Professional Documents
Culture Documents
OF CANDIDA A L B I C A N S F R O M P R E G N A N T W O M E N
by
(with 2 figs.)
A wide variety of differential media have been proposed for the
identification of Candida albicans, a yeast-like fungus commonly
accepted as having a major role in the etiology of vulvovaginitis
(24). More often than not these media have been formulated for the
purpose of stimulating chlamydospore production, for this charac-
teristic structure has been given diagnostic credence where C. albi-
cans is concerned (4, 6, 10, 11, 12, 18, 20, 21). The classic medium
used for this purpose is corn meal agar, described in 1931 by
BENHAM (2), who applied the Dalmau technique (5) of slit inocu-
lation plus the subsequent use of a coverglass to facilitate micro-
scopic observation of growth. GORDON, BRADLEY & GRANT (8)
tested four types of corn meal for their influence upon chlamydo-
spore production, and showed that the yellow unenriched variety
was superior. Covering the inoculum with a coverglass, as advo-
cated by WlCKER~AM (26), displayed no advantage in their hands.
BAKERSPIGEL (1) also found yellow corn meal to be superior.
Because of the variable results obtained with plant materials such
as potato-carrot pulp and corn meal, NICKERSON & )/IANKOWSKI
(13) formulated a medium containing soluble starch freed of re-
ducing sugars. Their "purified polysaccharide" medium 2) appeared
to them to be an improvement over corn meal agar. However, in
the experience of others this has not proven to be the case (9, 14,19).
t(EID, JONES & CARTER (15) devised a medium devoid of any poly-
saccharide, but containing the corn protein, zein, with which they
achieved better results than with corn meal agar.
SEELIGER (17) showed that the addition of Tween 801) to a dex-
trose-peptone-agar medium caused abundant mycelium formation
in several Candida species and also stimulated chlamydospore for-
mation in C. albicans. Working with 17 "recalcitrant" strains of
C. albicans isolated from a variety of clinical sources which failed to
form chlamydospores on rice infusion agar (22). TASCHDJIAN (23)
demonstrated that growth on a "cream of rice" infusion agar con-
taining Tween 80 resulted in abundant chlamydospore production
by all strains. ROSENTHAL (16) reported improved results also with
TABLE I.
Comparative Media Studies Regarding CMamydospore Formation by Candida albicans
M A T E R I A L S AND M E T H O D S
The 4 media evaluated were: corn meal agar (CMA), corn meal
agar with Tween 80 (CMAT), rice agar (RA), and rice agar with
Tween 80 (RAT). The coma meal agar was a commercial product 1!.
Rice agar was made from Cream of Rice according to TASCHDJIAN S
directions (23, 24). Tween 80 was added in a concentration of 1 9~.
The media were autoclaved, stirred well where Tween 80 was pres-
ent, and then poured into regular 90 mm Petri dishes.
Specimen material for culturing was obtained from 301 pregnant
patients in tile manner described previously (24). Sterile, dry,
cotton-tipped applicators, after having been rotated over the vagi-
nal wall and the vulva, were rolled over the surface of 1 quadrant of
a plate, and the inoculated area in part covered b y a sterile cover-
glass. Swab samplings were done in duplicate, and 1 swab served to
inoculate 2 media. Four specimens were cultured per plate. Incu-
bation was at room temperature. Using bright-field microscopy
at a magnification of 100 X, inoculated areas showing yeast-like
growth were scrutinized both through the coverglass and outside
the covered portion for chlamydospore formation. Observations
were made daily for a period of 1 week. This time limit was felt to
be a practical one for media being tested as selective and differential
for yeast-like fungi of vulvovaginal origin.
All yeast-like fungi were subcultured onto Sabouraud's dextrose
agar plates and purified b y the streaking process. Those strains
forming chlamydospores within 1 week on at least one of the media
were designated as CF (chlamydospore forming) strains. When ho-
mogeneity of colony type was ascertained, the strain was sub-
I~ESULTS
One hundred and eighteen patients (39.2 %) gave positive cultures
for yeast-like fungi. Eight (6.8 %) presented mixed cultures which
were of the following combinations: C. albicans and Candida stetla-
toidea (3 cases); C. albicans and Candida t~arapsilosis (2 cases);
C. albicans and Candida tropicalis (2 cases); C. stell~toidea and C.
tropicalis (1 case). Of the total 126 isolants, 8 died before the 6-weeks
subcutturing schedule was effected. Sixty (47.6 %) of the isolants
were identified as CF strains. The incidence with which these 60 CF
strains formed chlamydospores on the 4 media is summarized in
Table II, where it can be seen that only 27 (45.0~o) of them formed
chlamydospores on all the media. R A T appears to be the most
efficient in eliciting a chlamydospore response with 58 (97 %)
being positive on it.Only 32 (53 %) formed chlamydospores on CMA.
R A is shown to be definitelybetter than CMA, but the addition of
Tween 80 to both caused a remarkable improvement in theirability
to stimulate chlamydospore production. There were 2 strains which
formed chlamydospores on C M A T that failedto form them on RAT.
Conversely, there were 9 strains which formed eh]amydospores on
R A T that failed to form them on C M A T . No strains were found
which formed chlamydospores on IRA and failed to form them on
RAT. Three strains formed chlamydospores on C M A and failed to
form them on C M A T .
The rapidity with which chlamydospores were produced is pre-
sented graphically in Fig. I. The day of chlamydospore formation
on each medium was recorded for 50 of the CF strains. Sporulation
was earlier on RAT than on CMAT, 88 (76.0 %) strains having
formed chlamydospores on this medium within 3 days. Only 26
(52.0 °/o) had sporulated on CMAT within that time period; none
having been observed at 24 hours. Although for some strains sporu-
MEDIA FOR C. A L B I C A N S ISOLATION FROM PREGNANT WOMEN 273
b# o
Z ~
11+o
+II
+llI
l++l ~5
I1++
t~
+1 + ~
14 P~
+l+l ~
++ll ~
~3
O
+++I Z #
++++ S
0 0 0
m
"N
~ 0 ~ 0
II iI ~
+1~
,0 I
5
D A Y - ~ ILL~54567 I 25456..7J
WITH TWEEN 80 WITHOUT TWEEN 80
TABLE I I I .
Fermentation Reactions o/ 55 C F Strains o[ Candida
Fermentation Reactions*
No. %
Identification
G iV[ S L Strains Strains
G -- Glucose ** A --- A c i d
M -- Maltose G -- Gas
S -- Sucrose 0 -- No fermentatrion
L -- Lactose
~/
1o
X),Q, ~
70-
60-
50- /-//
40- / / / =:~wr
X>(b<
30- X/'fX ....
20- X><'3
X > ( N ......
KXN~ X?43, ~ ///
10- ...... ///
~k'2'// ///
TABLE IV.
Summary o/ Cultural Characteristics o/ the Di//erent Candida Species
* A b b r e v a t i o n s s a m e as for T a b l e I I I .
** C - - M y c e l i u m p l u s c h l a m y d o s p o r e p r o d u c t i o n .
M - h i y c e l i u m withou~ c h l a m y d o s p o r e p r o d u c t i o n .
N- No m y c e l i u m p r o d u c t i o n ; y e a s t - l i k e p h a s e only.
*** No s u r f a c e g r o w t h .
M E D I A FOR C. ALBICANS I S O L A T I O N FROM P R E G N A N T W O M E N 277
DISCUSSION
Despite the inference in Table I, the results of the current study
demonstrate that not all strains of Candida giving the fermentation
pattern of C. albicans form chlamydospores on nutritionally defi-
cient media containing Tween 80. Furthermore, the divergence of
results obtained by the various investigators using the same media
must reflect the diversities of strains tested and techniques utilized.
The proclaiming of a cultural characteristic for a species as preva-
lent as C. albicans based on the results obtained with relatively few
strains can lead to precarious conclusions. The identification of C.
albicans through recognition of chlamydospore production would
appear to be a case in point, in view of the fact that, in this investi-
gation, strains of 4 of 6 species were observed to sporulate. This
may be an indication that the process is of generic importance and
we await only the development of an appropriate cultural environ-
ment to establish its universality among the Candidas.
Whether chlamydospore formation would have greater signifi-
278 .. G. SMITEa.o.
Acknowledgment
We t h a n k Dr. CHARLES L. WISSEMAN JR., and Dr. MERRILL J. SNYDER for
their interest and counsel during this investigation.
Summary
Rice agar and corn meal agar, with and without Tween 80, were
evaluated clinically as directly inoculable selective and differen-
tial media for the isolation of C. albicans from vulvovaginal specimens
taken from pregnant women. Chlamydospore formation on these
media was investigated as a criterion for the identification of C.
albicans.
Of 301 patients cultured, 118 (39.2 °/o) gave positive cultures for
yeast-like fungi of the genus Casdids. Of 118 strains for which fer-
mentation patterns were determined, 69 (58.5 %) gave the pattern
for C. albicam. Of these, 56 (81.1 ~o) formed chlamydospores.
Tween 80 was found to exert a very stimulating influence on
chlamydospore production. Rice agar with Tween 80 appeared to
be the most efficient medium for elicitingchlamydospores. However,
since strains of 4 out of 6 spe~ ies of Candida isolated were found to
sporulate it was concluded that chlamydospore formation is not a
reliable criterion for the speciation of C. albicans.
Each of the 4 media served satisfactorily as a directly inocu-
lable selective medium for the isolation of yeast-like fungi of the
genus Casdida from vulvovaginal specimens. None of the media ap-
peared to preferentially stimulate chlamydospore production in
C. albicans.
References
1. BAKERSPIGEL, A. : A preferred m e t h o d for the routine identification of Candida.
J. infect. Dis. 94: 141--143, 1954.
2. BENHAM, R. W.: Certain monilias parasitic on m a n . Their identification b y
morphology a n d b y agglutination. J. infect. Dis. 4 9 : 183--215, 1931.
3. BENHAM, R. W.: Species of Candida m o s t frequently isolated from m a n :
m e t h o d s and criteria for their identification. J. chron. Dis. 5: 460--472, 1957.
4. COI'7ANT,N. F., SMITH, D. T., I3AKER, R. D., CALLOWAY, J. L. & MARTIN,
D. S.: Manual of Clinical Mycology, Ed. 2. Philadelphia: W. ]3. Saunders
Company, 1954.
5. DALMAU, L. M.: R e m a r q u e s sur la technique mycologique. Ann. Parasit.
7: 536--545, 1927.
280 A.G. SMIT~ a.o.