Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Key insights
The most widely investigated mechanisms of the fetal pro- Maternal Fetal Postnatal
factors, growth growth, Risk
gramming of obesity-adiposity and non-communicable dis- Genome Phenotype
environ- and environ- factors,
Epigenome at birth
mental devel- mental NCDs
eases (NCDs) are maternal-fetal nutrition and metabolism. The factors opment factors
maternal nutritional status, deranged metabolism, infections,
maternal stress and environmental factors have a major in-
fluence on fetal growth and programming. In this respect, the The DOHaD theory proposes that the risk of obesity-adiposity-related
periconceptional, intrauterine and postnatal periods are the NCDs is profoundly influenced by intrauterine and postnatal environ-
most influential in programming the health status of the fol- mental modifications of the epigenome. These occur during key peri-
ods of development, resulting in permanent changes in the structure
lowing generation. and function of the organism (phenotype).
Current knowledge
The regulation of gene expression and function depends not
only on the inherited DNA sequence, but also on the differen-
tial regulation of genes by environmental factors at different overnutrition contribute to NCDs, and in developing countries
times in the life course of an individual. The main mechanisms that are undergoing rapid socioeconomic and nutritional tran-
involved in this process are DNA methylation, which has a ‘si- sition, the two cycles may operate sequentially within one life
lencing’ effect on gene transcription, chemical modifications time, producing even more detrimental effects. Given the dif-
of histones, which alter chromatin structure and transcription, ficulty in implementing long-term lifestyle modifications in
and miRNAs, which interfere with mRNA translation. The risk adults, an attractive alternative is to influence the lifestyle of
of obesity-adiposity-related NCDs is profoundly influenced by young girls and pregnant women in the relatively short window
intrauterine and postnatal environmental modifications of the of the periconceptional and gestational periods.
epigenome.
Recommended reading
Practical implications Krishnaveni GV, Veena SR, Hill JC, Kehoe S, Karat SC, Fall CH:
The identification of these regulatory mechanisms reveals Intrauterine exposure to maternal diabetes is associated with
modifiable components in the intergenerational transmission higher adiposity and insulin resistance and clustering of car-
of health and disease. This offers potential means for curtail- diovascular risk markers in Indian children. Diabetes Care
ing the epidemic of NCDs worldwide. Both undernutrition and 2010;33:402–404.
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
E-Mail karger@karger.com
www.karger.com/anm
Ann Nutr Metab 2014;64(suppl 1):8–17 Published online: July 23, 2014
DOI: 10.1159/000362608
Transmission of Obesity-Adiposity
and Related Disorders from the Mother
to the Baby
Chittaranjan S. Yajnik
Diabetes Unit, King Edward Memorial Hospital and Research Center, Pune, India
Key Messages (NCDs). The original idea was based on fetal undernutrition
because lower birth weight was associated with a higher risk
• A conventional approach to non-communicable
of diabetes and heart disease. However, soon it was clear that
disease prevention targets unhealthy adult lifestyle.
the association was U shaped, and that the increased risk in
• Epigenetic fetal programming is a novel idea.
large babies was driven by maternal obesity and diabetes. A
• Human and animal studies support an ‘intrauterine
number of human and animal studies have refined our ideas
programming’ of obesity, diabetes and other
of ‘fetal programming’, which is now thought to be related
non-communicable diseases.
to acquired chemical changes in DNA (methylation), his-
• Maternal nutritional imbalance, a deranged
tones (acetylation and other) and the role of non-coding
metabolism, stress and other factors contribute to
miRNAs. Maternal nutritional disturbances are the major
fetal programming.
programming stimulus, in addition to a deranged metabo-
• Improving the health of young mothers will
lism, infections, maternal stress, extreme atmospheric tem-
contribute to a ‘primordial’ prevention of
perature, etc. The first demonstration of a link between fetal
non-communicable diseases in future generations.
‘starvation’ and future ill-health was in the Dutch Hunger
Winter studies. In the prospective Pune Maternal Nutrition
Study, we found that small and thin Indian babies were more
Key Words adipose compared to larger English babies, and their higher
Obesity · Adiposity · Diabetes · Fetal programming · risk of future diabetes was reflected in higher insulin and
Intergenerational transmission · Primordial prevention · leptin and lower adiponectin concentrations in the cord
Mother and baby blood. This phenotype was partly related to a deranged
1-carbon metabolism due to an imbalance in vitamin B12
(low) and folate (high) nutrition, which was also related to
Abstract insulin resistance in the offspring. Maternal obesity and dia-
The conventional aetiological model of obesity and diabetes betes have made an increasing contribution to childhood
proposes a genetic predisposition and a precipitation by an obesity and diabetes at a young age. This was prominently
unhealthy adult lifestyle. This hypothesis was challenged shown in Pima Indians but is now obvious in all other popu-
by David Barker who proposed that the intrauterine envi- lations. The best window of opportunity to prevent fetal pro-
ronment influences the risk of non-communicable diseases gramming of NCDs is in the periconceptional period. This is
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
E-Mail karger@karger.com
Rasta Peth, Pune, Maharashtra 411011 (India)
www.karger.com/anm
E-Mail csyajnik @ hotmail.com
the period when gametogenesis, fertilisation, implantation, discuss the scientific basis, observational and interven-
embryogenesis and placentation occur. Improving the nutri- tional evidence as well as future directions in this new
tion and the health of young girls could make a substantial paradigm called ‘developmental origins of health and dis-
contribution to reducing the rapidly rising epidemic of NCDs ease’ (DOHaD) in relation to obesity and related NCDs.
in the world. This is referred to as ‘primordial’ prevention. This article is not proposed to be a comprehensive review
© 2014 S. Karger AG, Basel but an attempt to discuss some basic concepts.
Fig. 1. DOHaD describes the life-time evolution of health and disease susceptibility in an individual. On the back-
ground of the inherited ‘fixed’ DNA sequence, chemical modifications in the genome regulate gene expression
and therefore the phenotype of the individual. The most critical windows are in early life but continue to operate
throughout the life (life-course model), manifesting in health and disease susceptibility.
–10 0
as gametogenesis, fertilisation, implantation, morpho- of maternal nutrition. These studies showed that low
genesis, embryogenesis, organogenesis and placentation, birth weight was a predictor of future diabetes, hyperten-
all of which have a profound influence on the growth, sion, coronary heart disease and other NCDs [10]. The
development, differentiation and phenotype of an indi- majority of these are associated with obesity (excess
vidual [9] (fig. 2). If the environment is not ideal (for ex- weight for a given height). It is to be appreciated that the
ample, maternal nutritional imbalance, altered metabo- BMI, the most frequently measured index of obesity, is
lism, infections, exposure to environmental pollutants, not a measure of body fat but only a surrogate. A higher
etc.), this might lead to undesirable programming and in- percent of body fat is more appropriately called ‘adipos-
duce the risk for later disease. ity’ and necessitates direct measurements of body fat
Barker’s [2, 10] ideas about intrauterine program- (skinfolds, bioimpedance, isotopic dilution, DXA, CT
ming and DOHaD were based on retrospective cohorts scan, MRI, etc.). It is important to distinguish between
in the UK, Finland and other countries. The most fre- these measurements because the interpretation could be
quently available measure of intrauterine nutrition and misleading, especially when comparing two different
growth was birth weight with very direct measurements populations [11].
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
type 2 diabetes
Odds ratio of
Fig. 3. The association between birth
weight and risk of diabetes is U shaped,
though in individual studies an inverse or
direct association may be seen due to pre-
Mean birth weight (kg)
ponderance of maternal under- or overnu-
trition and diabetes [15, 16].
Risk of SGA
2,631 3
2,584 High Hcy 33%
2,600
High MMA 90%
2
2,500 1.6
1.2 1.1 1.3
2,400 1
Never <Once/ Once/ Every
week week other day 8 9 10 11 12 13 14
a GLV intake b tHcy (μmol/l)
HOMA-IR
0.6 0.56
3.2 0.47 0.52
3.1 0.4
3.0
0.2
2.9
2.8 0
<734 <961 <1,269 1,269 Low B12 Med B12 High B12
c Red cell folate (nmol/l) d Low folate Med folate High folate
Fig. 5. Nutrient-mediated teratogenesis in the PMNS. Maternal folate was also associated with adiposity in the child (c) and high-
micronutrient nutrition as reflected in the intake of green leafy er insulin resistance at 6 years of age (d). B12 deficiency exagger-
vegetables (GLV) (a) and the circulating homocysteine concentra- ated the childhood insulin resistance (d) [24, 26]. Values are geo-
tion (b) influenced fetal growth. Mothers were folate replete but metric means. p values by trend. MMA = Methylmalonic acid;
B12 deficient and had a high homocysteine concentration. High tHcy = total homocysteine; Med = medium. Modified from [26].
ences cellular growth by helping synthesis of nucleic acids stimulates fetal islets and causes hyperinsulinaemia. In-
and providing the essential amino acid methionine. In sulin is a major growth hormone in utero and promotes
addition, methylation of DNA is one of the major mech- the growth of insulin-sensitive tissues and organs, leading
anisms of epigenetic regulation, thus influencing the ge- to fetal adiposity and macrosomia at birth. Freinkel [4]
netic regulation of growth and differentiation. The role of expanded this idea to suggest that the increased risk of
1-carbon metabolism and these vitamins in fetal growth postnatal obesity and diabetes was a ‘fuel-mediated tera-
and programming has been recently reviewed [30–32]. togenesis’ by comparing these common long-term out-
comes with rare disfiguring birth defects (for example,
neural tube defects). He proposed that this was mediated
Maternal Metabolism by a ‘stable change in gene expression’, which we now call
In addition to nutrition, maternal metabolism exerts a epigenetic programming, and not on the inherited genet-
major influence on fetal growth and programming. Sub- ic trait (fig. 6).
stantial evidence has now accumulated that maternal dia- The Pima Indian studies [34–37] critically investigated
betes and obesity (causing fetal overnutrition) influence the genetic-versus-intrauterine environmental aetiology
future obesity and diabetes in the child. The common of obesity and diabetes in the offspring of diabetic moth-
perception is that this mechanism must be genetic, but a ers. The Pima study has an unparalleled design where ev-
series of studies have shown a prominent role for non- ery member of the community more than 5 years of age,
genetic mechanisms. including all pregnant women, if not already diabetic, was
The central observation in this field was made by Pe- serially investigated with an oral glucose tolerance test
dersen [33], who suggested that an excess transfer of glu- every 2 years. This allowed a more confident classification
cose and other fuels to the baby in a diabetic pregnancy of the in utero exposure of the fetus to maternal diabetes.
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
P
l Macrosomia
Insulin Hypoglycaemia
a
c Obesity
e
n
t
a
Fig. 6. ‘Fuel-mediated teratogenesis’ refers Plasma Insulin IGT
to an excess transfer of fuels (glucose, ami-
no acids and fatty acids) across the placen-
ta to the developing fetus which causes ‘sta-
ble change in gene expression’ affecting not Glucose
Amino acids DM
only perinatal but also long-term outcomes ‘Mixed
in the offspring (obesity and diabetes) [4, Lipids
nutrients’
31]. IGT = Impaired glucose tolerance;
DM = diabetes mellitus. Modified from [4].
50
40
pendent of macrosomia at birth and manifest as early as
30 5 years of age. To investigate the possibility that the moth-
20 ers who were diagnosed as having diabetes at a younger
10 age will transmit a stronger genetic predisposition, a sub-
0 sequent study [36] investigated the risk of obesity and di-
5–9 10–14 15–19 abetes in the siblings (expected to inherit similar amounts
Age of siblings (years) of diabetes and obesity genes) who were discordant both
for the exposure to intrauterine hyperglycaemia (born be-
fore or after the development of maternal diabetes) and
Fig. 7. Intrauterine programming of obesity by maternal hypergly-
caemia in Pima Indians. Children born to diabetic mothers had a outcome (obese or non-obese, normal glucose tolerant or
much higher prevalence of obesity compared to children born to hyperglycaemic). This study showed that the risk of obe-
prediabetic and non-diabetic mothers [35]. Reproduced with per- sity and diabetes was higher in the siblings who were born
mission from [34]. after the diagnosis of maternal diabetes.
In all these studies, there was no corresponding asso-
ciation with paternal obesity and diabetes, which sup-
ports a stronger role for the intrauterine diabetic environ-
The first investigation showed that the children ex- ment compared to genetic predisposition in the aetiology
posed to maternal diabetes in pregnancy were more like- of obesity and diabetes in the children of diabetic moth-
ly to be obese (and glucose intolerant) compared to the ers. It is estimated that up to 70% of diabetes in Pima In-
children born to prediabetic (non-diabetic during preg- dian children is due to maternal diabetes [37]. It is of note
nancy, diagnosed diabetic later and, therefore, genetically that most of the diabetic Pima Indian women had preges-
predisposed) and non-diabetic mothers (non-diabetic at tational rather than gestational diabetes, and, therefore,
serial tests and, therefore, genetically not predisposed) the children were exposed to an abnormal metabolic mi-
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
Genome Epigenome
Disorder
Fig. 8. The life-course evolution of a phe-
notype depends partly on the inherited ge-
netic characteristics but is substantially
modified by the environment which alters
the fetal epigenome and continues to act in
the postnatal life producing various inter-
mediated phenotypes. The final phenotype
(disorder) is usually seen much later in life.
lieu periconceptionally rather than only late in the preg- tors (family history, obesity, previous abnormalities of
nancy. In this context, it may also be important to note glucose tolerance, low birth weight, short height, etc.)
that the subsequent risk of obesity and diabetes was inde- which may confound the association of later glucose in-
pendent of birth size which is largely ‘fueled’ in the last tolerance and mislead about its importance for fetal pro-
trimester. The follow-up of children born to mothers with gramming [41]. As of today, there is little information
gestational diabetes in the Parthenon study in Mysore, about the long-term benefits to the offspring of treating
India, has shown an increased risk of obesity and predia- maternal diabetes (either pregestational or gestational).
betes below 10 years of age especially in girls [38]. A Dan-
ish study which followed children of type 1 and type 2
diabetic mothers as well as children born to mothers with Other Intrauterine Exposures
gestational diabetes showed that all these children had a In addition to maternal nutrition and metabolism, a
higher risk of diabetes in later life [39]. Many of the dia- number of other factors have been implicated in the reg-
betic mothers in the Chicago Diabetes Pregnancy studies ulation of fetal growth and for programming of NCDs in
were also pregestationally diabetic [40]. the offspring. These include maternal smoking, exposure
to extreme (high) atmospheric temperature, pollutants
and toxins (especially the ‘endocrine disruptors’). Anoth-
Findings suggest that even subtle er major programming exposure may be maternal stress.
alterations in the maternal All these findings suggest that even subtle alterations in
intrauterine environment can have the maternal intrauterine environment can have pro-
found effects on the development of the fetal systems and
profound effects on the development that these effects last for the rest of the child’s life.
of the fetal systems and that these The importance of the time of exposure during preg-
effects last for the rest of the child’s life. nancy (window) can be easily understood by the sequence
of fetal development and has been described for the peri-
conceptional period earlier in the article.
The relative importance of periconceptional versus
late-pregnancy exposure to diabetes needs to be further
investigated. This has a major effect on the current prac- Synthesis
tice of diagnosis and management of gestational diabetes It is now well established that, in addition to the con-
in the third trimester. The majority of women with gesta- ventional genetic inheritance (the so-called fixed inheri-
tional diabetes have an excess of preconceptional risk fac- tance), there are additional ‘malleable’ epigenetic influ-
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM
ences (the so-called soft inheritance) which shape the fu- the last 25 years in this field both in animal and human
ture of the growing fetus. These mechanisms translate the models. The science of DOHaD is now well established,
environmental messages to the structure and the function and preventive trials are in progress. Considering the dif-
of the developing fetus and leave a permanent mark. They ficulty of implementing long-term lifestyle modifications
are described under the general term of ‘epigenetic’ and in adults to control the risk of NCDs, the model of primor-
represent gene-environment interactions. These new dial prevention by influencing the lifestyle of young girls
exciting findings describe a modifiable component of and pregnant women in the relatively short period of peri-
the intergenerational transmission of health and disease conceptional and gestational windows offers a more at-
traits and offer hope of curtailing the rapidly expanding tractive alternative. The success of such interventions will
epidemic of NCDs across the world populations. Specific be an appropriate tribute to the brilliant research of pio-
evidence is available for susceptibility to obesity-adiposi- neers in this field over the last many decades.
ty, diabetes, cardiovascular disease, neuropsychiatric dis-
orders and cancers. The life-course evolution of these dis-
orders includes a series of changes in the epigenome which Acknowledgement
start from the periconceptional period and continue to To all collaborators, funding agencies and participants.
occur in the later life, producing an evolving phenotype
which finally ends in a clinically recognisable disorder
(fig. 8). Both undernutrition and overnutrition contribute Disclosure Statement
The author declares no conflicts of interest in relation to this
to these processes. In the developing countries undergo- article. The writing of this article was supported by Nestlé Nutri-
ing rapid socioeconomic and nutritional transition, the tion Institute.
two cycles could operate one after the other in one life
time, producing an even more detrimental effect on the
phenotype (dual teratogenesis) (fig. 9). This may contrib-
ute to the high prevalence of these conditions. Preventive References 1 Hu FB: Globalization of diabetes – the role of
measures will depend on identifying specific exposures, diet, lifestyle, and genes. Diabetes Care 2011;
34:1249–1257.
demonstrating an effect of acting on them. Given the dif- 2 Barker DJ: In utero programming of chronic
ficulties in identifying specific exposures among the mul- disease. Clin Sci (Lond) 1998;95:115–128.
titude as well as the long latency between exposure and 3 Ravelli GP, Stein ZA, Susser MW: Obesity in
young men after famine exposure in utero
disease manifestation, this is not an easy task. Despite and early infancy. N Engl J Med 1976; 295:
these limitations, substantial progress has been made in 349–353.
138.5.159.110 - 4/13/2015 4:29:22 AM