Professional Documents
Culture Documents
The Applications of Posturography in Selected Neurological Disorders
The Applications of Posturography in Selected Neurological Disorders
1 Introduction
2 Posturography is one of the objective methods of evaluating the human balance system (both
3 in healthy and unhealthy people [1]. Human balance is the ability to maintain a vertical
4 projection of the center of mass of the body (COM) in the base of support surface (BOS), which
5 is determined by the contours of the feet adjacent to the ground [2,3,4]. COM in a uniform
6 gravitational field coincides with the projection of the center of gravity of the body (COG). The
7 vertical setting of the body axis in relation to the BOS allows to maintain an upright position,
8 which is characteristic for a human being [5,6]. Maintaining postural stability is associated with
9 the need to constantly minimise body tilts so that the COG projection does not move beyond
10 the BOS [2,8]. The postural control system (PCS) maintains the COG projection in the BOS
11 and counteracts external forces (gravity and inertia) that destabilize the posture of the human
12 body [9]. Minimizing sways is controlled by the central nervous system (CNS). The organ of
13 vision, the vestibular system, exteroceptors and proprioceptors receive external stimuli [5,7].
14 Information about stimuli is transferred to the CNS, which controls the musculoskeletal system
15 through centrifugal pathways (mainly by influencing the tension of postural muscles, especially
16 the calf muscles) to minimize the risk of falls [8]. The balance can be altered by various,
17 temporary or permanent factors [10]. The study aims to present three types of posturographic
18 examinations: static, dynamic and follow-up posturography; the use of posturography for the
19 objective diagnosis of balance disorders and as a method for rehabilitation and monitoring the
20 progress of therapy in Parkinson's disease and people after a stroke.
22 Static posturography
23 Static posturography is a test for which one or two platforms with dimensions of 50 cm x 50
24 cm are used. Its strain gauges measure the pressure forces and moments of forces exerted on
25 the ground by the feet of a patient. In the corners of the platform, there are supports with sensors
26 that register changes in the position of the COG on the platform. Posturography is usually
27 performed barefoot and begins with the patient being placed on a platform. The test is
28 technically easy to perform and does not require prior patient preparation. Measurements are
29 taken successively in a standing position, with eyes open, and then with eyes closed. This makes
30 it possible to compare the subject's balance with and without visual control [11]. The patient's
31 task during the basic examination is to maintain a static, upright position on the platform for a
32 certain period. The examined person is recommended to focus the eyes on one point, located at
33 1
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
34 a distance of about 1 meter [5,12]. Different positions are also used during the examination,
35 e.g.: standing on one leg (left or right), then the foot of the supporting leg is set so that in the
36 sagittal plane the center of the heel is in line with the second metatarsal bone, and the line
37 connecting the medial and lateral malleolus of this foot is 4 cm beyond the intersection of the
38 sagittal and coronal planes on the posturography platform. The rest of this test is the same as in
39 the bipedal position. The obtained results are transferred to the computer, and then the location
40 of the center of pressure of the feet (COP) is calculated, which in static positions is identical to
41 the COG projection on the support plane. As a result, a statokinesiogram is obtained, i.e. a graph
42 of COP swings (Fig. 1.) [5,12].
43 Fig. 1. The example of the record of COP’s movements registered at the tensometric platform
44 [from authors’ source]
45 The parameters of the statokinesiogram, i.e. a graphical representation of the foot center of
46 pressure sways, which are taken into account when interpreting the obtained results are:
51 2
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
56 Fig. 2. Averaged recording of changes in the COP position during free stand with open eyes.
57 AP - anterior-posterior plane (sagittal); ML - medial-lateral plane (frontal) [from authors’
58 source]
60 1. Percentage determination of the amount of COG presence time in each of the quadrants
61 of the coordinate system formed by the sagittal and frontal planes, thanks to which it is
62 possible to determine the load distribution of the lower limbs and determine the patient's
63 natural posture.
64 2. The Fast Fourrier Transformation (FFT) method, which is used to determine the
65 frequency of COG movement specific to a given person [5].
66 Dynamic posturography
73 1. Motor Control Test (MCT) - assesses the patient's ability to quickly and automatically
74 regain a stable posture after an unexpected external provocation, destabilizing the static
75 position. Destabilization is achieved by changing the COP position performed by the subject
76 (e.g. in an attempt to tilt the body as far forward or backward as possible) (Fig. 3A. and 3B.) or
77 through a sequence of small, medium and large forward and backward shifts of the platform
78 that cause an immediate postural response. Measurements include time, force, and lateral
79 symmetry of the response [5, 13].
80 4
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
81 Fig. 3. Averaged recording of changes in the COP position during free deflection (A) forward
82 and (B) backwards with open eyes. AP - anterior-posterior plane (sagittal); ML - medial-lateral
83 plane (frontal) [from authors’ source]
84 2. The Sensory Organization Test (SOT) consists of 6 different tests with a gradual increase
85 in difficulty:
93 1. effective use of information from the eyes, vestibular system and proprioceptors,
94 2. suppressing information that is inappropriate at the moment. For example, the information
95 obtained from the proprioceptors about the angular position of the ankle joint is distorted when
96 the ground is swaying in the sagittal plane. Closing the eyes or changing the position of the
97 reference point hinders the feedback process in maintaining balance.
101 3. The Adaptation Test (ADT) evaluates the patient's ability to modify equivalent reactions
102 and the ability to minimize body sway when the ground moves unpredictably tilting the patient
103 diagonally down or up. The force of the platform movement must be estimated so that it can
104 cause postural instability in a given patient. This test is a simulation of conditions occurring in
105 everyday life, such as moving on irregular surfaces [14,15].
106 Dynamic posturography is a test that uses modern technological possibilities to obtain the best
107 conditions for examination and therapy. During the posturographic examination, the following
108 can be additionally used: virtual reality (created by computer software), multi-channel sound,
109 glasses with integrated screens (HMD - Head Mounted Display) and the patient's sense of
110 acceleration and movement transfer. Additional elements that evoke visual stimuli make it
111 possible to induce balance disorders in a person participating in the test through not always true
112 5
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
113 information about the vertical or, for example, by provoking nystagmus as a result of
114 optokinetic stimulation. They also make it possible to induce postural reactions - the examined
115 person tries to counteract the induced disorders by controlling muscle tension [5,16,17,18].
116 Standing on the posturographic platform, the patient can control the movements of the body in
117 a computer game, by for example skateboarding, skiing or performing other activities. The
118 muscles responsible for maintaining body posture are strengthened. A positive effect on the
119 functions of the balance and deep sensation systems is observed. The results obtained in the
120 game, the element of competition and changing e.g. images on the monitor screen are additional
121 elements thanks to which the patient approaches the task with greater motivation and
122 enthusiasm. This form of training has many advantages, including: the risk of the patient's fall
123 and the risk of injury associated with falls are largely eliminated [19,20].
129 At the beginning of the examination, the average position of the COP point in the patient in
130 a standing position is determined, thanks to which it is possible to properly dose the moving
131 directional point and compare it with the COP point obtained during the main part of the
132 examination. Then the subject makes a maximum forward and backwards lean without taking
133 the feet off the platform. On this basis, the possible range of movement of the directional point
134 in the sagittal plane is selected. It was assumed that precise movement reflecting the direction
135 point requires 66% of the maximum body tilt. On the other hand, the range of body movement
136 in the frontal plane requires the transfer of 2/3 of the body weight to the left or right lower limb.
138 Initial stage (unregistered) - transition from the resting position to the maximum tilt to
139 the right;
140 Second stage (recorded) - movement of the tested COG with the direction point, which
141 makes a clockwise circle (30 seconds);
142 Intermediate stage - the patient's maximum tilt to the left and the change of the tilt
143 direction to the anti-clockwise direction;
144 6
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
145 The last stage - movement as in the second stage with the opposite direction of
146 movement.
147 The parameter of maximum tilt in the sagittal axis measured in this examination can be used
148 to diagnose balance disorders [21].
157 Posturography in a patient with Parkinson's disease is used to objectively quantify postural
158 instability. Studies conducted by Zawadek et al. showed that the above-mentioned patients show
159 a significant deterioration of stabilogram parameters compared to healthy people in a similar
160 age range and that the length of the stabilogram in the frontal plane is a sensitive indicator of
161 postural instability in the elderly population [24].
162 The advantage of posturography is obtaining objective, repeatable results. It has been used e.g.
163 for the assessment of deep brain stimulation (DBS) using high frequency in patients with
164 advanced Parkinson's disease. DBS was a supplement to pharmacotherapy. Posturography
165 enabled an objective comparison of this method of treatment and its impact on balance disorders
166 and body posture reactions of patients during the use of DBS and when DBS was stopped [25].
167 Posturography combined with modern technological possibilities such as game consoles are
168 used to rehabilitate patients with Parkinson's disease. Innovative solutions make it possible to
169 increase the attractiveness of training by adjusting the degree of difficulty and arousing the
170 patient's interest, e.g. by including their own movements in the virtual environment [26]. These
171 games use visual feedback, which gives good rehabilitation effects in patients with Parkinson's
172 disease [23].
173 7
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
174 Posturography is also used to compare the effects of balance training using visual feedback with
175 those of conventional balance training. Posturographic balance analysis using a feedback
176 platform enables postural assessment in quantitative terms and allows for a detailed study from
177 the dynamic side. The results obtained from feedback training of balance in patients with
178 Parkinson's disease have shown that computer-assisted exercises can be at least as effective as
179 standard treatment. Such training can be a good alternative to individual exercises with the
180 patient; it also allows for carrying out the rehabilitation process at home [26].
187 Stroke patients present with a variety of clinical symptoms, including: paresis, muscle tone
188 disorders, superficial and deep sensation disorders, cognitive disorders, vegetative system
189 disorders, emotional disorders, speech disorders, amblyopia and loss of sight [28].
190 Disorders resulting from a stroke lead to various degrees of disability, a frequent consequence
191 of which is locomotion impairment. Disturbed body posture control is considered to be the main
192 problem of this group of patients, and the consequence of this disorder is the occurrence of
193 frequent falls. Improving body balance is an important element when working with a patient
194 because good control of body posture is a condition for effective and safe movement [29].
195 Posturography as an objective test is used to assess the effectiveness of rehabilitation using the
196 method of Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) of patients after a stroke. This
197 examination allows for the assessment of the patient's reactions, especially reactions to
198 correcting body posture and maintaining balance [30].
199 The posturographic examination is used to compare and analyze stabilogram parameters in
200 healthy people and in people after a stroke before and after exercises to improve balance, and
201 it is also used to assess the eye-hand coordination factor [31].
202 Posturography in the Tetrax device (tetra ataxiometric posturography) in stroke patients is used
203 as a research tool and as a training method. The obtained results allow for the analysis of, among
204 8
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
205 others, fall rate, body weight distribution index and stability index. It allows drawing
206 conclusions about imbalances. The parameters measured with the Tetrax device allow for an
207 objective assessment and comparison of balance training using the Tetrax training program and
208 the training program using virtual reality. Based on the analysis, it was confirmed that Tetrax
209 as a training program is a good alternative for patients with proprioceptive disorders, while a
210 program using virtual reality can be used to improve people with preserved sensory functions
211 [32, 33].
212 Posturography also allows monitoring of the effects of NDT Bobath therapy
213 (Neurodevelopment Therapy - Bobath). The main assumption of this method in patients after
214 stroke is the correct distribution of body weight during the first 12 months after the onset of the
215 disease [34].
216 Movement impairment after a stroke often leads to an increased risk of falls, especially when
217 changing body position in space, for example from sitting to standing. The causes of this
218 disorder are: low muscle strength, poor postural control and poor perception of sensory stimuli.
219 Many tests are assessing the degree of disorders occurring after a stroke: muscle endurance test,
220 sit-stand-sit test, equivalent static and dynamic tests, Berg Balance Scale. Sometimes the tasks
221 that the patient must perform during the above-mentioned examinations exceed the capabilities,
222 and the correct assessment of balance and other parameters is impossible or unreliable.
223 Therefore, a new system for evaluating the control of the patient's body posture was created
224 [30,35]. This system, called the Multi-utility balance assessment and training system
225 (MUBATS), uses a special device that allows patients to safely perform the squat-stand test
226 thanks to a special sliding platform. This method allows for the maintenance of the symmetry
227 and balance of the patient, therefore it can be used even in the early stages of the disease, which
228 is not possible with other tests. For a more accurate assessment, this method can be combined
229 with a posturographic examination and during the squat-stand test, the following parameters
230 can be obtained: COP, average sway, path length, surface, maximum sway, speed of movement.
231 These parameters are calculated automatically by the computer [35].
232 The MUBATS scoring system is helpful for stroke patients who are unable to perform the sit-
233 stand-sit test. Thanks to the special apparatus used for the test, the patient has full stability
234 during the test. The direction of the acting forces and coordination of the hip and knee joints
235 during the sit-stand-sit test and the squat-stand test are practically the same, therefore the
236 posturographic examination used during the squat-stand test to some extent reflects the real
237 control of the body position [35].
238 9
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
239 Conclusion
240 Posturography can be used in patients with neurological disorders in a conventional way as a
241 diagnostic method as well as for therapeutic purposes using modern technologies.
242 Posturography is an objective diagnostic tool that also allows the assessment of the
243 effectiveness of treatment (pharmacological and non-pharmacological), moreover, in
244 combination with various technologies, it can be used as a method of kinesiotherapy.
245 Balance disorders, and consequently falls and injuries, are important elements that lead the
246 patients to limit their independence in everyday life, and consequently to develop a progressive
247 disability, forcing the use of orthopaedic equipment, including elbow crutches, walkers,
248 wheelchairs, to partially replace lost gait functions. Thanks to numerous advantages, perhaps
249 posturography will become a more and more used method allowing for safe and effective
250 diagnosis and then rehabilitation of people with neurological and musculoskeletal disorders,
251 due to the elimination of the risk of falls and injuries during its use and the attractiveness of
252 exercises.
253 10
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
254 References:
258 2. Paszko-Patej G., Terlikowski R., Kułak W., Sienkiewicz D., Okurowska-Zawada B. Czynniki
259 wpływające na proces kształtowania równowagi dziecka oraz możliwości jej obiektywnej
260 oceny. Neurologia Dziecięca. 2011; 20: 121-127.
286 11
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
287 12. Ćwirlej-Sozańska A., Wilmowska-Pietruszyńska A., Guzik A., Wiśniowska A., Drużbicki
288 M. Ocena przydatności wybranych skal i metod stosowanych w ocenie równowagi i sprawności
289 fizycznej seniorów – badanie pilotażowe. Przegląd Medyczny Uniwersytetu Rzeszowskiego i
290 Narodowego Instytutu Leków w Warszawie. 2015; 1: 8-18.
291 13. Vanicek N., King SA., Gohil R., Chetter IC., Coughlin PA. Computerized dynamic
292 posturography for postural control assessment in patients with intermittent claudication. Journal
293 of visualized experiments. 2013; 11;(82): e51077.
294 14. Honaker J.A., Converse C.M., Shepard N.T. Modified Head-Shake Computerized Dynamic
295 Posturography. Am J Audiol. 2009; 18: 108-113.
296 15. Karim H. Fuhrman S.I., Sparto P., Furman J., Huppert T. Functional brain imaging of multi-
297 sensory vestibular processing during computerized dynamic posturography using near-infrared
298 spectroscopy. NeuroImage. 2013; 74: 318-325.
299 16. Tossavainen T., Juhola M., Pyykkö I., Aalto H., Toppila E. Development of virtual reality
300 stimuli for force platform posturography. Int J Med Inform. 2003; 70: 277–283
301 17. Rosiak O., Puzio A., Kaminska D., Zwolinski G., Jozefowicz-Korczynska M. Virtual
302 Reality-A Supplement to Posturography or a Novel Balance Assessment Tool? Sensors
303 (Basel). 2022; 17;22(20): 7904.
304 18. Peters J.F. Computerized Dynamic Posturography (CDP) and the Assessment of Balance
305 with Active Head Movements. J Korean Balance Soc. 2007; 6: 243-247.
306 19. Józefowicz-Korczyńska M., Walak J., Szczepanik M., Grzelczyk W.L., Rosiak O. Ocena
307 zastosowania wirtualnej rzeczywistości jako metody fizjoterapii w uszkodzeniu obwodowym
308 narządu przedsionkowego. Otorynolaryngologia. 2014; 13: 51-57.
309 20. Strzecha M., Knapik H., Baranowski P., Pasiak J. Człowiek zazwyczaj ma dwie nogi –
310 ujęcie stabilograficzne. W: Czynniki ryzyka i profilaktyka w walce o zdrowie i dobrostan. Red.
311 Mosiewicz J. Wydawnictwo NeuroCentrum; Lublin 2008: 155–165.
312 21. Kidoń Z., Fiołka J., Ocena postępów rehabilitacji za pomocą stabilografii nadążnej.
313 Przegląd Elektrotechniczny. 2014; 90: 50-53.
314 22. Guler S., Bir L.S., Akdag B., Ardıc F. The Effect of Pramipexole Therapy on Balance
315 Disorder and Fall Risk in Parkinson’s Disease at Early Stage: Clinical and Posturographic
316 Assessment. ISRN Neurol. 2012; 2012: 1-7.
317 12
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
318 23. Sebastia-Amat S., Tortosa-Martínez J., Pueo B. The Use of the Static Posturography to
319 Assess Balance Performance in a Parkinson's Disease Population. International journal of
320 environmental research and public health. 2023; 5; 20(2): 981.
321 24. Zawadka M., Klawe J.J., Zalewski P. i wsp. Ocena wybranych parametrów stabilności
322 postawy i funkcji poznawczych osób z chorobą Parkinsona po 60 r.ż. Hygeia Public Health.
323 2013; 48: 80-85.
324 25. Nilsson M.H., Fransson P.A., Jarnlo G.B., Magnusson M., Rehncrona S. The effects of high
325 frequency subthalamic stimulation on balance performance and fear of falling in patients with
326 Parkinson's disease. J Neuroeng Rehabil. 2009; 6: 13-23.
327 26. Heuvel M. RC., Wegen E. EH., Goede C. JT., i wsp. The effects of augmented visual
328 feedback during balance training in Parkinson’s disease: study design of a randomized clinical
329 trial. BMC Neurology. 2013; 13: 137-146.
330 27. Barnes G., Hillebrand A. Statistical Flattening of MEG Beamformer Images. Hum Brain
331 Mapp. 2003; 18: 1-12.
332 28. Hong S.M., Im S., Park G.Y. The Effects of Visual and Haptic Vertical Stimulation on
333 Standing Balance In Stroke Patients. Ann Rehabil Med. 2013; 37: 862-870.
334 29. Halmi Z., Stone TW., Dinya E., Málly J. Postural instability years after stroke. Journal of
335 stroke and cerebrovascular diseases: the official journal of National Stroke Association. 2020;
336 29(9): 105038.
337 30. Fedak D., Latała B., Otfinowski J., Zajdel K. Ocena wpływu fizjoterapii na równowagę w
338 pozycji stojącej w grupie pacjentów po udarze mózgu określona na podstawie badań
339 posturograficznych. Acta Bio-Optica et Informatica Medica. 2010; 16: 208-211.
340 31. Zajdel K., Latała B., Mosurska D. Użyteczność posturografii i prób kalorycznych w
341 wybranych schorzeniach neurologicznych. Przegląd Lekarski. 2009; 66: 920-923.
342 32. Song Y.B., Chun M. H., Kim W., Lee S.J., Yi J. H., Park D.H. The Effect of Virtual
343 Reality and Tetra-Ataxiometric Posturography Programs on Stroke Patients With Impaired
344 Standing Balance. Ann Rehabil Med. 2014; 38: 160-166.
345 33. Ho TH., Yang FC., Lin RC., Chien WC., Chung CH., Chiang SL., Chou CH., Tsai CK.,
346 Tsai CL., Lin YK., Lee JT. Impact of virtual reality-based rehabilitation on functional outcomes
347 in patients with acute stroke: a retrospective case-matched study. Journal of Neurology. 2019;
348 266(3): 589-597.
349 13
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)
350 34. Kılınç M., Avcu F., Onursal O., Ayvat E., Demirci C., Yildirim S. The effects of Bobath-
351 based trunk exercises on trunk control, functional capacity, balance, and gait: a pilot
352 randomized controlled trial. Topics in Stroke Rehabilitation. 2016; 23:1, 50-58
353 35. Lu R.R., Li F., Wu Y., Hu Y.S., Xu X.L., Zou R.L., Hu X.F. Demonstration of
354 posturographic parameters of squat-stand activity in hemiparetic patients on a new multi-utility
355 balance assessing and training system. Journal of Neuroengeneering and Rehabilitation. 2013;
356 10: 37-45.
357 14
Index
Manuscript body
Download source file (894.66 kB)