Professional Documents
Culture Documents
A Research Plan
Gracelle G. Lucero
Cristina P. Guntiñas
Adviser
1
Table of Contents
Title Page 1
Table of Contents 2
Rationale 4
Procedures 11
Data Analysis 17
Bibliography 21
2
List Figures and Tables
Assignment of Concentrations
3
Rationale
Mosquitoes are thin, long-legged, two-winged insects and are typically six to 12
millimeters in length. Both males and females have antennae and an elongated "beak" or
proboscis three to four times longer than its head. These insects belong to the Diptera order,
known as the true flies, in the family Culicidae. All true flies have two wings; however,
mosquitoes are the only true flies to have scaled wings. Their way of breeding is by laying their
eggs on the surface of fresh or stagnant water. Eggs can be laid anywhere that water remains
stagnant — in cans, discarded tires, bird baths, ditches or puddles, although mosquitoes prefer
water surfaces protected from wind. It doesn’t take a lot of water as some mosquitoes can breed
in as little as one centimeter of standing water. Culex mosquitoes usually lay their eggs at night,
and they stick together due to a special sculpture on the sides of the eggs that form a raft
approximately 64 millimeters long and 38 millimeters wide. The raft can contain anywhere from
100 to 300 eggs and looks like a flake of soot floating on the water surface. Anopheles species
lay their eggs singly on the water surface. Aedes mosquitoes also lay their eggs singly, and most
species select damp soil. Aedes eggs are more resistant to drying out than those of other genera
and some require low temperatures before the eggs will hatch. Others hatch only when flooded
with water above a critical temperature. Certain mosquitoes can carry and spread disease-causing
bacteria. These organisms (disease pathogens) are frequently viruses that are caught or "picked
up" by the mosquito when it bites (feeds on) an affected host. Domestic and wild animals, as
well as humans, serve as hosts. The virus grows and replicates within the mosquito. When an
infected mosquito bites another, uninfected host, the virus is transmitted through its saliva. The
mosquito works as a "vector" of the sickness by transmitting the virus (Stephen Higgs, 2005).
4
For hundreds of years, mosquitoes have been recognized as the essential arthropod
vectors for the spread of pathogens that kill millions of people worldwide each year. Some of the
infectious diseases spread by mosquito bites includes the West Nile virus, yellow fever, dengue
fever, filarial, and malaria, which can eventually prove fatal to people (Sharma, 2001). Malaria
was estimated to have caused 216 million infections and 4, 45,000 deaths worldwide in 2016.
Furthermore, 100 million people in Africa and Southeast Asia suffer dengue fever each year and
predicts that 1 billion people worldwide will be at risk of catching the disease in the next 50
years. Bangladesh is especially vulnerable to dengue outbreaks due to high temperatures and
humidity, which are mostly caused by rising urbanization and inconsistent seasonal rain. Acute
dengue symptoms include fever, muscle pains, headaches, and a rash (WHO, 2020).
The World Health Organization estimates that more than 2.5 billion people live in
dengue- endemic areas, which contribute significantly to an estimated yearly death toll of 25,
000.
In the Philippines the most common disease caused by mosquitoes is Dengue. This
disease is epidemic in the Philippines and considered one of its eight pervasive infectious
diseases. From 2008 to 2012, the Philippines' Department of Health (DOH) reported 585,324
dengue cases, with a case fatality rate (CFR) of 0.55% or 3,195 deaths. Among the 10
Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), the Philippines ranks fourth in the number of
dengue cases. Four dengue virus (DENV; Flavivirus) serotypes are circulating in the
Philippines8, transmitted by Aedes aegypti L. and Ae. albopictus Skuse (Diptera: Culicidae).
increasing population, inadequate public health infrastructure, poor solid waste management, and
lack of an effective mosquito surveillance system contribute to the growing dengue challenge.
5
Different localities in the country recognize the threats brought about by these diseases
and consider different strategies in looking after the welfare of the general population. The risk
of being bitten by mosquitoes among children is very high, especially that mosquitoes can thrive
abundantly in environments if artificial containers can act as their breeding habitats. Children in
schools are recognized as important vulnerable groups in the Philippines, as their burden of
mosquito-borne diseases is great as they may be hospitalized, suffer long-term disabilities, incur
foregone opportunities by missing out in school, and, in worse conditions, even die. There is a
need to monitor the occurrence of mosquito vectors in places where children meet and
congregate and to institute vector surveillance strategies so that appropriate preventive and
control measures may be put in place to protect the children’s public health and welfare (Mistica,
When compared to the same period last year, the Department of Health (DOH) in region
7 observed a 118 percent rise in dengue cases this year. The Department of Health previously
proclaimed a nationwide dengue epidemic in response to the 146,062 dengue cases documented
between January and July 20 of this year, which is 98 percent more than the cases recorded
Such disease outbreaks impose a social and economic cost while obstructing economic
growth through several channels, including quality of life, absenteeism, incapacity to work, loss
of labor productivity, premature mortality, loss of savings, and medical costs, all of which result
in additional economic burden, that is, costs directly or indirectly related to disease diagnosis,
Managing the rising number of illnesses caused by mosquitoes entails controlling the
mosquito population. Larvicide products can be used to control the number of mosquitoes. For
6
decades, interest in developing natural, environmentally friendly larvicides has significantly
increased. Synthetic larvicide poses many risks to humans, the environment, and other livestock.
In this study, the researchers want to develop an effective organic larvicide out of
Lemongrass (Cymbopogon citratus), Garlic (Allium Sativum), and Papaya (Carica papaya):
Lemongrass (C. citratus) has known for its toxic effect on mosquito larvae. This effect relates to
the citronella chemical compound inside the stalk and leaves, which reaches 35% and becomes
the densest chemical compound inside lemongrass. Citronella affects the mosquito through direct
contact. The mosquito in contact with citronella would lose its body fluid and die. C. citratus has
no effect on first instar larvae but did inhibit growth and increase mortality in A. aegypti’s later
developmental stages. In this study, lemongrass leaves were extracted using methanol. The
extracts were tested against fourth instar A. aegypti larvae to observe its larvicide effect.
Garlic is thought to be played by Allicin, and Diallyl disulfide has bactericidal and
bacteriostatic properties. Allicin works by interfering with the synthesis of parasite cell
membranes so the parasites cannot grow further. Allicin is also toxic to the parasite and bacterial
cells. The oil content in the garlic solution may change the surface tension of the water so that
the larvae have difficulty taking oxygen from the water surface. This is thought to cause the
larvae not to get enough oxygen to grow, leading to larval death. (Rahmah, Ashari, Suryadi,
Chairani, 2019)
Based on a study conducted (Malathi & Vasugi, 2015), Carica papaya is claimed to have
mosquito larvicidal and repellant properties against the mosquito Aedes aegypti. The
composition of Carica papaya that is responsible for repelling insects, particularly mosquitoes,
is the alkaloid
7
content, which contains carpaine. This substance harms and attacks the neurological system of
The utilization of Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya as homemade larvicides offers several
advantages. Compared to synthetic chemicals, they have lower costs, are simpler to use, and
offer less environmental dangers. Additionally, by using these common substances, communities
that have little access to commercial larvicides can apply easy and long-lasting techniques to
lower mosquito populations and the dangers of disease transmission. By investigating the
larvicidal efficacy of lemongrass, garlic, and papaya leaf, this research addresses the need for
The findings of this study will assist in the development of homemade larvicide that can
be easily adopted by communities for effective mosquito population management. The study's
ultimate purpose is to advance sustainable and practical techniques for preventing mosquito-
borne diseases by providing informative information on the potential use of ordinary household
This output to be generated in this study would be extremely beneficial in reducing the
rising population of mosquitoes in Barangay Esperanza, Poro, Cebu. This study is also
advantageous to local farmers because lemongrass, garlic and papaya may be cultivated in our
domestic fields, in which the government and the non-government agencies might provide with
financial assistance.
Due to the continues neglect of people in managing areas where mosquito larvae are
rampant, the growing number of mosquitoes caused a lot of diseases, including dengue. This
study seeks to examine the effectivity of a product made through the extracts of lemongrass,
papaya
8
leaves and garlic which could serve as a useful tool to diminish the larvae which in extent lessens
Research Questions:
1. How long will each concentration (2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and 100%) make lethal
2. What is the mortality rate of larvae of each experimental setup after the application of
the six larvicide solutions with the concentration of 2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and
100%?
3. Which among the six concentrations of natural mosquito (Culicidae) larvicide solutions
made from botanical extracts such as lemongrass (Cymbopogon citratus), garlic (Allium
sativum) and papaya (Carica papaya) can kill the greatest number of mosquito larvae in
This study’s ultimate goal is to improve sustainable and practical strategies for mosquito-
borne disease prevention by giving instructive information on the possible use of common
Null hypothesis: The concentrations of the extracts administered to the larvae had no
Alternative Hypothesis: The concentration of extract applied has the potential power of
9
Materials Used/ Preparation
As this study involves experimentation on the application of the six concentrations of the
prepared natural larvicide solutions to come up with a concentration that would best kill a
mosquito larva, this study requires different laboratory tools and other materials and resources to
MATERIALS USAGE
NEEDED
Ladle Used in putting the larvae samples in the container from the dipper.
Petri dish Used in storing the larvae samples during the experiment.
Mortar & Pestle Used in crushing the ingredients into the ideal consistency of the extracts
Gloves Used in protecting your hands from directly touching the ingredients.
Thin cloth Used in squeezing out the extracts from crushed ingredients.
Graduated cylinder Used in measuring the solute and solvent in coming up with the right
10
The table below presents the variables of the study which include the independent
variable that is the application of the different concentrations of the natural larvicide solution
made from the extracts of lemongrass, garlic and fruit-bearing papaya leaf. While the lethal
effects or the number of larvae died in each experimental setup (A, B, C, D, E, F) after the
application of the different concentrations (2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%,50% and 100%) of larvicide
Study
Garlic (Allium Sativum) different concentrations (2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and
Papaya Leaves (Carica papaya) 100%) of the natural larvicide in caryring out of the
study.
Procedures
The following are the procedures to be undertaken in conducting the study. It involves
three stages of the development and operation that the researchers must achieve. This specifically
entails the flow of the study and the things that must be carried out. The table presents the stages
to be implemented.
11
Stage 1
2. Observation on ethical considerations (Seeking approval from the Barangay LGU and
4. Formulation of six concentrated solutions from the ingredients of the study. (Setup A:
Stage 2
3. Collection of Data
Stage 3
12
Larvicidal Assay
The following are to be undertaken in producing organic pesticide with the use of
Lemongrass (Cymbopogon Citratus), Garlic (Allium Sativum) and Papaya leaves (Carica papaya
L.). The three variables are to be chopped and crushed separately and the researchers will prepare
six concentrated solutions from the ingredients that is present in the study.
The following are the concentrated solutions that will be extracted from Lemongrass
(Cymbopogon Citratus), Garlic (Allium Sativum) and Papaya leaves (Carica papaya L.).
Setup A (2.5% concentration): 2.5ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya
Setup B (5% concentration): 5ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya leaves
Setup C (10% concentration): 10ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya
Setup D (25% concentration): 15ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya
Setup E (50% concentration): 20ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya
Setup F (100% concentration): 25ml of each extract; Lemongrass, Garlic, and Papaya
13
In the making of the organic larvicide, the researchers will prepare the ingredients needed
and the materials to be use. First, the 35 leaves of lemongrass will be rinsed off with great
caution. Next, it should be rinsed off again to ensure that there’s no dirt or grime left. Then, with
the use of knife, it should be chopped into fine pieces. After, the researchers will use mortar and
pestle to crush the lemongrass. To get its extract, the researchers will now put 15 tablespoons of
water to get the desired consistency. After, the process of extraction using a thin cloth will now
proceed, it will then be put into the six beakers with the proper measurements of its solutions
(Setup A: 2.5ml of lemongrass extract, Setup B: 5ml of lemongrass extract, Setup C: 10ml of
lemongrass extract, Setup D: 15ml of lemongrass extract, Setup E: 20ml of lemongrass extract,
The next ingredient in the study is the garlic. The researchers will prepare 7 bulbs of
garlic. Using a knife and a cutting board, the garlic cloves must be chopped into small pieces.
After it is chopped, it will be crushed using mortar and pestle. After it is crushed, the researchers
will now add 15 tablespoons of water to effectively get its extract. Using a thin cloth, it will be
extracted, and the extracts will then be put and divided into the six beaker with different
measurements (Setup A: 2.5ml of garlic extract, Setup B: 5ml of garlic extract, Setup C: 10ml of
garlic extract, Setup D: 15ml of garlic extract, Setup E: 20ml of garlic extract, Setup F: 25ml of
The last ingredient in the study is the papaya leaves. The papaya leaves need to be freshly
picked from a fruit bearing papaya tree. The exact amount of papaya leaves is 3. After it is
picked, it will now be chopped using a knife and a cutting board. After we get the smallest pieces
it can get after being chopped, the researchers will now use mortar and pestle to crush the small
pieces of papaya leaves. The addition of 15 tablespoons of water will let the papaya leaves
14
to be
15
effectively extracted. The extracts will now be put into the six beakers with its different
measurements (Setup A: 2.5ml of papaya leaves extract, Setup B: 5ml of papaya leaves extract,
Setup C: 10ml of papaya leaves extract, Setup D: 15ml of papaya leaves extract, Setup E: 20ml
of papaya leaves extract, Setup F: 25ml of papaya leaves extract) combining with the lemongrass
In addition to the concentrated solutions, different measurements of water will be put into
the six different beakers (Setup A: 67ml of water, Setup B: 60ml of water, Setup C: 45ml of
water, Setup D: 30ml of water, Setup E: 15ml of water, Setup F: 0ml of water) to test the lethal
The following will be the detailed steps in collecting the larvae samples in the different
experimental setups in conducting the study. The larvae samples will be collected near Luciano
B. Rama Sr. Memorial National High School in Barangay Esperanza, Poro, Cebu and it will be
The number of larvae samples that will be collected from road swales near the school is
60 larvae in total. The collection of the larvae utilizes ladle and dipper to carefully place the
larvae samples in the container to be experimented. The researchers will transfer the larvae
samples into the six petri dishes. Each petri dish will contain 10 larvae samples to accomplish the
experiment.
After distributing the larvae samples into the six petri dishes, the application of six
concentrations will take part, conducting the study. The researchers will apply the measured
16
concentration, Setup D: 25% concentration, Setup E: 50% concentration, Setup F: 100%
concentration) by pouring each solution into their respective petri dish. Thus, conducting the
study.
The following are the identified risks that has the potential to occur in the study. Since the
entire study involves biological and environmental elements, risks are inevitable, and the study
needs to be carried out without any serious casualties. The following are the possible risks and
the safety precautions to prevent any serious damage and danger within the study.
Biohazard potential risks: The study primarily involves around the experimentation of
the ingredients that will be applied to the larvae samples. Thus, the contamination of the water
where the larvae reside can affect human health in the collection of the larvae samples. It is
highly recommended that the student-researchers take extra care in the collection of the larvae
Chemical potential risks: In the formulation of the larvicide solutions, the ingredients
identified in the study can potentially harm the human skin due to the chemical components in
the ingredients. The student-researchers will wear safety attire like goggles and hand gloves to
avoid the risk of chemical hazard during and after the experimentation.
Utilization of Materials: The materials identified in the study can potentially harm the
researchers in conducting the study. This may involve in the chopping and crushing process of
the ingredients while conducting the study. The researchers will be oriented with the safety
measures on the conduct of the study to prevent harm as the experiment goes on.
17
Data Analysis
This study utilizes tables and graphs to present, analyze, and interpret the data collected
after the experimentation of the study. The tables below emphasize the elements and the proper
A 10 2.5%
B 10 5%
C 10 10%
D 10 25%
E 10 50%
F 10 100%
Table 3 above will be use as a guide in the distribution of larvae and desired
concentrations for each setup. The table shows the exact concentration for each experimental
setups and the number of larvae samples that will coincide with the distribution of each
18
Table 4: Observation of Mosquito Larvae after the Application of Natural Larvicide
Table 4 above will be used in the observation of the mosquito larvae after the application
of natural larvicide. This study observes and records the number of dead and alive mosquito
larvae. This table will also serve as a guide on the length of time that the larvicide’s
There will be five series of observations done to ensure the validity and reliability of the
result. This study compares the five series of observations to attain the most potent outcome of
this study. After the observations of this table, this study will acquire the most potent outcome by
getting the total population of dead mosquito larvae. This specifically answers the research
question number one, which is “How long will each concentration (2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%, 50%
and 100%) make lethal effect on the collected larvae in each experimental setup?”
19
Table 5: Mortality Data of Mosquitos Larvae in each setup
Table 5 above will be used in presenting the mortality data of the mosquito larvae in each
setup. This table will utilize the total number of larvae that died taken from Table 4: Observation
of Mosquito Larvae after the Application of Natural Larvicide and calculate the percentage by
dividing the of the number of dead mosquito larvae to the total population per setup multiplied to
100 after the application of the natural larvicide. This table will help in determining the most
effective concentration in the study. This will serve as the basis in assessing the effectiveness of
This study will further assess the total number of dead mosquito larvae in the study by
attaining the most effective concentration among the six experimental setups and the length of
time it will be observed in getting the maximum number of total mosquito larvae death in the
experimentation.
11
0
To answer the research question number two, which is the “What is the mortality rate of
larvae of each experimental setup after the application of the six larvicide solutions with the
concentration of 2.5%, 5%, 10%, 25%, 50% and 100%?” this study will first assess the mortality
After assessing the data, this study will now provide the mortality rate of the outcome of
each experimental setup by getting the percentage of the total population of dead larvae. This
will further serve as basis in identifying and answering the research question three, which is the
“Which among the six concentrations of natural mosquito Culicidae larvicide solutions made
from botanical extracts such as lemongrass Cymbopogon citratus, garlic Allium sativum and
papaya Carica papaya can kill the greatest number of mosquito larvae in the shortest period of
time?”
20
Bibliography
Baldacchino, F., Tramut, C., Salem, A., Liénard, E., Delétré, E., Franc, M., Martin, T.,
Duvallet, G., & Jay‐Robert, P. (2013, January 1). The repellency of lemongrass oil
against stable flies, tested using video tracking. Parasite; EDP Sciences.
https://www.cdc.gov/mosquitoes/ mosquito-bites/symptoms.html
DOH7: Dengue cases up by 118% in CV - Philippines. (2019, August 19).
ReliefWeb. https://reliefweb.int/report/philippines/doh7-dengue-cases-118-cv
Ghosh, A. (2012, May 1). Plant extracts as potential mosquito larvicides. PubMed Central
(PMC). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3401688/
Ilham, R., Lelo, A., Harahap, U., Widyawati, T., & Siahaan, L. (2019, October 14). The
Effectivity of Ethanolic Extract from Papaya Leaves (Carica papaya L.) as an Alternative
Larvacide to Aedes spp. Open Access Macedonian Journal of Medical Sciences; ID Design
2012/DOOEL Skopje. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6980815/
Islam, M., Haider, M. Z., & Halim, S. F. B. (2020, November 12). Health hazard of using
mosquito repellent in Khulna city, Bangladesh. Journal of Economics and Development;
Emerald Publishing Limited.
https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/JED- 05-2020-
0067/full/html#:~:text=Mosquitoes%20transmit%20several%20infectious%20diseases,hu mans
%20(Sharma%2C%202001
Life Cycle: Mosquito Biology 101. (2023, April 25). Vector Disease Control
International. https://www.vdci.net/mosquito-biology-101-life-cycle/
Marks, R. (2023, March 1). https://actascientific.com/ASOR/pdf/ASOR-06-0704.pdf. Acta
Scientific Orthopaedics, 6(3), 126–133.
https://www.dipterajournal.com/vol2issue3/pdf/2- 2-33.1.pdf
Mistica, M. S., Ocampo, V. R., De Las Llagas, L. A., Bertuso, A. G., Alzona, F. D., & Magsino,
E. A. (2019, August 30). A Survey of Mosquito Species in Public Schools of Metro
Manila, Philippines Using Ovitraps as Surveillance Tool. Acta Medica Philippina;
University of the Philippines Manila.
https://actamedicaphilippina.upm.edu.ph/index.php/acta/article/view/40
Mosquitoes Bite Symptoms and Treatment | CDC. (2023, May 24). Centers for Disease Control
and Prevention. https://www.cdc.gov/mosquitoes/mosquito-bites/symptoms.html
Pabjan, T. (2022, October 31). Realizm naukowy a hipoteza ciemnej materii i ciemnej energii.
Filozofia Nauki, 30(3), 51–69. https://oamjms.eu/index.php/mjms/
article/view/6727
Plata‐Rueda, A., Martínez, L. C., Santos, M. H. D., Wilcken, C. F., Soares, M. A., Serrão, J. D.,
& Zanúncio, J. C. (2017, April 20). Insecticidal activity of garlic essential oil and their
constituents against the mealworm beetle, Tenebrio molitor Linnaeus (Coleoptera:
21
Tenebrionidae). Scientific Reports; Nature Portfolio. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/
pmc/articles/PMC5397855/
Rahmah, S., Ashari, A., Suryadi, E., & Chairani, M. (2019). Garlic (Allium sativum) As Natural
Larvacides For Aedes Aegypti Larvae. Proceedings of the Proceedings of the 3rd
International Conference on Environmental Risks and Public Health, ICER-PH 2018, 26-
27, October 2018, Makassar, Indonesia.https://eudl.eu/pdf/10.4108/eai.26-10-
2018.2288708
Stephen Higgs. Vector-Borne and Zoonotic Diseases. June 1, 2005, 5(2): 93-94.
doi:10.1089/vbz.2005.5.93https://www.hww.ca/assets/pdfs/factsheets/mosquito-en.pdf
Vector-borne diseases. (2020, March).
https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/vector- borne-diseases.
22