklessness
(excess) and cowardice (deficiency).
Aristotle believes that the virtuous person is one who can feel and act in the right
way, at the right time, towards the right objects, and with the right motive.
By aiming for the intermediate, virtue allows individuals to find the balance and
harmony in their emotions and actions.
Are virtues and vices feelings like love, joy, hatred, envy? Explain. Are they
capacities for experiencing such feelings? Explain.
Virtues and vices are not considered feelings like love, joy, hatred, and envy.
Instead, virtues and vices are states of character that determine how we stand
with reference to these passions or emotions.
They are the states of character that determine how we respond to these
passions or emotions.
For example, with reference to anger, we stand badly if we feel it too
strongly or too weakly, but we stand well if we feel it in an intermediate way.
Virtues are the mean between the excess and deficiency of these passions or
emotions.
In summary, virtues and vices are not feelings or capacities themselves, but
rather they determine how we respond to and experience these emotional
states.
Aristotle categorizes the elements found in the soul into three types: feelings,
capacities, and states of character.
Feelings refer to emotions such as appetite, anger, fear, joy, and so on.
Capacities are the abilities or faculties that enable us to experience these feelings.
For example, the capacity to feel anger or to experience pleasure.
On the other hand, states of character are the qualities or dispositions that
determine how we stand with respect to our feelings.
They are the virtues or vices that shape our moral character.
For instance, if we feel anger in an extreme or excessive manner, we are said to
have a vice of anger. But if we feel anger in a moderate and balanced way, we
possess the virtue of anger.
. In summary, feelings are the emotions we experience, capacities are the abilities
that allow us to have those emotions, and states of character are the virtues or
vices that determine how we respond to those emotions.
Workspace 'Workspace' in 'ENDSEM ANVI'
Page 8 (row 8, column 1)
Why does Aristotle say that mere knowledge of what one is doing is insufficient
for moral virtue?
Aristotle believes that mere knowledge of what one is doing is lacking in moral virtue
because it is not enough to simply know what is right or wrong.
Moral virtue requires more than just intellectual understanding; it requires the
development of virtuous habits through practice and habituation.
Aristotle emphasizes that moral virtues are acquired through the repeated performance
of virtuous actions, rather than through mere theoretical knowledge.
It is through the actual practice of virtuous
So while nature may provide a foundation for the development of virtues, the
acquisition of moral virtue ultimately comes about as a result of habit and
repetition of virtuous acts.