Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract
The performance of PCBN (AMBORITE*) and PCD (SYNDITE) has been compared with that of coated tungsten carbide tool
currently being used to machine titanium aerospace alloy. Tests con"rm that SYNDITE gives a better surface "nish, longer tool life
and more manageable swarf than other tools. In addition, the `quick-stopa technique establishes that, for all three cutting tools,
a layer is formed between the rake face and the underside of the emerging chip which has a fundamental e!ect on cutting and wear
mechanisms. 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.
Fig. 4. (a) The quick-stop device utilising a humane killer to disengage the tool from the workpiece rapidly leaving the #ow of metal in the direction of
chip #ow. (b) Section through `quick-stopa specimen showing part of coated carbide tool adhering to underside of chip (100;). (c) Close-up view of
Fig. 4(a) showing strong bonding at the interface showing alpha () grain elongated in the direction of chip #ow (200;).
Fig. 5. (a) Section through `quick-stopa specimen showing part of cubic boron nitride tool adhering to underside of chip (100;). (b) Close-up view of
Fig. 5(a) (200;).
102 F. Nabhani / Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing 17 (2001) 99}106
Fig. 6. (a) Section through `Quick-stopa specimen showing fragment of polycrystalline diamond tool adhering to underside of chip. (b) Close-up view
of Fig. 6(a).
The maximum chip thickness (0.31 mm) is small com- sections through chips. Insofar as the actual mechanism
pared with workpiece materials such as plain carbon chip formation is concerned, cutting speed appears to
steel, re#ecting the large shear plane angle and the small have no signi"cant e!ect. However, it is an important
chip/tool contact length observed [34]. As a result, the factor in determining tool temperature, tool-wear, and
maximum rake face temperature occurs close to the cut- secondary chip generation [38}41].
ting edge.
The general chip form was segmented with narrow
bands of intense shear, separated by relatively unde- 3. Discussion of failure and wear modules
formed regions, in which the phase is elongated in the
direction of the chip travel (see Figs. 4c and 5b). Thus, it A feature of the wear test conditions was the absence of
would appear that the primary shear is not continuous a well-de"ned built-up edge on the tool inserts. Neverthe-
but rather proceeds in discrete `burstsa of catastrophic less, the strongly adherent workpiece maintains an inti-
shear [35]. Freeman [36] working with commercially mate and sustained contact with the rake face through an
pure titanium observed submicron alpha grains in the interfacial layer. The #ow zone where shear takes place to
shear bands, indicating that su$cient heat is generated form the base of a chip, exists at or within this layer.
during the intense primary shear to promote dynamic Ideally, separation of material should occur on the
recrystallisation. During the short periods of intense chip side of this interfacial layer so as to provide protec-
catastrophic shear, the chip is displaced across the sur- tion to the cutting tool. When this layer is detached with
face of the tool by plastic deformation within the #ow (or the chip, as will inevitably happen from time to time, the
secondary shear) zone. For a chip thickness of 0.31 mm at high adhesive forces are likely to result in the plucking
a surface speed of 75 m/min, the e!ective chip velocity is out of hard particles from the tool, causing it's surface to
64 m/min [34], and if it is assumed that the bottom become grooved and crater depth to increase. It is during
surface of the chip is welded to the upper surface of the this part of the process that resistance to plastic deforma-
stationary tool, the average values of strain and strain tion, at elevated temperatures, will be an important in-
rate within the #ow zone are of the order of 27 and trinsic property of the tool material. A similar process of
5.35;10\ s\, respectively. These conditions are quite attrition and grooving wear will be developing on the
su$cient to raise local temperatures above 9003C and #ank face, leading to a deterioration in the machined
give rise to dynamic recrystallisation, as indicated by the surface "nish. Ultimately, the combination of this crater
presence of "ne grains within the #ow zone. and #ank wear will undermine the integrity of the cutting
The sequence of events leading to cyclic chip formation edge (Fig. 7) and, unsupported, it will then break away. In
when machining titanium has been described by Koman- this "nal stage, the fracture toughness of the cutting tool
duri and von Turkovich [37]. Based on their detailed material will be important.
study of video tapes of low-speed machining within an When cutting the titanium alloy, the chemically va-
SEM, high-speed photography of machining under pour deposited coating was rapidly removed from the
workshop conditions and microscopic examination of carbide tools. In most cases, discrete fragments of the
F. Nabhani / Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing 17 (2001) 99}106 103
Fig. 7. (a) Carbide KC850 tool insert showing enlarged view of notch surface. (b) Smoothly worn crater surface evidence of di!usion/dissolution wear.
Fig. 8. (a) View of coated carbide tool with smooth rake face crater wear and remains of adherent metal layer. (b) Close-up views of rake face crater
wear showing smooth ridges with "ne scoring in direction of chip #ow.
coating were removed by a process of adhesive wear carbide substrate on a "ne scale as indicated by the
similar to that reported with tools coated with hafnium parallel scoring in the direction of chip #ow. These "ner
nitride [34]. However, as the cutting continued, a stage of score marks are most likely to have been caused by
rapid but smoothly progressive coating wear was en- plastic deformation as carbide particles are detached and
tered, leading to exposure of the substrate (Fig. 8b). removed from the chip/tool interface [42]. However, it
Examination of the rake face of the tool shows a crater should be noted that an alternative explanation is o!ered
within which are the remains of some of the metallic by Trent [43], who refers to the likelihood of increased
surface layer (Fig. 8a). In other places, where this layer chemical activity leading to etching of the tool material
has been removed, the surface is smoothly grooved as under conditions of high strain such as that occur in the
though by plastic deformation. The pitch of the ridges on #ow zone.
these grooves is approximately 50 m * too large for Turning now to the tests with polycrystalline high
them to have been due to scoring by individual carbide cubic boron nitride (PCBN) content cutting tools,
particles. Within these grooves, a close examination re- Figs. 9a and 9b show the condition of the rake face of an
vealed (Fig. 8b) the occurrence of progressive wear of the AMBORITE insert after cutting the titanium alloy for
104 F. Nabhani / Robotics and Computer Integrated Manufacturing 17 (2001) 99}106
Fig. 9. (a) Worn surface of #ank and rake face of cubic boron nitride tool. (b) Close-up view of rake face crater wear of cubic boron nitride tool
showing smoothly worn surface due to di!usion mechanism.
ultra-hard materials are being increasingly employed. [18] Le Huu T, Schmitt M, Paulmier D, Mamalis AG, Grabchenko A.
Their attractiveness will increase as wider usage brings Tribological properties of smooth diamond coatings for cutting
economies of scale to their manufacture and experience tools. Wear 1999;225}229(Part 2):843}7.
[19] In-Hyu Choi, Jeong-Du Kim. Development of monitoring system
breeds con"dence in their reliability. on the diamond tool wear. Int J Mach Tools Manufacture
1999;39(3):505}15.
[20] Faure C, HaK nni W, Julia Schmutz C, Gervanoni M. Diamond-
Acknowledgements coated tools. Diamond Related Mater 1999;8(2}5):830}3.
[21] Mallika K, Komanduri R. Diamond coatings on cemented tung-
The author is grateful to De Beers Industrial Diamond sten carbide tools by low-pressure microwave CVD. Wear 1999;
224(2):245}66.
Division (Pty) Ltd. for providing cutting tools inserts.
[22] Yu RS. Diamond coated silicon nitride cutting tool inserts. Met
Powder Rep 1997;52(6):39.
[23] Choudhury SK, Appa Rao IVK. Optimization of cutting para-
References meters for maximizing tool life. Int J Mach Tools Manufacture
1999;39(2):343}53.
[1] Vigneau J. Cutting materials for machining superalloys, Interna- [24] Dwan JD. Production of diamond impregnated cutting tools. Met
tional CIRP/VDI Conference on Cutting Materials and Tooling, Powder Rep 1999;54(1):37.
Dusseldorf, 19-20 September 1997. [25] Badzian A, Badzian T, Drawl WD, Roy R. Silicon carbonitride:
[2] Ezugwu EO, Wang ZM. Titanium alloys and their machinability a rival to cubic boron nitride. Diamond Rel Mater 1998;7(10):
* a review. J Mater Process Technol 1997;68(3):262}74. 1519}25.
[3] Gatto A, Iuliano L. Advanced coated ceramic tools for machining [26] Klages CP. Diamond and cubic boron nitride coatings for tools.
superalloys. Int J Mach Tools Manufacture 1997;37(5):591}605. Met Powder Rep 1998;53(2):40.
[4] Maekawa K, Kitagawa T, Kubo A. Temperature and wear of [27] Petrusha IA. Cubic boron nitride for cutting nickel base mater-
cutting tools in high-speed machining of Inconel 718 and Ti-6Al- ials. Met Powder Rep 1998;53(2):41.
6V-2Sn. Wear 1997;202(2):142}8. [28] Leung TP, Lee WB, Lu XM. Diamond turning of silicon sub-
[5] El-Wardany TI, Mohammed E, Elbestawi MA. Cutting temper- strates in ductile-regime. J Mater Process Technol 1998;73(1}3):
ature of ceramic tools in high speed machining of di$cult-to-cut 42}8.
materials. Int J Mach Tools Manufacture 1996;36(5):611}34. [29] Klages C-P, Fryda M, MattheH e T, SchaK fer L, Dimigen H. Dia-
[6] Liao YS, Shiue RH. Carbide tool wear mechanism in turning of mond coatings and cBN coatings for tools. Int J Refractory Met
Inconel 718 superalloy. Wear 1996;193(1):16}24. Hard Mater 1998;16(3):171}6.
[7] Huang CZ, Wang J, Ai X. Development of new ceramic cutting [30] Afaghani JED, Yamaguchi K, Nakamoto T, Yoshino K. Tear-o!
tools with alumina coated carbide powders. Int J Mach Tools wear mechanism of sintered diamond tool in cutting SiC-par-
Manufacture 2000;40(6):823}32. ticle-strengthened epoxy composites. Wear 1997;206(1}2):221}9.
[8] Jawaid A, Olajire Kabiru A. Cuttability investigation of coated [31] Oles EJ, Inspektor A, Bauer CE. The new diamond-coated car-
carbides. Mater Manufact Process 1999;14(4):559}80. bide cutting tools. Diamond Rel Mater 1996;5(6}8):617}24.
[9] Schlund P, Kindermann P, Sockel H-G, Schleinkofer U, Heinrich [32] Cook M. Wear resisting properties applications of polycrystalline
W, GoK rting K. Mechanical behaviour of PVD- and CVD-coated diamond. Met Powder Rep 1997;52(4):46.
hard metals under cyclic loads. Int J Refractory Met Hard Mater [33] Walmsley JC. In: Sarin V (Ed.), Proceedings of the Third Interna-
1999;17(1}3):193}9. tional Conference on Science of Hard Materials, Nassau Mat. Sci.
[10] D'Errico GE, Bugliosi S, Calzavarini R, Cuppini D. Wear of & Engineering, A105/6, 1987, p. 549}54.
advanced ceramics for tool materials. Wear 1999;225}229(Part [34] Greason AN, DEARNLEY. P.A. Mater Sci Technol 1986.
1):267}72. [35] Komanduri R. Wear 1982;76.
[11] Lim SC, Lim CYH, Lee KS. E!ects of machining conditions on [36] Freeman NRM, PhD. thesis, University of Birmingham, UK,
the #ank wear of TiN-coated high speed steel tool inserts. Wear 1986.
1995;181}183(2):901}12. [37] Komanduri R,Von Turkovich BF. Wear 1981;69.
[12] Vleugels J, Van Der Biest O. Chemical wear mechanisms of [38] Jeong-Du Kim, Marinov VR, Dong-Sik Kim, Built-up edge anal-
innovative ceramic cutting tools in the machining of steel. Wear ysis of orthogonal cutting by the visco-plastic "nite-element
1999;225}229(Part 1):285}94, 67. method. J Mater Process Technol 1997;71(3):367}72.
[13] Xing Ai, Jun Zhao, Chuanzhen Huang, Jianhua Zhang. Develop- [39] Arsecularatne JA, Fowle RF, Mathew P. Prediction of chip #ow
ment of an advanced ceramic tool material * functionally gradi- direction, cutting forces and surface roughness in "nish turning.
ent cutting ceramics. Mater Sci Engng A: Struct Mater: Properties J Manufacturing Sci Engng Trans ASME 1998;120(1):1}12.
Microstructure and Process 1998;A248(1}2):125}31. [40] Oishi K. Built-up edge elimination in mirror cutting of hardened
[14] Larrson M. Machining tests on multi-layer coated cemented steel. J Engng Ind Trans ASME 1995;117(1):62}6.
carbide cutting tools. Met Powder Rep 1997;52(12):45. [41] Wang JY, Liu CR. New concept for decoupling the cutting forces
[15] Chou YK, Evans CJ. Tool wear mechanism in continuous cutting due to tool #ank wear and chip formation in hard turning. Mach
of hardened tool steels. Wear 1997;212(1):59}65. Sci Technol 1998;2(1):77}90.
[16] Huang, Chuanzhen, Ai, Xing, Li, Zhaoqian. Cutting performance [42] Milovic R, Smart EF, Wise MLH. Mater Sci Technol 1986:2.
of advanced ceramic tools. Amer Ceramic Soc Bull 1997;76(7): [43] Trent EM. Metal Cutting, 2nd Ed. London: Butterworths, 1984.
83}5. [44] McQuillan MK. Titanium. London: Butterworth Scienti"c Publi-
[17] Ahmed W, Rego CA, Cherry R, Afzal A, Ali N, Hassan IU. CVD cations, 1956.
diamond: controlling structure and morphology. Vacuum 2000; [45] Dearnley PA. Wear 1985;101:1.
56(3):153}8. [46] Dearnley PA. Surf Engng, 1985;1:1.