Introduction Persuasion is the art of convincing others to give favorable attention to our point of view.
Persuaders want to influence how listeners believe
or act on issues they care about. In order to do this, they must offer sufficient reasons to accept their advice. Characteristics Informative Speaking Persuasive Speaking
1. Reveal and clarify options 1. Urge a choice from among them
2. Provide sound information to enlighten 2. To justify their recommendation
3. Less audience commitment 3. More commitment
4. Less leadership 4. More leadership required
5. Appeal to feeling is less important 5. More important
6. Ethical obligation is less great 6. Greater
Process of persuasion William J. McGuire, Professor of Psychology at Yale University suggests up to 12 phases are involved in effective persuasion.
These phases may be grouped into 5 stages:
Awareness > Understanding > Agreement > Enactment > Integration Process of persuasion • Awareness: often called as consciousness-raising. It includes knowing about a problem, paying attention to it, and understanding how it affects our Lives directly. • Understanding: audience must be moved by the ideas the speaker provide. You can use examples, Narratives or facts/figures. Process of persuasion • Agreement: depends on listeners accepting recommendations and remembering their reasons for that acceptance. Agreement can range from small concessions to total acceptance. • Enactment: moves listeners beyond agreement to action. Try to give them an active way to express their agreement, reinforce their commitment; for example, signing a petition, raise their hands, or voice agreement. Process of persuasion
• Integration: promoting the integration of new
attitudes and commitments into enduring patterns of audiences’ beliefs and values. Challenges of Persuasion 1. Enticing a reluctant audience to listen: When attitudes and beliefs are important to your listeners, they are especially hard to change.
One way to handle this is to adopt a co-active approach, which
seeks to bridge the differences between the speaker and the listeners.
The speaker should not be involved in great expectation
fallacy because he/she may experience boomerang effect. He/she may aim at getting sleeper effect. Co-active approach ✓ Establish identification and goodwill ✓ Start with areas of agreement before tackling areas of disagreement ✓ Emphasize explanation more than argument at the outset ✓ Use ‘borrowed ethos’ ✓ Set modest goals for change ✓ Offer a multisided presentation in which the speaker compares his/her position with others to show the superiority of his/her idea Challenges of persuasion 2. Removing barriers to commitment: Listeners may hesitate to commit because they lack important information, or they may not see the connection between their own values and the proposal, or they may not feel certain they can trust what the speaker says. To solve this, the speaker should: a) Provide needed information b) Affirm and apply values c) Strengthen the credibility Challenges of persuasion 3. Moving from attitude to action: They may feel that the problem does not affect them personally, or they may not know specifically what it is they should do; therefore, they may not be ready for any action. To move people to action, the speaker must present powerful reasons to act. Things to do:- (continued to next slide/s) Challenges of persuasion a) Revitalize shared beliefs: for common beliefs b) Demonstrate the need for involvement c) Present a clear plan of action: stress that “we can do it, and this is how we will do it.” The plan must show what has to be done, who must do it, and how to proceed. Try to anticipate and refute excuses listeners might offer. d) Make it easy to comply Designs • Categorical • Comparison/Contrast: why your proposal is superior to another • Sequential: clear plan of action • Problem-Solution: present a problem, it’s effect and then it’s solution • Refutative: must answer strong opposition on a topic before you can establish your position. The major opposing claims become main points for development. • Motivated Sequence Motivated Sequence • Advocated by Allan Monroe from Purdue University The steps are: ➢ Arouse attention: stimulate interest ➢ Demonstrate a need: show the urgency of the situation ➢ Satisfy the need: set forth a plan of action. To offer agreement, provide examples, narratives, facts/figures ➢ Visualize the result: show how the change will effect/affect ➢ Call for action: may be a challenge, an appeal, or a statement of personal commitment. It should be short and to the point.