Professional Documents
Culture Documents
12625 2020;22:75–82
The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist
Tips and techniques
http://onlinetog.org
Consultant Obstetrician and Gynaecologist, Wrexham Maelor Hospital, Betsi Cadwaladr University Health Board, Wrexham LL13 7TD, UK
*Correspondence: Bid Kumar. Email: bidyut.kumar@wales.nhs.uk
Please cite this paper as: Roberts R, Kumar B. Clinical reflective practice. The Obstetrician & Gynaecologist 2020;22:75–82. https://doi.org/10.1111/tog.12625
An individual’s approach to reflective practice may be frameworks for reflection based on Dewey’s original
influenced by the nature and scope of individual experience model. One of the most common methods used by
and their personal style of learning. clinicians is that offered by Gibbs.9 Gibbs’ reflective
framework prompts us to consider what happened and
Models of reflection how we felt at the time of the event, what the good and bad
points were in the experience of that incident and what
Reflection is personal, often confidential, and there are additional or alternative actions could have been taken. A
numerous ways to reflect. Two major dimensions to the plan of action is then formulated for similar future
models of reflection are described by Mann:2 encounters (Figure 1).
1. Iterative dimension: here, reflection is triggered by Kolb puts forward an alternative framework,10 in which he
experience, which then produces a new understanding, maintains that learning ‘is the process whereby knowledge is
and the potential or intention to act differently in response created through the transformation of experience’. Kolb’s
to future experiences. cycle of experiential learning (Figure 2) implies that effective
2. Vertical dimension: this includes different levels of learning occurs when a person progresses through a four-
reflection on experience. Generally, the surface levels are stage cycle.10
descriptive and less analytical than the deeper levels of Kolb views learning as an integrated process with each
analysis and critical synthesis. The deeper levels stage being mutually supportive of, and feeding into, the
appear more difficult to reach, hence are less next. It is possible to enter the cycle at any stage and follow it
frequently demonstrated. through its logical sequence. However, effective learning only
While clinical reflective practice might seem an abstract occurs when a learner can execute all four stages of the
concept with an ill-defined process, doubtful endpoints and model. Therefore, no one stage of the cycle is effective as a
uncertain benefits, several authors have described learning procedure on its own.10
Description
(what happened)
Feelings
Action plan (what were you
(if the event arose again, thinking and feeling
what would you do?) at the time
of the event?)
Evaluation
Conclusion
(what was good
(what else could you
and bad about
have done?)
the experience?)
Analysis
(what sense can you
make of the situation?)
Fish and de Cossart’s model describes elements of clinical appreciation of the significance of context;
practice that should be considered by the practitioner during personal qualities;
any episode of clinical reflection.11 These elements include: professional values;
knowledge;
technical processes and procedures undertaken;
clinical thinking that the practitioner engages in;
Concrete experience
(doing or having the ability to formulate sound professional judgement and
an experience) engage in wise practice;
the ability to establish a sound therapeutic relationship
with the patient (holistic medical practice);
the ability to work reflectively in socially and clinically
complex settings and further deepen a holistic vision of
Active experimentation Reflective observation clinical practice.
(planning or trying out (reviewing or reflecting
what you have learnt) on the experience) Numerous templates based on the models of reflection
described have been developed to facilitate the process of
clinical reflection. The template shown in Box 1 provides an
example that may be of use to the reader and has been
adapted from one provided by the Academy of Medical Royal
Abstract
Colleges.12 This template has similarities with the one
conceptualisation
(concluding/learning
available on the Royal College of Obstetricians and
from the experience) Gynaecologists’ website.13
Box 1. Template for written reflection, adapted from the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges12
Skill Description
Listening and responding Be able to use questions within the learner's professional context to stimulate reflection.
Be able to examine one's own prejudices, values, preconceptions and ideas, and assess the impact that these have on the
learner or trainee.
Observe strengths and weaknesses and any recurrent patterns in clinical practice.
Transparency Be able to be open about one's own opinion, reflect openly and justify with reasoning.
Feedback Be able to recognise the learner's fears and anxieties, to provide positive feedback and to encourage the learner's
professional development.
Sensitivity to wider social Be able to recognise the possible influence of the supervisee's social background, belief, faith and values on the
context relationships of the supervisee and their interaction with the supervisor.
Table 2. Stages of clinical reflective practice following encounter with the practical example of the fictional case presented in Box 2
Considers prior knowledge and Am I confident about my knowledge about assessment of CTG Take into account what the learner
personal experience, if any, in a and the actions to be taken as a result? perceives to be his/her internal
similar encounter (internal experience so that the learner's
experience) Am I happy undertaking caesarean sections in women with a objective and learning is appropriate.
high BMI and in the late first-stage of labour? How many times
have I performed this before? Do I have OSATS demonstrating
competence?
Focuses attention on different aspects Was the woman allowed to remain in labour for too long before Simplify or provide a structure to the
of the clinical case and its complexity caesarean section was performed, considering EFW is on the clinical encounter.
(assimilation; this could be during 95th centile?
or after the action)
Was my technique of fetal blood sampling satisfactory? Why
were the cord blood results so different from the scalp blood
results?
I will need to discuss the CTG trace in our CTG meeting. Am I up-
to-date with my mandatory training for CTG?
Draws comparison between ‘internal With a big baby, bulging lower uterine segment, occipito- Highlight variation between perceived
experience’ and the new experience posterior position in a woman with a high BMI, this caesarean ‘internal experience’ and ‘external
(external experience; constructs section was different from any I have performed before. experience’.
frames of reference)
With my supervisor, I need to explore other techniques for
delivering a baby in these circumstances.
Brings to bear the context of the case, I am at ST6 level and should be able to manage such cases on my Act as a resource for clarification of
including the wider context of the own. the context and ensure appropriate
team (temporal relations) interpretation of the context.
Table 2. (Continued)
Considers emotional factors, Decision to perform caesarean section was correct, but should it Signal to the learner the appropriate
professional values and human have been done earlier than this, given the pathological CTG? emotional concepts and recall or
values in managing a patient refresh the values that guide medical
At ST6 level, I should be able to manage such cases on my own. practice.
After another year I will be expected to take up a consultant job.
Will the baby have any long-term effects related to the low-cord
pH and hypoxia?
As a result of the new experience, Am I up-to-date with my mandatory CTG training? Guide the learner to the appropriate
considers exploring and searching for resources – for example, an
existing evidence or literature about I need to explore the literature and review outcomes of induction important publication.
the case of labour in large-for-gestational-age babies and delivery
methods that might have been less traumatic.
Assimilates the new knowledge and I could consider asking the consultant to attend when a difficult Act as a reflector of new ideas and
change of cognitive structure leads caesarean section is anticipated, but if there is fetal distress then direct the learner's process of
to accommodation (new delay could be risky. accommodation in the appropriate
knowledge) direction.
Table 2. (Continued)
Considers whether a written record of Avoid using a patient's name or initials, date of birth or any
this process is necessary unique conditions or circumstances.