Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/260185238
CITATIONS READS
3 1,711
2 authors, including:
SEE PROFILE
All content following this page was uploaded by George Charles Angelopulo on 07 May 2020.
ABSTRACT
Internal communication can, as part of an internal marketing approach,
contribute to the establishment of a service orientation in an organisa-
tion. This is necessary for survival in an era where a total service offering
is imperative to remain competitive. This study presents the results of a
survey of the extent to which internal communication supports a service
orientation among employees at Metropolitan Health Group (MHG) Head
Office and, eventually, the quality of service delivered. It concludes that
this is not entirely the case at MHG and recommends that an internal
communication programme be developed around the desired outcomes
of strategic alignment, knowledge management/information dissemi-
nation and staff motivation within the framework provided by the Gap
Analysis Model of Parasuraman, Berry & Zeithaml (1985) to remedy the
situation.
INTRODUCTION
The contribution of internal communication to the quality of service delivery to both
internal and external customers is explored in this work. The theoretical approach to
internal communication in this study is from the service perspective, and is drawn
from marketing theory. A measurement instrument that evaluates the degree to which
internal communication contributes to service quality is discussed and its practical
implementation described. The instrument is applied to the Metropolitan Health
Group (MHG), where internal communication has been identified as an area
requiring attention since the formation of the company in 2000. Earlier assessments
that identified internal communication problems proved to be of limited value
because they highlighted aspects of communication that did not appear to be linked
to the success of MHG as a business. The measurement instrument was specifically
Ms Landman is Internal Communication Manager, Metropolitan Health Group. Prof. Angelopulo is an Associate
Professor in the Department of Communication Science, University of South Africa. E mail: angelgc@unisa.ac.za
67
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
& Wilson (1997: 37) use the term ``emerging corporate landscape'' to describe the
radical change experienced inside organisations and they identify two major causes
for this, namely:
. Upsizing (competition through acquisition) and downsizing (growth through
reduction) of organisations
. The new employee contract.
The first (upsizing and downsizing) have negative effects on morale, the
management of expertise and complexity, and the effectiveness of communication in
organisations. The second, the new employee contract, is emerging as a result of the
dramatically changed relationship between employer and employee. This new
contract represents a shift from the traditional `psychological contract', where loyalty,
job security and trust characterise an almost patriarchal relationship, to an
arrangement where employer and employee work as partners on an equal basis.
This association is characterised by aspects such as more frequent, deliberate career
movements and a premium placed on competencies that revolve around synthesising
ideas into practical implementation and the ability to integrate patterns of awareness
into a common vision and to align individual contributions to overall organisational
goals (Marlow & Wilson 1997).
FIRM
Full-time marketers and sales people
PERSONNEL CUSTOMERS
TECHNOLOGY Keeping promises
KNOWLEDGE
CUSTOMER'S TIME
Source: Gro
Ènroos 1998: 325
tenance and design of information systems. As such, most employees are involved
with the customer as marketers ± most as `part-time marketers' if they are not
employed in marketing and sales departments. Part-time marketers often outnumber
full-time marketing and sales staff (GroÈnroos 1998). In order to be successful at part-
time marketing functions, it is important that all departments, irrespective of the
degree of their direct contact with the customer, understand that they affect the
keeping of promises to customers and the quality of service delivered (Ashcraft &
Stacher 2004; Auty & Long 1998; Bronn, Roberts & Breunig 2004; Chaston 1993,
1995; GroÈnroos 2001).
To enable employees to fulfil their responsibilities as part-time marketers, the
organisation requires a service orientation in its business conduct and in the way in
which it manages its employees (Schneider 2004). To this end, GroÈnroos (2001: 317±
324) proposes a model for analysing and planning the service process and as a
framework for establishing a service orientation among employees:
In brief, the model combines various service quality-generating sources in a
systematic way. The large central block in Figure 2 illustrates the service-producing
organisation from the customer's perspective. From the service producer's point of
view, a number of different departments or functions may be involved in the process,
but for the customer it is a single integrated process. The customer is located inside
the block, because of the integrated role the customer plays in the whole service
production process. The line of visibility divides the organisation into two parts: one
part that is visible to the customer and one that is not. The customer's expectations
are influenced by the factors in the block at the top right. To the left is the business
mission with its corresponding service concepts, which guide the planning and
70
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
management of the service production system. At the bottom is the corporate culture,
which should be service-oriented if the organisation is to succeed in service
competition.
L ne of v s b ty
Customers
Systems support resources
!
!
Management support
Corporate culture
Source: Gro
Ènroos (2001: 319)
The model indicates three kinds of support that need to be built into service
production, namely management support, physical support and systems support.
According to GroÈnroos (2001), the most important of these is management support,
because managers and supervisors should provide leadership, contribute to a service
orientation and ultimately to a service culture in order to succeed. Managers are key
to employees' maintenance of service-oriented attitudes and behaviour, because they
set the example, provide coaching and guidance, and motivate employees to perform.
In an analysis of the support part of a service system, it would therefore be important
to assess the impact of leadership, and for the purpose of this study particularly, the
impact of communication, on the service quality delivered by employees.
GroÈnroos's model (2001) indicates that the support and invisible part of the
organisation (from the customer's viewpoint) have an impact on what can be
accomplished in the interactive part, and eventually on the quality of service
delivered. From here stems the notion that the entire system is integrated into a
holistic service production system in which the different components affect one
another (Lovelock 1995). It is therefore important that support employees consider
the departments that they support (in all functions up to customer contact) as their
internal customers. Internal service has to be as good as the service to the external
customer, as it directly impacts on the quality of external service delivery.
71
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
objectives is to enable the internal market to deliver to the external market. GroÈnroos
(2001) suggests that communication management is a critical part of internal
marketing. Internal communication is discussed here as it relates to the service-
oriented perspective (Figure 1) and the service system model (Figure 2).
2000). This corresponds with the concept of the internal customer to whom internal
services have to be provided in the same customer-oriented manner as to external
customers (GroÈnroos 2001).
These concepts correspond strongly with one of the fundamental principles of
integrated marketing communication (IMC), namely the importance of creating a
customer consciousness, or as the term is used in the service marketing literature,
`service orientation', among employees. If one looks at the role of communication in
the emerging relationship marketing field, it is clear that communication becomes the
vehicle for building relationships and integrating marketing activities both within the
marketing and human resources (HR) functions and across the business as a whole.
The development of integrated marketing and integrated communication has
happened in parallel, and the two previously separate functions show intersections at
various intervals. Indeed, communication becomes the primary integrative element in
managing relationships. In contrast to earlier convictions, relationships (especially
those between an organisation and its stakeholders, of whom employees form an
important part) will be founded on communication and not persuasion (Duncan &
Moriarty 1998: 1).
There are a number of definitions of `integrated communication' found in the
literature. McGoon (1998: 15) defines integrated communication as ``a strategic
business process used to plan, develop, execute and evaluate coordinated and
measurable persuasive brand communication programmes over time with consumers,
customers, prospects and other targeted, relevant external and internal audiences''.
Barker & Du Plessis (2001: 2) define integrated communication as ``the application of
analysis, communication and evaluation techniques to create and manage integrated,
multi-faceted communication interventions combining information, collaboration,
business process design, feedback and incentive systems to improve human
performance and productivity in the workplace in order to achieve organisational
communication goals and objectives''.
Most definitions of IMC, for example McGoon (1998: 15), GroÈnroos (2001: 266)
and Barker & Du Plessis (2001: 2), include the internal audience of an organisation
(namely, its employees), who are the roleplayers in internal communication. As such,
within the context of the purpose of integrated communication, as stated by Barker &
Du Plessis (2001: 2), internal communication will then play a key role in ensuring
that human performance and productivity in the workplace are improved. According
to GroÈnroos (2001: 268), the challenge for organisations, and for MHG, is to manage
all sources of messages about a firm and its resources and all communication media
and their effects in an integrated way. If it is not successful in doing so, its customers
will receive different, possibly contradictory, messages from various sources of
communication.
The relevance of IMC for this study from a service perspective is that in order for
an organisation to survive service competition, it needs to form and maintain
74
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
Strategic alignment
One of the functions of internal communication is to align communication and
actions with an organisation's vision, goals, values and priorities, thereby enhancing
performance and reputation in a measurable way (Moorcroft 2003). This corresponds
with GroÈnroos's service system model (2001), which suggests that the company's
mission, vision and accompanying service concepts form the basis for the activities of
the organisation. It would therefore make sense to ensure that employees are
informed about these issues and that they are motivated and skilled to act in such a
manner that the company's mission is fulfilled. Puth (2002) terms this ``commu-
75
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
nicating for strategic alignment'', implying firstly that there is a strategic line (a clear
overall strategic direction, intent and a set of desired outcomes to which all
departments and individuals can align their actions), and secondly that everyone is
aware of this strategic line and that it is sufficiently visible for alignment to take place.
Puth (2002) further points out that the key to strategic alignment is
communication of the big picture. This corresponds with findings about employees'
internal communication needs, which highlight, among other things, that the
majority of employees are concerned about a lack of information about their
employing organisations, including where the company is headed and the reasoning
behind decisions (Mersham & Skinner 2001). Therefore, to successfully execute a
service strategy, employees need to know what the strategy entails and what they are
supposed to do to execute it. Relating business and communication strategies helps
employees understand and support the direction of an organisation.
Motivation
The relationship between employee motivation and satisfaction, the quality of
internal and external service delivery, the creation of a service orientation and the
integral role of communication in the process of motivation are widely noted in the
literature (Schumann 2004; Tourish & Hargie 1998; Watson Wyatt Worldwide 1999).
GroÈnroos (2001: 336) identifies motivation as a primary objective of internal
marketing, stating that it should ``create an internal environment and implement
internal action programs so that employees feel motivated to carry out part-time
marketing behaviour''. He identifies communication management as one of the most
important tools in achieving this.
The concept of employee motivation has enjoyed considerable attention in the
human resource management literature, placing emphasis on the different
approaches to motivation. Luthans (1992) describes the process of motivation as an
interaction between three interdependent elements, namely needs, drives and
incentives. If a need exists, drives or motives are set up to alleviate the need. The cycle
is complete when the need is actually alleviated, which then forms the incentive of
restoring a balance. Robbins (1998) captures this process in his definition of staff
motivation as the willingness to exert high levels of effort towards organisational
goals, conditioned by the degree to which the effort leads to the satisfaction of some
individual need.
77
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
Some of the most frequently articulated needs in organisations are those for
information, creating meaning and the general need for interaction (Tourish &
Hargie 1998; Wilson 2004). Effective communication structures, initiatives, climate
and channels contribute positively to employee motivation, and in turn to a service
orientation.
Tourish & Hargie (1998) have illustrated the relationship between internal
communication and the satisfaction of needs. They cite the work of Arnott, who
translated Maslow's hierarchy of needs into six employee questions related to the type
of information required to maintain satisfactory levels of motivation:
. What's my job?
. How am I doing?
. Does it matter to anybody?
. How are we (as an organisation/department) doing?
. How do we fit into the whole?
. How can I help?
nication's contribution to service delivery. To achieve this, the Gap Analysis Model, as
proposed by Parasuraman, Berry & Zeithaml (1985, in Auty & Long 1998) and
GroÈnroos (2001), is utilised. Table 1 specifies the role of internal communication at
the interfaces corresponding to the point of each gap. It incorporates factors that lead
to quality problems at the five interfaces along the service chain and the relationship
of internal communication to each of these.
Table 1: The role of internal communication at the interfaces of the Gap Analysis Model
Gap Potential role of internal Relevant function of
communication internal communication
Gap 1: The . Bad or non-existent upward information . Knowledge management
management from the customer interface to manage-
perception gap: ment
Management . Too many layers that stop or change . Knowledge management
perceives information flowing from customer con-
customers' quality tact points
expectations . Management commitment to service qual- . Motivation/strategic align-
incorrectly ity not visible ment
Gap 2: The quality . Lack of clear goal-setting or lack of under- . Strategic alignment
specification gap: standing of goals by members of the
Service quality organisation
specifications are . Management perceptions are not commu- . Knowledge management/
inconsistent with nicated or ineffectively communicated to strategic alignment
management the business
perceptions of . Lack of visible management support for . Motivation/strategic align-
customers' quality service quality planning and procedures ment
expectations
Gap 5: The Not applicable (the interface falls outside Not applicable (the interface
customer service the scope of internal communication) falls outside the scope of inter-
perception gap: nal communication)
Correlation between
customers' service
expectations and
perceptions of
service delivery
80
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
Methodology
The methodology for this study was initially used by Chaston (1995) to develop a
typology for the evaluation of branch-level perceptions of internal customer
management processes within UK clearing banks. Both studies have similar
theoretical foundations (the Gap Analysis Model) and both measure employee
perceptions to identify the internal processes that contribute to service delivery. As is
the case with this study, Chaston (1995) also structured his study on the principles of
the gap analysis models proposed by GroÈnroos (2001) and Parasurman et al. (as
discussed in Chaston 1993, 1995; Auty & Long 1998). However, where Chaston
defines specific constructs to measure employees' perceptions of internal customer
management practices, this study focuses on employees' perceptions of internal
communication processes in a service context. The methodology applied here is thus
similar to Chaston's, but the constructs measured are different.
The Gap Analysis Model based on the SERVQUAL system, as developed by
Parasuraman, Zeithaml & Berry, has been the topic of much debate regarding its
reliability and validity (Auty & Long 1998: 11). Yet, this model has made the most
significant contribution to the study of service marketing in recent years (Buttle 1996:
158). The reliability of the gap analysis model as applied here is derived from its wide
application in the field of service marketing, the context within which this study was
undertaken. Validity was addressed by identifying and measuring specific constructs
81
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
Sample
The sampling procedure was guided by three objectives:
. To obtain an overall indication of employees' perceptions of the degree to which
internal communication at MHG supports a service orientation
. To identify possible differences between the perceptions of managerial and non-
managerial staff
. To identify possible differences between the perceptions of client contact sections
(employees in direct contact with clients) and support sections (employees who
render support services and are not in direct contact with the client, including
Human Resources, Finance, Information Technology, Public Relations and
Branding, Document Processing and Office Support).
Response
The questionnaire and covering letter were e-mailed to every individual in the
sample. A total of 111 usable questionnaires were returned. A breakdown of response
percentages per stratum is indicated in Table 4. The total of 111 usable responses
represents 63% of the sample and 22% of the accessible population.
FINDINGS
Results
The results obtained from the questionnaire are categorised according to the five
internal communication constructs identified earlier. The values attached to each of
the responses are: Strongly disagree = 1; Disagree = 2; Neither agree nor disagree =
3; Agree = 4; Strongly agree = 5. For the purpose of analysing the results, the mean
scores are interpreted in the following manner:
. A score of 4 and higher would indicate that the majority of respondents agree to
strongly agree with a statement.
84
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
. Between 3.5 and 4 would indicate a neutral to more positive response, although
there would be less than general agreement on the issue in question. Such items
should be monitored and measures introduced to prohibit deterioration.
. Between 3 and 3.5 would indicate a neutral to negative response. These items
could be cause for alarm, requiring future action.
. Lower than 3 would indicate that the majority of respondents disagree to strongly
disagree with a statement. It will be considered an internal communication gap
warranting immediate attention.
Table 5: Summary of overall mean ratings for each construct per stratum
85
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
The summary provided in Table 6 indicates that none of the desired outcomes of
internal communication are effective in achieving the objectives of each of the
constructs. Strategic alignment is partially successful, as employees indicated general
agreement that they understand their individual roles in the service delivery process.
However, the same result was not achieved for Construct 4, understanding of
departmental role in the service delivery process, which points to a lack of a common
understanding of `the bigger picture' and what needs to be done to achieve service
objectives throughout the company. Organisational learning/knowledge manage-
ment/information dissemination and motivation are ineffective in the company at
large.
Furthermore, a significant discrepancy exists between the management grouping
of client contact departments on the one hand and the rest of the organisation on the
other. If viewed against the characteristics of a service orientation, it is clear that
internal communication at MHG head office does not support a service orientation,
particularly at Interface 3, which addresses actual service delivery. A service
orientation is characterised as follows:
. Service quality delivery and achieving customer satisfaction are viewed as top
priorities throughout the organisation, from strategic to operational levels.
. There is a realisation that the quality of service delivery to internal customers
directly affects the quality of service delivery to external customers.
. All internal service production activities are integrated to meet the needs and/or
requirements of the external customer.
87
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
Strategic alignment
An internal communication programme needs to be developed around the objective
of strategic alignment with the service strategy of the organisation. The following
specific areas need attention:
. Clarity and alignment among departments on the priorities regarding client
satisfaction
. General understanding throughout the business on corporate service strategy
. The establishment of internal service delivery and the concept of the internal
customer
. Clarification and consensus about the role of each department in the service
delivery chain.
internal service delivery process in particular. The following are specific areas that
were highlighted for attention:
. Effective and timely distribution of external client information from source to the
rest of the organisation
. Improvement of inter-departmental communication to ensure clarity on both
internal and external client requirements
. Accuracy of information.
Motivation
The motivation level of staff to meet organisational objectives is often a function of
the outcomes with respect to strategic alignment and organisational learning,
knowledge management and information dissemination, implying that an improve-
ment in these two could lead to increased motivation levels. However, the effect of
communication by and with management (departmental and overall) is highlighted
by the survey as an area of weakness. An internal communication programme would
therefore have to address the necessity for the affirmative communication of
management support of a service orientation within the framework provided in this
study.
CONCLUSION
This study sets out to provide a meaningful framework for an internal
communication needs assessment that relates in general to the success of a business,
but more specifically to its service orientation. The approach is derived from a service
marketing perspective of internal communication, and it provides a useful instrument
for the assessment of the quality of an organisation's internal communications.
It is suggested that a service orientation among employees is a prerequisite for
successful marketing in an ever-changing organisational environment, and that
internal communication plays a crucial role in the establishment of a service
orientation. Using the service-marketing model proposed by GroÈnroos (2001), a
measurement instrument that evaluates the degree to which internal communication
contributes to service quality was developed and tested at the Metropolitan Health
Group.
The findings point to the fact that internal communication does not entirely
support a service orientation at MHG, although there are areas of strength that
should be extended to the rest of the organisation. In particular, the Client Contact
Management grouping indicates a satisfactory perception of the necessity for internal
communication in establishing a service orientation, but perceptions in the support
89
The role of internal communication in service delivery ...
areas indicate a less than satisfactory situation. Specific areas that require attention
are identified, and these provide the basis for a structured internal communication
programme.
Since the conclusion of this study, MHG has embarked on a number of initiatives
that demonstrate a deliberate move in the direction of a service perspective as a
strategic approach, based on the same broad principles as those conceptualised by
GroÈnroos. As a first phase, MHG has launched a project called Super Service in
conjunction with one of its biggest clients. The objective of Super Service is to run
the business from a member-centric perspective, meaning that interactions with
individual members will be relationship-based. In support of the Super Service
initiative, an extensive internal communications programme, developed according
to the principles of internal marketing (as discussed in the article), has been
launched. In conjunction with training and other change management initiatives, it
has achieved several significant successes ± it has served to help staff in the pilot area
focus on specific outcomes and strategic objectives; it has served as a motivational and
educational driver and a change management vehicle; and (because of its internal
success) it was also used as a tool to promote MHG to prospective clients. Therefore,
the role of internal communication in service delivery, as applied in this study, has
provided MHG with a competitive edge on several levels, both internal and external.
REFERENCES
Ashcraft, L. & Stacher, B. 2004. `Courting customer service: all business processes, from
accounting to assembly, affect the ability to retain customers', Gifts and Decorative
Accessories, 105(5): 16 17.
Auty, S. & Long, G. 1998. ` ``Tribal warfare'' and gaps affecting internal service quality',
International Journal of Service Industry Marketing, 10(1): 7 22.
Barnes, B.R. & Morris, D.S. 2000. `Revising quality awareness through internal marketing: an
exploratory study amongst French and English medium-sized enterprises', Total Quality
Management, 11(4/5/6): 473 483.
Beckett-Camarata, E, Camarata, M.R. & Barker, R.T. 1998. `Integrating internal and external
customer relationships through relationship management: a strategic response to a
changing global environment', Journal of Business Research, 41(1): 71 81.
Berry, L.L. & Parasuraman, A. 1997. `Listening to the customer: the concept of a service-
quality information system', Sloan Management Review, 38(3): 65 76.
Bronn, P.S., Roberts, H. & Breunig, K.J. 2004. Intangible Assets, Communication and
Relationships. [Online] Available at: www.bledcom.com/pdf/papers. Accessed: 28 June
2004.
Chaston, I. 1993. `Internal customer management and service gaps in the UK manufacturing
sector', International Journal of Operations and Production Management, 14(9): 45 56.
90
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
92
M. Landman & G. Angelopulo
Wilson, A. 2004. `Is internal communication giving line managers the right support?',
Business Communicator, 5(2): 12.
Yeomans, L. 2004. Internal Communication and Organizational Learning: an Interpretive
Approach. [Online] Available at: www.bledcom.com/pdf/papers. Accessed: 28 June 2004.
93