LIST OF TABLES

Page
Table 4.1 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 1 cycle 1 48
Table 4.2 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 2 cycle 1 50
Table 4.3 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 3 cycle 1 52
Table 4.4 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 1 cycle 2 64
Table 4.5 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 2 cycle 2 65
Table 4.6 The Result of Teacher’s Observation Checklist in meeting 3 cycle 2 67
Table 4.7 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 1 cycle 1 70
Table 4.8 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 2 cycle 1 71
Table 4.9 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 3 cycle 1 72
Table 4.10 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 1 cycle 2 74
Table 4.11 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 2 cycle 2 76
Table 4.12 The Result of Students’ Observation Checklist in meeting 3 cycle 2 77
Table 4.13 Students’ score classification 80
Table 4.14 The Student’s writing score after the treatment cycle 1 80
Table 4.15 Students’ writing scores cycle 2 83
Table 4.16 The score for the teacher’s performance of cycle 1 and cycle 2 85
Table 4.17 The Percentage score of the students’ participation of cycle 1 and
cycle 2 87

xi