Professional Documents
Culture Documents
2. Historical Perspective
3. Diagnostic Issues
10. Treatment
12. Summary
A. George, a 32-year old high school teacher, consulted his doctor 37 times about chest
pains, which had caused him great anxiety because he was convinced he was having a
heart attack. Psychological evaluation revealed considerable distress and agitation
extending beyond concerns about physical health. He readily expressed complaints in
many areas of his life, and claimed that his achievements as a teacher gave him no
pleasure. He also reported going “all out” in his day-to-day life and routinely being on
the go from 5am until the evening. Of note, George smokes, abuses alcohol, and is not
physically active. The case suggests that behavioural and psychological factors will need
to be targeted to help George with his physical health.
B. Sarah is a student in her first year of medical school and is also an athlete. She had just
finished a gruelling set of exams when she noticed the first symptoms of what she
recognized as flu. By the start of the next day, she was experiencing full-blown
symptoms: high temperature, aches and pains, a deep cough, and a runny nose. This case
illustrates the role of stressors in infectious diseases, even in physically-fit people like
Sarah.
C. One Sunday morning, Jack awakened with a strange burning sensation in his stomach.
The burning pain came and went and Jack did not seek medical attention for it for some
time. Eventually, he was taken to the nearest hospital after vomiting blood, at which time
he was diagnosed with a perforated ulcer. He reported that at the onset of the burning
pain, he had been going through considerable stress in relation to his upcoming wedding,
about which he was ambivalent. This case illustrates the relationship between stress and
gut health.
D. The actor and comedian John Candy was a smoker and significantly overweight. There
was a history of heart disease in his family, and his father died of heart disease in his
thirties. He tried to lose weight and quit smoking but was unsuccessful, and he lived a
high-pressure life. At the age of 43, John Candy died suddenly from a myocardial
embolism (blood clot in his heart). This case illustrates the combination of biological,
behavioural and likely psychosocial factors in promoting cardiovascular risk.
2. Historical Perspective
The notion that psychological processes have an impact on bodily states, and can even produce
physical disease, has a long history in Western thought, and has also been prominent in other
cultures. Medical and psychological activities and interests converged in a branch of psychology
called psychosomatic medicine. However, there was an issue with this label because it implied a
dualistic view of the mind and of the body. Indeed, during the early to mid-1900s, the thinking
was that some but not all physical disorders were the direct expression of emotion or
psychological conflicts. Over several decades of research and clinical writings it became clear
that psychological factors play a role in all aspects of health and illness. This new understanding
led to a branch of psychology called behavioural medicine, which is contained within the
broader term, health psychology.
In the DSM-5, there is a new class of disorders called Somatic Symptom and Related Disorders
that has a specific diagnosis called psychological factors affecting a medical condition. An
example of when this would be assigned is in a case wherein it is clear that a psychological or
behavioural factor (e.g., overtly ignoring one’s symptoms) is directly correlated with worsening
or non-recovery from a medical disease. Those who work in the area of behavioural medicine do
not find this DSM diagnosis particularly helpful because it lacks specific information. An
alternative system, Diagnostic Criteria for Psychosomatic Research seems to provide more
information on the type of psychological factors that may adversely impact physical health e.g.,
“Type A Behaviour.”
One’s body tissues can be affected by certain behaviours, especially when they are recurrent. For
example, the act of smoking regularly exposes body tissues to toxins that in turn confer risk for
disease. In this example, smoking is not the direct cause of disease but rather serves as a vehicle
for transmission of nicotine, which is the more proximal cause of body tissue damage.
Psychosocial variables can also damage body tissues, again indirectly, via their effects on the
endocrine system, the autonomic nervous system, and the immune system.
The study of stress has provided answers to important questions regarding the pathways by
which psychosocial variables lead to, exacerbate, or maintain physical illness and disease. The
term “stress” has been interpreted and studied in three ways: (1) as a response (2) as a stimulus,
or a property of the external world, or (3) as a transaction that intervenes between stimulus and
response.
Selye proposed the first formal theory of stress called the general adaptation syndrome (GAS).
The first phase is alarm (adaptation challenge). If the challenge persists, then resistance
(fighting or coping) follows. With continued challenge comes exhaustion (resistance fails), and
the organism may succumb to disease.
This focus box highlights the usefulness of studying the way couples interact under stress.
Research has shown for example that hostile interactions are associated with greater release of
stress-relevant hormones.
A. Social Status
Social status “refers to an individual's relative position within a social hierarchy.” What
appears to be important is the extent to which individuals hold a more dominant versus a
more submissive position in their hierarchy. Individuals in a dominant position (like
bosses) show stress responses that are similar to those in a less dominant position,
however they appear to recover more quickly from stressors– that is, they do not show a
sustained stress response whereas those lower in dominance do.
B. Social Support
One of the most pervasive and consistent psychosocial variables that has been related to
health status is social support. Individuals who feel less connected to others are at higher
risk of mortality. Good social support is a potent protective factor in health; however the
exact mechanisms remain unclear.
C. Personality
Alexythymia refers to difficulty identifying and labeling internal experiences such as
emotions. Individuals high in alexithymia also do not view internal experiences as
important. Type A personality also plays a role in medical conditions.
A. Infectious Disease
The onset of infectious diseases such as colds or the flu has been shown to be associated
with the stressors and strains of daily life. The symptoms of some infectious diseases,
often seem to onset or become exacerbated during periods of emotional stress. Exam
stress, employment stress and marital difficulties have been linked to infectious disease
risk in some studies. It is likely that immune system mechanisms are involved, but these
are unclear at the moment.
B. Ulcer
Ulcers have long been considered a symptom of stress. Psychoanalysis was once the
treatment of choice for ulcers. Evidently, the conceptualization of ulcers has changed
over time and has become more complex. It is understood that exposure to stressors is
linked with increased secretion of gastric acids (i.e., digestive juices), which erodes the
stomach’s lining, giving way to the formation of ulcers. The unpredictability of the
stressor is a moderating factor. However, questions remain as to how chronic,
unpredictable stress creates these changes in the gut. Considerable excitement has been
aroused in the medical community by the discovery of a bacterium, H. pylori, that is
believed to play a primary role in the development of ulcers. However, it likely does not
act in isolation to cause ulcers. Some preliminary work indicates that exposure to stress
intensifies the harmful actions of this bacterium, possibly via cortisol relevant
mechanisms.
Numerous studies using the stress reactivity paradigm have shown that cardiovascular
functions are responsive to changing psychological conditions. It has been argued that the
risk of cardiovascular disease increases with heightened or exaggerated cardiovascular
reactivity. However, it has been shown that blunted or attenuated cardiovascular
reactivity is also associated with health risks, so over- and under-reactivity are both
problematic. In addition to reactivity, there also has been interest in the role of
cardiovascular recovery in health and illness—delayed return to a baseline state after a
stressor is over is indicative of poor adaptation.
Some psychological factors have been implicated in cardiovascular disease. In one study,
people identified as Type A (aggressively ambitious) were approximately twice as likely
to die from heart disease as those identified as Type B (calm and relaxed), and this was
independent of behaviours like smoking. Some studies found that hostility was the main
characteristic accounting for increased risk of heart disease. The Type A versus B
characterisations do not shed light on the specific features that confer risk for heart
disease. It turn out hostility is a key factor. It features prominently in at least five
theories: the psychophysiological reactivity model, the psychosocial vulnerability
model, the transactional model, the health behaviour model, and the constitutional
vulnerability model. Individuals who are high in hostility engage in more unhealthy,
heart-disease promoting behaviours and have difficulty regulating anger. Finally,
evidence has emerged for a connection between depression and cardiovascular risk and
mortality. Several explanations have been offered. One is reduced physical activity,
which coincides with depression and confers risk for cardiovascular events. A massive
Canadian study examining a large range of risk factors for a recurrence of heart attack
showed that psychosocial variables placed third in a list of 9 risk factors.
The longitudinal study, in which a large group of people are evaluated with respect to the
existence of psychological features and are then followed up to determine whether they have
developed the disease, can shed light on possible cause-effect relationships especially when they
span many years.
10. Treatment
There are two classes of intervention that are prescribed to manage/target psychosocial factors
within the context of physical illness. “Generic” approaches include basic stress management
principles and various type of relaxation. The more targeted interventions directly focus on
modifying known psychosocial factors. For example, programs have been developed to reduce
Type A behaviour and encourage social connection.
Dr. Lavoie is a health psychologist who studies the role of behavioural and psychological factors
in chronic diseases including asthma and cardiovascular diseases. She has developed and tested a
number of interventions designed to reduce health-compromising behaviours (e.g., increase
physical activity and reduce medication non-adherence). She also trains health professionals in
the use of motivational interviewing to help patients make positive health related changes.
12. Summary
1. Self-Awareness. Learning about your stressors and how the things you do affect
your stress levels. Learning what your strengths and weaknesses are and how to
cope with or improve upon those weaknesses.
5. Diet. While experts disagree on the exact role of diet in stress, eating a well-
balanced diet, as with exercise, is not only good for your overall health, but may
help you manage stress as well. In particular, avoiding excess caffeine and excess
sugar is important because they can make stressed people feel more “jittery” and
anxious.
7. Attitude. None of the above techniques will be very effective if you fill your head
with negative thoughts and regularly view the world with a pessimistic, fatalistic
attitude. Focusing on what you can do and on what you can control, and trying to
find the best in each situation, will make each of the above techniques work much
more effectively.
Dr. Gillian Booth at St. Michael’s Hospital in Toronto conducted a 5-year longitudinal
study with residents of Toronto. She identified 1.2 million Torontonians aged 30-64 who
did not have diabetes. The neighborhoods where these people lived were rated on the
degree to which they are conducive to walking. “Walkable” neighborhoods are highly
populated, have streets that connect to other streets, and are in close proximity to stores,
schools, and other destinations. The risk of developing diabetes in the 5 year follow-up
period was 32% higher for those living in the least walkable areas compared to those who
lived in the most walkable areas in Toronto. In a similar study conducted in Utah with a
sample of 650,000 residents, people who lived in older, more walkable neighborhoods
had lower BMIs (Body Mass Index), placing them at lower risk for obesity related
disorders. Some of these benefits are likely due to greater levels of physical activity, but
other factors, such as more interaction with neighbors and higher levels of community
involvement may also make people less susceptible to weight-related illnesses.
One year before his death when he was seventy-six years of age, he
was so feeble that he had to be carried to the concert hall where a
great performance of The Creation was given in his honor under the
direction of Salieri, who later taught Beethoven. Princes and nobles
and grand ladies did him homage and the ladies threw their beautiful
cloaks over his couch to keep him warm, for it was a cold night in
March, 1808. When that part of the oratorio came where they sing,
“And there was light,” it is said that Haydn exclaimed, “Not I, but a
power from above created that.”
He died on May 30th, 1809, from shock, it is said, caused by the
booming of cannon near his house when the French besieged Vienna.
So passed this conscientious musician, whose belief is summed up
in these sentences: “I know that God appointed me a task. I
acknowledge it with thanks, and hope and believe I have done my
duty and have been useful to the world. May others do likewise.”
Haydn’s Gift to Music
Mozart was years younger than Haydn and died while still very
young, but they were the closest friends. Haydn was his teacher, but
lived to think of Mozart as his superior and didn’t hesitate to say so.
This again shows the great spirit of Haydn.
Although Haydn was an innovator and a master of form his rules
were never cast into molds he could not break through inspiration. A
critic once asked him about the introduction to the Mozart Quartet in
C major which had been much discussed on account of its complex
harmonies,—a work which today we look upon as one of the greatest
examples of his genius. Haydn replied in a decided tone, “If Mozart
has written it, be sure he had good reason for so doing.”
Albrechtsberger, a strict technician, questioned him about the use of
consecutive fourths which was breaking a good old-fashioned law of
harmony. Haydn replied, “Art is free and must not be fettered by
handicraft rule. The cultivated ear must decide, and I believe myself
as capable as any one of making laws in this respect.” Thus spoke the
great musician and not just the teacher and follower.
He loved his art so well that he welcomed the young Mozart to
Vienna generously, because of his genius. Haydn, when asked by a
manager to have one of his operas follow the night after one of
Mozart’s refused, saying: “It would be too much to venture, for next
to the great Mozart it would be difficult for anyone to stand. Could I
force home to every lover of music the grandeur and inimitableness
of Mozart’s operas, ... and display of genius, and were I able to
impress all others with the same feelings which excite me, the
nations would contend for the possession of so rare a gem. Let
Prague strive to hold fast the priceless man. But reward him
adequately, for without this the history of great men is truly sad and
offers to posterity little inducement to exertion, as indeed many a
hopeful mind lies fallow for want of encouragement. It angers me
only that Mozart has not yet been engaged at some Imperial court.
Pardon this digression but I love the man dearly.” When he left
Mozart he wrote to his friend Frau von Gennzinger, “I am
inconsolable at parting,” and then he tells with the simplicity of a
child “a happy dream” he had listening to a performance of Mozart’s
Marriage of Figaro. (Adapted from Naumann.)
And thus we see this cheerful-hearted man according honor and
love even to his rivals, his broad realistic humor showing itself, as
well as charm, dignity and beauty, in all his works whether in music
or in life.
Papa Haydn was a good and truly religious man. He leaves us an
example of kindliness and thoughtfulness, for even the people who
loaned him money, which he repaid, were remembered in his will. A
touching story is told of him; that when he returned to his parent’s
home, he kissed the floor upon which his mother and father used to
walk, so well had he remembered them, yet so simple had he
remained, he who played among and played with and played for the
greatest people who lived in his time.
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart
1756–1791
After a “Portrait of
a Young Man”
(Mozart?) by
Prud’hon, in the
Louvre, Paris.
Let us see what was happening in the world into which Beethoven
was born.
The French Revolution had closed the 1700s with blood and terror,
and the American Colonies were uneasy under British rule, and
before Beethoven was six, the American Revolution was in full blast.
It was another time like the Renaissance, when people began to
think for themselves. In other words, the individual was commencing
to count more than the nation.
Slowly we see the idea die out that only the nobles and the wealthy
had the right to life, liberty and happiness, and we see the ideas of
freedom and equality taking the place of serfdom and slavish
obedience to over-lords. All this may seem strange to appear in a
book on music but art always mirrors the life and feelings of the
people of its time.
Then came Napoleon, who dragged the French army through the
continent of Europe, until he was defeated at Waterloo by the
English.
Then, too, came the War of 1812 between England and America,
and unrest seemed to be over the face of the world.
But through it all came the insistent demand of the people for
more democratic governments, and these new demands grudgingly
granted by monarchs caused revolts and uprisings everywhere.
This was the time when men like Goethe, Schiller, Kant, Fichte and
other famous poets and philosophers did their thinking and writing.
And into this world, the great democrat, Beethoven, came to add
his contribution to life, liberty, and beauty, as have few others of our
race.
And so the road is made easy for the people who followed
Beethoven,—Weber, Schubert, Mendelssohn, Schumann and Chopin,
and later Wagner, who helped make the 19th century, a great musical
era.
Romanticism
He was born December 16th, 1770, and his mother was the chief
cook in the Castle of Ehrenbreitstein. His father, a tenor, and his
grandfather were musicians in the band of the Elector of Cologne at
Bonn. His mother was sweet and loving, but his father was unkind
and intemperate. According to some accounts, his boyhood was
spent in poverty and his father tried to drive him to earn money for
the family. It was very hard on Beethoven that his mother should
have died early in his life.
At four years of age Ludwig’s father insisted upon his learning to
play the piano, and as he did not want to practise, he was whipped
often. Later he started to work in earnest and in spite of hating it,
played in public when he was eight and at eleven he had mastered
Bach’s forty-eight Preludes and Fugues, a difficult task even for a
grown up. Besides, he had written three piano sonatas published in
1781. We think he wasted little time after his first whippings!
When thirteen, he went on the opera staff where he played
accompaniments for rehearsals, without pay. Not a bad job for a lad!
One of his first teachers was Pfeiffer, who belonged to the opera
troupe and boarded with the Beethovens. Beethoven now was
growing most enthusiastic about music and took up the study of the
organ. Not only this, but he wrote a funeral cantata for organ, which
excited the whole town.
He played the piano very beautifully, as did Mozart, and when he
went to Holland with his mother, at eleven, he played at many
private houses, and gained confidence in himself.
Think of it! When Beethoven was twelve, Neefe, his teacher and
organist at Bonn, left town and Beethoven took his place. This proves
his great ability, because playing for services was complicated. He
was so successful that Neefe prophesied he would become a second
Mozart!
In 1787, Beethoven, despite his poverty, went to Vienna, where
Mozart said that he would “make a noise in the world,” and gave the
young pianist a few lessons. Not long afterwards, Beethoven was