Professional Documents
Culture Documents
7163/
GPol.2014.28
May 2014 July 2014
Geographia Polonica
Volume 87, Issue 3, pp. 409-421
http://dx.doi.org/10.7163/GPol.2014.28
Abstract
This paper presents the evolution of research paradigms in geography related to the study of relationships
between humans, environment and place, and their tenacious role in functional and spatial analyses of the en-
vironmental megasystem. The author describes ontological, epistemological as well as axiological dimensions
of interdependencies between humans, environment, and place, understood as space in which the integration
of nature and culture takes place, influencing, among other things, human behavior and generation of the
quality of human living conditions. Surveys conducted among the inhabitants of the environs of Warsaw re-
vealed how different the perception and valuation of environmental issues is depending on space of place, its
structure, and function. The author also emphasized the potential of environment as a value, which presently,
in connection with the quality of human life, is perceived in the category of supply and demand.
Key words
relationship • environment • space • place • paradigm • Warsaw Metropolitan Area
at undertaking and solving the issues connect- and environment, as it is a crucial attribute
ed with the nature of world and human (Lam- of human existence in the geographical envi-
bin 2005; Maik 2006). Geography is undoubt- ronment, which also constitutes an inherent ele-
edly one of multiple scientific disciplines, the ment of cognition. Deep psychological and emo-
research scope of which includes the study tional bonds occur between humans and their
of the interactional relationship of natural and homes (Tuan 1977: 45). According to the same
anthropogenic systems, and which will con- author, geographers did not take enough inter-
tinue to treat the study of these relationships est in this human commitment to place and its
as its proper and specific research subject. perception, analyzing mainly the abstract, geo-
As science develops, together with geography metrical and subjective notion of space (Tuan
as one of its disciplines, theoretical and method- 1974: 132). Such a state of affairs is caused
ological progress will also take place and new by, among other things, a widespread belief
theoretical models will be elaborated which, among geographers that space constitutes the
through empirical verification, will be adopted basic subject of their research and relationships
as applicable solutions. They will be used for occurring between subsequent spatial compo-
the assessment and/or prediction of the course nents are an inherent mechanism of cognition.
of natural, as well as anthropogenic, processes In the search for new research paradigms,
and phenomena, and their interactional inter- or while performing constructive revision
dependencies occurring in the megasystem of the existing concepts and theories consti-
of the geographical environment. The evolution tuting the foundations of geography, it is nec-
of the scope of research in its objective aspect essary to adopt the perspective of a human-
will also take place, caused by the emergence environment-place relationship. On one hand,
of new objects and phenomena of both physi- it becomes possible to assess dynamics of inter-
cal as well as socio-economical origin. actional interdependencies between socio-eco-
The issues connected with the human-envi- nomic process and natural factors that deter-
ronment relationship have thus been, and are mine them, or vice versa (anthropogenic impact
now among, the basic questions related to the on the environment), as well as to identify the
knowledge of our earthly existence in the onto- actions that optimize the functioning of the
logical, epistemological as well as axiologi- geographical environment megasystem on dif-
cal sense (Degórski 2006). These issues were ferent levels of spatial organization. On the
also of major importance for the development other hand, it enables the shaping of the
of geographical thought, being since the end human-place relationship, in both an ontologi-
of the 19th century, the cognitive foundation cal as well as a noospheric sphere.
accumulating fundamental empirical potential The aim of the paper is to determine the
(Maik 2006; Giuliani & Scopelliti 2009). In the role of geography as a scientific discipline
attempt to define their scientific discipline, in the study of human-environment interac-
geographers have also referred and refer now tion in the space of place as well as to define
to the relationship between humans and the the research paradigm enabling the research
environment. In Poland, Pulinowa (1996), based on these mutual relationships in contempo-
on the performed analysis of defining geogra- rary ontological and axiological conditions.
phy as a scientific discipline, pointed out that
in the last century of the second millennium, Geographical research
the most frequently repeating object of geo- and intersubjective paradigm
graphical cognition referred to interdependen- in the study of space of place
cies between humans and the environment.
Irrespective of the evolution of research par- The specific character of geographical research
adigms, the nature of place will still be present results from two research approaches connect-
in geographical studies aiming at understand- ed with the overall analysis of the geographical
ing the relationships occurring between human environment megasystem. The first approach,
according to the theory of Wilson (1998), to date, and states that a comprehensive
is based on the consilience of knowledge about approach towards the functioning of geo-
the structure and functioning of the geographi- graphical environment megasystem is an
cal environment megasystem through the inherent characteristic of geographical stud-
synthesis of a consistent set of information ies. However, other disciplines refer to the
about subsequent systems and subsystems. specificity of their subjects and methodolo-
The second approach is holistic and according gies and study subsequent components of the
to it, the phenomena create a comprehensive environment or gather information in the con-
system and reasoning is based on information text of the functioning of one of the systems
concerning the entire system and not on the of the geographical environment megasys-
rules governing its components. tem, being the natural environment or socio-
In this research context, the megasystem economic system.
of geographical environment can be defined The next characteristic of geographi-
as a comprehensive hierarchical system con- cal research, predisposing it to the studies
sisting of lower order systems (natural envi- of human-environment relationships, is the
ronment and socio-economic environment), application of different scales in spatial analy-
subject to evolution resulting in the emer- sis (so called multiscaling), enabling the gen-
gence of a new quality comprehensive system eralization of results from a local to global
(evolution or degradation of the megasys- scale and vice versa; the creation of local
tem of the geographical environment). This solutions based on phenomena and pro-
dualism is characteristic of geography, and cesses occurring on a global scale. It mainly
it is expressed in the study of the geographical concerns the functional analysis of each
megasystem, including the natural and socio- of the systems forming the geographical envi-
economic environment systems too, as well ronment megasystem as well as its entirety,
as the interactional relationships between and it refers to the concept of space of place
them. This constitutes a research approach, and space of flows developed in recent years
which makes it possible to create its overall and resulting from the theory of matter and
image and allow for studies on the human- energy flow in space (Brunn & Leinbach 1991;
environment relationship. The comprehensive Sassen 1991; Castells, 1996).
character of geographical studies had been The geographical environment, due to its
pointed out already when the methodologi- specific character, shaped by the indefinite
cal foundations of modern geography were number of processes, phenomena and objects
being formulated. For instance, in the middle which undergo constant evolution or emerge
of the 19th century, Galton (1855: 107) had and disappear spontaneously in space, con-
written in his work determining the founda- stitutes an empirically open research subject
tions of modern geography: “Geography (Degórski 2006). As a result, geography pos-
as a scientific discipline broadens the per- sesses an empirically open research subject,
ception of reality in a peculiar way. It accu- which undoubtedly constitutes another rea-
mulates the dispersed knowledge of other son predisposing it to complex spatial stud-
disciplines, assigning to them the meaning ies, including the studies assessing mutual
they lacked while taking them into account relationships between humans and the envi-
separately”. This statement has not become ronment, which results in new processes, phe-
outdated as it still emphasizes the specificity nomena and objects occurring in space.
of geographical research in the context of its The abovementioned space of place, which
consiliential and holistic character. Despite is above all a sociological and philosophical
the fact that 150 years have passed, its theo- category, is part of the human-environment
retical as well as pragmatic meaning is very system. Empirical notion of place is difficult
clear and thus verifiable. It makes it possi- to be defined mainly due to its complex-
ble to emphasize the thesis, which is still up ity (Relph 1976). Although places are usually
characterized by a defined location and per- Degórski 2003), in particular in the creation
manent identifiable features, the notion of natural and cultural identity, and the gen-
of place does not result from its location, func- eration of factors of socio-economic develop-
tion, or the community residing in the place ment (Barkers 2003; Degórski 2003, 2008;
or else from artificial or conscious experienc- Lambin 2005; Meyer & Degórski 2007; Sed-
es. The notion of place is much deeper and lacek & Gaube 2010). Researchers are taking
it can be discovered through examining the into account the potential of the natural envi-
intentions underlying human behavior (Relph ronment and its significant role in the shap-
1976). Place implies the location and integra- ing of conditions of human health and quality
tion of nature and culture (Walmsley & Lewis of life. Together with social wellbeing and high
1984), being at the same time an important psychological standards (Gawor & Głębocka
element for every human being. People often 2008), they determine individual behavioral
identify with the place emotionally and its attitudes in the context of space of place.
perception is highly influenced by the relation-
ships occurring between natural and social Cognitive behaviorism
systems. According to some researchers, in determining the relationship
geographers have attached too much impor- between human and environment
tance to natural and social environments
as a determinant of human existence, which Humans, since their appearance on Earth,
is rather beyond human will. In the analyses had been developing in harmony with nature,
of human-environment-place relationships, which had already been stated by Alexander
experience is a more important research sub- Humboldt in his treatise Kosmos. Nature
ject, as it makes it possible to understand how had been human shelter, a source of alimen-
human feelings and thoughts are linked with tation, as well as a working and living envi-
events and places (Gibson 1978). ronment (Redman 1999; Degórski 2007).
In recent years, geographical research Depending on cultural differences, the com-
has experienced an important development ponents of nature had often been perceived
of the paradigm of an intersubjective study as sacrum, treated with due humility and rev-
of the environmental megasystem. In physi- erence. For a human being, the natural envi-
cal geography, such an approach is reflected ronment had thus been important from the
in moving away from the studies of objec- ontological, epistemological as well as sacral
tively existing landscape towards the study point of view. However, together with civili-
of the environment of a certain subject, and zational development, the functions of the
especially the living environment of peo- natural environment were re-evaluated in the
ple and communities (Ostaszewska 2002). context of social life. Humans, by creating
This approach is similar to the paradigm their own anthropogenic system, concentrat-
of human geography, where environment ed on bringing it to perfection, whereas the
is perceived from the perspective of people system of natural environment was treated
and communities, thus being burdened with as its more and more distant surrounding.
the lack of verifiability (intersubjectivism). The The natural hierarchy of values, resulting from
‘environmental’ option in physical geography inherent, inborn and instinctively perceived
adopts similar assumptions, creating new existential conditions, was undergoing a grad-
opportunities of methodological rapproche- ual evolution, heading towards the deprecia-
ment between physical and socio-economic tion of importance of the natural environment
geography. in the life of individuals as well as entire socie-
In such a perception of reality, man is not ties. Nihilistic attitudes, more and more fre-
only a passive observer of his geographical quently adapting to reality, created the image
environment, but also a subject, taking an of homo sapiens as the conqueror of nature,
active part in its shaping (Buttimer 1996; able to transform and adapt the environment
in Warsaw agglomeration
Spatial development of urbanized areas and
increased civil pressure, as well as a rise
in the level of education (particularly in the
field of ecology) means that in Poland, we can
observe an increasing sensitivity of people
development of civilization
towards the values of the natural environ-
Figure 1. The relationship between civilizational ment. In addition, we also see an increased
development of societies and their environmental sensitivity to the natural environment’s role
awareness in the development of social-behavioral
attitudes that are connected with the assess- relaxation. One of the numerous questions
ment of the surrounding world – in particu- connected with the perception of environment
lar, the perception of place. This thesis can concerned the assessment by local communi-
be proved by looking at the very interesting ty of the influence of natural conditions on the
results of the studies on space of place in the attractiveness of their space of place. The
context of human perception of issues con- highest number of positive responses (91%)
nected with environmental resources, per- to the question formulated in this way was
formed based on a pilot survey conducted recorded in Otwock, a town with an important
in the Masovian Voivodeship (Central Poland) spa potential, benefiting from its location rent
on a sample of 2000 respondents. The author in an attractive forest complex. All respond-
presented preliminary results concerning one ents (irrespective of such criteria as age, edu-
of the communes and the research method- cation, sex) stated that natural values of the
ology in his earlier paper (Degórski 2008b). Masovian Landscape Park bordering the
However, new facts described in the work town increase its attractiveness as a place
of Degórska (2012) encouraged the author of residence; as many as 98% of the respond-
to extend the scope of research and take into ents saw the natural values of the town
account communes located in the zone char- as a chance for a positive influence on its eco-
acterized by the strongest settlement pressure nomic development. They claim that, apart
in the Warsaw metropolitan zone. The towns from their personal positive perception of the
chosen for the purposes of the survey were influence of the quality of environment on the
located 20-40 kilometers from Warsaw, but standard of living in their space of place, nat-
within its metropolitan area; Otwock located ural values may also result in an important
ca. 25 km southeast from the center of War- improvement. This improvement is in the form
saw, Dębe Wielkie located 30 km east from of the town’s financial condition, through an
the center of Warsaw, Mińsk Mazowiecki ca. increase in its attractiveness for the loca-
40 km in the same direction, and Piaseczno, tion of enterprises and services connected
located ca. 20 km south from the center with the broadly understood medical sector,
of Warsaw (Fig. 2). as well as in the development of the spa and
The towns and villages are located in the touristic function of the town and region. The
zone of influence of the capital city and are inhabitants of Otwock also emphasized the
all characterized by important residential and importance of implementing the rules of sus-
recreational function. Space of place is per- tainable development in the town’s expansion
ceived by the inhabitants as a hedonistic val- and functioning.
ue, which ensures the highest living standard, Environmental issues in the space of place
i.e. good accommodation conditions, rest and are perceived in a slightly different way by the
Figure 2. Location of the studied towns and communes of the Warsaw Metropolitan Area
local community of Dębe Wielkie (a rural com- of the natural environment as good (as many
mune). According to the inhabitants, the most as 41% of respondents) and average (34%
important factor connected with the optimiza- of respondents). For 11% of respondents, the
tion of the standard of living is the improve- condition of green areas was very good, while
ment of the condition of technical infrastruc- for 8% bad and for 6% very bad. The inhab-
ture, and in particular the quality of water. itants of Piaseczno express the most critical
Very interesting results were also obtained approach towards the condition of green
in the survey in connection with the attitude areas, as for 41% of respondents, the cur-
of local the community towards green areas rent condition of the natural environment
as an integral part of green infrastructure; is average, for 31% bad and for 15% very bad
53% of respondents assessed their condition (Fig. 3). In the zone located in the near vicinity
as satisfactory, 27% as good and very good of Warsaw (zone B), according to the major-
and only 15% as bad and very bad. ity of respondents, the condition of the natu-
Similar results connected with the main- ral environment in their place of residence
tenance of green areas were obtained in the is average (36% of respondents) and good
Piaseczno commune. The inhabitants, when (31% of respondents).
asked how they assess the condition of the Another problem connected with the
natural environment – including the condi- perception of space of place in the context
tion of forests, parks, roadside wooded are- of the human-environment relationship is the
as and green areas in residential districts sanitary condition of the environment and its
– expressed a positive opinion in the major- influence on the health of the population. An
ity of analytical units reflecting the division important factor in the perception of space
of Piaseczno into research zones. The most of place is thus constituted by human aware-
satisfactory results were obtained in the zone ness of the occurrence of natural, as well
of agricultural lands (D), where the major- as anthropogenic, risks in the system of the
ity of respondents assessed the condition geographical environment that may pose
a threat to human health and safety. It is the
most serious problem in the context of the
45 functioning of the natural environment for
40
over 80% of respondents. For instance, accord-
ing to the analysis of results of questionnaires
35
conducted in Piaseczno, divided into research
30 zones according to their location, the domi-
25 nating function of land use as well as employ-
20 ment structure, different points of view of the
local community can be presented in connec-
15
tion with the subject of research, which results
10 also from a different scale of influence of sub-
5 sequent hazards (Fig. 4).
0 Questions presented to the respond-
very good good average bad very bad ents were multiple-choice, with a possibility
A B C D to choose from one to three answers. Accord-
Figure 3. Respondents’ assessment of the ing to the inhabitants of the urban (Piasec-
condition of environment in analytical zones zno), and suburban areas (between Warsaw
of Piaseczno commune and Piaseczno), the quality of water consti-
(A – the town of Piaseczno, B – areas adjacent tuted a major health hazard. This risk is put
to Warsaw, C – areas where agricultural function in the first place by nearly 46% of respond-
prevails, D – agricultural lands located furthest ents in the town of Piaseczno and nearly 40%
from Warsaw) in its suburban area (zone B), while in the
0 20 40 60 80 100
Figure 4. Main health hazards in the social perception of subsequent research zones of Piaseczno
commune in the context of quality of natural environment
(A – the town of Piaseczno, B – areas adjacent to Warsaw, C – areas where agricultural function prevails,
D – agricultural lands located furthest from Warsaw)
remaining two zones, being mainly agricul- Nevertheless, it has to be said that the per-
tural lands characterized by their own water centage of respondents describing this influ-
intakes, the percentage drops below 20% ence as very significant and significant did
of respondents (Fig. 4). For local communities, not exceed 50% in each research location,
the problem of waste landfills located in their which results partly from the level of educa-
surroundings is perceived in a different way. tion, but is also caused by social policy of local
In agricultural areas (zones C and D), the authorities, often excessively concentrated
perception of this hazard as the most signifi- on economic development without taking into
cant for inhabitants’ health is the most visible. account environmental factors.
In the area located in close proximity to Cho-
jnowski Landscape Park, ca. 89% of respond-
Environmental potential paradigm
ents perceived it as the most significant for
their health, while in the second zone where The evolution of attitudes of societies of vari-
agricultural function prevails (zone D), the ous states towards the role of the natural
percentage reached over 77% of respond- and cultural environment in the functioning
ents. In urban and suburban areas, less that of socio-economic system results in the fact
40% of respondents assessed this factor that the improvement of the quality of life
in their questionnaires as important for their is no longer perceived as caused exclu-
health. Road noise and air pollution (Fig. 4) sively by economic and social development.
were other important health hazards pointed For them, it is also caused by the optimiza-
out by inhabitants of the urbanized area. tion of the use of the natural environmental
In all locations studied according to the potential and management of its resources
space of place, local communities referred (Dupont et al. 1998; Gunderson & Holling
to the positive influence of sustainable devel- 2002; Berbeka 2005; Murphy 2006). The
opment solutions on their quality of life. potential of the natural environment is usually
understood as all environmental values and a temporary state of social and economic
resources creating the natural system’s capa- equilibrium. This state can stabilize or under-
bility to satisfy broadly understood (physical go further development processes under
and psychological) human needs, present the influence of endogenous and exogenous
as well as future, together with self-regulatory factors. Attractors, being the equilibrium
and immune mechanisms maintaining this points attracting each trajectory of a given
capability in the environment. dynamic system constitute, thanks to the non-
In geographical studies, a lot of attention linearity of social and natural relationships,
is devoted to the potential of the environment a factor, which in specific conditions creates
(analyzed in various spatial scales, from local the systems characterized by metastability
to supraregional), its broadly understood (Domański 2008; Liu et al. 2009; Degórski
resources, including landscape and cultural 2013). In the search of development attrac-
values, as well as functional links with other tors created by the environmental potential,
components of the geographical megasystem artificial neural networks, so called multilayer
(Lagendijk & Cornford 2000; Degórski 2012). perceptrons, can be used as a modern tool
The environment is also perceived as a factor enabling the performance of multifactorial
capable of generating development trajecto- analysis of data characteristic for environ-
ries, which, because of their concentration, mental resources and quantified landscape
create attraction points, i.e. attractors, having values. Artificial neural networks are used
their attraction area, called basin of attraction, with success in different scientific disciplines.
deciding among others about the so-called They enable an unrestricted creation of mod-
stickiness of the place. According to general els of linear, as well as nonlinear, functions
system theory by von Bertalanffy (1973), an as well as control the complex issue of multidi-
attractor is the area or point in a certain mensionality which, when other methods are
space of states at which the system aims applied, considerably hinders the attempts
and around which the system remains at an to model nonlinear functions (in particular the
unrestricted time scale, subject to the evolu- functions with an important number of inde-
tion of chaotic systems. The system is con- pendent variables, so called vector functions).
sidered chaotic when in its state space map, The potential of the natural environment
saddle points, homoclinic intersection points can thus be treated as one of the most sig-
(intersection of the inflow and outflow of the nificant subjects of geographical research,
same trajectory) and heterocyclic intersection the study of which creates the possibilities
points (intersection of the inflow and outflow of identifying development directions for
of different trajectories) are observed. Due a given space of place. In such a case, the
to the presented features of the course of the research scope is often wider that the inter-
development trajectory, the values of the nat- ests of geographers, which results from the
ural environment do not always decide about synergic influence of different development
the attractiveness of a given place with equal factors of psychological and mental origin.
force. As it is commonly known, even slight Another key element in the research proce-
initial differences in environmental potential dure for the environmental potential paradigm
may result in a radically different outcome is constituted by an attempt to assess its val-
and, furthermore, the course of develop- ue in the context of supply and demand. Eco-
ment trajectories is highly influenced by the system services are increasingly used for this
interacting economic and social background purpose. Ecosystem services are understood
of the natural environment system. This fea- as nature components, which are directly con-
ture of each place in space is also responsi- sumed, perceived or used to increase human
ble for the drainage of human and economic wellbeing (Boydem & Banzhafem 2007). The
capital from the external system, and then service is thus the ‘final product’ of the ecosys-
for its anchoring (holding), enabling to obtain tem and not a natural process in the course
of which it is created. In this way, it is possi- of these studies for a better understanding
ble to measure a given service and perform of the functioning of the geographical envi-
its economic valuation. The abovementioned ronment megasystem, in particular in the
functions cannot thus be treated automati- context of human perception and actions con-
cally as ecosystem services, as there is a cer- ditioned by environmental potential for the
tain chain of interdependencies between the improvement of the quality of life. This very
ecosystem and human wellbeing, where the old geographical research direction remains
service constitutes a ‘bridge’ (de Groot et al. up to date and generates new research meth-
2010). The notion of ecosystem services is, ods, sets of concepts, empirical models and,
in general terms, defined as a set of eco- finally, it may lead to the formulation of theo-
system products and functions (e.g. water ries creating the basis of a new geographi-
and air purification, production of oxygen, cal research paradigm. Detailed theories and
recreation) that a person/community ben- notions of environmental potential paradigm
efits from (Costanza et al. 1997). According will thus be embedded with experimental
to their functions and effects, services offered (historical) data, which is now being verified.
by nature are divided into the following cat- This research approach is, and will continue
egories: provisioning services, regulating to be, in close correlation with the intersubjec-
services, supporting services and cultural ser- tive research paradigm of the space of place,
vices (TEEB 2008). The integration, study and perceived individually and not subject to sci-
understanding of these four types of benefits entific verification processes. It is also neces-
in the concept of ecosystem services is now sary to emphasize that correct identification
among the greatest challenges for specialists of the discussed interdependencies is cru-
in various scientific disciplines, managerial cial for determining development directions
staff, policymakers as well as the entire soci- for subsequent units of geographical space
ety (Sutherland et al. 2006, 2009; Burkhard and optimizing living conditions (Connelly &
et al. 2010). Even if the notion of ecosystem Richardson 2004). The 2011 Human Devel-
services was already formulated in the sec- opment Report argues that “(…) bad environ-
ond half of the 1990s (Costanza et al. 1997), ment and bad health are two overlapping
genuine development of this scientific branch deficiencies, very strongly correlated with
has only recently occurred (Lenda et al. 2010). each other”. Geographers should thus make
It is also emphasized that some of them are every effort possible to increase human liv-
difficult to be observed (Vejre et al. 2010) and ing standards. In this way, the space of place
are defined as a hidden value. of every human will become unique in both
a noological as well as an ontological sense.
Conclusion
Editors’ note:
The essence of research on the relationship Unless otherwise stated, the sources of tables and
of human-environment-space of place present- figures are the author(s), on the basis of their own
ed in the paper demonstrated the importance research.