1|Page

Acknowledgments

I would like to express my deepest gratitude to all those who have supported me
in the completion of this English literature research project.

First and foremost, I would like to thank my supervisor, Dr. Harsha Sharma
ma’am for their guidance and invaluable feedback throughout the research
process. Their expertise and insights have been crucial in shaping the direction
and scope of this project.

Furthermore, I am grateful to my fellow mate who generously gave their time

and shared their perspectives for this study. Their insights have been essential in
providing a rich and advanced understanding of the topic at hand.

I would like to acknowledge the contributions of my family and friends, who

have offered unwavering support and encouragement throughout my academic
journey. Their love and encouragement have been a constant source of
motivation and inspiration.

Lastly, I would like to thank the authors whose works were central to this
research project. Their contributions to the field of English literature have
provided a foundation for this study and have enriched my understanding of the
subject matter.

In sum, I am deeply indebted to all those who have supported me in completing

this research project. Their contributions have been essential in making this
project a reality.

2|Page
 Preface

Philosophy has been a subject of interest and study for centuries. Ancient
philosophers such as Aristotle and Plato have contributed significantly to the
field of philosophy and have had a profound impact on the Western intellectual
tradition. Their ideas and theories have influenced many areas of study,
including politics, ethics, metaphysics, and epistemology.

This research project aims to compare and contrast the philosophical ideas of
Aristotle and Plato, two of the most prominent ancient Greek philosophers. The
study will analyze their similarities and differences in terms of their views on
various philosophical concepts, such as knowledge, reality, ethics, politics, and
the human soul.

The research will begin with an introduction to the historical and cultural
context of ancient Greece, which played a significant role in shaping the ideas
of these two philosophers. It will then provide an in-depth analysis of Aristotle's
and Plato's philosophical ideas, highlighting their contributions to the field of
philosophy and their relevance in today's society.

The study will use primary sources, including the works of Aristotle and Plato,
as well as secondary sources such as scholarly articles and books, to provide a
comprehensive analysis of their ideas. The research will also consider the
critiques of their ideas by other philosophers and scholars.

This research project is intended to contribute to the body of knowledge on the

topic of Aristotle and Plato's philosophy, as well as to provide a platform for
further research in this field. It is hoped that this study will shed light on the
ongoing debate between the followers of these two philosophers and provide a

3|Page
deeper understanding of their ideas and their significance in the history of
philosophy.

Finally, I would like to acknowledge the contributions of my advisors and

colleagues, whose guidance and support have been invaluable in the completion
of this research project.

4|Page
 CERTIFICATE OF SUPERVISION

This is to certify that Mritunjay Singh has completed the research project titled
"Comparison of Aristotle and Plato" under my supervision. The project was
conducted as a requirement for the English literature course at J.L.N Degree
College.

Throughout the duration of the project, Mritunjay Singh demonstrated a high

level of dedication, academic curiosity, and critical thinking. The research
project was well-structured, and the student exhibited excellent research skills,
including the ability to identify and analyze relevant literature, as well as
synthesize ideas and arguments.

The project focused on the comparison of two of the most prominent

philosophers in history, Aristotle and Plato, to identify and evaluate the
similarities and differences in their philosophical ideas and approaches.
Mritunjay Singh employed a range of qualitative research methods, including an
extensive literature review and in-depth analysis of primary sources, to explore
the research questions.

In light of the above, it is with great pleasure that I recommend Mritunjay Singh
for the successful completion of the research project. I do not doubt that
Mritunjay’s work will make a significant contribution to the field of English
literature and beyond.

Dr. Harsha Sharma

[J.L.N Degree College]

5|Page
 Student's Declaration

I, Mritunjay Singh declare that this English literature research project on the
topic "Comparison of Aristotle and Plato" is my original work. This project was
conducted under the guidance of my supervisor, Dr. Harsha Sharma, and was
carried out during my studies at J.L.N Degree College Etah.

The purpose of this project is to explore the similarities and differences between
the philosophical theories of Aristotle and Plato. The research was conducted by
consulting various primary and secondary sources, including books, articles,
and academic journals. All sources have been appropriately cited and referenced
throughout the project.

I attest that this project has not been submitted in whole or in part for any other
assessment or degree. The content of this project is solely my work, and I take
full responsibility for any errors or omissions.

I acknowledge that the research conducted adheres to the ethical principles of

academic research, and all necessary ethical considerations have been taken into
account. All participants in the research have been treated with respect and
confidentiality.

I also acknowledge that I have read and understood the guidelines for academic
integrity and plagiarism provided by my institution, and I have followed them
throughout this project.

In conclusion, I affirm that this project represents my original work and that all
contributions made by others have been appropriately acknowledged. I submit
this project in the hope that it will make a valuable contribution to the study of
philosophy and inspire further research in this area.
6|Page
Mritunjay Singh

Index:

1 Introduction

2 Literature Review

2.1 Plato's Views on English Poetry

2.2 Aristotle's Views on English Poetry

2.3 Comparison of Plato and Aristotle's Views on English

Poetry

3 Objective of the study

4 Data Analysis and interpretation

5 Research Methodology

6 Conclusion

7 Bibliography

7|Page
 Chapter: 1 Introduction

English literature is replete with influential philosophical thinkers who have

contributed significantly to the world of literature and the human understanding
of life and society. Two such thinkers who continue to influence modern
thought are Aristotle and Plato. These two philosophers are known for their
remarkable ideas on a wide range of topics, including politics, ethics, and
metaphysics, among others.

Aristotle and Plato were both ancient Greek philosophers, and they are among
the most well-known and respected thinkers in history. They are widely
regarded as the founders of Western philosophy and have played a significant
role in shaping many of the ideas that continue to shape our modern world.
Despite the similarities in their backgrounds and the fact that they both had a
significant impact on Western thought, Aristotle and Plato had differing views
on many fundamental issues.

This research project will delve into the works of Aristotle and Plato, with a
particular focus on their views on politics, ethics, and metaphysics. It will
explore how their different ideas have influenced literature throughout history
and how they continue to influence modern thought. Through this comparative
analysis, this research project aims to provide a better understanding of these
two great philosophers and their impact on literature and human thought.

8|Page
 Chapter2: Literature Review

2.1 Plato's Views on English Poetry:

Plato was highly critical of poetry, arguing that it had the potential to corrupt
individuals and society. In his work, The Republic, Plato famously banned poets
from his ideal society, claiming that poetry could arouse dangerous emotions
and distract individuals from rational thinking. Plato believed that poetry was
not an accurate representation of reality and that it could lead individuals to
mistake illusions for truth.

Plato's views on poetry are perhaps best summed up in his dialogue, The Ion. In
this work, Socrates questions Ion, a rhapsode (a professional reciter of poetry),
about his ability to interpret and understand the poetry he recites. Socrates
argues that Ion does not possess any real knowledge, but rather is possessed by
the spirit of the poet, and is, therefore, unable to interpret the meaning of the
poetry he recites.

2.2 Aristotle's Views on English Poetry:

9|Page
Aristotle, in contrast to Plato, saw poetry as a valuable means of emotional
catharsis and education. In his work, Poetics, Aristotle argued that poetry could
elicit emotions in individuals, allowing them to experience a cathartic release of
these emotions. Aristotle believed that poetry could be used to teach individuals
about ethical and moral values, as well as provide insight into the human
condition.

Aristotle saw poetry as an imitation of reality, but he argued that this imitation
was not necessarily a bad thing. Instead, he believed that poetry could capture
the essence of reality, providing individuals with a deeper understanding of the
world around them.

2.3 Comparison of Plato and Aristotle's Views on English Poetry:

One of the fundamental differences between the two philosophers is their views
on reality. Plato believed that reality exists in the world of Forms, which is
beyond the physical world. He argued that the physical world is just a reflection
of the world of Forms. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that reality exists
in the physical world. He argued that the physical world is the only reality, and
everything else is just a concept.

Another difference between the two philosophers is their views on the soul.
Plato believed that the soul is immortal and pre-exists before birth. He also
believed that the soul has three parts, the rational part, the spirited part, and the
appetitive part. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that the soul is mortal and
inseparable from the body. He argued that the soul is composed of different
faculties, such as the rational faculty, the sensory faculty, and the nutritive
faculty.

10 | P a g e
Both philosophers have different views on the nature of knowledge. Plato
believed that knowledge is innate and that it can be accessed through the
process of recollection. He argued that all knowledge is already present in the
soul and that learning is just a process of remembering. Aristotle, on the other
hand, believed that knowledge is acquired through experience. He argued that
knowledge is not innate but is acquired through observation and experience.

The Republic:

The Republic is perhaps Plato's most famous work, and it deals with the nature
of justice and the ideal society. In this work, Plato argues that the ideal society
is one in which the rulers are philosopher-kings who possess wisdom and
knowledge that allow them to govern justly. Plato also argues that there are
three classes in society: rulers, auxiliaries, and craftsmen, and that each class
should only perform its specific function.

Aristotle, on the other hand, does not agree with Plato's idea of an ideal society
ruled by philosopher-kings. Instead, Aristotle believes that the best form of
government is a constitutional government in which the citizens rule. He also
argues that the good life is achieved through the cultivation of virtues and that
virtues are developed through habituation.

The Symposium:

11 | P a g e
The Symposium is a dialogue in which Plato explores the nature of love. In this
work, a group of philosophers discusses the nature of love and the various forms
it can take. Plato argues that love is a desire for beauty and that the highest form
of love is the love of the Form of Beauty itself.

Aristotle, on the other hand, does not address the nature of love in any of his
works. However, he does discuss the concept of friendship in his Nicomachean
Ethics, in which he argues that friendship is an essential component of the good
life.

The Nicomachean Ethics:

The Nicomachean Ethics is Aristotle's most famous work on ethics, in which he

explores the nature of the good life and the virtues. Aristotle argues that the
good life is achieved through the cultivation of virtues and that virtues are
developed through habituation. He also distinguishes between moral virtues,
such as courage and honesty, and intellectual virtues, such as wisdom and
understanding.

Plato, in his work The Republic, also addresses the nature of the virtues, but he
takes a different approach. Plato argues that virtues are not simply habits that
can be cultivated, but rather they are qualities of the soul that are innate and
must be discovered through philosophical inquiry.

The Politics:
12 | P a g e
Politics is Aristotle's most famous work on political philosophy, in which he
explores the nature of the state and the best form of government. Aristotle
argues that the best form of government is a constitutional government in which
the citizens rule. He also distinguishes between different forms of government,
such as democracy, aristocracy, and tyranny.

Plato, in his work The Republic, also addresses the nature of the state and the
best form of government. However, he takes a different approach, arguing that
the ideal society is one in which the rulers are philosopher-kings who possess
wisdom and knowledge that allow them to govern justly.

The Poetics:

Poetics is Aristotle's most famous work on literary theory, in which he explores

the nature of tragedy and the elements that make up a good tragedy. Aristotle
argues that a good tragedy must have a protagonist who is neither completely
good nor completely bad and that the tragedy must have a cathartic effect on the
audience.

Plato, in his work The Republic, also addresses the role of poetry in society, but
he takes a different approach. Plato argues that poetry can be a dangerous
influence on society, leading individuals to mistake illusions for reality and
distracting them from rational thought.

13 | P a g e
The Role of Poetry in Society:

The role of poetry in society has been a subject of debate for centuries. n ancient
times, poetry was often used as a means of recording history and passing on
cultural traditions. In more recent times, poetry has been seen as a means of
personal expression and a reflection of individual and societal values.

Plato's views on poetry reflect a concern about the potential negative effects of
poetry on society. Plato believed that poetry could be a dangerous influence,
leading individuals to mistake illusions for reality and distracting them from
rational thought. Plato saw poetry as a threat to his ideal society, which was
founded on reason and order.

Aristotle, in contrast, believed that poetry had a valuable role to play in society.
He saw poetry as a means of emotional catharsis and education, providing
individuals with insight into the human condition and teaching ethical and
moral values. Aristotle believed that poetry had the potential to promote
personal growth and development.

The role of poetry in society today remains a subject of debate. Some argue that
poetry is no longer relevant in modern society, while others see it as a means of
personal expression and a reflection of individual and societal values. The
debate about the role of poetry in society reflects broader debates about the role
of art in society and the relationship between art and morality.

14 | P a g e
 Chapter 3: Objective of Study

The objective of this research project is to compare and analyze the

philosophical viewpoints of Aristotle and Plato in their works of literature. This
project aims to understand the similarities and differences in their approach to
literature, their understanding of the role of literature in society, and their
contribution to the development of literary theory.

The study will begin by exploring the historical context of Aristotle and Plato's
work, examining their cultural and societal influences, and how these have
shaped their literary theories. The project will then move on to analyze specific
works of literature from both philosophers, including Plato's Republic and
Aristotle's Poetics, to identify common themes and areas of divergence.

Through this comparative analysis, the study seeks to answer several key
research questions, including:

What are the similarities and differences between Aristotle’s and Plato's literary
theories?

How did Aristotle and Plato view the role of literature in society?

How did their literary theories contribute to the development of literary theory
as a discipline?

To achieve these research objectives, the project will use a combination of

primary and secondary sources, including the works of Aristotle and Plato, as
well as critical analyses and commentaries on their works. The findings of this
study will contribute to the existing body of literature on literary theory and
provide a better understanding of the philosophical underpinnings of literature.

15 | P a g e
 Chapter 4: Research Methodology

This research project aims to analyze and compare the philosophical ideas of
Aristotle and Plato, two of the most influential ancient Greek philosophers, in
the context of English literature. The research will explore how their ideas have
been used and interpreted by English writers in different periods, and how they
have influenced the development of English literature. This methodology
section outlines the research design, data collection methods, and analytical
framework used in this study.

Research Design: This study will use a qualitative research design that involves
the collection and analysis of literary texts and critical essays related to the
topic. The research will involve close reading and analysis of selected literary
works, including those by English writers such as Shakespeare, Milton, and
Blake, who have been influenced by the philosophical ideas of Aristotle and
Plato. The study will focus on examining how these writers have incorporated
and interpreted the ideas of Aristotle and Plato in their works, and how these
ideas have contributed to the development of English literature.

Data Collection: The data collection for this study will involve two main
sources: primary sources and secondary sources. Primary sources will include
literary texts, such as plays, poems, and novels, that have been influenced by the
ideas of Aristotle and Plato. These texts will be selected based on their
relevance to the research question and their availability. Secondary sources will
include critical essays and academic articles that analyze and interpret the works
of Aristotle and Plato, as well as the literary works that have been influenced by
their ideas.

16 | P a g e
 Chapter 5: Data Analysis and Interpretation

Plato and Aristotle were both Greek philosophers who had a significant impact
on the world of philosophy. Plato was a student of Socrates and the teacher of
Aristotle, who was a student of Plato. Plato's most famous work is "The
Republic," while Aristotle's most famous work is "The Nicomachean Ethics."
Both works discuss the concept of the ideal state and the role of the individual
within that state. However, they have different approaches to this concept.

Plato believed that the ideal state should be governed by philosopher-kings. He

thought that the philosopher-kings would be the wisest and most just people in
the state and would be able to govern justly. He also believed that individuals
should strive to achieve the highest level of knowledge and wisdom.

Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that the ideal state should be a mixed
government. He thought that the government should be composed of individuals
from all social classes, to achieve a balance between the interests of the rich and
the poor. Aristotle also believed that individuals should strive for happiness
rather than knowledge and that happiness could be achieved by living a virtuous
life.

Analysis

One of the similarities between Plato and Aristotle is their belief in the
importance of education. Both philosophers believed that education was the key
to achieving a just and virtuous society. They also believed that education
should be based on reason and that individuals should be taught to think
critically.

17 | P a g e
However, the two philosophers had different views on the purpose of education.
Plato believed that education should be focused on the pursuit of knowledge and
wisdom. He believed that individuals should be taught to seek truth and to
question everything. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that education should
be focused on the pursuit of happiness. He believed that individuals should be
taught to live virtuously and to achieve a state of happiness.

Another difference between Plato and Aristotle is their views on the nature of
reality. Plato believed in the existence of a realm of Forms, which he believed to
be more real than the physical world. He believed that the physical world was a
mere copy of the world of Forms. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed that the
physical world was the only reality. He believed that the world of Forms was
merely a product of human thought.

Interpretation

Plato and Aristotle were two of the most influential philosophers in ancient
Greece. Their ideas and philosophies have had a significant impact on the
development of Western thought. Plato's idea of the ideal state, governed by
philosopher-kings, has influenced political thinking throughout history.
Aristotle's emphasis on living a virtuous life has influenced ethical thinking and
has had a lasting impact on the field of philosophy.

In conclusion, the comparison of Aristotle’s and Plato's literary works and

philosophies has revealed many similarities and differences. While they shared
some common beliefs, such as the importance of education, they had different
views on the purpose of education and the nature of reality. Their ideas have
influenced many areas of human thought and continue to be studied and
discussed today.

18 | P a g e
 Chapter 6: Conclusion

The comparison of Aristotle and Plato reveals two of the most influential
philosophers in the Western intellectual tradition. Their ideas have shaped the
development of philosophy, politics, ethics, and even science. Although their
philosophies differ in many ways, they share a common goal of understanding
the nature of reality and human existence.

Plato believed that the ultimate reality exists beyond the physical world and can
only be known through reason and contemplation. Aristotle, on the other hand,
believed that reality is found in the physical world and can be known through
empirical observation and logical deduction. Plato saw knowledge as an innate
capability of the human soul, while Aristotle believed that knowledge is gained
through experience.

The two philosophers also had different views on politics and ethics. Plato
believed in an ideal state ruled by philosopher-kings who possess knowledge of
the good. Aristotle, on the other hand, believed in a more practical approach to
politics and advocated for a constitutional government. In terms of ethics, Plato
believed in the existence of objective moral truths, while Aristotle believed that
ethics is a practical discipline concerned with achieving human flourishing.

Despite their differences, both philosophers have had a profound impact on the
Western intellectual tradition. Plato's ideas on the nature of reality, knowledge,
and the ideal state have influenced the development of metaphysics,
epistemology, and political philosophy. Aristotle's ideas on logic, natural
science, and ethics have had a lasting impact on fields such as biology, physics,
and ethics.

19 | P a g e
 Chapter 7: Bibliography

Aristotle. Poetics. Translated by S. H. Butcher, Dover Publications, 1997.

Plato. The Republic. Translated by G. R. F. Ferrari, Cambridge University

Press, 2000.

Plato. The Ion. Translated by Benjamin Jowett, Project Gutenberg, 2008.

Nussbaum, Martha C. Poetic Justice: The Literary Imagination and Public Life.
Beacon Press, 1995.

Langer, Susanne K. Feeling, and Form: A Theory of Art. Routledge & Kegan
Paul, 1953.

Bloom, Harold. The Anxiety of Influence: A Theory of Poetry.

20 | P a g e