Public Hearing of the Committee on Labor, Employment and Human

Resources Development

Chairperson: Sen. Jinggoy Ejercito Estrada

11 December 2023, Monday, 1:00 p.m., Sen. G. T. Pecson Room, Senate

Re: Timely Enforcement of Judicial Decisions in Labor Disputes

• P. S. Res. No. 692—Sen. Raffy T. Tulfo

Background

• In line with the 1987 Constitution's dedication to safeguarding the rights and well-
being of the labor sector, guaranteeing equitable and fair conditions for workers,
and acknowledging their significance in the nation's economic progress, the
committee led by Chairperson Estrada held its second hearing on November 29,
2023. This hearing focused on issues related to the non-execution and prolonged
enforcement of court rulings in labor disputes. It specifically probed on the labor
case involving former employees of Liberty Transport Corporation, the role of DMCI
in the case, matters concerning the writ of execution, and the payment of just
compensation, among other pertinent issues.

Highlights of the Hearing of the Committee on Labor, Employment and Human

Resources Development

• Chairperson Estrada steered the focus of the hearing on P. S. Res. No. 692 and a
related case involving former employees of Liberty Transport Corporation. It was
revealed that the land awarded to the complainants in a labor case from 1996 had
not been transferred to them despite a final decision. The involvement of DMCI in
the case added complexity. Senator Estrada stressed that the hearing aimed to
clarify the case's details and achieve justice for the workers. He emphasized that the
committee's ultimate goal is to identify system deficiencies and propose legislative
and policy solutions.

• Regarding Senator Escudero's inquiries, DMCI Project Developers, Inc. clarified its
ownership, stating it is not 100% owned by DMCI Holdings but that its income is
referred to the holding company. Senator Escudero highlighted Torre Lorenzo
Development Corporation's purchase of the land from the Lacsinas, emphasizing

Page 1 of 2
 the need to secure the property due to a labor case involving one sibling. He
requested location maps and cited the importance of understanding the property's
situation.

• Senator Tulfo questioned DMCI Project Developers, Inc. officials about settling
obligations related to a labor case. The company's counsel claimed they had
complied, but the complainant disputed receiving compensation. Senator Tulfo
called for company restructuring due to improper policies and protocols, advocating
for a more systematic approach. He also suggested inviting agencies that granted
permits despite litigation knowledge to the next hearing for clarification.

Possible Points for Discussion

• Challenges in Labor Dispute Resolution: The common obstacles that hinder the
timely resolution of labor-related cases and their consequences for workers.

• Objective of the Committee: Identify system deficiencies and possible legislative

and policy solutions that must be put in place.

• Ownership and Financial Aspects: Clarification regarding DMCI Project

Developers, Inc.'s ownership and financial structure, which raised questions about
transparency in its corporate ownership.

• Property Dispute and Labor Case: How do property disputes affect the labor rights
of individuals involved, and what measures can be taken to prevent such conflicts
from impacting workers adversely?

• Role of Government Agencies: Senator Tulfo's suggestion to invite agencies that

granted permits despite litigation knowledge raises questions about regulatory
oversight. A discussion can explore the role of government agencies in ensuring
compliance with labor laws and the consequences of inadequate oversight.

• Company Restructuring and Systematic Approach: Senator Tulfo's call for

company restructuring and a more systematic approach prompts discussions on
corporate governance, internal policies, and best practices for companies involved in
labor disputes.

• Enforcement of Court Decisions: As the committee aims to ensure the timely

implementation of judicial decisions in labor disputes, the challenges in enforcing
court decisions, potential solutions, and the crucial legislative actions in facilitating
timely implementation must be comprehensively discussed.

Page 2 of 2