Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Laser Pulses
Sergei A. Akhmanov
Victor A. Vysloukh
Anatoly S. Chirkin
Translated by
Yuri Atanov
AIP
© 1992 by American Institute o f Physics
All rights reserved
Printed in the United States o f America
In recent years one o f the most striking achievements o f laser physics is undoubt
edly the development o f methods for generation and shaping o f optical pulses
a few femtoseconds (10-15 s) long, i.e., pulses that contain only a few opti
cal oscillation periods under their envelopes. The significant reduction in time
scale is accompanied by impressive advances in physics and the technology of
ultrashort optical pulses. At present the spectroscopy o f ultrafast phenomena
is reaching new frontiers, the studies o f laser radiation interaction with matter
and the technique o f generation o f high-intensity light fields are making con
siderable progress, the new directions in optical processing o f information are
emerging, and the alternative approaches to the development o f generators o f
electron bunches and ultrashort x-ray and acoustic pulses are coming in view.
The consequences o f this transition to femtosecond pulses in spectroscopy are
justly com pared to the revolutionary changes in the spatial resolution o f opti
cal instruments that followed the invention o f the microscope. A very extensive
area o f research is thus involved, with many branches reaching far beyond the
traditional scope o f physical and applied optics.
A perceptible shift in emphasis has recently become evident in methods for
ultrashort laser pulse generation. While at the first stage the immediate efforts
were concentrated on reliable mode locking o f lasers with broad amplification
bandwidth, the present trend is to use passive systems for pulse compression
and shaping. This brought on much interest to various aspects o f linear and
nonlinear propagation o f short optical wave packets.
At the same time, one can say that the research in this area is about to be
completed. Now we are at the end o f the long road to succeed in the production
o f extremely short optical pulses that took almost 25 years o f intense work.
In this book we tried to give possibly a complete summary o f nonlinear wave
optics o f ultrashort light pulses. The last review dedicated to these problems was
published over 10 years ago.* The substance o f this branch o f nonlinear optics
has essentially changed since that time. On the rise are the volume and the level
V III Foreword
A m ong the cardinal directions in which laser physics and technology grow today
are the generation o f shorter pulses, concentration o f optical energy in time,
application o f such pulses for high-energy treatment o f substances, in studies o f
ultrafast processes, and, finally, in information processing systems.
In 1962-1963, after the development o f Q-switched lasers, the high-power
sources o f pulses 10-100 ns long becam e available. The generators o f giant
nanosecond optical pulses (with the power reaching 10-100 M W at that time)
extensively renovated many branches of laser physics. They also paved the way
for considerable success o f nonlinear optics.
T h e ’next" great success, the penetration into the picosecond time scale, dates
back to 1966-1968. A t that time the longitudinal m ode locking methods were
suggested and realized in practice through constructing the first picosecond
neodymium-glass lasers with power from 1 to 10 G W . For the first time, the
nonlinear-optics methods for compression and reshaping o f picosecond pulses
were demonstrated. The picosecond frequency-tunable parametric oscillators
put into operation at the same time could span the visible and infrared regions.
Thus, the utilization o f fast electronic nonlinearity was shown to be efficient in
picosecond and sub-picosecond optical systems.
Finally, in the early eighties several groups passed the 100 fs mark and the
speedy development o f femtosecond technology started. The first success came
in 1981 when a new concept o f a self-mode-locked dye laser was put forward,
which was a system with pulses colliding in an absorbing medium. Later, the
alternative mode-locking systems, other types o f lasers, and various m ethods o f
nonlinear optics were successfully used for generation o f femtosecond pulses.
Eventually, the sustained efforts to reduce the time scales had been almost
com pleted by 1987. Indeed, pulses 6_fs long were produced in the visible range
— i /in l ------- — nr\ i --------
2 Introduction
ond time scale signifies the almost complete realization o f optical methods in
studies o f ultrafast phenomena involving energy relaxation and phase mismatch
ing in optical excitations in matter. One oscillation period is the ultimate length
o f an optical pulse and also the limiting “speed” o f an optical response from a
material medium.
Using high-intensity femtosecond pulses, one can produce sharply nonequi
librium states resulting in quickly relaxing excitations (with relaxation times
from 10 to 100 fs), in particular, electronic excitations in multiatomic molecules,
semiconductors and metals, as well as observe new types o f fast optically induced
phase transitions in matter. The femtosecond optical technique allows one to de
velop the direct experimental methods to study the molecular dynamics o f com
plex (including, e.g., biologically active) molecules and condensed substances,
and also the phenomena that were previously investigated mostly by means o f
mathematical simulation.
From a practical point o f view the principal outcom e o f the development o f
efficient sources o f short optical pulses is associated with the now possible real
ization o f ultimate rates o f optical processing and transmission o f information. In
recent years some experiments were carried out that demonstrated vividly these
new capabilities: the optical bistable devices with 1 ps switching times have been
constructed, and the elements o f optical-fiber transmission lines developed, with
information being transmitted by optical solitons o f 0.1 ps duration.
On the other hand, the transition to femtosecond pulses is accompanied with
a great jum p to higher intensities. W ith the pulse duration rp = 100 fs, a com
paratively low energy o f W = 0.1 J corresponds to a power o f V 0 = 1 T W . The
systems o f moderate size can thus produce the power levels that were previously
achieved only in multi-kilojoule installations designed for controlled thermonu
clear fusion.
Owing to that, nonlinear optics has acquired quite new experimental means.
17 IS 2
The field intensities up to 10 - 10 W /c m can now be produced in focused
femtosecond pulses. Therefore, the optical field strength can amount here to
about 10 G V /c m , exceeding the interatomic field strength (equal to approxi
mately 1 G V /c m in a hydrogen atom). In such strong fields, the new phenomena
o f nonlinear electronic physics appear. The effects predicted by nonlinear quan
tum electrodynamics (such as nonlinear light scattering by relativistic electrons,
light scattering by light in vacuum, etc.) becom e now experimentally observed.
The new areas o f physical and applied research listed above form the two new
“lands” on the laser energy versus duration map ( W , r ) (see Fig. 1.1).
In this book, devoted primarily to the optics o f femtosecond pulses and to
the physics o f their reshaping and nonlinear propagation, we shall touch upon
applications only slightly. The understanding o f this rapidly advancing area
can be acquired from the proceedings o f the latest conferences on nonlinear
optics and spectroscopy o f ultrafast phenomena, as well as from special issues o f
jou rn a ls.1 5
Introduction 3
F IG . 1.1. Pulse energy as duration chart. Laser pulse duration rp is laid off
on the horizontal axis and pulse energy W on the vertical one. T he straight
lines indicate the levels o f equal power. T he separated regions o f ultrashort pulse
param eters m ark the present frontiers in research o f ultrafast processes and non
linear optics o f high-intensity fields.
The general principles underlying the diverse systems o f optical pulse generation
are fairly obvious (see Fig. 1.2). A short optical pulse can be obtained by
modulating the radiation intensity o f a continuous optical source. A n alternative
approach is based on phase synchronization o f various spectral components o f a
broadband radiation source.
The intensity modulation o f a spark source (or the solar radiation) by means
o f a mechanical shutter or a rotating mirror has already been used by Fizeau
and Michelson in their measurements o f velocity o f light. The application of
high-speed electronic shutters whose characteristic time is now reduced to a few
picoseconds allowed this technique to be essentially improved. The fast electro-
optical m odulation is also used in modern picosecond laser systems. There,
however, it plays an auxiliary role since the peak power thus obtained does not
exceed that o f the original quasicontinuous source.
The tremendous increase in radiation intensity, resulting in the generation o f
a giant optical pulse, can be achieved by means o f mechanical or electro-optical
Q-switching o f a laser resonator containing relatively long-living excited states
in its lasing medium [see Figs. 1 .2 (a ), 1.2(6)]. The width o f the giant pulse
is determined by the properties o f the lasing medium and the resonator. In
o n / » l r i “ r% w i a f l i A r ^ V s<5 fn i* r M ilc iic i
4 Introduction
E(t)
Lmuag
eJement
1}
0 -
(c)
Losing M odel
element aynchrooiter
^ /V v v V ^ ja >
N
E (t) = Y l pn c°s {[w + (n - 1)Q]< - <pn} (1.1)
n=1
is very sensitive to the phase statistics <pn . For the independent modes, the
probability density
and the field E (t ) becomes, in fact, the intensive optical noise with the correla
tion time rc « 1/NQ, N = Au>a/Q. W hen the modes are phase-matched via
their nonlinear interaction, i.e., by the self-mode-locking, or by the external ac
tion at the intermodal frequency, i.e., the active mode-locking, the regular train
o f pulses appears with the repetition rate Q and duration rp tv \/N£l , and the
resulting field takes the form
. sin (NSlt/'l') . . /T ..
£ W = P sm(Stt/2) CQ5(“ ‘ - y»)- (I'2>
Mirror Mirror
■ m
J^Mxing medium
1
Dye
<P) (expander) (amplifier, filter)
Delay 2L/c
--------- ------------------------ >
(O)
<4)
^ M
t
Saturable Saturable
absorber ibeoxber
(e)
FIG . 1.3. Tem poral evolution o f pulses in a m ultim ode laser with a nonlinear
absorber (spectrum expander): (a ) schem atic diagram of a laser; ( 6) equivalent
block diagram; (c) dye transmission as intensity function; (d) reshaping o f a
pulse due to its cycling through a saturable absorber; (e) enrichment o f a gen
eration spectrum . It is seen how the join t action o f an amplifier and nonlinear
absorber results in pulse com pression, which can be treated in the spectral dom ain
as involvement o f many phase-m atched m od es in the generation.
catching up with the low-frequency components located at the front o f the pulse
during its propagation through a dispersive delay line.
Introduction 7
function is shown in Fig. 1.3 (c) , compresses the pulse during its repeated circu
lations through the resonator. The time-domain approach allows one to trace the
transition to the mode-locked state and to analyze the phenomena that cannot
be studied in terms o f steady-state spectral description.
The general concepts underlying the methods of ultrashort optical pulse gen
eration by phase-matching the com ponents of discrete or continuous spectra
came to optics from radiophysics. The multimode laser whose modes are self
locked due to interaction in a medium with nonlinear absorption is an analog o f
a conventional radio-frequency short-pulse oscillator. The compression o f phase-
modulated signals was utilized as early as in the sixties to raise the peak power
in radar systems. The modern techniques o f linear and nonlinear optics allowed
these principles to be realized more efficiently than has been done in radio engi
neering.
It is worth mentioning that the principles discussed here have direct analogies
in classical optics o f wave beams. Indeed, the problem o f generation o f a short
pulse train by superposition o f synchronized discrete modes is similar to the clas
sical problem o f plane wave diffraction by an amplitude grating, with Eq. (1.2)
coinciding with the known formula for a diffraction grating. The compression of
a phase-modulated signal by a dispersive element (an optical compressor) is a
temporal analog o f spatial beam focusing by a lens.
T h e phase control o f an optical wave constitutes a com m on main feature in
all o f these cases. The spatial phase control technique was, in fact, mastered by
optical engineers already in the last century. The fast phase control applied for
generation o f ultrashort pulses has been perfected in recent years. Obviously,
it has to be based on systems with rapidly changing parameters. Since in the
ultimate case the rates o f these changes are compared with periods o f optical
oscillations, the most promising way to solve the problem is to control the optical
wave itself using fast optical nonlinearity. This explains the interest in nonlinear
interactions and self-actions o f short optical pulses propagating in media with
fast nonlinear response.
T h e generation o f ultrashort pulses is not the only stimulus for this kind
o f research. Nonlinear optics contributed significantly to the physics o f solitons.
The transient nonlinear interactions are utilized in efficient methods o f nonlinear
laser spectroscopy.
In this book the main emphasis is put on the results obtained in nonlinear
optics o f wave packets during the last decade.
T h e early stage o f research devoted to generators and optics o f short pulses is
surveyed by Hellworth and De Maria et al. 7 The state o f the art achieved by
1975 is reviewed in the collective monograph written by the leading experts in
the area o f picosecond physics and technology.
The twenty-fifth anniversary o f the first laser was celebrated in 1985. The
history o f development o f the fundamental ideas in quantum electronics and laser
physics is reviewed in the papers by Prokhorov 9 and B a so v .10 Some aspects
o f picosecond and femtosecond laser physics and technology are discussed in the
review s,11 13 Finally, the latest monographs 14 ’ 15 have to be also mentioned.
1. Short optical pulses
in linear dispersive media
M o d e m laser system s can produce light pulses so short as to consist o f only a few optical
oscillation periods. Even in the case o f a weakly dispersive m edium — that is, far from
the resonances and over very short distances — the linear propagation o f such pulses dif
fers dram atically from the conventional group-velocity propagation o f wave packets with
invariable envelope. A dispersive m edium can change the wave form o f short pulses to a
large extent. C hoosing the proper initial phase m odulation o f a pulse and the dispersion
sign, one can intentionally control the pulse shape, e.g., compress it effectively ( “time focus
ing” ). T h e effects arising due to propagation o f short optical pulses in a dispersive m edium
are similar in m any respects to the diffraction phenom ena accom panying propagation and
transform ation o f narrow light beam s. In som e cases the precise spatio-tem poral analogy
can be traced betw een these seemingly contrasting phenom ena. Many im portant problem s
are related to transmission o f short light pulses through optical devices and to the joint
action o f diffraction and dispersion effects. M ost of these problem s are treated by Fourier
optics o f wave packets.
T he present-day progress of experimental optics o f wave packets propagating in dispersive
m edia is w holly due to such achievements o f laser physics as the m od e locking technique,
fast phase m odulation o f light, dynam ic interferometry, and intensity interferometry. O n the
other hand, the dispersion effects accom panying propagation o f short wave packets can in
principle b e studied using traditional noncoherent light sources which are in fact the optical
noise generators w ith correlation times in the picosecond or fem tosecond range.
dispersive spreading o f the packet (see the detailed discussion in the monograph
by Ginzburg ) as well as to the precursors emerging when a short pulse interacts
with a dispersive medium. The modern status o f this classical problem can be
80
found elsewhere. However, until the late sixties the experimental optics failed
to contribute significantly to the studies o f the problems mentioned above. The
pulsed optical sources (including the first pulsed lasers) remained, in essence, the
generators o f relatively long bursts o f optical noise whose durations rp ~ 10 —
1000 ns were much longer than the correlation time rc o f radiation ( r rc ).
Therefore, the spectral radiation bandwidth Aw ;§> 1 /t p-
Naturally, under such conditions there could not be any possibility o f investi
gating the envelope and phase transformations o f a propagating pulse and, even
less, o f any control over these parameters in time. That is why the experimental
evidence o f precursors, for example, has been obtained first in the microwave
21
range. In contrast, the experimental technique for shaping and transforming
optical beams had been making progress before the advent o f lasers.
Physicists had learned how to control the phase o f optical radiation in space
with a high degree o f precision already in the last century. This accomplishment
provided a basis for making diverse diffraction instruments, developing the beam
focusing technique and methods o f image transformation and filtering. The
theoretical support o f these methods was furnished by advanced Fourier optics
o f wave beams.
In recent years the optical pulse shaping technique has been rapidly improving.
It has been augmented by the addition o f effective methods of control over the
envelope and phase o f optical oscillations in the picosecond and femtosecond
time scales. Today so-called transform-limited pulses as short as 10 fs became
a reality. Such pulses whose spectral width is determined only by the envelope
shape and for which rpAui ~ 1 , are quite analogous to diffraction-limited light
beams. A t the same time, the methods o f fast regular phase modulation of short
optical pulses have been developed. The principle o f these methods is based
8 9
on using a low-inertia nonresonant, nonlinear response o f condensed media. ’
The sophisticated technique has been also developed to measure the envelope
and phase o f short laser pulses (see Sec. 6.8).
The dispersion effects, just as the diffraction o f wave beams, can be used
for construction o f various systems for compressing and reshaping short pulses.
For this reason, the Fourier optics o f wave packets propagating in a dispersive
medium has recently undergone rapid development. In essence, the problems
to be solved are similar to the problems of formation and diffraction o f light
beams. In the quasioptical approximation they are described by the parabolic
18
equation introduced into the wave theory by Leontovich. The general problems
o f the Fourier optics o f wave packets are discussed in the review 10 and the
monograph 11 by Wainshtein.
This chapter describes the linear optics o f light pulses in dispersive media
with an emphasis on the current applied problems associated primarily with
compression and reshaping o f optical pulses o f specified profile.
1.1. Linear propagation o f short optical pulses 11
M ethods o f description
02 c ot
= 111
( . . )
oo
D(t, z) = J e0( t ') E ( t -t ', z)dt' (1.1.2)
o
+oo
E (t . z) = j E{w)ei(wt~ks)dw (1.1.3)
— 00
(the direction o f the z-axis coincides with that o f the vector k ), we obtain from
Eqs. (1.1.1) and (1.1.2) the dispersion relation
= 7 \ A oH = 7 no(w)> ( LL4)
where
OO
Jo(w) = j e 0(t)e~ lwt dt (1,1,5)
The dispersion o f a medium is seen to affect only the phase o f the Fourier com
ponents o f a pulse provided £0(w) is real, i.e., the absorption is inessential. The
spectral density s(w , z) — 2ir|E(w , z )|2 does not contain any phase at all and
therefore the spectral shape o f a pulse does not vary in a linear nonabsorbing
medium :
s(u , z) = s0(w). (1.1.7)
12 1. Short optical pulses m linear dispersive media
Knowing the k(uj) dependence o f Eq. (1.1.4) and making use o f Eq. (1.1.3)
one can in principle calculate the field strength at any distance z in a dispersive
medium. The exact analytical solutions, however, can be obtained, as a rule, only
in comparatively simple cases. Accordingly, the approximation methods based
on simplifying assumptions o f the initial Eq. (1.1.1) find extensive application
even in the analysis o f linear propagation o f wave packets.
The equations describing the propagation o f a short optical wave packet can
be efficiently estimated using the slowly varying amplitude (SVA) approxima
tion. 6 ’ 18 This m ethod is based on a natural assumption about slow change o f the
com plex amplitude o f a pulse during the average oscillation period T0 = 27r/u>0 ,
u>0 being the average frequency o f the pulse, and over the average wavelength
A0 = cT0/n(u>0). Such an approach is valid up to pulse lengths Tp/ T 0 w 10 . The
SVA approximation is thus applicable to the most problems o f linear (as well as
nonlinear, as we shall see later) optics o f femtosecond pulses. On the other hand,
the m odern laser physics has produced such an unusual object as a laser pulse
consisting o f a single oscillation period. 84 Naturally, in this limiting case the
assumption o f a slowly varying com plex amplitude does not hold in principle.
The solution o f the integro-differential equations (1.1.1) and (1.1.2) can be
12 IT
found on the basis o f the SVA approximation in the form
D ( t , z)
where
-i p
\(d k \ 1 —c (1.1.11)
is the group velocity. The parameter k2 characterizes the dispersion o f the group
velocity in the first-order approximation:
1 du \ = _ W 0 n\ (1112)
* = (? * - du> J Wn
2 \du2 2irc \dX ) \
d3k 2 d3k
u — __ + 3 (1.1.13)
3 2 jfcn I h J ukn
etc.
In the continuous radiation field, the dispersion is usually referred to as normal
at dvjdui < 0 (or dn/dui > 0 ) and anomalous at dv/du> > 0 (or dn/dui < 0 ).
In the studies o f propagation o f short wave packets it is not the dispersion o f
phase velocity (which is known to define the behavior o f a m onochromatic wave)
that is o f greatest interest, but the dispersion o f group velocity. Thus, referring
to a normal or anomalous dispersion, we shall mean the sign o f group velocity
dispersion. The dispersion is called normal if du/dui < 0 and anomalous if
du/dui > 0. The definitions o f dispersion in terms o f phase velocity and group
velocity do not generally coincide. The frequency dependences o f phase velocity
and group velocity in the vicinity o f the resonance are shown in Fig. 1.1. The
behavior o f group velocity dispersion far from the resonance is characterized by
the graphs in Fig. 1.4 where the length Ld ~ |fc2|_1 [see Eq. (1.3.2)].
FIG . 1 . 1 . Dispersion o f phase and group velocities near a single uniform ly broad
ened resonance Q e .
Equation (1.1.10) is exact in the sense that it takes into account the dispersive
properties o f a linear medium. At the same time, for many cases o f propagation
o f ultrashort picosecond and femtosecond pulses the second-order approximation
o f the dispersion theory is adequate. In this approximation the equation that is
derived from Eq. (1.1.10) by neglecting the terms under the sum can be simplified
14 1. Short optical pulses m linear dispersive media
+ 00
A {t], z) = J A 0{ t ) G { r ] - t , z)d t, (1.1.15)
— OO
where
z) = (i27rfc2z )~ 1 /2 exp ~ ■
E ( t , r , z) = ± A ( r , z )e i(Wot~k° z) + c. c. (1.1.17)
M o d e ls o f o p t ic a l p u lses
Apart from the com plex amplitude A 0(t) , the pulses are also described by a
real envelope p 0(t) and a phase <p0(t) :
Let us consider first the deterministic pulses. In thegeneral case, the pulse
duration is convenient to define as a root-mean-square value :
where
+oo
yyo' 1
W J tn \A0(t)\2 dt, n =l, 2,3,.. ., (1.1.20a)
and
+ co
W
vyo = J |^0(t)|2 rft (1.1.20b)
is the energy o f the pulse. The spectral width o f a pulse is similarly described
in the general form as
A^ = [ ^ - ( “ )2]1 /2 . (1.1.21)
where
+ co
+ °°
is the spectral density o f the pulse. The rms duration o f the pulse and its spectral
width are related as
T
rm s
Aw rm s = K —
> 1/2.
/
(1.1.23)' /
Then the change o f the instantaneous frequency varies linearly with time t as
In the last relation, Eq. (1.1.26) is taken into account. Frequency modulation
o f optical pulses is often called “ chirp” . The form (1.1.28) o f FM corresponds to
a linear chirp.
A super-Gaussian pulse. Concurrent with Eqs. (1.1.24) and (1.1.25), some
other models are used for the analysis o f propagation and transformation o f
ultrashort pulses. In particular, a super-Gaussian pulse should be mentioned
whose shape is close to a rectangular form:
^o(f) = Po exP - - ( 1 + ia )
^ \T,
(1.1.30)
o f a super-Gaussian pulse is the greatest at its front and tail. Its rms duration
is equal to
(1.1.33)
(t + t )) = cr R ( t ) , (1.1.34)
-(2n + 1 - N )Q + <pn
where n is the number and pn the amplitude o f a mode, and 0 is the inter-
}■ (1.1.35)
m odal beat frequency. The phases <pn o f modes are independent random values
uniformly distributed in the interval [—n , tt]. For a sufficiently large number
N o f modes the process statistics (1.1.35) with discrete spectrum is close to
G aussian.16
(«
(b
->■
t
( 1.2.1)
The field strength in a medium is described by Eq. (1.1.3) which can be rewritten
in a more convenient form as
OO
E (t z) d t , ( 1 .2 .2)
0
—oo
For a detailed calculation o f the field structure in the time interval [ts , i ]
it is necessary to specify the definite form o f the dispersion k(cv) = um(oj)/c.
Restricting ourselves as before by the case o f the normal dispersion, we shall
express the refraction index o f a medium in the form
Let us rewrite the solution (1.2.2) in terms o f the initial pulse (1.2.1):
+ 00
E(,, ,) = £ „ /
J U)n — U)
(L2.5)
—co u
+ 00
E{6 , C) ~ ~E QJ ^ 2 exp[i(w0 + C/w)] dui, (1.2.6)
— CO
where Jx{x ) is the Bessel function o f real argument. At 0 < 0.5 the value
E{9 , Q & ■ Consequently, reaching a point z in the medium at the
moment t s , the Sommerfeld precursor starts growing from the zero amplitude.
W hen the intervals are short (w0# <C 1) , the amplitude o f the precursor is small
compared to the initial amplitude EQ . As the interval 9 becomes longer, the
~ 2 ~
oscillation amplitude and period T grow. At £6 > 1 the period Tosc m tt /C
and is independent o f the carrier frequency oj0 (see Fig. 1.2).
At longer intervals, a new perturbation phase appears, which is referred to
as a Brillouin precursor. In this case the principal contribution to (1.2.5) is
provided by low frequencies in the vicinity o f poles u> — =fcu>0 ,
W hen k2 > 0 , we have the normal dispersion o f group velocity and when k2 < 0 ,
the dispersion is anomalous.
Let us discuss the propagation o f transform-limited pulses. The explicit
analytical results can be obtained for Gaussian pulses (1.1.25). According to
Eq. (1.1.15) the com plex amplitude o f the puke in the medium is equal to
1 t2
A { t , z) = V0 1/2{z)p Qexp + i<p(t, z) (1.3.2)
2 V f r ) r t2
where
Va2(z) = 1 + (z/Ld) 2 ,L d = L f = r 2
J \ k 2\,
^ , z) = _ J arctan
2 Vo ( z ) k 2z 2 ro
A t the same time, as it was noted before, the spectral width o f a wave packet
remains constant in a linear medium. That decrease in the contribution to the
envelope modulation spectrum is offset by the appearance o f phase (frequency)
modulation. Besides, according to Eq. (1.3.2) the rate o f frequency variation
a ( z ) = du>/dt = d 2>
p /dt2 is equal to
FIG . 1.3. Relative duration r = t ^(z )/t q (a ) and relative rate o f frequency
variation or = at(z)/aQ ( 6) o f an optical pulse as a function o f the distance
traversed £ = z/L>£ in a linear dispersive m edium : ( 1) pulse w ithout P M ,
c*0 = 0 , a = cx( z ) tq ; { 2 ) P M pulse, ^ a oTo = 2 .0 ; ( 3 ) P M pulse,
2
c*o^2 ^ ^ ’ “ o To — 2.0 .
Ldycm Ld,c/n
FIG . 1,4. Dispersive spreading for water (a) and crystals ( 6) as a function
o f the mean wavelength o f an ultrashort pulse o f duration r 0 = 0.1 p s . 19 Also
shown is the dependence o f the refractive index o f water.
E q- ( L 3 -4)!-
Just as in the case o f light beam diffraction, one can identify the near-field
zone ( z < Ld) and the far-field (Fraunhofer) zone (z L d) while analyzing
the dispersive spreading o f an optical pulse. In the near-field zone the pulse
1.3. Wave packets in a homogeneous dispersive medium 23
\k2\z
From Eq. (1.3.3) it is easy to find the initial duration r0 for which the pulse
1/O
has the shortest duration rmin(L) = V 2 r t , where ropt = (|fc2|i) = tq ,
after traveling a distance I in a dispersive medium. The shorter initial pulses
undergo wider dispersive spreading.
The second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory predicts the invari
able envelope o f a propagating Gaussian pulse. Envelope distortion o f non-
Gaussian pulses is treated in Sec. 1.4. Since in this case the pulse envelope
transformation cannot be obtained in an explicit form, one usually calculates
only the rms duration rrms (1.1.19). For example, in the absence o f PM , a
super-Gaussian pulse (1.1.30) has the duration
where f rms0 is given by Eq. (1.1.32). For m = 1 Eq. (1.3.6) coincides with
Eq. (1.3.3). For m 1 , we have
1/2
2 TO / k ~ Z
(z ) (1.3.7)
It follows from this expression that a super-Gaussian pulse can spread in a dis
persive medium much wider than a Gaussian pulse. The dispersive spreading of
a pulse becomes more pronounced in the pulses whose initial shape is closer to
rectangular.
<d z + 2 dt2 6 d i3 ) ’ } ~ (L 3 8)
+00
A ( t , z) = j A 0( t l ) G 3( t - t 1 , z ) d t 1 , (1.3.9)
24 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
where
+00
G, z) = (2 x )_1 J exp —i
k„z
6
k„z
w H— — w — ( i —i ,) w
2 v 11
duj
is the Green function. Even for an initially Gaussian pulse, the amplitude
A ( t , z) can be found only approximately at |i| —►00 by the steepest descent
method. Accordingly, let us turn to the results o f numerical calculations o f
the envelope p (t) , shown in Fig. 1.5, where the curves are drawn for different
values o f dispersion parameters
C — C2 —■ ^ 2 Z / r 0 > *>3 — ^ 3 2 / ^ T0 •
(1.3.10)
From Fig. 1.5 it follows that the cubic dispersion o f a medium at £3 > 0
brings about the modulation o f the falling edge o f the pulse, with the leading
edge remaining smooth. When <^3 < 0 , the situation is reversed. The pulse
1.3. Wave packets m a homogeneous dispersive medium 25
+ 00
2
» , 3 1 2 1 «x )
H ( x ) = T T /T t 1 + < 3 X) _1/2 exP (1.3.12)
2x “ i* 4 1 + i(„x
1/2
1 dH (x) \ 2 _ f 1 d2H (x )
(z) =
sV /
(1.3.13)
H {x) dx J x=0 \ H (x) dx2
t™ sw = (1.3.14a)
= >Vm, 0 [l + ( . / I , ) ’ + W i f ) ’ ] (1.3.14b)
Lf = ^ o /iy (1.3.15)
where
L' d{? =
~ [1
L-1- +' (fc3/2fc2r0)
V " '3 / '“ ' " 2 ' 0 / T
J 1/2L
^ d, "
(1.3.17)
+ o o +C O
Suppose that a pulse has the following form before entering a dispersive medium:
1 , -
o ( ro + ia o)r (1.4.1)
A > ( 0 = Po e x P
Let us trace the evolution o f the pulse in terms o f the second-order approximation
o f the dispersion theory. In accordance with Eq. (1.1.15) the com plex amplitude
o f the pulse in the medium
1 To + ia o
A ( t , z) = f 1/2(z) pQexp (1.4.2)
2 /(* )
where
f ( z ) = l - a 0k2z + ik2z/r0 .
1 tl
p (t , z) = V 1/2 (z) p Qexp (1.4.3)
2 V 2( z ) t?
_ l k2z { a 0 + T0 4) - a 0 2 1 k2z
- t — —arctan — (1.4.4)
¥>(< - * ) = 2
V 2(z) 2 To ( l ~ a Ok 2 Z)
If a 0fc2 < 0 , a PM pulse spreads faster than a non-modulated one. If a ak2 > 0 ,
the PM pulse first gets compressed and then starts spreading [cf. curves 2, 3 in
Fig. 1.3 (a )]. The shortest pulse duration
2.2, —1/2
r m in = + 1
(1.4.7)
is realized at a distance z = L :
i 2\2
W o ) a o To
L = (1.4.8)
11 i / 2\2 '
*0*21!+ 0 V o ) ] 1 + ( a oro)
28 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
„w = + f ) - (1 4 9)
(1 - < * 0k 2z) + ( z / L d)
is illustrated by the graphs in Fig. 1.3 (b) , In the region o f maximum compres
sion o f the pulse the rate o f frequency modulation a ( L c) = 0 and the duration
Tmin defined by the total spectral width. In other words, in the case o f the opti
mum compression the pulse turns transform-limited. The transition o f the pulse
through the region o f maximum compression is accompanied with the reversal
o f the sign o f a ( z ) [see curve 3 in Fig. 1.3 (6)].
Compression, or time focusing, o f pulses is undoubtedly the most interesting
effect arising during their propagation in dispersive media. The most efficient
compression takes place when a pulse with PM varying quadratically with time
travels in a medium with quadratic dispersion. This phenomenon is quite similar
to the aberration-free focusing o f light beams by a lens. It is known, however,
that such ideal performance is very difficult to realize due to various aberrations.
The situation is exactly the same as in the case o f time focusing o f optical pulses.
The cubic- and higher-order dispersion o f a medium, as well as nonquadratic PM
o f the initial pulse lead to temporal aberrations.
Let us begin with the analysis o f effects arising in the third-order approxi
mation o f the dispersion theory. According to Eqs. (1.3.8) and (1.4.1) the rms
duration o f the pulse [see also Ref. 20]
7"
, 2 x2 1/2
C — rms 0 __ 1 + ________ K ro) (1.4.12)
rms
rms min 1 + (2W o ) [ ^ ( “o^) ]
From Eqs. (1.4.11) and (1.4.12) it follows that the cubic dispersion o f the medium
leads to the decrease in the length Lc and compression ratio 5 rms . The effi
ciency o f compression o f PM pulses diminishes with growth o f k3 .
Now let us examine the effects that appear when the initial phase modulation
is nonquadratic:
1-4- Fourier optics o f wave packets 29
= i [i + (<*07-02)2 + (/ y 03)2]1/2
rm s o V /
Z rm s 0
It is seen from here that the quadratic term in phase modulation leads to reduc
tion in the effective dispersion length. The minimal pulse duration is therefore
attained over the length that is shorter than (1.4.8) by the amount
Lc = Li ^
14- ({aoTa) + (/Vo)
v (L 4 -16)
Thus, the addition o f a cubic term to the phase (bQ ^ 0) impairs the conditions
o f compression. It should be also noted that in the absence o f linear FM ( a Q = 0)
the pulse spreads [see Eq. (1.4.15)].
The compression ratio S is not a monotone function o f the pulse duration.
Srm s reaches its maximum value
at theduration ropt = ( 4 /5 ) 1^6/?0 1^3 . From Eqs. (1.4.14) and (1.4.17) we get
= i [i + ( / y 03) 2]1/2
rm s m in 2 Aw ' ( • ' )
rm s
system, we shall discuss now the basic compression stages using both the time
and the spectral terminology.
Let us consider once again a Gaussian pulse (1.4.1) with quadratic PM . Its
total phase is Q(t) = u>Qt — a Qt 2/2 and instantaneous frequency
d k\ dk\
Lc = k2LcA w P
0m. (1.4.20)
27-0 « A *d - ( Wh u] ) L - du)c du).
1 ( W
A 0(Q = u> - u>Q) = ' pQexp .2x2 (1.4.21)
2 i + O Vb)
A (Q , z) = K ( Q , z ) \ { 0 ) , (1.4.23)
32 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
(a.)
FIG . 1.7. Variation u<(t) o f instantaneous frequency o f a pulse and time de
lay in a m edium with normal (a ) and anom alous ( b) dispersion during
com pression o f optical pulses.
*In the general case the phase m atching con dition (1.4.25) guarantees only that the resulting
am plitude will be m axim um , since the con cep t of a pulse duration is ambiguous for pulses of
com plex shape.
1.4■ Fourier optics o f wave packets 33
It can be easily shown that from this relationship follows Eq. (1.4.8) for the
compression length Lc . Performing the inverse Fourier transformation, we can
obtain from Eqs. (1.4.23) and (1.4.25) the expression (1.4.7) for the minimal
pulse
r duration rnun
. .
Under optim um compression conditions the compression ratio
FIG . 1.8. Phase control o f light waves in space and in time, (a ) and ( 6) (for r )
Beam focusing b y a lens; beam shape: ( I ) in front o f the lens, (2) im m ediately
after the lens, (5) in the area o f beam waist, and ( 4 ) in the focal plane / o f the
lens (dashed lines, wave front o f a b ea m ). ( 6) (for t) and (c) Com pression o f FM
pulse in a m edium with normal dispersion; pulse profile shape: ( i ) at the input of
the frequency m odulator, ( 2 ) at the com pressor input, (5) in the area o f optim al
com pression, and (4) in the “foca l” plane. (<£) Phase ip(t) (dashed lines) and
the frequency w(<) (solid lines) in the same cross sections o f the m edium .
Compression o f FM pulses has many com mon features with focusing o f optical
beams. In Figs. 1.8 (a) , 1.8 (6) the shape o f a beam and a wavefront are shown
for different locations within a medium. The envelope profiles and frequency
modulation at certain stages o f pulse compression are depicted in Figs. 1.8(fe)-
1.8(d) . From the comparison o f both processes it follows that pulse compression
can be treated as time focusing, with the frequency modulator acting as a “time
34 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
lens.” The region o f optimum pulse compression is equivalent to the region o f the
beam waist. On passing through the region o f optimum compression the sign o f
FM reverses [see Fig. 1.3 (6) , curve 3\ similarly to the reversal in the phase front
curvature o f the beam crossing the region of the beam waist. Note that in the
case o f beam focusing the intensity in the waist grows proportional to the square
o f the ratio o f beam radii, while in the case o f pulse compression the power grows
proportional to the ratio o f their durations. Here lies the fundamental difference
caused by the different dimensions of the beams and pulses.
The focal length o f a “time lens” is the parameter
F = ( a 0k2) ~ 1 (1.4.27)
This value is obtained from Eq. (1.4.8) using the ray optics approximation under
2
the condition a QT0 1 , that is valid for pulses with strong frequency deviation.
Such pulses are analogous to strongly diverging optical beams. The FM pulses
can be directly produced by lasers, or obtained by means o f external modulation.
In the latter case, nanosecond pulses are usually modulated by electro-optical
means, whereas FM picosecond and femtosecond pulses are often generated using
self-phase modulation (see Sec. 2.2).
tp,"*.
1.5-
1.0
0.5
50 100 z.km
FIG. 1.9. Com pression o f P M pulses in a linear optical fiber. Experim ental
pulse durations are shown as a function o f distance. 28
Let us consider how the pulses whose shapes differ from Gaussian are compressed.
For clarity, we shall examine a PM super-Gaussian pulse (1.1.30). In the second-
order approximation o f the dispersion theory the rms duration o f such a pulse is
l.Jf. Fourier optics of wave packets 35
53
equal to
(1 .4 .2 8 )
Tr m s ( Z ) = t1 - f l ( Zf L d) + A W A l) 1 ' Trm s 0 >
where
2 T ( 2 - l/2 m )
A a
r(3/2m) ’ A = (1+ “ )m r(3/2m)
For definiteness, in Eq. ( 1 .4 .2 8 ) it is assumed that k2 > 0 . If a > 0 , then at a
distance
r ( l + l / 2 m)
L (m ) = ( 1 .4 .2 9 )
m r (2 - 1 /2 m) 1 + a 2 d
the rms duration reaches the minimal value and
1/2
1 3r ( 1 -f l/2 m )
1+ ( 1 .4 .3 0 )
1 -f a 2 2 m r (l + 3 /2 m )T (2 — l /2 m )
rm s 0
It follows from Eq. (1.4.30) that the minimal duration rrms min becomes longer
as the initial pulse approaches the rectangular shape, that is, with m growing.
In other words, the compression ratio o f a super-Gaussian pulse turns out to
be lower in comparison with a Gaussian pulse. The compression length also
decreases as m grows.
Let us analyze the propagation o f PM pulses in dispersive media for the arbitrary
initial envelope shape. Such analysis will make it possible to establish some
interesting and useful properties o f the optical pulse deformation that may be
utilized in laser physics and optical communication.
In the second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory one can obtain
the rigorous solution for the Gaussian pulse profile, and therefore the envelope
o f an arbitrary pulse in a dispersive medium can be calculated easily enough. By
analogy with the method used in the theory o f wave beams, the optical pulse is,
55
in this case, expanded in terms o f Gaussian wave packets.
A ccording to the second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory, the
evolution of thispulse in the medium is described by Eq.( 1 . 1 . 1 5 ) . Supposing
that theconsidered pulse o f an arbitrary profile p 0 ( t ) has thelinear chirp
= P o i * ) e x v ( - i a 0t 2/ 2 ) . ( 1 .4 .3 1 )
We can expand the pulse profile in a series o f the Hermitian polynomials H m (x)
P o W = £ Pm H m ( t / r 0) e x p ( - t 2/ 2 r 2) , (1 .4 .3 2 )
m= 0
where
+00
pm = x-1 /2 2-m (m!)_1 J p 0 (T0x ) H m ( x ) e x v ( - x 2/ 2 ) d x .
— OO
36 1. Short optical pulses m linear dispersive media
X l ~ o ^ + i ^ l?l z ) - m i p ( z ) ] \ , (1.4.33)
I 2 rp (z) J
where <p(t], z ) , V ( z ) , and t (z) are defined in Eqs. (1.4.4), (1.4.5), and
(1.4.6), respectively, and
k 2z
ip = arctan—j------- ------------.
r0 — a 0 ^ 2Z )
From Eq. (1.4.33) it is seen that all “modes” o f the pulse behave identically:
the same parameters characterize the duration and the phase o f the “modes.”
Naturally, this result obtained for pulses should have been expected by analogy
with the result obtained for beams. 56
Equation (1.4.33) has certain advantages in calculations o f the profile evolu
tion o f the pulse and its phase variation since the shape o f laser pulses is usually
close to Gaussian. From 20 to 30 terms in Eq. (1.4.33) are sufficient for accurate
approximation o f experimental data. 55 According to Eq. (1.4.33) the pulses
propagating in a dispersive medium possess the following inherent features. The
pulses whose envelopes are described by an even or odd function p 0(t) retain
their symmetry. The pulse with arbitrary pQ(t) becomes symmetrical at the
initial stage o f propagation and then starts broadening. One can make sure that
a pulse o f arbitrary shape becomes indeed symmetrical in the far-field zone with
out resorting to the expansion into the “modes.” In so doing, some additional
qualities o f the pulse transformed in a dispersive medium can be disclosed.
A spectron; the pulse shape in the far-field zone. Substituting Eq. (1.4.31)
into Eq. (1.1.15) we obtain
+ oo
‘( t - t j f a Qt I''
A(t, z ) = (i2irk2z ) ~ 1/2 j P oitjexp dt. (1.4.34)
2k2z
J )
+ oo
1 -
From the obtained result it is possible to draw the following conclusion about
the pulse in the “focal” plane o f the “ time lens” . The pulse shape is exactly
. . . 23 29
identical with the shape o f the Fourier spectrum o f the initial pulse. ’ Such
pulses are called spectrons. 30 ’ 31
The pulse envelope p i t , F ) turns out to be symmetric independently o f
the initial envelope p0(t) [see Fig. 1.10] with the exception o f an asymmetric
envelope described by an odd function pQ(t) . The transformed symmetric (or
asymmetric) pulse has the linear chirp, whose rate coincides with that o f input
FM but has the opposite sign.
Using Eqs. (1.1.19) and (1.1.21), one can demonstrate that the rms duration
o f the transformed pulse rrms = A u m s / a 0 , where Awrms is the rms spectral
width. Therefore, if « Qr > 1 , the pulse is narrower than the initial one, and
for a;0Trms < 1 it is wider. The described pulse properties are analogous to those
o f a light beam in the focal plane o f a lens. In the absence o f FM ( a Q = 0) , the
pulses have the described properties in a dispersive medium in the far-field zone
(z > - Ld) . In this case, it is possible to neglect the exponential term t^/2k2z in
Eq. (1.4.34) and reduce it to the form similar to Eq. (1,4.35). This property is
also completely analogous to the properties o f wave beams.
Pulse shape reversal. The “ time lenses” (frequency modulators) can be used
as basic elements in schemes for optical pulse modification that are analogous to
7 32
the schemes for the formation o f light beams and images. ’
As an example, we shall consider m odification o f an optical pulse by the
• 31
system “dispersive medium — frequency modulator — dispersive medium” .
38 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
Having passed the modulator, the pulse acquires the complex amplitude
-f-oo
where z j and z2 are the distances traversed by the pulse before and after the
modulator. If the condition
l/ z1 + l/ z 2 = l / F , (1.4.37)
which is equivalent to the lens formula in the ray optics approximation, holds,
then from Eq. (1.4.36) we obtain
It follows from here that the pulse shape is reversed in time relative to the initial
33
pulse (see the sign in the argument p Q). The amplitude o f the pulse changes
1/ 2
by the factor {z x/z2) and its duration by the factor z2j z r , Depending on
the value z2/zx , the pulse will be either compressed (z 2/z1 < 1) or broadened
(z 2/z \ > 1) • The pulse has frequency modulation with the sign opposite to
that o f FM provided by the modulator. An example o f the optical pulse profile
reversed in time is shown in Fig. 1.10 ( c ) .
Although in this section we deal only with deformation o f pulses with real am
plitude, the conclusions drawn remain in most cases valid for com plex amplitudes
as well, i.e., after the substitution in Eq. (1.4.38)
Needless to say that in this case some additional effects associated with the
phase <p0(t) appear. If <p0(t) is an od d function, the phase o f the pulse turns
out to be also reversed in time just as the pulse envelope. It is evident that if
the initial pulse, before its passage through the frequency modulator, was phase
modulated [y?0(<) = —a t 2/2 ], then the transformed pulse has no FM provided
a / a 0 = z2/z1. '
Transformation o f optical pulses into pulses reversed in time provides the pos
sibility to realize the time convolution in optics. The measurement o f convolution
33
can be used, for example, for the reconstruction o f an envelope shape. The
stretching o f pulses without changes in their shape can be obviously used for
conversion o f ultrashort pulses from one range o f durations to another one in
which the envelope shape can be easily measured.
L, Xi
L* if
where p 1(x ) allows for the finite dimensions o f the aperture o f element 1 (for sim
plicity, a two-dimensional case is considered). In the rear focal plane (the Fourier
*D iffraction o f a spatially lim ited wave packet by a grating is considered in Sec. 1.5.
40 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
We shall find the Fourier spectrum o f the field at the output o f element 2 taking
into account its transfer coefficient: t 4 ( Q , x ) = K ( Q , x) A 2(£ l, x) . Passing
in this expression from frequency Q to time and integrating over x , we obtain
the temporal dependence o f the radiation amplitude at the output o f the system
+ co
A (t)= J A 0( T ) G ( t - r ) d t , (1.4.45)
— CO
where
-f co
is the Green function o f the whole system. Here K A x ) is the Fourier transform
of K t( x ) .
It follows from Eq. (1.4.45) that the temporal response o f an optical system
can be controlled by changing its spatial response K t (x ) . As to the aperture
functions pt (x) and p2(x ) , their basic contribution consists in restricting the
response time T o f the system. For / <C T the function
G(t) ~ K t (t/k0q). (1.4.47)
In Chaps. 4 and 6 we shall provide some specific examples illustrating how one
can use these ideas o f profile reshaping o f ultrashort optical pulses.
1.5. Transmission o f ultrashort light pulses through optical devices 41
The Fourier components o f a pulse at the input and output o f a dispersive optical
device are related in the spectral domain as
In the general case, the transmission coefficient K (fi) o f the device is expressed
by a com plex function
The two contrasting situations may happen here. A more significant part may
be played either by the change o f the phase y?(0 ) or by the modulus o f the
transmission coefficient |/l(Q)|.
In the former case, K ( Q ) = K ( u 0)el<p^ and, assuming y?(0) to be a slowly
varying function, the dispersive properties are conveniently described as
The values o f (pQ and derivatives ip and ip" are taken at u> = u>g . There is
no need in individual calculations o f a pulse transformed by an optical device
with the given dispersion. The required expressions can be obtained from the
results o f Secs, 1.3 and 1.4, taking into account A'(wQ) and substituting —<p'Q
for the group velocity delay z j u and —tp"Q for the dispersion parameter k2z .
This is quite clear, since the phase grows in a medium as <p(ui) = —k (u ) z .
Besides, utilizing the expansion k (u ) into a power series o f Q = u — uig (1.3.1)
and comparing with Eq. (1.5.3), we can see that the substitutions are indeed
equivalent. This means that we can make use of, e.g., Eq. (1.4.2). Such an
approximation allows one to adequately describe, for example, the reflection o f
ultrashort optical pulses from the multiple-layer dielectric mirrors, or the total
internal reflection.
W hen the dependence |/f (Q)| is essential, the spectrum o f an ultrashort pulse
varies. Such systems act as optical filters. Let us consider how a short FM pulse
(1.4.1) is modified by a filter with the Gaussian transmission coefficient: 57
where A u f is the bandwidth o f the filter. W ith no FM, the pulse amplitude at
the output o f the filter is
e x p (— t2/2r2)
A {i) = Po~rT , P2 1 / 2 >(!-5-5a
[1 + (r0A Uf) ]
a c p [- (T p 2 + i a ) t 2/2]
' [1 + (r0Awf)~ 2 + io ^A o ;"2]1
where
2 , / ~ 2\ 2 , a
r2 _ % + ( t0 ) + A ^ f A - 2
Au, , (1.5.6b)
P — 2 i ~ 4 . - 2 . 2
a 0 + T0 + T0 Awf
Au)j
(1.5.6c)
“ o + ^ o + A w f )
57
The other extreme cases are possible
2 —2 —1
(i) a Q ;§> Awf , Tq , then t « , Awf , awO;
2 — 2
(ii) A w ( » a > t q , then r « Auf/a 0 , a » a 0;
2 —2 —1
(iii) a 0 < Awf , rQ , then r w rQ at A u f » t-q
Cases (i) and (ii) pertain to the strong FM whereas case (iii) to the weak
FM. The pulse duration in the latter case coincides with (1.5.5b). Thus, the
filtering o f an ultrashort FM pulse may bring about the conspicuous modification
o f its parameters. In case (i) the practically total suppression o f FM can be
observed. In the considered example the central transmission frequencies o f the
filter coincide with the central frequencies o f the pulse. Some other examples o f
optical filtering used as an ultrashort pulse shaping technique are discussed in
Chap. 4.
Since the phase and group velocities o f a pulse differ from one dispersive medium
to another, the planes o f equal phases and equal amplitudes do not coincide, when
1.5. Transmission o f ultrashort light pulses through optical devices 43
the pulse refracts at a boundary between the media. As a result, the transverse
group delay appears58 , and the refracted wave becomes in homogeneous. This
effect becomes appreciable for short pulses, since the delay time o f the amplitude
front relative to the wave (phase) front may be comparable to the pulse duration.
To examine this effect in more details, we shall consider a pulse with the
plane wave front coming from a nondispersive medium into a dispersive one
[see Fig. 1 .1 2 (a )]. The wave front o f the refracted pulse remains plane and
the phase delay times over the lengths A C — /j and B D = l2 are equal:
I J c = l2/vo — n o ^ / c >w^ere n o ~ n (OJo) ' s refractive index o f the dispersive
medium at a carrier frequency. However, the peaks of the pulses do not arrive
simultaneously at the points C and D located at the wave front and the group
delay between them
= ru ~ Tc = f\ ur - i VrQ k . ( 2-5-7)
(a) (b )
where 9 is the pulse refraction angle and kQ = u’g/vo ■ This expression can
be easily obtained, for example, from the continuity condition for the tangent
com ponent o f the vector jE7 at a boundary between the media. When rewritten
in the x 1z 1 coordinate system in which the wave front o f the pulse propagates
along the 0 z x axis, Eq. (1.5.8a) takes a more explicit form:
Z, ( 1 1
E (t , , 2^) t ----- - + X. I ---------- exp-0'[wo* - kazi\)- (l-5.8b)
u 1\u vn
44 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
The last term in the argument o f the amplitude determines the group delay [cf.
Eq. (1.5.7)] which is a function o f the transverse coordinate Xj .
According to Eq. (1.5.8b) the angle between the wave front and the amplitude
front is equal to
A t o = ao ( - ~ — sin (1.5.9b)
where the O z 2 axis coincides with the direction o f the pulse propagation. As
compared with Eq. (1.5.8b), the group delay has the opposite sign here.
A significant (although obvious) conclusion follows from the results presented
before. If an ultrashort pulse passes through a dispersive medium with parallel
input and output surfaces (e.g., a parallel-sided plate, lasing medium with Brew
ster’s angles), then there is no transverse group delay in the outgoing pulse. A
similar situation may arise when the pulse treated as a light beam passes through
a certain optical device, for example, a system o f prisms, and the paths covered
by different rays o f the beam in the dispersive media turn out to be equal. In
the opposite case, the transverse group delay is characteristic for a short optical
pulse.
The reflection o f a wave from the medium with lower optical density is known to
be characterized with a critical incidence angle ycr = arcsin(n2/ n 1) at the angles
exceeding 7 cr the incident wave totally reflects back into the medium with higher
optical density (n t > n2). In this case the reflected wave is accompanied by a
phase shift defined by the refractive indices and n2 and the incidence angle.
W hen an ultrashort pulse o f the visible range experiences total internal reflection
(T IR ), its phase shift proves to be strongly frequency-dependent, which results
in the pulse distortion. The reflection coefficient is calculated in the ordinary
59
way.
We use the com plex description o f the field in the form o f Eq. (1.1.3), so that
the, T IR coefficient
1.5. Transmission o f ultrashort light pulses through optical devices 45
2 2 2 1/ 2
ip — 2 arctan [tan 7 — (rc2/ n i) sec T] • (1.5.12)
Equation (1.5.11) pertains to the case when the wave polarization is perpendic
ular to its incidence plane. W hen dealing with T IR o f relatively long pulses with
spectral width Aw < wQ , the com plex amplitude o f the reflected pulse can be
-> . . 2
found from the ordinary expansion o f the. dielectric perm ittivity ( n 2/n1) = e
in Eq.(1.5.12):
This expansion leads to a frequency dependence o f the phase <p in the form
(1.5.3). Thus, in accordance with the results obtained in Secs. 1.3 and 1.4, it
becomes immediately clear that in the general case o f T IR an ultrashort pulse
may experience both the group delay and envelope distortion. Specifically, the
envelope distortion will be the strongest near the T IR angle.
A novel effect emerges when an optical pulse whose duration equals that o f
a single period o f the carrier frequency, i.e., when Aw0 « w0 , undergoes TIR.
In this case, the noticeable pulse distortion takes place even in the absence o f
dispersion. Such a situation has been practically realized for the reflection o f an
47
IR pulse with a single-period duration.
As an example, we shall consider T I R o f a pulse with the spectrum
where C is a constant. The pulses with such a spectrum are usually generated
in the Cherenkov radiation (see Sec. 3.5). Taking into account Eq. (1.5.11), we
obtain for the reflected pulse
i - -
6XP ' 2 7-02
t
cos ip — I erf sin ip 2C — sinv>, (1.5.14)
\/2 t
where
X
erft x — 2 If e ay.
0
When the incidence angle j is equal to the critical angle y cr exactly, the phases
o f the incident and reflected pulses in Eq. (1.5.14) should be assumed equal to
zero, <p — 0 . W hen <p ^ 0 , the shape o f the reflected pulse changes. The
value o f tp grows with J ( j > 7 cr) , increasing thereby the phase jum p o f
reflectivity near the zero frequency, and, consequently, amplifying the distortion
o f the reflected pulse.
46 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
The distortion o f the ultrashort pulse associated with the considered effect
was experimentally observed 47 in a pulse whose duration was close to one
period o f carrier frequency lying in the far IR. The pulse was excited in a lithium
tantalate crystal by the Cherenkov radiation from a visible ultrashort pulse. The
Cherenkov radiation fell on the boundary between the media at an angle o f 21 .
The critical angle j cr for LiTaO 3 crystal is equal to 8.7° , with the air being
the second medium. The authors o f Ref. 47 have observed the different pulse
profiles for the different conditions o f reflection (see Fig. 1.13). T o prove that
the pulse distortions are not associated with dispersion and absorption in the
LiTaO 3 crystal, the experiments have been performed for the reflection from
the boundary with silicon ( 7 = 31°) , with the incident and reflected pulses
having identical profile shapes. The Cherenkov generation o f the pulse and the
methods o f measurement of its duration are briefly described in Sec. 3.5.
The authors o f Ref. 91 measured the phase shift and reshaping o f terahertz
pulses due to T IR from quartz prism, using time-domain spectroscopic tech
niques. They obtained that measured value o f the phase shift is in excellent
agreement with the theoretical estimate calculated from Eq. (1.5.12).
E(t)
FIG . 1.13. Pulse shape in the case of tota l (solid line) and partial (dashed line)
internal reflection. 47 Field strength is given in arbitrary units.
Generally, both the amplitude reflection coefficient |r(w)| o f the mirror and
its phase <p{ui) can vary with frequency. In the reflection o f short pulses from
multiple-layer mirrors the frequency dependence (p(ui) is, in fact, predominant.
T o clarify some peculiar reflection properties o f such mirrors, the results obtained
in Secs. 1.3 and 1.4 may be used. Recall that from the expansion o f phase <p(ui)
[see Eq. (1.5.3)] and the subsequent analysis, the analogy between the patterns
o f the ultrashort pulse reflection and the propagation o f the pulse in a dispersive
medium can be observed. In other words, the multiple-layer dielectric mirror
reflecting a short pulse may bring about its linear transformation similar to the
transformation experienced by the pulse during its propagation in a dispersive
medium, e.g., the group delay, appearance o f phase modulation, profile distor
tion, etc. In particular, in the case o f reflection o f a PM Gaussian pulse from a
multiple-layer mirror, Eq. (1-4.2) is valid in the second-order approximation o f
the dispersion theory (see also Ref. 44).
The detailed theoretical study o f dispersive properties o f multiple-layer mir
rors in the second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory is reported in
Refs. 42-45, 60, and 61, where the values o f |r(w)|, <p(u) , and <p (w) are cal
culated for different numbers o f layers and different ratios o f the low (rij) and
high (n h) indices o f refraction. Also determined are tp{w) and <p"(w) as func
tions o f the deviation o f the layer thickness from Am/ 4 , and o f the detuning
o f frequency w from wm = 27rc/Am . Note that the dispersive properties o f the
medium were not taken into account, so that the variations o f phase (p(ui) and
ip (ui) are due to frequency dependence o f the result o f interference o f multiple
reflections inside the mirror structure (the so-called “dispersion” o f interference).
In Ref. 43 the group delay o f reflected pulses has been calculated and their
rms durations obtained as functions o f the ratio w /w m . Figure 1.14 illustrates
48 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
the frequency dependences R(u>) = |r(w) | 2 and ip"(ui) for a multiple-layer mir
ror (HL) 9 H. Here H(L) designates a layer with high (low) index o f refraction.
The authors of Ref. 44 observed a fast growth o f ip" with increasing number
o f layers and the ratio nh/n j . Figure 1.15 shows how the experimentally mea
sured duration o f a dye laser pulse varies with the total dispersion o f the cavity
mirrors. These data demonstrate how important are the dispersive properties
o f the mirrors in the ultrashort pulse production. Besides, it is also clearly seen
that the values o f ip" exceeding 2 x 10 28 s 2 inhibit the generation o f laser
pulses shorter than 50 fs.
The temporal evolution o f the amplitude o f the Gaussian pulses reflected from
multiple-layer mirrors has been calculated in Refs. 43 and 62 using the higher-
than-second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory. In Ref. 62, a cubic
term has been retained in the expansion o f phase <p(u>) . In the presence o f
resonance frequencies the function <p(ui) was specified analytically. It should be
noted that the results published in Ref. 62 agree with the theoretical results
derived for the ultrashort pulses propagating in a medium with cubic dispersion
(see Sec. 1.3). In Ref. 42 the change in the structure o f ultrashort pulses on
reflection from multiple-layer mirrors is suggested to be used in reflectometry
studies o f the mirror coatings.
65
F IG . 1.16. Reflection o f a pulse by a diffraction grating.
A0 and com plex amplitude A(x^ , t) (for the time being we consider a two-
dimensional case) falls on and reflects from a diffraction grating at the angles
7 0 and 60 , respectively (see Fig. 1.16). Let us expand the pulse into the plane
monochromatic waves:
-f o o
where the coefficient bm defines the grating efficiency in reflecting to the m-th
order o f diffraction (b < 1). The second cofactor in Eq. (1.5.18) represents, in
fact, the transfer function o f a dispersive device for a plane wave with frequency
ft = u - u 0 [cf. Eq. (1.4.40)].
In the time domain, the structure o f the reflected pulse takes the form
The pulse profile is seen to coincide with its initial profile, but the reflected pulse
has the transverse group delay A t = k0qx2 , and the angle between the ampli
tude front and the wave front equals ip = arc tan (k0cq) (see Fig. 1.16). This
50 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
angle depends on the carrier frequency w0 , the diffraction angle 0Q , and the
lattice parameter d . The transverse spatial size o f the pulse is changed by a
factor l/|f>|. Such a structure o f the reflected pulse is observed in the immediate
vicinity o f the diffraction grating. As the distance from the grating increases,
the diffractive spreading effects cause further pulse distortion. In Ref. 65 the
calculations o f the diffracted pulse have been published. The authors took into
account the fact that the diffraction lengths differ for different spectral com po
nents. Alternatively, disregarding this fact, one can assess the pulse structure at
a certain distance from the grating on the basis o f Eq. (1.1.16) by using a mov
ing coordinate system (z = z , rj = t — z f u ) and neglecting the group velocity
dispersion in the medium.
W hen an initial collimated pulse has the Gaussian spatial and temporal pro
files,
Here a is the transverse size of the reflected pulse along the x axis, ad is the
characteristic transverse group delay, and j is the generalized designation o f
subindices o f / and a .
The diffraction does not affect the pulse parameters at ip = 0 (q — 0)
since the pulse diffracts as a whole, and its different spectral components have
identical diffraction lengths. In the presence o f the transverse group delay and
in the case when q ^ 0 , the carrier frequency shift, proportional to the distance
z and to the transverse coordinate x , appears already in the near-field zone of
the reflected pulse [ /( z ) « f j ( z ) ss 1]. In the considered case the diffraction
brings about the change not only in the parameters o f the beam but also in the
parameters o f the pulse: it spreads and a linear chirp appears. At the same time,
the transverse group delay also changes the diffraction pattern o f the beam along
the x axis, that is, in the incidence plane o f the pulse.
According to Eq. (1.5.20) the duration o f the diffracted pulse is equal to
1/2
(1 + S2 + Szd) 2 + z 2
(1.5.22)
(1 + Z2)( 1 + z 2 + z z d'
d)
1.5. Transmission o f ultrashort light pulses through optical devices 51
2 2
Here the dimensionless lengths z = z/kQa and zd = z/kQad are used. The
inequality ad <C a corresponds to the most typical experimental conditions.
Furthermore, for wide beams (5 -C 1)
that is, the dependence of the pulse duration on the distance is the same as
in the presence o f group velocity dispersion [cf. Eq. (1.3.3)]. Thus, the angu-
lar dispersion o f the diffraction grating with dispersion parameter k0q proves
to be equivalent to the dispersion o f the group velocity. In the considered ap
proximation the value o f the angle ip remains constant during the propagation.
In Ref. 65 the variation o f ip is shown to be associated with the parameter
2pqz/aQT0 . In Ref. 64 the calculations are given for distortion o f a Gaussian
pulse diffracted by a finite grating.
To sum up, the above discussion indicates that an ultrashort pulse reflected by
a diffraction grating changes its parameters while propagating in a nondispersive
medium. There are two reasons for this phenomenon. One is the inclination o f
the amplitude front relative to the propagation direction. The other consists in
the difference in the diffraction lengths o f different spectral components o f the
pulse 65 . As a matter o f fact, we deal with so-called transient beam diffraction 15
that will be examined in more detail in the next section.
T0 = 2nh/c, A u tr = K u 0 , (1.5.24)
where h is the distance between the mirrors, n is the refractive index o f the
medium filling the inteferometer, and I t is the resolving power. In the time
domain, the value o f I t is determined by the time interval M T Q between arrivals
o f the first and the last interfering wave fronts, 48
f t = H / 2 w )M T0 , (1.5.25)
requires that the distance between the interferometer mirrors h = crQ/2n would
be less than 15 fJ,m . The construction o f such an interferometer presents consid
erable technological problems, which, however, are being successfully overcome
at present.
In the experiments 66 6S on generation and compression o f femtosecond pulses
the authors used the Gires-Tournois interferometer 26 representing a modifica
tion of the parallel-plate Fabry-Perot interferometer. Unlike in a Fabry-Perot
interferometer, the broadband front mirror has the reflectivity r(w ) = r < 1 ,
while the other one is totally reflecting (r = 1 ) . The striking feature o f this in
terferometer is that its modulus o f transmission coefficient is equal to unity and
its dispersive properties can be easily changed by varying the incidence angle y
o f incoming radiation. In this case the round-trip time
r = (^ >
Consequently, the wave reflected from the interferometer acquires only the phase
shift with respect to the incident wave. A similar situation happened before
many times. Neglecting the frequency dependence o f the reflectivity r and the
1.6. Diffraction of ultrashort pulses 53
time T , we obtain the following expressions for the group delay t d and the
interferometer dispersion dtA/du :
w T = 2 m 7r ± < 9 , m = 0, 1, 2 , . . . ,
_1r 2\ t 4 2 1 \ i/2i (1.5.31)
cos $ = (4r) [—(1 + r ) -(- (r + 34r + 1 ) ].
a whole. For laser pulses whose duration equals a few oscillation periods, the
inequality o f diffraction lengths for different spectral components o f the pulse
34 —36 65
may becom e significant. ’ Indeed, the high-frequency components o f the
pulse diffract slower than the low-frequency ones. Therefore, as it is noticed in
Ref. 15, distortion o f an optical pulse is to be expected even in a non-dispersive
medium and not too low values o f A u / u n . The same effect may show in the
37 70
focusing o f an optical pulse. ’ Both o f the abovementioned problems will be
analyzed in this section.
d i ik„ d2 i d2 \
ih + w Q r ’ ^ = 0, (L 6 ' 1)
where the last term describes the mutual influence o f spatial and temporal pa
rameters o f radiation. 15
Let us consider the propagation o f optical radiation with initial Gaussian pulse
envelope p0(t) (1.1.25) and with Gaussian shape o f the beam:
i ( f i , r , z ) = ^ - p 0( Q ) e x p
-foo
x J U i rj e x p { - ^ ( ^ > (1-6-2)
It follows from Eq. (1.6.2) that the dispersion lengths are not equal due to
the difference o f wave numbers k for different spectral components.
Generally speaking, the pattern o f the mutual influence o f spatial and tem po
ral radiation characteristics in dispersive media is quite com plicated. T o analyze
the pulse distortion caused only by spatial finiteness o f the optical beam, we
shall assume that k2 — 0 . This situation is exactly identical to that discussed
in Refs. 34-36. In this case the Fourier transformation o f Eq. (1.6.2) is
-foo
tfcr f
A {t’ T ’ z ) = 2 fz j U {r^
— OO
1.6. Diffraction o f ultrashort pulses 55
whence it is seen that the change in the structure o f the pulse is caused by its
delayed arrival at a given point due to the wave front curvature. In Ref. 36 the
time-domain profile (1.6.3) has been calculated for the lengths 2 « L di{ = kQag .
The obtained data are indicative o f an appreciable increase in the duration o f the
femtosecond pulse at the periphery o f the beam (the initial pulse was 4 fs long).
The same trend persists also in the far-field zone o f the beam ( z = z/Ldif >• 1) ,
in which
,,,4 ,
where
Tl = t* + (a0r / u z f . (1.6.5)
According to Eq. (1.6.4) the beam in the far-field zone becomes phase-modulated
in space and in time and its form differs from Gaussian. The envelope o f the
pulse is however Gaussian with duration (1.6.5) growing to the beam periphery.
The spatial shift o f the pulse maximum intensity within the cross section o f the
beam obeys a quadratic law.
The shape o f short optical pulses can be distorted in the process o f their focusing.
In Refs. 70 and 37 the authors consider pulse focusing by a lens and by a phase
screen respectively. Formation o f the amplitude front o f short pulses focused by
different types o f lenses is discussed in Ref. 92 in terms o f ray optics. In typical
experiments, short optical pulses are focused by a lens and we shall therefore
examine this particular case here.
It is a com mon practice to treat a spherical lens as an optical system with
transfer coefficient M ( r ) = exp (ikQr2/ 2 f ) , 7 where / is the focal length o f the
lens. However, this m odel is not adequate to describe the focusing o f ultrashort
pulses because in this case the longitudinal spatial dimensions o f the pulse may
be much shorter than the lens thickness and the lens cannot be thus treated as
thin. In the case o f short pulses one has to take into account first o f all the
difference in group delay times for different rays passing through the lens. As a
consequence, the delay between the phase and amplitude (group) fronts depends
on the distance traversed within the lens, which is determined by the transverse
coordinate. The effect o f dispersive spreading o f a wave packet proves to be
also dependent on the transverse coordinate. In this subsection we shall analyze
the characteristic properties o f focusing o f ultrashort pulses in the quasioptic
approximation.
Suppose that a light beam has the form
l(r ) = \ ( rl - r 2) ( ^ 1_ 1 + R 2 1) , (1.6.7c)
where n isthe refractive index o f the lens material, R 1 and R 2 are the radii
o f curvature o f the lens surfaces, and r 0 is the lensradius.The lens center is
assumed to coincide with the axis o f the incident beam (r = 0 ). When the
beam passes the distance between the planes tangent to the lens surfaces at its
center, the group delay time at the arbitrary point r of the cross section equals
dn —Hr) Hr)
‘d = + V T • t1-6-8)
where n = c/u is the “ refractive index” for the group velocity in the lens and
u is the group velocity. Taking into account Eq. (1.6.7), we obtain
* d = * d ( 0) - ^ 2 . ( ! - 6-9)
where td(0) = n r^/2(n — 1 ) c f is the group delay time at the lens center and
P = (ngr - l ) / 2 (n - 1 ) c f .
At the exit plane o f the lens the com plex amplitude o f the beam takes the
form
2 •; 2
r iKnr
exp (1 .6 .10 )
' K + ^ r
ih f *>
A ( v , r , z ) = 2 ^ J P oiv + P r J
1 **n \ 2 ikn
X exp d rx , (1.6.12)
a2 2/
. B ( r ) ) z 12
A (V, r , z) = pQ H (y, z)
where
B (v) z
z)= 1 - + B{rj) = 1 + 2/3a2
0TQ %
Jdif
and Ldif = kQa2 is the diffraction length o f the beam. At B(r/) = 1 (/? = 0)
Eq. (1.6.13) turns into the known expression describing the focusing o f m onochro
matic optical pulses (rQ —+ o o ) . It can be easily seen that the general case
(J3 ^ 0) corresponds to the focusing o f the beam whose initial radius varies
2 2 _l/2
with time as aQ(r)) = aQ( l + 2/?aQrQ 77) . When short pulses are focused
( B ( 77) ^ 1) , the beam parameters vary with time and the pulse duration de
pends on the transverse coordinate o f the beam. Let us consider this problems
in more detail.
In accordance with Eq. (1.6.13) the radius o f the beam outgoing from the
lens varies as
a(rf, z) = a0 B ~ l/2(rf) H - 1 ^ , z). (1.6.14)
W hence the beam radius at the focal plane is seen to grow with time (I77I < rQ)
initially. Such a dependence is due to a large group delay o f the central part o f
the beam in comparison with the peripheral one. The same effect leads to the
temporal dependence o f the beam waist position:
58 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
Thus, the beam waist region recedes from the focal plane o f the lens with time.
+r^vi_1/2
The beam radius at the waist is equal to
a( K ) - % B U2(v) i (1.6.17)
This relation differs from the temporal dependence (1.6.15) of the beam radius
at the focal plane. At the moment o f time r]0 found from the expression r/Q =
(L di{ — / ) t q / 2/?/a g the radius reaches its minimum value
It is interesting to note that it does not depend on the initial radius aQ . This
situation differs substantially from the focusing o f a monochromatic beam when
there is a strong dependence on aQ :
(m o n )
( iw ) = “ o [ l + ( W / ) V 1.
W hen / <C L di[ (strong focusing), a^mon\ L w) < amin(L w) and therefore the
conditions for short pulse focusing deteriorate.
The phase of the com plex amplitude (1.6.13) is defined by the expression
The amplitude front is seen to obey a parabolic law and its curvature pattern
remains the same in the immediate vicinity before the focal point and behind
it. Under the approximations made, the pulse duration grows according to the
expression [cf. Eq. (1.6.5)]
The broadening o f the pulse is inversely proportional to its initial duration and
increases toward the periphery o f the beam. The pulse broadening K at the
point r — f a j L dif corresponding to the radius o f the monochrom atic beam
can be evaluated:
K = {2pa0r'LdJ r Qf f * ( ^ / / c r j 2
1.1. Optical wave packets in optical fibers 59
For the pulse duration rQ = 1 ps, beam radius aQ = 0.3 cm and / = 10 cm,
K = 0.09, i.e., the pulse broadens at the beam periphery by about one tenth of
its original duration.
Thus, the analysis of focusing o f short optical pulses in the first-order approx
imation o f the dispersion theory shows that its spatio-temporal picture is rather
com plicated; a decline in focusing efficiency is accompanied with pulse broad
ening. W hen the dispersion o f the material o f the lens is taken into account
in the second-order approximation, the picture o f focusing becomes still more
com plicated. In particular, the structure o f the exit beam turns to be much
more intricate. It can be obtained from Eq. (1.3.2) by substituting dQ — /3cr
for z and t — £d(0) 4- /3r2 for t . Naturally, the second-order approximation
o f the dispersion theory is to be used if the lens thickness is comparable with
the dispersion length L d [see Eq. (1.3.2)]. Remarks about the second-order
approximation o f the dispersion theory will be limited to this statement.
d i ik d n
cl lf (r ) A (t, z) = 0 , (1.7.1)
dz 2 fc
where the last term, responsible for refraction, includes the refractive index of the
cladding ncl , the maximum value o f the refractive index o f the core nc , and the
dimensionless function f ( r ) specifying the distribution o f the refractive index
over the cross section of the waveguide; kcl is the wave number in the cladding
material. A few o f the possible profiles of the refractive index are shown in
Fig. 1.18(a) . It should be pointed out that Eq. (1.7.1) is adequate for weakly
39
directing optical waveguides [(nc — n cl) *C 1] with smooth, on the scale of
A , variations o f the index o f refraction. A more general case has been studied,
for example, in Ref. 1. In practice, the value o f (n_ — nd ) is o f the order of
0 .01- 0 .0 0 1 .
60 1. Short optical pulses m linear dispersive media
Ulr)
(a) <b)
FIG . 1.18. (a ) Norm alized profiles o f the refractive index o f the m edium ;
(b) respective distributions o f field intensity for the lowest m od e o f a waveguide.
where the function U (r ) specifies the field distribution over the cross section
o f an optical waveguide, ip(t, z) is the com plex temporal amplitude, and k
is the correction to the wave number fcc] [0 < k < (kc — &cl)]- Substitution o f
Eq. (1.7.2) into Eq. (1.7.1) leads to two independent equations
(1.7.3)
l u { r ) = 2i rcl A ^ (r) + cl /( r ) u {r) -
.dip _ k2 O'2ip
(1.7.4)
%dz ~ 2 dt1
with the boundary conditions
Equation (1.7.3), together with the boundary conditions, leads to the problem
o f finding the eigenvalues k-m and eigenfunctions U}m (r) , i.e., modes of an
optical waveguide. The eigenfunctions o f weakly directing optical waveguides,
39
usually denoted in the literature by LPjm constitute modes polarized in the
direction perpendicular to the axis. Figure 1.18 (b) shows the field distributions
for the lowest mode L P Q1 calculated for various profiles o f refractive index and
for the dimensionless wave number V = &cla [(nc —nci ) / nci] = 2.5 (a is the core
radius). For a number o f practically important cases these distributions can be
approximated by a Gaussian curve.
Note that Eq. (1.7.1) is written without allowance made for optical losses
which in the visible range are o f the order o f 20 dB /km , and in the near IR ( A »
1.55 f i m ) can be reduced down to 0.2 d B /k m . W hen necessary, the optical losses
can be taken into account by supplementing the right-hand side o f Eq. (1.7.1)
with the term —i8QA , where 8Q is the amplitude attenuation constant.
Dispersive characteristics of optical waveguides are determined mainly by
properties o f the materials used (material dispersion). One o f the experimental
methods o f investigating the dispersive characteristics is based on the measure
ment of delay time o f an optical pulse f d in the fiber as a function o f frequency.
Indeed, after having passed the distance L in the fiber, the two pulses with
carrier frequencies and u>2 (Aw = — w2| <C Wj , u 2 ) acquire a group
delay A^d (1.4.20) between them. Hence, it follows that k2 = A t d/LAu>.
F IG . 1.19. T ypica l dependences o f the tem poral delay o f an optical pulse (dashed
line, experim ent) and o f a dispersive param eter (solid line, calculations) in the
vicinity o f the wavelength corresponding to the zero dispersion o f the group ve
locity in an optical waveguide.
= = <L 7 -5>
group velocity dispersion ( k2 < 0) is realized and for A < Acr the normal
dispersion (k2 > 0) .
Note that in the vicinity of the point Acr the contribution o f the waveguide
dispersion can becom e significant. This contribution appears because the cor
rection to the wave number k depends on A . Besides, when A « Acr , the
higher-than-second-order terms are to be retained in the expansion o f k into a
power series o f (u> — wQ) .
Thus, the ultrashort pulses propagate in the single-mode optical waveguides
similarly to the plane waves propagating in a dispersive continuum. The char
acter o f the dispersion changes drastically on passing the wavelength Acr .
We shall consider the propagation o f noise pulses (1.1.33) with a Gaussian en-
2 2 .
velope F ( t ) = pQexp( —t /2 r Q) and random modulation £(<) characterized by
the correlation function R (r) = e x p (—t 2/t 2q) . The correlation function o f the
input noise pulse has the form
2 2 2
For the initial condition (1.8.1) the correlation function in the medium can
be obtained analytically. Using Eq. (1.1.15), we can get in the second-order
approximation o f the dispersion theory
B ( t 1 , t 2 ’ 2) = Vi X{ z ) p I
tt + tl *^2 y 2'
x exp + ( 1.8 .2)
4 1
c0
where is the spectral width o f the noise pulse, and the superscript nc stands
for non-correlated.
According to Eq. (1.8.2) the pulse duration and the correlation time in the
medium are equal to 31,71
Equations (1.8.5) coincide precisely with the formulas for the beam radius a (z )
and the correlation radius rc( z ) o f random optical beams provided <z0 , rc0 , and
k0 1 are substituted for r0 , rc0 , and k2 . 16 A pulse with random modulation
spreads faster than a transform-limited pulse o f the same duration. The noise
pulse, just as a random beam, possesses a fundamental statistical property: the
so-called coherence coefficient o f the pulse C = rc( z ) / r (z) is a constant quan
tity. As has been established in Ref. 31, this statistical invariant is valid when
the envelope F ( t ) and the correlation R ( ) are described by identical functions.
t
The pulse duration rQ and the correlation time rc0 featured in Eq. (1.8.3)
are not equivalent in the sense that when rc0 —►oo , the dispersion length
—►L d , whereas at rQ —►o o , it grows infinitely, —►o o . The latter
fact signifies that the correlation time o f steady-state noise does not vary in a
dispersive medium. W ith a fixed spectral width o f the noise pulse, the dispersion
length increases as the duration rQ gets longer [see Eq. (1.8.4)]. In accordance
with Eq. (1.8.5)
in the far-field zone (z L^c) and in the extreme case rQ r 0 . Here the
correlation time rc is determined by the initial duration rQ and, conversely, the
pulse duration rp in the medium is determined by the initial correlation time
64 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
In the case o f compression o f the noise pulse or the propagation o f the noise
pulse with linear chirp Sui(t) = —a Qt (1.1.28) in a dispersive medium we have
for the duration and correlation time:
Tp ( Z ) = V 2 ( Z ) r 0 > Tc ( Z ) = V 2 ( Z ) TC 0 -
(1.8.7)
V2\ z ) = ( l - a 0k 2z f + (z/Ln
c cf .
The compression length and the maximum compression ratio S nc are equal
to
The correlation time (1.8.6) can be regarded as a consequence o f the tem po
ral analog o f the well-known van Cittert-Zernike theorem for spatially incoher
ent beams. Indeed, assuming the random process £(t) to be ^-correlated, i.e.,
R (t) = R q S( t ) , where <5(r) is the Dirac function, and using Eq. (1.1.15), we
obtain for the correlation function in the medium:
— OO
This problem has been thoroughly examined in Ref. 74. The results have been
obtained in terms o f transient diffraction equation ( 1 .6 .1) for the factorized cor
relation function o f the initial pulse
> ^2 i r i ’ ^*2) = (-^0(^1 ’ r i ) -^0(^2 ’ **2)) — ^t(^i > ^2) ■®s(r*i > ^*2) ’
where the temporal correlation function is determined by Eq. (1.8.1). The spatial
correlation function B j r j , r 2) o f the beam with radius aQ and correlation
radius rc0 has the analogous form. We shall discuss some o f the calculation
results given in Ref. 74.
First, note that in the dispersive medium the correlation function o f the noise
pulse in the far-field zone cannot be factorized. In particular, the spatio-temporal
distribution o f the mean intensity is given by the expression
/o \2 2 i
r/ 2z) r
( I ( t , r , z ) ) ~ exp (1.8.13)
2uz J 1 + P ( r/uz)
Here
-2 -2 -2
r e ff
( 2aQ) - 2 + r - 2 r e ff cO '
(1.8.14)
The pulse duration r (z) is defined by Eq. (1.6.5). The correlation time
In quantum optics 104 the intensity and induction o f an electric field are de
scribed by the operators E and D in the space o f states satisfying the Maxwell
equation. In the case o f quantum wave packets the field intensity operator as
sumes the form
+ ‘ >= °- <1IU7>
Its solution is
-j-00
i (+ )(t , z) = J G*(rj - t , z ) A (q+ \ tI) dr), (1.8.18)
—OO
where i4g+ \ t/) = ^4 ^ ( 77, 0) is the value o f the operator at the entrance to the
medium and the function G (rj — t , z) is a com plex conjugate o f the function
G(r) — t , z) entering in Eq. (1.1.18).
From the comparison o f Eqs. (1.8.17) and (1.8.18) with Eqs. (1.1.14) and
(1.1.15) it follows that the forms o f the quantum and classical equations, as
well as their solutions, coincide. Differences may arise, however, due to non
com mutativity o f the operators A^+ \ t , z ) and A^ \ t , z) when calculating
the characteristics o f the pulses. In the further analysis it is convenient to use
the dimensionless time r — t / t q , where rQ is the duration of the mean pulse.
The Fourier components o f the operators A^+ \ t , 2) and A ^ \ t , 2) :
+ OO
a+ ( f 2 , z ) = (2?r) j A^ \ t , z) exp ( —j f 2r ) dr
— OO
1.8 Some statistical problems 67
[ a ^ , z ) , a+ ( ^ 2 , z)]
= , z ) a + ( fi 2 , z) — a+ ( f i 2 , z )a (f21 , z) = — f i 2) , ( 1 .8.20)
It should be noted that Eq. (1.8.17) can be derived from the evolution quan
tum equation
r\
H ~ - r 12 J J( r , z )d r . ( 1 .8 .22b)
2 z ) - ^ - A ('+ \ t ,
- f CO
N (z) = J n (r , z )d r (1.8.24)
— 00
and the operator o f the mean number o f photons averaged over a certain finite
time T o f observation is
f
t + T /2
n ( r , T) = T 1 h ( r , z) dr. (1.8.25)
- T /2
Note that the eigenvalue is denoted by A*(f2) in Eq. (1.8.26a) in order to unify
with the notation used in this book for description of Fourier transformation o f
classical functions. For the photon creation operator (f2) we obtain
4 + V ) I ^ o) = ^ oW K ) . (1.8.28)
where
-j-OO
Thus, for the mean value the classical result proves to be valid [cf. Eq. (1.8.32)
with Eq. (1.1.15)]. One can easily see that the expressions for the mean val
ues o f the normally ordered operators A*- ^(r, z) and z) (all positive-
frequency operators are placed to the right o f the negative-frequency operators)
coincide with the classical expressions. For example, according to Eq.(1.8.23)
(n (r , z)) = |A(r , z ) | , i.e., the expression for the mean number o f photons in
a medium is analogous to the expression for the intensity. This means that the
spreading o f a quantum wave packet in terms o f the mean values o f the normally
ordered operators is analogous to the spreading o f a classical wave packet con
sidered in Secs. 1.3 and 1.4. In terms o f coherent quantum pulses, the results
obtained in those sections pertain to the dynamics o f statistically mean pulses.
Indeed, Eq. (1.3.2) describes the com plex amplitude o f a mean Gaussian pulse
while Eq. (1.3.3) describes the evolution o f its duration during the propagation.
Photon statistics; quantum invariants. For characterization o f quantum field
statistics it is convenient to use the so-called Fano factor F defining the ratio
o f the variance o f the number o f photons to their mean number. In the case o f
a single-mode field
_ ( [ a + ^ ) a 0( ^ ) ] 2) - ( a + ( ^ ) a 0( ^
< a + ( f i) a0(fi)>
-j-OO
4 = { ( A N ) 2) = ( ( N - ( N ) ) 2) = ( N ) , (N ) = J \A{r , z ) f dr (1.8.34)
an
2 ( r , T ) = < [A n (r , T )]2) = (n (r , T ) ) , (1.8.35)
r + T /2
(h (r, T ) ) = T 1 J |A ( r , z)fd r
r —T/2
in the second case. In the both cases the Fano factor turns out to be equal to
unity. Therefore, the statistics o f initially coherent pulses remains Poisson in
spite o f their spreading in dispersive media.
As was mentioned, one can make use o f Eq. (1.3.2) when treating a mean
pulse. If the observation time is substantially less than the pulse duration
tq (T <C 1) , then according to Eq. (1.8.35) (n (r , T )) = |A(r, z ) |2 = p 2( r , z).
This means that in this situation the mean number o f photons and the variance
follow adiabatically the pulse intensity variations.
70 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
-j-OO
B ^ z) = N 1 J rn(r, z )d r , (1.8.37)
— OO
Using Eq. (1.8.17) and the Hermitian-conjugated equation, one can easily check
105
that the operators P ( z ) and N ( z ) do not vary in the medium:
N ( z ) = N ( 0) = N , P ( z ) = P ( 0) = P. (1.8.38)
&(*), P] = ih
{ ( A P f j d A ^ , ) ] 2) ^ ^ (1.8.39)
Assuming that at the input to the medium the pulse envelope |A0(r)| has a
symmetrical shape, e.g., Gaussian, and using Eq. (1.3.2) or (1.4.2), we obtain
(< ? > )) = 0 .
Taking into account the commutation relation (1.8.21), we obtain for the mean
square o f the operator
-J-OO
( § l( z )) = <[A0» ] 2) = ( N ) - 2 J r 2|A(r , * ) |2 dr. (1.8.42)
1.8 Some statistical problems 71
From the classical point o f view the right-hand side o f the last expression is
associated with the rms duration o f the pulse [see Eqs. (1.1.19), ( 1 .1 .20a), and
(1.1.20b)]. W ith allowance made for Eq. (1.4.2), the expression (1.8.42) reduces
to
( § l(z )) = V \ z ) / { 2 ^ p l ) , (1.8.43)
( V / 2= ! ^ Y ' V w r. = f e Y ' V
<‘ > - { w ) = <1-8'44>
In the last equality the pulse duration in a dispersive medium is assumed to be
defined by Eq. (1.4.6). The presence o f the Planck constant in Eq. (1.8.44)
corroborates the purely quantum character o f the fluctuations discussed here.
To evaluate numerically Eq. (1.8.44), we shall take the radiation wavelength
Aq = 1.5 fim (w0 Ri 1.2 x 1015 Hz) and the pulse energy W « 10 11 J. In
this case the ratio ( ( t 2) ) 1^2/Tp{z) ^ 10- 4 , i.e., the effect o f random shift o f the
“center o f gravity” o f the pulse is insignificant. This effect becomes comparable
with the pulse duration when the pulse contains about ten photons.
The similar calculations performed with the rms duration operator
+oo
§2(z) = (N ) 1 J t2h (r , z)d r (1.8.45)
— OO
From this it follows that the quantum fluctuations o f the rms duration o f the
pulse turn to be so small as to be insignificant provided the number o f photons
in the pulse exceeds 100.
The calculations carried out in this subsection indicate that the quantum
fluctuation effects accompanying pulse propagation in linear dispersive media
can be as a rule neglected; they becom e appreciable only when the number o f
photons is about ten or less. As a consequence, the pulses in the coherent state
can be treated in terms o f the theory o f propagation o f a deterministic classical
pulse in dispersive media, developed in Secs. 1.3 and 1.4.
Finally, it should be pointed out that the spatial analog o f the considered
effect is a random walk o f a laser beam center. This can be evaluated either
from the measurements o f the ultimate spatial coherence o f a laser beam or
from direct measurements. 107
12 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
£ ~ (n — im )2. (1.9.2)
rot E = —i k H , rot E 1 — —i k H 1 ,
rot H = i k E , rot H 1 = i k e E l , (1.9.3)
div E — 0 , div e E x = 0 , div H = 0, div H 1 = 0.
E - n { n E ) = E 1 - n { n E 1) , —n ( n H ) = — n(nijr1), (1.9.4)
H
n = (1+ f l + /s2)_1/2(/rer+ f y e y - ej (1.9.5)
1.9. Reflection o f ultrashort pulses from a random surface 73
+ ^ A 9 e x p [ i( w * - f c 9r ) + r 92] , (1.9.7)
9.
If kq = |fey —q\ < k — w /c , the diffracted waves are radiative in nature, whereas
at kq > k , they are not (surface waves). For simplicity, we shall hereinafter write
the scalar subscript q instead o f the vector one q , for example, r = T .
P r o p a g a t io n o f o p t ic a l fie ld s in v a c u u m ; th e W o o d a n o m a lie s
The analogous expression is valid for the magnetic field in the medium.
From the exact boundary conditions (1.9.4) we find that in the medium con
sidered
E is * E x + f xEt , E l y ^ E y + f yE z , H 1= H. (1.9.11)
On the other hand, taking into account Eq. (1.9.10) we obtain from the Maxwell
equations (1.9.3)
E ls « ikT ~l H Xy , E ly « - i k T ^ H ^ . (1.9.12)
From Eqs. (1.9.11) and (1.9.12) the following boundary conditions can be derived
for the fields in vacuum:
Let us express the field H in Eq. (1.9.13) in terms o f E using the equation
—i k H = rot E ; taking into account Eq. (1.9.7) we get the following relations:
The distribution o f the fields in vacuum can be derived provided the conditions
are satisfied. In this case the factors exp [—ikzf ( x , ?/)] and e x p [ r ?/( a ;, ?/)] in
Eq. (1.9.14b) can be expanded into Taylor series and only the first two terms re
tained. Then equating the terms with identical powers, we obtain a set of related
equations for the amplitudes of the diffracted fields. After transformations (see
Ref. 113), we obtain the amplitudes o f the field of the zeroth order o f diffraction
A °z ek z - i T Aiz ek z - iT ^ q + ^qy
A qx = ~ lk qxT A qx + *[ ^ ( A * “ A oJ + k q A A ix +
- V [ r ,A g , r + t(fe
/ j »■ g
1 ~ fcq x )‘ A q ,x *] {^ q ~ q , ,’
V q x
?Vo
= - v 1-4 . . - fc2) ( A , + a , , k ,
~ X L [ 'V - V * + ' ( V » -
9
q z 3^ q —q
— / ./L
[iT ,k
q
A 1q + *k ?(k
q ' 5— fc i)A
q '
. ]£ ) ’
(1.9.17)
where = ^ t, - k q = ^ if = k q, - k q = g. , and £q_ q, = £*. if q - q =
for the p polarization o f the incident radiation. (The vector E i lies in the
incidence plane, the amplitudes are A jx = 0 , A iz ^ 0 , A iy ^ 0 ). For one
resonant and several non-resonant fields, the amplitudes o f the components o f a
specular-reflected wave (0 = 7 ) are equal to
A 0x = 0 1
A n = A n cot 7 ,
y (1.9.18)
where
H v{y) = Iffr^rl2 COS_1 7-
The amplitudes o f the components o f the resonant field take the form
4 qx
r ) = 0 ,’
A(r)
qy -- iT(r)k ~ 1A
11 q Kqy A (r)
qz ’ (1.9.19)
A Vz = (±fl'r) A o >
where
Pn = - 2 ^ - T + E ( W q y ' i K i K ~ k q ) ) 2 \Z(K ~ \ ) t
m + n k' <k
In Eq. (1.9.19) the upper signs refer to k r = k y — g v and the lower signs to
k T = ky + g r . The sums in j3m and j3n are associated with re-scattering o f
the plane wave from the resonant to respectively non-radiation (fc? > k) and
radiation (fc? < k , including kq = ky) non-resonant waves (k ^ k) diffracted
by the gratings. Note that j3 , /? 1.
On reflection o f an optical wave from a periodically modulated surface sepa
rating media, the amplitudes o f diffracted waves turn to be strongly dependent
on the incidence angle 7 and the wavelength A . These phenomena are referred
to as the W ood anomalies. Let us consider how the W ood anomalies manifest
2 2
themselves in the case o f a specular reflection coefficient R 0 = |AQ| / 1Aj;| .
According to Eq. (1.9.18) we have
ek z + *T
R0 =
ek Z - iT
1.9. Reflection o f ultrashort pulses from a random surface 77
—1 fr)
The minimal value o f R 0 is obviously reached at fim — k 1^ . Total suppres
sion o f specular reflection (TSSR , R 0 = 0 ) takes place when
Pm = [(9v/ k ± s i n 7 f - 1]1/2.
In this case the wave with amplitude A ?r corresponds to a surface wave be
cause it turns out that k qr > k . For given g . , £ , g tr, and k the expression
(1.9.22) determines the amplitude f and the angle o f incidence necessary for
the TSSR effect to set in. W ithout taking into account the re-scattering between
the resonant and nonresonant fields, i.e., neglecting the sum in the second re
lation o f Eq. (1.9.20), Eq. (1.9.22) yields the following result for a sinusoidal
profile (see Ref. 110)
1/2
2d
4|ej = — H r — - 3 cos 7 , (1.9.23)
n + m
2
*2 , m
arcsm n = 1 + / 2 , 2\2 1
(m + n )
where 4|f | is the full amplitude o f the grating and d its period. Now we
can evaluate the TSSR angle 7 and the optimal depth 4|£ | for aluminium
[e = (0.47 — *4.84) ] at the wave length A = 436 nm and the grating parameter
d = 370 nm. W hen q\\ky , Eq. (1.9.23) yields the value 7 = 9.07 and 4|f |=
33 nm. These estimates are in excellent agreement with the numerical results o f
Ref. 115. The presence o f the additional terms in Eq. (1.9.22) associated with
field redistribution brings about the change in the value o f the optimum angle
7 at which is minimal.
Let us examine the reflection o f a short p-polarized optical pulse from a surface
with arbitrary periodic profile. The components o f the initial pulse are equal to
(see Fig. 1.20)
r > z) = °>
E iy( t , r > z ) = ~ E i ( t , r , z ) cos 7 1 (1.9.24)
+ OO
Ai = A f(w) = (2ir) 1 j A { (/) exp [i(w0 — w)t] dt (1.9.25)
78 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
after the reflection from the periodic surface on the basis o f the results given in
the previous subsections. The integration o f the corresponding expressions over
the Fourier spectrum yields the formulas for the diffracted pulses.
We shall analyze the specular-reflected pulse. A ccording to Eq. (1.9.18) we
get
+ oo
1Z I 2
X <1 ^ t f r(7 )} exP M * ~ V c)ldoj> (1-9-26)
we obtain
A = - ^ t (u - u + . V 1) , (1.9.27)
where
Here 0 ^ and 0 ^ are calculated from Eq. (1.9.20) at w = ui^. , and can be
regarded as the lifetime o f the resonant diffracted wave, (surface electromagnetic
wave, SE W ). Note that the frequency ui depends on the angle 7 and for the
optim um angle
T = 70 a r c s i n { ^ rycwQ 1 ± [1 + ( / ^ ) 2]1/2}
for both long and short pulses. Hereinafter we assume that the latter inequality
{ f i l » PZ ) holds.
In the case o f an initial Gaussian pulse with the shape (1.1.25), the specular-
reflected pulse is described as
£ COS 7 0 + y / ^ £
£
f r.os 7
cos <Y_0 4-
+ iy/—£
i
pin) = Po
£ COS 70 - iy/—£
From Eqs. (1.9.29), (1.9.30) it follows that for rj —* oo p(r]) ~ exp ( —r]2/2r^ ) ,
whereas for i] —►—oo p(rj) ~ exp(rj/T ) . In the specular-reflected pulse, at a
certain moment o f time i) determined by the equation
where
o
q — __ro _ l
y° V 2r^ + V 2 r 0 '
8U 1. Short optical pulses in linear dispersive media
ii
<c> I
V° V
FIG . 1.21. T h e shapes o f m irror-reflected initially Gaussian pulses for different
values o f the param eter N = H T("fQ)/2/3^ : (a) short (t q t ^ ) or long ( r Q
) pulse at JV < 1 ; (4) Tg W at N SS 1 ; ( c) long pulse at N > 1 .
the envelope is p(j7°) = 0. Thus, the reflected pulse proves to have two maxima,
i.e., the Gaussian pulse breaks into two pulses. The profiles o f the reflected pulses
calculated from Eq. (1.9.28) are shown in Fig. 1.21. It is seen that the proper
choice o f the profile parameters ensures the separation o f the reflected pulse into
two pulses with equal amplitudes comparable with the amplitude o f the incident
pulse. More information on distortion of-a rectangular ultrashort pulse reflected
from a non-plane boundary between media can be found in Ref. 112.
Thus, the shape o f the ultrashort optical pulse reflected from a periodically
modulated surface can drastically differ from that o f the incident pulse due to
its spectrum transformation resulting from the energy conversion to a SEW and
back, i.e., from the strong interaction o f the diffracted waves.
Let us analyze the behavior of energy reflectivity o f a short pulse and surface
absorptivity as a function o f profile depth and shape. For specular reflection the
energy reflectivity is equal to
J
+ co 4-co
where 5 rz , .S’iz are the Poynting vector components for the reflected and inci
dent pulses, and the subscript t means time-averaged. Using the results of the
1.9. Reflection o f ulirashort pulses from, a random surface 81
£ C O S J + i y f^ l '2
R p (y ) =
£ COS 7 —
R.
The value R em-m depends on the optical constants m and n o f the medium,
the profile depth and shape, and the pulse duration. It should be also pointed
out that for very short pulses (r Q r ^ ) the value o f the coefficient R emin is
close to the Fresnel value for any profile depth and shape. In the case o f pulses
j . snort optical pulses in linear dispersive media
with finite duration rQ , however, the difference between iZemin and the Fresnel
value can be significant.
Hence, the absorptivity j4abs o f a rough surface can vary strongly in the
process o f resonant excitation o f SEWs in the field o f ultrashort pulses and under
the condition o f W ood anomalies. In the absence o f re-scattering o f the resonant
SE W to form resonant waves with kq £ , the absorptivity A abs « 1 — R e{ j ) ■
This means that the radiation energy influx into a rough-surfaced target can be
much higher for ultrashort optical pulses as compared with the case o f a plane
surface for which, typically, A abs « 0.02 .
2. Self-action of optical pulses: self-modulation,
self-compression, solitons, and instabilities
Self-action effects arising due to nonlinearity o f refractive index are fairly com m on : they
show u p in the propagation o f high-intensity laser radiation in gases, liquids, and solids.
Vigorous studies o f various aspects o f self-action o f light beam s and pulses started in the
m id-sixties, having been inspired by the discovery o f self-focusing o f light. No dou bt, the
physics o f self-action remains u p to now one o f the m ost rapidly progressing branches o f
nonlinear optics. In the research o f self-actions the strong nonlinear effects were observed,
such as tem poral and spatial bistability, generation o f structures, optical turbulence, and
generation o f optical fields, all having no analogs, even distant ones, in linear optics.
Transition to the fem tosecond time scale has evoked a new surge o f interest in physics o f
self-actions and its diverse applications. T h e new effects have appeared in such traditional
areas as self-focusing o f beam s and self-m odulation o f wave packets. T h e utilization o f
self-actions has open ed new prospects in the developm ent o f ultrafast optical systems for
inform ation processing and in the con stru ction o f optical com puter elements, as well as
played a decisive role in production o f extrem ely short pulses.
P = P 1+ P nl, P n] « P 1, (2.1,2)
OO
/q ’V
Here x J(t , t , , , t3) is the triple-time function o f nonlinear response. Ex
pressions similar to Eq. (2.1.4) are also valid for the higher-order terms in the
expansion o f the nonlinear transient polarizations in terms o f the field. These
expressions contain the higher-order response functions, for example,
X^5\ t 1 , f 2 , f3 , <4 , f 5) , etc. In order to establish the relationship, between
Eqs. (2.1.2)-(2.1.4) and the nonlinear index o f refraction (2.1.1), we shall con
sider the cubic nonlinear response in the quasimonochromatic light field
n (3 )/ . \ ^ (3 )/ \ i .| 2 , iU jjt — A k r )
P (oj; t, r) = -x '(w )|A|Aev + c. c . , (2.1.6)
(^){ \ ^(3)/ \
X (w) = ex (w ; w , w , -w ) eee.
2.1. Physics o f self-actions 85
00
The fourth-rank tensor x)jki has nonzero components not only in anisotropic,
but also in isotropic media, including the media possessing a center o f inversion.
This explains why the self-action effects are so widespread.
Substituting Eq. (2.1.6) into the expression for the induction
D = E + A ir P ,
we obtain the relation for the nonlinear correction to the dielectric permittivity
nl » 2 o (3) / \ I * I2
etj = A n y = 37r x ijH( w ; w , w , - w ) e t e,|A| .
Re n = n0 + A n ( I ) , (2.1.8a)
6 = (w /c) Im n = <§Q + A 6 ( I ) . (2.1.8b)
✓•
to-7 /
' CuCl /
10~9 — -7 ^ X
✓ N itrobenzene
// • •s\
10-" / C52/ > 7
' • I /
Chlorobenzene
to~’3- Qu&rtz glass s']
hC _____J__ s ’ I I I
W'M 10 12 f0~w IO'1 i0~s 10~* W~* 10° 10z r nl,s
In a medium with a nonlinear index o f refraction the shape and spectrum o f the
wave packet undergo strong m odifications manifesting under certain conditions
in instabilities. The first in the succession o f various nonlinear wave phenomena
emerging here is the self-phase m odulation (SPM ) effect. It is quite obvious when
the nonlinear response can be treated as quasi-steady-state [see Eq. (2.1.3)]. We
shall consider the wave packet in the form (2.1.5), propagating along the 2 axis.
In the medium with the index o f refraction (2.1.9) the total phase o f the wave
^2 ^2 j
a (* . Z^ = ~ ^ = ~ kozii2-^2 - (2.1.13)
The behavior o f a wave packet is determined, as shown in Sec. 1.4, by the sign
o f the dispersion o f the medium. The case o f a k 2 < 0 is o f special interest
since it demonstrates the stages o f optical pulse self-compression. SPM causes
compression which, in turn, increases the rate o f self-modulation.
It should be noted that these processes were already studied in 1965-1967.
A t that time the primary efforts in exploration o f dispersive self-actions were
concentrated on investigations o f spatial self-focusing o f wave beams.
The physics o f self-action o f a wave packet is illustrated in Fig. 2.2 which shows
qualitatively the modifications o f the phase and shape o f the pulse and its fre
quency spectrum ( ) as it propagates in a nonlinear dispersive medium with
s c j
88 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
n2 > 0 and k2 < 0 . There is much in common between the considered process
and the self-action o f a wave beam. The initial stage of beam self-action is as
sociated, as in the case o f a wave packet, with SPM. This time, however, it is
a spatial SPM that brings along a nonuniform intensity distribution due to the
nonlinear index o f refraction, and distorts the wave front. In the medium with
n2 > 0 , when the beam power exceeds the so-called critical power V cr , the in
duced spatial self-modulation leads to compression of the beam with bell-shape
intensity distribution. As a result, the effect o f self-focusing occurs. 1
FIG . 2.2. Self-action o f a transform -lim ited wave packet and a collim ated op
tical b ea m in a m edium with cubic nonlinearity (n 2 > 0) . For self-action o f a
wave packet (fc2 < 0 ) : (a ) lines o f equal intensity in the plane r ;, z (solid
lines) and self-m odulation phase (dashed lines) for different values o f ( = z j L d ;
(b) pulse profile; (c) spectrum o f a pulse after SP M . Same pictures are valid
for the b ea m self-focusing: (a) side view, beam s (solid lines) and wave fronts
for different z / L Aif ; (b) profile o f the beam ; and (c) angular spectrum o f the
beam .
where P ^ is defined by Eq. (2.1.4) and whose left-hand side has the form
(1.1.1). In general, when deriving the approximate nonlinear equations for com
plex amplitudes o f short optical pulses, one should take into account not only
the dispersion o f the linear response, but also o f the nonlinear response.
In this section we shall derive the truncated equations for dispersive self-
actions. The detailed procedure o f obtaining the linear truncated equations for
com plex amplitudes through simplification o f the left-hand side o f Eq. (1.1.1)
is given in Sec. 1.1. Here we shall tackle the right-hand side o f Eq. (2.2.1).
According to Eqs. (2.1.4) and (2.1.5) the cubic component o f polarization at a
frequency w is equal to
= TJ Tz < 1 » (2 '2-4)
According to Eq. (2.2.6) the nonlinear source in Eq. (2.2.1) takes the form
c dr
x exp [i(vt — kz)} c. c. (2.2.7)
The summands in the last relation differ by the order o f smallness with respect
to the parameter
A* = T / tvtq , (2.2.8)
where T is the optical oscillation period; the first summand has the zero order o f
smallness, while the second summand is equal to O(fi) and the third to .
The parameter m will be referred to as a wave transience parameter.
W hen nn , f i < l and
= _ WV 3)
(the overdots denote a derivative with respect to time), we deal with quasi-steady-
state self-action. There are many significant examples indicating that such an
approximation holds down to pulse durations about 100 fs. This approximation
proves quite adequate for description o f self-phase modulation (see Sec. 2.3) and
propagation o f solitons in fiber waveguides (see Sec. 2.6).
Wave transience becomes evident in a nonlinear correction to the group ve
locity since the derivative
£<wvi)=1^+414’.
The augend in this formula is responsible for profile shock waves* (see Sec. 2.4).
A t the same time, as the pulse becomes shorter, one often comes across strong
effects o f inertia o f nonlinear response (see Fig. 2.1); in the field o f ultrashort
pulses 5-10 fs long even the fastest electronic nonlinearity becomes, generally
speaking, inertial.
The theoretical description o f nonlinear wave phenomena under these condi
tions is usually based on the simultaneous solution o f the wave equations and
dynamic equations for a nonlinear response. In the case o f a nonperiodic response
the dynamic equations take a relatively simple form. If the nonlinear correction
to the index o f refraction is associated with inertial effects (for example, with
the high-frequency Kerr effect in molecules with anisotropic polarizability), then
the dynamic equation for the nonlinear correction A n takes the form
(2.2.9)
Here f20 is the natural frequency o f the oscillator, T , 7 , and q are the coeffi
cients characterizing attenuation, nonlinearity, and field influence, respectively.
In the case o f electronic nonlinearity q = Ne/m , where e and m are the charge
and mass o f an electron; N is the number o f electrons in a volume unit. For
the pulsed field that is of interest to us, Eq. (2.2.10) can be simplified using the
perturbation method.
In the linear approximation ( 7 = 0) we can represent the solution o f
Eq. (2.2.10) in the form
— CO
It follows from here that in the general case the temporal behavior o f the nonlin
ear correction to the pulsed field differs, due to Eq. (2.2.12), from the behavior
2 2
specified by Eq. (2.2.9). However, far from the resonance ( fi0 — w > 2wT) ,
when the envelope variation time tq l/T , the quasi-steady-state relation
— q A (t) is valid. Then, expressing A e via A n as A n = we
obtain an equation for A n identical to Eq. (2.2.9).
Note that the calculation presented here provides the frequency dependence o f
2 2 » •
time rn] : rnI = 2F j ( i l a —u> ). The classical model o f an anharmonic oscillator is
o f course inapplicable in the vicinity o f the resonance, and the nonlinear response
is described by the Bloch-type equations. Besides, the self-actions becom e very
com plicated under these conditions (see Sec. 2.7).
If one calculates the nonlinear response function x (^i > ^2 ’ ^3) on the basis
o f the m icroscopic model, the transient self-actions can be studied by expanding
the integrand in Eq. (2.2.3) into a Taylor series o f the delay time, similarly
to what was done in the case o f a linear dispersive medium in Sec. 1.1. In
the first-order approximation o f the nonlinear dispersion theory we obtain from
Eq. (2.2.3)
3 r o a ,,> Ft - 1
A ‘ >= j (2.2.16)
From the comparison o f Eqs. (2.2.17) and (2.2.7) it is seen that the dispersion o f
nonlinearity (or, inertia o f nonlinearity) may lead, just as the wave transience,
to the appearance o f profile shock waves. The correction to the group velocity
(3^ (3^
depends in this case on the sign o f the derivative d\ / du . If dx /dw > 0 ,
it has the opposite sign to the correction caused by the wave transience [see
Eq. (2.2.7)].
The expressions for the nonlinear polarization (2.2.17) and (2.2.7) derived in
this section together with the expression for the electric induction (1.1.9) make
it possible to pass from the rigorous integro-differential description (2.2.1) o f a
self-action process to the description based on only the differential equations that
take into account the dispersion o f linear and nonlinear susceptibilities as well
as the wave transience effects. The specific form o f the approximate equations
describing the self-action o f short pulses is given in the following sections.
2.3. Self-phase modulation o f regular pulses 93
^'4+;Jr4+i'J>|-4|!-4=0' (2-31>
where
P, = Z ^ h j 2 n l = k0n J 2 n 0 (2.3.2)
= (2-3.5)
V’max = “ f * M = P lI o ( ° ) Z ( 2-3-6)
FIG . 2,3. Shape o f a Gaussian pulse (a ) , the reduced phase $ = (p/(PmgLX (&) >
reduced frequency deviation <5u/(<) = Sw(t)/Su>0 (c) , and reduced frequency vari
ation rate a ( t , z ) — a ( t , z)/ct( 0 , z ) (d ) as a function o f time r = v /tq » =
The magnitude o f the frequency change 6w(t) (2.3.5) grows with the increase o f
p raax . Graphs in Fig. 2.3 show the tem poral behavior o f Sw(t) and the rate o f
its variation.
The spectral density o f the pulse after SPM is specified by the relation
From Fig. 2.3 (c) one can see that at Cl > 0 the condition (2.3.9) can be satisfied
at the time moments t 1 and t2 (tj = t . t () ) , and at Q < 0 at the moments —
and —12 . Consequently, the spectrum will be symmetric with respect to the
frequency uiQ .
The maximum shift in the frequency Su>(t) for a Gaussian pulse (1.1.25) is
equal to
Z S fe , , 3.5tt
(a )
1.5JT
2 .5 rt 3 . 5 TO
J ____I____L
L 5 0 6Hz x l
4 . 5 ft
(b)
FIG . 2.4. Spectrvim o f a Gaussian p u k e for different m axim um values o f phase
Vmax : ( “ ) theory; ( 6) experiment. 4
where
A (tj ) = [ - i 2 ^ ( t j , z ) ] - 1' 7Po( t.). (2.3.13)
s ( w = w 0 + Q , z) = |A(^)|2 + |A(jt2)|2
At ^>max 1 Eq. (2.3.15) yields the value that practically coincides with the
width Au>' (2.3.11) estimated from the maximum frequency shift. In Ref. 20 the
spectral broadening is calculated for ultrashort noise pulses and the rms width
o f the spectrum,
A -L = [1 + ( 2 ^ ( / 0) , ) 2]A Wr2ms0 , (2.3.16)
The quasi-steady-state self-action considered here takes place when the pulse du
ration rQ is much longer then the nonlinear response time rnl . Such a condition
is satisfied in fiber waveguides down to rQ Kt 100 fs (r nl < 10 fs). Conversely,
2.3. Self-phase modulation o f regular pulses 97
700 A,r>m
FIG . 2.6. B roadened spectrum o f a Gaussian pulse w ith tq — 2.7 ps and the
nonlinear response time rn( = 9 ps for ¥>max = 265,10
' » + I » + , A a „ ( W ’ ) A ( t , z) = 0 (2.3.17)
Oz u dt n0
describing the self-action process [cf. Eq. (2.3.1)]. According to Eqs. (2.3.17)
and (2.2.9), the phase correction caused by self-action is equal to
z) = -
2 CTnl J pIU)e x p t-------
— T)
dt.
Tn l
(2.3.18)
(2.3.19)
2CT.nl
The frequency shift is negative over the entire pulse (n 2 > 0) . Therefore,
the points o f steady-state phase (2.3.9) exist only for negative frequencies Cl.
And this implies that in the limiting case o f “very slow nonlinearity” the pulse
spectrum broadens towards the low-frequency Stoke region.
For a Gaussian pulse the maximum variations o f the phase and frequency are
equal to
, , 1/2 2 wQn 2
= max \<p\ — 7r / V o - ^ 7 m ax ~ P o ~ ^ Z IT 1 (2 -3 .2 0 )
'n l ZCTnl
written in the moving coordinate system, where /?2 = n2/ c . As it was noted
in Sec. 2.2, the presence o f the additional term in Eq. (2.4.1) leads to the
dependence o f the group velocity on the intensity o f a propagating pulse. This
fact was noticed for the first time by O strovsky.11
The nonlinear correction to the group velocity for a medium with n2 > 0
leads to the steepening o f the trailing edge o f the pulse in the course o f its
propagation. On the contrary, when n 2 < 0 , the leading edge o f the pulse
becomes steeper. This reminds the well-known phenomenon, the generation of
shock waves in acoustics. Pulse profile distortions growing with distance can
become so intense as to form the shock wave o f the envelope (the profile shock
wave).
Let us turn to the specific analysis. B y going over to the profile and phase,
from Eq. (2.4.1) we obtain the set o f equations
| + 3V 2| = 0, (2-4.2)
<2'« >
Equation (2.4.2) is the equation for the simple wave. In the theory o f waves
in weakly dispersive nonlinear media (nonlinear transmission lines, nonlinear
acoustics), which is based on the m ethod o f slowly varying profile, developed
12
by Khokhlov, an equation o f type (2.4.2) is obtained for the field itself. This
analogy allows one to transfer a number o f results obtained for simple waves, for
example, in the area o f nonlinear acoustics,13 to simple waves o f envelope.
2.4- Self-steepening o f optical pulses 99
E n v e lo p e d e fo r m a t io n
F IG . 2.7. Shape o f a Gaussian pulse ( / ) in a nonlinear m edium , (2) for 3/3^zp^k0 = l .14
To see how the pulse envelope evolves in a nonlinear medium, the last relation
should be rewritten as
where the minus corresponds to the leading edge o f the pulse and the plus to
its trailing edge. The pulse envelope change in the course o f propagation is
illustrated in Fig. 2.7. The pulse is seen to deform so that the leading edge
becomes flatter, and the trailing edge, on the contrary, steeper. Thus, self-
steepening phenomenon takes place,*
According to Eq. (2.4.5) the pulse peak propagates with the velocity Uj =
u / ( l + 3(32uPa) > which is lower than the group velocity u in the medium. The
steepening o f the trailing edge o f a pulse eventually results in the formation o f a
discontinuity, for which dp/dij = o o , and a profile shock wave. This occurs at
the distance
*In a tw o-level m edium the steepening o f th e pulse leading edge is shown 21 to be viable
due to its preferential am plification.
100 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
Note that profile shock waves in the absence o f group velocity dispersion have
been theoretically studied in Refs. 14-17, and in the presence o f dispersion and
nonlinearity relaxation in Refs. 11, 14, 18, and 19. The first attempts to observe
experimentally the profile shock waves in optics were made in the late sixties.
Unfortunately, an unambiguous interpretation o f the experimental results was
complicated by a significant contribution o f spatial self-focusing.
22
Grischkowsky et al. observed directly the shape distortion of a 10-ns dye
laser pulse in R b vapor, caused by the formation o f profile shock waves, self-phase
modulation, dispersion o f linear and nonlinear components o f the refractive index
(see Fig. 2.8). For picosecond and sub-picosecond pulses, direct observations o f
the shape are not always possible; information about self-action can be obtained
from spectral chaxacteristics. The form o f spectral broadening under the condi
tions o f manifestation o f the nonlinear correction to the group velocity, described
by Eqs. (2.4.2) and (2.4.3), differs from the broadening under the conditions o f
fast SPM described by Eq. (2.3.1). We shall illustrate this by the approximate
calculations carried out for a pulse of a constant shape ( z <C £ disc i see also
Ref. 23).
Rothenberg and Grischkowsky 84' 85 studied a formation o f profile shock waves
during nonlinear propagation o f ultrashort optical pulses in fiber waveguides in
the region o f normal dispersion. They measured the pulse shape distortions at
the output o f a 2.5-m single-mode fiber waveguide as a function o f power o f an
input pulse 1 ps long. The output pulse had sharp self-steeped edges for a wide
range o f input powers. As the maximum powers reached 250 W , the oscillations
0.3 ps long were found to develop in the vicinity o f sharp edges.
Spectral broadening
2
2<p(ii, z) = - w 0»7 + w0T-0 arsinh[sinh(77/r0) - « 2p0z/cT-0]. (2.4.10)
2-4- Self-sieepenmg o f optical pulses 101
(a) | M
■ ■ M
M
H W
W
H M I
a a |H | | il j2 !H |H ||
■ ■ S S l i a S H !
a
m m m m i r m
i — — w— xm ^■
i i i i n a i
I 1 M W M M W
i S l R i n m j w n
*Expressions (2.4.10) and (2.4.11) differ from the corresponding formulas of R ef. 23 by a
factor o f 2. This difference (see also Ref. 24), in our opinion, is due to the fact that the m ethod
developed in R ef. 23 takes into account only the dependence o f group velocity on intensity.
102 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
In the case when Q 1 , the maximum broadening towards the Stokes re
gion is pa —o)0/2 , and towards the anti-Stokes region 6ui^ax tm Q lo0/2.
Consequently, for <3 1 , the spectral pulse distribution becomes strongly asym-
metrical; this asymmetry is associated with the presence o f the term 87p dip/dr}
in Eq. (2.4.3). The authors o f Ref. 23, using the theory presented here, inter
preted the experimental data obtained by Fork ei at. 25 In experiments 25 an
80-fs pulse with a wavelength 627 nm generated, due to self-action, the spectral
continuum extending from 190 to 1600 nm. The laser radiation was focused on
a film containing ethylene glycol, and, at the intensity IQ rs 100 T W /c m , the
spectrum was observed to broaden towards the Stokes (^w„ ax/ w0 = —0.6) and
anti-Stokes (^w^,ax/ w0 = 2.3) regions.
The authors o f Ref. 26 interpreted broadening o f the pulse spectrum in cap
illary fiber waveguides using the picture o f formation of profile shock waves. In
Ref. 27 the spectrum o f ultrashort pulses in a nonlinear medium was calculated
with the account taken for the finite response time o f a nonlinear correction to
the group velocity.
The theory o f spectral broadening presented in this section, as well as the
approach undertaken in Ref. 23, is based on the slowly varying envelope ap
proximation. Clearly, the results o f this theory are not applicable when a pulse
duration equals only a few periods of the carrier frequency. In this case one has
to solve the general equation (2.2.1). In Ref. 24 that equation was solved by
the m ethod o f multiple scales to obtain both the pulse envelope variation and
asymmetric broadening o f the spectrum.
A ir ,, r , J) = 0 , (2.5.1)
which is written in the moving coordinate system. In the case o f inertial nonlin-
2
earity An|j4| is the functional given by Eq. (2.2.9).
S te a d y -s ta te s e lf-fo c u s in g
For illustration, let us examine the solution obtained for collimated Gaussian
beams
A>(r ) = A (r > z = ° ) = A o exP (~ r2/ 2ao) > (2.5.3)
in the so-called aberration-free approximation. Assuming that in a nonlinear
medium the beam retains its shape, we seek the solution o f Eq. (2.5.2) in the
form
A ( r , z) - exp -l g { z ) k2
0 r 2 -i< p (z )
/(* ) 2 f \ z ) al 2
Now we substitute Eq. (2.5.4) into Eq. (2.5.2). In the paraxial approximation
[r <C f ( z ) a 0] , substituting the nonlinear term as
1 el/ ■> I
f ( z )ao
33
and equating the coefficients o f different powers o f r to zero, we obtain
= ( £d
“ ? - C ) / '% ) , (2.5.5)
dz
- ^ i f r/- 2 _ -2 ,
(2.5.6)
dz 2f nl M>'
2,1/2
■^dif — 0“ 0 > *nl = a o (2 n o / n 2N ) (2.5.7)
The function f ( z ) specifies the width o f the beam, while g(z) and tp(z) the
spatial SPM.
The solution o f Eq. (2.5.5) is
f \ z ) = 1 + ( L ~ 2 - C j ) z 2 = 1 + (z/Ldi{) 2( 1 - V J V J , (2.5.8)
1 2 2
where V Q = g c n 0a0A Q is the total power o f the beam,
V CT = cX /16ir (2.5.9)
-1 / 2
L^ = LdM r a -i) (2.5.10)
1U4 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
It should be emphasized here that this result is valid only in the paraxial approx
imation, since the expression (2.5.4) does not satisfy the rigorous Eq. (2.5.2).
A more accurate solution can be obtained by numerical methods. In this case,
according to Ref. 28 the Gaussian beam (2.5.3) at V 0 > V'cr is focused at the
distance
L s‘ t = C 0[ v l ' 2 - 0.852(7>'r) 1/2] _ 1 , (2.5.11)
where
CQ = 0.36Ldif(7>'r) 1/2 , V'a = (1.22A)2c/1 2 8 n 2.
The exacting analysis o f the Gaussian beam self-focusing reveals the qualitative
difference from the picture o f the paraxial approximation; in fact, the beam is
not focused at a point as a whole and the peripheral rays cross the beam axis
at longer distances than the paraxial rays. In the cross section o f the beam,
aberration reveals itself in the form o f a ring structure o f intensity distribution.
It follows from Eqs. (2.5.10) and (2.5.11) that the rate o f self-focusing is a
nonm onotonic function o f the initial beam radius. Consequently, there exists
the optimum radius aopt at which the length Ls{ is the shortest. From the
condition dLs{/da0 = 0 we find
“ opt = 2* o
_ 1K / M ! ) 1 /2 = *o * (2 W 0 ) 1 /2 - ( 2 .5 .1 2 )
The value o f aQpt given by Eq. (2.5.12) coincides up to a factor with the charac
teristicdimension o f inhomogeneities having the maximum increment along the
z axisand calculated by the perturbation method (see Ref. 30 and Sec. 2.8). The
presence of inhomogeneities of this size is crucial for self-focusing o f the beams
with com plicated amplitude distribution, since the inhomogeneities whose size
ao fts aopt self-focus more efficiently. As a result, the self-focusing beams prove
unstable with respect to transverse perturbations. In the media with n , ~
10 2
10 cm / k W (e.g., in CS 2 ) aopt Rs 50 pm for laser radiation at A = 1.06 pm
and with intensity I 0 = 100 M W /c m 2 . The growth in laser radiation intensity
leads to the reduction in the size o f inhomogeneities aopt . In this subsection we
considered three-dimensional self-focusing o f light beams. In an optical wave
guide it is possible to realize two-dimensional self-focusing similar to the temporal
self-focusing o f pulses resulting in an optical soliton generation (see Sec. 2.7).
Recently the authors o f Ref. 86 reported the observation o f nondiffracting spatial
soliton beams in a glass planar waveguide.
Q uasi-steady-state self-focusing
Such a process takes place when the pulse duration is much longer than the
nonlinear response time (r Q >• rn]) and described by Eq. (2.5.2) in which the
time i) = t — z f u in the moving coordinate system appears as a parameter;
besides, ^40(r) is replaced by A 0(rj, r) and A { r , z) by A (r j, r , z) . As a
consequence, the length o f self-focusing becomes time-dependent, that is, the
focal point moves. In the aberration-free approximation
(2.5.13)
2.5. Self-focusing o f ultrashort pulses 105
FIG . 2.9. Quasi-steady-state picture o f the m otion o f the foca l spot of a self-
32
focusing beam w ith relatively slow am plitude m odulation as a function of time:
(a) time dependence o f a pulse power; ( 6) foca l spot position.
A moving focus concept was developed for the first time by Lugovoi and
31
Prokhorov. Only the portion o f the pulse whose power V 0(t) > V cr experi
ences self-focusing. The temporal diagram showing the m otion o f focal points is
seen in Fig. 2.9. The moving-focus m odel is applicable down to sub-nanosecond
pulses provided the nonlinear response time r ( ss 1-10 ps.
According to Eqs. (2.5.4) and (2.5.8) the pulse intensity in the aberration-free
approximation is equal to
where
,, = i (2.5.15)
d if
It can be readily found from Eq. (2.5.14) that in the prefocal region (or in the
case o f weak focusing) the pulse duration
2
(2.5.16)
. 2 U tJ V aV - *
The last equation shows that the pulse compression becomes more efficient with
the increase in z and the beam power ^ ( O ) . The pulse duration, as in the
case o f focusing by a lens, is observed to be the shortest in the beam center
and grow towards the periphery. Obviously, rp can diminish considerably in
106 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
the moving-focus region. Typically, the pulses compressed in this way are 10 to
100 ps lo n g .10 ’ 42
The picture o f SPM observed for quasi-steady-state self-focusing is more com
plicated than that discussed in Sec. 2.3. In a compressed pulse, the total phase
proves to vary over the cross section o f the beam. As a result, the spectral
bandwidth exceeds to a great extent the value calculated from Eq. (2.3.11) for
a pulse in the absence o f self-focusing.
Some interesting results o f the numerical calculations of quasi-steady-state
self-focusing o f super-Gaussian beams are reported in Ref. 41. The moving-
focus region is determined by the spatial distribution and is the greatest for the
Gaussian shape. It is also shown that the beam self-focusing combined with
the spatial filtering in an optical system makes it possible to enhance the pulse
contrast and control the overall profile o f the pulse train.
In conclusion, note that the moving-focus model helps overcome many dif
ficulties in interpretation o f pulse self-focusing. For more detailed information
concerning this approach we recommend Refs. 5, 7, and 31-34.
Transient self-focusing
The solution (2.5.17) determines the temporal and spatial evolution o f the
beam radius. The qualitative picture o f transient self-focusing is illustrated in
Fig. 2.10 showing how various parts o f the pulse propagate. Parts (a) and ( b)
diffract in a linear medium; for the moments o f time ij <C rnl , corresponding
to these parts, the value o f A n is extremely small and self-focusing is absent
2 2 2
( / = 1 + z / £ dif) ■ For parts ( c ) - ( f ) , the value o f A n is sufficient to induce
self-focusing. As a consequence, the pulse distorts into a horn shape with the
optical waveguide forming at the trailing edge o f the p u lse.1
The steady-state regime o f nonlinear propagation in the case /n| = L dif can
be realized for large times. Indeed, from Eq. (2.5.17) we have
v
z) = rn\1 f J
f ~ 4( t , * ) A 0 exP -— ~ dt■
r nl
(2.5.18)
2.5. Self-focusing o f ultrashorl pulses 107
describing the behavior o f both the leading edge ( t] <C rnl) and the trailing edge
(n > rni) o f the pulse. Defining the bandwidth o f the optical waveguide at the
2
level / = 2 , we obtain the expression
relating the length 2 o f the waveguide with the moment o f its origin. According
to Eq. (2.5.20) the waveguide propagates with the velocity
which is less than the group velocity u o f the pulse. Therefore, the length o f
the optical waveguide will be less than the distance traversed by the wave. The
brightest waveguide portion o f the beam is observed as a filament. However, at
distances exceeding appreciably the spatial scale utq , diffraction leads to the
disruption o f the waveguide regime o f propagation.
The qualitative picture o f transient self-focusing considered above is confirmed
by the results o f numerical analysis. The temporal variations o f the beam
37 3S 3 6 _3 g
radius ' and o f the pulse envelope and spectrum were also investigated.
It is established that an initially symmetric pulse, in the process o f its propaga
tion in a nonlinear medium, grows asymmetric due to steepening o f the trailing
edge. At relatively large distances the envelope modulation may appear. Far
more conspicuous changes are experienced by the pulse spectrum which broad
ens towards the Stokes side. All these changes are illustrated by the graphs in
108 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
F IG . 2.11. N orm alized shapes o f pulse (a) and o f spectrum ( 6) at the axis o f
the beam for transient self-focusing at different distances z .37 Curves are plotted
fo r CS 2 for m axim um intensity 280 M W /c m 2 f b ea m radius 125 ^.m , pulse
duration 3.8 ps, and nonlinear response tim e 2 ps.
Fig. 2.11, plotted for CS 2 (rnJ 2 ps) and the input beam radius 125 fim and
maximum intensity 280 M W /c m ; the total pulse duration at the half-height is
equal to 3.8 ps.
Experimental studies o f transient self-focusing are reported in Refs. 39 and
40, in which the ruby laser pulses 10 ns long were used. The liquid crystals
of MBBA and E BBA were used as a nonlinear medium, which enabled
the authors to change rnl by varying the crystal temperature. Since the ratio
To/Tn\ could be changed from 0.21 to 11.3, both the transient and the quasi
steady-state regimes o f self-focusing were realized. The results obtained agree
with theoretical concepts discussed here.
o f picosecond pulses was studied in the seventies (see, e.g., Refs. 43-48, 53);
o f the most recent studies we would like to note Refs. 87-90. The experi
ments on spectral superbroadening o f femtosecond pulses are reported in recent
publications. 49 52 ’ 91 93 Such experiments draw special interest caused by high
intensities and strengths o f electric fields that can be obtained in these pulses.
Here we shall present a brief review o f some experimental results involving fem
tosecond pulses.
Figure 2.12 shows typical examples o f the spectral continuum generated by the
pulses with energy W ~ 0.5 mJ, wavelength A = 0.6 um , and duration 2 ns and
50
70 fs , in gases. In the blue region the spectra are identical for different gases,
pressures, and maximum intensities. In contrast, the spectral density in the red
region depends on the gas com position, the pressure, and pulse intensity. In all
the cases the continuum generation had a clearcut threshold. For femtosecond
pulses the product o f the gas pressure and the threshold power o f the pulse
remained practically constant for 30-fold change in power.
The spectral broadening o f the 0.3-mJ pulses (o f 85-fs duration and wavelength
628 nm) during their propagation in the air was investigated in Ref. 51. Tw o
types o f experiments were carried out, in which the spectral broadening was
studied as a function o f the distance traversed by the pulse and o f the energy
o f the focused pulse. In Ref. 52 the strong spectral broadening was observed in
the 350-fs U V pulses ( A = 308 nm) propagating in the atmosphere.
The authors o f Ref. 92 observed the superbroadening o f kilohertz-rate, sub-
100-fs laser pulses tunable from 785 to 825 nm. The white-light continuum was
produced by focusing the pulses up to maximum intensities about 10 T W /c m
into a spot with diameter 15 on a jet 1.2 mm thick. The liquid jet con
sisted o f a mixture o f 80% ethylene glycol and 20% glycerine. The continuum
generation threshold was equal to approximately 5 T W /c m 2 . The light contin
11U 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
uum spanned the spectral band from 0.4 to 1.0 p m . The continuum generation
threshold in ethylene glycol was found to be three to four times higher at 800 nm
than at 600 nm.
where
A k = &(wj) — k(uf2) — k(w3) — k(w4). (2.6.4)
where A - = A ( wjt ) , u>1 = u>2 + u>3 -f u>4. The expression for A k r is derived
from Eq. (2.6.4) by replacing the frequencies u . with Wjt .
At the same time, one can establish the relation between the spectral-domain
equations (2.6.3) and the time-domain equations, which is easily traced for the
nonresonant non linearity. Indeed, suppose that the interacting pulses have the
spectral widths Aui. with mean frequencies w . Q and the dispersion x can
be neglected within the frequency bands Au>j . We shall describe the dispersion
o f the linear susceptibility o f the medium using the second-order approximation
(1.3.1). Then, the time-domain equations for the com plex amplitudes o f the
pulses can be found from Eq. (2.6.3).
We shall illustrate what was said by the example o f a parametric interaction
o f the type w10 + w4Q = w20 + w3Q , with the phase detuning A kQ = &(w10) +
^(w4o) — ^(w2o) — K w3o) ■ Taking into account Eq. (1.3.1) and the relationship
A ( —lj , z) = A * (w , z ) , and using Eqs. (2.6.1) and (2.6.2), one can rewrite Eq.
(2.6.3) as
dA(Q.1 , z)
= —ip exp {i[A fc + /i(ft)]z } J J j A(£l2 , z ) A ( f l 3 , z ) A * { & a , z)
dz
where
TTUJ-, (3)
f3 — P(^x) — 2cn (w (W10 ’ W20 ’ W30 ’ ~ CJ4o) ’
h ((i.) = ^ - - - k j u . n) n 2 , Q . = u . - u . n.
y 3} u 2 3 1 1 3 3°
i
If we convert now Eq. (2.6.6) to the time-domain form by means o f the relation
+ OO
9 J L d _ *t ^ 1A ^ t , z) = - i p A 2A 3A l e iAk°z . (2.6.7)
dz + U l dt 2 2 10 fit2
d_ lS__i
A {t , z) = -i/31\A\2A , (2.6.8)
dz udt 2 2 Qt2
2. 7. Steady-state pulses: soliton regime o f propagation 113
^ - ^ 0 + ^ 1 ^ = °, (2.7.1)
n2 > 0 (/?j > 0) , the pulse frequency shift determined by Eq. (2.3.5) varies as
shown in Fig. 2.3 (c) . On the other hand, a relative delay o f various spectral
components o f a PM pulse is related to the dispersion parameter k2 ^ 0 (see
Sec. 2.4). In a medium with normal dispersion (fc2 > 0 , du/dw < 0) the initial
transform-limited pulse spreads faster than in a linear medium. In a nonlinear
medium with anomalous dispersion ( k2 < 0 , du/dui > 0 ), self-compression
o f a pulse takes place* [see Fig. 2 .2 (6 )]. These processes are analogous to
self-defocusing and self-focusing o f a two-dimensional beam. The nonlinearity
length
l k2Ps + TP s ~ P l p l = Q-
M A / + 2I>s2 - i V s = ° - (2.7.3)
W hen > 0 and k2 < 0 , Eq. (2.7.3) has the solution
where the duration ts of the soliton and its amplitude ps0satisfy therelation
*N ote that the self-com pression o f short optical pulses is shown in R ef, 58 to b e possible
in allcali m etal vapors.
2.1. Steady-state pulses: solilon regime o f propagation 115
FIG . 2.13. E volution o f pulse shape w ith distance at different energy density:
(a) W < W cr ; ( 6) W — W CI , soliton regime; (c) W > W Qr .
In a focusing medium with the normal dispersion (fc2 > 0 ) the short pulses
spread; for the details see Chap. 4. Here we shall explore the possible formation
o f the so-called “ dark” solitons. 60 T h ey have the form
—i T z
A S( V ’ z ) = P.o tanh (>?Ak) e (2.7.7)
r = V s “ 2 = /V s o -
i.e., the dark solitons represent the drop in the radiation intensity. Another
interpretation o f the solution (2.7.7) is a profile shock wave with the rise time r8 .
8 2E 1 d E And P
(2.7.8)
c 2 d t2 c2 dt2
[cf. Eq. (2.2.1)]. We shall limit our analysis with the case o f the exact resonance
( cjq = u>r) . Then the polarization o f the medium
where N is the density o f atoms (molecules) and dQ is the dipole moment. The
functions a ( t , z) and b ( t , z) are the envelopes o f the quadrature components
a ; b . to -tc
a = - — , b = —— + qpw , w = —q pb--------^ - 2 - . (2.7.11)
b ( t , z) = —s i n 6 ( t , z) , w ( t , z) = — cos 0 ( t , z ) , (2.7.14)
where
t
Substituting Eqs. (2.7.16) and (2.7.12) into Eq. (2.7.8), and assuming p ( t , z)
a slowly varying function, we obtain the dispersion relation
Y z ’ z) = - ^ ~ N d o s i n e (t ’ ZY (2.7.18)
2.7. Steady-state pulses: soliton regime o f propagation 117
The last term in Eq. (2.7.17) can be neglected since it does not exceed the value
8ttN d l u n JVfcwn / 0 , \ 2 , 2
Tt ) feo- (2-7.19)
he p /8 w Vwo
where 0 R = dQp/h is the Rabi precession frequency. The first cofactor, being
the ratio o f the energy stored by the particles to the energy o f the field, is less
than unity; the ratio 0 R/w Q <C 1 . Thus, neglecting the term mentioned before,
we obtain the simplified equation (2.7.17) which becomes the same as in the case
o f vacuum: fcQ = wQ/ c .
The most interesting results are obtained from Eq. (2.7.18). Expressing
p ( t , z) in terms o f 0 ( t , z ) by using Eq. (2.7.15), we substitute it into
Eq. (2.7.18) and eventually obtain the Gordon sine equation:
(2.7.22)
process proceeds without any energy loss since the duration rs is less than the
relaxation times 7^ and T2 . 61 ’ 62
According to Eq. (2.7.22) the resonant solitons propagate at the velocity
It diminishes with the growth o f the density N o f the particles, carrier frequency
u Q , and duration rs . The last dependence seems quite obvious as the reemission
o f energy o f the optical field results in the delay in the pulse propagation. The
longer the pulse duration, the greater the delay.
(a ) (b)
FIG . 2.14. Input (d otted lines) and ou tpu t (solid lines) pulses in a resonance
m edium at self-induced transparency: (a ) experiment; (b) theory. T he curves
correspond to the pulses whose area is less than 7r ( i ) , 2ir (£), betw een 2-x and
37: (<?), less than 5tt (4)^ and equal to approxim ately 6-tt (5).
The solution o f Eq. (2.7.20) for the arbitrary area # (+ o o ) is fairly compli
cated, being represented as a set o f interacting pulses. Figure 2.14 shows the
behavior o f the pulses with different initial durations in a resonant medium.
The initial pulses with 0 (+ o o ) < 2?r are seen to subside while the pulses with
2?r < 0 (+ o o ) < 3 tt take the steady-state form (2.7.24) and with 0 (+ o o ) > 3ir
break down into separate pulses. A m ore detailed analysis o f the interaction o f
short optical pulses with a resonance medium can be found in Ref. 61.
2.8. Instability o f optical waves m nonlinear media 119
A 0(t) = p0 + 6A 0( t ) , (2.8.1)
where £j40(i) is the com plex perturbation amplitude, |<5vl0|-C p0 ■ The solution
o f the self-action equation (2.7.1) for the considered wave superposition is sought
in the form
z ) = [p0 + ^ M rl> z)] e x p ( - i r z ) , (2.8.2)
where T = 0 1po is the correction to the wave number, caused by the intense
monochromatic wave. Substituting Eq. (2.8.2) into Eq. (2.7.1) we obtain in the
first-order approximation o f the perturbation theory
- 2
l k2 ^ ) SA = A + 6A*). (2.8.3)
In fact, Eq. (2.8.3) describes the behavior o f the perturbations in the parametric
approximation, with the intense m onochromatic wave performing the pumping.
Separating the real and imaginary components o f the perturbation,
I/*o
4
A A A.
2
In a medium with normal dispersion ( k2 > 0) the parameter h is real and the
modulated wave is therefore stable in a nonlinear medium. The situation changes
in a medium with anomalous dispersion (k2 < 0 ). The parameter h becomes
. 1J1
imaginary within the frequency bandwidth 0 < Q < Qcr = (4r/|fc2|) , and
the perturbations grow along the 2 axis with an increment
0 0.S i
Figure 2.16 shows how the distance Z<p at which the continuous radiation
transforms into a pulse train, depends on the modulation frequency Qm . It is
seen that L .p is at its minimum at in in ax
and weakly
*
depends
r
on Q m at
the center o f the amplification bandwidth. The value o f L grows appreciably
as the frequency Qm approaches the high-frequency boundary Qcr .
122 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
For the first time, the stability of a plane wave with respect to spatial transverse
perturbations was investigated in detail by Bespalov and Talan ov.30
Similarly to the problem o f temporal instability, the field in a nonlinear
medium is to be written in the form
A ( r , z) = [pQ + 6 A (r , z)\ exp ( - i T z ) ,
where 8 A {r , z) allows for the weak transverse perturbations (|M| -C p0) . In
accordance with Eq, (2.5.2), their evolution in the medium is described as
The transverse perturbations with the wave number |fcx |< fcXcrare unstable.
The maximum increment and the corresponding transverse wave number are
equal to [cf. Eqs. (2.8.9) and (2.8.10)]
U = *oV o - (2.8.14a)
Suppose that the initial conditions o f Eq. (2.8.3) take the form
The effects o f random perturbations on a regular pulse at the initial stage of non
linear propagation have been studied74 76 in the fixed channel approximation
using the path integral method. The essence of the developed approach consists
in rewriting Eq. (2.7.1) in a continual-integral form which is more suitable for
an analytical determination o f statistical characteristics of randomly modulated
pulses in a nonlinear medium. Before demonstrating how this approach is taken,
we shall rewrite Eq. (2.7.1) in the form
|V = 0. (2.8.17)
where Lspm is defined by Eq. (2.3.7), and &2 < 0 . Using the Feynman m ethod
o f path integration, Eq. (2.8.17) can be written in the form
+00
C
G{0 , t ; C) = J exp [ - J £ (r (x ) i ^(x )) dx D t (x ), (2.8.19)
£ { t (x ) , f ( x ) ) = ^ t 2{ x ) + R\ i/>(t ( x ) , x )f ,
t - R ^ - \ i p ( r ( x ) , x)\2 — 0 , (2.8.21)
Consequently,
I/O -, *)|2 = |i&0(r)|2. (2.8.22)
The utilization o f this equality in Eq. (2.8.21) means that at the next stage o f
solution o f Eq. (2.8.18) we consider the propagation o f the pulse in the medium
whose properties are determined by the initial pulse. Such an approximation is
customarily called a fixed channel approximation (F C A ). It remains valid over
the distances z < Z<n] [see Eq. (2.7.2)].
2.8. Instability o f optical waves in nonlinear media 125
75
We shall restrict our consideration to the self-action o f PM pulses. From
Eq. (2.8.22) it is easy to see that the pulse modulation does not affect the
parameters o f the given channel. Provided the pulses have the Gaussian envelope
2 2
|^>0(r)| = exp( —t ) , and taking into account Eq. (2.8.22), we obtain in the
paraxial approximation ( r < 1) the following expression for the optimal paths
from Eq. (2.8.21):
where hQ — (2R ) 1^2 . The substitution o f Eq. (2.8.23) into Eq. (2.8.19) yields
G ( t , 6 ; 0 = [ - i 2 * h - 1 s i n ( V ) ] “ 1/2
b (t 2 ’ ri ; 0 = i . 0 (r2 , 0 )
r i + r a “ 2( ff/ rph)2(r2 - ri ) 2-
= V2 (C)exp (2.8.27)
2V22( 0
From Eq. (2.8.27) it follows that in the considered approximation the ensemble-
averaged duration rp o f the pulse and the correlation time r, obey the similar
laws: rp (£) = j rc( 0 ~ '^2Tc p U <T ' Both quantities remain constant
the average duration o f the pulse and the correlation time can therefore be
constant.
Random PM o f the pulse leads to the increase in the threshold ha (2.8.29)
o f steady-state propagation and, consequently, to the increase in the threshold
energy density. At weak phase fluctuations (a < 1) the pulse (2.8.25) can be
represented as a sum o f a regular and a random part, each o f which behaves
differently in a nonlinear medium. Hence, there is no condition for the steady-
state propagation o f such pulses. The effects o f noise perturbation on the nonlin
2.9. Quantum theory o f self-action 127
ear propagation o f a regular pulse have been considered in Ref. 74 in the given
channel approximation. Threshold conditions for optical soliton formation from
noise pulses have been analyzed in Refs. 79 and 80.
Self-actions o f noise pulses wexe investigated both by the method o f path
76 63 81 8
integration and the method o f statistical testing. ' ’ Let us
Ref. 68 where the influence o f random perturbations o f the form
on the supercritical pulse was examined; £(t) is the com plex Gaussian random
process with the correlation time rc . Figure 2.18 shows the intensity profiles
o f the initial and disintegrated pulses for different times rc . The pulse is seen
to disintegrate into the sequence o f randomly located subpulses. The disinte
gration length is the shortest when the characteristic “frequency” o f random
perturbations « 27r/t coincides with the center o f the instability region
determined by p0 . As the correlation time increases up to the values com pa
rable with the pulse duration, there may arise a single pulse above the broad
pedestal, although the distance at which it appears does not generally coincide
with the self-compression length o f a deterministic pulse. The overlapping inte
gral o f spectral noise density and g(Cl) play the decisive role here. Hence, the
supercritical pulses experiencing noise perturbations do not compress. At suffi
ciently long distances (z —*■oo) the pulse transforms into a sequence o f solitons
with random parameters.
76 81 82
The calculations o f correlation times, ’ intensity fluctuations, and dis-
81
tribution o f probability density o f the field fluctuations have been carried out
for the noise pulses at the initial stage o f self-action.
In conclusion, we want to emphasize that the investigation o f perturbation
evolution in the presence o f both spatial and temporal modulation is more com
plicated. That is why the behavior o f such perturbations has been so far discussed
77 83
only at the background o f a plane wave.
This equation can be formally derived by replacing the com plex amplitudes
ip ( r , C) j 7P(T > C) in a com plex conjugate o f Eq. (2.8.17) with the slowly vary
ing operators <^(r, Q , <P+ ( t , Q corresponding to positive- and negative-
frequency parts o f the field respectively. The nonlinear term has to be replaced
iw Z. belj-achon of optical pulses
The operator (j> differs from A ^ used in Sec. 1.8 in its normalization
B = l \ I ^ + ( T ' ° dT
— OO
+ OC
4-00
+ R J {<f>+ ( T , C)]2 [ ^ ( t , C)]2 ^ | . (2.9.5)
Q u a n tu m lig h t s q u e e z in g
We have already discussed in Sec. 1.8 the quantum effects associated with the
second derivative in Eq. (2.9.1). Therefore we shall primarily analyze here the
role o f quantum effects in self-actions in the absence o f dispersive spreading. We
shall show that the self-action process can promote formation o f non-classical
optical fields. 93-103
Thus, we proceed from the quasi-steady-state quantum equation o f self-action
To make the quantum effects more evident, let us first consider the self-action
o f single-mode coherent radiation described at the entrance to the medium by
the operator aQ. In this case Eqs. (2.9.7) take the form
For the initial coherent state with amplitude aQ, the mean value of the operator
(2.9.9a) is equal to
2
At q < 1 , neglecting the terms o f order q and higher, we obtain the classical
result [cf. Eq. (2.3.3)]:
a(q) = aQ exp ( i ' t ) , (2.9.11)
where <?x = ( ( A X ) 2) , A X — X — { X ) .
The interest in the quadrature com ponents is caused by the fact that they
determine the current o f a balanced hom odyne detector
K r) = J H ( T - Ti ) j 0( Ti ) dri ’ (2.9.15)
— OO
where H ( t ) is the response function o f the detector and j 0(r ) is the operator
o f the instantaneous current, which, in the case o f intense heterodyne radiation
and unit quantum efficiency o f the detector, is equal to
j { T) = 2 J H ( r - Ti ) A h( Ti ) X ( Ti ’ l ) dri- (2.9.17)
— CO
j(Sl) = A hH ( Q ) X ( S l , q ), (2.9.18)
where H(Sl) is the transfer function of the detector. In the radiation detection
technique considered here the fluctuations o f current are associated with the
fluctuations o f the quadrature com ponent X .
The mean value o f the quadrature X is equal to
cr2
x (q) = 1 {1 - 2 sin [2(v? + * ) ] + 4 tf2 sin2 (v? + * ) } . (2.9.20)
4 m i n ( 9 ) = j [ ( l + ^ 2) 1 /2 - ^ ] 2 , (2.9.21)
Similar calculations show that under this condition the variance o f the quadra
ture Y has the maximum value
Let us analyze now the quantum self-action o f pulses, described by Eqs. (2.9.7).
Naturally, we shall be dealing with intense optical fields. First, we shall separate
in the operator <P0( t ) the fluctuation contribution A 4>0{ t ) :
0 ( r , q) = a ( r , q) + A ^ ( r , q ) , (2.9.25a)
where 'S'('r) = </|a0( r )[2. In the considered case we obtain the quantum correla
tion function o f the field (the Glauber correlation function o f the first order):
Note that the structure o f Eq. (2.9.27), coincides with that o f Eq. (2.9.20). If
the phase modulation o f the initial pulse satisfies the expression [cf. Eq. (2.9.22)]
which coincides with the quadrature variance in the case o f the self-action o f
single-mode radiation (2.9.21). In fact, F ( t ) is a quadrature variance; it changes
adiabatically with the pulse profile variations. In other words, the quantum
fluctuations are suppressed non-uniformly along the pulse profile. The strict
calculation o f the spectrum (2.9.28) for the function (2.9.30) can be performed
only by numerical methods. The quantum analysis o f self-action o f ultrashort
pulses has thus shown that intense pulses can be formed in a non-classical state.
2.9. Quantum theory o f self-action 133
^ o W = ao + 4 W - (2.9.31)
where 0Q is the phase o f the intense wave, and 7 = 7?|«0|2 is the change o f the
wave number due to the self-action.
In the parametric approximation (in the first-order approximation o f pertur
bation theory) the evolution o f quantum fluctuations in a nonlinear medium is
described by the equation
2
+00
we obtain
a A b(Q , C ) + ( 7 - m , 0 + 7 b+ ( - Q , C) = 0. (2.9.34)
2
| ^ 6 ( Q , 0 + 52(Q)6(Q, 0 = 0,
aC
9{n) = %2 72 - n 2) 1/2. (2 .9 .36 )
134 2. Self-action o f optical pulses
The solution o f Eq. (2.9.36) with boundary conditions taken into account yields
where
b0{Q) = b{Q, 0 ),
For param etric am plification and conversion o f light, as well as for optical harm onic gener
ation, a nonresonant electronic nonlinear response in gases and condensed m atter is usually
em ployed. In this case the response time does not exceed 10 fs. T he increase in light inten
sity resulting from m ode-locking o f a laser (tem poral focusing) leads to a substantial growth
in the efficiency o f nonlinear interaction o f waves.
Pulse shortening is usually accom panied w ith an increase in the breakdow n threshold o f
a nonlinear m edium ; the critical field value for an avalanche break-dow n is equal to
^cr ~ V ^ /V
It is therefore natural that the ultim ate efficiency o f an optical frequency doubler and of
a superlum inescent param etric optical oscillator has been achieved for the first time in the
field o f fem tosecond pulses.
T he linear dispersion o f group velocity is a lim iting factor which manifests itself very
sharply for fem tosecond pulses. Th at is w hy the developm ent o f the m ethods to com pen
sate the group-velocity m ism atch o f interacting pulses, that is, the group-velocity m atching
m ethods, is so urgent. O n the other hand, param etric interactions o f wave packets produce,
under conditions o f strong group-velocity m ism atch, som e new nonlinear wave phenom ena
that can b e used as a basis for efficient m ethods o f ultrashort pulse form ation. A m ong these
m ethods are the generation o f “giant” param etric pulses resulting from the interaction o f
short wave packets with largely differing durations, param etric soliton form ation etc.
W hen the pulse durations r p < rn] , nonlinear interactions can be utilized in various
techniques o f transient nonlinear spectroscopy. It becom es possible not only to com pre
hensively study the relaxation o f energy and phase o f an optical excitation b ut to observe
directly the form o f m olecular oscillations o r optical vibrations o f the lattice: the m odern
fem tosecond laser technique makes it possible to obtain optical pulses whose durations last
only one osciEation period !
frequencies. Such interactions prove efficient only when a fast optical nonlinearity
is involved. These interactions can be described in relatively simple terms. A
nonlinear response o f a medium can be represented as a power series in an optical
field:
F = F 1 + F n l, P " 1 = x m E E + x (3)E E E + . . . (3.1.1)
It should be immediately pointed out that even in the case o f high-intensity
(2s)
fields o f pico- and femtosecond optical pulses, the inequalities x E 1,
X ^ E E <C 1 for the spectral com ponents and x ^ responsible for the
interactions considered here, are usually valid. Therefore, a standard procedure
describing the nonlinearity that we intend to use, remains within the framework
o f the perturbation theory. The Maxwell equation
E , { t , 0) = ^ 10(*)eiWlt + c . c . (3.2.1)
falls on a medium with quadratic optical nonlinearity. The field in the medium
can be written in the form
E ( t , z ) = E 1( t , z) + E 2( t , z)
JL^tU j . ra ram etn c interaction and coherent scattering
Substituting Eq. (3.2.2) into Eq. (3.1.2), we obtain the truncated equations in
the first-order approximation of the dispersion theory
= <3-2’4>
where
„ (2) 2 . ( 2) 2
2 ttX w, 4ttx w,
y' = - F ^ ' ,!= 1 # ( 3 ' 2 ' 5 )
are the coefficients o f nonlinear wave coupling; and u2 are the group ve
locities o f the fundamental wave and o f the second harmonic (SH), respectively;
A k = 2A/1'* — k^ is the phase mismatch.
Group velocity matching; quasi-steady-state regime. The set o f Eqs. (3.2.3)
and (3.2.4) has the exact solution when the group velocities are equal, u1 = u2
(the group-velocity matching). Th e solution appears especially simple when the
condition o f phase matching, A k = 0 , is also satisfied. Introducing the real
amplitudes and phases A n = pn exp(*Vra) > we get
In the fixed field approximation, when px and (py can be assumed invariable
along the whole interaction length, that is, when the conversion o f energy of
the fundamental wave into that o f SH is insignificant, p2(r), z) = j z p yo(r}) .
The SH pulse shortens in the process. For a Gaussian pulse o f the fundamental
radiation p 10(r]) = p0 e x p ( —t 2/2T2) the SH pulse duration r2 = Ty/\/2 . As the
conversion efficiency grows, the duration r2 becomes longer and approaches .
According to Eq. (3.2.6c) the frequency doubling of a pulse with the linear chirp
¥>10(!j) — QLTj j 2 is accompanied by the doubling o f the SH frequency variation
2
rate, tp2(r)) = arj — 7r/2 .
Group delay effects; transient regime. In reality, the group-velocity matching
conditions do not hold, as a rule, u 1 ^ u2 . The group delay, appearing due
to group-velocity mismatch, defines the picture o f nonlinear interaction most
effectively. This group-velocity mismatch, or group mismatch, is equal to
a -1
A„
* -1
=A «2 1= _
1
—
1 1 / * ^” 9 * dni \ ,
(3. 2. 7)
X
(3.2.8a)
3.2. Ultrashort pulse frequency doubling 141
where Atiij is the spectral width of the fundamental pulse. For a transform-
limited pulse
Lvi = r y \ A u ~ 1\. (3.2.8b)
+°° 2
ST ( n ) = ( y 2z ) y , (3.2.10b)
— OO
where ^410(Q) is the Fourier spectrum o f the com plex amplitude vl10( i ) ;
s in cz = x sin x (see Fig. 3.1). Equation (3.2.10b) describes the SH spectral
density in the quasi-steady-state regime o f generation. Equations (3.2.10) are
valid for the arbitrary modulation o f the envelope and phase o f the original pulse.
W hen z Lw , the spectral width o f the SH is less than that o f the fundamen
tal radiation. This implies that transient frequency doubling is accompanied
^_3
with strong spreading o f the SH pulse. W hen the frequency doubling o f a
transform-limited pulse takes place, the SH pulse duration is in fact independent
o f the fundamental pulse duration:
r2 k , |Au 1\z.
It should be noted that for PM pulses the transient effects arise at the lengths
z > L Yv ‘, but not at z < L Yv .
For crystals o f potassium dihydrophosphate (K D P ) and lithium niobate
(LiNbO 3 ), which are used in nonlinear optics, the excitation o f an extraordinary
SH wave by an ordinary fundamental wave with Aj = 1.06 p m is characterized
_^ 12 —13
with the mismatch A u equal to 5 .2 x 1 0 and —1 .0 x 1 0 s /cm , respec-
^ 12
tively. In the former crystal A u = 2.5 x 10 s /c m for A1 = 0.53 p m . To
evaluate the walk-off length we shall take, for example, a fundamental pulse du
ration o f Ty = 100 fs. Then for the above-mentioned values o f Aw 1 we obtain
I<w = 0.2-10 mm. A K T P crystal ( K T i 0 P 0 4 ) with the group-velocity mis-
—1 —12
match Aw = 4.4 x 10 s /c m at Ax = 1.06 p m is quite efficient in frequency
doubling o f pico- and femtosecond pulses. 57
J -tz j. ra ra m etn c interaction and coherent scattering
In Ref. 107, 108 the authors calculated the group velocities and their disper
sion for widely used nonlinear crystals (B B O , KDP, K TP, L iN b O a and others).
The SH spectrum has a maximum at the frequency wmax = 2u>l — A fc /A u 1
(see Fig. 3.1), and its width A w 3 = 2n/z\Au 1|. In the transient regime the
central frequency o f the SH can be continuously timed by varying the phase
mismatch A k . In the case o f strong energy transfer, transformations o f the
spectrum and pulse shape are more complicated. One o f the possible approxi
mations to the solution of this problem is indicated in Ref. 1 where the phase
invariance is assumed (see Fig. 3.2).
^ io (* ) - P0 e x p [ - ( r ~ 2 - i a ) t 2/2], (3.2.11)
Then, for r ” 1 < A Q f < 2 a rx we obtain from Eq. (3.2.9) the SH intensity
(Air = 0) *
From the last equation the pulse duration r2 « (az\Au J|) 1 can be shown to
decrease as z 1 . 1 ’ 4
Note that due to the spatio-temporal analogy mentioned above the discussed
effects appearing in frequency doubling o f short wave packets have the evident
analogy in the theory o f frequency doubling o f limited optical beams. This
analogy has been carefully followed in Ref. 1. The group-velocity mismatch
effects have the corresponding effects associated with a drift o f the beams due
to anisotropy o f a medium.
Back-action effects o f SH on a phase o f the primary radiation; the fixed inten
sity approximation. At a high SH conversion efficiency, an analysis based only
on Eq. (3.2.4) is incorrect since the back-action effects o f the second harmonic on
the fundamental radiation need to be taken into account. A complete analytical
solution o f such a problem is impossible. At the same time, many details o f a
frequency doubling process in the presence o f the back-action can be understood
only after having taken into account the SH effects on the phase o f the funda
mental radiation. Since the phase effects are predominant, this approximation,
referred to as the fixed intensity approximation, 5 is adequate up to a frequency
doubling efficiency o f 50%.
We shall tackle first the problem that has the exact solution and allows one
to grasp the essence o f the fixed intensity approximation and indicate its scope.
For a quasi-steady-state regime, we obtain from Eqs. (3.2.3) and (3.2.4) the
second-order equation for the SH amplitude:
d2 ... a
A 2 {t), z ) = 0 (3.2.13)
d ? + i A k f c + 2 j i'r2I i ( TI’
3A2
A Jr), z = 0) = 0 , (3.2.14)
dz 2=0
where
1/2
J l7 2
« = 2 Ak 1 + i
(Ak)
Comparing Eq. (3.2.15) with the exact solution, we can find the region in which
the approximation is valid. From Eqs. (3.2.3) and (3.2.15) we find how the phase
o f the fundamental wave varies:
In the case A k ^ 0 an addition to the phase, and consequently to the phase ve
locity o f the fundamental wave, depends on an intensity o f the fundamental wave.
In other words, a peculiar self-action sets in.* T h e nonlinear phase addition at
A k z > 1 and ( A k ) 2 > 167172A1/ lo (0) is equal to
(3.2.17)
It follows from the comparison o f Eqs. (3.2.17) and (2.3.4) that the equivalent
correction to the refractive index o f a medium equals
eq
7 i7 2V (2 7 r A fc ). (3.2.18)
It is seen from here that in the case o f the SH back-action on the fundamen
tal wave the nonlinear medium possesses focusing properties at A k > 0 and
defocusing properties at Afc < 0. Consequently, frequency doubling o f high-
intensity optical beams will be accompanied with self-focusing ( A k > 0) or
self-defocusing o f the fundamental beam, i.e., in media with quadratic nonlin
earity, one can observe the self-actions similar to those appearing in media with
cubic nonlinearity.
Now we shall examine a transient frequency doubling in the fixed intensity
approximation. The com plex amplitude o f the fundamental wave will be taken
in the form (3.2.11). Passing in Eqs. (3.2.3) and (3.2.4) to the new coordinates
*This phenom enon was reported for the first time in Ref. 6 .
3.2. Ultrashort pulse frequency doubling 145
31
+ i n * ) A ( Vl> r,2) = 0 (3.2.20)
dV! dv2 4
7?2)U1=r?2 = °>
/ 27T / 2 A 1|/2
AQf = ^ r T l 1“ 7 TlT2/lo(0) j ’ (
i.e., the SH back-action brings about a narrowing o f its spectrum. The experi
mental observations o f this effect were reported in Ref. 7. The narrowing and
140 X Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
SHG efficiency
FIG . 3.3. Energy efficiency o f SHG as reduced length C* = z /Lcony for different
P M at otr\ : (1) 0 , ( 2 ) 5, (3) 10 . 8
other modifications o f the spectrum were registered in the cross section o f the
SH excited by a Gaussian beam.
Frequency multiplication o f P M pulses; numerical results. At high conversion
coefficients, transient SHG excited by PM pulses cannot be studied analytically.
The numerical solution o f Eqs. (3.2.3) and (3.2.4) has been obtained in Ref. 8;
the results are shown in Fig. 3.3. The phase modulation is seen to hamper a
total conversion o f the fundamental radiation energy into the SH. The phase
relations between the interacting waves produce an oscillating dependence o f the
conversion efficiency on the interaction length.
All the results listed before characterize the frequency doubling o f plane waves.
O f course, their comparison with experimental data requires the cross sectional
distribution to be allowed for. We have already mentioned Ref. 7 in which the
authors report SH spectrum modifications associated with nonuniform intensity
distribution in the beam cross section. O f particular interest is the problem o f
SHG by focused ultrashort pulses. Its detailed analysis is given in Ref. 9.
W hat was said is illustrated in Fig. 3.4. The duration A r 2 o f the peak forming
in the vicinity o f the leading edge is equal to
in accordance with Eq. (3.2.25). The shortening o f the length -£conv , or the
increase in the intensity o f the fundamental radiation, leads to shortening o f the
peak. W hen the group velocity mismatch Aw-1 = 1 x 10-13 s /cm , the length
L co n v » 0.1 cm, then A r 0 ~ 10 fs. The fronts o f such duration can be formed
in a field o f picosecond pulses o f fundamental radiation.
From the experimental standpoint, the effects of this kind are easier to ob
serve for nondegenerated interactions. In particular, a well-known example is
the generation o f giant pulses o f stimulated Raman scattering in the case o f
3T
counterpropagating wave interaction with quasi-cw pumping.
j/io J. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
W hen the group-velocity mismatch effects are insignificant, the dispersion can
affect a SHG efficiency by means o f dispersive spreading o f pulses. It is therefore
clear that whenever we deal with frequency multiplication o f pico- and femtosec
ond pulses, the question o f their optim um duration, resulting in the maximum
conversion efficiency, is legitimate. We shall calculate the optimum duration in
the fixed field approximation for the fundamental wave.
In the second-order approximation o f the dispersion theory the frequency
doubling is described by the equation
where
is practically reached at
0.47(|fc22)|z)1/2. (3.2.31)
Despite the large difference between the dispersion parameters and k[l> ,
the expressions for the optimum durations (3.2.31) and (3.2.32) differ only by a
numerical factor. Inasmuch as the condition k ^ = 2k ^ cannot be satisfied in
media with normal dispersion, Eq. (3.2.31) is more suitable for description o f
real phenomena.
_ t l 9 ( a a ; ) (3 2 3 4 )
Wj dt 2wj dt
respectively. A contribution o f wave transience, or nonlinear coupling dispersion,
to the SHG process is proportional to ( w ^ ) 1 . Equations (3.2.3) and (3.2.4)
generalized in this way are not analytically tractable. Numerical calculations
under the conditions o f simultaneous phase and group-velocity matching are
presented in Ref. 11. The basic results consist in the following. The highest SH
conversion is reached at the distance
^ = 0 -8 3 ^ X 2 .4 1 ^ ). (3.2.35)
In the region z > Leff the conversion efficiency oscillates around a mean value
that is much below 100%. Thus, the nonlinear coupling dispersion can be re
garded as an additional factor limiting the efficiency o f frequency doubling of
ultrashort pulses.
150 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
E (t, z) = E p( i , z) + Es ( t , z) + E i( t , z)
dA 1 dA * ;A b
^ ^ ■ - (3-3.3)
\ a
“ 9 7 + ^ r “ 9 T = - l7 p ^ e - (3 -3-5)
where
r\ (2) 2 „ (2) 2 o v (2)2
2 ttx w 2 ttx W:
7 ^ - T T ~ ' T i = =
p
are the coefficients o f nonlinear coupling o f the waves. If the phase and group-
velocity mismatch is small, the weak waves at the frequencies w and grow
exponentially in the field o f a high-power pump wave.
3.3. Parametric amplification o f short pulses 151
where rs(z) is the duration o f the signal pulse. Thus, the signal pulse acquires
a Gaussian shape irrespective o f its original form. A duration o f the ampli
fied signal pulse shortens with distance as 1j-J z . In practice the pulse can be
compressed by several-fold.
Under the conditions o f strong energy transfer the shape o f the amplified
pulse distorts. It is possible to carry out the relevant numerical calculations.
Figure 3.6 shows how the reverse transfer o f the signal wave energy to the pump
pulse results in the development o f a valley in the signal pulse form.
Note that according to Eq. (3.3.6) the phase o f the signal pulse remains
constant in the process o f parametric amplification provided both the input
152 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
signal pulse and the pump pulse are phase modulated. The situation is different
when an idler wave
is considered. According to Eq. (3.3.8) this wave acquires the phase modulation
o f the pump pulse (see the cofactor exp [i<pp0(r))]) • At the same time, the phase
front o f the idler wave proves to be conjugate relative to that o f the signal
wave. As we shall see later, this fact allows the development o f efficient phase
modulation control.
Group-velocity mismatch effects. T h e analysis of the transient regime of
parametric interaction o f wave packets is best started with the case of the signal
and idler waves propagating under the conditions o f group-velocity matching
(z < L while their group-velocity mismatch relative to the pump pulse
(z > L^s ’ p ) , L ^ ’ p^) is sufficiently large. Then in the fixed pump field ap
proximation we can get from Eqs. (3.3 .3 )-(3.3 .5 ), by analogy with Eq. (3.3.6),
F IG . 3.7. Giant subharm on ic pulse form ation in the quasi continuous pum p field
for > u p and leading edge rise tim e r le > r cr = |Au“ 1p |La : ( l ) initial
pulse, (2) pulse at j: = L (orrn , (3) z X 2Lform , (4) ' > 2 ; LfoJm is the
distance over which the steady-state pulse is form ed; it is determ ined b y the pump
• - 13
intensity and pulse rise time.
It follows from here that the group-velocity mismatch lowers the gain; as z
grows, predominant amplification is experienced by either the leading edge o f
3.3. Parametric amplification o f short pulses 153
the pulse (at us < up ) or the trailing edge (at us > up ). As a result, the
signal pulse broadens, the interacting pulses leave a pump region at the distance
z L^’ , L^' , and the energy transfer discontinues.
Just as in the case o f SHG, generation o f giant pulses is possible in the process
o f parametric amplification under the conditions o f noticable walk-off. Figure 3.7
illustrates the dynamics o f formation o f a giant subharmonic pulse (in a degen
erated regime o f parametric amplification, ws = u i = wp/2 ) . In contrast to
the frequency doubling regime, the pulse is seen to be compressed much more
efficiently. The detailed numerical analysis is given in Refs. 13 and 14.
It should be finally noted that in the three-frequency parametric interaction o f
short optical pulses a steady-state regime o f the so-called mode amplification is
feasible. In fact, this is still another manifestation o f a peculiar balance between
the nonlinear interaction and dispersion. If the group velocities o f the pump,
signal, and idler waves are chosen so that ug < up < Uj or < up < ug , then
the exponential amplification regime remains also at the distances exceeding
the walk-off length. Besides, the pulses of invariable shape are formed at the
frequencies u g and located on either side o f the pump pulse. This effect was
discussed for the first time by Freidman et al. 15 and by Sukhorukov et al. 16
who presented an elaborate theory o f this phenomenon. The numerical analysis
is carried out in Ref. 12.
F I G .3.8. M odes o f param etric signals in the pum p field pp (ij ) = Pp0 sech (ijp / t )
(dashed line) at various values o f param eters m and l 'ni : ( / ) 1/2, 0 ; ( 2 ) 1 ,
l/ 2 £ , a ; ( J ) 2 , 3 /2 L a ; Vp = t - z / u p .1B
Figure 3.8 shows the structure o f m ode pulses at a signal wavelength for
equal group velocity mismatches A u ~ Xp = A u Xp = A n -1 . The mode gain
coefficients are equal to — e x p (r mz ) . T h e behavior o f the pulses is determined
by the ratio m o f the walk-off length to the amplification length, m = Lw/ L a ,
L w — rp/|A u 1|. At m > 1 /2 the pulse shape remains invariable, its amplitude
grows exponentially with m , and its duration shortens as against the pump
pulse, r [ m^ = rp/m . The amplification terminates at m — 1 /2 .
Note that the condition z > L W has to be satisfied in order to *pass to the
mode regime. Accordingly, the duration exceeds rs in a quasi-steady-state
regime o f amplification. The peak o f a steady-state pulse shifts relative to the
maximum of a pump pulse by the time interval —rp/2 m .
154 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
We have considered how the phase modulation o f a pump pulse affects the phase
modulation o f an idler wave in a quasi-steady-state regime o f amplification [see
Eq. (3.3.8)]. W hat are the characteristic properties o f interaction o f PM pulses
in the transient regime o f amplification? T o answer this question, the set o f
Eqs. (3.3.3)—(3.3.5) has to be solved for a PM pump pulse. Before performing
the necessary calculations, we shall make use o f simple considerations based on
the relations between the frequencies and wave vectors:
Wp = Ws + Wi , kp — ks + t , Ak = 0 (3.3.10)
In the case o f the pumping with quadratic PM <p {t) = —a pt 2j 2 the phases
o f the signal and idler waves <^5(t) = —a gt 2/ 2 and ^ ( f ) = —a [t 2/2 , where
a s ; = % ia p ■ At qs 1 the frequency variation rate o f the excited pulses
exceeds that o f the pump wave. A ccording to Eq. (3.3.11), however, the signs
o f frequency variation rate are opposite. No doubt, the actual dynamics o f the
interaction o f PM pulses o f finite duration proves to be more complicated.
Here is the solution o f Eqs. (3.3.3)-(3.3.5) for a PM Gaussian pump pulse:
T = z t /Tp> o c j = a . i -p, j - s , i, p ,
^ ^ + (3.3.13)
These equations are valid provided the process transience is associated with PM
s-*,, a z 2 <C L ^ ’ S^ L ^ ’ l^). Let us assume that at
o f the pump pulse (z < L ^ ’ ^
the input o f a nonlinear medium
A ( r > z = ° ) = A so(r ) ex p ( - * a ;r 2/ 2 ) , A ^ r , z = 0) = 0.
3.3. Parametric amplification of short pulses 155
FIG . 3.9. D ependence o f dispersion param eter q, on the frequency ratio ujJ uj
— OO
where A s0(f2) is the Fourier spectrum o f the signal pulse. It follows from the last
equation that the signal gain in a PM pump field is accompanied by a time shift o f
the frequency band o f amplification according to a linear equation u>s = u)s —a st .
Using this relation together with the expression for the instantaneous pump
frequency a / = wp — a t , one can easily derive Eq. (3.3.11). The maximum
frequency deviations in the generated pulses are
s m ax
W as r p, ' Slll>.m ax t e a1 rp .
The ratio
Su>s m ax'
/Aui a = a p\(z L a /)1/2(L(p’
V vv
s))' _1 < 1
specifies the condition at which PM o f the pump pulse weakly affects the ampli
fication process. The same condition limits the maximum frequency deviation
o f the pulse amplified.
156 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
( I + { I ) A-{t • (‘ ■- t, ) ^ (* ■- i ) (3'41>
in the first-order approximation o f the dispersion theory. Here the amplitudes
A w (t) and A 2Q(t) are the given functions, A k ~ 0 . In the general case the
efficiency o f generation o f the sum frequency ws = uj1 -f lu\2 is determined by the
group-velocity mismatches
and their respective walk-off lengths. Thus, the generation practically stops
when the group delay td — |A«21 \z equals the duration o f the input pulse
propagating with the highest velocity. A t u1 > u 2 the walk-off length
1) = ( A « - 1A U i) " 1 , (3-4-3)
ftA u 2n
P 2
ss(U , z) 1 +' (3.4.5)
A u 1A u 21
In this equation, as distinct from Eq. (3.4.4), the spectrum is not modulated at
the sum frequency. From Eq. (3.4.5) one can easily find the spectral width in a
substantially transient regime o f generation. Here is its estimation for the cascade
generation o f an extraordinary fifth harmonic in a calcite crystal by ordinary
waves consisting o f mixed fundamental and third-harmonic radiation. For the
wavelengths A1 = 1.06 fim and A2 = 0.353 fim the parameter A u s2 /u21 = 3.3
and the spectral width ratio o f the generated pulse in the transient and quasi-
steady-state regimes is equal to 0.08. In other words, the fifth-harmonic pulse
turns to be 12-fold longer than the original one. Note that the theory o f transient
frequency mixing has been developed in Refs. 19-21.
The effects associated with group velocity dispersion are considered in Ref. 20.
The joint effects o f the mismatch and dispersion o f group velocities shorten the
pulse duration at the sum frequency and raise its energy.
Let us take up now the regime o f highly efficient mixing o f short pulses. Suppose
that a pumping is provided by a wave at the frequency u>l . Then in the first-
order approximation o f the dispersion theory the process under consideration is
described by the set o f equations
dA _ i dA . *
^ 7 + 21 o f - = - z)A i M -
(3.4.6a)
dA _i dA
(3.4.6b)
~d7 + sl d ^ = ’ ^ lo fa i) ’
The general solution o f the set (3.4.6) can be written using the Riemann method;
in more detail, it is examined in Refs. 22 and 23. Here we shall discuss a para
metric soliton generation, the phenomenon which is more interesting from the
physical standpoint. When a pump pulse is short, while a pulse with the fre
quency u>2 long { A 20 ~ const), then the leading edge o f the generated pulse with
the frequency ws propagates with the velocity uld = max (u 1 , u2) and its trail
ing edge with the velocity utr = m in (u 1 , u2). The duration o f the generated
pulse increases with the distance traversed. A t z > = Ti/| A ,usl1|, =
T j/I A u ^ I a steady-state pulse is formed at the sum frequency. This quasisoli-
ton can be calculated by assuming d A %2j d z = 0 in Eq. (3.4.6). We shall
3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
analyze the solution in the way it has been done in Ref. 22. Depending on
the ratio o f the group velocities o f the pulse, the two regimes are distinguished:
At/ j1 > 0 and Awsl1Aw211 < 0 . In the former case the pump pulse moves
faster (w-j > u 2 , us) or slower (u j < « 2 , us) than the low-intensity waves.
A t (mj < u 2 , u$) the steady-state pulse shape is
/ y A ll” 1 \ l ! 2
M v 1) = - i ( 2^ r ^ r ) A ^ s in G ^ ), (3.4.7)
2a « 21 j
/y | A iT 1| \ 1/ 2
z ) = ( ~S, A ^ i . ) A sechG(oo)sinhC?(?y1). (3.4.8)
Vt2|A«21 IJ
At G (o o ) 1 the pulse amplitude saturates. Parametric quasisolitons can exist
in the PM field o f pump pulses. The numerical calculations presented in Ref. 23
confirm this conclusion.
In three-frequency phase-match interactions o f wave packets a “true” soli-
24
ton can exist in media with quadratic nonlinearity, where spreading o f wave
packets becomes significant. A s in the case o f Schrodinger solitons, the dis
persive spreading o f the pulses is counterbalanced by their nonlinear compres
sion. In this case, however, the pulses with different frequencies get captured
to form multiple-frequency solitons. Generation, collision and decay o f para
metric multiple-frequency solitons are investigated in detail in Ref. 25 (see also
Ref. 106).
Wl - W2 = f i >
(3.5.1)
3.5. Difference-frequency generation and IR Cherenkov radtation 159
- fc ( 2 ) _ knip u(fi)
« - * . = — — = — ( 3 J U >
E (t, r , z) = E 1( t , r , z) + E 2( t , r , z)
1 j z x — 1 . . - i(w t—k ^ z ) _ . N
~ 2 i ( r) e +5 2(r) + C ' C‘ ( ^
is fed to the input o f a nonlinear medium. Then, according to Eq. (3.1.2), the
3.5. Difference-frequency generation and IR Cherenkov radiation 161
v at
A£df - A | U f - ^ £ ( X (2)^ c at 2)
= ( 7 ) X (2 ) ^ i ( r ) A * ( r ) - fen lp Z ) ] i ( 3 -5 -5 )
A E df( r , z) + k 2E d{( r , z)
where
Cl Cl
k = - = - n(Cl) (3.5.8)
v c
is the wave number o f the free DF electromagnetic wave. Integrating Eq. (3.5.7)
for the case o f plane waves, we obtain
where
A k = k — knlp = k - kW + k{2\
+ OO
If the beams with the frequencies w1 , w2 are slightly divergent, the DF com
ponent o f the spatial spectrum satisfies the equation
d2
Edf( k x , z) + (k — kj_)Ed{( k ± , z) = —j F ( k ± ) exp (—iknlpz ) , (3.5.11)
2 2 2
k = ^|| + k± , where fey and k± are the longitudinal (along the z axis) and
+ OO
Integrating Eq. (3.5.11) with allowance made for the boundary conditions at
the input to the medium, E dt(k ± , 0) = 0 , and for the radiation conditions, we
obtain
z ) = ~ i k T k— F (k ± )
K || + * n lp
The solution (3.5.13) makes it possible to substantiate and refine the qual
itative considerations which led us to derivation of Eq. (3.5.3). The two key
aspects are (i) a slight divergence o f pump beams, i.e., the vector &nlp insignifi
cantly deviates from the z axis, and (ii) a small characteristic size o f the spatial
region, occupied by the nonlinear polarization wave, as against the DF radiation
wavelength. Thus, the value o f jbn, in Eq. (3.5.13) can be regarded constant
and the DF field is therefore maximal when
P ( 2\ i , v, z ) ^ X^ \ A 0( r )\2 I ( i - z / u ) , (3.5.17)
where |A0( r ) | 2 specifies the transverse intensity distribution; 1 (f) describes the
pulse shape; u is the group velocity. T h e electric field strength produced by the
pulse satisfies the equation
3.5. Difference-frequency generation and IR Cherenkov radiation 163
As before, we shall use the Fourier transformation to solve Eq. (3.5.18). Then
the frequency-angular spectrum o f the DF field at the output of a nonlinear
medium can be written as
,3 + °°
E d{(t, 90> z) = C - , J I(r)
— OO
/ Z \ 2 / u \ 2 2
x «p (-j cot »„ dr, (3.5.20)
(3.5.21)
It follows from Eq. (3.5.21) that the finite radius o f the exciting beam leads to
an increase in rp . The more detailed presentation o f the theory o f Cherenkov
radiation can be found in Refs. 31 and 33.
The Cherenkov radiation o f a femtosecond laser pulse has been experimentally
investigated by Auston et al. 32 A dye laser was used to generate the exciting
pulses 100 fs long at the wavelength 625 nm with energy 100 pJ and repetition
rate 150 MHz. The laser radiation was split into two pulses, the exciting and
probing ones, and directed on an isotropic lithium tantalate crystal. A Cherenkov
pulse generated in the crystal propagated at an angle 0O = 69 and via the
electro-optical effect induced the birefringence which was measured by means o f
a probing pulse (see Fig. 3.12).
164 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
FIG . 3.11. Shape o f Cherenkov pulse for different ( a / « ) sin &0 : ( 1) 1.6 ps,
(2) 16 ps, (5) exciting Gaussian pulse w ith duration tq = 5 ps. 31
FIG . 3.12. Schematic o f the experim ent used to generate and detect short bursts
o f IR Cherenkov radiation from ultrasliort optical pulses. 32
F IG . 3.13. Experim entally observed (solid line) and theoretical (d otted line)
32
forms o f the Cherenkov pulse.
tion was paid to the technique based on high-speed photoconductors. 111 116 In
Ref. 117 the m ethod o f generation o f femtosecond electromagnetic pulses from
semiconductor surfaces was investigated. The authors o f Ref. 118 have shown
the possibility o f the generation o f FIR radiation with gigawatt peak power from
a plasma at the focus o f the high-intensity femtosecond laser pulse as a result
acceleration o f electrons through ponderemotive forces.
x(Q) = X0 + o
(dx/dQ) Q + ■• • (3.6.1)
The second term o f this expansion describes the modulation o f light by molecular
oscillations. In the induced polarization o f molecules the new spectral com po
nents appear, shifted by the frequency o f oscillations o f the nuclei. The molecular
polarization is
p = x ( Q ) E = x 0E + (dx/dQ) 0 QE. (3.6.2)
W hen the shift Q is determined by thermal m otion in the medium, Eq. (3.6.2)
describes the spontaneous Raman scattering.
166 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
acting on the molecular oscillations. If the field contains the components with
frequencies wp and u>s whose difference is close to the natural frequency f2m w
uip —u>s of molecular oscillations, then the acting force brings about the resonance
amplification o f oscillations. The random intramolecular m otion is superposed
by regular stimulated oscillations whose phases for different molecules are de
termined by the phases o f the optical field components; a phase matching o f
molecular oscillations takes place.
Experimentally, SRS reveals itself as an instability of the high-power optical
pump wave in the Raman-active medium. The second component of the optical
field appears due to spontaneous Raman scattering. The SRS is a threshold
effect because the instability occurs when the intensity I ro f the high-power
optical pump wave with frequency wp exceeds the threshold value Ith defined
by the level o f optical losses. In this case the intensity o f a low-frequency (Stokes)
wave with frequency u>s grows according to the law
Is = Ico ™ P ( 9 sI z ) , (3-6.4)
dA i dA i i-n\d2A
^ 7 + ^ - a f - 2^ V = - ^ Q ’ ( 3 -6 ' 5 a )
dAa 1 dA i (si d 2A *
~dT + ^s ~ d f ~ 2 k* ~ d ^ = ~ iJsApQ ' (3 '6,5b)
dQ
+ Q r + i Q ) Q = ~ {1 q A p A *- (3 .6 .5 c )
dt
Here A p and A s are the amplitudes o f the pump and Stokes waves; Q is the
com plex, slowly varying amplitude o f the molecular oscillation wave; T2 is the
relaxation time determining the linewidth o f the spontaneous Raman scattering,
_ ®X t N u p _ dx * N u s _ dx 1 c
7p dQ cn p ’ 7s dQ cns ’ 7« dQ 4wMQm ’ { ' ' '
We shall begin with the analysis o f group delay effects that predominate when
r0 T 2 and the dispersion length Ld exceeds the walk-off length
where g ( 0) = 2JpJqT 2 , have in the fixed field approximation the simple solution
M *' z)
2 2
where
2 ,-1
fl(fi) = ff(o)[i + (n r3) (3.6.10)
In the strongly transient regime o f amplification (z > Lw) Eq. (3.6.9b) reduces
to
The effective walk-off length Leff depends on the pump pulse shape. In the
case o f a Gaussian pulse Leff = - / tFLw. It follows from Eq. (3.6.11) that the
group-velocity mismatch leads to the amplification saturation at the distance
The effects o f finite pulse duration show very vividly in the asymmetry o f the
Stokes forward and backward scattering. In the latter case the effective length
o f the nonlinear interaction o f counterpropagating waves
T+ _
tls +U p
For example, in quaxtz glasses L^. = 0.3 mm, and Z eff ~ 1 m for Ap =
1.06 /i m , r0 = 1 ps and the Stokes frequency shift 440 cm 1 . The asymme
try o f SRS o f copropagating and counterpropagating waves in liquids has been
experimentally studied in Ref. 38. T h e solution o f Eqs. (3.6.8) has been re
ported in Ref. 42 for the strong energy exchange and for both copropagation
and counterpropagation wave interactions. Note that in the interaction o f coun
terpropagating waves the preferential amplification o f the leading edge o f the
Stokes wave can lead to formation o f a "giant” Stokes pulse. This phenomenon
is in many respects analogous to the production o f giant pulses observed in SHG
3.6. Stimulated Raman scattering o f ultrashort pulses 169
« 47
F IG . 3.14. C ontour o f R am an gain line in fused quartz.
FIG . 3.15. Experim ental dependence o f the Stokes frequency shift on the
wavelength o f pu m p radiation. 48
and parametric amplification (see Sec. 3.3). The first experimental observation
o f this effect has been reported in Ref. 37.
The most interesting results concerning the SRS o f ultrashort pulses have been
recently obtained in fiber waveguides. Th e quartz fibers possess broad Raman
lines ( A v = 250 cm 1 , T2 ~ 100 fs, see Fig. 3.14) and consequently allow
the pulses about 100 fs long to be amplified and transformed. In the long fibers
the group delay effects develop to a large extent. The gain saturation over the
distance comparable to the walk-ofF length is only one o f those effects. Since
the gain increment [see Eq. (3.6.11)] is expressed, with allowance made for the
frequency dependence o f the walk-off length, as
then the gain maximum coincides with the center o f the Raman line ws0 only
when the length o f the fiber L < Leff . This effect is observed quite clearly
when a frequency-tunable parametric generator is used as a pump source. As
wp approaches wcr at which the dispersion parameter —s- 0 , the walk-off
length tends to infinity and the gain maximum is realized at the frequency ws0 .
On tuning wp away from wcr the walk-off length diminishes making the gain
maximum shift toward the pump frequency. This situation is quite unusual for
the steady-state SRS.
170 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
(3.6.14)
2i
dz \u s u ) dr, n:o
p
+ 2 /8p l^ p|2] 4 + ^ / sp|Ap|2A s - ^ A s
where r)p — t — z /u p is the time in the coordinate frame connected with the
pump pulse, , <5s are the absorption coefficients, and / „ are the overlapping
integrals o f waveguide modes.
3.6. Stimulated Raman scattering o f ultrashort pulses 171
FIG . 3.16. Stokes-frequency pulse form ation from a continuous seed signal under
conditions o f norm al dispersion o f group velocity. Tim e marks are indicated on the
seed signal profile. T h e signal arriving at the optical fiber input simultaneously
w ith the trailing edge o f the pu m p pulse is seen to undergo the highest gain. The
follow ing parts o f the seed signal propagate through the depleted pum p field while
the preceding parts cross only a part o f the pum p pulse. T he dotted line shows
50
the in itial shape o f the pum p pulse. In the inset, the experim ental dependence
o f the Stokes pulse du ration rg on the optica l fiber length L.
Basic laws o f Raman frequency shift in fiber waveguides were found in nu
merical experiments 52 ’ based on the solution o f the set (3.6.14). Depending
on the spectral region within which a pump pulse and a Stokes component o f
SRS fall, the various generation regimes can be identified. If Ap and As belong
to the region o f normal group-velocity dispersion, the joint action o f self-phase
modulation and dispersion results in spreading o f the pump pulse and lowers
efficiency o f energy exchange. Similar phenomena are observed when the pulses
with the fundamental and Stokes frequencies interact via the nonlinear contri
bution to the refractive index (cross-m odulation). The resulting duration o f the
Stokes pulse exceeds perceptibly the initial duration o f pumping (see Fig. 3.17)
and, besides, the Stokes pulse has strong frequency modulation. In principle, it
can be compressed by means o f a dispersive delay line.
± iz J. Faram elnc interaction and coherent scattering
F IG . 3.17. E volu tion o f ultrashort SRS pulses in optical quartz fiber excited by
picosecond p u m p pulses w ith Gaussian envelope; the spectral region corresponds
to norm al dispersion o f group velocity. Show n are tem poral intensity profiles of
pum p and Stokes pulse (Ap - 1.06 fan , = 1.12 /tm , Ip = 18 M W /c m 2 ,
Tp = 5 p s , k^ = 2.3 X 10 28 s2 /c m ).
In the case when the Stokes com ponent falls within the region of anomalous
group-velocity dispersion, the picture changes radically as the joint action of
dispersion and nonlinearity provides the conditions for self-action o f the Stokes
pulse. The transition of frequency modulation of the pumping to the Stokes
frequency also promotes the pulse compression. In this regime the peak power
o f the Stokes pulse can substantially exceed the power o f the pump pulse (see
Fig. 3.18).
And, finally, at Ap , As > Acr self-action leads to self-compression o f both
the Stokes and pump pulses, with cross-modulation encouraging the process. In
this regime, the prospects for achieving higher transformation efficiencies and for
substantial (by one order o f magnitude) decrease in the Stokes pulse duration
appear (see Fig. 3.19). Choosing the proper parameters o f a pump pulse and of
a fiber, one can realize the regime o f transformation of a multiple-soliton pump
pulse into a high-power one-soliton pulse at the Stokes frequency (see Chap. 5).
These were the illustrations o f the group-velocity matching. A group-velocity
mismatch brings about a shortening o f the Stokes pulse and decrease in the
energy transformation efficiency. A t small values o f the group-velocity mismatch,
a nonlinear capture o f the Stokes pulse by the pump pulse was found in numerical
experiments, which is associated with the “reactive” interaction of the pulses via
• 53
the nonlinear contribution o f to the refractive index. Recently, the effects
caused by cross-modulation have been confirmed by direct experiments both in
the boundless media and in the fibers. 54 56
The Raman frequency shift of ultrashort pulses together with soliton effects
has brought about a whole class o f frequency-tunable femtosecond Raman soliton
lasers to be considered in Chap. 6.
3.6. Stimulated Raman scattering o f ullrashort pulses 173
FIG . 3.18. SRS pulse form ation. T he R am an frequency falls into the region o f
anom alous group-velocity dispersion whereas the pum p frequency into the normal
dispersion region (Ap = 1.25 fj,m , As = 1.32 /jm , I = 2.7 M W / c m 2 , r p =
5 ps, k2P^ = 0.34 X 10 -28 s 2 / c m ) .
Here we consider the SRS of ultrashort pulses in media with narrow Raman lines
when a transient local response becom es significant (r() T2) . The joint action
o f local and wave transience was treated in detail in Ref. 45 in which, in partic
ular, the possibility of formation o f steady-state Stokes pulses and suppression
o f SRS in PM pulses were shown. W e shall restrict our considerations to the
spectroscopically significant case in which the dimensions of a medium are less
than the walk-off length L w . Then in the fixed field approximation, Eqs. (3.6.5)
X(*± j . va ra m etn c interaction and coherent scattering
___________ Signai
FIG . 3.19. E volu tion o f high-intensity Ram an solitons in the spectral region
corresponding to anom alous grou p-velocity dispersion at the frequencies
p1
(Ap = 1.55 lira. , \ = 1.67 /jm , / p = 20 M W /c m 2 , r p = 5 ps, fc(p>
2 -—
i 2i \
10 s /c m ).
9A.
= *'TsJ^po(7?) Q* > (3.6.15a)
(3.6.15b)
IAp|
IA,I
J V _ L
(a ) (b)
FIG . 3.20. D ynam ics o f transient m olecular response arising in the Ram an-
44
active m edium due to propagation o f a rectangular pum p pulse. Shown are
the tem poral distributions |Ap(t)|, |As(t)|, and |Q(t)| : (a) at the input of
the m edium ; ( 6) at the interm ediate point z — L / 2 ; (c) at the output o f the
m edium ; z = L .
these equations is
T)
sO J e x p (- t, z))& , (3.6.16)
exp[2(G 0y / r 2) 1/2]
Js(»7> z ) 1/ 2
(3.6.17)
(g 0 v /t 2)
Figure 3.21 illustrates the most widely used version o f active coherent spec
troscopy, that is, CARS spectroscopy. Tw o pump waves with frequencies ui^
and u>2 (whose difference w1 — w2 fa , the molecular oscillation frequency)
excite coherent molecular oscillations which then are explored by a probing wave.
3.7. Ultrashort optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 177
Figure 3.22 shows how one can get spectroscopic information provided the
excitation and probing are accomplished by means o f cw or quasi-cw frequency-
tunable sources. The higher signal intensity and application o f sources with a
narrow spectral line facilitate to enlarge the information contents o f light scat
tering spectra.
How does the scattering picture and the obtained information change on tran
sition from a quasicontinuous emission to short optical pulses?
Some new physical and technical applications appear in this case. O f greatest
interest is utilization o f extremely short, femtosecond pulses. They help not only
to trace in real time energy and phase relaxations o f optical excitation in gases
and condensed media but also directly measure the actual shape o f molecular
oscillations, i.e., construct a sampling optical oscilloscope to register the shape
o f elementary excitations in a medium.
E = E1+ E 2
A x = c o n s t, A 2 = c o n s t, A pr — co n st, (3.7.3)
the excitation and probing processes are o f continuous nature and the spectro
scopic information is acquired by tuning the frequency difference w1 —u>2 o f the
pump waves. This technique is called a steady-state coherent light scattering
spectroscopy, or frequency-domain spectroscopy (see Fig. 3.22).
Obviously, an alternative version, a Fourier-conjugate, or transient (time-
domain) spectroscopy is possible. If both excitation and probing are carried out
by short optical pulses, then in the limiting case
i
4/»
iig[wjtii/wa(o)]
a
j y
k
Ja
OO
where
E — E y -f E 2 + E pr -f c. c. (3.7.6)
Using Eq. (3.7.5) and the expressions for the fields, one can easily write the
general formulas for the intensity o f signals o f steady-state and transient coherent
anti-Stokes Raman scattering:
/ K ) ~ |p(3) K ) | 2.
where
OO
x (3 )K ; w pr - W1 . w 2) = \ I I J X (3 )(<1 - h > h )
0
X e x p [i(wpr^1 + — W2^3)] ^ 1 ^ 2 ^ 3 (3 -7 .8 )
One comes across the time-dependent transient spectra in the transient spec
troscopy while investigating nonequilibrium states. The data obtained by the
C ARS spectrochronography are not difficult to interpret if the time o f spectral
measurement
(3.7.10)
% ~ Q .5 5 p .m
Pulsed C__ I
P h otod etectoi
Photomultiplier —
Experiments o f this kind make it possible to trace in real time the physics
o f laser-induced phase transitions in solids. The spectra o f an optical phonon
59
in crystalline silicon were registered by CARS spectrochronography with the
3.7. Ulirashort optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 181
Figure 3.25 shows the spectra o f the optical phonon mode F 2 for vari
ous energy densities o f exciting radiation from w — (0.30 ± 0.05)ui0 to w rj
wQ (w Q — 0.2 J /c m 2 is the energy density o f radiation at A = 560 nm caus
ing the melting). At room temperature in the absence o f excitation the optical
phonon spectrum consists o f a relatively narrow ( A v « 3.5 cm 1 ) intense line
located at the frequency v = 520 cm . As the excitation intensity grows, a
substantial broadening and distortion o f the line takes place, accompanied with
a fall in its intensity as against the nonresonant (electron) background. These
changes are caused by the inhomogeneous broadening o f the phonon line due
to substantial increase in the phonon temperature and generation of a dense
3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
F IG . 3.26. Dynam ics o f free carrier concentration and tem perature in optically
excited silicon.
The center o f the Raman scattering (RS) line shifts due to temperature and
mechanical stress in the opposite directions: as the static experiments show,
squeezing stresses produce a shift o f the phonon line toward higher frequencies
with a rate o f 0.47 cm 1/k bar , whereas the lattice heating leads to “softening”
o f the phonon mode and broadening o f the RS line toward lower frequencies. The
presence o f the quite considerable gradients o f temperature and mechanical stress
typical for the picosecond excitation brings about an inhomogeneous spectral
broadening.
As the calculations show, the highest temperature o f 1240 K is reached at
21 —3
w = 0.7 wQ , with the maximum carrier concentration 3.5 x 10 cm and
pressure 40 kbar. The experiment thus shows that a substantial warm-up o f the
optical phonon mode in the center o f the Brillouin zone is accomplished during a
time interval o f about 10 ps. The high rate o f energy thermalization within the
optical part o f the phonon subsystem is also corroborated by the well-known fact
that the energy o f photoexcited electrons in silicon is transferred predominantly
to the short-wave parts o f the phonon branches.
A decrease in the duration o f the exciting and probing pulses and transition
to the femtosecond time scale allow the C ARS spectrochronography technique to
be extended to the studies o f an electron-phonon relaxation under the conditions
o f strong optical excitation o f a semiconductor. The first results in this field have
been so far obtained by spectrochronography o f spontaneous RS in the unique
3.7, Ultrashort optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 183
(3.7.11)
under which the pulse response carries the most comprehensive information
about the studied relaxation processes. If, conversely,
rp > rr , (3.7.12)
the shape and duration o f the registered signal are practically independent o f
the properties o f the medium and are apparently defined by the laser pulse
parameters.
46
The theory o f transient CARS spectroscopy is in fact based on the SRS
equations derived in the previous section. Assuming the shape o f exciting laser
pulses used for biharmonic pumping (3.7.1) to be A x = A ^ t , z ) , A2 =
A 2( t , z) and using Eqs. (3.6.5), we can find the envelope Q ( t ) o f molecular
oscillations. The com plex amplitude o f the anti-Stokes wave appearing in the
probing process satisfies the equation
1 7 + iT
a
lT = ^ (\ ‘ - 7 p-r - /
' <3 J 1 3 >
-f-C O
\Q(t)\2A 2T(
p t - t d)dt.
— OO
If the probing is carried out using the pulses shorter than the relaxation time
^ pr(f ) = ^ Pro^(f ) ’ the C A RS signal
184 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
2 ( A w -2 , i 2 + Auint \
\Q{t)\ <x e x p ( ------(3.7.14)
V 1 + Awir)hTQ )
It follows from the last expression that the character o f the free polarization decay
in the oscillator ensemble depends on the relation between Au>0 , Awinh > ’ ’J' 1 •
If Awinh= 0 , the inhomogeneous broadening is absent, the free oscillation
frequencies are equal for all oscillators, and the polarization decays according to
the exponential law
\Q(t)f oc e x p ( - 2 f /T a) , T2 = 2 /A w 0 , (3.7.15)
|Q(i) |2 oc e x p [ - ( * /r * ) 2] (3.7.16)
T* = r f + A 0 1/2. (3.7.17)
T w o alternatives are possible here. W hen the exciting pulse isshort (r0 -C
AwinJi) , the relaxation time is determined by the spectral width o f the studied
inhomogeneously broadened band
T* — A
*
w.inn
- i
,.
If the pulse is long enough (rQ Aw^)
, the relaxation proceeds during the
time interval comparable with theduration of the exciting pulse
r* = tq . (3.7.18)
In the latter case the pulse response repeats the form o f the exciting pulse and
carries no spectroscopic information about the investigated medium.* Neglect
o f this fact leads to the wrong interpretation o f some experiments performed
*This conclusion is valid for the usual conditions o f C A R S spectroscopy when the ampli
tudes o f exciting laser pulses rem ain practically constant in the process o f interaction w ith the
m edium . It however does not h old under conditions of strong energy exchange. In R ef. 66
it is shown that when the energy o f high-frequency pu m p pulse is depleted, the transient
C A R S spectroscopy allows the hom ogeneous relaxation time to be m easured even in the case
o f substantial inhom ogeneous broadening o f the investigated resonance.
3.7. UUrashort optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 185
*Naturally, when registering a tem poral evolution o f a noncoherent anti-Stokes signal in
dependent o f phase relations, one can measure the longitudinal relaxation time T j , i.e., the
energy relaxation time (for m ore details see Ref. 46).
3.7. Ultrashort optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 187
allows one for the first time to register the evolution o f the molecular oscillation
coordinate itself. The direct oscillography of molecular oscillations becomes thus
possible, as well as the probing o f the amplitude and the phase o f molecular
oscillations.
The physics o f interaction o f such short pulses with the medium is character
ized by a number o f distinctions. If the condition (3.7.19) is met, the spectral
width o f an exciting laser pulse exceeds, obviously, the Stokes shift:
Under these conditions the biharmonic pumping is not needed any more. One
femtosecond pulse is sufficient for excitation o f Raman resonance since the spec
tral com ponent o f the field (the Stokes com ponent) shifted by the value o f the
frequency o f molecular oscillations is contained already in the pump pulse itself.
In this case the C A RS processes can be regarded as apeculiar Raman self-action;
due to theexcitation o f molecular oscillations, the energyredistribution takes
place in the spectrum o f the ultrashort optical pulse (the shift toward the Stokes
side) that excites the Raman-active medium (see Fig. 3.29).
Femtosecond pulses offer the way to control the amplitude and phase o f m olec
ular oscillations. For example, if two femtosecond pulses separated by a time
delay tfd act on an oscillator ensemble, the second pulse can, depending on the
value o f tfd , amplify or attenuate the molecular oscillations as well as change
their phase. In particular, when the delay is equal to half o f the period of molec
ular oscillations, the second pulse suppresses them completely. Application o f
trains o f femtosecond optical pulses offers interesting possibilities for control o f
molecular oscillations. For example, a frequency-selective buildup o f molecular
oscillations or excitation o f “rectified” oscillations become possible.
De Silvestri and co-workers 67 realized experimentally the femtosecond C A RS
spectroscopy under the conditions (3.7.20). The coherent Raman scattering was
observed with the two phonon modes o f perilene (the mode frequencies are 80
and 104 c m - 1 ) with the exciting pulses 70 fs long. The schematic layout o f the
experiment is shown in Fig. 3.30. The crossing o f the exciting pulses with wave
188 3. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
Scattered
pulse
Exciting
pulses
vector difference K induces the coherent optical phonons that form a standing
wave with wave vector K . After a delay ,td , a probing femtosecond pulse is
sent which is diffracted by the lattice oscillations induced by the exciting pulses.
The energy o f the scattered (diffracted) pulse is measured as a function o f .
This function conveys directly the form of molecular oscillations.
• • 67
F IG . 3.31. Experim ental data o f transient C A R S spectroscopy o f perilene crystal.
Beats o f sum and difference frequencies o f Ram an-active m odes are clearly seen.
3.7. UUrashori optical pulses in scattering spectroscopy 189
The experimental results reported in Ref. 67 are shown in Fig. 3.31. The
pulse response is made up o f the beats in which both the difference and the sum
o f frequencies o f molecular oscillations are represented.
119
The similar method was applied to study low-frequency molecular oscilla
tions in some liquids. In particular, the pulsed response from a CH2B r2 molecule
was measured. The response can be, in fact, regarded as an oscillogram o f molec
ular oscillations with a period o f 197 fs and frequency o f 173 cm - 1 . In the same
experiment, the pulsed response o f liquid carbon bisulphide CS2 was observed,
caused by rotation o f anisotropic molecules in the field o f a polarized femtosecond
optical pulse. It is interesting to note that the response keeps growing for some
time after the termination o f the exciting pulse. This effect is obviously due to
inertia o f orientational m otion o f molecules in a liquid. The detailed discussion
o f possible applications o f the SRS and C A R S techniques for femtosecond optical
pulses can be found in Ref. 68.
If, for example, a coherent optical pulse with duration rp = 30 ps has a spectral
width A i/p = 1/ CT'p = 1 cm - 1 , then a 60-fs pulse has Ai^p = 500 cm 1 and a
6-fe pulse Ai'p = 5000 cm - 1 . These evaluations show that picosecond pulses are
capable o f exciting selectively certain well-defined oscillations in a molecule, that
is, the oscillations o f an atom or group o f atoms. On the other hand, femtosecond
pulses possessing a very wide frequency spectrum provide a nonselective excita
tion o f molecular oscillations in a wide spectral range. In this case the pulsed
response combines several modes, i.e., it is indicative o f dynamic properties of
the com plex molecular system as a whole, but not an individual oscillational
subsystem o f the molecule.
The beat frequencies can be accurately found by computer simulation, i.e.,
the “difference” spectrum o f molecular oscillations can be reconstructed. In
the experiments reported in Ref. 120, where 80-fs laser pulses were used, the
pulsed response o f a mixture o f pyridine and cyclohexane was measured. The
data obtained allowed the authors to derive the difference spectrum o f molecular
oscillations in the broad spectral region exceeding 300 cm
Probe Poiariton
direction direction
F IG . 3.32. Layout o f G ARS spectroscopy o f polaritons resolved in time and
space ( td , time delay; , probing beam displacem ent).
^ Vv ib r 2^ Vv ib r _ ^ ^ /■<> o i\
d t2 a “ p0 d td z ’
FIG . 3.34. Generation o f ultrashort acou stic pulses: on the left, optical pulse falls
on crystal surface and is absorbed in the layer whose thickness I b ~ S ; on the
right, the tem poral profile o f oscillation velocity o f acoustical pulse propagating
within the crystal. T h e acoustic pulse polarity is determ ined by the deform ation
potential eipot (the case o f dpot < 0 is show n).
tent slowed down due to a strong scattering by thermal vibrations o f the lattice.
Accordingly, for thermoelastic generation o f ultrashort deformation pulses, it is
necessary to decrease the duration o f laser irradiation simultaneously with the
optical absorption length. Finally, it should be borne in mind that the time o f
lattice heating can be determined not by the time o f optical irradiation, but by
the time o f energy transfer from electrons to phonons, which also hinders the
shortening o f deformation pulses.
FIG . 3.35. Change in optical transm ittance o f a thin film o f a-A s 2 Te , caused
b y m ultiple reflections wit hit; the film o f a p h otoexcited acoustic pulse; the film
thickness values are indicated for each curve. 77
kU
amplification for processing the reflected signals allow the reception sensitivity
to be substantially increased. In the case o f vr — 250 MHz and modulation
frequency 10 MHz the relative changes o f reflectivity of about 10 6 were reliably
gg ( _-r
registered; the highest possible sensitivity was estimated to be 10 . The
signal profiles reported in Ref. 83 have typical durations about 10 ps.
Recently the methods o f thermal modulation reflection spectroscopy devel-
84
oped in Refs. 80 and 83 were transferred from the picosecond into the fem
tosecond region o f temporal resolution ( r ~ 65 fs). 85 In the nearest future, one
can expect the experiments in which ultrashort acoustic pulses will be registered
using femtosecond optical pulses. As to the generation o f sound, the application
o f femtosecond lasers in the considered experimental systems does not seem ad
vantageous so far, since the actual duration o f excited acoustic pulses depends
on the depth o f the radiation penetration into a crystal, or the thickness o f an
absorbing film, or the surface quality. Even for iabs ~ 5 nm and ca ~ 5000 m /s,
the characteristic acoustic time ra ta fabs/ c a ~ 1 ps substantially exceeds the
times of femtosecond phenomena. Still, femtosecond lasers can be used in other
systems for generation o f giga- and terahertz acoustic waves. For example, owing
to an introduction of modulation instability in the radiation propagating along
an optical fiber, a train o f sub-picosecond optical pulses ( r = 0.5 ps) with a
tunable repetition rate o f vr = 0.3 THz has been obtained. 86 Obviously, the
similar trains o f laser pulses can be used for generation o f quasiharmonic acous
tic pulses with frequency ss vr in complete analogy with the experiment
described in Ref. 87 in which picosecond lasers ( r = 10 ps, ur = 0.02 GHz)
were used for the first time for generation o f sound over 20 years ago.
3.8. Ultrashort acoustic pulses 197
d \ ib r _ 2 d \ ib r = dp d ‘ n
(3-8.3)
d t2 a dx2 P0 d t d
9jle _ p0\ % , 6( 1 ~ R o) , - ^ r ( f / r } fo cA
o ' “ 1 7 “ ^ + — ( / -} ' ( 3 'M
2
associated with the carrier diffusion. Note that at rrec <C D fc^ , the time t d &
\/DTrcc/c&, i.e., t d has the meaning o f the time taken by the sound to travel
the distance through which the carriers diffuse before recombination. As the
acoustic pulse reverses its polarity over the time approximately equal to r (see
Fig. 3.34), the generation o f dilatation pulses with duration ra ~ r requires
that rJd ~ rp , i.e., ra , TD(rrec) < rp . For optical pulses with duration rp ~
100 ps such a situation can be realized, for example, in silicon by using the optical
radiation with a wavelength o f 0.53 //m . Indeed, assuming ca ~ 106 c m /s ,
D < 100 cm 2 /s , 6 > 104 cm 1 , we get ra < 100 ps, f D (r,ec) < 100 ps. In the
general case for the crystal deformation the following approximate evaluations
are valid : the acoustic Mach number M a ~ dpotne/(pQc^) , p a ~ dpotne ■ For
silicon (cfpot « 8-1 eV ) they lead to
experiments 101 ’ 102 showing that the plasma undergoes a supersonic hydrody
namic expansion with the drift velocities vd reaching 10?- 1 0 8 cm /s. At the
same time, there are other experiments, e.g., Ref. 103, in which the plasma could
not be accelerated above the velocity o f a slow transverse acoustic mode. The
final answer could be obtained from acousto-optical experiments. For example,
if under the assumptions made in the foregoing calculation, the drift expansion
o f plasma takes place within the time rd ~ rp , the acoustic signal will reach
a detector earlier by the time interval A t = vdTp/c& ~ 1-10 ns than in the
absence o f the supersonic motion o f plasma. If the plasma does not break the
sonic barrier, its motion does not broaden the acoustic pulses under any condi
tions. In this case, by decreasing the penetration depth o f the optical radiation
to /abs ~ 10 6 cm and the duration o f optical excitation to rp ~ 1 ps, we can
reduce the duration of dilatation pulses down to ra ~ fabs/ c a ~ 1 ps.
A ccording to the experimantal results reported in Ref. 104 the concentra-
22 _3
tion ne > 2 x 10 cm was achieved for A = 0.31 //m at rp = 100 fs,
I tp as 10 m J//cm 2 . Our evaluations show that in this case one can obtain M a ~
0.1, pa ~ 300 k b a r, >?conv~ 0 .0 3 , /a ~ 0 . 0 1 / / m , pa/ / a ~ 3 x 105 M b a r/cm ,
ldisc ~ / . Thus, propagation o f such pulses can be studied only at low temper
atures because /disc ~ /a . A decrease in n& by one order o f magnitude and,
consequently, in pa and M a would make the length of discontinuity formation
equal to /disc ~ 0.1 //m and the nonlinear acoustic processes observable in thin
films at the room temperature.
The duration of the trailing edge o f the compression pulse is equal, according
to Ref. 95, at rdisc > r*r to rtr ~ r(* = m a x {r p , rD , r j . If the carrier
recombination time rrec < rtr , then rtr ~ max { r rec, rp} . Thus, if rrec is less
than the time ra taken by the sound to travel the photoexcited region and the
time t d associated with the motion o f carriers, the compression pulse decay
time and, consequently, the compression pulse duration are independent o f the
absorption depth and diffusion processes. This is because the compression pulse
is a result o f superposition o f two acoustic pulses, one o f which is generated
during the photogeneration o f plasma and the other during its recombination.
The durations o f either signal depend on Ta and t d . They have the opposite
polarities and are delayed by the time equal approximately to the sum rp + r.ec .
That is why at rrec < rn , t d the compression pulse duration in the resulting
wave turns out to be independent o f ra and t d . Therefore, there are no obsta
cles caused by fast plasma expansion for generation o f picosecond compression
pulses. In accordance with the ideas developed in Refs. 94-96, if at low optical
intensities r.ec ra r and the compression pulse decay time rtr ~ ra ,
then the conditions rrec < rp < Ta can be realized, as the light intensity and,
consequently, plasma concentration ne grow, and the acoustic pulses with dura
tion ra ~ rp can be excited. Such an approach has been experimentally realized
in the nanosecond ran ge.94, 96 An increase in the optical energy density (Si,
A = 1.06 / / m ) from 0.1 to 1 J /c m was accompanied with shortening o f the
compression pulse from ra ~ r a « 100 ns (6 « 0.1 c m ' ) to ra ~ rp « 20 ns.
202 S. Parametric interaction and coherent scattering
Let us evaluate the parameters o f this effect in the case o f gallium arsenide
subjected to the pulsed radiation with wavelength A = 0.53 //m and rp = 30 ps.
Then 6 « 7 x 104 cm 1 , ca « 5 x 103 m /s , D ~ 200 cm 2/ s and therefore ra «
30 ps and at rrec > rp the time rD > V D r/ r.a ks 150 ps. If there were no super
position o f the signals, induced by photogeneration and carrier recombination,
then the compression pulse duration would obey the condition ra ~ t d « 150 ps.
Actually, when we satisfy the condition rrec ~ rp , we obtain ra ~ rp ; this hap
pens provided the carrier concentration nQ ~ w 2 x 102° cm - 3 ( 7 «
7 x 10 31 cm6/s in G aA s). In the considered case ( t d ra) , the concentra
tion o f carriers does not grow because o f their diffusion deeper into the crys
tal. Hence, the required excitation intensity is estimated from the relation
n 0 ~ (1 — R 0)lTp/ ( y j D r phv to be equal to J ~ 300 M W /c m 2 ; we also obtain
P rodu ction o f extrem ely short pulses is a result o f realization o f a simple and obvious
com pression principle, the tem poral focusin g o f optical radiation. T h e key features o f the
tem poral focusing, in analogy w ith the spatial focusing o f wave beam s, are the fast phase
(frequency) m odulation and com pression o f the m odulated pulse in a dispersive m edium .
O bviously, if we want to produce pulses whose duration is com parable with a period o f optical
oscillations, the range o f frequency sweep m ust be com parable with the carrier frequency.
A t present, the m ost convenient m eth od o f creating the required fast m odulation is a
self-phase m odulation in a m edium with fast electron nonlinearity. A n ideal com pression
system , similarly to an aberration-free focusin g o f a wave beam , perform s a linear-in-tim e
F M and accurate phase-m atching o f the com ponents o f a broadened spectrum at the focal
poin t. A practical realization o f the con ditions for ideal com pression presents a fairly difficult
problem . T h e elim ination o f aberrations appearing in a m odulator and com pressor, increase
in energy efficiency, im provem ent in quality a nd stability o f com pressed pulses, and effective
con trol o f the shape are the problem s now attracting m ost attention.
*A s it has been m entioned in Chap. 1 , a “tem poral lens” can b e constructed on the basis
o f an electro-optical m odulator. W hen the generation o f picosecond or sub-picosecond optical
pulses is undertaken, the m odulator must b e controlled b y picosecond electric pulses. T he
potential o f this technique was lately dem onstrated in Ref. 2. Having accom plished the fast
phase m odulation o f cw argon laser radiation w ith a subsequent convertion o f phase m odulation
into am plitude m odulation in a dispersive delay line, the authors o f Ref. 2 obtained the pulses
w ith duration 8 ps and repetition rate 10 G H z. It is too early to claim however that this
technique can successfully com pete w ith the m ethods o f nonlinear-optics com pression.
Z lK i 4 . Uompression and shaping o f optical pulses
anomalous group-velocity dispersion. Cells with metal vapors (in the frequency
3 1
region close to one-photon resonance), devices made o f a pair o f diffraction
gratings,4 and some types o f interferometers 5 were used as such media. Com
pression ratios S ~ 10 (from 20 to 2 ps 6 and from 100 to 7 ps 7 ) were achieved
in experiments. The drawbacks o f compression schemes that use bulk media are
associated with the nonuniformity o f the chirp in the transverse cross section o f
the beam and with close relationship between spatial and temporal self-action
effects, leading to instabilities o f compressed pulse parameters.
Indeed, the compression ratio o f the pulse is proportional to the relative broad
ening o f its spectrum. Resorting to the formula for the relative value o f spectral
broadening (2.3.15)
Aw 1 + ( 0.88kan2^ - L
1/ 2
(4.1.1)
a—
A /,? ^
“'o ‘-’ e f f
and taking into account that the effective self-action in a nonlinear medium takes
place over the longitudinal length of the beam waist region L « 2kQaQ, where
aQ is the beam radius, we conclude that a perceptible spectral broadening can
be obtained only at the power V Q « ir/(2k2h2) which corresponds to critical
power o f self-focusing (2.5.9).
A radical change in the situation has become possible owing to the use of
single-mode optical fibers as nonlinear phase modulators. The small nonlinear
contribution to the index o f refraction in quartz glasses (n 2 « 10~~13 CGSE)
is more than compensated by the possibility o f sustaining a stable transverse
profile o f the light beam with diameter 5-10 //m over the distances o f the order
o f a characteristic absorption length /abs « (in the visible optical range
/abs = 100 — 1000 m ). Comparing /abs with the characteristic length o f focal
waist L « 2k0a,Q , we obtain an increase o f 105- 106 in the nonlinear interaction
length. Using the fibers o f various length, one can get a substantial spectral
broadening not only for high-power pulsed lasers, but also for the sources oper
ating with a high repetition rate and with peak powers o f pulses equal to a few
watts. Due to the wide transparency range of quartz glasses the compression
can be accomplished in the wide wavelength range. Besides, the high breakdown
threshold and stability o f the geometry o f fibers should also be noted.
The magnitude o f the nonlinear contribution to the index o f refraction be
comes comparable in quartz fibers with the core-cladding index difference only
2 2
for intensities I & 1 T W /c m . If one works in the interval 1-1000 M W /c m ,
the self-action model based on the assumption o f constancy o f the radiation
mode structure in a fiber is quite adequate (see Sec. 1.7). From the conservation
o f radiation mode structure one more important advantage follows immediately,
a high degree of homogeneity o f FM in a transverse cross section o f the beam.
Real limitations on the frequency scanning range in a fiber modulator are spec
ified to a large extent by the input pulse parameters. For high-power pulses
o f picosecond duration (V 0 « 1 kW ) the basic limitations are associated with
a com peting SRS process. For pulses with peak power o f a few watts, whose
modulation is carried out in the long fibers (100-1000 m ), optical losses become
4-2. Optical compressors 205
The time taken to travel the optical path A B C is expressed in terms o f the
incidence angle j 0 , diffraction angle #dif , and distance b as
Using the known relationship between the angles of incidence and diffraction
The substitution o f Eq. (4.2.4) into Eq. (4.2.1) yields the expression for the
dispersion parameter
4 . vom pression and shaping o f optical pulses
D = —27tc^2/Aq , (4.2.6)
t (c) _ _ Ap (A J d f
2 <1 2 1
2irc 1 — /\ /J — sin
(AQ/d • 7 0)\2 ' )
For typical values of the parameters j Q = 60° , d — 1 //m , A0 = 0.5 fim, the
coefficient k ^ is of the order 10 26s2/ c m , and the effective dispersion length
for tq 1 ps is L a = r ^ / k ^ m 1 m.
Significantly larger values o f dispersion can be achieved by letting the light
beam fall on a grating at the grazing angle. Such arrangements are used for
compression o f pulses with initial duration about tens o f picoseconds. The char
acteristic features o f such a system are discussed in Ref. 9.
FIG . 4.2. Com pressor w ith anom alous dispersion: (a ) one-pass variant in which
spatial displacement o f spectral com ponents takes place; ( 6) two-pass variant.
Possibilities for controlling the am plitudes and phases of spectral com ponents
using a phase screen are shown.
Note that in the grating pair shown in Fig. 4.2 (a) an undesirable effect devel
ops, which is the spatial shift o f high-frequency and low-frequency components.
The indicated drawback can be overcome by using a mirror that sends the radi
ation back to the grating pair. The spatial shift o f the frequency components is
offset after a double passage o f the beam 10 [see Fig. 4.2 (6) ].
Cells with alkali metal vapors are successfully used as media with anomalous
dispersion at frequencies close to the one-photon resonance. 3 A n acceptable
level o f losses (20%) can be achieved in such cells. Weak points o f these elements
4-2. Optical compressors 207
FIG . 4.3. Prism com pressor realizing anom alous and normal dispersions 11 .
are associated with the need for operating close to fixed wavelengths and some
technological problems o f their fabrication.
For compression o f FM pulses with an initial pulse duration o f tens and hun
dreds o f femtoseconds, prism compressors were developed 11 whose experimental
layout is shown in Fig. 4.3. The prisms are so oriented that an optical beam
falls on the entrance face o f the first prism at the Brewster angle, while all the
remaining prisms are oriented under the angle o f the minimum deflection. It is
demonstrated in R e f 11 that such a prism system is equivalent to a medium
with dispersion constant
F IG . 4.4. Schematics for com pression o f optical pulses using SPM in a fiber
waveguide. Shown are the tem poral profiles o f the correction 5cj(r) to carrier
frequency and o f intensity 1 { t ) , and the pulse spectrum s(w ) at the waveguide
output.
= + t4 '3' 1)
where r = (t — z/u )tq 1 is the “running” time normalized to the initial pulse
duration, the distance £ is expressed in units o f dispersion length L d = /k2 ,
the parameter 6 = SQLd characterizes the absorption over the dispersion length,
and the amplitude xp is normalized to the maximum value.
The nonlinearity is characterized by the ratio R = L J £ spm o f the dispersion
length to the SPM length L spm = (^o” 2^eff) 1 • con*rast to the case o f a plane
wave, £ spm is determined by the effective value o f peak radiation intensity in
the optical fiber
h ft = Io (U 4)/(U 2) , (4.3.2)
2* 00
where (Un) = f dtp f Unr d r , and IQ is the peak intensity value. For practical
° °
calculations it is more convenient to use the expression
^ e ff — n / ^ r r ’
(4.3.3)
4-3. Dispersive self-phase modulation 209
where V 0 is the peak power, Sefc = ( U 2) j(U^) is the effective area o f a mode,
which differs only insignificantly from the geometric area of the optical fiber core.
Note that the self-action efficiency also depends on radiation polarization.
The expression for nonlinearity parameter R given before is valid for an optical
fiber in which the light polarization remains constant. In the case o f circular
polarization n 2 should be substituted for 2n2/3 ; when the polarization varies
randomly the averaged value 5n2/6 can be u sed .15 Some interesting effects o f
polarization self-action were examined both theoretically and experim entally.16
Nevertheless, the optical fibers in which the linear polarization remains constant
seem to be most suitable for pulse compression.
Typical modifications o f an envelope, spectrum, and frequency modulation of
a Gaussian pulse, obtained as a result of numerical solution o f Eq. (4.3.1), are
shown in Fig. 4.5.
FIG . 4.5. E volution o f the profile and spectrum o f an ultrashort pulse in the
case o f self-action in a m edium with norm al dispersion.
iri/ b
JL
-1 t* -1 1 *
6 w t0 SaitB
x
X J
l/h l/i„
In Fig. 4.6 the temporal profiles o f intensity and instantaneous frequency are
compared for two compression regimes, nondispersive and dispersive ones. Pa
rameters V Q and L are chosen so as to provide the same compression ratio in
the both cases, either by increasing V 0 or L . The analysis o f the compressed
pulse structure vividly demonstrates the merits o f the dispersive regime. A l
most 90% o f the energy in the dispersive regimes is contained within a narrow
central peak, whereas in the nondispersive regime the corresponding fraction of
energy does not exceed 68%, which testifies to perceptible aberrations that the
“temporal lens” possesses in this case.
(4.4.1)
The approximate expression for the compression ratio determined from the spec
tral broadening [see Eq. (1.4.26)] takes the form
l . U T 2(k(2c)k0n2IeSL y \ (4.4.3)
The given expressions illustrate the scaling laws o f compression, but do not al
low calculations of such important characteristics as the compressed pulse shape,
its peak power, etc. In particular, it follows from Eq. (4.4.2) that the compres
sion ratio must grow linearly with distance. However, it is clear from the previous
section that the rate o f FM will be limited by dispersive spreading.
212 J,. Compression and shaping o f optical pulses
The case o f larger nonlinearities, R = 104- 1 0 5 , which are typical for com
pression o f pulses with initial duration o f the order o f tens o f picoseconds is
examined in Ref. 20. A specific instability appearing at steep edges o f a pulse
was observed in numerical experiments in the vicinity o f the point z = L opt
4-5. Spectralfiltering, compression o f noise pulses 213
(see Fig. 4.8). The appearance o f this effect is associated with characteristic
properties o f the temporal dependence o f instantaneous frequency (see Fig. 4.5).
Under the conditions o f very weak normal dispersion of group velocity, the low-
frequency components, corresponding to the point o f deflection o f the intensity
profile, overtake the higher-frequency components located at the leading edge.
This results in a frequency mixing and appearance o f a small-scale pattern of in
terference type. The results obtained in Ref. 20 helped to explain some features
in the spectra observed in Ref. 21.
The expression (4.4.4) for the compression ratio has been obtained without
taking into consideration com peting nonlinear processes. In real experimental
situations the compression ratio is limited, as a rule, by the SRS process.
The SRS process starting from the random noise level leads to a pump deple
tion under the conditions that
S je f t L « 16 . ( 4 '4 ' 5 )
where gs is the signal gain coefficient at the Stokes frequency, equal to about
2 X 10- U c m /W in the visible optical range. On substitution of L = 16/(ffs/ eff )
into Eq. (4.4.2) we obtain the following limiting value for S in the nondispersive
approximation:
S < 14kQfi2/gs fa 30. (4.4.6)
where i p Q and % [> are the deterministic and random field components, er is
the parameter characterizing the noise level. The most comprehensive informa
tion on processes taking place in an optical fiber can be obtained in numerical
experiments that make it possible to analyze both a behavior o f individual real
izations and statistical characteristics averaged over the ensemble o f solutions of
Eq. (4.3.1) with the initial data (4.5.1).
W e shall begin with a discussion o f some results o f mathematic modeling o f
self-action o f optical noise bursts
where £ (r ) is the com plex Gaussian random process with a zero average value,
variance equal to 1 and with Gaussian correlation function. Figure 4.9 shows
the temporal dependences o f intensity I ~ |^>|2 and frequency chirp at
different cross sections z/Lnl o f an optical fiber.
FIG . 4.9. Self-action o f a noise pulse in optical waveguide with normal group-
velocity dispersion: (a) tem poral intensity profiles; (f>) carrier frequency cor
rections. 22
A t the initial stage o f propagation SPM plays the main part as z ~ ■^spm <
L n l. W ithin the limits of fluctuation intensity overshoots a positive chirp is
J,.5. Spectral filtering, compression o f noise pulses 215
(*)
U)
FIG . 4.10. Self-action o f a noise pulse: (a) tem poral intensity profiles at
the waveguide outpu t; (S>) carrier frequency corrections; (c) com pressed pulses.
A series o f curves corresponds to various realizations, z — 1.8L nt , R = 300.22
+ oo
^ 0 ( 0 = - * {i>*rxp) + c. c . ,
(4.5.4)
“ 2 0 (C ) = 2 + R ((ipip *)2) ,
“C
+ oo
where the angular brackets denote a time average, ( / ) = f f d r , and the
—oo
overdot denotes differentiation with respect to r . The rms duration averaged
over the ensemble o f realizations o f the initial data (4.5.1),
+ 00
0(C ) = j rpr2\j}* dr , (4.5.5)
— OO
0 ( 0 = M O + ° 2m - (4-5.6)
Substituting Eq. (4.5.1) into Eq. (4.5.4), averagingand equalizing the values o f
the same order o f smallness in terms o f i t , we obtain two equations
- ^ 0 = 2 {< M o ) + ’
\ ^ _ (4.5-7)
— = 2 ( ( ^ * ) ) + 4 R ((r p 0rp*0)(-ip^*)).
“C
It follows from these equations that a low-intensity noise almost does not af
fect the rms duration o f the deterministic com ponent. The reciprocal effect o f
the signal on the noise is more significant: the rate of spreading o f the noise
component grows.
Let us make the initial conditions more specific by assuming
and calculate the right-hand side o f Eq. (4.5.7) at the point £ = 0 . We get the
equations with a constant right-hand side
.2 _
0o = v ^ ( l + R/y/2),
2 (4-5-9)
-j -j O = [1 + 4 (r ~ 2 + R j a/2)] , .
“C
where the correlation time rc is normalized to the initial pulse duration. The
equations adequately describe the initial stage o f evolution (£ <C 1) o f the rms
4-5. Spectralfiltering, compression of noise pulses 217
FIG . 4.11. Ensem ble-averaged com pression ratio as a function o f reduced length
of optical waveguide (solid line). T h e dashed line corresponds to a transform-
lim ited pulse. T he nonlinearity param eter R — 300 . Standard deviations are
indicated. 22
duration o f an average pulse. It follows from Eq. (4.5.9) that 0Q and 9 grow
proportionally to a square o f distance and at R 1 the rate o f spreading o f
the noise component is about four times higher than that o f the deterministic
component.
Now let us discuss statistical characteristics o f compressed pulses using the
22 25
results o f mathematical modeling ’ Figure 4.11 shows the dependence o f the
compression ratio S , averaged over the ensemble o f realizations, on the length
o f the optical fiber expressed in units o f L nl . For comparison, the corresponding
dependence calculated for a transform-limited pulse [<r = 0 in Eq. (4.5.1)] is
shown by a dashed line. It is seen that, as before, the optimal compression is
obtained at the length 2 k , 2L n] o f the optical fiber. The presence o f fluctuations
leads to a decrease o f the average compression ratio with the growth o f <7 . A s
the numerical experiments showed, a decrease o f the correlation time o f noise
also leads to a decrease o f the value o f S .
These results are quite natural as the amplitude and phase fluctuations in
the initial pulse bring about an increase in the rate o f dispersive spreading and
a resulting decrease o f amplitude and, therefore, o f effective nonlinearity. The
analysis carried out in Ref. 25 showed that systems o f optical-fiber compression
operating in the dispersive regime are less sensitive to phase fluctuations than
to amplitude ones.
The special features o f self-action o f partially coherent pulses noticed in nu
merical experiments and, in particular, the fluctuations being “pushed” toward
high- and low-frequency wings o f the spectrum, permit a stabilization o f param
eters o f compressed pulses by spatial filtration o f their spectral components in
a grating compressor. The simplest spectral filtration is achieved by placing an
appropriate mask at the plane o f beam-returning mirror (see Fig. 4.12).
Mathematical modeling shows that an addition o f a frequency filter with the
rectangular transmission function K [ w ) = 1 in the spectral band Aw corre
sponding to the value o f the spectral broadening o f a deterministic pulse, lowers
218 4. Compression and shaping o f optical pulses
where |A'(w)| < 1 for all w . The spectrum o f a pulse which has undergone
SPM assumes the form
A similar problem applied for linear systems was treated in Sec. 1.4.
FIG . 4.13. Pulse shape control by phase-m atching o f spectral com ponents:
(a) spectral pow er density (solid line) a n d phases o f Fourier com ponents (dashed
line) o f a pulse after nondispersive S P M , z/ L &prn = 1 8 ; ( 6) shape o f the com
pressed pulse after an “ideal” (solid line) and a quadratic (dashed line) com pressor,
the pulse com pressed using apodizing filter (dotted line). 29
As was shown in Sec. 4.2, real grating and prism compressors perform phase
matching o f spectral harmonics in a parabolic approximation. The dependences
<p(uj) arising in the process o f SPM are more complicated. As an illustration,
Fig. 4 .1 3 (a ) shows the dependences s(w ) = |A(w)|2 and <p{w) for a Gaussian
pulse that had undergone nondispersive SPM. Figure 4.13(6) shows the shape
o f a compressed pulse for the cases o f ideal and quadratic compressions. It can
be seen that the use o f the ideal compressor gives a significant increase in the
intensity and compression ratio. The addition o f apodizing frequency filter with
the transmission function
where N = 4 -6 , and the proper selection o f the passband Aw improve the con
trast o f the compressed pulse [see Fig. 4 .1 3 (6 )]. This effect is used when the
pulses in the near IR (A ~ 1 fim) with initial duration o f tens o f picoseconds are
compressed. As a rule, compression o f these pulses is performed in the nondis
persive regime.
In practice, an ideal compressor can be realized with the aid o f a usual grat
ing pair and a phase mask placed in the plane o f the “returning” mirror [see
Fig. 4 .1 2 (6 )]. Its function is to remove phase aberrations, i.e., deviations o f
the real dependence ip(u>) from a parabolic dependence. The controlled liquid-
crystal spatial modulators are successfully used at the present time for phase
30
correction o f coherent optical beams and in adaptive interferometers.
Combination o f amplitude and phase methods o f control o f the spectrum
broadened by SPM allows one not only to compress pulses and improve the
structure o f compressed pulses, but also to solve a number o f other shape control
problems. It is reported in Ref. 31 that rectangular transform-limited pulses,
with duration about 6 ps and rise time less than 1 ps, can be produced by means
o f amplitude-phase masks placed in a grating compressor. Such pulses can be
applied in metrology and optical information systems.
Ls«0)
0)
(V
F IG . 4.14. Envelope control using an am plitude mask: (a) tem poral depen
dences o f intensity, frequency and transmission function o f the filter; ( 6) pulse
spectrum after filtration s(w) , tem poral dependence o f intensity after filtration,
I ( t ) , and at the com pressor output / com ( r ) .
Using the amplitude filtration technique, one can easily form a train o f several
pulses from one FM pulse. For illustration, we present here some results o f math
ematical modeling. Figure 4.14 (a) illustrates the profile o f a transform-limited
pulse at the output o f an optical fiber, dependence 6 u i(r), and transmission func
tion o f a frequency filter, having the form o f two separated bands. A practically
single-valued relationship between the moment o f time r and the corresponding
spectral region results in a sequence o f two pulses with almost rectangular shape
forming at the filter output. The pulse repetition interval A r is expressed in
4-7. Compression o f high-power femtosecond pulses 221
The initial equation written with allowance made for nonlinear group-velocity
dispersion, transient character o f nonlinear response, and third-order dispersion,
takes the form
where the small parameter //j = k3/(k2rQ) -C 1 characterizes the relative con
tribution o f third-order dispersion, the parameter fi = T0/(wr0) , appearing in
front o f the term responsible for nonlinear dispersion o f group velocity, is pro
portional to the ratio o f the optical oscillation period TQ ~ 2 fs to the initial
pulse duration.
The dynamics o f establishing a normalized nonlinear contribution 8 n(r , ( )
to the refractive index can be described by the phenomenological equation o f the
relaxation type (2.2.9)
S n = \ r P f - ^ 2~ M \ (4.7.4)
= ~ Y d } + R ~ ^ 2^ J ^ l 2 + - (4.7.5)
FIG . 4.15. Self-action o f fem tosecond pulses: (a ) pulse shape at different dis
tances from the optical waveguide in pu t; ( b ) tem poral dependence o f instanta-
T 35
neous irequency.
Having taken into account all perturbing factors, one can interpret various
features o f femtosecond pulse compression observed in experim ents,39' 40 such
as asymmetric spectra and their superlinear broadening with the growth o f input
power, violation o f FM linearity, saturation o f compression ratio with the increase
o f R . The offset o f quadratic correction to linear FM by means o f a combined
grating-prism compressor allowed the authors o f Ref. 42 to reduce the pulse
duration from 10 to 6 fs.
FIG . 4.17. Experim ental layout for param etric acceleration o f FM pulses:
( i ) phosphate-glass laser with passive m ode-locking, (£) frequency doubler,
( 3) param etric amplifier using a C D A crystal, [ 4 ) single-m ode fiber optical wave
guide, (5) dynam ic interferometer, (5) com pressor. (7) duration meter. 43
than the signal pulse, so that the frequency sweep range at the crystal output
decreased down to 200 c m -1 .
I--------1 5 5 5 cm -1
Investigation o f FM o f signal and idler pulses was carried out by the dynamic
interferometry m ethod. Figure 4.18 illustrates the dynamic interferograms at the
output o f an optical fiber and at the output o f parametric amplifier. The range
o f free dispersion o f the Michelson interferometer amounted to 555 cm _1 . Mea
suring the fringe inclination, one can calculate the rates o f frequency variation o f
a p , a s , and with time. The sign o f fringe inclination is determined by the
sign o f FM . As it can be seen from the figure, the fringes corresponding to the
frequencies ws and wi are inclined to opposite sides, i.e., the phase characteris
tics o f signal and idler waves are conjugate, which immediately follows from the
equations o f parametric amplification, written in the approximation o f a given
pump field (see Sec. 3.3). Parametrically amplified FM pulses were compressed
to 280 fs, with peak powers o f compressed pulses reaching 1 G W .
Broadband parametric amplification allows in many cases an increase in the
energy o f FM pulses by 5 or 6 orders o f magnitude without distortion o f their fre
quency characteristics. Besides, the concurrent generation o f a phase-conjugate
pulse at an idler wavelength allows the FM reversal in the picosecond duration
range. In essence, we deal with a temporal analog o f the wave front reversal.
In particular, FM reversal allows one to use media with normal group-velocity
dispersion as compressors.
The second group o f experiments 45 relates to FM transformation o f pulses
in optical parametric generators with synchronous pumping. The main outcom e
226 4. Compression and shaping o f optical pulses
o f such experiments was the development o f a new technique for FM rate con
trol. It was experimentally shown that the frequency variation rates a s and n i
o f parametric generation pulses may substantially exceed the rate o f frequency
variation a p o f pump pulses, with the coefficient o f transformation o f the values
o f a s and being determined only by dispersion characteristics o f the crystal
(see also Sec. 3.3).
The parametric amplification in the presence o f FM o f pump pulses is equiv
alent to the amplification accompanied with the temporal shift o f the frequency
band. Indeed, when the pump frequency varies with time according to a linear
law
wp = wp o - (V > (4 '8-1)
where the time r is normalized to the pump pulse duration, then the central
frequencies at the maximum o f the amplification lines o f signal and idler waves
vary as
Ws = Ws0 - a sr » Wi = Wi0 - a ir - ( 4 -8 - 2 )
, = ________^ ________ ( 4 8 4)
T h e shorter an optical wave packet, the m ore substantial its envelope distortion due to
the effects o f dispersion and nonlinearity. In the foregoing chapters we considered diverse
examples in w hich these distortions bring about destabilizing effects, such as m odulation
instability, pulse spreading, and filament form ation.
O f special interest is the case when the balance between dispersion and nonlinearity
yields the stable pulses that keep practically invariable shape during their propagation over
the distance exceeding the pulse length / = cr 0 b y the factor 10 6- 107 - Such pulses are
reasonably called optical solitons. T h e first cogent observations o f optical solitons were
carried out in 1980. This becam e possible owing to advanced laser sources o f transform-
lim ited picosecond pulses, tunable in the near IR , find developm ent o f single-m ode fiber
waveguides w ith losses o f a few tenths o f a decibel per kilometer.
T he succeeding experiments perform ed under carefully controlled conditions made it pos
sible to reveal a num ber o f subtle peculiarities in the form ation, propagation, and interaction
o f solitons in the presence o f numerous pertu rbing factors, and designate the prospects for
diverse technical applications. A t present, the soliton effects are clearly shown to b e appli
cable for inform ation transmission in optical fibers, generation and shaping of fem tosecond
pulses, and research o f ultrafast processes.
a ( z ) - k2 1( z 2 + L2
d) ~ 1z. (5.1.1)
Conversely, the SPM process causes the frequency to grow from the leading to
trailing edge,
q 2j
Assuming that both processes counterbalance, i.e., <*+ <*spm = 0 , and the pulses
therefore remain transform-limited, we derive the balance condition
h W s * = N / ro . (5-i-4)
2
in which the equalities ^eff ~ Vo /Seff , and Ld = rQf\k2\ are taken into account.
From Eq. (5.1.4) one can appraise the critical power as
(5.L 5)
A similar result is also obtained from the condition o f cqnstant rms duration of
the pulse (see Sec. 4.5.). Allowing for the sign o f k2 , we can write the equation
for rms duration
where R = Ld/spm and the angular brackets denote the averaging over t . The
first term on theright-hand side o f this equation can be treated as a dispersion
“force” leading to an increase in pulse duration whereas thesecond term as a
nonlinear “force” tending to adjust the dispersive spread.
Assuming a specific shape o f the pulse, for example, %j} = sechr , we calculate
the right-hand side o f Eq. (5.1.6) at £ = 0 and equating it to zero, we obtain
the balance condition:
The expression for critical power obtained from this equation coincides with
Eq. (5.1.5). Substituting into Eq. (5.1.5) the typical values o f the parameters
[A = 1.5 fim , D = 15 p s/(n m •k m ), 5 gff = 100 jjm 2 , rQ = 3 -4 p s , h 2 —
3.2 x 10-16 cm 2/ W ] , we get V cr w 1 W .
5.2. Soliton solutions o f the nonlinear Schrodinger equation 229
In Sec. 2.6 we derived one o f the soliton solutions o f the nonlinear Schrodinger
equation (NSE), q = sech r exp ( —*C/2) • Let us generalize it by using the
directly verified invariance (5.2.1) with respect to the scaling transformations
q {r , £) = x s e ch x r exp ( —i x 2£ /2 ) (5.2.3)
is also a solution o f Eq. (5.2.1); the parameter x defining the amplitude and
duration o f a soliton is frequently referred to as a form factor. Since Eq. (5.2.1)
is invariant with respect to the Galilean transformation
we can conduct further generalization and write Eq. (5.2.3) in the form
It can be easily shown that the solution (5.2.5) used with thearbitrary constant
phase (pQ and the initial coordinate r . of the pulse center,
q = q exp (iipn) , / = r - t. ,
230 5. Optical solitons
also satisfies Eq. (5.2.1). Another significant class o f analytically tractable NSE
solutions is a bound state o f N solitons that corresponds to the initial conditions
q ( r , 0) = g0 sech r , (5.2.6)
It is worth mentioning that |g2| varies periodically with respect to £ , with the
period £0 = 7t/2 (in dimensional variables, zQ = ttL^/2) . For N > 2 the
solution can be found for the arbitrary r , C from the set o f N linear equations
(see Sec. 5.8).
It is essential that for the boundary conditions (5.2.6) and for q0 > 1 a
transform-limited pulse experiences self-compression at the initial propagation
stage. This indicates a possibility o f efficient compression o f transform-limited
pulses. A profile modification o f iV-soliton pulse is illustrated in Fig. 5.1 for
N = 4 . In the case of small amplitude perturbations qQ = iV -f £ for |£| < 1 / 2
the asymptotic behavior o f the pulse is determined by its soliton component with
the relative error 0 [£ / (N + £ ) 2] (see Ref. 7).
Figure 5.2 illustrates a soliton in the process o f its formation from the pulse
5 ( 7-, 0 ) = qQsech t for qQ = 1 + £ , where |£[ < 1 /2 is the perturbation o f the
5.2. Soliton solutions o f the nonlinear Schrodinger equation 231
F IG . 5.2. D ynam ics o f form ation o f one-soliton pulse at different initial am
plitudes q0 . T h e peak am plitude is shown as a fun ction o f reduced distance
C= and its steady-state value is indicated. 7
initial amplitude. The pulse amplitude is seen to approach, after few oscillations,
the constant value >c = 1 + 2£ . At £ < 0 the process starts with broadening o f
the pulse whereas at £ > 0 it starts with self-compression.
The soliton solution sets in very fast whenever the initial pulse envelope differs
strongly from a hyperbolic secant form. Figure 5.3 shows how a super-Gaussian
232 5. Optical solitons
T ; N. = c o n s t, u i ^ i = const. (5.2.10)
i i
Here the first equality expresses the conservation o f the general number o f pho
tons, and the second the conservation o f their total energy or the total momentum
o f the field. A more detailed treatment o f this problem in the spectral domain
can be found in Ref. 9.
Finally, we shall mention still another significant property of the Schrodinger
solitons, that is, their stability with respect to collisions. If at £ —►—oo two
solitons with form factors , >c2 have the velocities V1 and V2 , then after the
collision at £ —►+ o o their parameters , x 2 and V1 , V2 remain invariable;
only the phases <p01 , ipQ2 and coordinates o f the maxima r01 , r02 vary. When
several solitons interact, the collective effects are absent and the total shift of
soliton parameters ipQi, rQ. is an algebraic sum o f pair shifts. 8
To illustrate, Fig. 5.4 shows the results of computer simulation of collision of
the Schrodinger solitons. Figure 5.4 (6) corresponds to the solitons with equal
phase and with the initial condition
(a) (b)
FIG . 5.4. Collision o f Schrodinger solitons: (a) opposite-phase solitons;
( 6) equal-phase solitons.
.dq
(5.2.12)
dC
It has an important particular solution
and referred to as a dark soliton. By analogy with bright solitons, the general
solution can be easily written as
proved integrability o f Eq. (5.2.12) applying the inverse scattering method and
developed procedures to obtain multisoliton solutions.
As in the previous case, the physical picture o f dark soliton formation is
determined by the joint effects of SPM and group-velocity dispersion. Owing to a
nonlinear index o f refracion, the instantaneous frequency increases at the leading
edge and decreases at the trailing edge o f the pulse (5.2.14). Under conditions of
normal group-velocity dispersion, when red-shifted pulses propagate faster than
blue-shifted ones, the dispersive spreading o f the intensity dip is inhibited. In
the next section we shall briefly consider experimental aspects of dark soliton
realization.
i_i_i
-10 0 10ps
5.0 11A 22 .5
20-
10
And finally, a few words on experiments with dark solitons. The experimen
tal realization o f “pure” dark solitons, i.e., a dip against the uniform radation
background (see Sec. 5.2) involves some difficulties primarily due to a com pe
tition o f the stimulat ed Brillouin scattering emerging when the cw radiation
intensity reaches tens o f milliwatts. Nevertheless, a pico- or subpicosecond dip
at the background o f a pulse a few picosecond long provides a good approxima
tion. In this case the Brillouin scattering is depressed because the characteristic
. 5 9
time o f Brillouin response lies in the nanosecond range. In the experiments
an input pulse was 26 ps and a dip 5 ps long. The authors o f Ref. 60 used
longer pulses (100 ps) with a subpicosecond (0.3 ps) dip. To form the inten
sity dip (with a phase changing by 7 r ) , the pulse shaping technique described
in Sec. 4.6 was successfully applied by the authors o f Ref. 61. At present,
the fine effects associated with Raman frequency self-shift of dark solitons are
experimentally studied. Successful experiments with optical solitons yield the
results that quantitatively agree with the theory and thus stimulate experimental
and theoretical studies in new directions. Here is the list o f new research areas:
(i) control over the envelope and spectra o f picosecond pulses, including their
compression down to femtosecond durations; (ii) research o f soliton propagation
over very long distances due to loss compensation; (iii) development o f soliton
lasers; (iv) generation in fiber waveguides o f pulse trains with extremely high
repetition rate; (v) nonlinear-optics filtration. In the following sections we shall
discuss the main results obtained in these areas o f investigation.
& U \J v. upncai soizions
FIG . 5.6. Calculated dependence of optim al fiber waveguide length (in units
) on initial pulse amplitude.
5 = C ( q 0 - 1 ), (5.4.2)
in which C fa 4.6 . The uncertainty o f this relation does not exceed 10% at
2 < qQ < 15 . It should be noted that the fraction o f energy contained in the
5-4■ Self-compression o f high-power picosecond pulses 237
which differs from Eq. (4.7.2) by the sign in front o f the dispersive term; the pa
rameters n , fi1 , fi2 coincide with those introduced in Sec. 4.7. Let us analyze
the contributions o f perturbing terms on the right-hand side o f Eq. (5.5.1).
If optical losses over a distance o f the order o f the dispersion length are small,
then the soliton amplitude »c(C) will decrease, and its duration r(£ ) = >f_1 will
grow:
jf = jf Qexp ( —25C) , r = rQexp (2<5£). (5.5.3)
For example, for losses 0.2 d B /k m the pulse duration will increase by a factor
o f 2.7 over a distance 20 km for an initial pulse duration r0 & 10 p s . Validity
o f Eq. (5.5.3) is determined by the inequality 5 < 1 that expresses, in fact, the
condition for adiabatic transformation o f a soliton to the new amplitude value
jf(C) corresponding to a lower energy. A comprehensive analysis can be found
in Ref. 21.
More complicated is the question concerning the influence o f large optical
losses on the evolution o f single solitons and N solitons. In this case the m od
ification o f the intensity profile can b e studied by the methods o f computer
22 23
simulation. ’ Figure 5.7 shows the £ dependences obtained by the authors
o f Ref. 23 o f the mean square o f the length of an JV-soliton pulse ( N = 2) for
different levels o f losses <5. The spatial period o f pulsations {r2(£)) and modula
tion depth are seen to increase with the growth of 6 . In numerical experiments
a decay o f the bound state o f solitons into two pulses moving in the opposite
directions was also discovered.
o. Uptical solitons
FIG . 5.7. Solitons in an absorbing m edium . D ependence o f the rms pulse dura
tion on the distance C = for different levels of losses: solid lines, N = 2 ;
dotted lines, N = l .23
where the gain <jrg is o f the order o f 10 11 c m /W for the frequency shift v —vs »
440 cm 1 , corresponding to the center o f amplification line. The effective area
S'eff in Eq. (5.5.4) is determined by the overlap integral (Up}(U^)/{Up U^)
and in a single-mode optical fiber differs only slightly from the geometric area
S — Traa o f the core cross section. Note that the pump depletion can be allowed
25
for by a substitution o f the distance z for the effective length
FIG . 5.8. Schematic arrangement for the com pensation o f losses dining soliton
propagation in lon g fiber waveguides using SRS. Inset: the profiles of intensity
correlation functions: ( J) input pulse, (2) output pulse in a waveguide with losses,
(5) output pulse after com pensation o f losses. 24
By including cubic terms in the expansion k(u — wQ) we obtain the summand
3 3 .
(iH1/6)d q/dr in the right-hand side o f Eq. (5.5.1), where [i1 = kz/(rQ\k2\)
characterizes the relative contribution o f the third-order dispersion. In the re
gion o f maximum transparency o f quartz glass (A « 1.5 /xm ) this parameter is
small (/ij » 10 2 for rQ ~ 1 ps; see Sec. 1.3) and the third-order dispersion
effects are estimated using the perturbation theory. The authors o f Ref. 21 have
shown that in this case there appear insignificant distortions o f the envelope
and a group-velocity correction o f the order O(^Xj) . Qualitative results o f per
turbation analysis performed in Ref. 21 are confirmed by results o f numerical
28
experiments, even for ~ 1 . Typical intensity profiles are illustrated in
Fig. 5.9 for different values o f £ (jtj = 1, q(r , 0) = sech t ) .
However, as the radiation wavelength approaches the region o f zero group-
velocity distortion and increase o f nonlinearity parameter, the physical picture o f
self-action changes. An irreversible decay o f the initial pulse into fragments takes
place, and its total duration and additional group delay increases significantly.
The characteristic intensity profiles are given in Fig. 5.10. Note that the third-
order dispersion being a perturbing factor with respect to bound states o f N
solitons leads to a removal o f degeneration in terms o f velocity and to an eventual
decay into single-soliton pulses.
Dispersion o f nonlinearity
Let us consider how the perturbing term affects the steady-state soliton solu
tion. T o do this, we shall pass in Eq. (5.5.6) to real amplitude and phase using
the substitution
Separating the real and imaginary parts, we obtain the set o f equations
/a \ 2
dip Id p I f dcp\ 3 adip
= 0,
p d c + 2 ^ ~ 2 p { d ^ J + p + f x p dr
(5.5.8)
dC d r dr 2 P dr2 9t
( rs t l d 2p 1 f& i p \ 2 3 3 dip
0,
dr)
(5.5.9)
rdp dp dip 1 d ip „ 2 dp
+ 3pp 0.
dr) dr) d-q 2 P d r? ' '"'~r dr.
Since we seek the solution in the form o f a single pulse for which p(r,) —+ 0 at,
H
|^| —* oo , then
= (5.5.11)
Multiplying this equation by dp/dr) , we can easily see that it possesses the
integral o f the form
H(p) = p \ l - p V ) - p 2 (5.5.13)
K l 'l +nM = c-
Since p (r)), dp/dr) —►0 for |^| —*■oo , the constant C x = 0 . Assuming
P{®) = P0 , (dp/dr)T=Q = 0 ,
we shall normalize the potential II (p) by the condition II (p0) = 0. Then the
constant K determining the phase shift £ is expressed as
244 5. Optical solitons
Integrating Eq. (5.5.13) with allowance for the normalizations made, we derive
the expression for the shape o f the steady-state pulse:
A more general case is considered in Ref. 30. Note that Eq. (5.5.6) is integrable
by the inverse scattering method; the detailed analysis is given, for example, in
Ref. 31.
The evolution of JV-soliton pulses is affected by the dispersion o f nonlinearity
far more significantly. The shift o f the central frequency o f the spectrum toward
the Stokes region appearing due to the nonlinear frequency modulation (5.5.15)
and depending on the soliton amplitude leads to a removal o f degeneration in
terms o f velocity and a decay o f bound states. Nontrivial dynamics o f the ini
tial stageo f decay has been tackled by the authors o f Ref. 32 innumerical
experiments, and the comprehensive analysis has been published, for example,
in Ref. 31.
Another interesting feature o f propagation o f femtosecond solitons that was
observed in recent experiments is to be mentioned here. It is connected with the
distance-dependent shift o f the central frequency in the spectrum o f a femtosec-
33
ond soliton toward lower frequencies. The effect is associated with Raman
interaction of various spectral components o f the pulse. If the low-frequency
wing o f the soliton spectrum falls into the Raman gain band, the energy o f high-
frequency spectral region converts into the low-frequency region. So, for the
initial pulse duration t^ 2 — 120 fs (A = 1.5 /im ), the shift o f the maximum in
the soliton spectrum amounts to 20 THz at the output o f the fiber waveguide
52 m long. The magnitude o f the effect is shown to be strongly dependent on the
pulse duration; the frequency shift is proportional to . The physical pic
ture o f SRS self-transformation and the corresponding methods o f mathematical
description were discussed in detail in Sec. 3.6.
Interaction o f solitons
trajectories o f m otion o f intensity m axim a are shown for the initial conditions
(5.5.16). 36 T w o solitons w hose m axim a initially are separated in the time dom ain
com e closer, merge, propagate as a single wave packet, and then separate once
again. T h e variable param eter is the tem poral interval 2Tc between the original
pulses.
An effective approach that allows one to select a soliton com ponent for an
arbitrary sequence o f N pulses and to study its evolution with distance is de
veloped in Ref. 36. As an illustration, Fig. 5.11 shows the motion trajectories
for the m axim a o f the function |(/(r)|2 for the case A <p = 0 for different T .
The collision length £ u depends significantly on the temporal separation of
the original solitons. For the partial case A <p — 0 , = >c2 = >c,
— 2
In the limit T —* oo , the value £ (1 ^ (?r/4)>f exp >cTc , which agrees with
the asym ptotic result o f Ref. 35.
Direct experimental observations o f the interaction o f optical solitons have
been carried out by the authors o f Ref. 56. The soliton laser pulses with ini
tial duration 1 ps (A = 1.5 ^ m ) were sent to the Michelson interferometer at
whose output a pair o f pulses was formed with the controlled time delay and
phase difference. It was observed that the solitons having equal phases superim
posed after traveling a distance o f 340 m (corresponding to about 15 dispersion
lengths) along an optical fiber. The solitons with opposite phases repelled, as the
theory predicted. Some departures from the theory based on the nondegener
ate Schrodinger equation were, however, observed for the time delays comparable
with the duration of pulses. According to the authors o f Ref. 56, these departures
246 5. Optical solitons
2L = (*/2)T2
0 \k2\ - \ V2 = 4\k2\Sea/ ( r X ^ ) - (5-6.2)
F IG . 5.13. Soliton laser perform ance. 37 T he critical pow er o f form ation o f one-
soliton ( P t ) and tw o-soliton (V 2 ) pulses, as well as the length o f the forming
fiber, are shown as a function o f the reciprocal duration o f the generated pulse.
The stable operation poin t r 2 is indicated.
Following Ref. 37, we shall draw the quantities 2L and V., as functions o f
the reciprocal o f pulse duration t ~j 2 (it should be reminded that txj2 — 1.76rQ) .
5. Optical solitons
Figure 5.13 also shows the dependence o f the peak power value V o f the pulse
in a fiber:
V p - 0 . 5 n (V )T r/ro. (5.6.3)
where r] is the coupling coefficient, (V) is the time-averaged power in the second
resonator, and Tr is the repetition period o f the pulses with duration t q . The
slope o f the straight line in Fig. 5.13 varies with the change o f rj. The laser
operation is stable at the point r2 where all three conditions (5.6.2) and (5.6.3)
are simultaneously satisfied. If, owing to some random influences, the pulse
duration grows, the optimum point r2 shifts to the left along the straight line
(5.6.3), and the inequalities V p > ' P 2 , ( v / i ) L (i > 2L becom e valid. This results
in the shortening o f duration at the waveguide output.
To make synchronous operation o f a soliton laser stable, a very accurate
matching (to 1 /jm ) of the lengths o f the main and auxiliary resonators is
required. An automated system for stabilization o f soliton laser operation is
reported in Ref. 38, allowing the minimal pulse duration to be reduced to 100 fs.
Note that other operation points determined by the condition V N = N 2rPCT,
where 7V = 1 , 2 , 3 , . . . , may in principle exist. Obviously, the point V 1 = V
corresponding to the propagation o f a single-mode pulse in a fiber waveguide,
possesses the lowest energy threshold. However, there has been no confirmation
o f experimental realization o f such regimes so far.
Although the soliton laser theory underwent rapid developm ent39-41 recently,
all presently existing simplified models, so far, have not reached the level assuring
quantitative agreement with performance o f real devices.
/ T l \
’• 71 72
The most recent investigations ’ demonstrated convincingly that the pres
ence o f an additional resonator containing a fiber waveguide results in a sub
stantial compression o f the output pulse in the spectral region of normal group-
velocity dispersion as well.
The theory o f this effect is based on the concept of additive-pulse mode
73
locking. Here is a simplified picture o f the pulse compression. The pulse
experiences a self-phase modulation in the passive nonlinear optical resonator.
Getting back into the active resonator, it interferes with the primary pulse. If
5.6. Soliton Lasers 249
the phase difference between the peaks o f the primary and auxilliary pulses is
a multiple o f 2 ir, the constructive interference leads to formation o f a “spike
on pedestal” structure which in its turn brings about shortening o f the pulse
circulating in the active resonator.
In the experiments described in Ref. 74 it was found that in an active
Ti : A120 3 element the generation may develop from the spontaneous noise level
without synchronous pumping o f the active element. The authors o f Ref. 75
analyzed the self-starting conditions for generation and established that the pro
cesses o f dynamic saturation o f amplification play a decisive role.
The soliton effects in combination with Raman frequency conversion consti
tute the basis o f Raman soliton lasers. The simplest scheme o f such a laser is
42
presented in Fig. 5.14. A color-center laser emits a train o f pulses (A =
1.47 /im , Tjy2 = 10 ps) that are coupled into a synchronous resonator contain
ing a single-mode fiber waveguide 500 m long. The zero-dispersion wavelength
of the optical fiber is shifted toward Acr = 1.536 /im by special choice o f the
refractive index profile. Thus, the center o f the Raman gain line As = 1.588 fim
falls into the region o f anomalous group-velocity dispersion.
As soon as the peak power pumped into the fiber reaches 6 W , the 240-
fs soliton pulses with peak power o f tens o f watts are formed at the Stokes
frequency at the laser output. The process o f effective energy transfer between
the pump radiation and the Stokes pulse discontinues at a distance o f 100 m from
the fiber input end. The rest of the fiber serves as a nonlinear filter improving
the temporal structure o f the radiation (see Sec. 5.9).
Delay 1\ming
line elem ent
FIG . 5.15. Schem atic o f a fiber laser o f soliton type working in the region of
44
norm al group-velocity dispersion.
44
o f the experimental arrangement is shown in Fig. 5.15. A quasi-cw radi
ation from a NdrYAG laser (Ap = 1.064 p m , rxj 2 = 80 ps) is coupled into
a synchronous ring resonator comprising a single-mode 100-m fiber waveguide,
grating compressor, interference filter used as a tuning element, and a number
o f birefringent plates ensuring the restoration o f polarization.
A t the output o f the system, 0.8-ps pulses are formed at the Stokes frequency
(Ag = 1.10 fim ). In this system a synchronously pumped fiber waveguide acts as
a lasing medium and a fast phase m odulator, while the presence o f the grating
compressor allows stabilization o f the minimum duration o f the output pulse. In
similar devices, the minimum duration is limited by the Raman-gain bandwidth
and can be in principle reduced down to 100 fs.
i___ i___ u
[b>
1 1 ---- 1
l»)
, — / \ J L rv,
(d)
FIG . 5.16. Developm ent o f m odulational instability starting from the sponta
neous noise level. Shown are the spectra at the waveguide output measured for
different values of input power: (a) below -threshold power; (b) V 0 = 5.5 W ;
48
(<0 W ; (d) W.
FIG . 5.17. C orrelation function o f radiation intensity at the output o f the fiber,
measured experimentally. A tem poral separation o f 2.2 ps between the maxim a
corresponds to self-m odulation period.
The intensity correlation function is given in Fig. 5.17. The 2.2-ps time inter
val between the consecutive maxima corresponds to the self-modulation period.
The experimental values o f the period are in good agreement with the theoretical
predictions. Indeed, the maximum increment o f perturbation growth obeys the
formula [see Eq. (2.8.9)]
9max = V 2 V 5 e f I = i s’ pm t 5 ’ 7 ' 1)
T = * f i \ k 2 |/w (5.7.2)
To produce a pulse train with tunable repetition rate, a regular seed m od
ulation was employed by the authors o f Ref. 49. The experimental arrange
ment is schematically shown in Fig. 5.18. The radiation from a N d:YAG laser
(A - 1.319 /im , t^ 2 = 100 ps) was mixed in a single-mode fiber waveguide
with semiconductor laser radiation o f close frequency in order to produce an ini
tial modulation o f intensity. To raise the threshold o f emergence o f com peting
nonlinear processes, such as SRS and SBS, the beams o f the main and auxil
iary lasers were coupled into the fiber with orthogonal polarizations. The initial
modulation frequency was tuned by varying the frequency o f the semiconductor
laser radiation.
FIG . 5.19. Correlation function o f the intensity at the fiber output, measured
at different detunings o f the primary and auxiliary lasers. 49
= + W|2« - (5 '8 1 )
conditions by assuming that f \q \dr < o o , and take into account that the
— OO
modulus |g°| decreases faster as |r| —►oo than any power function. One has to
find q { r , £) for an arbitrary £ > 0 .
According to the inverse scattering m ethod, instead o f Eq. (5.8.1) we consider
a linear scattering problem, in which the required solution q enters in the form
o f a potential
9 *± (l 0 ^ ± , . /0 q° \
8 f* = iAU + • (,.- I ) * • (5.»-2)
'1 0
$ ± ( A, r ) - * exp (5.8.3)
i A r ' 0-1
when r —►± o o , respectively, since the potential q —►0 when r —►± o o . The
relationship between the functions $ and <I>+ is established by means o f the
scattering matrix T ,
whose coefficients depend only on A £ 1 . From Eqs. (5.8.3) and (5.8.4) one
can derive directly the following expression
which can be regarded as the relation between the amplitudes o f the waves:
(i) the incident one coming from + 0 0 (the first term on the right-hand side),
(ii) the reflected one due to the potential with the coefficient r ( A) = b/a ,
5.8. Analysis o f nonlinear wave fields 255
and (iii) the one transmitted to —oo (the left-hand side). The coefficients a and
■ 12 2
b are related by the normalization condition |a| + |6| = 1 . Besides, a(A) —►1
and 6(A) —►0 when |A| —►oo .
Note that for com plex values o f the spectral parameter A Eq. (5.8.2) can
generally have the solutions that vanish both when r —►+ o o and t —►—oo .
These values {A j.} constitute a discrete spectrum and coincide with the roots
(zeros) o f the coefficient a : a(A k) = 0 , analytically extended to the upper
half-plane Im A > 0 . As shown in Ref. 8, the potential q° is unambiguously
determined by the scattering data including the set o f zeros o f the coefficient a ,
the values bk = b(Kk) , and the reflection coefficient r(A ) = bja , specified on
the real axis A £ l .
It should be pointed out that if g ( £ , r ) satisfies Eq. (5.8.1), then the coef
ficient b(A , C) varies with distance as
N
9s = X X ( r ’ 0 . ( 5-8-8)
fc=l
k
where qs is expressed by Eq. (5.8.7). Th e nonsoliton component o f the solution
o f Eq. (5.8.1) determined by the reflection coefficient J’ ( A ) , A £ M declines for
_1/2
( c o as ( . Note that the collision o f Schrodinger solitons results only in
the shift o f their centers and phases.
An energy relationship between the soliton and nonsoliton parts o f the solution
can be found using a nonlinear generalization o f the Parseval theorem according
to which
+ oo N +oo
The first term on the right-hand side o f this equality corresponds to the energy
o f the soliton part o f the solution (a discrete spectrum) while the second term
corresponds to the nonsoliton part (a continuous spectrum). This theorem allows
256 5. Optical solitons
N
fl.0 -. 0 = - 2 £ c m(C)*m( r ) , (5.8.10)
m = l
( i- k ) x = p, p = (p 1 , p 2 , . . . . Pjv)t r .
Am , n = Am - An> n< N ,
N
° ( a ) = r i ( A ~ AJt)/(A ~ Ai ) , k =(-*■)*•
k= 1
The dynamics o f propagating A'-soliton pulses has been studied by the inverse
scattering method 10 in connection with the problem o f self-compression (see
Fig. 5.1). In Refs. 35 and 36 the analogous technique was applied for the
analysis o f superposition o f two time-resolved solitons.
The number o f practical problems that can be effectively treated using the
inverse scattering method increased substantially after the development o f an
efficient numerical procedure for calculating scattering data and subsequent
reconstruction o f q ( r , £) at arbitrary Q . 51 According to this procedure a
5.8. Analysis o f nonlinear viave fields 257
F IG . 5.20. Soliton spectrum of a Gaussian pulse (solid lines) com pared with
that o f an N -soliton pulse (dotted lines). Inset: the ratio of the energy W of
soliton com ponent to the initial energy W 0 o f the pulse as a function o f the initial
am plitude g0 .51
j sin dk
ak - exp (i k h k) cos dk — iAnk—
Ur
(5.8.12)
, o*. , 0 - A , s in d
K = % hk ( Aj+1 / 2) j
T (A ) = n T t (A). (5.8.13)
k=l
Separating in this matrix the coefficients a and b , one can, using standard
com putational procedures, find the set o f the roots {A j.}. and other scattering
data required for restoration o f q ( r , £) .
5. Optical solitons
F IG . 5.21. Soliton com ponent of a n oisy pulse: (a) initial profiles o f intensity
and phase; ( 6) soliton com ponent separated by the inverse scattering m eth od at
52
the distance C — 1 *
0 ( 0 = 90 + a 20.
The functions #0(C) and 0(£) satisfy the set o f equations [cf. Eq. (4.5.7)]
^ 0 o= 2<9 oO - < ( 9 oO 2) ’
(5.9.2)
- ^ 0 = 2 ( ^ * ) - 4 ((q0ql)(qq*))
where £ ( t ) is the com plex steady-state Gaussian noise with the zero mean
value, unitary dispersion, and Gaussian correlation function. After substitut
ing Eq. (5.9.3) into the right-hand side o f Eq. (5.9.2) and assuming £ = 0 , we
obtain Eq. (5.9.2) in the form
ZDU 5. Optical solitons
d 7t I „ d -
d f o | c= o= 0 >
It follows from here that the soliton component suppresses the dispersive spread
ing o f “slow” fluctuations with r > \/2 (it should be recalled that the corre
lation time is expressed here in the units o f the initial pulse duration). For fast
fluctuations with r < \/2 the rms duration o f the noise component grows with
£ according to a quadratic law
The indicated behavior is observed at the distances £ not exceeding the charac
teristic self-action length since the right-hand side o f Eq. (5.9.2) was calculated
at the point £ = 0 .
T o trace the dynamics o f self-action o f the noise com ponent at long distances,
we shall use the results o f mathematical modeling based on numerical integration
53
o f NSE. Figure 5.22 shows the intensity profiles at different £ for a pulse with
the random phase modulation
where the phase <p(r) is distributed according to a Gaussian law with the zero
2
mean,' the variance <x = 0.25 >, and the correlation time rC = 0.2 at £’ — 0 .
From the intensity profiles shown one can see that a fast conversion of phase
fluctuations into amplitude ones takes place at the initial stage o f propagation.
The mean peak duration equals r . Later, a relatively fast filtering o f the
soliton component proceeds at the expense o f dispersive spreading o f the noise
com ponent. A t £ « 1 the pulse turns into a soliton. Note that the soliton
amplitude obtained by direct integration o f NSE coincides with that calculated
by the inverse scattering method for the same realization o f the initial data
(5.9.6).
FIG . 5.23. D ependence o f the total energy o f soliton and noisy com ponents
within a fixed time interval for different initial correlation times o f phase fluctu
ations rc : (1) 0.1, (g ) 0.2, (5) 0.4.
Figure 5.23 illustrates the dependence o f the total energy of soliton and noise
T /2
Suppose that
where p( r ) isthe real random process with correlation time tc . It then follows
from Eq.(5.9.7) thatonly the amplitude o f the formed soliton fluctuates:
CO
8x
= J/ -cosh
^ rT dT- ( 5-9 -9)
8 x = 2 p 0. (5.9.11)
A wave packet at the output o f the waveguide with the length £ > 1 has the
envelope
Phase fluctuations
Let us consider the phase modulation (5.9.6) where <p(r) is, as before, a real
Gaussian random process with correlation time tc . Then
For slow fluctuations ( r > 1) the expansion similar to Eq. (5.9.10) is valid:
Substituting the last equation into Eq. (5.9.7) one can easily see that the random
component o f the phase <p0 does not change the soliton velocity and amplitude,
whereas the component linear in terms o f r leads to their variations:
It follows from here that at <C 1 the velocity variations 5V = (pY are of
the first-order and the amplitude variations 8>c ~ are o f the second-order of
smallness.
Thus, the output pulse at £ 3> 1 represents a disturbed solitone
If the distribution density o f the random coefficient <p1 is Gaussian, then the
velocity distribution is described by the same law. The standard deviations of
the parameters 8V and <p1 coincide.
Let us consider a more general case o f the initial data (5.9.3) where £ (r ) is the
steady-state com plex Gaussian noise. After substituting these initial conditions
in Eq. (5.9.7) we immediately find that the amplitude fluctuations are deter
mined by the real com ponent o f the noise R e £ ( r ) , and the velocity fluctuations
by the imaginary component Im £ (r ) . Since £ = 0 , the mean values o f varia
tions Sx — 0 and SV = 0 . For variances cr2 and <rj) one obtains the following
54 x
expressions:
2 a 2 [ T3t s t coth 7- — 1
<x = 8<x I B ( t ) -----------g---------dr
I B^ ~ sinh t
(5-9.17)
G ( t ) = 6 sinh (2 r ) [sinh (2 r ) — 2 r]
— [cosh (2 r ) — 1] [2 cosh (2r ) — 2 + t sinh ( 2 r ) ] ,
FIG . 5.24. R edu ced variance o f fluctuations o f form ed soliton param eters as a
function o f correlation tim e o f initial perturbations: (a ) am plitude fluctuations;
( 6) velocity fluctuations (solid lines, perturbation m ethod calculations; points,
com puter sim ulation).
P(x)
correlation time r = 0.5 is fixed, the variable parameter is the noise variance
<r = 0.25, 0 .5, 1, and the number o f realizations M = 1024. Comparison
o f the histograms calculated for different noise variances shows that for a < 0.5
the distributions p ( x ) and p ( V ) are close to Gaussian.
The <?-dependences o f the mean amplitude 3? and standard deviations <?
and <rv are plotted in Fig. 5.26. The curves shown demonstrate that the linear
formulas o f the perturbation theory for and crv are in good agreement with
the data of numerical experiments for a < 0.5 . In the range 0.5 < <r < 1 the
linear perturbation theory fails (see Fig. 5.26). The obvious deviations o f p ( x )
5. Optical solrtons
from the Gaussian law, caused by the violation o f one-soliton regime, have to be
pointed out. It is interesting that the velocity distribution p ( V ) is adequately
approximated by a Gaussian function throughout the considered cr range.
As an illustration o f practical application o f the found behavior, we shall con
sider the transmission o f soliton pulses (r Q = 7.1 p s , A = 1.5 /im , V Q — 1 W )
along a 10-km fiber waveguide with a core cross-section area o f 100 /<m . Let
us evaluate the temporal scatter o f solitons registered by a detector in the case
when the energy signal-to-noise ratio equals 10, and the Gaussian noise (5.9.3)
has r = 0.3 ps. The delay o f a single pulse expressed in units o f its duration
is equal to the ratio o f the waveguide length L to the dispersion length L-d ,
multiplied by the standard deviation o f velocity fluctuations:
St / to = ( L /Ld)ffV
Estimating <xv from the curve in Fig. 5.26 to be equal to 0.15 and taking
into account that for the chosen parameter values Ld = 2.4 km, we obtain
St fw 0.6r0 = 4 ps. The relative energy fluctuations o f the registered solitons
equals 20%.
FIG . 5.26. Calculated average am plitude value X o f form ed solitons and the
standard am plitude a x and velocity a v deviations as a function of a (solid
lines, com puter simulation; dashed lines, perturbation theory calculations). 54
is coupled into a nonlinear fiber waveguide. Here qs is the probing soliton defined
by the parameters x , V , <p0 , rd and q(r , 0) is the unknown ( “signal” ) pulse
to be reconstructed.
We shall begin with the case when the signal pulse amplitude is small, so
that the dispersive spreading is predominant. Superposition o f q ( r , 0) with
the soliton pulse qs( r , 0) results at £ 1 in a change o f the probing soliton
parameters: x —> x + 6 x , V —* V + SV . This change can be expressed in
terms o f the perturbation theory 36 as
Our task consists in finding q from the registered variations 6V , 6>c, treated
as functions o f the probing soliton parameters. Depending on the variable pa
rameters, several approaches can be identified.55
Positional m ethod
In this method the variable parameter is a time delay rd o f the probing soliton
relative to the signal pulse. W ithout loss o f generality, it can be assumed that
<p0 = 0 and both the probing soliton and the signal pulse have equal group
velocities, i.e., carrier frequencies, and therefore V = 0 . From Eq. (5.10.2) it
immediately follows that
OO
qR( r) dr
S x ( T d ) = X J
cosh [ x ( t — Td)]
(5.10.3)
sinh - T,)l
rd)] ^
/ ---- - 3 — ---------
, - f \[ x ( t —
8V{Td) = x q ^ d r,
J cosh2
cosh [fxx (( tt -— rrd)]
,)\ ‘
4U O b. Optical solitons
where qR and g7 are the real and imaginary components o f the com plex ampli
tude o f the pulse to be reconstructed. The second relation o f Eq. (5.10.3) can
be readily reduced to the form
CO
6V
= / (5 1 0 '4)
Td
? fl(rd) = 7r~ 1^ ( rd ) . ? / ( rd) = 7r_1 J $v (r)dT. (5.10.5)
— OO
In the considered version o f the position method the empirical data are the
soliton amplitude that definitively corresponds to the energy W — 2 (x + 6 x ) ,
with the soliton being formed at £ 1 , and the contribution to the group
velocity that is definitively expressed via the additional time delay.
In practice, a more convenient approach involves two probing solitons with
the fixed time delay rd , interacting with the signal pulses in two independent
channels (fibers) and differing by the initial phases (^’q1’1 = 0 , = 7t/2 ).
Denoting the corresponding amplitude variations by 6x^ , 6 x ^ 2> and making
use o f Eq. (5.10.2), we obtain
OO
The right-hand side o f Eq. (5.10.6) is a convolution o f the signal pulse with the
probing soliton; its inversion yields the reconstruction procedure sought
- 1/2
where
OO
F ± ( f ) — (2ir) J f ( x ) exp(=pi ux ) d x
is the direct and inverse Fourier transformation. For a “narrow” soliton, the
kernel function o f the integral transformation (5.10.6) can be substituted by the
delta function. Finally, the algorithm is written in the following form:
The uncertainty o f the given formulas (in terms o f the amplitude contrast) has
•the order o f magnitude 0 ( Q / x ) , where Q = max |g(r , 0)| .
Here are some results on envelope reconstruction from numerical experiments.
Figure 5.27 (a) shows the signal pulse with rectangular envelope (the dashed
line) and the result o f its reconstruction by means o f Eq. (5.10.8) in the narrow
soliton approximation, x 1 . The accuracy o f amplitude reconstruction is
seen to improve as Q diminishes from 2 to 0.5. Here the temporal resolution is
determined by the probing pulse duration x ~ X = 0.1. Figure 5.27 (6) illustrates
the reconstruction o f a pulse with a linear chirp.
270 5. Optical solitons
FIG . 5.28. R econstruction o f ultrashort pulse envelope in the case o f b roa d prob
ing soliton: dashed line, initial pulse; solid line, result o f inversion o f convolution
(5.10.6); dotted , calculation using Eq. (5.10.8), one h alf o f the pulse is shown.
(dashed line), for different probing soliton amplitudes x -. Since the probing
soliton duration is close to that o f the signal pulse, the application o f algorithm
(5.10.8) fails to provide satisfactory results (dotted line). The reconstruction
by means o f a more general formula (5.10.7) ensures the temporal resolution o f
the signal pulse structure (solid line) even at = 1 . Note that the number o f
discrete points taken for the parameter rd was relatively small (M = 16).
Relying on the analogy between the solitons and quasiparticles, the soliton
probing can also be compared to the methods generally adopted in nuclear
physics for determination o f structure o f atoms and nuclei from the scattering
o f probing particles, such as protons, a particles, etc. The soliton parameters
will change drastically in those points o f the time axis, where the “potential”
determined by the signal pulse has conspicuous maxima.
5.10. Reconstruction o f the picosecond laser pulse shape 271
The right-hand side o f Eq. (5.10.9) is in fact the Fourier transformation o f the
product o f the unknown function q(r) and the kernel function determined by
a probing soliton. Performing the inverse Fourier transformation o f (5.10.9), we
obtain
Here o 0(fi) is the eigenvalue o f the operator a0(fi) and <p0 is the initial phase
o f the soliton. Let us write down the operator <^0( r ) in the form
4*oo
Here
C,
L{T(y), y) = J S(r{y), y)dy , (5.11.9a)
0
\ dr(y) ^ dr(y)
274 5. Optical solitons
C
T exp [i L ( r ( y ) , y)] = exp [i S ( r ( y ) , y) dy\.
y—0
From comparison of Eq. (5.11.11) with Eq. (5.11.5)) it follows that, providing
the solution o f the quantum NSE is represented in the form o f Eq. (5.11.7), the
“Green’s function” (5.11.8) corresponds to the operator
C
L o(T( y)) = J S0( T ( y )) d y , S0( r( y )) = (y) + |o0(r)|2.
0
Let us analyze now the behavior o f quantum fluctuations in the field of the
soliton (5.11.11). The operator <f>(r, £) in Eq. (5.11.8) is to be replaced by
4>0(t ) ■ In the linear (in terms o f fluctuations) approximation we obtain
C
L ( r ( y ) ) = L 0(T(y)) + 6 L( T( y ) ) , SL(r ( y ) ) = J SA ( r( y ) ) d y , (5.11.13)
0
where
SA ( r( y ) ) = a0(ri)[A<j>+ ( r( y ) ) + A <£(r(y))].
Replacing in the last expression A ^ (r (j/)) by A(j>0(r)) , i.e., assuming that the
fluctuations do not affect the paths over which the integration in Eq. (5.11.9) is
taken, we get
and
T exp [iL(r(y))] = exp [iLQ(r (y )) + iSL(rj)].
Thus we obtain
A^r, C) = [1 C)]^/2A^0(r)
-iH (r, C ) e (2Vo+C/2}A ^ ( r ) , (5.11.16)
+00
^ a x (^ ) “ ( ^ ) 1 J F ( r ) e xp ( iQr) dT , (5.11.17)
— OO
where
Laser system s generating stable frequency-tunable pulses w ith duration from 100 to 10 fs
are n o d ou b t one o f the highest achievements o f m od em physics and technology. T h e m ost
im portant constituents o f this progress are the successful realization o f new ideas in putting
together the m ethods o f generation and am plification o f short pulses in lasing media, the
wide application o f control com puters, and the creation o f effective nonlinear and lasing
m edia.
M o d e m pico- and fem tosecond laser system s make it possible to explore thoroughly the
physics o f energy and phase relaxation o f op tica l excitation in com plex m olecules and solids,
and to develop direct experim ental m ethod s for m olecular dynam ics studies.
A dvances in am plification technique o f ultrashort light pulses allowed the generation o f
very strong optical fields with the strengths about 10 G V /c m , i.e., one order o f magnitude
higher than intratom ic field strengths. O th er applications include picosecon d electronics,
produ ction o f ultrashort electron bunches, and x-ray and acoustic pulses.
Needless to say, a detailed review o f the facts accum ulated in these areas would neces
sitate a special m onograph. Consequently, in this chapter we pursue a m ore m odest goal,
w hich is to illustrate the trends and achievements o f m o d e m fem tosecond technology by the
exam ple o f the systems utilizing solid-state lasers as m aster oscillators. Prim ary emphasis
is given to quasi-cw pico- and fem tosecond systems based on such lasers; the developm ent
o f highly efficient nonlinear-optics frequency converters using the K T P crystals makes these
systems truly pliable. T h e contents o f this chapter is based primarily on the research, tech
niques, and approaches being developed in the Nonlinear O ptics Laboratory o f the M oscow
University. W h at has been said also relates to the discussion o f further progress in generation
o f fem tosecond pulses in the UV and far IR ranges.
Operational modules
T A B L E 6 .1 .
of fem tosecond laser complexes
FIG . 6.3. Shortening o f a chirped pulse during its am plification: (a) inten
sity I and instantaneous frequency v o f the initial pulse as a function o f time;
(b) gain line contour; (c) output pulse.
equal to 10 mJ. Note that high spectral quality is achieved as a rule in the begin
ning o f the generated train. In the case o f a broad inhomogeneously broadened
amplification line the SPM plays a negative role by promoting the development
of modulational instabilities, appearance of substructure, and spectral quality
deterioration.
The situation can be radically changed by introducing a frequency filter into
the resonator. The authors o f Ref. 6 studied generation characteristics o f an
actively mode-locked Q-switched phosphate-glass laser. A Fabry-Perot etalon
having a thickness o f 0.25 mm and transmission band 15 cm was used as a
filter. Owing to SPM and a restricted amplification band, the duration o f pulses
in the train diminished from 40 down to 4 ps. The highest spectral quality was
observed at the end o f the train.
Another method of stabilization and improvement o f performance character
istics o f solid-state lasers has been recently developed, which uses negative feed
back to trace pulse energy variations over a round-trip period. In this method,
the losses introduced into the resonator by electronic control o f the Q-factor are
determined by the pulse energy on one o f the previous (usually preceding) round
trips. By using negative feedback, one can succeed in producing a train o f repro
ducible picosecond pulses. Such a train may contain several thousands pulses.
Negative feedback has been employed in N d-glass,104 106 Nd-.YAG,107 108 and
ruby 106 lasers. For example, the authors o f Ref. 107 report the production of a
stable laser pulse train containing up to 5,000 pulses, each 20 ps long. The total
energy was about 2 mJ and variation o f pulse energy in the train did not exceed
5%.
with repetition rates from 82 to 100 MHz and average output power from 7 to
10 W . The rms fluctuations o f the output power at the fundamenal radiation
frequency do not exceed 1.5-2% . Frequency doubling in a K T P crystal leads
to the following parameter values: rp = 30-70 ps, (V) =1.5-0.75 W , power
fluctuations 2 -3% . The pulses produced by these lasers at the fundamental
and second-harmonic frequencies are successfully compressed more than 100-fold
using optical fiber compressors. The experimental data are reviewed in Sec. 6.4.
One o f the primary applications for which these systems are extensively used is
synchronous pumping o f frequency-tunable dye lasers.
In these lasers the merits o f pulsed (high-energy) and quasi-cw (high repetition
rate, stability) systems are successfully combined. One o f the possible versions
o f the laser with double modulation is schematically shown in Fig. 6.4. Mode
locking is affected by a standing-wave acousto-optic modulator. A traveling-
wave acousto-optic m odulator is used for Q-switching. In the double modulation
regime the laser emits a train o f picosecond pulses with variable repetition rate
(up to 5 kHz). The average power attained at the fundamental frequency equals
2 W , mean pulse duration 70 ps, peak power 2 M W , number o f pulses in the train
30, energy fluctuations 4%. The efficient frequency doubling in a K T P crystal
produces the second-haxmonic pulses with duration about 50 ps and peak power
1 MW.
1
%— p i— r
n r L — 1
1 2 3 *
3 +
F IG . 6.4. Schem atic of a Q-sw itched actively m ode-locked N d : Y A G laser:
( i ) non-transm itting spherical mirror, ( 2) Brewster plate, (J) lasing element,
(^) acou sto-optical m odulator o f Q factor, operating in a travelling wave regime,
(5) acou sto-optical m od e synchronizer operating in the standing wave regime,
(5) ou tpu t mirror. 7
qI
Performance o f a Nd : Y A G laser with double modulation has been further
refined by using the electronic control o f the Q factor and by a special choice o f
< S ♦ • •
the operation regime (see Fig. 6.5). The time-domain structure o f radiation
was preliminarily shaped when the resonator had a low Q factor; then, after a
sharp increase o f the Q factor, a rapid generation o f the pulse train took place.
The electronic feedback system provided a sudden rise o f the Q factor of the
resonator within the interval between the peaks o f preliminary generation. For
the optimal 100- ps duration o f free generation, the trains o f 35-fs transform-
limited pulses were formed with peak power over 1 M W (at repetition rate 1 kHz)
and energy fluctuations below the 5% level. The repetition rate o f the trains
v rep could be varied from several kilohertz to tens of kilohertz. The authors of
Ref. 8 believe that the frequency v can be raised up to hundreds o f kilohertz
provided a special Q-switching technique is used.
zo4 6. Femtosecond, laser systems
reliably obtained at the output. Many laboratories are engaged in the develop
ment o f such lasers whose performance favorably compares with, and in many
cases excels, that of passively m ode-locked lasers.
Tunable femtosecond pulses are generated due to parametric interactions in
media with quadratic nonlinearity, as well as in media with broad Raman gain
lines, especially in fiber waveguides. The high efficiency o f synchronous pumping
in such systems has been convincingly demonstrated in recent publications.
A schematic diagram o f a dye ring laser with the pulses colliding in the absorbing
jet is shown in Fig. 6.6 (a) . Pulse compression in this system is caused by the
bleaching o f the absorber resulting from the interference o f two pulses traveling
toward each other. In the experiment by Shank et al. 9 a rhodamine 6G laser
operated with a D O D C I solution used as a saturable absorber. The size of the
absorbing element is known to be significant; in the work cited the solution jet
was 30 fim thick. At the laser output, the pulses 65-90 fs long were obtained
with the spectral width about 125 cm 1 . The physical picture o f pulse shaping
in the lasers o f this kind has been comprehensively analyzed and described, for
example, in a monograph. 2
laser w ith intracavity com pression; ( 1) absorber, (2) lasing dye jet, (3 ) prism
10
com pressor.
zoo 0. fem tosecond laser systems
pump pulses Tpump Tx . In this situation the generated pulses are rapidly
formed from the spontaneous luminescence noise serving as a seed.
In the analysis o f performance of synchronously pumped lasers, the depen
dence o f the generated pulse duration rp on the detuning o f the resonator
lengths o f the pumping and the pum ped lasers, A L = — £ pump , plays an
important part. In real systems, this detuning characteristic takes the form o f
a sharply asymmetric resonance curve with a typical width A L/L ~ 10 6 . In
practice, the resonator lengths are adjusted to provide the minimal width o f the
intensity correlation function or the highest energy of the second harmonic. The
resonance properties o f the detuning characteristic and its small relative width
require a meticulous stabilization o f the pump pulse repetition rate. Fine tuning
o f the repetition rate within a ± 10-kHz interval is performed by an acousto-optic
modulator.
2 .....................
J /
t^ M=w
/ .* Ik
/ ' //
j N.
X
Wk M~?0
\ ■
\
r .v
j/\
<55> ;:
/ /\
i 5
it
/ :
/ ••
-
j A
A
/■ ’ ...... . M=150
/ ;
/ .•
s 1 / i i i
Figure 6.7 illustrates the evolution o f an ultrashort pulse during its consecu-
19
tive passes through the resonator. A t the outset o f pumping, during the first
t>. Femtosecond laser systems
passes the lasing medium develops the gain exceeding the loss level. The tem po
ral gain maximum corresponds to the peak of generated pulses that are longer
than the pump pulses. During subsequent passes, the intensity o f the generated
pulses grows while their duration diminishes due to preferential amplification of
the pulse peak coinciding with the gain maximum. In the process o f transition
to the saturation regime, the generated pulse peak shifts toward the pump pulse
and thus leaves the maximum gain region. In the steady-state generation regime
the gain-loss balance is realized over a repetition period o f the pump pulses.
(a)
If the duration rpump and intensity Ipump o f the pump pulses satisfy the
inequalities rpump > r , Jpump/J ,at <C T J tt , where 7sat is the saturation
intensity, then the rate o f transition from level 1 to level 4 is less than the 4~3
transition rate and therefore levels 4 and 2 will be practically depleted. For a
small detuning from the generation line center, the resonance contribution to
the SPM can be neglected. Then the set o f equations describing the interaction
1 _ .2 1
o f pump radiation with a four-level medium can be transformed to the set o f
equations for an equivalent two-level medium.
In the steady-state regime and for the zero detuning o f the resonator lengths
( A L = 0) , the generated pulse duration is estimated to be equal to
t
p
~ (Vr pumpT „2)-'1 /2 ’ , (6.3.1)
V /
agrees well with the theoretical dependence (6.3.1). The shortest duration at
tained in these experiments, rp = 210 fs, at rpump = 460 fs, with average
23
output power being equal to 40 m W . In the subsequent studies the output
power wets raised to 125 m W owing to the additional pumping o f the dye by
non-compressed radiation and the shortest pulse duration reduced to 180 fs.
The theoretical limit o f duration o f the pulses generated in the synchronous
pumping regime is associated with the fact that the population inversion of the
lasing level cannot be produced during the time interval less than the oscillation
relaxation time r « 1 ps for the given excited state o f a dye molecule. If the
pump pulse duration rpump falls within the interval T2 <C Tpump r . , then the
minimal duration o f the generated pulse is limited, as the calculations 24 show,
by the value rmin = \JrI'.2Tr & 50 fs.
The dependence o f r on the transmission bandwidth A v o f the frequency-
selective element for the constant duration o f pump pulses (i"pump = 100 ps)
— 1/2
was experimentally studied in Ref. 15. It was shown that rp ~ A t/
Duration, ps
FIG . 6.11. Tem poral dependence o f ran dom param eters o f the pulses generated
by a dye laser synchronously pu m ped by a cw train o f pulses with fluctuating
duration (the relative standard deviation 10% ).
Note that the intensity fluctuations are “fast” as their characteristic correla
tion time is comparable with the time that the radiation takes to pass several
times along the resonator. The fluctuations o f duration and delay time are rel-
27
atively slow, which agrees with the experimental results. The appearance o f
the two characteristic correlation scales is linked with the presence in the system
o f two substantially different characteristic times, i.e., the lifetime o f a photon
in the resonator and the time o f form ation o f the generated pulse.
Statistical treatment o f the ensemble o f realizations allows one to analyze the
distribution o f random parameters o f the output train and to calculate the aver
age values and variances. The calculations carried out in Ref. 26 showed that in
the case of the normal distribution o f fluctuations of pump pulse duration and
intensity, the distribution o f the corresponding parameters o f the output radia
tion is also close to the normal law. The typical values o f standard deviations
are summarized in Table 6.2.
Statistical investigations o f synchronously pumped lasers demonstrated that
the main destabilizing factor affecting the reproducibility o f output parameters
is the instability o f the repetition period o f pump pulses that is equivalent to
the fluctuating detuning o f the resonator lengths. This conclusion is in good
27
agreement with the experimental results.
292 6. Femtosecond laser systems
T A B L E 6 . 2 . Fluctuations o f radiation
param eters o f synchronously pum ped lasers*
Fluctuations
o f pump pulse Intensity Duration Rep etition
parameters period
Using the passive mode locking in picosecond lasers, one obtains shorter pulses
and higher stability o f radiation parameters, while the active mode locking pro
vides higher-energy characteristics. In many cases simultaneous application of
the two methods in synchronous pumping o f picosecond lasers provides optimal
results. 28.
The dynamics o f transition to steady-state generation in a synchronously
pumped laser with saturable absorber spatially separated from a lasing medium
was studied in numerical experiments. 26 To distinghish the effects o f the sat
urable absorber, the initial transmittance o f the system was taken equal to the
initial transmittance o f the synchronously pumped laser considered in the pre
vious section.
For A L = 0 and in the absence o f radiation focusing into the absorber,
the duration o f generation pulses remains practically constant. In numerical
experiments, after a fivefold increase o f intensity in the absorber (due to beam
focusing), the duration was found to be shortened almost by half. The physics o f
the process is as follows. A t the initial stages (the linear regime) the dynamics
o f the generation pulse compression does not differ at all from that considered
earlier. At the nonlinear stage (the saturation o f the lasing and absorbing media)
the effects o f the absorber lead to the steepening o f the leading edge o f the pulse,
whereas the lasing medium in this situation brings about the steepening o f the
trailing edge o f the pulse.
The essential feature o f lasers with hybrid mode locking is a relatively weak
29
dependence o f the generation pulse on the resonator length detuning. This
reduces the accuracy requirements for resonator tuning and stability o f pump
pulse parameters. In the region o f large negative detunings the pulse duration
practically does not change with A L , but its energy falls. On further increase
o f |AL| a new generation regime sets in, a pulsed one. In this regime a pulse
is first formed during 400-500 passages, then it slowly shifts forward in time,
and finally disappears. Then a new pulse starts forming and the process repeats
itself. Neither satellite pulses nor com plicated fine structure are observed in the
process.
Such a property o f the detuning characteristics is due to the fact that in the
case o f combined mode locking the lasing media can compensate considerable
detunings o f the resonators. Negative delays are caused by an absorbing medium
and positive delays by an amplifying one. A substantial increase in stability of
the generation regime as compared with the purely active mode locking is to be
also noted.
Let us analyze the systems in which the hybrid mode locking is applied. Using
rhodamine 6G as the gain and D Q O CI as the absorber medium, the authors o f
Ref. 30 obtained 70-fs pulses with average power 30 m W . Second-harmonic
oI
pulses with average power 300 m W from a Nd : Y A G laser were used for
31
pumping. In subsequent experiments a different technique was realized: one
o f the resonator mirrors was replaced by an antiresonance cavity containing a
saturable-absorber jet (see Fig. 6.12). The cavity geometry is chosen so that
the two pulses propagating in the absorber in opposite directions collide causing
294 6. Femtosecond laser systems
£ -------2w N d 3+ :Y A G
1.0
6t
0.5
a
FIG . 6.13. Calculated distribution o f pulse param eters in the train generated by
a dye laser synchronously pu m ped by a train o f N pulses: ( i ) pum p pulse energy,
(2) generated pulse energy, (5) generated pulse duration, (4) delay o f generated
pulses w ith respect to pum p pulses (points, experimental results 24 ).
The physical picture o f pulse shaping can be imagined as follows. The first
pump pulses provide a gain in a lasing medium, sufficient for generation o f long
6.3. Frequency-tunable picosecond and fem tosecond lasers 295
pulses existing as long as the gain exceeds the losses (see Fig. 6.7). The peak o f
the generated pulse corresponds to the gain maximum. W ith each subsequent
passage, the generated pulse rapidly shortens and its intensity grows due to
the temporal gain modulation. As this takes place, the delay relative to the
pump pulse does not practically change. Next, as the gain saturates, the peak o f
the generated pulse shifts toward the pum p pulse resulting in a mismatch with
the gain maximum. This process leads to a steady-state regime when the gain
increment due to the pumping is counterbalanced by its decrease caused by the
pulse generation. These temporal variations of the delay and o f the gain o f the
32
lasing medium were explored using the temporal dependence o f spontaneous
luminescence proportional to the gain o f the medium.
FIG . 6.14. C alculated dependences o f duration (rp) averaged over the train
and energy (VF) , norm alized to the steady-state value (VFSS) on the num ber M
o f pulses in the pum p train. 26
The commonest efficient sources operating in the near IR are color-center lasers
using alkali halide crystals. 33 A typical example is provided by the F2 color-
center KF laser described in Ref. 34. W hen pumped by a continuous pulse
train generated by a Nd3+ : Y A G laser ( {V) = 5 W , rp =100 ps, repetition rate
100 M Hz), it produces pulses 3-5 ps long in the tunable range 1.24-1.45 /im .
The lasing element is placed in a vacuum cryostat maintaining an operation
296 6. Femtosecond laser systems
Due to the broad bandwidth o f parametric gain in crystals with quadratic nonlin
earity, the femtosecond optical pulses can be amplified; the summary on optical
parametric oscillators (O P O ) is given in Ref. 3. Application o f O PO in femtosec
ond laser systems imposes more stringent requirements on stability and spectral
quality o f generated pulses.
A very advantageous method to improve the spatial and temporal haracter-
istics o f OPO radiation is an injection o f a highly coherent low-power external
signal. In this case the generation starts developing not from the noise level but
from the level of the injected signal. For injection, one can use the radiation
emitted by semiconductor lasers41 or dye lasers synchronously pumped by the
part of the train produced by the master oscillator. In distinction to the semicon
ductor lasers which possess a narrow frequency-tuning range, the injecting dye
6.3. Frequency-tunable picosecond and femtosecond lasers 297
f F\t)dt
- T /2
One can distinguish at least three areas in which the development o f compression
systems and phase modulators calls for technical realization.
In the first place, the frequency-tunable pulses generated by synchronously
pumped lasers are compressed from the initial duration o f several picoseconds
down to a few tens o f femtoseconds. Here we usually deal with sufficiently pow
erful pulses; moreover, there are possibilities for an intermediate amplification,
including also the amplification o f pulse trains with kilohertz repetition rate. In
this case the multistage compression techniques and conventional grating com
pressors are very efficient.
The second approach involves a highly efficient compression o f pulses gener
ated by quasi-cw actively mode-locked solid-state lasers from the initial duration
o f tens o f picoseconds down to hundreds o f femtoseconds. More often, the rel
atively low-power pulses are treated here and amplifiers are usually rejected.
At the same time, the nonlinear processes utilized are o f quasi-steady-state na
ture and the inertia o f a nonlinear response does not practically show up. In
the development o f the grating compressors, to the forefront come the problems
o f enhancing the transmittance and eliminating the spatial shift o f frequency
components (see Sec. 4.2).
The third area covers the production o f ultimately short optical pulses (6 -
10 fs) by compressing the amplified pulses with initial duration 40-100 fs emitted
by the dye lasers. In this situation, the transient effects leading to the violation
o f a linear chirp at the fiber output prove to be significant. Compensation o f
nonlinear aberrations plays a vital role in compressors.
the input power fostered SRS. In the second 55-cm fiber a stronger chirp was
obtained. At the output of the second compressor the pulses had a duration of
90 fs, peak power 10 kW , and repetition rate 800 Hz. The further refinement
of this technique by utilization o f an intermediate dye amplifier allowed one to
attain extremely short (16-fs) output pulses with peak power 88 kW and 1-kHz
repetition rate. 46
Quasi-cw Nd : Y AG lasers emit relatively long 100-ps pulses with low peak
power about 100 W and high repetition rate 100 kHz. A sufficient chirp o f such
pulses can be achieved only in long (100-1000 m ) fibers.
The authors o f Ref. 48 succeeded in 80-fold compression o f second harmonic
pulses from an actively m ode-locked Nd3+ : Y A G laser. The 33-ps initial pulses
had a peak power o f 240 W and repetition rate 100 MHz. The input radiation
parameters were matched with those o f a polarization-preserving 105-m optical
fiber with core diameter 3.8 (im to realize the optimal compression regime.
The round-trip grating compressor technique made it possible to eliminate the
diffraction shift o f beams and to obtain 410-fs pulses with a peak power o f 1.2 kW .
49
In the following work the output peak power was raised up to 3.4 kW owing to
an increase in the transmission coefficient o f the compressor. Duration-tunable
compressed pulses were used for synchronous pumping o f the dye laser.
Let us discuss the experiments on compression of the pulses generated by
Nd3+ : Y A G lasers at the fundamental frequency. On conversion from the visible
to the IR range, the losses in the fiber diminish from 16-20 to 0.2-1 dB /km ,
making it possible to use the fibers 100-1000 m long and efficiently compress
low-power pulses. For example, the authors o f Ref. 50 succeeded in a 45-fold
compression (from 80 to 1.8 ps) o f quasi-cw Nd3+ : Y AG laser pulses. A 300-m
single-mode optical fiber served as a phase modulator. After frequency doubling
in a K T P crystal, the average power became equal to 40 m W at repetition rate
82 MHz.
A two-stage technique allowed the authors o f Ref. 51 to achieve a compression
ratio o f 113 and obtain subpicosecond (750-fs) pulses with power PQ = 400 W .
As a rule, the first stage operates in a nondispersive and the second stage in
a dispersive SPM regime. The further advance in the cascade compression
52
technique resulted in raising S up to 450. The compressed pulses were 200 fs
long and their peak power equal to 8 kW .
The detailed study o f spectral and temporal characteristics at A = 1.06 /jm
was carried out by the authors o f Ref. 53. As the input power V Q increased
from 50 to 100 W , the pulse duration at the output o f the 125-m fiber waveguide
increased from 85 to 127 ps while its envelope acquired a more rectangular shape
(see Fig. 6.17). Then rp was observed to shorten down to 43 ps at V 0 =
180 W . The authors o f Ref. 53 believe that this nonmonotonic behavior is
associated with Raman frequency conversion. This can be illustrated by part
(5) of Fig. 6.17 (a) in which the Stokes pulse (Ag = 1.12 fxm ) is clearly seen to
lead the pump pulse. The generation o f Stokes-frequency radiation is supressed
due to a group-velocity mismatch. The pulse divergence rate at the frequency
302 6. Femtosecond laser systems
1.0655 1.0625
__ i
12 7ps
shift 440 cm 1 corresponding to the center o f the Raman gain line, is equal to
1.5 p s/m at A = 1.06 fim and 5 p s/m at A = 0.53 fj.m . This restricts the length
o f efficient energy exchange to 20-70 m for pulse duration 100 ps. In the case o f
a large group-velocity mismatch the Raman frequency conversion is equivalent
to a growth o f losses at the fundamental frequency and therefore reduces the
efficiency o f SPM.
To refine the ultrafast optical information systems and provide their metro
logical support, the ultrashort pulses at A « 1.3 fjim
are needed. It is reported
in Ref. 54 that the pulses generated by a Nd : Y AG laser at 1.319 (im were
compressed by a factor o f 50 from 100 to 2 ps. To obtain a dispersive SPM,
a 2-km optical fiber was used. The wavelength Acr corresponding to the zero
group-velocity dispersion was shifted to the vicinity o f 1.59 fjim
by proper dop
ing o f the glass and by special choice o f the refractive index profile. The peak
power V = 615 W of the output pulse was achieved. Addition o f the second
40-m fiber with anomalous group-velocity dispersion (Acr = 1.275 / /m ) made it
possible to obtain the 90-fs pulses in the soliton self-compression regime. The
total compression ratio S — 1000.
Usage o f optical fibers with opposite signs o f group-velocity dispersion allows
one to create the compression systems without prism compressors. 55 The first
fiber is used as a phase modulator and the second as a distributed nonlinear
compressor. The theory o f such compression systems published in Ref. 56 iden
tifies the optimal operation conditions and recommends how they can be utilized
to convert multisoliton pump pulses into high-power one-soliton pulses.
6.4. Compression system s: experimental data review 303
The merits o f lasers operating in the double modulation regime were discussed
in detail in Sec. 6.2. The main advantage is the combination o f a high pulsed
power o f about 1 M W with the kilohertz repetition rate. To compress high-
57 58
energy pulses at both the fundamental and second harmonic frequencies,
one has to use the relatively short optical fibers from 1 to 10 m long. The restric
tion imposed on the optical fiber length L is determined by a SRS threshold
and leads to the inequality I ^ L < 16/<75 , where gB ~ 10 11 c m /W and 7eff is
the effective intensity (see Sec. 5.5). In this case a nondispersive SPM is real
ized, which reduces the eneigy efficiency o f compression and the contiast o f the
compressed pulse. Besides, the lasers with double modulation possess a higher
level o f fluctuations o f radiation parameters and are thus characterized with less
stable parameters o f the compressed pulses.
To overcome these drawbacks, a special compression technique was proposed
with a frequency-doubling crystal placed between an optical fiber and a grating
compressor. 59 It should be remembered that in the nondispersive regime the
compression ratio S w 0.88 x 2irh2IeftL/\ . Since the limiting value o f the prod-
uct IeftL < 16/<7s and the gain gs at the Stokes frequency is inversely propor
tional to the wavelength: gs — C/X , where the constant C ~ 10- U c m /jm /W ,
then the highest ratio o f non-dispersive compression S = 0.88 x 2nh2lQ/C fa 30
is practically independent of the wavelength. In the systems where the frequency
doubling is accomplished either before or after compression, the ratio S calcu
lated relative to the pulse duration at the monitor frequency grows by a factor
o f \/2 due to pulse shortening during SHG.
In the technique proposed by the authors o f Ref. 59 (see Fig. 6.18) the
frequency o f the swept pulses doubles. If in this process the bandwidth o f spectral
synchronism does not limit the radiation spectrum, then the frequency sweeping
range also doubles. As a result, the ultimate compression ratio at the second
harmonic frequency is raised by a factor o f \/2 . W ith an increase in the length
o f a nonlinear crystal, the bandwidth o f spectral synchronism narrows and the
doubling crystal begins to operate as an apodyzing band filter. As the results o f
59
com puter simulation and experiments showed, the spectral filtering enhances
the contrast and suppresses the fluctuations o f compressed pulse parameters.
The experimental layout is shown in Fig. 6.18. A laser operating in the
double m odulation legim e emitted pulse tiains with 2-kHz repetition rate (A =
1.06 fj.m , t = 100 ps, V 0 = 1 M W ). The basic elements o f an optical fiber
compressor were a 1-m single-mode fiber, K T P crystal, and holographic diffrac
tion grating. The bandwidth o f spectral synchronism was varied by changing the
length o f the doubling crystal Z cr (2, 5, 8, and 11 mm). Figure 6.18 illustrates
the intensity correlation functions o f the second harmonic measured prior to (a)
and after (6) compression in the grating compressor. The increase o f L(.r from
2 to 11 mm is seen to reduce the duration o f the chirped pulses at the crystal
output from 62 to 30 ps. A s it takes place, the compressed pulse duration grows
from 1.1 to 2.8 ps. This reduction in a compression ratio is however compensated
304 6. Femtosecond laser systems
*•* • ••
.*• • • Lor=i,mm
• ••
* f v s . Jtfps
• »
• • • •
«
•*
•. •• •* ••
•• *•
•••* (* )
■
9 ...
• • •
• • ••
• L cr = 8mm • . L c r - 2mm
•
• •
* 4 8p s /./p s
* r - p • •
• •
/
• •
•••
• •• (b)
In the first experiments o f this kind the colliding-pulse dye ring lasers were used
as sources. The dye amplifiers provided a high input power o f about 1 M W
(see Sec. 6.5) that was necessary for compression and eventual production o f
fem tosecond pulses with energies o f tens o f nanojoules.
FIG . 6.19. (a) Intensity correlation function o f a fem tosecond pulse obtained
experim entally; (6) correlation fu n ction o f the field o f a 6-fs pulse. 64
90 6.7 15.0 30 3 10 60
65 55.0 0.8 16 4 10 61
110 260.0 1.5 12 8 800 62
40 250.0 0.7 8 5 5 000 63
50 200.0
300.0 0.8 6 8.3 8 000 64
6-4- Compression system s: experimental data review 307
The minimal duration achieved using a grating compressor for matching the
harmonics o f the broadened spectrum in the parabolic approximation, is equal
to 8 fs 63 and corresponds to about four periods o f optical oscillations.
The next step toward production o f ultimately short pulses was taken after
the theoretical analysis o f perturbing effects (see Sec. 4.7) violating the chirp
linearity due to self-action in fibers, and after the development o f combined
grating-prism compressors that made it possible to compensate not only the
linear but also quadratic chirp, i.e., the development o f the “temporal lens”
capable o f eliminating aberrations.
In the experiments 64 50-fs 125-nJ pulses o f the wavelength 0.625 p m were
chirped in a 8-mm optical fiber. Then they were compressed down to 10 fs using
a grating pair (600 lines/m m , 6 = 4 m m ). Registering the dependence o f the
signal generated at the sum frequency (o f the initial and compressed pulses) in
a thin K D P crystal on the relative tem poral delay o f the pulses, the authors
o f Ref. 64 detected the presence o f residual quadratic chirp in the compressed
pulse. Elimination o f this chirp by the compressor consisting of two prism pairs,
two gratings and a quartz plate, ensured compression of the pulses down to only
6 fs. Intensity correlation function o f the compressed pulses measured using
the collinear SHG technique is illustrated in Fig. 6.19. Thus, the experimental
results, obtained in the visible range, approached very closely to the theoretical
limit o f one optical oscillation.
The prospects for using X P M in ultrashort pulse shaping are becom ing quite
clear now. Consider two wave packets A x( t , z) and A 2( t , z) interacting due
to a nonlinear correction to the index o f refraction producing the additional
nonlinear phase
from 2 ps to 300 f s . 117 The authors o f Ref. 118 used X PM for conversion of
cw radiation emitted by a diode laser (A = 1.5 /jm ) into a continuous train of
100-ps pulses following with a repetition frequency o f 100 MHz. A cw-pumped
mode-locked N d:YAG laser ( A = 1.06 /Jm ) was used as the modulation source.
Positive FM o f cw radiation from a diode laser led under conditions o f anomalous
group-velocity dispersion to the formation o f a pulse train.
D ye amplifiers
In the visible wavelength range, most efficient are the dye amplifiers that can
be pumped by second-harmonic radiation from solid-state lasers, by excimer
lasers and metal vapor lasers. Figure 6.20 shows the schematic of a relatively
65
simple system whose main element is a dye laser synchronously pumped by
second-harmonic radiation o f a passively mode-locked phosphate glass laser. On
matching o f the resonator lengths, the dye laser emitted the trains o f 6-8 pulses
with average duration 10 ps and peak power 16 kW. The pulse possessing the
highest amplitude was singled out by means o f an electro-optical switch. The
dye laser pulse was then chirped in a 5-m single-mode fiber so that its spectrum
broadened to 40 cm -1 . At the compressor output the pulses were 700 fs long.
The peak pulse amplitude was raised up to 7 M W by a two-stage amplifier
pum ped by amplified monitor radiation at the double frequency. The usage
o f the same monitor for pumping both the dye laser and amplifiers eliminates
FIG . 6.21. Multistage amplifier o f fem tosecond pulses: ( I ) pum p laser w ith am
plifier, (2) frequency doubler, (•?)-(6) dye cells, (7) grating com pressor. Filters of
spatial frequencies with saturable absorbers are placed between the am plification
stages. 67
first three amplification stages. The fourth stage was pumped longitudinally.
The pump energy was distributed among the four stages as follows: 1.5, 1.5,
26, and 71%. The respective gains, with allowance made for absorption, were
equal to 750, 20, 10, and 40. The important elements o f this setup were the
filters o f spatial frequencies used for improvement o f the spatial structure o f the
beam and the saturable absorbers that enhanced the temporal contrast o f the
amplified pulses and suppressed the spontaneous emission.
During amplification o f the dye laser pulses with initial duration 70 fs and
energy 0.2 n j up to the energy 1 mJ (the peak power 2 G W ) their duration
increased up to 400 fs. A perceptible increase in duration is associated with dis
persive spreading in a solvent (water, 20 cm) and optical elements (quartz, 5 cm).
A grating compressor placed at the output o f the system ensured compensation
o f dispersive spreading and production o f 70-fs 0.3-G W transform-limited pulses.
The compressor consisted o f two parallel gratings (600 lines/m m ) separated by
a distance 5.2 cm.
Further improvement o f femtosecond pulse amplification technique is a de
velopment o f amplifiers operating with very high repetition rates. 68 A part o f
second-harmonic radiation from an actively mode-locked Nd3+ : Y A G laser serv
ing as a monitor, was used for synchronous pumping o f a dye laser. Additional
shortening o f the dye laser pulses was achieved by means o f a saturable absorber
and the colliding-pulse operation technique. The other part o f monitor radia
tion was coupled to a regenerative garnet amplifier assembled according to the
scheme similar to the one shown in Fig. 6.22. After 45 round trips, the amplified
pulse was coupled from the resonator with an energy o f 1 mJ, duration 100 ps,
and repetition rate 1 kHz. Then after frequency doubling in a KDP crystal with
efficiency 30%, it was used for transverse pumping o f a dye amplifier comprising
two cells each 1 cm long. During the amplification, the pulse energy grew from
350 pJ up to 1.5 fij (a gain o f 10 4 ) and duration from 85 to 170 fs. Pulse broad
ening is associated with dispersive spreading and gain saturation. In principle,
such systems make it possible to amplify the pulses with duration o f several tens
o f femtoseconds up to megawatt values o f power for kilohertz repetition rate.
6.5. Ulirashort pulse amplification 311
72 . . - 3+
perimental layout comprising a quasi-cw actively mode-locked Nd : YAG
laser, single-mode 1.4-km fiber waveguide with 9- fim core diameter, regener
ative neodymium-glass amplifier, and two-pass grating compressor. Owing to
self-action in the fiber, the monitor pulse duration grows from 150 to 300 ps
and spectral width broadens to 5 nm. Chirped pulses are injected into the re
generative neodymium-glass amplifier. A A /4 plate and a Pockels cell placed
into the amplifier resonator couple the amplified pulse out o f it after several tens
o f passages. The energy o f the amplified pulse with a linear chirp amounts to
2 mJ. Then it couples into the grating compressor and shortens down to 1.5 ps.
Despite some envelope distortions caused by the gain saturation, the contrast o f
the compressed pulses is fairly high.
A ccording to recent communications, the pulse energy was raised to 100 mJ
♦ • • 73
and eventually to 1.3 J by adding more amplification stages. The peak power
o f such a pulse reaches 600 G W . The authors o f Ref. 73 report a high degree of
coherence: the focal spot diameter exceeds the diffraction limit only by a factor
18 2
o f 2. This enables one to obtain intensities o f 10 W /c m at the focal point.
Further progress in amplification o f FM pulses and their successive compres
sion is associated with sharpening o f contrast and lowering a fluctuation level o f
121
output pulse parameters by means o f spectral windowing technique. Energies
about 10 J have been achieved by now for an output pulse duration below one
picosecond.
It should be emphasized that from the standpoint o f reaching the minimum
duration, the amplification o f a chirped pulse and its subsequent compression
are equivalent to its compression and subsequent amplification since the gain
bandwidth is o f fundamental significance here. In energy terms, however, the
amplification o f a chirped pulse is more favorable, since self-focusing and break
down limit the peak intensity value in the amplifier by a level o f 10 10 W /c m 2 .
The peak intensity o f a chirped pulse is 2 orders o f magnitude lower than that of.
the compressed pulse and therefore the maximal energy extracted from a lasing
medium grows considerably.
FIG . 6.23. Fem tosecond laser system o f the UV range constructed at the Non
linear O ptics L aboratory o f the M oscow State University. 80
F IG . 6.25. Energy density o f pico- (triangles) and fem tosecond (circles) pulse
amplified in X eC l excim er as a function o f energy density o f input radiation.
FIG . 6.26. U V picosecond pulse shape measured using a streak cam era at the
output o f X e C l amplifier operating under the deep saturation conditions. Break
ing into subpulses is associated with coherent effects. 83
spot with diameter 2.3 /im and its ultimate radiation intensities pushed up to
about 3 x 1019 W /c m 2 .
and photoionization o f excited atoms in the intense radiation field, are analyzed
in Ref. 86.
The latest achievements in the femtosecond IR pulse generation are reported
in Ref. 87. A relatively long hybrid C O laser pulse ( r = 100 n s , A = 9.5 /im )
was gated using two fast semiconductor switches. One o f them, made o f cadmium
telluride, used for reflection (see Fig. 6.28). At the moment when a high-
power femtosecond pulse o f visible range reaches the semiconductor, the highly
concentrated free carriers released at its surface form a plasma mirror sending
an IR pulse to the second switch used for transmission. This switch is made o f
silicon and serves to shape the trailing edge o f the IR pulse.
FIG . 6.28. Experim ental setup for generation o f IR fem tosecond pulses:
( / } fem tosecond dye laser, (2) dye amplifier, (3) hybrid C O 2 laser, (./) CdTe
reflection switch, (5) germ anium etalon, (6) polarizer, (7) quartz transmission
switch. 87
Th e 70-fs gate pulses o f visible range emitted by a dye laser were boosted in
a two-stage amplifier pumped by excimer laser radiation. The moments o f their
arrival to the switches were controlled by an optical delay line. The resulting IR
pulse had 130-fs duration that corresponded to four optical oscillation periods at
a wavelength 9.5 pm . Its spectrum shown in Fig. 6.29 spanned the range from
7.5 to 10.5 fj,m . The power o f the final IR pulse is relatively low, V Q m 10 kW .
As seen from Fig. 6.29, the central wavelength AQ = 9.3 /im in the spectrum
o f the femtosecond IR pulse is shifted from the initial value 9.5 p m toward the
anti-Stokes region. According to the authors, this shift is caused by the growth
o f density o f free charge carriers in the second switch and the associated chirping
o f the passing pulse. Reduction in the duration of gate pulses from a dye laser
down to 35 fs opens the real prospects for generation of IR pulses whose duration
equals one optical oscillation period.
320 6. Femtosecond laser systems
focused, together with the rest part o f the radiation (10 pJ ) coupled out o f the
amplifier, on a LiNbO 3 crystal. The output radiation carried by 200-fs 10-kW
pulses at the difference-frequency could be tuned over the range 1.7-4 pm by
turning the crystal.
For the development o f parametric oscillators in the IR range, AgGaS 2 crys
tals look very promising because o f their high nonlinearity and broad transparent
window extending from 0.6 to 13 pm . Figure 6.30(a) shows the conversion curve
o f this generator pumped by a Nd3+ : Y A G laser. Figure 6.30(6) illustrates the
91
quantum conversion efficiency as a function o f the radiation wavelength.
FIG . 6.32. Correlator for measuring duration o f fem tosecond pulses in the U V,
93
visible, and IR ranges.
in the optical elements o f the correlator. When necessary, the optical path in
quartz can be reduced to a minimal thickness o f the input window in a vacuum
chamber. An input window thickness o f 3.5 mm corresponds to the 8-fs dispersive
spread o f a 0.308-pm UV pulse. The duration o f a pulse in the visible and
UV ranges can be measured without evacuation o f the nonlinear crystal, thus
preventing the pulse propagation through dispersive elements.
FIG . 6.33. Noncollinear SHG u pon reflection from the surface (a) and within a
nonlinear crystal (b) ; illustrated are the effects that are associated with a beam
convergence angle.
where a is the dimension o f the spot at the crystal surface in which the beams
overlap. Suppose that for a reliable signal registration, N 2 quanta o f SH radi
ation are needed. Then the minimal pulse energy at the fundamental frequency
is equal to W u = 2huiN2M/r,c . This energy can be focused into a spot with
l/2
minimal diameter amin = \^WwjiTWth sin (7 / 2 )] , where u>th is the threshold
density o f the energy destroying the nonlinear crystal surface. In this case, the
minimal duration rmi = (“ mjn/ c) sin 7 ■ For a GaAs crystal at A = 0.53 pm ,
2 —9
u>th — 0.1 J /cm " , 7]c = 10 , 7 = 0.1 rad, we obtain rmin = 10 fs. The ex-
perimental intensity correlation functions for femtosecond UV pulses are shown
in Sec. 6 .6 (see Fig. 6.24).
A m ong the correlation methods recently developed to measure the duration
o f ultrashort optical pulses we specifically distinguish the technique based on
noncollinear SHG proposed and realized for the first time by Krivoshchekov and
co-workers. 125 ’ 6 Here is the idea o f the method. The extension o f the region
in which cw beams interact noncollinearly is determined by the radii o f the
interacting beams and their convergence angle. In the case o f pulsed radiation,
however, this region can be limited due to the finite duration o f the pulses [see
6.8 . Advances in ihe fem tosecond pulse measurement technique 325
Fig. 6.33 (&)]. For initial Gaussian beams o f radius aQ and pulse duration , t q
the radius o f the SH beam propagating along the x-axis [in the plane o f Fig.
6.33 ( 6) ] is equal to
where 7 is the beam convergence angle and u is the group velocity o f the
fundamental wave in the nonlinear crystal. When the spatial dimensions o f
the measured pulse u t0 a0 tan (7 / 2) , the SH beam radius is determined
exclusively by the pulse duration: a2 = urQ/sin (7 / 2) . Under this condition,
the distribution o f the SH energy density in the cross-section along the x-axis is
determined by the second-order correlation intensity function B (x ) :
Some experimental systems which allow one to measure the correlation function
($)
B (tj , t 2 ) were proposed in Refs. 144-146.
M e a s u r e m e n t o f in te n s ity a n d p h a s e as a f u n c t io n o f tim e
oo
* .0 -)= / W + r)d< (6.8.2)
— OO
1.0 - I f to 60 - 6 f
s~ \ 1 >'
/ /
40
0
20
1.0 - t i h / * \ 2 0f v / ,
J \
80 ' 5v, cm"1
* V
0.1 -A I!lo
0 —
0.1 1 1 _ 1 -8 0 - / , , 2
-10 0 10 £,ps -4 0 t,ps
(a) (b)
FIG . 6.35. R econstruction o f tem poral dependence o f phase and frequency of
a picosecon d pulse from a dynam ic interferogram . (a) Intensity profile: ( 1) in
put pulse, ( 2) pulse at the output o f interferom eter, (3) difference o f intensities
o f input and output pulses; (6) result o f interferogram interpretation: (J) tem
poral dependence o f phase, (2) tem poral dependence o f frequency obtain ed by
differentiation o f the phase dependence. 94
V (t ) = [1 + ^ ( 0 ] £ f ( t + m T + 8Tm(t) ) , (6.8.4)
m
where the random function J (t) = 5Tm (t)/ T at t = t m characterizes the rela
tive fluctuations o f the repetition period.
The correlation function o f the power B ^ calculated with allowance made
for statistical independence o f A (t) and J (t) can be rewritten as
where ® denotes the convolution operation. Taking into account Eq. (6.8.3),
the spectral power density can be rewritten as
( 2 7T\ ^
Sp ( W ) = ( Y j 2
I ^ W)| I Z [ 5 (Wm ) + Syl(Wm ) + ( 27r m ) 2 s j ( W) ] : ( 6 '8 '8)
' ' m
The spectral density o f random radiation power is shown in Fig. 6.37 for the
case o f a train o f the pulses with fluctuating parameters (6.8.4). In the absence
o f fluctuations the power spectrum is a superposition o f narrow peaks separated
by the frequency intervals wm+1 — = 2 tt/T . The presence o f amplitude
fluctuations leads to the appearance o f relatively broad pedestals whose height
h ~ m 2 [the last term in Eq. (6.8.8)]. From the considered example it is seen
that the analysis o f the spectral density o f random radiation power enables one to
estimate the contributions o f fluctuations o f different parameters. In particular,
one can easily see that the variance o f amplitude fluctuations is proportional to
the area limited by the broad pedestal in Fig. 6.37.
h s.
F IG . 6.37. Spectral pow er density o f quasi-cw pulse train with fluctuating am
plitude and repetition period. Narrow peaks following with the frequency inter
val 1 / T correspond to a deterministic signal, appearance o f broad pedestals is
caused by am plitude fluctuations and o f narrow pedestals by repetition period
fluctuations.
1/ 2
AW V {A t
(6.8.9)
4l l f ' + '
This implies that by measuring the level o f energy fluctuations at the fundamen
tal and doubled frequencies, one can evaluate the fluctuations o f duration.
In the experiments described in Ref. 101 (see Fig. 6.38) the stability o f
radiation parameters was investigated for different types o f lasers, such as an
actively m ode-locked argon laser, synchronously pumped dye laser, and CPM
laser. In particular, it is shown that the random “jitter” o f the argon laser
pump pulses with a typical standard deviation o f 20 ps and a correlation time o f
0.4 ps is transferred to the pulses o f a synchronously pum ped dye laser without
6.8. Advances in the fem tosecond pulse measurement technique 331
FIG . 6.38. Spectral density o f power em itted b y a synchronously pum ped dye
las('r. T h e spectrum is shown in the 5-M Hz band with the center at the frequency
ojj/2?r = 79.81 M H z corresponding to the repetition rate o f generated pulses.
noticeable changes. This is caused by the fact that the typical time taken to
reach a steady-state generation regime in a dye laser is equal to 1 /is which
is substantially less than the correlation time o f the fluctuations o f pump pulse
repetition period. The random energy variations o f dye laser pulses are primarily
associated not with the pumping but with intrinsic properties o f the dye laser
itself. All radiation parameters turned to be stable to a high degree in a ring
laser with passive mode locking.
In conclusion, it should be emphasized that the spectral analysis o f fluctua
tions in quasi-cw lasers makes it possible to identify the basic destabilizing factors
and optimize a femtosecond laser system. An example o f such an optimization
can be found in Ref. 102.
Conclusion
T h e new approaches in the physics and technology o f ultrashort pulse shaping, compression,
and am plification, as well as new m od e-lock in g techniques in lasers discussed in this b ook
have brought about results that cou ld hardly have been predicted in the beginning of the
80s. Laser pulses as short as 6 fs have revolutionized tim e-dom ain spectroscopy. In fact, it
has becom e possible to “freeze” any m om ent o f com plex processes o f energy transformation
in optically excited atom s, m olecules (including organic ones) and condensed media. It
has b ecom e possible to actually observe coherent interactions with biological molecules and
register the dynam ics o f elementary chem ical reactions in real time. A novel branch o f
chemistry, som etim es called “fem tochem istry” , has thus emerged.
Superhigh-intensity optical fields generated by table-top fem tosecond terawatt excim er
and solid-state system s make it possible to extend the m ethods o f optical physics to nonlinear
electron physics and nonlinear quantum electrodynam ics. From the technological point o f
view, all these achievements were realized as a result o f the shortening o f time scales by
approxim ately three to four orders o f m agnitude. A s we m entioned in the Foreword, this
breakthrough was in the offing for 25 years: by the late 60s optical pulses with durations o f
tens o f picoseconds and powers up to 0.1—1 G W h ad been generated.
B efore con cluding this b ook , it is natural to discuss the following question: what are the
prospects for further com pression and increase in intensity o f an electrom agnetic radiation
flash? N o doubt, each new success achieved along this road promises dram atic developm ents
in optical physics, chemistry, biophysics, a nd technology. W ith the awareness that making
predictions is rather precarious, we venture to give a brief outline o f the nearest prospects.
In a certain sense, this limit has in fact been already obtained in the visible
range o f the optical spectrum. Indeed, Shank and co-w orkers1 obtained a 6-
fs transform-limited pulse under whose bell-shaped envelope only three optical
oscillations are contained. Bipolar infrared pulses produced by Auston et al.
by optica] rectification o f femtosecond laser pulses in a medium with quadratic
nonlinearity can also be regarded as ultimately short because their duration
equals only one optical oscillation period.
At the same time, it should be borne in mind that more or less symmetric
pulses at the optical carrier frequency are, generally speaking, by no means the
only type o f wave packet that can propagate in a material medium or in vacuum.
For example, in a strongly nonlinear medium and high-intensity optical field
generation o f optical shock waves is possible, with pulse rise times substantially
334 Conclusion
S u p e rin te n s e r a d ia tio n : fr o m te r a w a tt to p e ta w a tt p o w e rs
T A B L E l. Generation o f high-intensity
optical fields by fem tosecond laser systems
T Ws T W I T W I
(fs) ( j / c m 2) (fs) (J) (W /c m 2) (fs) (J) (W /c m 2)
*T h e best results for each param eter are presented; it should be n oted that in real experi
m ents it is difficult to obtain these values simultaneously.
336 Conciusion
To get a clear view o f the current situation in this area, one can refer to vari-
uos conference proceedings, special issues o f journals, and monographs (see, e.g.,
Refs. 9-13). Here we shall confine ourselves to a brief discussion o f the problems
closely related to the principal subject o f this book, that is, the physics and tech
nology o f generation and shaping o f high-power short radiation pulses. The fact is
that atoms, molecules, and plasma subjected to superintense optical fields prove
to be effective sources o f high-power short flashes o f x-ray and microwave radia
tion and shock waves. Th e character o f conventional nonlinear-optical transfor
mations o f frequency and angular spectra in a transparent medium is changing
dramatically. Pumping by high-power femtosecond laser pulses underlies the
physics and technology o f table-top x-ray lasers.
T o assess the importance o f modern femtosecond laser technology for the physics
o f the interaction o f radiation with matter, it is appropriate to recall some charac
teristic field values which define the role o f the fundamental interaction processes.
We shall express these values in terms of intensities in order to make comparison
with experimental values more convenient. O f special significance is
E a = 5 x 109 V /cm .
For E > E , the discrete structure o f the atomic levels does not show and the
linear and nonlinear optical responses o f the matter are determined by electronic
transitions in the continuous spectrum. This means that the nonlinear optics of
atoms and molecules is being replaced by nonlinear electron physics.
The intensity I{ inducing tunnel ionization o f atoms. At this intensity an
atom gets ionized by electron tunneling during a time interval of the order o f an
optical oscillation period. For w/u>a I 14, 15
*t = (“ K ) 2 'a
The avalanche break-down threshold Ihd in the gas is equal to (see Refs. 16
and 17)
7 ^ m e ; y a ( i + i / V oll) i iv cr
2 7 r e 2 r c o ll Tp N 0
E = E rei ..mojc/e
the energy o f electron oscillations becomes comparable with the electron rest
energy. Accordingly, the “relativistic” intensity
r 2 2 3 >a 2
JTrel = m lo c /4 x e
defines the boundary line o f the relativistic nonlinear optics o f the free electrons.
For frequencies corresponding to the visible range o f the optical spectrum, / re] «
1019 W /c m 2 .
formed near the target surface, and having a typical thickness o f 500 to 600 A
(depending on the depth to which the laser radiation penetrates into the target),
remains constant during the propagation o f the pulse. There are some estimates
indicating that the degree o f ionization caused by collisions grows so rapidly that
24 3
one can expect to obtain an electron density Ne o f about 10 cm . At the
considered intensities the fast and practically linear increase in energy o f the
electrons can raise the electron temperature up to 1 keV.
2S
These basic facts were first discovered by Falcone and Murnane , who
studied the femtosecond dynamics and kinetics o f the electron temperature and
demonstrated that femtosecond x-ray pulses can indeed be generated. Numerous
experiments on the excitation and diagnostics o f a dense femtosecond plasma in
semiconductor and metal targets conducted later 29-32 resulted in the discovery
o f previously unpredicted properties o f this novel state o f matter.
The parameters o f femtosecond laser plasma were experimentally evaluated by
measuring the target reflectance and absorptance at different excitation levels,
with energy flux density w varying from 1 to 10,000 J /c m , and by studying the
spectral and temporal characteristics o f the inherent x-radiation o f the plasma.
In Ref. 31 the optical reflectance o f a femtosecond plasma generated in a silicon
target is shown to increase with excitation level, reaching about 75% at w =
1 k J /cm . This fact agrees with calculated results based on the classical Drude
model o f the permittivity. It should be recalled that in a field o f nanosecond
pulses the reflectance o f the laser plasma diminishes with an increase o f the
excitation energy owing to the hydrodynam ic expansion o f the plasma.
Self-reflection and self-absorption o f high-power femtosecond pulses by alu
minum and copper targets were investigated in Refs. 30 and 32. The experi-
12 15 2
ments, which were carried out at intensities 10 - 1 0 W /c m , made it possible
to evaluate the electron temperature Tg , electron density Ne , and character
istic femtosecond plasma density gradients L . It was shown that L/X < 0.2
at I fa 1 P W /c m 2 , Te « 200 eV, and Ne/N^ fa 6-8, where N & is the atom
concentration. This implies that a plasma with large density gradients is gener
ated. The increase in intensity up to 1-10 P W /c m 2 leads to a fast growth of
the electron temperature and nonlinear mechanisms start to predominate in the
absorption and reflection o f laser radiation.
The properties o f femtosecond laser plasma listed above make it very promis
ing as a lasing medium for the new sources o f high-power short bursts o f x-
radiation, that is, picosecond and subpicosecond table-top x-ray lasers.
2
10 P W /c m . The duration o f the generated x-ray pulse was measured by means
o f a high-speed x-ray camera to be equal to about 1.5 ps. The x-radiation
spectrum extended to 1-keV energies. To reduce the target cooling time, one
33
can use thin films instead o f massive targets. In this case the pulse can be
shortened down to 500 fs.
The spectral and energy parameters o f ultrashort x-ray pulses obtained so far
have still not reached their ultimate values. The x-ray spectrum is noticeably
affected by the laser radiation wavelength chosen “to match” the target material.
Excimer femtosecond systems are preferably used to obtain x-ray pulses with
34 22 23 _3
energies o f about 1 keV. In a dense (10 - 10 cm ) femtosecond plasma
the electrons with energy about 1 keV are capable o f producing via bremsstrah-
lung bursts o f hard x-radiation o f extremely high intensity. According to the
data published in Refs. 35 and 36, the efficiency o f conversion o f laser radiation
into x-rays can be increased up to 10 and even 20%. In the visible and near
IR ranges, this efficiency can be improved by increasing the absorptivity o f the
periodically modulated surfaces (see also Sec. 1.9).
In assessing the prospects for x-ray pulse sources employing incoherent radia
tion from femtosecond laser plasma, one should take into account the exceptional
progress that has been achieved in the development o f optical devices in the soft r
37
x-ray range, primarily multilayer dielectric mirrors. The authors of Refs. 34
and 38 have shown that a subpicosecond source o f soft x-rays (A « 40-100 A ),
using the incoherent radiation o f a femtosecond laser plasma and equipped with
a spherical x-ray mirror, yielded intensities exceeding 1 T W /c m . Construction
o f such incoherent sources will clear the way for x-ray diagnostics o f transient
states and offer ample scope for the physics and technology o f the interaction o f
x-radiation with matter.
Laser plasma serves as the lasing medium for the most advanced current sys
tems; 40 in the well-known 208-A x-ray laser operating in the Lawrence Liv
ermore Laboratory 41 the medium is o f “collisional” type while in the shemes
discussed in Refs. 42 and 43 it is of “recombination” type.
In a collisional laser the upper levels become populated as a result of collisions
o f the ions with high-energy (1 .5 keV) electrons; laser plasma is produced at the
focus o f one channel in the powerful Nova-Novetta installation, which generates
nanosecond pulses with energies exceeding 100 kJ. In recent experiments with
x-ray recombination lasers Nd-glass systems generating high-energy nanosecond
pulses were utilized. In both types precise control o f the degree o f ionization and
the distribution o f electron energy is o f paramount importance.
In a femtosecond laser plasma the above mentioned parameters are controlled
44
in a natural way. M ultiphoton or tunnel ionization allows one to obtain a
practically cold laser plasma with very high degree o f ionization. To form the
required electron energy distribution, above-threshold ionization can be used.
These ideas underlie the design o f table-top x-ray lasers excited by solid-state or
excimer femtosecond laser systems.
342 Conclusion
TABLE 2 . P ic o - a n d fe m t o s e c o n d te c h n o lo g y : s ta t e -o f-t h e -a r t
Pulses Parameters
Parameters microwave optical incoherent acoustical o f acoustical
x-ray pulses
Power
(now) io 3 i o 13 io 2 3 ■106 Pressure
(W ) (W ) (W ) (bar)
(projected) io 9 i o 15 io 6 3 - 109
(W ) (W ) (W ) (bar)
Intensity
(now) io 6 i o 19 10s io 5 Pressure
(W /c m 2) (W /c m 2) (W /c m 2) (b a r/A ) gradient
(projected) i o 11 i o 24 i o 12 io 7
(W /c m 2) (W /c m 2) (W /c m 2) (b a r/A )
Bibliography
I n tr o d u c tio n
1. Proc. X llih All- Union Conf. on C oherent and N onlinear O ptics, M oscow , 1985.
2. Fem tosecond optical interactions, J. O p t. Soc. A m . B 2 (1985), No. 4.
3. Ultrafast P h en om en a I V (D . H, A u ston and K . B. Eisenthal, eds.), Springer, Berlin,
1984.
4. Ultrafast Ph en om en a V (G . R . Flem ing and A. E. Siegman, eds.), Springer, Berlin, 1986.
5. L aser optics of condensed m atter, Proc. USSR-USA S y m p Plenum Press, New York,
1988.
6. R . W . Hellworth, Control of flu orescen t pulsations, in Advances in Quantum Electronics
(J. R . Singer, ed.), Colum bia University Press, New York, 1961, p. 334; Giant optical
pulses from ruby, J. A pp l. Phys. 33 (1962), 828.
7. A . I. D e M aria, W . H. Glenn, M . J. Brienza, and M . E. M ack, P icosecond laser pulses,
P roc. IE E E 5 7 (1969), 2.
8. Ultrashort Optical Pulses (S. L. Shapiro, ed .), Springer, New York, 1977.
9. A . M . Prokhorov, To la ser’s tS -ih year jubilee, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 3.
10. N. G . B asov, Quantum E lectronics in the P,N . Lebedev Physical Institute. of thz Academy
o f Sciences o f the USSR, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 179.
11. B. Ya. Z e l’dovich and T . I. Kuznetsova, G eneration of ultrashort light pulses by means
o f laser, Sov. Phys. Usp. 15 (1972), 25,
12. P. G. K ryukov and V . S. Letokhov, Propagation of the light pulses in a resonantly
(absorbing) medium., Sov. Phys. Usp. 1 2 (1969), 641.
13. S. A . Akhm anov, V . A. Vysloukh, and A. S. Chirkin, Wave packets self-action in a
nonlinear medium and laser pulses generation, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 642.
14. I. Herrmann and B . W ilhelm i, Laser fu r Ultrakurze Lichiim pulse, Akademie, Berlin,
1984.
15. Y . R . Shen, Principles of Nonlinear O ptics, J. W iley and Sons, New York— London,
1984.
C h a p te r 1
46. S. V . V inogradova, A. E. Yekzhanov, and Yu. A. Pirogov, M oscow Univ. Phys. Bulletin
2 5 (1984), No. 3, 73.
47. K . P. Cheung and D . H. A uston, O pt. Lett. 10 (1985), 218.
48. C. Roychoudhuri, J. O pt. Soc. Am . 65 (1975), 1418.
49. V . S. B abayev, O. Denchev, A. G . Zhiglinsky, and V . V. Kuchinsky, O pt. Spektrosk. 54
. (1983), 337.
50. A . G . Zhiglinsky and V . V . Kuchinsky, Real Fabry-Perot In terferom eter, Mashinos-
troyeniye, Leningrad, 1983. (Russian)
51. E. M. D ianov and A . M . Prokhorov, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 116.
52. G . P, Agrawal and M . J. Potasek, O pt. Lett. 11 (1986), 318.
53. D . Anderson and M . J. Lisak, O pt. Lett. 11 (1986), 569.
54. D . Anderson and M . J. Lisak, Phys. R ev- A 35 (1987), 184.
55. S. N. Perepechko, Vestn. Akad. Nauk B S S R ., Fizm at. Ser. (1986), No. 2, 60.
56. D . M arcuse, Theory o f D ielectric Optical Waveguides, A cadem ic Press, New York —
London, 1974.
57. J. T . Manassah, A ppl. O pt. 25 (1986), 1737.
58. M . R . T op p and G . C. O raer, O pt. Com m un. 13 (1975), 276.
59. M . B ora and E. W olf, Principles o f O ptics, Pergam on Press, O xford, 1975.
60. W . Zhi-Jiang and Y . B en-Chi, R ev. R ou m . Phys. 31 (1986), 917.
61. M . Yam ashita, M . Ishikawa, K . Torizuka, and T . Sato, O pt. Lett. 11 (1986), 5 04.^
62. D. N . C hristodoulides, E. BourkofF, R . I. Joseph, and T . Simos, IEEE J. Quantum
Electron. Q E -2 2 (1986), 186.
63. Yu. A . Pirogov, Bull. A cad. Sci. USSR, Phys. Ser. 50 (19S6), No. 6, 138.
64. K . Stankov, Bulg. Phys. J. 12 (1985), 424.
65. O . E. M artinez, O pt. Com m un. 59 (1986), 229; J. O pt. Soc. Am . B 3 (1986), 939.
66. Jii. Kuhl and J. Heppner, IE E E J. Q uantum E lectron. Q E -2 2 (19S6), 182.
67. P. M . French, A . S. L. Gom es, A . S. G ouveia-N eto, and J. R. Taylor, O pt. Quantum
E lectron. 18 (1986), 171.
68. P. M . French, G. F. Chen, a nd W . Sibett, O pt. Com m un. 57 (1986), 263.
69. E. Berhabeu, C. R u bio, and L. L. Sanchez-Soto, J. O pt. 17 (1986), 59.
70. I. P. Christov, O pt. Q uantum E lectron. 17 (1985), 356.
71. B. E. A . Saleh and M. I. Irshid, O pt. Lett. 7 (1982), 342.
72. D. M arcuse, A ppl. O pt. 19 (1980), 1856; 2 0 (1981), 2969.
73. I. P. Christov, O pt. Quantum Electron. 17 (1985), 353.
74. I. P. Christov, O pt. A cta 33 (1986), 63.
75. V . I. Tatarskii, W ave Propagation in the Turbulent Atm osphere, Nauka, M oscow , 1967.
(Russian)
76. J. R . K err, P. J. T itterton , and C. M . Brow n, A ppl. O pt. 8 (1969), 2233.
77. A . Zardecki and W . G. Tam , A ppl. O pt. 19 (1980), 3782.
78. G . H. W atson, P. A . Fleury, and S. L. M cC all, Phys. R ev. Lett. 58 (1987), 945.
79. K . P. Bum eika, R . V . Danelyus, V . N. D obrygin, and A. S. Piskarskas, Litov. Fiz. Sbom ik
2 7 (1987), 96.
80. E. Varoquaux, G . A . W illiam s, and O. Avenel, Phys. Rev- B 3 4 (1986), 7617.
81. T . K obayashi, K . A m ano, T . Fujita et a l in Topical M eeting on UUrafast Phenom ena,
Techn. Digest, June 16-19, Snownass, C olorado, 1986.
82. L. Allen and J. H. Eberly, Optical R eson ance and Tw o-Level Atom s, W iley - Interscience,
New York, 1975.
83. M . J. Frankel and J. L. Birm an, Phys. R ev., A 15 (1977), 2000.
84. D. H. Auston, K . P. Cheung, J. A . Valdm anis, and D. A. Kleinman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 53
(1984), 1555.
85. P. W yns, D , P. Foty, and K . E. Oughstun, J. O pt. Soc. Am . A 6 (1989), 1421.
86. P. W yns, D. P. Foty, and K . E. O ughstun, J. O pt. Soc. Am . A 6 (1989), 1430.
87. F. V. Bunkin, G. A . Lyakhov, and N. V . Suyazov, O pt. Spektrosk. 68 (1990), 105.
88. C . Froely, B. C olom bean, a nd M . Vam pouille, in Progress in Optics X X (E. W olf, ed.),
N orth-H olland, Am sterdam , 1983, p . 65.
89. A . M . W einer, J. P. Heritage, and E. M . Kirschner, J. O pt. Soc. A m . B 5 (1988), 1563.
348 Bibliography
C h a p te r 2
C h a p te r 3
114. Ch. Fattinger and D. Grischkowsky, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62 (1989), 2961.
115. B. B. Hu, J. T . Darrow, X .-C . Zhang, and D. H. Auston, A pp l. Phys. Lett. 56 (1990),
886 .
116. J. T . Darrow, B. B . Hu, X .-C . Zhang, and D . H. Auston, O pt. Lett. 15 (1990), 323.
117. X .-C . Zhang, B. B. Hu, J. T . Darrow, and D . H. Auston, A pp l. Phys. Lett. 56 (1990),
1011.
118. H. Ham ster and R. W . Falcone, Preprint, Departm ent o f Physics, University, California
at Berkeley, 1990.
119. S. R uhm an, A . G. Joly, B. K ohler et al., Rev. Phys. A ppl. 22 (1987), 1717.
120. R . Leonhardt, W . Holzapfel, W , Zinth et ah, Rev. Phys. A ppl. 22 (1987), 1735.
121. H. T . G rahn, D . A . Young, H. J. Maris et aL, Appl. Phys. Lett. 53 (1988), 2023.
122. H. T . Grahn, H. J. Maris, J. Tauc, and K . S. H atton, A ppl. Phys, Lett. 53 (1988),
123. H. T . G rahn, H. J. Maris, J. Tauc, and B. Abeles, Phys. R ev. B 38 (1988), 6066.
124. B. M . Clemens and G. L, Eesley, Phys. R ev. Lett. 61 (1988), 2356.
125. H. T . G rahn, H. J. Maris, and J. Tauc, IE E E J. Quantum Electron. 25 (1989), 25
126. C .-D . Zhu, H. J. Maris, J. Tauc, in P honons 89, W orld Scientific, Singapore, 1990, p. 408.
127. V . E. Gusev, Phys. Status Solidi D 158 (1990), 367.
128. S. A . Akhm anov, V. E. Gusev, V . I. Pryalkin, and V. V . Tarasenko, I I I Int. Conf. on
Laser Scattering Spectroscopy and D iagnostics o f Biological Objects, Research Centre
“ Progress” , M oscow , 1990, Vol. 1, p. 29.
C h ap ter 4
28. J. P. Heritage, R. N. Thurston, W . J. Tom linson et a/., Appl. Phys. Lett. 47 (1985), 87.
29. S. A Akhm anov, V. A. Vysloukh, and A . S. Chirkin, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 642.
30. M . A . Vorontsov and V . L Shmalgausen, P rin ciples o f Adaptive Optics, Nauka, M oscow,
1985. (Russian)
31. A . M . Weiner, J.P. Heritage, and R. N. Thurston, O pt. Lett. 11 (1986), 153.
32. M . Haner and W . S. Warren, O pt. Lett. 12 (1987), 398.
33. D. Anderson and M . Lisak, Phys. R ev. A 27 (1983), 1393.
34. M . N . C ristodonlides and R. L. Josef, Electron. Lett. 20 (1984), 659.
35. V . A. V ysloukh and T . A. M atveyeva, Optim um Com pression o f Fem tosecond Optical
Pulses, Preprint, Physics Faculty, M oscow University, 1985, No. 24.
36. V. A . V ysloukh and T . A . M atveyeva, Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 16 (1986), 665.
37. V . A . Vysloukh and T . A . M atveyeva, Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 17 (1987), 498.
38. E. BourkofF et a l , O pt. Com m un. 12 (1987), 284.
39. J. M . H albout and D. Grischkowsky, A ppl. Phys. Lett. 45 (1984), 1281.
40. W . N. K nox, R . L. Fork, M . C. Downer et al.t A ppl. Phys. Lett. 46 (1985), 1120.
41. I. Thom azeau, J. Etchepare, G . G rillon et a/., O pt. Lett. 10 (1985), 223.
42. C. H. B rito-C ruz, R . L. Fork, and C. V . Shank, in Proc. Conf. on Laser and Elec
tro-O ptics!t Baltim ore, M aryland, 1987, p. 12.
43. A . Piskarkas, A. Stabinis, and A. Yankauskas, Sov. Phys. Usp. 29 (1986), 869.
44. P. Danelyus, A . Piskarkas, V. Sirutkaitis et al., JE T P Lett. 4 2 (1985), 122.
45. A . Piskarkas, A . Stabinis, and A . Yankauskas, Sov. J. Q uantum Electron. 15 (1985),
1179; 1539.
46. A . M . W einer and D . E. Leaird, O pt. Lett. 15 (1990), 51.
47. A . M . W einer, D. E. Leaird, J. S. Patel, and J. R. Wullert, O pt. Lett. 15, 326.
C h a p te r 5
C h a p te r 6
1. Ultrashort Optical Pulses (S. L. Shapiro, ed.), Springer, New York, 1977.
2. I. Heermann and B. W ilhelm i, Laser fu r ultrakurze Lichtim pulsen, Akademie, Berlin,
1984.
3. Optical P aram etric Oscillators and P icosecond Spectroscopy (A . Piskarskas, ed.), Mok-
slas, Vilnius, 1983. (Russian)
4. A . M . Valshin, V . M . Gordiyenko, S. V . Krayushkin et a/., Sov. J. Quantum Electron.
16 (1986), 1125.
5. D . Linde and A . M . Malvezzi, A ppl. Phys. B 37 (1985), 1.
6. T . Thom ie, Jap. J. A ppl. Phys. 24 (1985), 1008.
7. D . N. Dovchenko, V . A . Dyakov, V. I. K uznetsov, and V . I. Pryalkin, in X I I A ll-U nion
Conf. on Coherent and N onlinear O ptics, Abstracts, M oscow , 1985, p. 3.
8. G . I. Onishchukov, M . F. Stelmakh, and A. A . Fom ichev, Bull. A cad. Sci. USSR, Phys.
Ser. 50 (1986), No. 6, 72.
9. R. L. Fork, B . I. Green, and C. V . Shank, A ppl. Phys. Lett. 38 (1981), 197.
10. O. E. Martinez, R. L. Fork, find J. P. G ordon , O pt. Lett. 9 (1984), 156.
11. M . Yam ashita, K . Torizuka, T . Sato, and M . Ishikawa, in Ultrafast Phenom ena V
(G . R . Flem ing and A. E. Sigman, ed.), Springer, Berlin, 1986, p. 8.
12. J. Heppner and J. K uhl, A ppl. Phys. L ett. 4 7 (1985), 453.
13. J. A . Valdmanis, R . L. Fork, and J. P. G ordon , Opt. Lett. 10 (1985), 131.
14. J. C, Diels, W . Dietel, J. J. Fontaine et al., J. O pt. Soc. A m . B 2 (1986), 680.
15. F. Salin, P. Grangier, G . R oger, and A . Brim , in Ultrafast Phenom ena V (G . R . Fleming
and A, E. Sigman, eds.), Springer, Berlin, 1986, p. 20.
16. P. M, W . French and J. R , Taylor, ibid., p. 11.
17. J. D obler, H. M . Schulz, and W . Zrnth, O pt. Com m un. 5 7 (1986), 407.
18. W . Kaizer and A . Seilmeier, Infrared Phys. 25 (1985), 15.
19. V . A . Nekhayenko, S. M. Pershin, and A . A . Podshivalov, Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 16
(1986), 299.
20. D ye Lasers in Topics in Applied P h ysics, Vol. 1 (F. P. Schaffer, ed.), Springer, Berlin,
1973.
21. A . I. Kovrigin, V . A. Nekhayenko, S. M . Pershin et al., Sov. J. Q uantum Electron. 14
(1984), 1346.
22. A . M . Johnson and W . M . Sim pson, J. O p t. Soc. A m . B 2 (1985), 619.
23. A . M . Johnson and W . M . Simpson, IE E E J. Q uantum Electron. Q E -2 2 (1986), 133.
24. A . I. K ovrigin, V . A . Nekhayenko, S. M . Pershin et al., O pt. Q uantum Electron. 17
(1985), 95,
25. C. P. Ausschnitt and R . K . Jain, A ppl. Phys. Lett. 32 (1978), 727.
358 Bibliography
Conclusion
1. R . L. Fork, C . M . B rito-C ruz. P. C . Becker, and C. V . Shank, Com pression of optical
pulses to six fem tosecon d by using cubic phase com pensation, O pt. Lett. 12 (1987), 483.
2. J. T . D arrow , B. B. Hu, X . C. Zhang, and D . A uston, Subpicosecond electrom agnetic
pulses from large aperture photoconducting antennas, O pt. Lett. 15 (1990), 323.
3. S. A. Akhm anov, S. M . Gladkov, and N. I. K oroteev, N ew mechanism o f higher or
der optical harm onic generation in superstrong laser fields, in Superintense Laser-A tom
Physics, Digest o f Technical Papers, June 28-30, University o f Rochester, New York,
U SA , 1989.
4. X . F. Li, A . L ’Huillier, M. Ferray et a lM u ltip le -h a r m o n ic generation in rare gases at
high intensity, Phys. Rev. A 39 (1989), 5751.
5. F. Brunei, H arm onic generation due to plasma effects in a gas undergoing muliiphoton
ionization in the high intensity limit, J. O pt. Soc. A m . B 7 (1990), 521.
6. M . W atanabe, K. Hata, T . Adachi et a/., H igh-repetition-rate terawatt excim er laser
system with gated gain amplification, O pt. Lett. 15 (1990), 845.
7. M . D . Perry and F . G . Patterson, D esign and P erform an ce o f a Multiterawatt Subpi-
cosecond Neodim ium Glass L aser, Preprint, Lawrence Livermore Nat. Lab., 1990.
8. C. Sauteret, G. Mainfray and G, M ourou, Laser designers eye petawatt pow er, Laser
Focus W orld 26 (1990), 85.
9. Superintense Laser-A tom P h ysics, Digest o f Technical Papers, June 28-30, University o f
Rochester, New York, USA, 1989.
10. X Int. Vavilov Conf. on N onlinear Optics, Program , 31 May —4 June, 1990, Novosibirsk,
USSR.
11. X V I I Int. Quantum Electron, Conf., Technical Digest, 21—25 May, 1990, Anaheim , Cal
ifornia, USA.
12. A tom s in Intense Radiation Field (M . Gavrila, ed .), A cadem ic Press, 1990.
13. Theory o f high-order processes in atoms in intense laser fields. Special issue of J. O pt.
Soc. A m . B 7 (1990), No. 4.
14. L. V . Keldysh, Ionization in field of strong electrom agnetic wave, Sov. Phys. JE T P 47
(1964), 11.
15. F. V. Bunkm , A . E. Kazakov, and M . V. Fedorov, Interaction o f optical intense radiation
with free electrons, Sov. Phys. Usp. 15 (1972), 758.
16. Yu. P. Raiser, Laser Spark and Propagation o f D ischarges, Nauka, M oscow , 1974. (Rus
sian)
17. Y . R. Shen, The Principles of N onlinear O ptics, J. W iley and Sons, New York, 1984.
18. W . W o o d , G. Focht, T . Tzang et al., Blue shifting of intense fem tosecond pulses during
strong field ionization: a direct m easurem ent o f the Keldysh quiver energy, O pt. Lett.
13 (1988), 984.
19. P. Corkum , N . H. B urnett, and F. Brunei, Multiphot on ionization in large ponderm otive
potentials, in A tom s in Intense Radiation Field (M . Gavrila, ed.), A cadem ic Press, 1990.
20. D . Strikland and P. Corkum , G eneration and nonlinear interactions of high pow er 20-fs
pulses, in X V I I Int. Quantum Electron. Conf.f Technical Digest, Q T H l, M ay 21-25,
1990, A naheim , California, USA.
21. V . M . G ordienko, S. A . Akhm anov, M . S. D jid joev et al., Broadly tunable source of
superintense laser field, in S P IE ys Int. Symp. on High P ow er Lasers, L A S E ’ 91, Los
Angeles, U SA , 1991, p. 11.
22. S. Augst, D . Strickland, D . M eyerhofer et al., Tunneling ionization o f nobble gases in
high intensity laser field, Phys. Rev. Lett. 63 (1989), 2212.
Bibliography
23. C. Chen, Y . Wu, A . Jiang et al., N ew nonlinear-optical crystal: LiB 30 6 , J. O pt. Soc.
A m . B 6 (1989), 616.
24. V . A . D ’ yakov, M . K . D jafarov, A . A . Lukashev et a/., Laser radiation frequency con ver
sion in lithium triborate crystals, Sov. J. Q uantum Electron. 21 (1991), No. 3 (subm itted
for publication).
25. L aser Program A nnual R eports, 1986, 1987, Lawrence Livermore N at. Lab., USA.
26. S. M . G ladkov and N. I. K oroteev, Q uasi-resonant nonlinear optical processes with par
ticipation o f excited and ionized atom sy Sov. Phys. Usp. 33 (1990), No. 7.
27. S. A . A khm anov and A. V . Andreev, Electron in the interference field as an ideal sys
tem fo r nonlinear transform ations o f superintense laser pulses, O pt. Lett. 16 (1991)
(subm itted for publication).
28. R . W . Falcone and M . M . M um ane, Proposal fo r a fem tosecond x-ray source, in Short
W avelength Coherent R adiation: G eneration and Applications (D . T . A tw ood and J.
B okor, eds.), A IP , New York, U SA, 1986, Vol. 147.
29. O . L. Landen, E. Cam pbell, and M . Perry, X -ray characterisation o f picosecond laser
plasmas, O pt. Com m un. 63 (1987), 253.
30. H. M . M ilchberg, R . Freeman, S. Davey, and R. M ore, R esistivity o f a simple m etal from
room tem perature to 10 K , Phys. Rev. Lett. 61 (1988), 2364.
31. M . M um ane, H. C. K apteyn, and R . Falcone, High density plasmas produced by ultrafast
laser sources, Phys. R ev. Lett. 62 (1989), 155.
32. J. Kieffer, P. A udebert, M . Chaker et aL, Short pulse laser absorption in very steep
plasma density gradients, Phys. R ev. Lett. 62 (1989), 760.
33. H. Tom (private com m unications, 1989).
34. S. A . Akhm anov, I. M . Bayanov, V. M . G ordienko et al., X -ray picosecond pulses gen er
ation in a dense plasmas produced by pow erful picosecond laser pulses at 308 nm wave
length, Sov. J. Quantum Electron. 21 (1991), No. 3.
35. R . Falcone, H igh-density plasmas produced by ultrafast laser, in X Int. Vavilov Conf. on
N onlinear Optics, Program , 31 M ay — 4 June, 1990, Novosibirsk, USSR.
36. S. A. A khm anov, V. Ya. Panchenko, V. N. Sem inogov, and V . I. Sokolov, D ifraction
and absorption subpicosecond laser pulses at space-modulated surface, Sov. J. Quantum
Electron. 20 (1990), 1433.
37. V . L. A rtsim ovich, S. V . G aponov, Yu. S. K as’yanov et ai Form ation of directional
intense U V-radiation from laser plasma, Sov. Phys. J E T P Lett. 46 (1987), 311.
38. R . Freeman, Experim ental investigations o f high temperature plasmas and x-ray em ission
induced by subpicosecond laser pulses, in X V I I Int. Quantum Electron. Conf., Technical
Digest, Q T H B 3, M ay 21—25, Anaheim , California, USA, 1990.
39. M . M um ane, H. K apteyn, and R . Falcone, G eneration and application of ultrafast x-ray
sources, IEEE J. Quantum Electron. 25 (1989), 2417.
40. M . A . Duguay and P. M . Rentzepis, Som e approaches to vacuum UV and x-ray lasers,
A pp l. Phys. Lett. 10 (1967), 350.
41. D . L. M atthew s, P. L. Hagelstein, M . D . Rosen et al, D em onstration o f a soft x-ray
amplifier, Phys. R ev. Lett. 5 4 (1985), 110.
42. L. I. G udzenko and L. A . Shelepin, Am plification in recombinating plasma, Sov. Phys.
Dokl. 10 (1965), 147.
43. S. Suckewer and C. Skinner, Soft x-ray lasers and their applications, Science 2 4 7 (1990),
1553.
44. P. B. Corkum and N. H. Burnett, M ultiphoton ionization f o r the production of x-ray
laser plasmas, in Conf. on Short W avelength Coherent Radiation: G eneration and A p
plications, C ape C ode, M A , USA, Sept. 1990.
45. M . Perry, E. Cam pbell, J. T . Hunt et a lU ltr a -h ig h brightness ( > 1021 W / c n ?) laser
facility, Lawrence Livermore Nat. Lab., M em orandum , 1988.
46. P. Eisenberger and S. M cCall, X -ra y param etric conversion, Phys. R ev. Lett. 26 (1971),
684.
47. L. D a Silva, M . M uendel, R. Falcone et al., N onlinear optics with focused x-ray lasers,
in Proc. 2nd Intern. Colluquium x-ray Lasers', York University, York, Sept. 17-21, 1990.
48. S. A . A khm anov, Proposals fo r nonlinear x-ray optic, (in press).
Index
aberration coherence
phase 220 spatial 65
tem poral 28, 53
tem poral 65
absorbtion 83 color-center laser 234, 246
nonlinear 85 com plex amplitude 27
acoustic pulse 191 com plex index o f refraction 85
acoustic specroscopy 191 com pression 28
active m od e locking 282 fem tosecond pulse 221, 306
adaptive optics 221 noise pulse 213
am plification com pression length 31, 64
param etric 224
com pression ratio 28, 33, 256
Ram an 240
compressor
amplifier
grating 205, 219
dye 307
prism 207, 219
exim er 312
correlation
neodym ium -glass 311
spatial 65
am plitude
tem poral 65
com plex 27
correlation time 63
am plitude fluctuation 262
correlator 322
anom alous dispersion 13, 62, 204
critical power 103, 204, 228
approxim ation
cross-phase m odulation (X P M ) 307
aberration-free 105
cu bic dispersion 23
fixed-channel 123
cubic nonlinearity 85
fixed-field 140, 168, 173
fixed-intensity 143 dare soliton 115, 223
first order o f dispersion theory 140t 150, 156 difference-frequency 158, 160
second order o f dispersion theory 148, 167 diffraction
third order o f dispersion theory 23 Fraunhofer 26
grating 48
biharm onic pum ping 177
transient 51
bipolar pulse 160, 333
diffraction length 22, 57
B loch equation 116
dispersion
bright soliton 233
anomalous 13, 62, 204
Brillouin precursor 19
cu bic 23
C A R S spectroscopy 176 group-velocity 20
Cherenkov radiation 46, 160 interferometer 53
chirp normal 13, 62
o f nonlinearity 241
linear 16, 50
3t>4 Index
m od e locking precursor
active 282 Brillouin 19
h ybrid 293 Sommerfeld 18
passive 285 prism com pressor 207
m odulation pulse
cross-phase (X P M ) 307 acoustic 191
frequency 21, 154 bipolar 160, 333
phase 21 focusing 55
random 262 Gaussian 16
self-phase (S P M ) 87, 203, 208 giant 147, 152
m odulational instability 121, 123 noise 17, 62, 214
m otion integral 232 phase-m odulated (P M ) 16
m ultiple-layer dielectric m irror 46 super-Gaussian 16, 34, 231
m ultiple-tim e responce fu n ction 84 transform-limited 15
pulse duration measurement 326
near-field zone 22 pulse shape control 218, 220
neodym ium -glass amplifier 311 pulse shape reversed 37
noise pulse 17, 62, 214 pum ping wave 151
noise pulse com pression 213
nonlinear absorption 85 Q-switched laser 283
nonlinear index o f refraction 83 quasy-steady-state responce 85
nonlinear length 114 quasy-steady-state self-focusing 90
nonlinear polarization 84 quantum pulse 66, 127
nonlinear Schrodinger equation (N LS) 113, 229
n onlinear susceptibility 84 R abi frequency 117
n onlinear x-ray optics 342 Ram an gain 169
n orm al dispersion 13t 62 Ram an soliton laser 249
Ram an soliton 172
operator random m odulation 64, 123, 260
p h o to n annihilation 67 refraction
ph oton creation 67 index o f 59
optica l com pressor 298 com plex 85
optica l detection nonlinear 83
optica l filtering 42 resonant soliton 113, 115
optica l losses 239 responce
optica l sam pling oscilloscope 186 quasi-steady-state 84
optica l soliton 227 nonlinear 84
transient m olecular 173
param etric am plification 151 responce function 85
param etric generation 296 root-m ean-square duration 15
param etric interaction 150
param etric oscillator 297 scattering
param etric soliton stimulated Ram an (SRS) 165
paraxial approxim ation 103 second harmonic generation 139, 322
passive m o d e lockin g 285 self-action 87
phase 15 self-action o f random pulses 123
phase fluctuation 262 self-compression 87, 114, 236
phase m atching 159 self-focusing 87, 102
phase measurem ent 326 quasi-steady-state 103
phase m od u lation 21 transient 106
phase m od u la ted pulse 16 self-indused transparency 117
ph oton annihilation operator 128 self-phase m odulation (SP M ) 87, 203, 208
ph oton creation operator 128 self-phase m odulation length 93
polarisation self-steepening 98
nonlinear 84 shock wave 98
transient 191 signal wave 151
p ositional m ethod 267 single-m ode fiber 59
366 Index
slowly varying am plitude (SV A ) 12 w alk-of length 140, 153, 156, 167
soliton 113 wave
bright 233 idler 151
dark 233 pum ping 131
optical 227 signal 151
param etric 157 Stokes 176
Ram an 172 wave packet 11
resonant 113, 115 wave transience 149
Schrodinger 113 waveguide 59
soliton interaction 244 waveguide dispersion 62
soliton laser 246 W o o d anom aly 72, 74
soliton statistics 258
Som m erfeld precursor 18
sound generation 191
spatial coherence 65
spatial correlation fu n ction 65
spatial-tem poral analogy 14
spectral broadening 96, 100, 108, 204
spectral contonuum 102, 110
spectral w idth 15
spectrochronography 176, 180
spectron 37
spectroscopy
acou stic 191
C A R S 176
steady-state 177
transient 178, 183, 189
spectrum reconstruction 189
squeezed light 129
squeezing 129
steady-state spectroscopy 177
stim ulated Ram an scattering (SR S) 165
Stokes wave 176
slim frequency 156
super-G aussian pulse 16, 34, 231
superlntense radiation 334
superbroadening 108
susceptibility 85
synchronously-pum ped laser 286
waist 58