Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Chapter 1
The following chapter lays the ground in understanding the issue of the problem
to be analyzed in the policy analysis, including the context of the policy problem,
definition of the policy problem, and the methodology and limitations of the study.
contributing to its prevalence (Mittal & Singh, 2020) define gender-based violence as a
parental violence, substance abuse, marital status, and educational status (Beyene et al.,
2019). The vulnerability of internally displaced people (IDPs) in the Philippines due to
safety and security issues, gender-based violence, and militarization has been highlighted,
emphasizing the intersectionality of racial, ethnic, gender, and social class inequality
(Veloso, 2022). Furthermore, the aftermath of natural disasters, such as Super Typhoon
Haiyan, has been found to intersect with cultural and social norms, leading to patterns of
In the context of the Philippines, election violence has been a focus of research,
with efforts to understand its frequency and nature (Smith & Reyes, 2021). Additionally,
the impact of tropical storms in the Philippines has been linked to a critical need for
gender-based violence prevention (Bellizzi et al., 2022). The media's role in perpetuating
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
stereotypes and prejudices about the role of women in society, contributing to gender-
based violence, has been explored (Belmonte & Negri, 2021). Moreover, social work
recommendations for further research on its effects and the role of the family in social
addressing gender-based violence has been highlighted, critiquing Western logic and
emphasizing the need for indigenous understandings (Keddie, 2022). The consequences
of the gender backlash in education have been addressed, offering new insights into
interventions in rural areas has been explored, highlighting the experiences of combining
gender audits have been used as a basis for developing modules for Gender and
Development (GAD) policies in the Philippines, aiming to reduce gender biases and
gender-based violence have been discussed, emphasizing the need for an intersectional
lens to recognize unique risk factors and the differential impact on women (Graaff,
2021).
arguing that these approaches often oversimplify the complex nature of gender identity
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
gender, moving away from rigid, static definitions. Hicks advocates for the inclusion of
post structural, queer, and trans theories in social work education and practice. This
intersections, rather than a fixed attribute. Hicks' critique underlines the necessity for a
more inclusive, flexible approach to gender in social work, which can better address the
Valdeza et al. (2022) reveals the multifaceted barriers Filipino women face in
seeking support against violence. The authors highlight how societal norms, economic
pandemic has further intensified these challenges, limiting women's access to necessary
resources. This study underscores the urgent need for systemic changes, including
address these barriers. The findings call for a concerted effort to challenge the patriarchal
structures and cultural norms that perpetuate violence against women in the Philippines.
Dvoriak, Karagodina, & Semigina (2020) evaluates the gender education and
system. The study reveals that while various gender theories coexist in the curriculum,
there is a predominant focus on traditional gender roles and socialization. This approach
advocate for an educational shift towards a more inclusive and justice-oriented approach
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
Labrague Jr. et al. (2022) sheds light on the complexity of gender-based violence
and its impact on women and children. The study categorizes the abuse into four types:
nature of domestic violence and the challenges in addressing it effectively. The findings
including enhancements in the justice system. This research underscores the urgency of
addressing the issue of domestic violence in a more comprehensive and effective manner,
pervasive nature of GBV, exacerbated by cultural norms and societal attitudes that often
discourage reporting and seeking help. Garcia points out the inadequacy of government
responses, which tend to be reactive rather than preventive. The thesis emphasizes the
the role of cultural factors as both risk and protective elements. This research calls for a
more nuanced approach to addressing GBV, focusing on both prevention and response
and underscores the need for comprehensive data to better understand and tackle the
issue.
reflects the multidimensional nature of this issue, encompassing various factors such as
displacement, natural disasters, media influence, education, and the role of digital
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
segments of the population underscores the need for comprehensive and context-specific
The findings from the reviewed studies highlight the critical intersection of
gender violence and the field of social work. They emphasize the multifaceted nature of
women in different contexts, such as domestic violence in the Philippines. These studies
underscore the barriers that hinder victims from seeking help, including socio-cultural
norms, economic constraints, and victim-blaming. Importantly, they emphasize the need
Moreover, the studies emphasize the role of systemic changes, better law enforcement,
community support, and policy reforms in addressing these complex issues effectively.
Collectively, these findings underscore the urgency of social work professionals adopting
gender justice.
individuals based on their gender. It is deeply rooted in societal norms, cultural beliefs,
and structural inequalities that perpetuate power imbalances between genders. GBV is a
pervasive problem that affects individuals' safety, dignity, and rights, often leading to
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
by factors such as societal attitudes, cultural norms, economic constraints, and the
effectiveness of legal and support systems in addressing and preventing such violence.
Statement of Intent
The present policy analysis aims to examine policy implications for how social
workers can be better prepared for handling cases of gender-based violence. More
1. How do the social workers perceive their ability to handle cases related to gender-
based violence?
2. What policy options may be offered given the current demands of training needs
3. What policy option is the most optimal policy given the following options?
Stakeholders Involved
The policy analysis focusing on preparing social workers for handling gender-
Social Workers: They are at the frontline of GBV response. Enhanced policies
could provide them with better training, resources, and support systems to effectively
handle these cases. This includes education on legal aspects, psychological support to
combat secondary trauma, and strategies for dealing with systemic and cultural
challenges.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
interventions, victims would gain from more effective, empathetic, and culturally
sensitive support. Enhanced policies could lead to more comprehensive and timely
Government Agencies: Agencies responsible for social welfare, justice, and law
enforcement would benefit from clear, coordinated policies that define roles and facilitate
collaboration. This would lead to more effective case management and resource
allocation.
societal norms that perpetuate violence, and promotes a safer environment for all
members.
ca would not only enhance the capabilities of these professionals but also significantly
impact the wellbeing of victims, the efficacy of government agencies, and the overall
workers from a municipal social welfare district. These participants were selected
was conducted via Google Forms, which provided a convenient and secure platform for
ended and Likert-scale questions, and quantitative analysis was performed, including
calculating means and standard deviations to gauge the central tendency and variation in
responses.
identifiable information used in the analysis. Informed consent was obtained from all
participants, and they were informed of their right to withdraw at any time. Additionally,
measures were taken to securely handle data collected through Google Forms. This
overview of the social workers' perspectives on the policy in question, ensuring a robust
Chapter 2
Problem Description
properly contextualize the subsequent policy analysis, which includes discussions on the
background of the problem, and the problem within its current policy environment.
comprehensive overview of the legal framework that guides social workers in this field.
The 1987 Philippine Constitution sets a foundational legal basis for equality and
human rights, which includes specific protections for women. This constitutional
mandate underpins all other laws related to GBV and guides social workers in advocating
Understanding these provisions enables social workers to support clients facing gender
The Magna Carta of Women (Republic Act No. 9710) is a cornerstone in the fight
against GBV, providing comprehensive protection and rights for women. This law is
crucial for social workers as it outlines specific rights and protections that they must
ensure for their clients, including access to services and legal remedies.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
The Anti-Violence against Women and Their Children Act of 2004 (Republic Act
No. 9262) specifically targets violence against women and children, encompassing
physical, sexual, psychological, and economic abuse. Social workers use this law to
protect and advocate for victims of domestic violence, ensuring they receive necessary
Overall, these laws provide a critical legal structure within which social workers
operate. They ensure that social workers are equipped to offer informed guidance,
navigate legal channels effectively, and collaborate with various entities for the
laws is essential for social workers to fulfill their responsibilities in advocating for and
social workers dealing with GBV cases is a significant concern. Constant exposure to
traumatic stories and events can lead to emotional and psychological strain, often
mirroring symptoms of PTSD, such as nightmares, anxiety, and persistent sadness. This
not only affects the mental health of the social workers but can also impact their
professional efficacy, leading to decreased empathy and burnout (Valdeza et al., 2022).
psychological support and professional supervision. Practices like peer support groups,
There is also a need for organizational policies that recognize and address the risks of
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
secondary traumatization, ensuring that social workers are supported in managing these
challenges effectively.
Systemic Challenges. Systemic issues in handling GBV cases often stem from
legislative and structural inadequacies. Laws may not be comprehensive enough or may
not be effectively implemented, leaving gaps in protection for victims. The sluggish pace
of legal processes can also discourage victims from seeking justice (Garcia, 2020).
insufficient shelters and support services for GBV victims. Furthermore, the lack of
difficult for victims to receive comprehensive support. Advocacy for policy change and
Cultural and Societal Norms. The role of cultural and societal norms in GBV
cases cannot be overstated. In many societies, GBV is often normalized, and victims may
face stigma, shame, and blame, which discourages them from seeking help. These norms
can also influence the attitudes of law enforcement and judicial systems, leading to biases
and a lack of sensitivity in handling GBV cases (Labrague Jr. et al., 2022).
clients, challenging harmful norms, and working towards societal change. Education and
awareness campaigns are crucial in altering public perceptions of GBV, along with
preventing violence.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
Table 1
The survey conducted among 30 social workers about their familiarity with
and favorable perception of their readiness and consciousness in this field. The
Societal Factors' (mean = 6.50, standard deviation = 2.67), and 'Knowledge of Prevention
Programs' (mean = 6.50, standard deviation = 2.50). These findings indicate that social
workers possess the requisite knowledge and abilities to effectively assist victims of
All items received scores within the 'Agreement' range, suggesting a widespread
gender-based violence (GBV). This includes a variety of domains, ranging from legal
'Training in Intervention Strategies' (mean = 6.13, standard deviation = 2.83) and 'Ability
to Educate Others' (mean = 6.37, standard deviation = 2.48) indicate the respondents'
strong belief in their training and proficiency in spreading knowledge about GBV in an
efficient manner.
These findings suggest that social workers possess the necessary skills and
training and updates on gender-based violence (GBV) legislation and policies. This is
necessary to ensure that all social workers possess the same level of proficiency in
dealing with such delicate cases. Furthermore, given the dynamic nature of societal
continuous professional development and education in this field are essential for social
method has the potential to not only maintain existing levels of preparedness but also
violence.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
Chapter 3
Policy Options
The present chapter presents the analysis of policy options and alternatives
Framework of Analysis
tools and methods used to implement gender equality policies. These instruments
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
are influenced by contextual factors like policymaking styles and advocacy, and
tools.
process, considering the diversity of actors involved and the resources dedicated
more gender-just society. It aims to understand the extent to which policies have
To create indicators of success for a policy based on this approach, one could
equality.
gender and sexual hierarchies have been dismantled and the extent of
strategies for secondary traumatization. This aligns with the Gender Equality Policy in
Practice Approach by ensuring social workers are well-equipped with the necessary tools
and knowledge (Effective Use of Policy Instruments), and addresses their mental health
Develop integrated service models that combine resources from various sectors
for holistic GBV support. This policy aligns with the Inclusive Policy Empowerment
address societal norms contributing to GBV. This policy supports Gender Transformation
as the Outcome by challenging harmful norms and biases, fostering societal change, and
increasing cultural sensitivity among social workers and the general public (Achievement
of Gender Transformation).
The most fitting policy option in accordance with the Gender Equality Policy in
Practice Approach is the Integrated Service Model Development. This policy directly
holistic approach to GBV. It aligns with the Inclusive Policy Empowerment Process by
ensuring diverse stakeholders are involved in the policy implementation, enhancing the
support network for victims. Additionally, it fulfills the Gender Transformation as the
Approach to Implementation
government agencies, NGOs, and social work professionals to assess current gaps
in service delivery.
3. Training and Capacity Building: Develop training programs for social workers
evaluation to assess the impact and efficiency of the integrated service model.
consistent funding for such an expansive program is another major concern, as it requires
sustained financial commitment from the government and possibly other donors. The
effectiveness of the model depends heavily on the quality of training and the willingness
Furthermore, the success of this approach hinges on the adaptability of the model to local
contexts, requiring a flexible and responsive design that can be adjusted based on
regional needs and challenges. Lastly, measuring the impact of such a holistic approach
can be difficult, as changes in societal attitudes and behaviors towards GBV are gradual
and multifaceted.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
Chapter 4
focusing on the legal framework, challenges faced by social workers, and their
perceptions of handling GBV cases. The analysis aims to identify effective policy options
Summary of Findings
2. Potential Policy Options: Given the training needs and the complexities of GBV
cases, policy options include enhanced training and support programs, integrated
3. Optimal Policy Option: The most optimal policy option is the Integrated Service
collaboration not only enhances the efficiency of service delivery but also ensures that
the unique needs and perspectives of GBV survivors are considered from a
multidisciplinary standpoint.
in handling GBV cases within an integrated service model, continuous training and
support are crucial. This includes equipping social workers with the necessary skills for
training is vital to ensure that social workers can sensitively and appropriately address the
diverse needs of GBV survivors, acknowledging that cultural factors can significantly
impact their experiences and help-seeking behaviors. Ongoing training and support
programs not only improve the quality of care but also contribute to the professional
model in addressing GBV. Regularly tracking key performance indicators and outcomes
allows stakeholders to gauge the impact of their efforts and identify areas for
improvement. Moreover, these mechanisms should provide a feedback loop that enables
timely adjustments to the model, ensuring that it remains responsive to the evolving
and evolve over time, ultimately enhancing its ability to provide comprehensive support
in the Philippines, underscoring the pivotal role of social workers. The findings suggest a
general proficiency among social workers in managing GBV cases, yet also point to the
need for more structured, collaborative approaches. The recommended Integrated Service
Model Development stands out as a holistic solution, addresses systemic and cultural
and a commitment to ongoing evaluation. This policy analysis serves as a call to action
effectively combat GBV and support those at the forefront of this critical issue.
LA CONSOLACION UNIVERSITY PHILIPPINES
Bulihan, City of Malolos, Bulacan 3000
References
Adams, A., Lea, S., & D’Silva, E. (2021). Digital technologies and interventions against
gender-based violence in rural areas. International Criminal Justice Review,
31(4), 438-455. https://doi.org/10.1177/10575677211040413
Bellizzi, S., Molek, K., & Nivoli, A. (2022). Tropical storm in the philippines and in
vietnam: a critical need for gender‐based violence prevention. Developing World
Bioethics, 22(4), 187-188. https://doi.org/10.1111/dewb.12382
Beyene, A., Chojenta, C., Roba, H., Melka, A., & Loxton, D. (2019). Gender-based
violence among female youths in educational institutions of sub-saharan africa: a
systematic review and meta-analysis. Systematic Reviews, 8(1).
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13643-019-0969-9
Buiten, D. and Naidoo, K. (2020). Laying claim to a name: towards a sociology of
“gender-based violence”. South African Review of Sociology, 51(2), 61-68.
https://doi.org/10.1080/21528586.2020.1813194
Engeli, I. and Mazur, A. (2018). Taking implementation seriously in assessing success:
the politics of gender equality policy. European Journal of Politics and Gender,
1(1-2), 111-129. https://doi.org/10.1332/251510818x15282097548558
Giesen, M. (2023). Framing gender-based violence in multi-level contexts: a networked
approach to studying adoption of the istanbul convention. European Journal of
Politics and Gender, 6(1), 76-91.
https://doi.org/10.1332/251510821x16693059192022
Hearn, J., Strid, S., Humbert, A., Balkmar, D., & Delaunay, M. (2020). From gender
regimes to violence regimes: re-thinking the position of violence. Social Politics
International Studies in Gender State & Society, 29(2), 682-705.
https://doi.org/10.1093/sp/jxaa022
Mittal, S. and Singh, T. (2020). Gender-based violence during covid-19 pandemic: a
mini-review. Frontiers in Global Women S Health, 1.
https://doi.org/10.3389/fgwh.2020.00004
Villegas, J., Bauyot, M., Sacro, J., & Siarot, L. (2023). Gender audit as basis in
developing modules for gad focal persons in mati, davao oriental, philippines.
Discourse and Communication for Sustainable Education, 14(1), 48-56.
https://doi.org/10.2478/dcse-2023-0005