What phase of the innovation process are we in ?

Prototyping Compass
TRL

Role HMP

Describe the prototyping Objective:

Describe the prototyping Setup:

Prototype assesment by author

Prototype assesment by reviewer
Prototyping Compass
Prototyping objective
Primary Tips
Technical Validation TRL
HMP
Role

Prototyping Author assesment

TRL

Role HMP

Prototyping objective definition

Evaluating the Look and Feel (HMP) Evaluating the Role

Variety Physical 2 Context
Complexity Sub-system 2 Target Audience
Fidelity Realistic 3 Interaction

Score: 2.5 Score:

Prototyping Reviewer assesment
Evaluating the Look and Feel Evaluating the Role
Variety None 0.4 Context
Complexity Product 3 Target Audience
Fidelity Form 1 Interaction

Score: 0.5 Score:

 Target Score
TRL 4
HMP 1.5
Role 1

ent Prototyping Reviewer

assesment
TRL

HMP Role HMP

Photo

Evaluating the Functional level (TRL)

None Technical Readiness
Family friends and foes
Listen and/or see

0.2 Score:
 Evaluating the TRL
None Technical Readiness
Family friends and foes
Listen and/or see

0.2 Score:
 Prototyping Reviewer
assesment
TRL

ole HMP

e Functional level (TRL) TRL Definition

3

Experimental proof of concept

3.3
0.2
Nothing defined

0.2
 PTRL PHMP PRole Variety
Problem definition 0 1 5 Physical
Ideation 0 3.5 1 Virtual
Customer Validation 0 2 6 None
Technical Validation 4 1.5 1
Incubation 6 5 4
 Complexity Fidelity
2 Component 1 Detailed 4
1 Sub-system 2 Realistic 3
0.4 Product 3 Basic 2
Component and sub-system 3 Form 1
Component , sub-system and pr 6
Sub-system and product 5
Context Audience
Real 3 Extended target audience 4
Simulated 2 Selected target audience 3
None 1 Uncorelated audience 2
Family friends and foes 1

18
48
0.375
Interaction TR
None 0 0.2
Listen and/or see 1 1
And touch 2 2
Interact following the lead 3 3
Interact 4 4
5
6
7
8
9
Nothing defined
Basic principles observed
Technology concept formulated
Experimental proof of concept
Technology validated in lab
Technology validated in relevant environment (industrially relevant environment in the case of key enabling technologies)
Technology demonstrated in relevant environment (industrially relevant environment in the case of key enabling technologi
System prototype demonstration in operational environment
System complete and qualified
Actual system proven in operational environment (competitive manufacturing in the case of key enabling technologies; or