1

A Critique of Kapic's "A Little Book for New Theologians"

Student’s Name

Institutional Affiliation

Course Name and Number

Instructor’s Name

Date
 2

A Critique of Kapic's "A Little Book for New Theologians"

Kelly M. Kapic provides a concise and approachable manual for aspiring theologians in

"A Little Book for New Theologians," focusing on the significance of humility and spiritual

development in theological endeavors. The main argument of Kapic is as follows: A modest,

spiritually-based existence should not be separated from theological knowledge and thought;

instead, they should be deeply interconnected (Kapic, 2012). This book appeals to aspiring

theologians to approach their studies with reverence, humility, and devotion to God,

understanding that studying theology is more than just an intellectual endeavor but also a way to

strengthen one's connection to the Divine.

I identify with Kapic's appeal for humility in theological endeavors as a reader with

experience in theology and ministry. One of the book's principles is the propensity for people,

particularly those beginning their theological studies, to become haughty and cerebral without

the necessary spiritual progress, which I have seen in my life and career. I have encountered

many theologians and students who can articulately discuss theological issues but don't seem to

have a meaningful, life-changing connection with God (Chung, 2021). Kapic's focus on the value

of humility and spiritual development is an essential reminder that the study of theology is not a

goal in and of itself but rather a means to a more excellent knowledge of and relationship with

the divine (Kapic, 2012).

Spiritual breathing is one of Kapic's most inspiring concepts. He advises readers to strike

a balance between theological intake and exhalation. Kapic believes that theological study

should not only gather information but also lead to worship, prayer, and a changed life. This idea

encouraged me to think about my approach to theology and how to better incorporate it into my

life and ministry (Kapic, 2012). This realization has significantly changed how I approach my
 3

theological studies and instruct others in theology. Furthermore, I related to Kapic's presentation

of the theological qualities of love, hope, and faith. He adds that these qualities should be

developed alongside intellectual knowledge since they are necessary for every theologian. This

made me realize how important it is for my ministry to nurture love, hope, and faith and teach

theological truths. By fusing theological ideas and personal tales that highlight the

transformational potential of these virtues, Kapic successfully justifies his position (Petrovich,

2023).

But there are several things Kapic says that I can't entirely agree with. He says, among

other things, "Being right is overrated." I agree with his point that intellectual pride may result

from the arrogant pursuit of accuracy, but it is crucial to pursue theological truth. Since theology

deals with timeless and transcendent issues, it is essential to pursue truth and knowledge (Chung,

2021). Instead of compromising on the value of being correct, I argue that theological humility

should be the prism through which we search for truth. Furthermore, Kapic's criticism of

theology as a field of study can be perceived as too harsh. Although the academic approach to

theology has drawbacks, serious intellectual engagement also offers advantages. It may

encourage analytical accuracy, critical thinking, and a more subtle grasp of intricate theological

matters (Chung, 2021). Although insightful, Kapic's viewpoint can be one-sided because it

prefers spirituality above intellectual rigor.

Despite these differences, Kapic's work had a profound effect on me. I want to apply his

idea of spiritual breathing to my life and service. To preserve a balance between theological

study and spiritual practice, I shall thus make an effort. This strategy will assist me in avoiding

the pitfall of becoming an academic theologian without strengthening my spiritual life. In my

teaching and practice of theology, I will also be more deliberate in encouraging the theological
 4

virtues of faith, hope, and love. These qualities serve as the cornerstone of a dynamic and

revolutionary theology that reaches the mind, heart, and soul.

In conclusion, "A Little Book for New Theologians" by Kelly M. Kapic presents an

insightful viewpoint on the fusion of theology and spirituality. His appeal to humility, spiritual

development, and a fair attitude to the study of theology serves as a reminder that theology

should eventually result in a closer relationship with God. The book's insights have motivated me

to review and enhance my theological path and the way I approach ministry, even if I may have

some qualms about some of its assertions. In addition to serving as a valuable resource for

aspiring theologians, Kapic's book also serves as a timely reminder for more experienced

theologians to maintain their hearts and brains in harmony in their search for ultimate truth.
 5

References

Chung, E. J. (2021). The God Who Gives: How the Trinity Shapes the Christian Story, by Kelly

M. Kapic with Justin Borger. Evangelical Quarterly, 92(1), 89–91.

Kapic, K. M. (2012). A Little Book for New Theologians. InterVarsity Press.

Petrovich, C. G. (2023). Writing an Amish Theology. The Journal of Religion, 103(3), 365–378.