You are on page 1of 23

 Ky4 P] 1(7(‫­@א‬W2‫Œא‬a ،$(7 ‫`א‬+‫@א‬

#5C5y‫א‬5P5!*?_\5 @‫©?? ?א‬#5(+,5+aAPd3 ‫א א‬0F/


AP5B ‫א‬5$"##!zƒP"K( .Réduction_\5 @/‫א  א‬F($™ ‫א‬0$ ‫א‬
555™2555 K6555!_5557‡a#555 ‫_א‬5557j‫א‬555 =‫ א‬E‫~=א‬555FK555( ‫א‬
55(+)-‫ א‬55G-‫ א‬55(B ‫( א‬N<55+-‫ א‬55("7j‫א‬355‫א‬55($"،55s12
(2Q5-‫"(א‬$ ‫א‬Fr ‫ א‬KA ‫(א‬R$%2 f ‫(א‬$%2 ،!,;‫א‬
#5z5%#5 ‫א‬5(!$ ‫א‬0Q5-‫ ”א‬35A5($"5(+LQ+2(Nx#($%
`55"c55 KC55WE‫א‬h55P55.55$ ‫א‬z552=55*¨ t55 K55!$ *(55GE‫א‬55
 K1!9‫א‬L¤ ] ‫א‬L¤
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 WAW$;‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬$! ‫א (א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫_א‬7
 7  ’2 Y“-‫ א‬D

2008
36  ‫  א אא   א‬
 ،(<%"HF ‫א‬h(P‫"א‬aKL
 ،f&2،(V‫א‬H/2$2.
 K_^;‫א‬
 W€]2
o*32 0( ‫ א‬$% ‫& ( א ( א‬G-‫© א‬Da Axa@ ‫ˆ א‬tP 0 %
Q /‫ א‬,26P ،AW$;‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬$! ‫א‬#D 7;‫א א‬
 KQ /‫ˆא‬tP`"MF ‫(א‬8(* ،(Pt;‫א‬
 ‫( א‬7$;‫ א‬32 ! # z ‫ א  א‬،( &G-‫ˆ א‬tP 9$;
W 'xQxY
$"– ،( D%‫ א‬2P!*MF ‫א‬0182‫ א‬C E‫©א‬4% J
Q2‫ א‬M," !^ ‫  א‬b ‫ א‬8 & 0182 +E  $.‫א‬2 ‡a  J ( ‫א‬
‫א‬tPÇ!*KMP‫א‬t;‫("`א‬F(Fy‫א‬Q /‫א‬P.?$%D‫א‬4 ‫א‬0
$! s!  2 .D MF ‫  א‬,2 32 $— ‫ א‬J,;‫א¡ \ א‬
 K(2Q-‫א‬
MF ‫ א‬A2 1 FFD ‫א א‬Y“-‫› א‬$  $ 6+r ‫ א‬h,F ‫ א‬2  J
 @‫א א‬3X@ ‫­Œא א‬4& ،=@?4+32r*t2MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬
A(," k7 (2Q-‫ א‬$! ‫ Œ ¨ =  א@ א‬، . ‫א א‬tP b*$ Ht ‫א‬
(2Q-‫› א א= א‬$"  (Pt;‫@( א‬E‫› א‬$ (!1%  KPt;‫ א‬M4$ ‫א‬
3!&%،3 ‫אא‬tP‫ א‬3!&% ‫א‬F(!$ ‫_א‬E‫(=א‬2،=‫א‬a c‫א‬$ *
:%(.E‫א‬Q ‫ א=א‬،(1F8 ‫א‬g 8 ‫א‬b( CWE‫א‬Q /‫א‬
K(Pt;‫אא‬4 ‫@א‬
A[,27 ?’2?&G#DnF;‫›א‬$"z r ‫א‬h,F ‫א‬0@   J
K(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫א‬g <2

Résumé :
Le discours du rapprochement entre les doctrines religieuses dans les
sociétés musulmanes contemporaines
2008
37  ‫  א אא   א‬
Cet article soulève la question de divergences doctrinales religieuses
qui représente une problématique sérieuse et un défi énorme pour les
sociétés musulmanes contemporaines.
Pour analyser cette problématique, la recherche s’était basée sur un
ensemble de données qu’on a traité en trois axes :
-Tout en défendant l’idée du besoin du monde musulman à un tel
rapprochement entre ses doctrines religieuses, le premier axe critique le
concept du rapprochement qui paraît assez confus et dissimule les vraies
divergences doctrinales, d’où la nécessité d’une révision du concept actuel.
-Le deuxième axe rappelle les efforts des partisans du rapprochement
et leurs réalisations depuis un demi siècle, mais il met en même temps
l’accent sur le fait du fanatisme doctrinal qui demeure encore vivant et ne
cesse de se répandre dans quelques sociétés musulmans comme celles de
l’Irak et l’Iran, ainsi que la marginalisation des minorités doctrinales à
travers des exemples et des états vécus.
- Le troisième axe est consacré à des suggestions que nous avons
présentées sous forme de « principes » et que nous pensons qu’elles
peuvent faire avancer la marche du rapprochement entre les doctrines
musulmanes.
 W2F2
\3!™2P+ S(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫_א‬7­W
321F2 ،1979(+‫א‬-‫א‬Ar ‫א‬4 +‫א‬$"W،( ‫"א‬7j‫א‬
 t"1d32M%%2 ،2003‫"^א‬iFhx ،Qr ‫(˜א‬j‫ _א‬D
`" $ ‫  א‬KPt;‫ א‬$ ‫  א‬,2 $¾ Ht ‫ א‬2E‫ א‬،(Pt2 (8NL ‫א‬W
0: ,%O6P ، ‫ א‬OE‫א‬32$ ‫[א‬r(Pt;‫א‬+&;‫ ?א‬¤
3&, ‫  א‬،1%xa  j‫ א‬0  n, ‫ א‬C" ،SW F(! ".a
 K(@E‫א‬MPt2#7,% HDE‫&א‬8 ‫”א‬, *‫א‬
\% M7  ¨NG g™2 3 (G ".a hF% @ ‫ˆ א‬tP 0 % /
`! ;‫ א‬32 /‚P [J  6. " n+E‫  א‬¥‚;‫  א‬6. (, ‫  א‬3 ‫ Ž א‬1.
Xd ‫\ א‬F ‫ א‬32  Axa ‡a #$,  1+ /a ،($;‫ א‬CFy‫;] ? א‬
 2 ،6™;‫= א‬F ‫  א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫ א‬A& " = t2 1+&2 ” ‫א‬%
 Kg™;‫אא‬xa32:;‫‡א‬a4%DnF2hF%
 WMP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF  .y‫ א‬h(P8;‫א‬W/ 
2008
38  ‫  א אא   א‬
 Wh(P8;‫א‬  J1
=F ‫(( א‬$" t2  !$ ‫ " א‬،zD [$% MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫א‬
 ‫@؟‬E‫א‬#B+ J(WX†!,D2182P!،6™;‫א‬
+"@6< ‫ א‬Wh\ " _@F_$ ‫=א‬,  ،H^ ‫א‬fE‫(א‬D+32
›(F+ _F ‫  א‬،% ™ W _F%  ،^ ;‫ א‬Z%  4 @‫ א‬W _@  ،2 + W
 KE_@A2W2004،0KB23"‫א‬F$ ‫א‬
CWE‫ א‬CD 2E‫( א‬D% ،MF ‫ א‬32 4F; ،018;‫  א‬/  2
P ، ‫א‬, ‫א‬h( $% h& ‫~=א‬F ‫א‬32A! ,;‫א א]א‬X"‫א‬r ‫א &( א‬
X4+ ‫( א‬2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF   6;$ ‫ * ( "( א! א‬2
1+" Œ MP‫א‬t;‫*א‬14+‫•א‬$/(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫=א‬#
h1("!(R$ ‫ א‬hP8 ‫ ”א‬Ga `!,;‫! א‬9A7P"،D‫ א‬MPt2
 KE2004،&,(-‫א‬Fh1NF ‫א‬
N,;‫<](€ א‬%  !$ ‫ א‬W MF " 4F (!$ ‫( א‬s1;‫( א‬D ‫ א‬32
1(RQ/ ‫\א‬F ‫ €א‬،MP‫א‬t;‫א‬N`"&8 ‫א;<*א‬
 E‫א‬#‫ א !א‬،!$ *n<2(™¾-6$, ‫ א‬،F8 ‫ א‬A(F$ ‫א‬C
t ،­(4 ‫א‬62Q-‫א < א‬4232| ,;‫(­א‬4 ‫=א‬Po ‫( א‬$7F ‫א‬
(8N7 ‫ א‬4@a  ،M4$ ‫ א‬3 s ‫  א‬،(2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬g% `" @8 ‫א‬
$29‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬AE‫א‬0182F% ،MP‫א‬t;‫¨א‬%`"MF ‫א‬R1" F(\ ‫א‬
 KE161 J160W2005،gKH¾ ‫א‬F@8 ‫א‬gY‫א‬+1"Xr=$"
:†32cQ7+/‫א‬PMF ‫=א‬A!!'&8;‫©א‬c(, ‫אא‬tP
MPt; M4$ " ©E‫ א‬MP‫א‬t!  MPt2 68+ 0  ،8 ];‫  א‬A$ ;‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
¨ Œ  ˆ,  K E 286 J285  W 5P 1423 ، 0KA!F ˆ‫א‬2 ›  ،D‫א‬
2 CF 2*W , = ?ˆ$2MF ‫=א‬o $Ht ‫א‬6L ‫א <(א‬
 KE @2W2003،6L ‫א‬F?v‫א‬

2008
39  ‫  א אא   א‬
8 , ‫א‬8$ ‫א‬//((‹2™#h(P8;‫ˆא‬tPA‫@א‬3&)
*n<;‫א‬3z،6F‫א‬% JQ N‫ א‬JH(D%_7MF ‫=א‬،*t ‫א‬
`"+Y‫ א‬2@Q1(h(F( 62Q-‫א < א‬42327 ,;‫&א‬8 ‫א‬
 KMP‫א‬t;‫ ?א‬¤
،WE‫ א‬F7 ‫ א‬F $;‫א‬#$u6%،H^ ‫א‬k7;‫א‬k 1WMPt;‫א‬2
‡a  ,;‫  א‬Pt2  "PŒ  "PŒ MPŒ W  Š8  32 k <2 ? MPt2? ­742
A2،0KB23"‫א‬F$%‫א‬#$uMPt;"MPt† ،H ‫Œ ¨א‬1(©H،‫א‬t*
 KEMPŒ
‡a  ,;‫ א‬H&8 ‫! א‬$ ‫ א‬+" MPt;‫ א‬R$ ،6DQ7W/‫ א‬#$;‫ א‬
(;‫  א‬E‫ א‬32 P[J  ،f(F ‫  א‬g-‫  א‬, ‫ א & _  א‬32 6< ‫א  ( א‬
\@  ‫א‬$ ‫ א‬N,2 32   !( !$ ‫  א‬1F8 ‫ א‬P@ CW  ‫ @א‬#
" !$  (W   2 k(F ‫  א‬f ‫ א‬$" 12 ‫א‬4] ‫  א‬،Q2$;‫א‬
 KEfK0،&,(-‫א‬Fh1%‫א‬1 ."  @‫א‬3; ،h1,8+E
 WMF  .y‫ א‬J2
2,F+/‫א א‬% "+<;‫ א‬،n;‫א‬62Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫א‬g™ =¨G/
 ("+&2`"_»Fg <2‡a=&2šD$—،&8 ‫(( א‬, ‫א‬
‫א‬: ‫&<? = א‬% F   ،‫א‬4 " ¨1;‫ א‬6(, ‫! א‬,.  ،Ar$;‫א‬
%‫א‬:+ 32 r* %‫ @א‬R: ,% 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ א א(  א‬Qj‫א‬
،(s(%‫א‬n-‫א אא‬:*234 ‫א‬F ‫"=א‬F J/   K(.j‫א‬
À"(™;‫א‬,!j‫א‬F$ ‫א‬CQ6(N‫א‬-‫ א‬$ ‫ א‬2g‫א‬4 ‫=א \א‬
=(22,5‡aW (‫א א‬%‫א‬W# F ‫`=א‬D،(1G?  N2
 KE @2،2007،0KG"F( @
!(l‫  א‬r! ;‫ א‬D E‫ א‬M7F ‫ א‬A(  ، R9‫; א‬$ ‫( א‬% = !*
#2 ، (, ‫‹ א‬/‫( א‬1+‫ א‬$" . h4]* 0Q-‫  א ( א‬،(&2E‫א‬
(D "Dœa ،M,&,X,( _D A ™ M7F ‫אא‬tP#

2008
40  ‫  א אא   א‬
،– KX!P 3"F (Pt;‫ א‬Qj‫ א‬t+ h S 2 P  ،NF  (!(@  $2
 KE212 J211W2005
# C$% 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ א‬2 "D  _^ ‫( א‬s(%‫א‬n‫ = א‬#8w /
2 P  ‫ א א ؛‬32 @‫א‬n‫  א‬$™- ‡  D!* (Pt;‫ א‬%Q ˜(.%
#62Q-‫א‬7j‫‚†? א‬2PF  ‫? א &! א‬b +"?"Rn‫א‬
z(D،200624‡a21`"2(:%PF$;‫?א‬A ;‫א‬/ ‫( א‬N‫א‬a
6», ‫"`א (א‬g‫א‬4 ‫ @ א‬#h –0Q-‫ א‬Jv‫ א‬2g‫א‬4 ‫‡=א‬aG
# ("^ ‫ א‬N‫ א  א‬$% ©2  F;‫ˆ א‬tP *‚%  K 6$(< ‫  א ( א‬6"P ‫א‬
‫א‬W_^ ‫(א‬s(%‫א‬n‫א‬32 D!*،‫א א‬3262Q-‫א‬KPt;‫[א‬s8 ‫א‬
 KE @2W2007،fK€@2FK62Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫ א‬2
(; A& ^ a ‡a H‚% @ (Pt;‫ א‬87W/‫‡ Œ ¨ = א‬a R\
1+E،(Pt;‫א‬P 2A12XW ‫א &(א‬hP326P ،0Q-‫א‬
 KA[*."`!,;‫א‬0,F+"6D%
P‫א‬ ‫ ( א‬y‫ א‬1 ^(4"  J ‫\א‬y‫א א‬D  F2  = ™n‫Œא א‬a
‫אא‬D ¨ Œ @ M7  [E‫א א‬tP 2 ‫א‬y‫ ¬= א‬،(W  (™  J _^ ‫א‬
*$;‫  א‬A@ ?@2  62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ &= א‬# D ،(2Qa  J(2Qa
‫א‬y‫א‬LMF ‫אא‬tP=&=6^،© ,;‫אא‬tlF%/‫  (א‬K‫א‬y‫א‬
 KMF   .D6*:2P ،s 2 /$
F ‫ \ א‬n( ،MF   .y‫ א‬o Ht ‫ א‬H4 @/‫ א‬È,;‫ א‬2
 $ ‫ א‬2 ‫א‬W  »!‹ 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫‡ =  א‬a G Ht ‫* א‬t ‫ ? א‬, ‫א‬
‫א‬4 ‫ˆ א‬N,X^"!("،/ =(" 300(™;‫א‬, ‫א‬CQ6+(14 ‫א‬
•$ / MF ‫ ¨ ¬= א‬t ،E 2007 ،0 KG"F /  =% 1,2 PD  (‫א א‬
 K(2Q-‫א‬2q 4 @/‫א‬,‚;‫"א‬Aa"،(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬MF%|F
 WBDQ2 J3

2008
41  ‫  א אא   א‬
MF ‫ א‬g <2 ‡a 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ א‬.D *‚% F", ‫א א‬G‚;‫* א‬
‫א‬tP   ‫ ؛‬MF   ‡ E‫א א‬7j‫  א‬,& 2 P  ،(2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"` א‬
1. 32 (F ‫ א‬,‚;‫› א‬$"  t" 2 & = @$  3&) / ،4 ‫א‬
4 ‫א א‬tP  *t+  ،1 (  ' hJ (L ˜N + 3 8 A!'
،1947  APF " X, ‫( ? א‬2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫œŒš ? א א‬
#X" ،PYE‫!א‬32! 6!F ‫א‬3 ‫א‬6F%!'2Q$ ‫א‬32Au
`" MF   6!$ ‫   א! א‬#8w / !* K? 0Q-‫א  ?   א‬Wa
3 ¨(P+ ،1984  XO<+ ‫ א‬6Nj‫ א‬02-‫ א‬,‚2  =‫א‬17" MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
C‫!­ א‬, / © ,‚2  ،=»!$" 62Q-‫& א‬8  X( ‫ א‬C~ ,‚2
 KC "/ P*t"
©  8  PYE‫š ! א‬2a APF " MF ‫ א א‬1.  3 ›]† @
‘  G (< ‫   © א‬W  ،H4;‫( א‬4]< ‫ א‬C‫א‬DE‫= א‬+@  ($(< ‫א‬
،E 225 W 1991 ،0K6!F ‫ א‬F =F;‫ א‬F8 ‫ א‬A2 3!™ 6$(< ‫ א‬F8 ‫ א‬b " ¼‫א‬
`" B ‫ א‬1.  C% 1( Á (! (F 2  ‫‚†א‬2  ‫ א‬+ X!B+ !*
 KMP‫א‬t;‫א‬
? , ‫ א‬6!(P8;‫ א‬Y1s  ()F% "F2 32 @Q7+‫  א‬،¨ Œ 2 3&
32 ! =¬ ،MF ‫‡ א‬a ;‫  א‬.D  /‫` א‬$" tE‫ א‬2 ،*t ‫א‬
 W12*t+،MF ‫א‬A[,;€8 2  2HE3$%BDQ;‫א‬
x  ™ F ،!$ ‫ * א‬g¬" ŠS Ž MF ‫ א‬g™2 =a J1
A& = CF ‫ א‬D‡a MPŒ Ht ‫ א‬Hx& ‫ א‬P‫א‬Y !' 02-‫ * <( א‬h12
KE 218 W1994،Y  KHx& ‫א‬F (8HP‫ = א‬،P<2A&MF ‫א‬
6&, ‫(?'!א‬7 ‫@א <(א‬32™$2KF ‫א‬g <;‫א‬6F !*
&8;‫ א‬3Q\ ،42 !$ ‫ * א‬H\،R!' (< ‫א‬
[,8% F(Da# 1L<+:(*%?MF ‫?אא‬F +‫א‬Ht ‫א‬61 ‫'!א‬
MPŒ"  KE 439 W1982،0 K61 ‫א‬F،=~F ‫ (א‬a2‡aA ‫א‬C"$(< ‫א‬

2008
42  ‫  א אא   א‬
7-X^ ‫א‬ ‫א‬MF ‫א‬7j2^;‫א¡* א‬F7;"CF ‫‡א‬a›$ ‫א‬
01%/‫¨א‬W(.% 2،Q(W‫&א (&א‬8 ‫א‬$. ،(< ‫א‬8WL ‫א‬
‫א‬tPg.a#»M4=6^MF ‫"=א‬h: ‫ א‬،L [< "6$(< ‫ (א‬
 KE281 J280،175W2š،=KH8F ‫א‬Fky‫˜א‬12‡a( ‫א‬
،MF ‫ א‬A&8  `"F ‫! א‬$ ‫ "` א‬# D HP. $% \ à J2
`" . ‫ ;@< א‬،‫א‬y‫ א‬AN‫  א‬v‫ א‬Z‫א‬Ga  =$+) / 3t ‫א‬
 MPt;‫אא‬tP_W1DL ‫&א‬E‫›א‬3X8<*،(Pt;‫א (אא‬
!¡ (y‫ א‬12 (< ‫א א‬F +‫ א‬6%% 4 ‫א א‬tP    K1™$% M," Z‫Œא‬
( &G-  9$2  7 ^;‫š _ א‬1 +"  ˆa !1 2 ،¼‫` \ א‬,D
–6D ¨ Œ=E?$(< ‫"?א‬F2 ? ("P ‫­?א‬742  !$ "¨ Œ ،MF ‫א‬
=  RQj‫‚ ( א‬,2 !  », ‫ א‬32 ‫א‬D‫  א‬L = #  J ˆB+ 1.  32
– ($(< ‫ א‬.‫ ™^| א;א‬X‹ $.‫א‬%  ˆF +‫  *! א‬K©E‫( א‬, ‫ א‬R‫א‬LE‫א‬
6"` 8(j‫א‬32?@;‫ א‬,26P ،KPt;‫א‬RQj‫א‬,y‫א‬7F ‫א‬#
­(4 ‫א‬C E‫א‬k7 ‫‡א‬aA$ 6$(< ‫[ˆא‬B+(y‫ –א <(א‬K! &"
K‫א‬P: ‫!א‬LA(, ‫™ א‬,*xD32o%2
!$ ‫› א‬$" 32 ‫א‬F +/‫ א‬32 !9 MF ‫ א‬A& X™$% ،r;"
W Å4;  h1F k(™ M," ،`F8 ‫ א‬Q* 32 ` 2: ;‫`  א‬4$ ;‫א‬
‘ G(< ‫[א‬$%M,Dh1NF +!™ ،RQ /‫@  א‬8 ‫א‬1+ ¾
R1 ,%1+# ›$ ‫@א‬32MF ‫א‬R‫א‬P %Á ،%‫Œא‬X@ ‫  א‬K¼‫א‬
 KE @253WšKH(1GF.MPt2c ‫ א‬h1P‫א‬t23`!,;‫א‬6‰
MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬P. `" RQ P !( 4% / (Pt;‫ א‬Qj‫= א‬a J3
h18@‫א‬2 M," MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬g% `" Qj‫‡ א‬a ˆ‫א‬$ % " ،M, (2Q-‫א‬
32 = 4 2  ،= & 2 M,"  ،(Pt;‫ א‬h1%($.; +(D \@;‫א‬
= S 3t ‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬32 3< ;‫› א‬$"  2E‫א א‬tP #s   K ©  
\$;‫ˆ א‬tP #s %  K ‫א‬y‫ א‬1( 0$ F(! Q ‡a (Pt;‫ א‬Q /‫א‬

2008
43  ‫  א אא   א‬
_: ‫ א‬32 g+ ‡a ©  8 ‫א  א‬v‫ א‬MF% z(D  ،$2 $(< ‫  א‬, ‫ א‬P 
6(, ‫א‬M4$ ‫  א‬،C ;‫ א‬k(,8 ‫[ א‬8& ‫ א‬H 12 ½Rs Ht ‫א‬KPt;‫א‬
 K2;‫א‬6! ./‫א‬M] ‫ א‬،#!E‫א‬
W`(F ‫אא‬DQ2‫ א‬HB ‫" א‬7 ‫א‬J J4
= HB ‫א‬C‫א‬A42XdMP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫ א‬,2=ŠDQ
] ‫ א‬P % É Xd D 7 ‫ א‬hB$! ،k(7 ‫ ½ א‬1FL — =
1(M^%c‫ א‬6P ،(F ‫ !‚†אא‬0F%c‫& א‬G#6%% ،;$ ‫א‬
=*  ،‫א‬y‫ ~א_ א‬C   Q /‫¨ א‬% C: ‰ 2  J  ،Q2‫א‬
#$;" (&G  6!(F ‫ א‬#$;" (@Q 6P 3  ;‫( "` א‬E‫א;<& א‬
o!  22 J20F Cr;‫ ( א‬# 3 ‫‚† א‬2  D 2 P  ،6N‫א‬.-‫א‬
,(D#F%?(W%? 3†‚;‫"`א‬c$" ‫¨א;‚†א‬% hB$2 61 % KE2003
‡a1FL—== ،!]8 ‫א‬c8 ‫א‬+ W ‫  @א;‚†א‬F^;‫א‬R^ ‫א‬
 K[PA&­4 C %/hx32 ،f ‫א‬2
`"(F(Fy‫א‬Qj‫א‬3231 ‫ˆא;‚†אא‬tP#M^،©1.32
`"@Q$ ‫—ˆא‬K ‡a6\82P ،1(n, ‫ א‬PY — ،MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
/(8( %"7#•% |! ‫אא‬t1"MF ‫­!(א‬4  ،MF ‫א‬R‫א‬L
Q /‫ א‬B  ،E @2 2003 ،0 KM(7j‫א‬F B ‫ א‬C‫@א‬E‫  א‬D ^%
 KlD#(E‫א‬
f =" ‫@א‬-‫ א &(  א‬A9‫ א‬1  b(  (F ‫* א‬y‫= א‬a J5
6P ،CWE‫›א‬$""،(8 ‫( א‬1F8 ‫א‬Q /‫א‬3!&/Q /‫א‬
 Kz ‫אא‬tP326+r ‫א¡א‬1( a$ ‫א‬A[7j‫ א‬,;‫א‬
[17% ،MF ‫א‬0182$.‫א‬2A ™‡a$%‫א‬G‚;‫ˆא‬tP* J6
6^ ‫(א‬F(Fy‫& (א‬G-‫ א‬CDn, ‫ א‬b ‫א‬C&G*32& ,2
D42 " ،?L‫א‬$ ‫ א‬1"  ,% (F 2  |F b(  MF  K1 9$2
MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫ א‬P _7;‫ א‬b(  KRQ /‫ א‬P. b† 8G&2

2008
44  ‫  א אא   א‬
2#4@  ،i /‫( א‬s12   ˆ42MPt2& =Œa ،(2Q-‫א‬
g%`"$ ‫א‬P(2Q-‫א‬2E‫(א‬D% MF  .y‫א‬dˆ¾a3&)
RP ­4 ¨ t"  Kv‫ א‬C@ ،P9‫ א‬1%Q ‫ א‬hJ Z‫  Œא‬MPt;‫א א‬tP
M$4(Q‫א‬F $2`" !9‫א‬Pb(   J @‫א א‬P‫*א‬aX‹  JMF ‫א‬
P ،^ ‫ א‬M4$ ‫א‬t+  ،$ ‫ = א‬$ ‫ א‬8 E‫א‬¥2Ga"،1(" !9‫א‬
2 hJ • ‫ א‬k‫א א א‬tP r;  (2 < ‫ א‬A78 ‫= א‬E ،k(F ‫ א‬3&ª 2
‫א‬tP k(F  A ‫_ א‬W  !$ ‫Œא — א‬a W ،F Q 32 1("
32t ‫ א‬،$2($ "CF ‫  א‬،v‫א‬0‫א‬nD‫א‬# ,Ht ‫א‬6<$ ‫א‬¥;‫א‬
K($< ‫א‬i E‫ אא‬8 ‫^א‬2
  ،MF ‫ א‬19 LDa   ‫• א‬$% / *t ‫ א‬8 , ‫ א‬BDQ;‫= א‬a
A:1. ]  ،‫א‬t ‫  א‬,2 R1 , F+  " ،g <;‫= א‬G 32 WF+a
hF%CQ32r* y‫ˆא‬tP­\  ،(Pt ‫[~ (א "[א‬7% h(P8;‫א‬
 K0( ‫א‬KPt;‫א‬62Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫'¨ א@ א‬#g <;‫אא‬tP
 W @‫א=א א‬:(2(2Q/‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫א‬D LW(+x
 WQ /‫&א‬,;‫ א‬J1
#!(!((F%(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫א‬g <2h((F%(!0: ,%
 W212»M =»&% ‫א‬Q /‫א‬32` ,2`":((! ‫א‬، @‫'¨א א‬
6P 6P  ،CWE‫  = א‬g 8 ‫ א‬b† ‫( א‬1F8 ‫( א‬Pt;‫ א‬Q /‫ א‬J
KPt;‫ א‬RQ /‫ Œ ¨ = א‬،H\D  Fx Ž *  ($(L  (W APd
& *D P œa  ،  <%  @:†  2,F+‫ א‬b(  68 ‫ א‬#$;‫א א‬t1"
L-‫ א‬3!™ ©« ‫  א‬Z‫  א;א‬01E‫ "` א‬RQ ‫ א‬.  2 ،!s,2 ($(L
(1F8 ‫א‬Q /‫א‬C@‫א‬:(! 2Å4 ‫?א‬, ‫א‬0»@@ K 29‫א‬D‫א א‬
02-‫ א‬3 6$< ‫ א‬02-‫ א‬%  KPt ‫Š א‬y‫ Œ* א‬K? ];‫ א‬0‫א‬nD‫א‬
،6$< ‫ א‬32 F X 2 ? W C@ + "W D b+ #2 6" Šy‫א‬

2008
45  ‫  א אא   א‬
/ ،#2 "  W C@ hx H(" t •(F  @n‫ א‬hx  ,2  2 %d+
 KE15W10š،KPt ‫א‬F?‫ ؟‬,2k8 +Ž=a +‫א‬a=&+=h(F ,
hB$2 ?   ‫א‬kNFD ?" *6™ ‫א  א <?א‬، 1.32
M *3!™8(4%(M$4_ & ’F ‫=א‬# D،, ‫א‬P#% 2
 K$(< ‫ א‬, ‫א‬P
A ˜‰  .D h,2  H] ‫= א‬22-‫ Ž ¾ א‬،/‚P ‫א‬J #
H Sh,2_ *=‫א‬CF ‫‡א‬a€6L(, ‫=א‬# D$(< ‫א‬32A‫  א‬zD
 KEfK0،&,(,-‫א‬F($(G8+#
`8 ];‫א‬#‫ א‬t! %،Z‫ Œא‬MPt;‫אא‬tP31 ‫א‬32‫[א‬r*=a ‫א‬tP
،,8+ MPt;‫! א‬N `" +(D 0F RQ /‫ " *= א‬K 61F8 ‫ א‬MPt;‫  א‬hl
$ 8(D " 02- ،6$(G Ž 1 .‫ א‬32 M@ • Ž 1 .‫(&= א‬
P3202a!PQ*= 2،6$< ‫‡א‬a2N,;‫›א‬$": ‫‡א‬a_@
،0 K$&< ‫ א‬F _‫א‬4 ‫ א‬3 J‫א‬Y !1+ ©  `22-‫ א‬F 2 F  Ž  ،, ‫א‬
 KE531W2003
h1+¬،©(\@ ،Q] h1 «(™"E‫א‬RQ ‫א‬hJ
W 1988،g ،!$2 F  ‫(   א א‬7" , ‫ א‬P F  ‡a _@ h11F = o $
 KE24
 : $;‫ !  א‬،D‫ א א‬MPt;‫  א‬DE‫ א‬AB ‫ א  < א‬Xx @
6$(< ‫א‬MPt;‫!(` א‬L8 ‫ ' א‬،`($ ‫א‬32Y(2Q& ‫א‬h1 « 
 KC7%r2E‫ א‬،1"W#(j‫< א‬8 ‫א‬CŒ.،42 _^;"
O( ‫א‬Y‫א‬a (!‫א‬1 .‫א‬A( 6P(1F8 ‫א‬Q /‫ˆא‬tPr2=a
©­ 82 »D6! .‫א‬¥2 (F(D#(  ،W(7$2  2
،h$ ‫ א‬k7;‫א‬# ,2‫א‬Dk(7%`!,! ”% ،1 ./‫!(א‬7%‡a
 Kv‫א‬68+ $(7F ‫א‬C&G*3($"

2008
46  ‫  א אא   א‬
 ]   s ‫א א‬tP * 6 , / 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ ¨ ¬=  א@ א‬t
MF ‫‚†א א‬2 $  KH\D 7% WD (4‹ 32 $% (1F Q ‫א‬
32:%"،`!,;‫א‬1dh4F%/(Q ‫א‬CDR8 /‫œŒšא‬,—
 K61F8 ‫א‬hl‫א‬x
Q /‫א‬6PlH4 ‫‡א‬a`!,;‫ š א@ א‬S ‫א‬Q /‫=א‬a
1%7 32=»1 ،l %0SP"L#F%=3&)/ ‫ א‬،CWE‫א‬
6P ،E 2007، 0K3 ‫א‬bÊFMPt2*?(W4?321+$ŒX‹
 W`(` !<%Q ‫א‬
 6,(N ‫ א   א‬22-‫ א‬# € ‫ ( א‬M$  Ht ‫ א‬6(, ‫ א‬C‫ א‬J
(% 1(" 32 (Pt2 ‫(א‬%  c A ‡a `!,;‫ א‬h,@ RQ P  ،RQj‫א‬
4@a &" 6"$(K!9‫ א‬, ‫א‬P  : $;‫ א‬O.;‫ א‬$(< ‫אš א‬j‫א‬
M," =8 3" =!r  F2  8(F, ‫ א‬g! .‫  א‬Qj‫ א‬32 M L 6" 3" 6
(( 2‫ א‬1* ،h(& ‫  א‬,2 hx  $2  6 4+ `" 24j‫א‬
4 2(Pt2‫(א‬%‡ah12,F+‫!` א‬,;‫א‬AD [*¥G3X\]†
 K
8G (%  ‫א‬$ ‫א‬Axa &<;‫א‬k(!$%32((, ‫א‬Qj‫א א‬Y
SHt ‫א‬6w ‫א‬1x‫א‬% ،Wj‫א‬1%($.28NL& ­W# D،RQj‫א‬
 K‫א‬PE‫ א‬M4$ "
=)-‫[ ( @\( א‬x Ht ‫ א‬C‫ א‬P  ،NF$ ‫  א‬6F ‫ א‬C J_
ˆ ‫©א‬2 ،=)-‫(א‬$2CQ3212182 ،( . '8& ‫א‬
0 0 =)-‫ א‬32 ‫א‬:. !$ ‫  א  א‬، =, " ‫@א‬a  MF " k4% 
M—=‫א‬1L‫ א‬AFHt ‫א‬MF  6;$ ‫*!=א! א‬K¨ Œ ‫א‬
6$(< ‫א א‬n ‫ א‬M * 1+: ‰ ‫ א‬k(,8 ‫[  א‬8& ‫ א‬0&D ”L =v‫ א‬y
3t ‫" א‬4 ‫ א‬8&% ‫ א‬0&DE K22-‫\( א‬F" X7%‫א‬ ‫  א‬،•, ‫א‬
AD  P ‫(א‬E‫א‬Q\$;‫©א‬Da6PM L6"3" 6Q‫ א‬

2008
47  ‫  א אא   א‬
8&% ‫א‬0&DE‫›א‬$"1r2 ،0( ‫א‬# D Qj‫א‬4t262Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫א‬
 Cy‫ א‬P !* ›‫ א  א‬+  h1$\%  •, ‫א א‬n ‫ א‬M *  $(< ‫א‬
(< ‫( א‬,s ‫א‬hP% ‫אא‬v‫›א‬$"3¨(P+،`(8, ‫א‬323< ;‫›א‬$"
 KEfK0،0KA!F(l-‫אא‬t
،$(< ‫ א‬, ‫"`א‬F$ ‫א‬Q /‫ א‬k!30r ‫ ©†(|א‬,2
‹(D+!P/ W` (D+32, hPB26s1;‫א‬h1Q ‫א‬#s %
, ‫א‬$(LP.Q ‫“א‬z(D، ‫אא‬tP(s12 , ‫א‬32X"r ‫א‬
P 3  2 =* 2 /a », ‫ א‬32 $(< ‫ א‬F / Œa W `7 ‫   © א‬F;‫א‬
, ‫א‬hB$2=r)3t ‫"א‬4 ‫א‬3H 2& 4@a•$2P ،X( ‫א‬
 K, ‫א‬P©  F;‫א‬
», ‫  א‬D h(%  `Pt;‫ "` א‬RQ /‫  א‬r!  (+r ‫ א‬2
$  C@ |F b(  !<   y‫ˆ א‬tP =77) $(< ‫ “ א‬z(D ،($< ‫א‬
‫א‬tP r! K04$;‫ א‬02-‫ א‬F%  $  C@  \ œa  ،EF C ‫ א‬F%
C ‫ א¼   א‬CF  Y‫א‬2 .!*  J<" hP  – !NE‫ א‬C‫ @א‬hF 4 ‫א‬
،6D ‫ א‬g7F+‫  א‬A ‫ א‬h  A&8" /Qa &< ª ،0Q, ‫  א‬AQ4 ‫( א‬
 K @‫ א א‬#AF$2»7202MF ‫א‬$¾
،=~F ‫  ‹? א‬,u A;‫ˆ א‬tP k$ % © F »72 Yo% ،r;"
”F== E5P328F•(& ‫א‬P‫ א‬ ‫אא ? א‬tPCD& ‫ אא‬
 $L@ !,D0: , ،#$2 P%‫א? " א‬+E‫  ?ƒ א‬6,‫” א‬W  ،1(
?42 ? _ #!, 2 4} \ •(& ‫(¨ !»   א‬P+ ، ,;‫ˆ א‬tP
;1(h,y‫א‬6^ ، @‫ א א‬#,%&NG(\@\ˆt1،?!L
CF$;‫א‬32b( ،$(< ‫ א‬, ‫אא‬F $2`"c8%A7321%(L `"!‹
¨< ‫א‬32AŒ#F%= ،¼‫* _א‬CD|^ ‫אא‬t1"­!,=_F%Hd
 KE @22003،0KM(7j‫א‬F D

2008
48  ‫  א אא   א‬
،` 8 , ‫ ` א‬7;‫ א‬3 A7 F% / r x F »72 ¨ Œ ‡a R\
MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬N =  ˆ1B"(22-‫ א‬$(< ‫ א‬F $ Ht ‫  א‬,;‫ א‬02-‫  א‬,2 6P
Ž 02-‫  "  = א‬,;‫ˆ א‬tP 32 =»1 ›$ ‫Œא *= א‬a  K©E‫( א‬2Q-‫א‬
،E530W2003،0K$&< ‫א‬F(? É k8 +=3&)ˆ1d ،$"1B
sF7"l  % ،( &G-‫א‬, %&< ‫אא‬t1" ,;‫©=«א‬++¬
3 A($" D L 3  ،MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬F(!$ ‫ א‬Qj‫ א‬Axa 0 R1"
 KKKKMP‫א‬t2= 23&%Aa6P ، @‫א א‬
 WKPt;‫א‬68N7 ‫א‬by‫א‬62% J2
KPt;‫ א‬68N7 ‫ א‬by‫ א‬#2% 3 0( ‫ א‬62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫&<?  א@ א‬
@ K2003‫"^א‬iFt2c‫א‬$ ‫א‬4j‫א‬# ،B X82&<"
% ‫א‬32A$ 2P<2Y(Pt2 ((87W‫&א‬G¨ Œ#—
 K *‫(א;א‬2Q-‫א‬s\ ‫א‬M,"ˆ@ ‫א‬Y‫א‬Ht ‫?א‬$ ‫א‬
`4$ 2`!,2H"c‫א‬$ ‫א‬A$ ‫ א‬X" .,;‫א‬X@nD‫א‬F
=("H !,+ F+Ž ،"‫א‬2@2o%#68N7 ‫א‬3< ‫ א‬M\^ ‫א‬h1‘
.,26P ‫א‬.,! , "c‫א‬$ ‫א‬X4D ‫*א‬1 +/‫א‬0S­W
 *‚% `!,;‫ ! א‬O(P X(F"  ،$(< ‫»  א‬,  .,2 X,(  ،¼‫א‬
X"X@ ‫ Œאא‬K», ‫א‬P[2%R1 ,%(8NL7. #1%+("
‫ @  <א‬3 8 ª ،]]8;‫(א א‬, ‫ א‬X4+  ، \ ($(< ‫א;א@ א‬
A[,2  A7 H ­& ª ،Z‫  Œא‬MPt;‫א א‬tl `! ;‫" א‬E‫ א‬32 R/v‫א‬
 K_F ‫א‬
 W_F ‫אא‬2`"_ s ‫א‬0  J2
$(< ‫  ©!א‬X،1947APF "?MF ‫?אא‬b(%t2
(!PE‫א‬32h(BM+.#© W ،H4;‫(א‬4]< ‫א‬C‫א‬DE‫=א‬+@
 "r ‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬f#$ ‫א‬Y‫א‬.CD¼‫ ‘א‬G(< ‫א‬32
Fb%PYE‫*!@א‬K<#x-‫(א‬22-‫א‬$(< ‫א‬MPt212 ،CWE‫א‬

2008
49  ‫  א אא   א‬
2š ،1978،g Kh(B$ ‫ א‬F M4$% [J 32 1$(G  1( (2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
 KE188 J187W
Ž+/a،^ ‫ ?א‬¤‡a G(< ‫ ©א‬$(< ‫!א‬h.%@
32 D‫  א‬X8 Ž  K($(< ‫ א‬.‫ א;א‬32 .2 H 32 l Ad2 ©  H 4%
(, ‫( א‬1F8 ‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬F k  6$(< ‫ א‬h,;‫ א‬2$%  $% Y‫ א‬$(< ‫! א‬
1!9‫=   א‬a " K($;‫ א‬R‫א‬LE‫ "` * א‬/ 2 MF ‫ &= א‬# D
Pt2H8$9‫א‬MPt;‫א‬$.D‡aMPŒ@(2Q-‫א‬Ar ‫א‬$"4 ‫(א‬+‫א‬-‫א‬
‫א‬tP # 7 !( P[(^% Y¾ / ¨ Œ F% ‫ א‬A;‫ = א‬# €
» +  ، 
 K_F ‫א‬3z ‫א‬A [W 1.a#!$2P ،Ef،0KA!F  ‫א‬
 Wv‫א‬MPt;‫א‬g%E$;‫  ©א‬8 ‫אא‬Wa  J3
،!$ ‫› א‬$"  ‫ א‬KPt;‫ א‬3< ‫א א@ \ = א‬  # ŠDQ
b((,% = F $+  K v‫ א‬MPt;‫ א‬g% ™ $F2  ( ©   ‫ א‬W
|3»$% ‫  ©א‬8 ‫"`א‬32 KR7 ‫אא‬tP @ 32‫א‬Y(Pt;‫אא‬4 ‫א‬
AW2 1( 0». ‫ א‬3o. ¼‫(  © א <(  א‬Pt;‫((  א‬, ‫ א‬c‫ א‬E‫א‬
#  ،2006032Y( 6+(14 ‫ א‬$ ‫ א‬21™ ‫"א‬D¼‫_א‬:D
3=.›‫   א‬J–h1+E4 "¼‫_א‬:Dg%E ‫א‬Y‫א‬.0$"
g <2<#C%\A[7 ,2ˆtP ،E @220030،0KM(7j‫א‬F;‫א‬
 Kk(7 ‫ ©א‬,2#MF ‫א‬
 WL‫ ©א;א‬,2#(Pt;‫@(א‬E‫!(א‬1% J4
3?<&%،62Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫=א‬,+-‫א‬cFD7j4DAB+=a
? ‰2&DA7(X‹.% ‫(א‬Pt;‫@(א‬E‫א‬cFD#6F(FD3—
3&)/6  " ،C  ‫א‬RQ "? w¨ Œ=hJ،KPt;‫ !א‬+/‫א‬h1
‫א‬t1"L‫@א;א‬Q3< K62Q-‫Žא‬$ ‫א‬2&y‫( א‬#1!(!$%
17™/‫ א‬C:$ ‫  א‬t " !*y‫[ א‬J MP‫א‬t;‫ א‬32 ‫א‬E‫› א‬$" $G &< ‫א‬

2008
50  ‫  א אא   א‬
H‚ ª ،  ‫ א‬M( ‫ א !(  א;<*   א‬C  =2y‫  א‬،6(, ‫א‬
 K("$ ‫א‬C  ‫›א‬$"D!*g< ‫™א‬8 +‫‡א‬a+(D
 WMP‫א‬t;‫א‬b((,%  J4
1.ª،(, ‫[א½א‬7‫א“א‬R$%(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"א‬
_" 1G  ،M4$ ‫א  א‬$ ‫ א‬$@  1" #F    ،( ‫ א‬PWF2 3
 K‫א‬$ ‫ א‬$(7F ‫א‬
$@!*y‫א_א‬:DE‫! א‬B+E‫›א‬$"s"b((, ‫אא‬tPh.%@
$;‫א‬0B ‫א‬1 [,8% (1F (rD˜P2 ™ ‡a62Q-‫א‬3L ‫א‬
_ & ‫א‬32#F ,;‫א‬fF;‫א‬0Q-‫א‬1"Wr†Wz(ƒ،0Q¿
 K, ‫" & _ א‬l@Q/((1.% @‫א א‬6P!("،, ‫א‬
\ ,+ = 3&) KPt;‫  א‬6(, ‫א א א "` א‬tP # šŒ!*
Ž1& ،¼‫_א‬:D2YX‹= ($(< ‫א‬2 F;‫א‬ ‫א=א‬a?@2
|j‫אא‬tPr!،6&2E‫א@(™א¡ א‬$ ‫א‬2 F! ( ‫א‬b8+˜1%
="6Dª،?0Q-‫?אא‬H:];‫א א@ א‬3 32+‫­א‬W!;‫א‬
 KKKƒ‹WMF ‫א‬1.
 W @‫א א‬Hn ~. KPt;‫ א <[א‬J6
، ‫ א‬# X: ‫ א‬M4  .  ، @‫­ א א‬7 # X8L ©  ,2
`"[< ‫ א‬,26P ،(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫א‬D!LC<ah1,%
1"0F ‫א <[א‬/ '=< ‫אא‬tP*t   KZ‫ Œא‬MPt;‫אא‬tPg%
6(, ‫Œ א‬8 ‫ א‬62 " X7%‫* א‬D 6P  ،(, ‫ א‬Q ‫  א‬6$(< ‫א ( א‬
‫א‬tP»$ K5P1979t2( ‫א‬1 2&D (+‫א‬-‫א‬1!9‫א‬0(@$"=‫א‬-
 2 ‫א @ —"א‬+* 3t ‫ א‬, ‫› ! א‬$" M+. 32 @ $   x 2
^232‫ א‬tD،@E‫א‬# ¨ Œ3‫א‬$.‫א‬%=‫א‬r 23& ،MF ‫א‬A&
A22[J»+Ht ‫א‬H ™F ‫א <(?א‬$!*MF ‫א‬A&<

2008
51  ‫  א אא   א‬
›$" M,&% @ ‫ א <[ א‬A7 ‡a %‫א‬d2  %"‫א‬s ‫  א‬%" *
 KMF ‫א‬g <u­(7%@A ‫ א‬%1& ،4+E‫א‬
 ‫ א‬3 ?<&% ،62Q-‫ א א@ א‬1,&$ ‫ א‬P<;‫ˆ א‬tP =a
32Y   @‫ ! = א א‬،=@ ?4+ 32 r*E  2‫א‬ ‫ א‬MF ‫ א‬D L
 K1 G<P &E‫א‬k!©2f(F (F2o $2YE‫א‬
 W ‫א‬% J7
32 €] % Ž 1+ AW$;‫( א‬2Q-‫ א‬$! ‫ א‬A‫ @א‬CQ 32 
%8W"8‹u(2Q-‫(א‬Pt ‫א א‬1» ‫!(&א‬, ‫א‬F7 ‫א‬
(W8% B+ F ©E‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ ? א‬¤  $(< ‫  א‬, ‫( "` א‬2‫א א‬W 32
ˆ$""6™;‫אא‬tPC‫א‬:/ KE523 J520W0K$&< ‫א‬W(2‫(א א‬w ‫אא‬DE‫א‬
/8 D/‫› א‬$" ,&$% 2 P  K`7 ‫ "` א‬F(!  8S (, ‫א‬
# (‹ PB2 32 1]  2  F;‫ א‬3*2E‫› א‬$  ‫א‬: ‫  א‬،(V;‫א‬
 ‫א‬PB;‫ˆא‬tP=aK$(< ‫ א‬, ‫"`א‬W،(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫›א‬$"`"‫א‬$ ‫א‬
($+* 0( ‫א‬KPt;‫א‬1<;‫א‬$—،$@‫ א‬h\1$@ #($+C‫א‬:+/
‫א‬$ (Da+#/y‫א‬3,DF ،`(!L8 ‫` א‬2E‫א‬4
 K (F2(Pt2
 WY s ‫(א‬+&2-’2Wr x
(1F8 ‫א‬Q Q , "&8 ‫א‬xa ‘RQ /‫Œא*=א‬a
\@  (Pt;‫ א‬Q]  , " (4$ ,2 =& ¨ Œ =¬ ،g 8 ‫ א‬N,2
‡a (œ ‫› א;’ א‬$" 7, +¬ ،?@;‫" א‬$4" +)a 2   K( W
K2& "12‫א‬nD‫א‬Á‫Œא‬aMF ‫“”!(א‬ahP,=3&)1(%=3B ‫א‬
(48 ‫&= א‬2-" =* © ’u CQ@-‫’  = א‬2 < # :*
  ،#F !  !B;‫ א‬s ‫(! א‬$% 1 \ @‫א‬ ‫ א‬c‫ א‬E‫ א‬D,2 k(™ /  1(
32 Œ‫א‬tE‫  א‬3&8;‫!  א‬$ ‫› א‬$" RL 32 DL k @ 1\$" = M,"
 KE2006،MF ‫’א‬2Wh(F ‫* "א‬B+‫א‬FH ™F ‫א <(?א‬Y‫א‬L

2008
52  ‫  א אא   א‬
MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF   ‫א‬D H  (, ‫(  א‬+~F ‫( א‬$.;‫ א‬0‫א‬: ‫ א‬J1
=& ‫ א‬0B  0Q-‫ א‬B2 $; =(E‫א= א‬4;‫! א‬P " (2Q-‫א‬
=~F ‫ א‬R D 32 RD  3$7+ = 3&) Q ،=,+-‫  א‬Av‫  א‬A(y‫א‬
 %Aa R‫ *א½א‬،($7F ‫א‬APB ‫(א‬4 ‫א א‬, ‫ א‬h& ‫א‬
6P  ©o& ‫ א‬NF$ ‫ א‬0Q-‫ א‬CW  ¨(&<%  ،, ‫~=  א‬F ‫ א‬4
 KˆWF2 MF ‫א‬R‫א‬PE@o $A ‫א‬h  h& ‫~=א‬F ‫ א‬6l-‫(א‬D ‫א‬
 W(2Q-‫א‬AD ‫א‬u=)-‫ א‬J2
 ‫א‬, ‫ א‬h& ‫~=א‬F ‫א‬#:&%MF ‫א‬C E‫Œא*=א;א‬a
(2Q-‫ א‬AD ‫ א‬u r< 2 (F ‫ א‬R‫א‬LE‫&= א‬% = ‡ E ،(4 ‫א‬
46WC8+E‫–א‬103W=‫!א‬C~F, ‫~= א‬F ‫א‬32(F ‫ א‬E‫*א‬P*‚% ‫א‬
AD ‫ א‬2 32 cQ7+/‫ ¬= א‬hx 32  ،E 80 W7š،H] ‫ – א‬92 W (+E‫–א‬
1+E b(F;‫ "& א‬KF ‫(   א‬s1;‫@ א‬Q7+/‫ א‬W •$ (2Q-‫א‬
g <232$— ‫<&(א !א‬%Aa3z ‫ א‬Y® ‫‡א ® ? א‬a#$, 
 K.+ <2MF ‫א‬
 WMF ‫א‬.32‫א‬y‫א@(א‬42 J3
( ‫א‬3,D (@‫א‬4;‫א‬2# ‫Œאא‬a /a­s%/MF ‫=!(א‬a 
،‫א‬PkF % MF ‫א‬WF2#%s, ‫ˆא‬tPHP#$،7 ‫א‬2Q
،(G !\%  O(G CF% MF ‫ א‬R‫א‬L X+* ‫Œא‬a 2 Ks 2 ‫א‬y‫ א‬$—
 ‫(?א‬F ‫ ?א‬,2‡a4 ‫אא‬tP[<+ K_F ‫א‬g <2<‡aH‚‫א‬t1
MF ‫ א‬A 02 Ar sD +(D ?F% !(" ،$(< ‫(  א‬+)a ‫א‬$" t%
W2003،0 KM(7j‫א‬F$(< ‫!א‬3240Q*H(@‫א‬42¨&<%1+E
`"MF ‫ "=&=א‬7;‫א‬, ‫›!א‬$"kD32­46  " ،E @2
MP‫א‬t;‫א "` א‬D H  L " / ky‫ א‬f # (2 $(< ‫  א‬, ‫א‬
 KE2003،HKH ™F ‫א‬F
 W(Pt;‫א‬Q /‫א‬f2@32[8& ‫א‬4@a J4

2008
53  ‫  א אא   א‬
t] ،$(< ‫ א‬, ‫"`א‬W،(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬RQj‫(­=א‬W
،!4$ ‫   א‬1;‫  א‬22-‫  א‬F /‫ א‬M,"  HNF$ ‫ א‬C‫  א‬A[7 ‫א‬$"
،k(,8 ‫[ א‬8& ‫א‬D‡a4=M¾/2E‫א‬3& ،6w ‫ א‬-‫א‬M,"
ˆtP'21a K (2 MF ‫א‬$¾21%/‫ˆא‬tPr2#_* ‫=א‬E
D # ?[8& ‫ א‬J&8 ‫ ?א‬0^ E‫ˆ א‬tP c7+ ‹ 6^ ،(N1+ !1 ‫א‬
$.‫א‬2 Aa hx ،(x‫א‬n ‫ א‬M & ‫ א‬32 1 ‫א‬Y- 7 k(7%  ،A! !' [$%
b ‫א‬321 ‫א‬Ya ،(, ‫( א‬$(< ‫אא‬،v‫[א‬8& (‫א א‬M & ‫*א‬
 KA9‫א‬$7 ‫א‬321tD ،(2Q-‫א‬$29‫!( א‬$ ‫אא‬Yy‫א‬
 Wv‫א‬F;A-‫א ^ א‬M— J5
3231 ‫‡ א‬a ‫א‬PŒ 3t ‫! א‬$ ‫› א‬$" H " ? É 6 2 ‫א‬tP
،¼‫`\א‬,D!'F” 82‫א‬DcQ7+‫א‬02‫א‬:.D&<+ "+G
»b2M“M.‫ א‬3Q\،, ‫~= א‬F ‫א‬PfF;"4F+ ،E @25Wˆ1428
‡aH‚,*$2(8L2kw¨ Œ=E،h1$  "4 ‫א‬32D‫ א‬H
 K3$ ‫ א‬M, ‫א‬361 ‫( א™א‬2Q-‫א‬4 ‫ א‬،MF ‫א‬s?@%
 W(O(\;‫א‬M+‫א‬9‫א‬CQ^ ‫א  א‬AF32€] ‫ א‬J6
 ‫    א‬،AD‫(  א‬7œ AW  b(  W P  ‫= א‬a
=*"،$LF2 $(7@1<ŽHG‫א א‬4$ WO(\2šŒœ62Q-‫א‬
Å4u 2E‫ א‬k$  2 ‰ 2 = B ‫ א‬1.   Q ‫ א‬R$
g! .‫ א‬$" (( $(L # " 0@ 6@8 ‫ א‬0,F+/‫(­ = א‬W K`!,;‫א‬
32 @ =* 32  Qj‫ א‬c V M L 6" 3" ( 3&  ،8(F, ‫א‬
K!9‫* א‬$2 1 +‫ א‬$" (. ',% 1d !* K ­4 ‫ א‬hl €  8j‫א‬
z(D((, ‫א‬2E‫ !<*א‬A ‫א‬h.n%_7j‫א‬3"‫!א‬$  F2Ã
? [E‫א א‬tP _‫א‬.  ،? l 3,D " / \$; X< 2 ? W 6$   @  x
=#@›1ª،E2006W€8D6+PF ?`!,;‫א‬2X!23!E
M t  A~2 o $% 0Q-‫   א‬6F(Fy‫ א‬4$ ‫<& א‬% ‫ א‬Fy‫ˆ א‬tP
‫א‬tP  ?‫א‬, ‫* ?א‬, ‫ א‬#  /‫ א‬2 K `(F ‫א א‬D  Qj‫א‬
‫א‬y‫ א‬F8 ¨ Œ =¬ ،2^2 ( ™  ?‹   :% 32 1( 2 2  ‫א‬
 ‫א‬Ë 32 ™%C‫א‬:%/ ‫(א‬, ‫(א‬$< ‫אא‬F $;‫›א‬$": ،sP

2008
54  ‫  א אא   א‬
‡a #1 +‫ א‬Ht ‫ Œ ¨ א  א‬2‫   א‬1+*  ($% _$< ‫ˆ א‬tP $—  ، :;‫א‬
 K"E‫א‬
 W1%($.2CW‡ag. "(Pt;‫א‬$;‫א‬k(!$% J7
`"R$ ‫—א‬32:،62v‫א‬MPt;"$;‫א‬k(!$%=a
32 =& = 6^ / k(!$ ‫א א‬tP 42 = [J K(2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫! א‬
(WE‫ א‬4;‫<ˆ א‬% 2  J ‫  א‬E7‫ " א‬F% ‫א‬F (7 ‫א & " א‬
)=(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬32MPt2& 6^ KE @2 W2004،84 ‫א‬3,DF
¨%=&%= ،©E‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬NF3(4 ‫א‬R$;"%
Z‫ Œא‬MPt;‫אא‬tl¨26P ‫(א‬F(Fy‫א‬kNx ‫ א‬0&DE‫א‬#(2R$;‫א‬
 KEfK0W–KX!P3"F
 WMF ‫א‬b((,%0 6+;‫א   א ! א‬1.\% J8
MF ‫* א‬D #% = 62Q-‫Ž א‬$ ‫ א‬. *    ‫ א‬#
HE 6$, ‫!(  = א‬$ ‫ א‬1FN‫א‬L (!% # P,%  2& ‫ א‬1 D 1†
(7$% ‡a H‚ MF ‫* א‬D b((,% =E ،G2 H7  6( RP
= 1($ ، C ‚,;‫ א‬b(  3\ ¡‫   א‬Y s % 3  1+ ¨ Œ #$2  ،1 *D
O(l‫א‬3Q\،!B2 "F+ _‫א‬:D326+;‫א‬1$! !&ƒ6^4%
•$MF *f,D=‫(א‬26+;‫"`א   א ! א‬$(7F ‫=א‬E،(!$ ‫א‬
MF ‫ א‬G‚2 .‫א‬% •$ `7 ‫ = "` א‬$ ‫א א‬tP _,2 .‫א‬%  ،   ‫ ^א‬a
 K+&;‫ˆא‬tP (`"2Zn<2Y“aPHt ‫א‬
N  M$% = 6\ F MF ‫“” !( א‬- 19‫\ א‬% = !*
H ‫ א‬CF  2P (2Qa ‫  א‬6+;‫ א    א ! א‬RL 32 ‫ א‬0Q-‫א‬
?$ ‫א‬hx،­2, ‫א &‚ א‬#hNF ‫אא‬y‫@אא‬a ،? ];‫א‬v‫א‬
1. C !$ ‫"`א‬Q4 ‫ "|א‬،MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬Ct% ‫!(א‬$ ‫א‬19"
32 ( H7 u  MF   6F(Fy‫ א‬018;" f ‫ א‬2 h1 MF%  B ‫א‬
 K(2R‫א‬P
 W6$29‫ ©א‬,;‫א‬#("n ‫˜א‬P2J(WAa J9
Ht ‫ א;&=א‬،Z‫א‬-‫ א‬h18 ‫ &=(א‬Ht ‫א‬o;‫א‬$%$29‫=א‬E‫א‬B+
`" MF ‫ א‬g <2 =¬ ،&8 ‫ א‬h1%‫א‬12 F4%  _< ‫ א‬CF ( <%

2008
55  ‫  א אא   א‬
 ‫אא‬F;‫*א‬Rtƒ( y‫(א‬$29‫˜א‬P;‫א‬B ‫א‬AaM7 MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
RQ /‫ א‬0‫א‬nD‫ א‬# C(.E‫ א‬6"%  ،Z‫  Œא‬MPt;‫א א‬tP Fu b†
3 32  RQ /‫( "  = א‬2Q-‫ א‬AD ‫ א‬La  (Pt;‫ א‬$ ‫א‬
(!$ ‫ א‬2‫< א‬+a  ،*n<;‫א א  א‬.a (s<% 3 Q\ ،=& ‫א‬
z" ،E129W2005،ÅW$FMP‫א‬t;‫*א‬32!h\% ‫*א‬n<;‫א‬
RQ /‫ _ א‬h18  =F;‫ א‬F8 ‫ א‬b% # :(*n ‫א  א‬y‫  א‬hP8 ‫ ” א‬
(!FL!$ ‫›א‬$"B+1. 32o $+W،^2‫˜א‬sD#•;‫א‬
 KMPt! (4$ ‫_א‬#\F
 WMF ‫א‬Fr"?g< ‫?א‬6 (!% J10
(!$ ‫ א‬2‫( א;‚†א  @אא א‬W% #F% = +(D ?‚;‫ א‬32
6P  ،f ‫ א‬2 cn‰ = =  F ‫ @  א‬E‫  א‬R^ ‫ א‬A[ ,‚;‫א‬
?(Fr ‫*א‬DhF%Aa n82‫א‬tP ،MF ‫א‬g <2hPE‫!(א‬$ ‫א‬
#F(!$ ‫= א‬F $+  K=(F ‫=א‬8Fr;‫ א‬A ‫א‬1"0F ‫א (א‬
W‫אא א‬tPr2=E،PY:$ h1%‫‚@אא‬K$G<ƒ\$ŽŒa#$2= 
. k  MF ‫ א‬#$2 h1  hP,( f ‫ א‬2  ‫א‬y‫(א א‬F ‫"` א‬
 K8 ];‫(א‬2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬hP8 ‫ א‬Zn<;‫(א‬$ ‫ א‬% ‫א א‬Ya ­2, ‫א‬
Qj‫ א‬Y — (+&2a  M4% © DnF2 Ã Cy‫ א‬$(7"
`" :(! ‫ א‬0  (2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "& א‬6++F ‫ א‬R‫א‬n/‫ א‬A \* (Pt;‫א‬
A ™3¨(P+،MF ‫א‬Fxts A! ,2!–‫ א‬h(B% ،1%
 ‫א‬DnF;‫א‬32P[J 4$ ;‫א‬4;‫א‬$.‫א‬2 k(F‹Aa ?(  ‫( א‬s<%
 K(F ,2ƒ1%N‫ א‬%=3&)
 Wd2
P. 0$ 2‫א‬l‫ א‬r;‫ א‬.‫א;א‬8W›$"0@+(D+Ž
‡a +G  ،(F(x ‫ א‬2$;‫ א‬12 (F ‫( א א‬+ n& -‫ א‬.‫  א;א‬QW
 @‫@!  א;א‬2 [J (+ n& a 8W 1+ ‡a ( * ? @2 ? ­74u ¨ Œ
84 ‫א(   א‬J( ‫  א‬n !* z ‫א א‬tP  A! $;‫( א‬+ n& -‫א‬
 K( ‫א;א‬
 (‫א‬J(("

2008
56  ‫  א אא   א‬
 Kh& ‫~=א‬F ‫א‬ J
F C. ‫ א‬hD‫א‬%  0Q  &2 ،_$ ‫= א‬,  ،2004 ،E 0&2 3" !' F ،B2 3"‫א‬ J
 K%(!& b$ ‫*א‬G،$, ‫א‬،E0 
،X, E‫ א‬$L ،H] ‫(­ א‬W E % = F ،E(Va 3" !' F ،H] ‫ א‬02-‫א‬ J
K&8 ‫אא‬،C7‫א‬
`" MF ‫( א‬s(%‫א‬na،2004 ،E Fr ‫  א‬0$ ‫"(  א‬n  (2Q-‫! א‬B;‫ א‬F &,(-‫א‬ J
Ki" ‫א‬،(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫א‬
W @2  (+ n& -‫א‬ ], ‫א‬ ! ‫א‬ Á J
 http://www.isesco.org.ma/pub/arabic/StratTakrib/P2.htm
 "<+،EE$(< ‫ א‬, ‫\א¼ א"`א‬A2FF،2007،E‘6FšD" J
W @2  5P 1428 =$G 14
 http://islameiat.com/cms10/php/vision/show1.php?aid=68
 @2<+،?`!,;‫"`א‬AD ‫ א‬MF ‫א*אא‬t2?،2007،E#\%26FG" J
 www.alwihda.com/taqreeb.phpW
   ،? (2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫ ? א‬،2005 ،Eˆ‫א‬Y G" &G F X!P 3"  J
K214 J211 J،50،=‫א‬17"MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF  6;$ ‫א! א‬،MF ‫א‬
P   &2 ،APF ‫א‬،3i ،W$;‫  א ! א‬62Q-‫& א‬8 ‫ א‬،1982 ،E !'F 61 ‫א‬ J
K Y ‫< א‬
(2Q-‫ א‬2E‫(˜ א‬,+ &<% 1$  " iF+ ? 2003 ،E =\2 ($ !'F ،6L ‫א‬ J
K2003o! 22–20،MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫א‬3 ‫;‚†א‬X2@@ ،?AD‫א א‬
،? ‫א‬P  !(P82 W MF ‫ ? א‬،5P 1426 J02005 ،E =!r 3" ::$ ‫  א‬F H¾ ‫א‬ J
K، 47  ،=‫א‬17" MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF   6;$ ‫ א! א‬،MF ‫   א‬
 K186 J157
 "<+،E$(< ‫ א‬, ‫"`א‬MF  Q2KKK?(w ‫?א‬FF،2003،E: $2FM(7j‫א‬ J
 W @22003" *28
http://www.islamonline.net/servlet/Satellite?c=ArticleA_C&cid=1173695057581&page
name=Zone-Arabic-Shariah%2FSRALayout
A\y‫&  א   א‬2 ،10 š ،Q ‫ א‬0Q [ ،E ‘ 3" !' F،KPt ‫  א‬J
K˜2‫א‬o ‫ א‬k,  M(7j‫א‬،=»!،1.5‫א‬W-‫א‬،E0 F،(2Q-‫א‬
K(+ ‫א‬4;‫א אא‬،APF ‫א‬،15i،MP‫א‬t2Q"0Qa،2003،E#8742F$&< ‫ א‬J
AD ‫ @\ א‬O(l 6,(% cr(2 J(4  (  A2 ? ،E H12 !' F 3 ‫ א‬bÊ J
3 ‫ א <© ;!& א‬b @2  <+ ،? MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫(  א‬2Q-‫א‬
 http://www.shura.gov.bh/default.asp?action=article&id=519W

2008
57  ‫  א אא   א‬
6;$ ‫ א! א‬،MF ‫    א‬،? MF ‫א ½ א‬7 ? ،E 8$. (, ‫ א‬F H(1G  J
 K55 J50K،1،=‫א‬17"MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF 
25  " <+ ،?`!,;‫_ "` א‬F ‫˜ א‬1+  H. o ‫ א‬02-‫ ?א‬،2004 ،E 3,D F 84 ‫א‬ J
 http://www.saffar.org/?act=artc&id=842W @22004o!+
6;$ ‫ א! א‬،MF ‫     א‬،?MF ‫ א‬Fx Ga ? ،2005 ،E$ F ÅW  J
 K132 J115K،51،=‫א‬17"MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF 
 ‫<א ! א‬2 ،APF ‫ א‬،1i ،PYE‫<(] א‬2 ،1978 ،E 6 F h(B$ ‫  א‬ J
 K(2Q-‫א‬
 !‫א‬،MF ‫ א‬،?MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF ‫?א‬،5P1423 J2002،E!'FA! J
 K296 J285K،36،=‫א‬17"MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF  6;$ ‫א‬
 J4 J26 "<+،?h$ ‫א‬P   ‫ א‬،MP‫א‬t;‫א‬MF%?،2006،E6+PF€ J
 W @22006
http://www.islamonline.net/arabic/contemporary/2006/04/article04.shtml
،1i ،(2Q-‫ א‬MP‫א‬t;‫ "` א‬MF ‫א  א‬y‫’  א‬2 ،2006 ،E ? F،H ™F ‫ א‬ J
 KP  &2،APF ‫א‬
 J28 "<+،?(2Q-‫א‬MP‫א‬t;‫"`א‬MF  ’2?W 2003،E?FH ™F ‫ א‬ J
: @22003 J10
http://www.islamonline.net/Arabic/contemporary/2003/10/article01.shtml
 K(L‫א‬،  ‫א‬،6i،$(< ‫ א‬, ‫"`א‬MF ‫ א‬,2،5P1420،EW+FH8F ‫ א‬J
b‫ א‬،APF ‫ א‬،kNx  % WMF ‫ א‬A ،1991 E 6F% !' ¼‫  א‬F ،6!F ‫  א‬J
K(2Q-‫ <‚ =א‬#E‫א‬
 K Y ‫ א < א‬7 0Q, ‫אא‬،Hx& ‫א‬/F2،1998،EP‫א‬YF،Hx& ‫ א‬J
 J11 "<+،??(Pt;‫‡?א‬a?(+(" ‫?א‬32b +"?،2007،E[VF€@2 J
W @22007 J4
http://www.alwihdah.com/view.php?cat=1&id=1768
 Kry‫ א=א‬E‫א‬$72،3i،C $262QaMPt2(d"E‫א‬،1988،E6S6F!$2 J
 
 

2008
58  ‫  א אא   א‬

You might also like