Class II Class II

Reference ISO 5199 ASME B73.1

Design life Not regulated Not regulated

uninterrupted operation Not regulated Not regulated

Pressure casing 16 Bar 19 Bar

Flange Ratings* PN16 (16 bar) B16.5 Class 150 or 300

Bearing L10 Life, hours** 17,500 17,500
Nozzle load Less Less
Hydrotest Pressure 150% of MAWP for 10 minutes 150% of MAWP for 10 minutes
NPSH Margin, Minimum > 0.5 m > 0.9 m
Driver Sizing, % of Pump Rated
137% < x > 110% Not regulated
Input
Critical Speed Margin,
10% 20%
Minimum
Balance Specification Not Specified ISO 1940 G6.3
3.0 mm/sec for <= 225 mm centerline 4.5 4.8 mm/sec for < 200 kW 5.6 mm/sec
Vibration Level, Maximum
mm/sec for > 225 centerline for >= 200 kW
Corrosion Allowance, Minimum 3 mm 3 mm
Shaft Deflection, Maximum 0.05 mm 0.13 mm
0.05 mm up to 50mm OD 0.08 mm up to
Shaft Run-Out, Maximum 0.025 mm on centers 0.05 mm installed
100mm OD 0.1 mm over 100 mm
Thrust Bearing Locking
No circlips permitted Not Specified
Mechanism
Bearing Isolators No lip seals permitted Not Specified
Price 3 to 5 4 to 5.5
Class I
API 610
Min 20 years
at least 3 years of uninterrupted
operation
minimum rated pressure of 4 000 kPa
(40 bar) (600 psi) at 38 °C (100 °F)
Min ANSI 300#
Min 25,000
Highest
150% of MAWP for 10 minutes
> 0.9 m

137% < x > 110%

Regulate in stric formula

ISO 1940 G6.2.5

limit up to 3.0 mm/s in BEP, up to 3.9
mm/s in the rest of the operating range
3 mm
Stricly regulated in API table

0.025 mm

No circlips permitted

No lip seals permitted

6 to 10
 OH1 or OH2 BB1 or BB2
Reference Horizontal Between Bearing
Horizontal Overhung
Single or 2 stage
Invesment cost 3 to 4 7 to 10
Maintenance Easy More Complicated
Spare part cost Cheapest More Expensive
Setting Easy More Complicated
Mech seal used 1 pcs 2 pcs
Bearing used 1 pcs 2 pcs
User view More familiar Less Familiar
follow standard (Ex. API 610 follow standard (Ex. API 610
Pump life have min 20 years design life) have min 20 years design life)
follow standard (Ex. API 610 follow standard (Ex. API 610
have min 3 years uninterupted have min 3 years uninterupted
Pump reliability operation) operation)