Aldeon A.

Nonan BSED-SS-2A

CLASS DEBATE: WOMENS RIGHT ( REVISED RUBRICS)

CRITERIA 25 10 15 10 SCORE
(Exceeding) (Meeting) (Approaching) (Beginning)
1. Clarity and Presentation All parts are Clear in some Unclear and
organization: that is very mostly clear parts but not disorganized
clear and and ordered. overall throughout
The main orderly
arguments
and responses
are presented
in a logical
and ordered
manner.
2. Usage of Throughout, Numerous Some good There were
Argument: very solid and strong justifications, few or no
persuasive arguments are but seriousgenuine
The resolution arguments are presented, flaws arguments
is supported made. with only presented, or
by arguments. small flaws. all of the
arguments
presented had
severe flaws.
3. Application Good cross- Excellent Good cross- Poor cross-
of cross- examination cross- examination exam or
examination and response examination and/or rebuttals,
and rebuttal: to the and rebuttals, rebuttals, but failure to
arguments of with only few with some point out
Detection of the negative errors serious issues problems in
flaws in the team Negative
Negative team’s
team's position or
arguments failure to
and capacity defend itself
to defend against
itself from attack.
attack.
4. All style Most style Few style Very few style
Presentation features were features were features were features were
Design: used used used used, none of
convincingly convincingly convincingly them
Tone of voice, convincingly
clarity of
expression,
and argument
precision all
help to hold
the audience's
attention and
persuade
them of the
team's
position.