You are on page 1of 8

DOI: 10.1111/tog.

12625 2020;22:75–82
The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist
Tips and techniques
http://onlinetog.org

Articles in the Tips and techniques


Clinical reflective practice section are personal views from
experts in their field on how to
undertake procedures in obstetrics
and gynaecology.
Ruth Roberts MBBS PhD MRCOG, Bid Kumar MBBS DGO MD Dip NBE FRCOG
PGCert Med Education PGCert Clin Risk Management*

Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, Wrexham Maelor Hospital, Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board, Wrexham LL13 7TD, UK
*Correspondence: Bid Kumar. Email: bidyut.kumar@wales.nhs.uk

Accepted on 4 April 2019. Published online 14 December 2019.

Please cite this paper as: Roberts R, Kumar B. Clinical reflective practice. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2020;22:75–82. https://doi.org/10.1111/tog.12625

through reflective practice can be challenging for many of us.


Introduction
This article reviews the literature that underpins the practice
Reflective practice is an established component of medical and aims to provide practical advice to facilitate the process.
education and clinical development. It is accepted that the
process of critically reflecting on a clinical experience
enhances knowledge and understanding, and facilitates History of reflective practice
learning.1 Experiences, good and bad, provide learning
Most modern-day philosophies on reflective writing are
opportunities for the individuals involved and for the wider
based on the US psychologist and philosopher John Dewey’s
system. While intuitively one might accept that reflective
assertion that ‘we learn by doing and realising what came of
practice will benefit the patient, to date there is little clinical
what we did’.6 However, Dewey’s reflective thought is only
evidence to support this notion.2 However, reflective practice
triggered by challenging or uncertain circumstances and the
is a compulsory part of medical training and is seen as
need for their resolution. According to Dewey’s theoretical
integral to a clinician’s continued professional development.3
description of reflective thinking:7
Reflection is a type of self-regulated learning. Self-regulated
 a problem arises out of present experience;
learning can be broken into three essential components:
 suggestions for a solution come to mind;
 Cognition: the mental process involved in knowing,
 relevant data are observed;
understanding and learning.
 a hypothesis is formed, acted on and tested.
 Metacognition: often defined as ‘learning to learn’.
 Motivation: a willingness to engage our metacognitive and Donald Sch€ on contextualises this for the professional and
cognitive skills. describes how reflection may be used to manage complex
problems: ‘Competent practitioners usually know more than
Metacognition and self-regulation approaches (sometimes
they can put into words. To meet the challenges of their
known as ‘learning to learn’) aim to improve learning by
work, they rely less on formulas learned in graduate school
encouraging individuals to think about their own learning
than on the kind of improvisation learned in practice.’8
more explicitly so as to take increased responsibility for
Sch€on described two terms:8
their own achievement. Metacognition involves con-
1. Reflection-in-action: thought processes that occur and
sciously planning, monitoring and evaluating one’s
influence actions taken contemporaneously during
own learning.4
an event.
The word ‘reflection’ has its roots in the Latin word
2. Reflection-on-action: a process that occurs after the event
reflectere, meaning ‘to bend back’. In medical education,
and can potentially enhance the effects of reflection-
reflection can be difficult to define. Over the past century,
in-action.
medical educators have put forward various definitions and
descriptions of reflection. In essence, it is the process of He also suggests that there are two types of knowledge:8
learning through the critical analysis of one’s actions. As De 1. Technical rationality: evidence or research-based
Cossart and Fish surmise,5 ‘there is far more to a clinical theoretical knowledge.
event than is visible on its surface’. 2. Professional artistry: knowing in action, which could be
As clinicians, every day we instinctively reflect on our clinical inferred to be a consequence of ‘reflection-in-action’ and
encounters. However, illustrating this intuitive process ‘reflection-on-action’.

ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 75


Clinical reflective practice

An individual’s approach to reflective practice may be frameworks for reflection based on Dewey’s original
influenced by the nature and scope of individual experience model. One of the most common methods used by
and their personal style of learning. clinicians is that offered by Gibbs.9 Gibbs’ reflective
framework prompts us to consider what happened and
Models of reflection how we felt at the time of the event, what the good and bad
points were in the experience of that incident and what
Reflection is personal, often confidential, and there are additional or alternative actions could have been taken. A
numerous ways to reflect. Two major dimensions to the plan of action is then formulated for similar future
models of reflection are described by Mann:2 encounters (Figure 1).
1. Iterative dimension: here, reflection is triggered by Kolb puts forward an alternative framework,10 in which he
experience, which then produces a new understanding, maintains that learning ‘is the process whereby knowledge is
and the potential or intention to act differently in response created through the transformation of experience’. Kolb’s
to future experiences. cycle of experiential learning (Figure 2) implies that effective
2. Vertical dimension: this includes different levels of learning occurs when a person progresses through a four-
reflection on experience. Generally, the surface levels are stage cycle.10
descriptive and less analytical than the deeper levels of Kolb views learning as an integrated process with each
analysis and critical synthesis. The deeper levels stage being mutually supportive of, and feeding into, the
appear more difficult to reach, hence are less next. It is possible to enter the cycle at any stage and follow it
frequently demonstrated. through its logical sequence. However, effective learning only
While clinical reflective practice might seem an abstract occurs when a learner can execute all four stages of the
concept with an ill-defined process, doubtful endpoints and model. Therefore, no one stage of the cycle is effective as a
uncertain benefits, several authors have described learning procedure on its own.10

Description
(what happened)

Feelings
Action plan (what were you
(if the event arose again, thinking and feeling
what would you do?) at the time
of the event?)

Evaluation
Conclusion
(what was good
(what else could you
and bad about
have done?)
the experience?)

Analysis
(what sense can you
make of the situation?)

Figure 1. Gibbs's reflective framework.9

76 ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Roberts and Kumar

Fish and de Cossart’s model describes elements of clinical  appreciation of the significance of context;
practice that should be considered by the practitioner during  personal qualities;
any episode of clinical reflection.11 These elements include:  professional values;
 knowledge;
 technical processes and procedures undertaken;
 clinical thinking that the practitioner engages in;
Concrete experience
(doing or having  the ability to formulate sound professional judgement and
an experience) engage in wise practice;
 the ability to establish a sound therapeutic relationship
with the patient (holistic medical practice);
 the ability to work reflectively in socially and clinically
complex settings and further deepen a holistic vision of
Active experimentation Reflective observation clinical practice.
(planning or trying out (reviewing or reflecting
what you have learnt) on the experience) Numerous templates based on the models of reflection
described have been developed to facilitate the process of
clinical reflection. The template shown in Box 1 provides an
example that may be of use to the reader and has been
adapted from one provided by the Academy of Medical Royal
Abstract
Colleges.12 This template has similarities with the one
conceptualisation
(concluding/learning
available on the Royal College of Obstetricians and
from the experience) Gynaecologists’ website.13

Figure 2. Kolb's cycle of experiential learning.10

Box 1. Template for written reflection, adapted from the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges12

Title and description of activity or event


 Date(s) of activity or event(s)
 Category in which the activity belongs
 General information about your practice
 Review of your practice – for example, quality improvement, significant events, etc.
 Feedback on your practice – for example, patient/carer/colleague feedback, complaints and compliments

What have you learned?


 Describe how this activity contributed to the development of your knowledge, skills or professional behaviours.
 Consider linking this to one or more of the General Medical Council’s Good Medical Practice domains to demonstrate compliance with their
principles and values:
○ Knowledge, skills and performance
○ Safety and quality
○ Communication, partnership and teamwork
○ Maintaining trust

How has this influenced your practice?


 How have your knowledge, skills and professional behaviour changed?
 Have you identified any skills and knowledge gaps relating to your professional practice?
 What changes to your professional behaviour were identified as desirable?
 How will this activity or event lead to improvements in patient care or safety?
 How will your current practice change as a result?
 What aspects of your current practice were reinforced?
 What changes in your team/department/organisation’s working were identified as necessary?

Looking forward, what are your next steps?


 Outline any further learning or development needs identified (individual and team/organisation, as applicable).
 If further learning and development needs have been identified, how do you intend to address these?
○ Set SMART objectives for these (specific, measurable, achievable, relevant and time-bound).
 If changes in professional practice (individual or team/department) have been identified as necessary, how do you intend to address these?

ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 77


Clinical reflective practice

Table 1. Skills of reflective supervision, as described by Rolfe and Freshwater14

Skill Description

Listening and responding Be able to use questions within the learner's professional context to stimulate reflection.

Be able to respond skillfully with clarification, summarising, reflecting and accepting.

Reflexive Be self-aware and flexible in approach.

Be able to examine one's own prejudices, values, preconceptions and ideas, and assess the impact that these have on the
learner or trainee.

Observing Recognise and acknowledge progress.

Observe strengths and weaknesses and any recurrent patterns in clinical practice.

Identify areas for development.

Transparency Be able to be open about one's own opinion, reflect openly and justify with reasoning.

Feedback Be able to recognise the learner's fears and anxieties, to provide positive feedback and to encourage the learner's
professional development.

Sensitivity to wider social Be able to recognise the possible influence of the supervisee's social background, belief, faith and values on the
context relationships of the supervisee and their interaction with the supervisor.

metacognitive process can be structured and formalised to


Box 2. Details of fictional clinical episode of a woman giving birth
benefit our learning process and practice.
The detailed case is included here as an example, but in practice, the
case notes will be available to the trainee and supervisor and this
detailed summary need not be included in the reflection. Group
A nulliparous woman at 38 weeks of gestation complained of reduced
Traditionally, within clinical practice, reflection is a solitary
fetal movements for the third time in 1 week. Her body mass index process undertaken by individual practitioners. This could be
was 36 kg/m2 and the estimated fetal weight was on the 95th centile. considered to be at odds with the clinical reality whereby
A recent haemoglobin level was 95 g/l. She underwent induction of most practitioners work as part of a team. Group reflection
labour (IOL) at 38 weeks and 3 days of gestation. In labour, fetal blood
sampling had to be performed twice because of a pathological
may be a more appropriate way of learning in some
cardiotocogram (CTG). The result of both were normal. Twenty- situations – for example, following a critical incident on
two hours after IOL, she had progressed to a cervical dilatation of 8 cm. the labour ward or in the operating theatre. Collective
During the next 4 hours, there was no progress in labour and the fetal discussion and reflection may lead to greater insight and
head was in occipito-posterior position. The CTG had improved but
remained suspicious. A caesarean section was performed at 2:00AM by learning not only for an individual, but also for the team as
an ST6 doctor. At caesarean section, the lower segment was found to a whole.
be distended and stretched. During delivery of baby, there was The models or frameworks of reflection described above can
extension of the caesarean section incision at one of the angles and
be implemented within a group. The group may consist of:
behind the urinary bladder. The consultant obstetrician was asked to
attend and the uterine defect was repaired. Estimated blood loss was  team members sharing their reflections as equal partici-
2 l. Umbilical cord pH was 6.98 (artery) and 7.04 (vein). Postoperative pants;
maternal haemoglobin was 6 g/l. The woman was given 4 units of  individuals with different roles within the group (for
blood. Haematuria persisted for 7 days. Urinary catheter was removed
example, a supervisor facilitating the reflective process of
on day 10 after caesarean section and the woman was discharged.
the other group members).
Group reflection allows individuals to share their
Types of reflection interpretation of events. What one sees or experiences may
Individual be very different from that of other team members.
This is a personal, internal, cognitive and confidential process Individual reflection may change as different perspectives
that may not necessarily be written down. This informal, come to light, thereby facilitating the learning process.

78 ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Roberts and Kumar

Table 2. Stages of clinical reflective practice following encounter with the practical example of the fictional case presented in Box 2

Role of supervisor, facilitator or


Stages of learning by learner Points for reflection (in first person) mediator

Considers prior knowledge and Am I confident about my knowledge about assessment of CTG Take into account what the learner
personal experience, if any, in a and the actions to be taken as a result? perceives to be his/her internal
similar encounter (internal experience so that the learner's
experience) Am I happy undertaking caesarean sections in women with a objective and learning is appropriate.
high BMI and in the late first-stage of labour? How many times
have I performed this before? Do I have OSATS demonstrating
competence?

Focuses attention on different aspects Was the woman allowed to remain in labour for too long before Simplify or provide a structure to the
of the clinical case and its complexity caesarean section was performed, considering EFW is on the clinical encounter.
(assimilation; this could be during 95th centile?
or after the action)
Was my technique of fetal blood sampling satisfactory? Why
were the cord blood results so different from the scalp blood
results?

I will need to discuss the CTG trace in our CTG meeting. Am I up-
to-date with my mandatory training for CTG?

Was my technique of delivering the fetal head correct for this


situation? Should I have asked for the fetal head to be pushed
up vaginally or should I have used a fetal pillow?

Does my assistant need any feedback about assisting during


caesarean section?

With a haemoglobin level of 95 g/l, I should have ensured that


blood was available if needed before starting the caesarean
section.

Was the WHO checklist followed satisfactorily or was everybody


in a rush because of the circumstances? Should we have
discussed the implication of high BMI, EFW and low
haemoglobin while going through the WHO checklist?

Draws comparison between ‘internal With a big baby, bulging lower uterine segment, occipito- Highlight variation between perceived
experience’ and the new experience posterior position in a woman with a high BMI, this caesarean ‘internal experience’ and ‘external
(external experience; constructs section was different from any I have performed before. experience’.
frames of reference)
With my supervisor, I need to explore other techniques for
delivering a baby in these circumstances.

I should have checked the colour of urine before closing the


abdomen; this would have alerted me to the haematuria and I
may have taken different actions intraoperatively, such as
ensuring the integrity of the urinary bladder by instillation of
methylene blue dye solution.

The suspicious CTG and lack of progress meant that I had to


proceed urgently and not wait for a consultant to arrive. The
cord pH supports my feelings.

On a previous occasion, such a low cord pH necessitated


prolonged neonatal support and the neonate suffered seizures.

Brings to bear the context of the case, I am at ST6 level and should be able to manage such cases on my Act as a resource for clarification of
including the wider context of the own. the context and ensure appropriate
team (temporal relations) interpretation of the context.

ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 79


Clinical reflective practice

Table 2. (Continued)

Role of supervisor, facilitator or


Stages of learning by learner Points for reflection (in first person) mediator

If this happened during normal working hours with availability of


an in-house consultant obstetrician, would the outcome at
caesarean section have been different?

Usually, the anaesthetist would ask for cross-matched blood


before starting caesarean section in these circumstances.

My junior colleague is at ST2 level and is a trainee GP; this is his


first month in his first obstetrics placement.

Did the woman lose so much blood because of my technique, or


did the scrub team or assistant have a role in this?

To hasten the delivery, perhaps I should have asked for general


anaesthesia and not waited for spinal anaesthesia to be
administered. Could I have been more explicit regarding the
timeframe in which I wanted the baby to be delivered? This
does depend on the experience of the anaesthetist, but I should
also have considered the high BMI.

I should have asked for a category 1 caesarean section. I should


consider communication issues with the senior midwife, who
was the shift co-ordinator.

What was the educational value of this clinical episode for my


assistant, a GP ST2?

Considers emotional factors, Decision to perform caesarean section was correct, but should it Signal to the learner the appropriate
professional values and human have been done earlier than this, given the pathological CTG? emotional concepts and recall or
values in managing a patient refresh the values that guide medical
At ST6 level, I should be able to manage such cases on my own. practice.
After another year I will be expected to take up a consultant job.

Debriefing for the woman and her relatives is important.

Will the baby have any long-term effects related to the low-cord
pH and hypoxia?

I must follow up with the neonatologist to find out what


happened.

Daily postoperative review was undertaken as I was worried


about undetected bladder injury. Should I have asked for
imaging tests of the urinary bladder?

I was relieved when haematuria subsided after 7 days but feel


that I removed the urinary catheter too soon after. What if there
was bladder injury and it did not heal properly.

As a result of the new experience, Am I up-to-date with my mandatory CTG training? Guide the learner to the appropriate
considers exploring and searching for resources – for example, an
existing evidence or literature about I need to explore the literature and review outcomes of induction important publication.
the case of labour in large-for-gestational-age babies and delivery
methods that might have been less traumatic.

Assimilates the new knowledge and I could consider asking the consultant to attend when a difficult Act as a reflector of new ideas and
change of cognitive structure leads caesarean section is anticipated, but if there is fetal distress then direct the learner's process of
to accommodation (new delay could be risky. accommodation in the appropriate
knowledge) direction.

80 ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists


Roberts and Kumar

Table 2. (Continued)

Role of supervisor, facilitator or


Stages of learning by learner Points for reflection (in first person) mediator

Mentally formulates an action plan or Help to define or provide structure to


a modified way of acting as a result the next learning objective. Consider
of the present encounter, which is to a timeframe for next session of
be implemented in the future reflective practice.

Considers whether a written record of Avoid using a patient's name or initials, date of birth or any
this process is necessary unique conditions or circumstances.

Try not to be judgmental of yourself and others, particularly


when your reactions and feelings are still raw.

Take advice from an experienced senior colleague when writing


reflections about cases that may be contentious or result in an
investigation.

Adapted from Moon (2004).16


BMI = body mass index; CTG = cardiotocography; EFW = estimated fetal weight; GP = general practice; OSATS = objective structured assessment
of technical skills; ST2 = Specialty Trainee (2nd year); ST6 = Specialty Trainee (6th year); WHO = World Health Organization.

Box 2 contains a fictional case involving a clinical episode


Supervision and feedback
of a woman giving birth. Table 2 shows a plan of the process
Sch€on’s description of reflective learning also highlights the of reflective practice and the role of a supervisor or mediator,
role of a mentor.8 Clinical supervision has been described as a based on this example.16
process of facilitating reflection in a structured format.
Freshwater maintains that clinical supervision, when well
Ethical issues and confidentiality
facilitated, can provide cues for reflection, allowing the
individual to identify their own ways of knowing.14 The skills In the wake of the recent case involving Dr Bawa-Garba,
of reflective supervision as described by Rolfe and Freshwater concern has been raised in the medical profession about the
are summarised in Table 1. use of written reflective material as evidence in the court of
While reflective practice is a mandatory component of law. Despite reassurance from the Medical Protection Society
training and continued professional development, there are and the Queen’s Counsel that reflective notes were not part of
recognised difficulties inherent to the reflective process: the evidence presented before the court, the profession
 The obligation to provide a pre-determined ‘quota of remains fearful that this case will impede open and honest
reflection’ may lead to disengagement and resentment. reflection, which in turn will prevent learning from mistakes
 Questions have been raised about the process of assessing and errors. The General Medical Council (GMC) has
and reviewing the reflections of individual clinicians. As acknowledged the strength of feeling surrounding this case
highlighted in a study by Sizer et al.,15 reflection may not in a recent publication.17 Important ethical considerations
be an intuitive process for all doctors but a skill that needs regarding confidentiality include who has access to the written
to be learnt, and while annual review of competence reflection and for what purpose. Many educational
progression panels comment on the poor standard of programmes and professional revalidation schemes insist on
reflective writing when challenged, they find it difficult to individuals keeping a reflective diary and often the entries are
explain why. used for assessment. At the time of writing this article,
 In day-to-day practice, the educational supervisor is tasked reflective notes can be required by a court of law. Therefore,
with several roles and may end up in the position of being any such notes should focus on learning rather than a full
both a mentor facilitating the reflective process and the discussion of the case or situation. Factual details should be
one responsible for assessing the e-portfolio. Conflict may recorded elsewhere. There remains a tension in these
arise when the facilitator is also the assessor. circumstances, as assessment usually requires evidence of
‘deep’ reflection, but when documented, this type of reflection
For group and self-reflection, adequate time and scope
may expose the vulnerability of the individual. Doctors in
should be allowed. Individuals facilitating reflection also need
training should include insights gained and any changes made
suitable training, opportunity and time.

ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists 81


Clinical reflective practice

to practice in their learning portfolio. Supervisors should Acknowledgements


confirm in the learning portfolio that the experience has been Staff of the John Spalding Library at Wrexham Maelor
discussed, agree appropriate learning outcomes and plan Hospital, BCUHB, North Wales, for their whole-hearted
actions. Sharing original, non-anonymised information with support with the literature search and acquiring the
supervisors is important, but factual details should not be necessary references.
recorded in the learning portfolio.
The GMC, however, highlights a clinician’s professional
duty of candour: ‘be open and honest with patients when
References
something goes wrong with their treatment or care that 1 Mamede S, Schmidt HG, Penaforte JC. Effects of reflective practice on the
causes, or has the potential to cause, harm or distress’.18 In accuracy of medical diagnoses. Med Educ 2008;42:468–75.
2 Mann K, Gordon J, MacLeod A. Reflection and reflective practice in health
these situations, nothing should be recorded in the reflective professionals education: a systematic review. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory
notes of which the patient, or those close to the patient, are Pract 2009;14:595–621.
not already aware. As such, if a doctor faces a complaint and 3 General Medical Council. The New Doctor. London: GMC; 2007.
4 Education Endowment Foundation. Metacognition and self-regulation
they chose to share their reflections, being able to provide [https://educationendowmentfoundation.org.uk/evidence-summaries/teac
evidence of their openness and insight will help them hing-learning-toolkit/meta-cognition-and-self-regulation/].
demonstrate that they are fit to practise.3 The Academy of 5 De Cossart L, Fish D, eds. Reflection: an essential means of learning in clinical
settings. In: Cultivating a Thinking Surgeon: New Perspectives on Clinical
Medical Royal Colleges has issued guidelines on how doctors Teaching, Learning and Assessment. Shrewsbury: tfm Publishing Ltd;
should record their written reflections.19 2005:71–92.
6 Dewey J. Experience and Education. New York: Macmillan; 1938.
7 Soltis JF. John Dewey (1859-1952). Experience and Reflective Thinking,
Conclusion Learning, School and Life, Democracy and Education. Education
Encyclopaedia. 2019 [https://education.stateuniversity.com/pages/1914/De
Writing a reflection will be off-putting to some, and may be wey-John-1859-1952.html]
8 Scho€n DA. The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action.
seen as the worst form of naval-gazing. However, reflective United States: Basic Books Inc.; 1983.
practice is crucial for professional development, allowing 9 Gibbs G. Learning by Doing: A Guide to Teaching and Learning Methods.
practitioners to learn from experiences and adverse events. London: FEU; 1988.
10 Kolb DA. Experiential Learning: Experience as the Source of Learning and
Reflection is believed to improve clinical competence and Development. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall, Inc; 1983.
subsequently patient care, with evidence showing that 11 Fish D, De Cossart L. Developing the Wise Doctor: A Resource for Trainers
adopting a reflective practice framework when making a and Trainees in MMC. London: Royal Society of Medicine Press Ltd; 2007.
12 Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. Academy reflective template for
clinical diagnosis in complex or non-routine cases improves revalidation. 2012 [http://www.aomrc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2016/
diagnostic accuracy.1 Furthermore, it is a mandated 06/Reflective_template_for_revalidation_0312-2.pdf].
component of medical training and clinical and professional 13 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists. RCOG personal reflection
template [https://www.rcog.org.uk/globalassets/documents/cpd/rcog_pe
development. Despite recent concerns around the possible rsonal_reflection_template.pdf].
ramifications of reflection, if undertaken with openness and 14 Rolfe G, Freshwater D, eds. Clinical supervision and reflective practice. In:
honesty, it is a process that can only benefit both doctor Critical Reflection in Practice. London: Pallgrave Macmillan; 2011:100–126.
15 Sizer A, Chivers C, Hayes K, Khan R. Reflective writing: training and
and patient. assessment. RCOG World Congress 2016, 20–22 June 2016, Birmingham,
UK. Poster EP12.156.
Disclosure of interests 16 Moon JA, ed. Reflective and experimental learning: taking stock. In: A
Handbook of Reflective and Experiential Learning: Theory and Practice.
BK is an Associate Editor of The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist. Abingdon: Routledge;2004:71–8.
He was excluded from editorial discussions regarding the 17 General Medical Council. Factsheet: Dr Bawa-Garba's case. 2018 [https://
paper and had no involvement in the decision to publish. RR www.gmc-uk.org/-/media/documents/factsheet—dr-bawa-garba-case-fina
l_pdf-74164961.pdf]16.
has no conflicts of interest. 18 General Medical Council. The professional duty of candour [https://www.gmc-
uk.org/ethical-guidance/ethical-guidance-for-doctors/candour—openness-
Contribution to authorship and-honesty-when-things-go-wrong/the-professional-duty-of-candour].
19 Academy of Medical Royal Colleges. Academy and COPMeD Reflective
Both RR and BK searched the existing literature and Practice Toolkit. 2018 [https://www.aomrc.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/
contributed equally to compiling the manuscript. Both 2018/09/Reflective_Practice_Toolkit_AoMRC_CoPMED_0818.pdf].
authors approved the final version.

82 ª 2019 Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists

You might also like