You are on page 1of 12

Sensors & Actuators: A.

Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Contents lists available at ScienceDirect

Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical


journal homepage: www.journals.elsevier.com/sensors-and-actuators-a-physical

A strain-resistant flexible thermistor sensor array based on CNT/MXene


hybrid materials for lithium-ion battery and human
temperature monitoring
Baichuan Sun , Gaobin Xu *, Xu Ji , Zhaohui Yang , Cunhe Guan , Shirong Chen , Xing Chen ,
Yuanming Ma , Yongqiang Yu , Jianguo Feng
Micro Electromechanical System Research Center of Engineering and Technology of Anhui Province, School of Microelectronics, Hefei University of Technology, Hefei,
Anhui 230009, People’s Republic of China

A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T

Keywords: Flexible thermistor sensors (FTSs) are well-suited for myriad applications involving strain and dynamic tem­
Flexible thermistor sensors (FTSs) perature monitoring due to the outstanding thermosensitive performance and flexibility but still challenging. In
Carbon nanotubes (CNTs) this study, a novel FTS is proposed based on the hybrid materials of carbon nanotubes (CNTs) and MXene, in­
MXene
tegrated with an innovative flexible substrate (paper/polydimethylsiloxane (PDMS)/Si3N4 nanoparticles), which
FTS array
achieves low cost, stain resistance and results in a wide temperature detection range (− 20 to 220 ◦ C) with su­
Lithium-ion batteries (LiBs)
Wearable devices perior thermosensitivity (− 0.52% ◦ C⁻1), exceptional temperature resolution (~ 0.3 ◦ C), rapid response and re­
covery times (~300 ms and 3 s, respectively), and excellent mechanical durability (withstanding 2000 bending
fatigue cycles). And the sensors excel in diverse conditions like compression, underwater, and curved surfaces.
Additionally, the optimal thermosensitive performance is achieved with a 1:2 ratio of CNT and MXene. Mech­
anistic analysis reveals that the addition of CNT can effectively adjust the interlayer spacing of MXene, enhancing
its electrical and thermosensitive properties. Furthermore, a 2 × 2 FTS array is successfully applied for
comprehensive temperature monitoring in lithium-ion batteries (LiBs), as well as for monitoring human body and
environmental temperatures as wearable devices. This technology offers high sensitivity and real-time temper­
ature recognition, providing the possibilities for FTS applications in environmental monitoring, medical elec­
tronics, and electric vehicles.

1. Introduction sensor (FTCS) [9], the flexible capacitive thermistor sensor (FCTS) [10],
the flexible infrared sensor (FIRS) [11], and the flexible thermistor
Temperature, as a fundamental parameter, holds undeniable signif­ sensor (FTS) [12]. While FTMS offers a wider temperature range but
icance, playing a critical role in various domains, from ensuring the with lower precision, suitable for general low-precision industrial ap­
safety of LiBs in the rapidly evolving electric vehicle industry to its vital plications. FTCS has challenges in low-temperature detection, sensi­
importance in medical applications, especially in COVID-19, directly tivity, and temperature range. FIRS enables non-contact measurements
influencing safety and well-being [1–3]. However, conventional rigid but are typically characterized by larger dimensions, rendering them
temperature sensors and infrared (IR) cameras exhibit limitations in unsuitable for miniaturization, and are sensitive to ambient temperature
achieving dynamic and real-time temperature detection, often suscep­ and reflectance. FTS, known for the rapid response times, heightened
tible to interference from moving targets, leading to inaccuracies [4,5]. sensitivity, and suitability for irregular surfaces, has attracted significant
In contrast, flexible temperature sensors, with their inherent adapt­ research attention. However, these sensors face challenges like me­
ability to irregular shapes, have addressed these limitations and are chanical stress vulnerability and limited temperature measurement
widely used in wearable devices, electronic skin, environmental moni­ range, driving ongoing research for improvements.
toring, automotive, and aerospace applications [6–8]. Efforts to achieve superior mechanical performance and precise
Flexible temperature sensor encompasses the flexible thermocouple temperature measurements have focused on using thermosensitive

* Corresponding author.
E-mail address: gbxu@hfut.edu.cn (G. Xu).

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.sna.2024.115059
Received 24 November 2023; Received in revised form 25 December 2023; Accepted 18 January 2024
Available online 20 January 2024
0924-4247/© 2024 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

nanomaterials, including carbon nanomaterials (CNTs [8,13], carbon monitoring purposes. We firmly believe that the proposed FTS, not only
black [14], graphene [15]), MXene [16], and metallic materials (Pt [17], fulfills the aforementioned demands but also opens new avenues and
Ag [18], and Au [19]). Among them, metallic materials are considered possibilities for more precise temperature monitoring in various fields,
suboptimal due to the high cost, limited stability, and potential envi­ including aerospace, electric vehicles, and medical electronics.
ronmental hazards. In contrast, carbon nanomaterials offer impressive
electrical conductivity, thermosensitivity and a wide operational tem­ 2. Materials and methods
perature range but suffer from weak mechanical performance, leading to
delamination and fractures [8]. Conversely, MXene demonstrates 2.1. Materials
excellent mechanical properties and electrical conductivity. However, it
is susceptible to oxidation and humidity, yet it demonstrates favorable Whatman No.1 filter paper was purchased from Whatman Company,
compatibility when combined with other materials. In this study, we UK. PDMS (Sylgard184) was purchased from Dow Corning, USA. Ag/
aimed to develop a novel hybrid material by combining CNT with Agcl ink and PI film was purchased from Zhuhai Jinshi Energy Tech­
MXene, striving to achieve a material that offers exceptional mechanical nology Co., Ltd. CNT (In this study, single-walled carbon nanotube
performance, excellent thermosensitivity, and a wide temperature (SWCNT) is employed, which will be refer to as CNT for conciseness
range. Furthermore, the domain of CNT/MXene hybrid materials in the throughout the paper), MXene and Si3N4 nanoparticles were purchased
field of thermistors has been relatively unexplored, and there is a lack of from beike 2D materials Co., Ltd. Silane coupling agent (SCA) and acetic
substantial theoretical groundwork, leaving room for further research acid were purchased from Dongguan Shanyi Plastics Co., Ltd. Screen
and exploration. printing machine was purchased from Hunan Deyun Printing Equipment
In addition to excellent thermal sensitivity, the FTSs rely on the Co., Ltd. Magnetic/electric stirrers, ultrasonic disruptor, constant tem­
flexible substrate for exceptional mechanical performance, enabling perature heating table and vacuum drying oven were purchased from
adaptation to irregular shapes, bending, and deformation, reducing the Lichen Technology Co., Ltd. CCD and microscope were purchased from
impact of stress on its performance. Commonly used flexible substrate Beijing Lepu Technology Co., Ltd. Thermal IR imaging camera was
for FTS include polyimide (PI) [20], polyethylene terephthalate (PET) purchased from Hangzhou MicroImage Software Co., Ltd. Thermostatic
[21], PDMS [22,23], and paper [24,25]. PI and PET, as traditional bath (HMDC2006) was purchased by Jiangsu Hengmin Instrument
polymers, offer exceptional heat resistance and chemical stability. Manufacturing Co., Ltd. Lithium batteries (LiBs) and battery capacity
However, PI faces challenges due to its high production costs and testers were purchased from Anhui Sanuo Electronic Technology Co.,
manufacturing complexities, while PET, in comparison to PI, exhibits Ltd. Digital multimeter purchased from Future Electronic Technology
lower heat resistance and mechanical strength and is prone to softening Co., Ltd.
and deformation when exposed to high temperatures. PDMS, provides
excellent transparency and flexibility but suffers from poor mechanical 2.2. The fabrication process of FTS
properties and high coefficient of thermal expansion (CTE), making it
prone to deformation and detachment of the electrodes [26]. In recent To fabricate the FTS, materials need to undergo a series of treat­
years, paper has garnered interest because of its remarkable biocom­ ments, as illustrated in Fig. 1(a–c). The initial step involves separately
patibility, cost-effectiveness, and eco-friendliness. Nonetheless, it does mixing MXene and CNT powders with deionized (DI) water and the
have certain mechanical limitations and is best suited for single-use surfactant through ultrasonic dispersion and stirring to prepare solu­
scenarios. To enhance the performance of paper, a common approach tions, which are subsequently combined using the same process to
involves combining it with PDMS to improve its hydrophobicity and obtain the blended solution. Next, as depicted in Fig. 1(b), the Si3N4
mechanical properties [27]. Nevertheless, this method retains the dis­ nanoparticles are chemically surface-modified using the SCA (intro­
advantages associated with PDMS. To address these challenges, the ducing amino functional groups). This modification serves to establish
incorporation of nanofillers has become a prevalent choice [27–29]. For not only a physical connection between Si3N4 and PDMS but also a
instance, Racles et al. [28] have combined PDMS with Ag nanoparticles, chemical reaction (amino functional groups, -NH2) that can react with
resulting in a harmonious enhancement of PDMS’s mechanical perfor­ the silicone-oxygen bonds (-Si-O-) in PDMS, forming silicon-nitrogen
mance while reducing its CTE (in a linear relationship with Ag content) bonds (-Si-NH2) [31]. Furthermore, the enhanced surface roughness of
and achieving a maximum strain of 550%. Suzuki et al. [29] have the modified nanoparticles promotes superior topological interlocking
effectively lowered the CTE of PDMS by blending it with four types of [32]. Prior to modification, the nanoparticles undergo activation treat­
silicon nanofillers, with mesoporous silica particles demonstrating ment at 120 ◦ C for 2.5 h in the vacuum oven. Next, they are subjected to
optimal results. ultrasonic and stirring processes in the SCA. Notably, the solution re­
Herein, we employed Si3N4 nanoparticles as nanofillers due to the quires the addition of acetic acid to adjust the PH to 5. The mixture is
excellent high-temperature stability, outstanding mechanical proper­ then left at room temperature for 1 day, followed by centrifugation
ties, corrosion resistance, and biocompatibility, which were integrated (during which distilled water and anhydrous ethanol are separately used
with the paper/PDMS composite using a combination of screen printing for washing, with three cycles). Finally, the materials are placed in the
and compression techniques, resulting in the topological interlocking vacuum oven at 60 ◦ C for 12 h to yield the surface-modified Si3N4
and heterogeneous arrangement that gave rise to the FTS capable of nanoparticles. The last step (Fig. 1(c)) involves mixing the chemically
withstanding deformation and high temperatures. Furthermore, Si3N4 modified Si3N4 with PDMS (2.0 wt%), resulting in the necessary solution
played a crucial role in dispersing stresses and further restraining for printing.
deformation [30]. Moreover, the novel hybrid materials of CNT and The experiment uses the screen printing to create the FTS. Custom
MXene exhibited the capability to detect a wide range of temperatures, screen-printing plates are prepared (Fig. 1(d)) to define the required
spanning from − 20 ◦ C to 220 ◦ C, with excellent thermosensitivity patterns. PDMS/Si3N4 is then printed onto paper, requiring multiple
(− 0.52%℃− 1), remarkable resolution (0.3 ◦ C), and rapid response times printings for full contact and pattern creation (Fig. 1(d)). This step es­
(3 s). Even after enduring over 2000 bending deformations, FTS tablishes hydrophobic and hydrophilic regions, with the latter for
continued to perform temperature monitoring flawlessly, with minimal thermosensitive materials. The substrate is heated at 80 ◦ C for 1 h in the
interference, thus achieving accurate temperature discrimination on vacuum oven. CNT/MXene hybrid materials are printed in the desig­
irregular surfaces. Most importantly, the 2 × 2 FTS array has been nated pattern area (Fig. 1(e)), followed by Ag/AgCl electrode printing
successfully integrated into LiBs and wearable devices, meeting the (Fig. 1(f)). Then, the second PDMS/Si3N4 printing (Fig. 1(g)) serves to
temperature monitoring needs of LiBs while also detecting temperature encapsulate the CNT/MXene, preventing oxidation upon exposure to air
fluctuations in real-time in and around the human body for health and acting as a barrier against contaminants. Additionally, the

2
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 1. The fabrication process of FTS. (a) Preparation of CNT and MXene blend solution; (b) Surface modification of Si3N4 nanoparticles; (c) Mixing PDMS with
Si3N4 nanoparticles; (d) Screen printing PDMS/Si3N4 on paper; (e) Screen printing of MXene/CNT hybrid materials; (f) Printing the Ag/AgCl electrode; (g) Second
Round of PDMS/ Si3N4 printing; (h) Second encapsulating of FTS using PI film and compression (20 MPa); (i) Cross-sectional image of FTS.

mechanical and thermal properties in this region are enhanced. Simi­ structure and to assess how they respond to external conditions under
larly, it is heated at 80 ◦ C for 1 h. The final step (Fig. 1(h)) involves identical resistance. SolidWorks was employed for three-dimensional
attaching a PI film to the back of the FTS, serving as a secondary (3D) modeling, and COMSOL Multiphysics was used for further char­
encapsulation and facilitating attachment to the desired location. acteristic analysis.
Furthermore, it is crucial to subject the completed FTS to compression In the thermodynamic simulation, the boundary conditions for FTS
(20 MPa, 30 min) to improve the contact, eliminate void between ma­ were established based on the actual testing system and conditions. The
terial layers, and further enhance mechanical performance. With these sensitive materials were the CNT/MXene hybrid materials, and the
steps, the FTS is completed, and the cross-sectional image is shown in flexible substrate was considered as a solid block for analysis. The
Fig. 1(i). ambient temperature was set at 25 ◦ C, and the heating temperature was
set at 80 ◦ C, with the bending stress of 10 N/m2. Stress was applied from
2.3. Simulation both the X and Y directions. As depicted in Fig. 2(a–d), it can be observed
that, under the combined influence of bending deformation and thermal
Prior to conducting experiments, we performed mechanical and expansion, the block structure exhibited significantly greater internal
thermal simulations on the FTS to compare the curved and block stress compared to the curved structure. Consequently, it was more

3
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 2. Simulation analysis of FTS. (a)-(b) Thermodynamic simulation analysis of curved structure FTS in X and Y directions; (c)-(d) Thermodynamic simulation
analysis of block structure FTS in X and Y directions; (e)-(g) Thermodynamic simulation analysis of Si3N4 in the flexible substrate.

susceptible to deformation and more prone to stress-induced de­ width of 0.5 mm, the bending radius of 0.5 mm, and the approximate
formations. Moreover, the lower CTE of the thermosensitive material, in thickness of 0.2 mm. As observed in the SEM image, the CNT/MXene
comparison to the substrate, aids in mitigating stress concentration hybrid materials exhibit the fibrous tubular structure for CNT and the
during thermal expansion. Therefore, the adoption of the curved design sheet structure for MXene. CNT primarily consists of C atoms, while the
enhances the stability of FTS for measuring temperature variations. employed MXene is Ti3C2Tx, composed of Ti, C, Tx (F and O atoms), and
Additionally, thermodynamic simulations were performed on the H atoms (Fig. 3(b)). Moreover, Fig. 3(c) reveals that after the second
Si3N4 nanoparticles within the substrate to characterize their role in the layer of PDMS/Si3N4 encapsulation, the CNT/MXene is covered
FTS. The 3D structure (10 ×10 ×2 µm3) consisted of two layers, with the beneath, serving to prevent exposure to contaminants and oxidation
first layer being the CNT/MXene and the second layer as the flexible risks. Furthermore, energy-dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS) analysis
substrate. The boundary conditions matched the previously described in Fig. 3(d) and (e) reveals higher C content, primarily due to the
setup, with the bottom of the substrate being subjected to fixed con­ presence of cellulose fibers in the paper and the inherent C content in
straints. As depicted in Fig. 2(e) - (g), it is evident that the presence of CNT and MXene. Additionally, there are notable amounts of Ti, O, and F
Si3N4 concentrates stress within its own region. This property effectively present. In the encapsulated FTS, the introduction of Si and N elements
disperses in-plane stress concentration, thereby suppressing the defor­ due to the PDMS/Si3N4 encapsulation is confirmed.
mation and thermal expansion effects. Moreover, due to the low CTE, Furthermore, as depicted in Fig. 3(g), the unencapsulated FTS un­
high strength, and good thermal conductivity of Si3N4, it further en­ dergo oxidation when exposed to the air, resulting in increased resis­
hances the substrate’s mechanical properties, reducing mechanical tance and thus impacting the detection performance. Moreover, this
deformation and the impact of temperature on the FTS. oxidation process accelerates with rising temperatures. For instance, at
20 ◦ C, after 9 h, the resistance increased by approximately 1%. At 80 ◦ C,
3. Results and discussion the resistance increased by around 8%. In contrast, the encapsulated FTS
maintains stable resistance at the same temperature conditions. Even
3.1. FTS encapsulation and resistance variation after 30 days of storage at room temperature (Fig. 3(h)), the resistance
remains essentially unchanged. In contrast, the unencapsulated FTS
The fabricated FTS in this study is illustrated in Fig. 3(a–c). Fig. 3(a) experiences the resistance change of approximately 7.5%. This clearly
shows the FTS without PDMS/Si3N4 encapsulation, featuring the black highlights the significance of encapsulation, while also confirming the
pattern representing the CNT/MXene (1:2) hybrid materials, with the convenience and effectiveness of using the same materials in flexible

4
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 3. Internal structural analysis and resistance change comparison of encapsulated and unencapsulated FTS. (a) Physical and SEM images of unencapsulated FTS;
(b) Schematic representation of CNT and MXene composition; (c) Physical and SEM images of encapsulated FTS; (d) EDS analysis of unencapsulated MXene; (e) EDS
analysis of unencapsulated CNT/MXene; (f) EDS analysis of encapsulated CNT/MXene; (g) Resistance comparison of encapsulated and unencapsulated FTS under
heating conditions (20–80 ◦ C); (h) Resistance comparison of encapsulated and unencapsulated FTS at room temperature (20 ◦ C) after 30 days of storage.

substrate for this purpose. observation, we used a 0.5 × 4 mm2 paper along with the thermo­
sensitive materials (Fig. 4(a)). The resistance of CNT and MXene is
48.47 Ω and 194.27 Ω, respectively. Furthermore, we observed varia­
3.2. Performance analysis of CNT/MXene hybrid thermosensitive
tions in resistance at different mixing ratios. Following mixing, an initial
materials
resistance increase was observed, with a subsequent decline in resis­
tance becoming apparent as the MXene content increased. This behavior
To determine the optimal performance of CNT/MXene hybrid ma­
stems from interface effects between MXene and CNT. Limited contact
terials in thermosensitive applications, we compared different mixing
introduces interface resistance, hindering electron flow and increasing
ratios (4:1, 3:1, 2:1, 1:1, 1:2, 1:3, 1:4). To simplify the fabrication and

5
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 4. Performance comparison of the CNT/MXene hybrid materials. (a) Resistance comparison of CNT, MXene, and different mixing ratios; (b) XRD comparison of
CNT/Paper, MXene/Paper, CNT/MXene/Paper, and encapsulated CNT/MXene; (c) Comparison in resistance variation with temperature for CNT, MXene, and
different mixing ratios of hybrid materials; (d) Schematic illustration of the NTC principle for hybrid materials; (e) Comparison of TCR for CNT, MXene, and different
mixing ratios of hybrid materials; (f) Comparative I-V characteristics of hybrid materials at different temperatures (20–80 ◦ C); (g) Resistance variation of hybrid
materials under heating and cooling conditions (− 20–220 ◦ C); (h) Arrhenius plot depicting the linear correlation between ln(R) and temperature (1000/T).

resistance. Simultaneously, fibrous structure of CNT can fill gaps be­ observations [33]. Furthermore, it’s worth mentioning that PDMS and
tween MXene layers, reducing electron scattering and enhancing con­ Si3N4 nanoparticles lack specific crystal planes, resulting in the absence
ductivity while lowering resistance [33]. of prominent crystal facets in the XRD analysis.
To further substantiate the findings, we conducted X-ray diffraction Additionally, to further compare the performance of materials in
(XRD) tests on CNT/Paper, MXene/Paper, CNT/MXene/Paper, and thermosensitive applications, the FTS was attached to the surface of the
CNT/MXene/Paper encapsulated with PDMS/Si3N4. As shown in Fig. 4 thermostatic bath and connected them to the DMM for testing. It’s
(b), apart from the three cellulose crystal planes of the paper (101), essential to note that we assessed the thermal responses by studying the
(101), and (002) corresponding to angles of 14.9◦ , 16.5◦ , and 22.8◦ , two relationship between relative resistance change (ΔR/R0) and tempera­
crystal planes persisted: CNT’s (100) plane and MXene’s (002) plane, ture. In Fig. 4(c), we observed a consistent decrease in resistance for
corresponding to angles of 26◦ and 6.9◦ , respectively. Notably, with the different materials from 20 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C. This behavior can be attributed
addition of CNT, the peak of MXene shifted to around 4.6◦ , indicating to the negative temperature coefficient (NTC) properties of both CNT
that the inclusion of CNT resulted in an increased interlayer spacing in and MXene. As the temperature rises, electrons transition to the con­
MXene, corroborating the accuracy of the previously described duction band, increasing carrier density, which, in turn, reduces

6
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

resistance (Fig. 4(d)). Notably, when CNT and MXene are combined in a FTS, multiple thermal cycles (20–90 ◦ C) were performed, and the rela­
1:2 ratio, the resistance change is particularly conspicuous. Further­ tive current change (ΔI/I0) was recorded. As depicted in Fig. 5(b), after
more, compared to pure CNT and MXene, the hybrid materials exhibit a 10 cycles, the performance of FTS exhibited negligible variation, making
faster resistance change within the same temperature range. To evaluate it suitable for continuous monitoring applications. Additionally, preci­
the role of thermosensitive materials in thermal sensing, the tempera­ sion tests were conducted, demonstrating that FTS can accurately detect
ture coefficient of resistance (TCR) was quantified as Eq. (1): resistance changes within around 0.3 ◦ C range (Fig. 5(c)). This illus­
trates the outstanding temperature resolution of FTS, rendering it suit­
TCR = [(RT − R0 )/R0 ]/ΔT (1)
able for detecting subtle temperature variations.
where RT represents the instantaneous resistance at temperature T, and To further validate the applicability of the FTS in complex conditions
R0 corresponds to the initial resistance at the reference temperature such as compression, underwater environments, and bending de­
(20 ◦ C). As illustrated in Fig. 4(e), it is evident that the hybrid materials formations, we integrated the FTS with these different scenarios and
with the 1:2 mixing ratio exhibit a notable TCR, amounting to − 0.52% conducted reactivity tests by monitoring relative resistance changes
◦ − 1
C , surpassing several literature-reported thermosensitive sensors (ΔR/R0). As shown in Fig. 5(d), when subjected to varying levels of
with CNT, as shown in Table 1. This further illustrates that the addition pressure by adding pure water into the beaker (0–44 N), the resistance
of CNT into MXene fills the interlayer gaps, enhances electrons transi­ remained almost unchanged, indicating its stress-inhibiting character­
tion to the conduction band, increases carrier density, thereby istics, which may be related to the topological interlocking between the
improving the TCR of the hybrid materials. However, an excess of CNT substrate materials and stress dispersion of Si3N4 nanoparticles. Sub­
can lead to insufficient interlayer contact in MXene, thereby diminishing merging the FTS underwater (Fig. 5(e)) and heating it to 90 ◦ C, the re­
the TCR (Fig. 4(e)). Consequently, we adopted the CNT/MXene blend sults were nearly identical to those obtained in the air, confirming the
ratio of 1:2 in our experiments. Moreover, Fig. 4(f) showcases that the waterproof performance of FTS. In addition, we conducted bending tests
hybrid material maintains a robust I-V relationship with exceptional at various angles (from 0 ◦ − 90◦ , Fig. 5(f)). As the bending angle
ohmic characteristics across various temperatures. increased, the resistance also increased. However, at a high angle of 90◦ ,
Furthermore, we conducted extensive high and low-temperature the relative resistance change did not exceed 0.15%, making it negli­
experiments on the FTS, expanding the scope of our investigations, as gible. After undergoing 100, 1000, and 2000 bending cycles, the resis­
shown in Fig. 4(g). Remarkably, over a wide temperature range from tance changes displayed a consistent trend, further verifying the strain
− 20 ◦ C to 220 ◦ C, the change in resistance of the FTS demonstrated an resistance of FTS. Moreover, as shown in Fig. 5(g), the relative resistance
approximate quadratic relationship, with correlation coefficients (R2) changes at high temperatures (80 ◦ C) remained consistent, even after
reaching 0.99 during both the heating and cooling phases. Notably, numerous deformations. To validate the adaptability of FTS to different
cyclic heating and cooling tests revealed nearly overlapping curves, surfaces, as shown in Fig. 5(h), we conducted temperature tests on both
suggesting minimal hysteresis effects. Given the nonlinear relationship flat and curved surfaces (20–90 ◦ C). The results revealed nearly identical
between resistance and temperature, we utilized the Arrhenius model relative resistance changes. Therefore, the FTS is suitable for most
(Eq. (2)) to fit the data: operating conditions and enables real-time, precise temperature moni­
toring over a wide range.
ln(R) = ln(Ri ) + B/T = ln(Ri ) + Ea /2kB T (2)
3.4. Practical applications of FTS
where Ri signifies the resistance at infinite temperature, Ea represents
the thermal activation energy, kB represents the Boltzmann constant, 3.4.1. Practical application of FTS in LiB monitoring
and Ea /2kB T=B is referred to as the thermal index (Fig. 4(h)). The strong Temperature monitoring of LiBs is crucial to ensuring their safety
linearity observed between ln(R) and 1000/T within the range of − 20 ◦ C and efficient operation. To enable real-time temperature monitoring of
to 220 ◦ C, with an R2 value of 0.97, underscores the dominant role of the commercial LiB (10 Ah, with dimensions of 110 mm in length,
thermally activated charge carriers in the Arrhenius-like temperature 60 mm in width, and 12 mm in thickness), the thermal IR imaging
dependence, highlighting the pronounced NTC behavior. camera was used in comparison with the FTS. Furthermore, for the
convenience of data recording, the resistance changes in the FTS were
3.3. Sensing performance of FTS converted into temperature changes using the linear equation as illus­
trated in Fig. 4(h). In order to further determine the internal tempera­
To quantitatively analyze the sensing performance of FTS, tests were ture distribution of the LiB during charging, simulation and modeling
conducted under various conditions. Specifically, FTS was attached to were conducted. As shown in Fig. 6(a), it was observed that the tem­
the outer wall of the thermostatic bath and subjected to temperature perature surrounding the positive electrode of the battery was higher
changes from 20 ◦ C to 80 ◦ C and from 20 ◦ C to − 20 ◦ C, to evaluate its than that around the negative electrode, and the central region exhibited
response time and recovery time. Typically, response time and recovery higher temperatures compared to the sides. In pursuit of enhanced
time are determined using the criteria of a 10% and 90% change in temperature monitoring accuracy and sensitivity, as depicted in Fig. 6
resistance, respectively, to assess the response speed and recovery (b), a 2 × 2 sensor array (with dimensions of 60 ×50 mm2) was
characteristics of sensors [13]. As shown in Fig. 5(a), under both heating employed to facilitate comprehensive analysis and monitoring of the
and cooling conditions, the response time of FTS was approximately LiB. The experimental setup for temperature monitoring, shown in Fig. 6
300 ms, with recovery times of about 3 s and 3.3 s, respectively, (c), consisted of the FTS, LiB, battery capacity tester, and DMM.
showing minimal differences. Furthermore, to validate the stability of The initial experiment involved charging and discharging the LiB at a
3C rate (9A). Fig. 6(d) and (e) show that the battery generated heat
Table 1 during these processes, with the discharging process exhibiting slightly
Comparison of sensitivity and detection ranges for different FTS. higher temperatures than the charging process. Notably, there was an
Material Sensitivity (℃− 1) Range Ref. initial rapid temperature increase, followed by a period of stabilized
temperature rise, and finally, a rapid increase in heat generation. These
CNT/PET -0.4% -40-100 ℃ [13]
CNT film -0.07% 4.2-420 K [34] observations are consistent with previous research findings [38].
MWCNT/PVBC_Et3N -0.4% 20–40 ◦ C [35] Importantly, FTS embedded the LiB monitoring results closely aligned
Epoxy/MWCNT composites -0.036% 20-160 ◦ C [36] with thermal IR monitoring, affirming the practicality and effectiveness
MWCNT/PMMA composites -0.13% 20-160 ◦ C [37] of the FTS.
CNT/MXene/Paper/PDMS/Si3N4 -0.52% -20-220 ◦ C
Subsequently, we conducted tests using the battery tester at different

7
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 5. Sensing Performance of FTS. (a) Resistance changes of FTS under heating (80 ◦ C) and cooling (− 20 ◦ C) conditions; (b) Relative current changes (ΔI/I0) of FTS
after 10 cycles of heating; (c) Resolution of FTS; (d) Resistance changes of FTS under compression (0–44 N); (e) Resistance changes of FTS when heated underwater;
(f) Resistance changes of FTS under bending deformation (No.1, No.100, No.1000, No.2000); (g) High-temperature response of FTS after bending deformation; (h)
Comparative analysis of relative resistance changes with temperature for FTS on different surfaces.

charge and discharge rates, specifically 1C (3A), 2C (6A), 3C (9A), 4C To further validate the effectiveness of the sensor array and assess
(12A), and 5C (15A), while recording temperature changes. As depicted temperature variations at different locations within the battery, we
in Fig. 6(f) and (g), as the charge and discharge rates increased, the employed each of the four individual FTS sensors separately. As
temperature rise rate of battery accelerated, accompanied by a corre­ observed in Fig. 6(h) and (i), the temperature increase was most rapid
sponding temperature increase. This behavior can be attributed to the near the positive electrode (Sensor 1), followed by Sensors 2 and 3.
heat generation formula (Q = I2 Rt), where higher current results in Sensor 4, situated far from the positive electrode and closer to the edge
increased heat production, consequently leading to a faster temperature of the battery, exhibited a temperature difference of approximately 2 ◦ C
rise. Furthermore, the heat generated during charging was slightly lower compared to Sensor 1. This comprehensive data underscores the ca­
than during discharging, and both temperature variations followed pacity of array for real-time monitoring at distinct locations within the
linear trends. Specifically, the charging process exhibited an R2 of battery. Moreover, real-time monitoring achieved through flexible
approximately 0.99, while the discharging process displayed an R2 of contact enhances methods such as IR monitoring that are unable to meet
around 0.96 (with a slight deviation at the 1 C rate, where the R2 was the demands of continuous monitoring.
approximately 0.948).

8
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 6. Physical application of FTS in LiB Monitoring. (a) Schematic diagram of internal temperature distribution within the LiB; (b) Schematic diagram of the FTS
array placed inside the LiB; (c) Monitoring platform for LiB charge and discharge; (d)-(e) Temperature variations during LiB charge and discharge at the 3 C rate,
compared with IR camera monitoring; (f)-(g) Temperature changes during LiB charge and discharge at different rates (1 C, 2 C, 3 C, 4 C, 5 C); (h)-(i) Temperature
monitoring distribution of the array during LiB charge and discharge.

3.4.2. Physical application of FTS in wearable devices temperature differences not exceeding 0.1 ◦ C. These minor differences
Wearable devices are crucial in temperature monitoring, providing may be attributed to the non-uniform temperature distribution on the
real-time and convenient temperature data, which is essential for health human body and transient temperature fluctuations. Additionally, the
and various applications. Therefore, our experiment applies FTS to average temperature is calculated from the four sensors within the array
temperature monitoring on both the human body and the environment. and compare them with data from the IR monitoring camera (Fig. 7(e)).
In the experiment, the FTS array is placed directly on the skin of the The results reveal that under normal state, the temperature of the arm
human arm for monitoring, as depicted in Fig. 7(a), and compare it with remains at approximately 33.3 ◦ C. After physical activity, the temper­
real-time data from the IR imaging camera. As shown in Fig. 7(b) and ature increases by approximately 1 ◦ C due to the movement of blood
(c), the images display the temperature of the arm skin under normal within the body. And, it returns to its original temperature within half an
state and after running, demonstrating that the temperature in the FTS hour. The high level of consistency with reference data reaffirms the
closely corresponds to that of the arm, highlighting excellent thermal effectiveness of the FTS.
conductivity. Furthermore, Fig. 7(d) illustrates the temperature from the Next, we affixed the FTS array onto the surface of clothes to achieve
four sensors within the array, all exhibiting consistent trends with environmental temperature monitoring, as shown in Fig. 7(f). To

9
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Fig. 7. Practical applications of FTS as a wearable device for human body and environmental temperature monitoring. (a) Physical image of the FTS array in contact
with the arm skin. (b)-(c) IR images of the human arm under normal state and after running. (d) Real-time temperature monitoring comparison of the FTS array’s four
sensors on the arm. (e) Temperature comparisons between FTS and IR camera monitoring under different states. (f) Physical image of the FTS array attached to
clothes. (g) Comparative monitoring of environmental temperature by FTS and an IR camera. (h) Temperature monitoring comparisons at various distances of the
FTS from a heat source.

monitor real-time environmental temperature changes, we deactivated 220 ◦ C) with outstanding thermosensitive properties (TCR=− 0.52%
◦ 1
the lab’s temperature control device, allowing us to observe temperature C⁻ ), remarkable resolution (~0.3 ◦ C), and excellent response and re­
fluctuations. The monitoring results from FTS and the IR camera were covery times during high and low-temperature cycles (~300 ms and 3 s,
almost identical, as depicted in Fig. 7(g). Furthermore, we placed the respectively). It showcases superior durability, maintaining accurate
FTS array in close proximity to a heat source (50 ◦ C) and observed that temperature data acquisition even after undergoing 2000 bending cy­
the closer it was to the heat source, the more accurate the temperature cles. Moreover, it can be applied in various scenarios, including
measurements became. When positioned at a 1 cm distance, the moni­ compression deformation, underwater conditions, and on curved sur­
toring accuracy reached 99%. This capability provides FTS with an faces. Additionally, we have successfully applied the 2 × 2 FTS array to
application in early heat warning systems. However, at a 10 cm distance LiB and human/environmental temperature monitoring, particularly as
from the heat source, there was still some thermal response, albeit with a wearable device. In comparison to the commercial IR imaging camera,
reduced accuracy due to heat diffusion and convection effects, providing FTS excels in temperature recognition and overcomes the limitations of
a form of temperature warning to a certain extent. continuous monitoring faced by IR detection. In conclusion, from a
structural perspective, the preparation of the FTS substrate mitigates the
4. Conclusion impact of deformation interference in the temperature sensor domain. In
terms of materials, the introduction of a novel hybrid thermosensitive
In this work, we propose a novel FTS based on hybrid materials of materials of CNT and MXene offers improved sensitivity and mechanical
CNT/MXene, which is fabricated on the flexible substrate composed of performance. Concerning performance, the FTS array achieves high
paper/PDMS/Si3N4, enabling accurate real-time temperature moni­ sensitivity, a wide temperature range, and high-precision temperature
toring and exhibiting resistance to deformation interference. It holds recognition. It can be anticipated that FTS provides a simple, cost-
practical application value in various fields, including LiB temperature effective, and efficient method for producing flexible temperature sen­
monitoring, human and environmental temperature sensing. Notably, sors and holds promising prospects in various fields, including aero­
our research reveals that a 1:2 mixture ratio of CNT/MXene exhibits space, electric vehicles, and medical electronics.
optimal performance in the thermosensitive fields. Furthermore, the
proposed FTS is capable of a wide temperature detection range (− 20 to

10
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

CRediT authorship contribution statement [18] J. Bang, et al., Highly sensitive temperature sensor: ligand-treated Ag nanocrystal
thin films on PDMSwith thermal expansion strategy, Adv. Funct. Mater. 29 (2019)
1903047.
Ma Yuanming: Methodology. Chen Xing: Validation, Methodology. [19] J. Shin, et al., Sensitive wearable temperature sensor with seamless monolithic
Chen Shirong: Methodology, Investigation, Data curation. Guan integration, Adv. Mater. 32 (2020) 1905527.
Cunhe: Supervision, Software. Yang Zhaohui: Project administration, [20] P. Sahatiya, et al., Graphene-based wearable temperature sensor and infrared
photodetector on a flexible polyimide substrate, Flex. Print. Electron. 1 (2016)
Methodology. Ji Xu: Software, Resources, Methodology. Xu Gaobin: 025006.
Visualization, Validation, Investigation, Funding acquisition, Formal [21] J. Ma, H. Fan, Z. Li, Y. Jia, A. Yadav, G. Dong, W. Wang, W. Dong, S. Wang, Multi-
analysis, Conceptualization. Sun Baichuan: Writing – review & editing, walled carbon nanotubes/polyaniline on the ethylenediamine modified
polyethylene terephthalate fibers for a flexible room temperature ammonia gas
Writing – original draft, Software, Project administration, Investigation. sensor with high responses, Sens. Actuators B 334 (2021) 129677.
Feng Jianguo: Visualization, Validation. Yu Yongqiang: Methodology, [22] R. Zhang, Q. Zhai, F. Bao, D. Zhao, Z. Lu, J. Wang, W. Wang, A highly stretchable
Formal analysis. force sensitive and temperature sensitive sensor material with the sandwich
structure of PDMS + PDMS/GaInSn + PDMS, Polymers 15 (2023) 3776.
[23] L. Wu, J. Qian, J. Peng, et al., Screen-printed flexible temperature sensor based on
FG/CNT/PDMS composite with constant TCR, J. Mater. Sci Mater. Electron 30
Declaration of Competing Interest (2019) 9593–9601.
[24] H. Liu, H. Xiang, Y. Wang, Z. Li, L. Qian, P. Li, Y. Ma, H. Zhou, W. Huang, A flexible
The authors declare that they have no known competing financial multimodal sensor that detects strain, humidity, temperature, and pressure with
carbon black and reduced graphene oxide hierarchical composite on paper, ACS
interests or personal relationships that could have appeared to influence Appl. Mater. Interfaces 11 (43) (2019) 40613–40619.
the work reported in this paper. [25] J. Lee, Y. Choi, J. Jang, S. Yeom, W. Lee, B. Ju, High sensitivity flexible paper
temperature sensor and body-attachable patch for thermometers, Sens. Actuators A
313 (2020) 112205.
Data availability
[26] J. Liu, G. Zong, L. He, Y. Zhang, C. Liu, L. Wang, Effects of fumed and mesoporous
silica nanoparticles on the properties of sylgard 184 polydimethylsiloxane,
No data was used for the research described in the article. Micromachines 6 (2015) 855–864.
[27] E. Noviana, T. Ozer, C.S. Carrell, J.S. Link, C. McMahon, I. Jang, C.S. Henry,
Microfluidic paper-based analytical devices: from design to applications, Chem.
Acknowledgments Rev. 121 (19) (2021) 11835–11885.
[28] C. Racles, M. Asandulesa, V. Tiron, C. Tugui, N. Vornicu, B. Ciubotaru, M. Mičušík,
M. Omastová, A. Vasiliu, C. Ciomaga, Elastic composites with PDMS matrix and
This research was partially supported by National Key Research and polysulfone-supported silver nanoparticles as filler, Polymer 217 (2021) 123480.
Development Program of China (2022YFB3205903) and Major R&D [29] N. Suzuki, Y. Kamachi, K. Takai, S. Kiba, Y. Sakka, N. Miyamoto, Y. Yamauchi,
Innovation Project of Anhui Provincial Development and Reform Com­ Effective use of mesoporous silica filler: comparative study on thermal stability and
transparency of silicone rubbers loaded with various kinds of silica particles, Eur. J.
mission (JZ2021AFKJ0050).
Inorg. Chem. (2014) 2773–2778.
[30] S. Hao, Q. Fu, L. Meng, et al., A biomimetic laminated strategy enabled strain-
References interference free and durable flexible thermistor electronics, Nat. Commun. 13
(2022) 6472.
[31] J. Dai, Y. Huang, J. Ma, Surface characteristics and aqueous dispersibility of
[1] H. Wang, M. Ülgen, M. Trajkovski, Importance of temperature on immuno-
commercial silicon nitride powders: effects of acid leaching, surface hydrolysis,
metabolic regulation and cancer progression, FEBS J. (2023) 1742–4658.
and thermal oxidation, Ceram. Int. 34 (8) (2008) 1835–1842.
[2] M. Ujiie, S. Tsuzuki, N. Ohmagari, Effect of temperature on the infectivity of
[32] X. Shang, Y. Zhu, Z. Li, Surface modification of silicon carbide with silane coupling
COVID-19, Int. J. Infect. Dis. 95 (2020) 301–303.
agent and hexadecyl iodiele, Appl. Surf. Sci. 394 (2017) 169–177.
[3] J. Peng, S. Jia, H. Yu, X. Kang, S. Yang, S. Xu, Design and experiment of FBG
[33] X.Y. Fu, L.L. Wang, L.J. Zhao, Z.Y. Yuan, Y.P. Zhang, D.Y. Wang, D.P. Wang, J.Z. Li,
sensors for temperature monitoring on external electrode of lithium-ion batteries,
D.D. Li, V. Shulga, G.Z. Shen, W. Han, Controlled assembly of MXene nanosheets as
IEEE Sens. J. 21 (2021) 4628–4634.
an electrode and active layer for high-performance electronic skin, Adv. Funct.
[4] D. Assumpcao, S. Kumar, V. Narasimhan, J. Lee, H. Choo, High-performance
Mater. 31 (2021) 2010533.
flexible metal-on-silicon thermocouple, Sci. Rep. 8 (2018) 13725.
[34] A. Di Bartolomeo, M. Samo, F. Giubileo, C. Altavlla, L. lemmo, S. Piano, F. Bobba,
[5] R. Alfredo Osornio-Rios, J.A. Antonino-Daviu, R. de Jesus Romero-Troncoso,
M. Longobardi, A. Scarfato, D. Sannino, A.M. Cucolo, P. Ciambelli, Multiwalled
Recent industrial applications of infrared thermography: a review, IEEE Trans. Ind.
carbon nanotube films as small-sized temperature sensors, J. Appl. Phys. 105
Inform. 15 (2) (2019) 615–625.
(2009) 064518.
[6] R. Liu, L. He, M. Cao, Z. Sun, R. Zhu, Y. Li, Flexible temperature sensors, Front.
[35] A. Giuliani, M. Placidi, F.D. Francesco, A. Pucci, A new polystyrene-based
Chem. 9 (2021).
ionomer/MWCNT nanocomposite for wearable skin temperature sensors, React.
[7] B. Kuzubasoglu, S. Bahadir, Flexible temperature sensors: a review, Sens.
Funct. Polym. 76 (2014) 57–62.
Actuators, A 315 (2020) 112282.
[36] H.C. Neitzert, L. Vertuccio, A. Sorrentino, Epoxy/MWCNT composite
[8] Z. Chen, D. Zhao, R. Ma, X. Zhang, J. Rao, Y. Yin, X. Wang, F. Yi, Flexible
astemperature sensor and electrical heating element, IEEE Trans. Nanotechnol. 10
temperature sensors based on carbon nanomaterials, J. Mater. Chem. B 9 (2021)
(2011) 688–693.
1941–1964.
[37] M. Sibinski, M. Jakubowska, M. Sloma, Flexible temperature sensors on fibers,
[9] M.M. Mallick, L. Franke, A.G. Rösch, M. Hussein, Z. Long, Y.M. Eggeler,
Sensors 10 (9) (2010) 7934–7946.
U. Lemmer, High-sensitivity flexible thermocouple sensor arrays via printing and
[38] T. Dong, P. Peng, F. Jiang, Numerical modeling and analysis of the thermal
photonic curing, Adv. Funct. Mater. (2023) 2301681.
behavior of NCM lithium-ion batteries subjected to very high C-rate discharge/
[10] G.Y. Sun, S.T. Chang, Microfluidic capacitive sensors with ionic liquid electrodes
charge operations, Int. J. Heat. Mass Transf. 117 (2018) 261–272.
and CNT/PDMS nanocomposites for simultaneous sensing of pressure and
temperature, J. Mater. Chem. C 5 (2017) 1910–1919.
[11] L. Lv, W. Dang, X. Wu, H. Chen, T. Wang, L. Qin, Z. Wei, K. Zhang, G. Shen,
H. Huang, Flexible short-wave infrared image sensors enabled by high- Baichuan Sun received his B.S., and M.S. degree in School of
performance polymeric photodetectors, Macromolecules 53 (23) (2020) Mechanical and Electronical Engineering from Henan Univer­
10636–10643. sity of Technology, Zhengzhou, China. He is currently pursuing
[12] J. Wu, X. Yang, H.J. Ding, Y.M. Wei, Z.X. Wu, K. Tao, B.-R. Yang, C. Liu, X.T. Wang, his PhD at the Hefei University of Technology, with my main
S.L. Feng, X. Xie, Ultrahigh sensitivity of flexible thermistors based on 3D porous research focus on MEMS, flexible sensors, thermal runaway of
graphene characterized by imbedded microheaters, Adv. Electron. Mater. 6 (2020) lithium batteries and wearable devices, etc.
2000451.
[13] V.S. Turkani, D. Maddipatla, B.B. Narakathu, B.J. Bazuin, M.Z. Atashbar, A carbon
nanotube based NTC thermistor using additive print manufacturing processes,
Sens. Actuators A 279 (2018) 1–9.
[14] J. Gu, et al., Multifunctional poly(vinyl alcohol) nanocomposite organohydrogel
for flexible strain and temperature sensor, ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 12 (2020)
40815.
[15] J. Wu, et al., Self-calibrated, sensitive, and flexible temperature sensor based on 3D
chemically modified graphene hydrogel, Adv. Electron. Mater. 7 (2021) 2001084.
[16] G. Ge, et al., NTi3C2Tx MXene-activated fast gelation of stretchable and self-
healing hydrogels: a molecular approach, ACS Nano 15 (2021) 2698.
[17] J. Huang, N, et al., Stretchable and heat-resistant protein-based electronic skin for
human thermoregulation, Adv. Funct. Mater. 30 (2020) 1910547.

11
B. Sun et al. Sensors and Actuators: A. Physical 368 (2024) 115059

Gaobin Xu received his B.S. degree from Hefei University of Xing Chen received his B.S and M.S degree in school of mi­
Technology in 1993, M.S. degree from Hefei University of croelectronics from Hefei University of Technology, Hefei,
Technology in 2001 and Ph.D. degree from Southeast Univer­ China. He is currently working at school of microelectronics,
sity in 2004. Now he is a professor and Ph.D. supervisor at Hefei University of Technology, Hefei, China. His research in­
Hefei University of Technology. His main research interests terests include MEMS and nMEMS.
include MEMS sensor design, manufacturing, packaging and
reliability, multi-sensor module integration and information
fusion technology.

Xu Ji received his B.S. degree in School of Science at Yanshan Yuanming Ma received his B.S. and M.S. degree in School of
University in Applied Physics, Qinghuangdao, China. He is Microelectronics, Hefei University of Technology, Hefei,
currently pursuing his M.D. at the Hefei University of Tech­ China. He is currently a lecturer in School of Microelectronics,
nology, with his main research focus on electrostatic Hefei University of Technology, Hefei, China. His research in­
microspeaker. terests include MEMS sensors and systems.

Zhaohui Yang received his B.S. degree in School of Mechanical Yongqiang Yu is currently an associate Professor in School of
and Electronical Engineering from Chizhou University, Chiz­ Microelectronics, Micro Electromechanical System Research
hou, China. He is currently pursuing his PhD at the Hefei Center of Engineering and Technology of Anhui Province,
University of Technology, with his main research focus on Hefei University of Technology. His main research interests are
MEMS infrared detectors. low-dimensional semiconductor materials and micro/nano Si-
based infrared photodetectors and its applications in PPG
measurement and single-pixel imaging, and wide band-gap
semiconductors.

Cunhe Guan received his B.S. degree in School of Mechanical Jianguo Feng received his B.S., M.S. and PhD degree in School
and Electronical Engineering from Chizhou University, Chiz­ of Mechanical Engineering from Northwestern Polytechnical
hou, China. He is currently pursuing his M.D. at the Hefei University, Xi’an, China. He is currently working at School of
University of Technology, with his main research focus on the Microelectronics, Hefei University of Technology, Hefei,
reliability of MEMS devices. China. His research interests include microfluidics and
bioMEMS.

Shirong Chen received her M.S degree in detection technology


and automation from Institute of Intelligent Machines, Chinese
Academy of Sciences in 2006. She is currently a lecturer in
School of Microelectronics, Micro Electromechanical System
Research Center of Engineering and Technology of Anhui
Province, Hefei University of Technology. Her main research
interest is microelec-tronic technology and microelectronic
packaging.

12

You might also like