You are on page 1of 14

Materials Science and Engineering A258 Ž1998.

1]14

Iron aluminides: present status and future prospects

N.S. Stoloff
Materials Science and Engineering Department, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY 121280-3590, USA

Abstract

This paper constitutes a broad survey of the physical, mechanical and corrosion properties of Fe 3 Al alloys, as well as a
review of principal processing methods. This class of alloys, once thought to be inherently brittle, is shown to possess moderate
ductility, provided that mechanical testing is carried out in an inert environment. Methods to improve mechanical properties
by alloying and microstructural control are described. The influence of alloying elements on corrosion and stress corrosion
resistance and weldability also is reviewed. Q 1998 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Fracture; Impact; Iron aluminides; Corrosion welding

1. Introduction and historical review The physical properties, mechanical behavior and
corrosion resistance of Fe 3 Al alloys have been exten-
The iron aluminides Fe 3 Al and FeAl have been sively reviewed in recent conferences w4,5x as well as
among the most widely studied intermetallics because in other volumes on intermetallics w6,7x. Accordingly,
of their low cost, low density, good wear resistance, only a brief summary of the early work on these alloys
ease of fabrication and resistance to oxidation and will be presented here. Most of the review will be
corrosion. These advantages have led to the identifi- devoted to the current status of research and develop-
cation of several potential uses, including heating ment efforts on iron aluminides as well as a discus-
elements, furnace fixtures, heat-exchanger piping, sin- sion of prospects for commercial applications.
tered porous gas-metal filters, automobile and other
The excellent corrosion resistance of Fe]Al alloys
industrial valve components, catalytic converter subs-
was first recognized in the 1930s w8x, but detailed
trates and components for molten salt applications
w1,2x. In addition, Fe 3 Al is one of the few structural studies of mechanical behavior commenced with the
work of Cahn and his co-workers in the late 1950s
intermetallics that can be disordered Žwith respect to
and early 1960s w9]11x. This work included reports of
DO 3-type order. by appropriate elevated temperature
heat treatment, as shown in Fig. 1 w3x. This pheno- the creep resistance of Fe 3 Al above and below the
menon is both an advantage Žfor scientific studies of critical ordering temperature, Tc w9x, as well as a
the influence of ordering on mechanical behavior. description of the effect of long-range order on yield-
and a disadvantage, owing to the degradation of creep ing w10x and mechanical twinning w11x. A discontinuity
and tensile strengths upon disordering. Further exac- in the slope of plots of creep rate vs. inverse tempera-
erbating this disadvantage is the low temperature, ture near Tc was attributed to a change in the activa-
approx. 5508C, at which disordering occurs. This criti- tion energy for diffusion at this temperature w9x. Later
cal temperature, Tc , becomes the limiting tempera- work by Stoloff and Davies dealt with the influence of
ture for structural applications, although it can be long-range order on yielding w12x and strain hardening
raised substantially by alloying with silicon or molyb- w13x of Fe 3 Al. A study of compositional effects on
denum, among other solutes. At present, some of the yielding of Fe]Al alloys was reported by Sainfort w14x.
major issues that continue to delay commercial viabil- Other noteworthy early work by Justusson and
ity include low ductility and impact resistance at low Zackay w15x and by Kayser w16x on fracture behavior
temperatures and inadequate creep resistance at ele- of Fe 3 Al should be cited. These studies showed that
vated temperatures. as aluminum is added to iron ductility drops sharply,

0921-5093r98r$ - see front matter Q 1998 Elsevier Science S.A. All rights reserved.
PII S0921-5093Ž98.00909-5
2 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

more complex arguments concerning dislocation core


structures, but still serves as a readily understandable
model of the role of superlattice dislocations in plas-
tic flow behavior of intermetallics. Furthermore, the
electron microscopic studies of Marcinkowski and
Brown w17x at approximately the same time provided
information about slip systems, dislocation configura-
tions and antiphase boundaries in these alloys.
Efforts to develop iron aluminides as structural
materials were carried out under Air Force sponsor-
ship at Pratt and Whitney Aircraft w18x and Marko
Materials w19x, among others. The superior corrosion
resistance of Fe 3 Al in aqueous solutions was well
known, but it was recognized that utilization of alloys
based on Fe 3 Al would be limited by the relatively low
temperature at which long-range order is lost Žapprox.
Fig. 1. Variation of DO 3 order determined from variations in 5508C.. Accordingly, efforts were made to improve
X-ray as a function of annealing temperature before quenching w3x. high-temperature strength by adding hard particles,
but these efforts ultimately were terminated without
any resulting applications w18x.
especially as the Fe 3 Al phase becomes stable. The
early work indicated that the low ductility of ‘dis- 2. Phase relationships
ordered’ Fe 3 Al was further reduced slightly by order-
ing w15x. It was established also that a peak in yield The currently accepted Fe]Al phase diagram, in
stress at an intermediate degree of long-range order the vicinity of 25 at.% Al, appears in Fig. 2 w20x. The
occurs at room temperature in quenched Fe 3 Al as Fe 3 Al region ranges from approx. 22]30 at.% Al, but
well as at elevated temperature w13,15x. This work, two-phase regions exist on either side. Two-phase
together with studies of the FeCo]V intermetallic, alpha q B2 and alpha q DO 3 regions noted in the
led to the suggestion that the flow stress peak in many diagram must be accounted for when determining
intermetallics is due to a transition from motion of heat treatment schedules for these alloys. In the
single dislocations to superlattice dislocations as the two-phase regions, age hardening behavior which can
degree of long-range order increases from zero to one substantially alter mechanical properties has been
w12,16x. This theory has since been supplanted by reported w1,21,22x. For example, Morris w1x has noted

Fig. 2. Phase diagram in vicinity of Fe]25 at.% Al w20x.


N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 3

that in the temperature range of approx. 300]5508C purity test materials. However, for commercialization
and for alloys containing 20]25 at.% Al, it is possible to be practical, less expensive methods are needed.
to retain a stable two-phase alpha q DO 3 ordered Also, prevention of hydrogen gas uptake in the mol-
microstructure similar to the gamma]gamma prime ten alloy is important to produce ingots free of voids.
microstructures in nickel-base superalloys. The tem- Argon gas blown through the melt effectively elimi-
perature range of stability of this two-phase mixture nates the porosity w4x. Another approach, carried out
can be extended by adding Si in the range of 1]3%. in India, is to air induction melt, followed by electros-
In the range 23]27 at.% Al, the B2 structure can only lag remelting ŽESR. w24x. Clean, defect-free ingots
be retained at low temperatures by quenching from were obtained from remelting even of porous induc-
above Tc , but at higher Al contents B2 replaces DO 3 tion melted ingots. Improved microstructures and me-
as the stable phase. The wide solubility range of B2 chanical properties were obtained with cast ESR in-
FeAl allows it to exist in the partially ordered condi- gots containing 0.074]0.14 wt.% C. Cast Fe 3 Al ingots
tion above Tc on either side of stoichiometry. are best reduced by hot working, typically at tempera-
tures of 1000]12008C; warm working is then carried
3. Dislocations and antiphase boundaries out between 6508C and 8008C w4x. In laboratory exper-
iments, cast material tends to have much lower ductil-
Plastic deformation in dilute, disordered Fe]Al al- ity than wrought samples of the same composition,
loys is accomplished by the motion of unit a o²111: due in large part to the coarse grain size and weak
dislocations, as in pure iron, and wavy slip indicates grain boundaries of the castings; as a result, such
that cross slip readily occurs among planes containing castings cannot be cold worked or used in the as-cast
the slip vector. In hyperstoichiometric Fe 3 Al, super- condition for structural applications.
lattice dislocations are observed, of the fourfold type The exothermic reaction between aluminum and
in the DO 3 condition, and paired in the B2 condition, iron can be utilized in both melting and powder
but always of ²111: type. At the stoichiometric com- consolidation. Although the exotherm is not as great
position uncoupled dislocations often are seen. At as for the nickel aluminides, low ignition tempera-
high temperatures deformation has been thought to tures permit melting by the Exo-Melt TM process, see
be controlled by the glide of perfect ²100: disloca- Fig. 3 w25x, or by powder processing via the reactive
tions w23x; however, Kad and Horton w61x report that sintering Žself-propagating high-temperature synthe-
only ²111: dislocations are present in FeAl deformed sis. w26]28x approach. Utilizing the exothermic reac-
at 925 K and in Fe 3 Al deformed at 1075 K. Composi- tion lowers costs and, in the case of melting, offers
tional effects do not appear to account for the dis- greater safety, shorter melt times and improved
crepancy, especially for the FeAl alloy, and texture process control. Iron aluminide powders can be used
measurements are not in agreement with the activa- to form near net shape parts Žby hot isostatic press-
tion of ²100: slip systems. Therefore further work is ing., or can be used to produce spray coatings. Powders
required to unambiguously identify operative disloca- are typically prepared by gas atomization, utilizing
tions at high temperatures. nitrogen, argon or helium. Spherical particles usually
Thermally produced antiphase domains are found result, with oxygen contents approximately the same
in both the B2 and DO 3 variants of Fe 3 Al. Their as in the melt in purged systems with pure carrier gas
boundaries do not lie on preferred planes, resulting in w27x. Nitrogen gas atomized alloy FAS Žsee Table 1.
a wavy, isotropic appearance that is easily imaged by prepared by reactive sintering has been shown to have
transmission electron microscopy. There is no evi- slightly higher yield and tensile strengths at tempera-
dence that these boundaries inhibit dislocation mo- tures to 8008C than cast product, but much higher
tion. However, unit dislocations trying to move creep resistance; elongations of the material prepared
through the fully ordered DO 3 lattice would leave by the two methods were similar.
behind a trail of antiphase boundary, the energy for Hot pressing of elemental powders resulted in the
which has to be supplied by the applied forces. formation of single phase Fe 3 Al with 98.2% of theo-
retical density. Other successful powder techniques
4. Processing included hot extrusion and a combination of mechani-
cal alloying and reactive sintering w26x. Excellent me-
Iron aluminides are readily prepared in small quan- chanical properties were attributed to uniformity of
tities either by melting and casting or by powder microstructures and fineness of grain sizes. Other
processing. Alloys can be melted by a variety of tech- powder techniques that have been reported include
niques, including air induction melting ŽAIM., vac- mechanical alloying of prealloyed, atomized powders
uum induction melting ŽVIM. and vacuum arc remelt- with small amounts of Y2 O 3 w29x, injection molding of
ing ŽVAR.. Arc melting, vacuum induction melting Fe 3 Al with short Al 2 O 3 fibers w30x and thermal spray-
and drop casting have been utilized to prepare high- ing of elemental Fe and Al powders followed by
4 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

Table 1
Compositions of iron aluminides a chosen at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory for commercialization w2x

Element Alloy Ž%.


FASb FALc FA-129d FAPYe
Weight Atomic Weight Atomic Weight Atomic Weight Atomic

Al 15.9 28.08 15.9 28.03 15.9 28.08 8.46 16.12


Cr 2.20 2.02 5.5 5.03 5.5 5.04 5.50 5.44
B 0.01 0.04 0.01 0.04 ] ] ] ]
Zr ] ] 0.15 0.08 ] ] 0.20 0.11
Nb ] ] ] ] 1.0 0.51 ] ]
C ] ] ] ] 0.05 0.20 0.03 0.13
Mo ] ] ] ] ] ] 2.00 1.07
Y ] ] ] ] ] ] 0.10 0.06
Fe 81.89 69.86 78.44 66.81 77.55 66.17 63.71 77.07
a
FAS, FAL, and FA-129 are the Fe 3 Al-base alloys. FAPY is a disordered a alloy.
b
Sulfidation-resistant alloy.
c
High room-temperature tensile ductility.
d
High-temperature strength with good room-temperature ductility.
e
Very high room-temperature ductility.

annealing to produce the intermetallic w26x. High-en- and ductility decreases; ductility changes are particu-
ergy ball milling also has been used to form nanocrys- larly pronounced as the ordering range, above 16
talline iron aluminides w31x. Control of composition in at.%, is reached w23x. It is now known that sensitivity
all of these methods is very important, although Fe 3 Al to moisture is the primary cause of low ductility in
is less sensitive than FeAl in this regard due to the Fe 3 Al alloys at room temperature, although contami-
absence of constitutional vacancies in the former. nation by impurities such as carbon is a contributing
factor. Chromium is the most effective solute to com-
5. Alloy development bat environmental embrittlement, and as a conse-
quence a series of Fe]Al]Cr alloys has been devel-
As aluminum is added to iron, strength increases oped at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, see

Fig. 3. Furnace-loading sequence to take advantage of heat of formationof Fe 3 Al during the melting of iron-aluminide alloys w25x.
N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 5

Table 1. Optimum ductility is produced at the


28Al]5Cr level w23x. Zirconium additions also im-
prove ductility, but the effect depends upon whether
carbon is present w32,33x. The mechanism for solute
improvements is not yet known, although interference
with the moisture dissociation reaction at an Al-rich
surface is a likely candidate.
Alloys containing Si, Ta, Ce, Zr, Mo, Hf or Nb have
been shown to increase high-temperature creep and
tensile strength of Fe 3 Al, usually at the expense of
room-temperature ductility w22x. Chen et al. w34x, sug-
gest that Mo is the most effective of these solutes,
Fig. 4. Temperature dependence of the critical resolved shear
possibly because of its effects on Tc Žraised by Mo.,
stress to of Fe]28 at.% Al q Cr single crystals deformed in uniaxial
the increased APB energy and reduced diffusivity. compression. B: No Cr, orientation w123x; I: 6 at.% Cr, orienta-
The low solubilities of these solutes, as well as their tion w123x; 0:6 at.% Cr, orientation w001x w36x.
tendency to form intermetallic compounds or borides
or carbides, allows them to be used for precipitation
hardening and for grain refinement. Quantities of creasing test temperature, in the range 450]5508C,
these solutes up to 10 at.%, together with very small depending upon composition; the peak occurs at
additions of boron or carbon, can be used to improve slightly lower temperatures at higher Al contents w23x.
both tensile and creep strength with little adverse Although most data have been obtained for polycrys-
effect on low-temperature ductility w23x. Carbide tals, Kral et al. w36x have reported data for Fe]28
strengthening is particularly effective in Fe 3 Al, but at.% Al and Fe]28Al]6Cr single crystals. As shown
melting and subsequent processing should insure that in Fig. 4, the critical resolved shear stress decreases in
carbides will precipitate from the liquid, thereby pro- region A, just above room temperature, and then rises
ducing refined cast structures and subsequent fine- to a peak near 8508K. Cr produces some softening at
grained wrought product. Heat treatment schedules temperatures below the peak. No evidence of a rela-
are particularly important in optimizing creep proper- tion between the state of long-range DO 3-type order
ties of Fe 3 Al alloys. For example, an alloy containing and the peak was observed. Early theories of the flow
small additions of Nb, Mo, Zr, B and C showed much stress peak associated it with the loss of DO 3-type
longer creep lives at 5938C under a stress of 207 MPa order as the critical ordering temperature, Tc , was
when heat treated at 11508C rather than at 7508C approached. However, Schroer et al. w37x showed that
w35x. This effect was attributed to the dissolution of the peak could still be seen in DO 3-based alloys
coarse carbides and subsequent precipitation of fine modified to retain order at the temperature of the
particles on matrix dislocations. peak. Morris w1x has recently analyzed the various
theories that have been advanced to explain the peak:
6. Mechanical properties
1. extensive cross slip between  1104 and  1124 ;
6.1. Yielding 2. APB relaxation, leading to dislocation drag on
²111: dislocations;
The yield stress of binary Fe]Al alloys increases as 3. transition from ²111: to ²110: and ²100: disloca-
Al content increases, to a peak at the stoichiometric tions with increasing temperature;
composition; strength then decreases until B2 FeAl 4. superdislocation climb locking; and
forms. The strength of Fe 3 Al is related to the pres- 5. vacancy hardening.
ence of long-range DO 3-type order and the occur-
rence of two-phase alpha q DO 3 regions as Al con- Strain rate change tests as well as temperature
tent exceeds 16 at.%. Although McKamey w23x at- jump experiments carried out in order to deduce the
tributes strengthening to the interaction of superlat- operative mechanism were inconclusive, leading to
tice dislocations with thermally produced antiphase the conclusion that several mechanisms may control
boundaries and boundaries produced by superpartial deformation over a range of temperature, strain rate
glide dislocations, this seems unlikely, based on ear- and alloy composition w1x.
lier work of Stoloff and Davies w16x on Cu 3 Au. Stoloff and Davies w16x showed that there is a
Quenching of Fe 3 Al alloys to produce partial B2-type maximum in yield stress with the degree of quenched
order results in a small decrease in flow stress. in long-range order at room temperature upon
As in the case of many other intermetallics, the quenching from just below Tc . This peak seemed to
flow stress of Fe 3 Al alloys displays a peak with in- be related to that obtained at temperature, in that
6 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

both occurred at an intermediate degree of long-range 6.3. Impact properties


order. The recent investigations cited by Morris
w1x above do not seem to have considered the im-
plications of these observations. More recent Limited studies of impact behavior of stress-re-
work has been reported by Lu et al. w38x for a lieved Fe 3 Al alloys has revealed disappointingly low
Fe]28Al]5Cr]0.3B]0.003% Mg alloy. Room-temper- absorbed energies and a high ductile]brittle transi-
ature tensile strength rises to a maximum for speci- tion temperature Ž3088C., as shown in Fig. 7 for the
mens quenched in oil from 600]6508C subsequent to FA-129 alloy w38x. Furthermore, the upper shelf en-
a stress relief heat treatment, see Fig. 5 w38x. Cooling ergy is very low, only 37 J, while the lower shelf
rate has a significant effect, with furnace-cooled ma- energy is only 5 J w39x. Liu et al. w40x have reported
terial displaying lower tensile strength and ductility impact data for Fe]25% Al and Fe]25Al]20Mn.
than oil-quenched samples, probably because of the They too found very low-impact energies at the lower
different ordered states existing in the two cases. shelf for the binary alloy, but the ternary alloy was
much tougher. Peaks in total impact energy vs. tem-
perature were noted for both alloys near 6008C, con-
6.2. Tensile strength and ductility siderably higher than reported above for FA-129.
However, above the peak the impact energy dropped
sharply for the ternary alloy and hardly at all for the
Since iron aluminides are often considered to be binary alloy. The addition of Mn introduced an or-
potential competitors to stainless steels for structural dered L1 2-type phase, and decreased the DO 3 order-
and corrosion-resistant applications, it is interesting ing energy of the alpha phase. These factors appear to
to compare tensile properties of several wrought be responsible for both increased toughness and a
Fe 3 Al alloys with types 310 and 422 stainless steels, transition from cleavage to dimpled rupture with the
addition of the Mn.
see Fig. 6a,b w2x. Note that yield and tensile strengths
of FAS, FAL and FA-129 Žsee Table 1. are intermedi-
ate between those of the stainless steels, and a shal- 6.4. Fracture toughness
low peak in yield strength is exhibited by all of the
aluminides. Similarly, Fig. 6c w2x shows that the room-
temperature ductility of the aluminides is intermedi- Most fracture studies have been conducted with
ate to those of the stainless steels, but at higher tensile specimens. However, there are now limited
temperatures a transition to ductile behavior occurs fracture toughness data Žincluding J integral data.
for the former. As a result, the total elongation of the available for binary Fe]28 at.% Al w40x. As in the case
aluminides exceeds those of the stainless alloys at of tensile experiments, environmental effects are sig-
temperatures above 5508C. A more extensive discus- nificant, with oxygen atmospheres providing higher
sion of low-temperature ductility appears in the sec- fracture resistance than vacuum or air, see Fig. 8w41x.
tion on environmental embrittlement. Note that toughness in oxygen is double that in air for

Fig. 5. Room temperature tensile properties vs. heat-treatment temperatures for oil quenched specimens w38x.
N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 7

Fig. 6. Comparison of average tensile properties of wrought Fe 3 Al-based alloys with that of types 422 and 310 stainless steels: Ža. yield
strength; Žb. ultimate tensile strength; and Žc. total elongation w2x.

Fe]28% Al, with an even greater disparity noted for competing structural alloys such as types 310 and 422
Fe]35% Al ŽB2 structure .. However, there is no dif- stainless steels, see Fig. 9 w2x. Note that in spite of
ference in toughness in any environment between the comparable tensile strengths, the creep rupture lives
DO 3 and partially ordered B2 structures, unlike the of the steels are much superior. Fortunately, it is
case of tensile elongation, which is higher in the B2 possible to improve rupture lives of Fe]28 at.% Al by
condition. In general, the toughness of Fe 3 Al is higher addition of Ti, Nb, Zr, B and especially Mo, as shown
than that of other aluminides such as TiAl and NiAl. in Fig. 10 w43x. The combination of 2% Moq 0.1Zrq
0.2B Žalloy FA-114. is particularly effective, with that
6.5. Creep and stress rupture alloy showing the highest creep resistance of several
alloys tested. It was suggested that fine ZrC particles
The creep resistance of binary Fe 3 Al alloys is rela- pin dislocations, thereby improving both strength and
tively poor, largely due to the open B2 and DO 3 creep resistance w43x. Another factor that can
crystal structures. Therefore a major aim of alloy markedly affect creep resistance is heat treatment.
development efforts Žsee above. has been to improve Fig. 11 shows that the highest creep-rupture life for
creep resistance while not reducing low-temperature alloy FA-180 Žsee Table 1. occurs at a heat treatment
ductility. temperature of 11508C for 1 h w43x. Fine carbides
The stress sensitivity of creep rate and stress expo- precipitate during this treatment. The creep strength
nent have been determined for several Fe 3 Al alloys, of this alloy compares favorably with that of 316 and
as shown in Table 2 w42x. Both parameters are stress 403 stainless steels. Heat treatments at 11508C for
dependent, although the average stress exponent is in more than 4 h result in shorter lives, possibly due to
the range 3]7. Similarly, the most common value for carbide coarsening. Rupture lives are increased fur-
activation energy is 300]350 kJrmol. Note that sev- ther by quenching from 11508C into either oil or
eral different mechanisms of creep are observed. water.
Binary and more complex Fe 3 Al solid solution al- Chromium, which is usually present for resistance
loys display lower creep rupture resistance than many to environmental embrittlement, slightly lowers rup-
8 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

Fig. 7. Absorbed energy vs. temperature for full-size T-L specimens of iron]aluminide alloy FA-129 w39x.

and Nb also show increased lives, up to 2000 h, at


larger grain sizes.

6.6. Superplasticity

Superplasticity has been observed in coarse grained


FeAl and Fe 3 Al alloys by Lin and co-workers w43x.
Maximum elongations of 620% have been noted for
Fe]28 at.% Al]2Ti at 8508C under an initial strain
rate of 1.26= 10y3 rs. At this temperature strain
hardening is slight, while at 700 and 7508C distinct
strain hardening is noted, see Fig. 13 w44x. The fol-
lowing criteria for superplasticity have been identi-
fied:

1. high strain rate sensitivity Ž m ) 0.3.;


2. low, strain independent flow stresses;
3. temperature at least 0.5Tm ; and
Fig. 8. Fracture toughness of iron aluminides in different environ- 4. high ductility.
ments w41x.
The unusual feature of superplasticity in the iron
ture lives of B2 Fe 3 Al at 6008C and 200 MPa, while aluminides is the large grain size at which it occurs
increasing the tendency for intergranular fracture w34x. Ž60]100 m m for Fe 3 Al and 500]600 m m for FeAl.;
The same investigation revealed that Cr lowers the these grain sizes may be compared to the 1]5 m m
APB energy, resulting in larger separations of twofold usually necessary for superplasticity in conventional
dislocations and a greater tendency for motion of metals and alloys.
uncoupled dislocations. The result is larger elonga-
tions and increased stress concentrations at grain 7. Environmental resistance
boundaries, thereby accounting for more intergranu-
lar failure. 7.1. En¨ ironmental embrittlement
Chen et al. w34x report that grain shape has little
effect on rupture life of Fe]28Al]2Cr, but grain size The results of early work on the iron aluminides
is an important variable. Fig. 12 shows that rupture had suggested that they were intrinsically brittle at
life increases to a maximum as grain size increases low temperatures w13]16x. However, it was shown by
from 70 m m to 372 m m w34x. Alloys with Mo, Cr, Zr Liu and co-workers w45,46x that when water vapor and
N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 9

Table 2
Summary of creep parameters in Fe 3 Al and its alloys w42x

Alloy T ŽK. Qe ŽkJrmol. n Mechanism Žcomments. Ref

Fe]19.4Al 773]873 305 4.6]6 for Diffusion controlled w9x


Fe]27.8Al 823]888 276 different Al
Higher temperature 418 ] Controlled by state of order

Fe]15]20Al ) 773 260 to 305 Žincreases ] Diffusion controlled w57x


with increasing Al.
- 773 s dependent ] Motion of jogged screw
dislocations

Fe]28Al 898 347 3.5 Žlow s . Viscous glide


7.7 Žhigh s . Climb
Fe]28Al]2Mo 923 335 1.4 Žlow s . Diffusional flow w58x
6.8 Žhigh s . Climb
Fe]28Al]1Nb] 923 335 1.8 Žlow s . Diffusional flow
0.013Zr 19.0 Žhigh s . Dispersion strengthening

FA-180 866 627 7.9 Precipitation strengthening w59x

Fe]28Al 873]948 ] 3.4 Viscous glide w60x


Fe]26Al]0.1C 873]948 305 3.0 Viscous glide
753]813 403 6.2 ?
Fe]28Al]2Cr 873]948 325 3.7 Viscous glide
Fe]28Al]2Cr]0.04B 873]948 304 3.7 Viscous glide
Fe]28Al]4Mn 873]948 302 2.6 Viscous glide

Fig. 10. Creep-rupture data showing the effect of additions of Zr


and heat teatment on the creep strength of Fe]28Al]2Mo w43x.

B2 structure is beneficial. Consequently, adequate


Fig. 9. Comparison of creep rupture properties of wrougt Fe 3 Al- ductility for most structural applications can be
based alloys with types 422 and 310 stainless steels w23x. achieved in the alloys listed in Table 1. Interestingly,
fracture occurs by transgranular cleavage, indepen-
other sources of hydrogen are excluded from the dent of the environment, except for alloys containing
environment, ductilities in excess of 10% were achiev- Cr, which exhibit mixed intergranular and transgranu-
able at room temperature. The deleterious effects of lar crack segments. Also, when heat treatment of
hydrogen-containing environments are seen in other Fe]28Al]5Cr subsequent to a stress relief anneal is
aluminides, especially Ni 3 Al, TiAl and Ti 3 Al, as well applied, Lu et al. report w38x intergranular fracture
as in Ni 3 Si and other intermetallics w47x. Even in after slow cooling from the annealing temperature.
moist air, the ductility of Fe 3 Al can be increased by The environmental effects on fracture in tension
adding Cr or Zr andror by producing a stress-relieved described above are replicated under cyclic loading.
but not recrystallized microstructure w23x. Also, Fatigue crack growth rates are much lower in vacuum
quenching from above Tc to form the partially-ordered or oxygen than in air or in hydrogen gas, as shown, for
10 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

Fig. 11. Creep-rupture life vs. heat treatment for 1-h anneals of alloy FA-180. Specimens were air cooled following heat treatment w43x.

Fig. 13. True stress]true strain for Fe]28Al]2Ti showing super-


plastic behavior at 7508C and 8508C w44x.

in acid- and sulfur-bearing environments, especially


Fig. 12. Effects of annealing temperature on the creep properties
of Fe]28 at.% Al]2 at.% Cr alloy at a stress of 200 MPa and 6008C
relative to the reference material, 304L SS. In 1
w34x. molrl NaOH, on the other hand, all four materials
are passivated at the corrosion potential, Ecorr , and
remain passivated to high potentials; this is indicative
example ŽFe]15]9 wt.% Al]5.5Cr]1.0Nb]0.05C. in of good overall corrosion resistance. Low average
Fig. 14 w44x. Fractography reveals transgranular cleav- corrosion rates are seen also in chloride solutions, but
age in air or hydrogen gas w47x, but microvoid coales- localized corrosion initiates in FA-84 and FA-129
cence is observed for tests carried out in oxygen. alloys within 24 h. The addition of 1]2% Mo and
Similar effects of gaseous environments on growth 4]6% Cr is beneficial in delaying initiation, as shown
rates have been observed on several other Fe 3 Al in Table 4 w50x. Tests of these alloys under crevice
alloys w48x.
corrosion conditions Žmild acid]chloride solutions for
18 h. showed inferior behavior relative to 304L SS,
7.2. Aqueous corrosion and stress corrosion indicating that crevice corrosion can occur even in
Fe 3 Al containing Cr and Mo.
The aqueous corrosion behavior of Fe 3 Al alloys Embrittlement caused by hydrogen released from
containing 28 at.% Al Žheat treated to produce B2 water vapor in air has been documented in many
order. in various corrosive media have been reported studies of tensile stress]strain behavior. Similarly,
by Buchanan and co-workers w49,50x, with their results stress corrosion of Fe 3 Al alloys in aqueous solutions
reproduced in Table 3. High corrosion rates are noted has been linked to the evolution of hydrogen, result-
N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 11

Fig. 14. Fatigue crack growth of Fe 3 Al alloy FA]129 258C w48x: Ža. B2; Žb. DO 3 .

ing in embrittlement. Kasul and Heldt w51x have shown Tortorelli w53x. The formation of Al 2 O 3 films provides
that ductility of Fe]24.6% Al is decreased at cathodic oxidation resistance; the minimum Al content to form
potentials in both acid and basic environments, see Al 2 O 3 is 16]18 at.% and these films can form even in
Fig. 15, exactly as expected from test conditions fa- low pressures of oxygen. Small additions of Cr can
voring release of hydrogen. Similarly, slow strain ex- reduce the minimum Al content somewhat. The me-
periments carried out in air in a mild acid]chloride chanical integrity of the films and their reformation
solution show decreasing ductility with more negative characteristics are critical to adequate behavior at
potentials as well as at the highest anodic potential, long exposures. When Fe 3 Al is exposed to sulfur-
see Fig. 16 w50x. The latter observation seems to be bearing atmospheres, weight gain is adversely affected
connected to the formation of corrosion pits during by the presence of large quantities of Cr, as shown in
exposure, leading to accelerated hydrogen production Fig. 17 w53x. Note that the binary Fe]12 wt.% Al alloy
in the presence of a stress concentrator. The maxi- as well as Fe 3 Al alloy FA-61 shows no weight gain at
mum ductilities are observed near the free corrosion 8758C. Apart from Cr, the only other solute which has
potential and are comparable to the ductility in air. been studied in detail is Zr, which appears to improve
Even the disordered Fe]16 at.% Al alloy exhibits oxide adherence at elevated temperatures w54x.
stress corrosion behavior Žas well as very high fatigue
crack growth rates in hydrogen and in moist air w52x., 8. Welding
in sharp contrast to the high ductility and dimpled
fracture mode resulting from tensile tests. In sum-
mary, low strain rates, cathodic potentials and condi- Considerable attention has been devoted to the
tions favoring pitting are detrimental to the stress weldability of Fe 3 Al alloys because of concern about
corrosion behavior of both ordered and disordered the problem of hydrogen embrittlement in the pres-
Fe]Al alloys containing 16]28 at.% Al. ence of water vapor w55,56x. All traces of the latter
must be excluded from the weld surface in order to
7.3. Oxidation and hot corrosion avoid delayed cold cracking. Reducing grain size has
proven to be an effective means of improving weld
The high-temperature corrosion behavior of Fe 3 Al ductility and increasing resistance to hydrogen em-
alloys has recently been reviewed by Natesan and brittlement. Another method to control cold cracking
Table 3
Corrosion rates by the polarization-resistance method for Fe 3 Al-based iron aluminides in acidic, basic and sulfur-compound solutions w50x

Solutions Average penetration rates Ž m mrday.


Materials
FA-84 FA-129 FAL-Mo 304L SS

1 molrl HCI 430 52 14 9.7


0.5 molrl H2 SO4 400 72 120 0.014
1 molrl HNO3 160 3.5 1.4 0.007
1 molrl NaOH 0.042 0.021 0.056 0.007
0.1 molrl Na2 S2 O3 7.8 9.9 2.6 0.004
0.1 molrl Na2 S4 O6 21 6.5 6.5 0.020
12 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

Table 4
Localized-corrosion initiation times for Fe 3 Al-based iron
aluminides in a mild acid-chloride solution w50x

Iron aluminides Localized-corrosion


initiation times
Ždays.

Fe]28Ala 1
Fe]28Al plus:
2Cra 2
2Cr]0.05B ŽFA-84.b 1
4Cra 2
5Cr]0.2C]0.5Nb ŽFA-129. 1
6Cra 27
1Moa 2
2Cr]1Moa 41
4Cr]0.5Moa 59
4Cr]1Moa ) 122c
4Cr]2Moa ) 122c
5Cr]1Mo]0.04B]0.08Zr ŽFAL-Mo.b ) 259c
Fig. 16. Slow-strain-rate ductility vs. electrochemicals potential for
304L Stainless steel ) 259c FA-129 iron aluminide w50x.
a
DO 3 heat treatment.
b
B2 heat treatment.
c
Tests terminated. 9. Summary

is to preheat at 3508C or higher or post-heat at 7508C, This review has dealt with the highlights of recent
in order to relieve stresses and drive off hydrogen research on the processing, microstructure, mechani-
w55x. These temperatures are higher than those previ- cal properties and environmental resistance of Fe 3 Al
ously suggested by McKamey w23x. alloys. While much progress has been made in solving
Hot cracking of iron aluminides is not as pervasive the twin problems of poor low-temperature ductility
as cold cracking, and is highly dependent on composi- and inadequate high-temperature creep resistance,
tion. Zirconium, boron and TiB 2 are detrimental to Fe 3 Al alloys appear still to be a few years away from
weldability, while niobium, chromium and small widespread applications. In part this situation stems
amounts of carbon are beneficial. Threshold cracking from the contradictory effects of chromium on
stresses are similar to those of some austenitic stain- strength Žlowered. and low-temperature ductility
less steels and Ni 3 Al w23x. Žraised.. As others solutes are added for improved
creep strength, ductility may be expected to decrease

Fig. 17. Weight change data for Fe]Cr, Fe]Cr]Ni, Fe]Al and
Fig. 15. Ductility of an Fe]24.6% Al alloy under conditions of Fe]Cr]Al alloys, and Fe aluminide Fe 3 Al tested in OrS environ-
control potential and pH Želectrochemical potentials are vs. SCE. ment with pO 2 4.1= 10y1 8 and pS 2 s 9.4= 10y7 atm at 8758C
w51x. w53x.
N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14 13

again; in any case, ductility can be expected to ap- w14x G. Sainfort, P. Mouturat, P. Pein, J. Petit, G. Cabane, M.
proach zero when atomic hydrogen from the environ- Salesse, Mem. Sci. Rev. Met. 60 Ž1963. 125.
w15x F.X. Kayser, Ford Motor Co., WADC Tech. Rept. 57]298
ment or within the alloy is mobile. Therefore care Žpart 1., 1957.
must be taken in processing, cutting or joining to w16x N.S. Stoloff, R.G. Davies, Prog. Mat. Sci. 13 Ž1966. 3.
protect alloys from moisture or other sources of hy- w17x M.J. Marcinkowski, N. Brown, Acta Metall. 9 Ž1964. 764.
drogen. While coatings may alleviate the problem, w18x R.G. Bordeau, Development of Iron Aluminides, AFWAL-
TR-4009. Wright Patterson AFB, OH, 1987.
their utilization entails extra expense, and if the coat-
w19x R. Ray, V. Panchanathan, S. Isserow, J. Metals 35 Ž1983. 30.
ing is damaged, protection is lost. In spite of these w20x P.R. Swann, W.R. Duff, R.M. Fisher, Metall. Trans. 3 Ž1972.
difficulties, Fe 3 Al alloys continue to offer advantages 409.
over other structural materials, as outlined in the w21x H. Inoue, in: C.C. Koch, C.T. Liu, N.S. Stoloff ŽEds.., High
introduction, and alloy development continues. To Temperature Ordered Intermetallic Alloys, MRS Sym. Proc.,
39, MRS, Pittsburgh, 1985, p. 255.
date, most of such development in the United States w22x G.E. Fuchs, N.S. Stoloff, Acta Metall. 36 Ž1988. 1381.
has been conducted at the Oak Ridge National w23x C.G. McKamey, in: N.S. Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds.., Physical
Laboratory. It is desirable to expand alloy develop- Metallurgy and Processing of Intermetallic Compounds,
ment efforts to other laboratories here and abroad in Chapman and Hall, New York, 1996, p. 351.
w24x R.G. Baligidad, U. Parakash, A. Radhakrishna, V.R. Rao,
order to continue and accelerate the momentum of
P.K. Rao, N.B. Ballal, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Mazi-
ORNL’s efforts. asz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on Nickel
and Iron Aluminides, AMS International, Materials Park,
OH, 1997, p. 177.
Acknowledgements w25x V.K. Sikka, in: N.S. Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds.., Physical Metal-
lurgy and Processing of Intermetallic Compounds, Chapman
and Hall, New York, 1996, p. 561.
w26x S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Mazi-
The author is grateful to the US Department of
asz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on Nickel
Energy, Fossil Energy AR&TD Materials Program and Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials Park,
for financial support under subcontract No. 19X-SF- OH, 1997, p. 283.
521C with Lockheed Martin Energy Research Corp. w27x J.K. Wright, R.N. Wright, in: J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp
ŽEds.., Processing, Properties and Applications of Iron
Aluminides, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1994, p. 47.
w28x K.G. Shaw, J.H. Reinshagen, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J.
References Maziasz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on
Nickel and Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials
Park, OH, 1997, p. 301.
w1x D.G. Morris, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W. w29x M.N. Srinivasan, V.K. Sikka, in: J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp
Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on Nickel and Iron ŽEds.., Processing, Properties and Applications of Iron
Aluminides, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, 1997, p. Aluminides, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1994, p. 69.
73. w30x J. Scott, MS Thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Inst., 1992.
w2x V.K. Sikka, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W. w31x R. Frattini, J. Schiffine, G. Scipione, E. Bonett, S. Enzo, in:
Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on Nickel and Iron J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp ŽEds.., Processing, Properties
Aluminides, ASM International, Materials Park, OH, 1997, p. and Applications of Iron Aluminides, TMS, Warrendale, PA,
361. 1994, p. 79.
w3x D.G. Morris, in: J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp ŽEds.., Process- w32x V.K. Sikka, Oak Ridge National Lab., unpublished.
ing, Properties and Applications of Iron Aluminides, TMS, w33x D.A. Alven, Ph.D. Thesis, Rensselaer Polytechnic Inst. 1997.
Warrendale, PA, 1994, p. 117. w34x G. Chen, Y. Huang, W. Yang, Z. Sun, in: J.H. Schneibel,
w4x V.K. Sikka, in: J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp ŽEds.., Processing, M.H. Crimp ŽEds.., Processing, Properties and Applications
Properties and Applications of Iron Aluminides, TMS, War- of Iron Aluminides, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1994, p. 131.
rendale, PA, 1994, p. 3. w35x C.G. McKamey, P.J. Mazsiaz, in: J.H. Schneibel, M.H. Crimp
w5x S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., ŽEds.., Processing, Properties and Applications of Iron
International Symposium on Nickel and Iron Aluminides, Aluminides, TMS, Warrendale, PA, 1994, p. 147.
ASM International, Materials Park, OH, 1997. w36x F. Kral, P. Schwander, G. Kostorz, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka,
w6x N.S. Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds.., Physical Metallurgy and Pro- P.J. Maziasz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on
Nickel and Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials
cessing of Intermetallic Compounds, Chapman and Hall, New
Park, OH, 1997, p. 337.
York, 1996.
w37x W. Schroer, H. Mecking, C. Hartig, in: O. Izumi ŽEd..,
w7x J.H. Westbrook, R.L. Fleischer ŽEds.., Intermetallic Com-
Proceedings of the International Symposium On In-
pounds, John Wiley, New York, 1996.
termetallics ŽJIMIS 6., Japan Inst. of Metals, 1991, p. 567.
w8x N. Ziegler, Trans. AIME 100 Ž1932. 267.
w38x Y.H. Lu, Z.Q. Xing, H. Zhang, Scripta Metall. 33 Ž1995. 609.
w9x A. Lawley, J.A. Coll, R.W. Cahn, Trans. Met. Soc. AIME 218 w39x B.G. Gieseke, D.J. Alexander, V.K. Sikka, R.H. Baldwin,
Ž1960. 166.
Scripta Metall. 29 Ž1993. 129.
w10x A. Lawley, E.A. Vidoz, R.W. Cahn, Acta Metall. 9 Ž1961. 287. w40x J.N. Liu et al., in: C.C. Koch, C.T. Liu, N.S. Stoloff, A.
w11x R.W. Cahn, J.A. Coll, Acta Metall. 9 Ž1961. 138. Wanner ŽEds.., High Temperature Ordered Intermetallic Al-
w12x N.S. Stoloff, R.G. Davies, Acta Metall. 12 Ž1964. 473. loys VII, MRS Symp. Proc. 460, MRS, Pittsburgh, 1997, p.
w13x R.G. Davies, N.S. Stoloff, Acta Metall. 11 Ž1963. 1187. 343.
14 N.S. Stoloff r Materials Science and Engineering A258 (1998) 1]14

w41x S.H. Ko, R. Gnanamoorthy, S. Hanada, Mat. Sci. Eng. A222 Environmental Effects on Advanced Materials, TMS, War-
Ž1997. 133. rendale, PA., 1991, p. 67.
w42x D.H. Sastry, R.S. Sundar, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. w52x A. Castagna, N.S. Stoloff, in: J.A. Horton, I. Baker, S. Hanada,
Maziasz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on R.D. Noebe, D.S. Schwartz ŽEds.., High Temperature Or-
Nickel and Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials dered Intermetallics V, MRS Symp. Proc. 364Ž2., MRS, Pitts-
Park, OH, 1997, p. 123. burgh, 1995, p. 1171.
w43x N.S. Stoloff, D.A. Alven, C.G. McKamey, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. w53x K. Natesan, P.F. Tortorelli, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J.
Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W Cahn ŽEds.., International Sympo-
Maziasz, R.W. Cahn ŽEds.., International Symposium on
sium on Nickel and Iron Aluminides, ASM International,
Nickel and Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials
Materials Park, OH, 1997, p. 65.
Park, OH, 1997, p. 265.
w44x D. Lin, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W. Cahn
ŽEds.., International Symposium on Nickel and Iron w54x P.F. Tortorelli, B.A. Pint, I.G. Wright, Proceedings of the 11th
Aluminides, ASM International, Materilas Park, OH, 1997, p. Annual Conference On Fossil Energy Materials,
187. ORNLrFMP-97r7, 1997, p. 235.
w45x C.T. Liu, C.G. McKamey, E.H. Lee, Scripta Metall. 24 Ž1990. w55x M.L. Santella, in: S.C. Deevi, V.K. Sikka, P.J. Maziasz, R.W.
385. Cahn ŽEds.., ASM International Symposium on Nickel and
w46x C.T. Liu, in: I. Baker, R. Darolia, J.D. Whittenberger, M.H. Iron Aluminides, ASM International, Materials Park, OH,
Yoo ŽEds,., High Temperature Ordered Intermetallic Alloys 1997, p. 321.
V, MRS. Symp. Proc. 288, MRS. Warrendale, PA, 1993, p. 3. w56x S.A. David, M.L. Santella, in: N.S. Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds..,
w47x N.S. Stoloff, in: N.S. Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds.., Physical Physical Metallurgy and Processing of Intermetallic Com-
Metallurgy and Processing of Intermetallic Compounds, pounds, Chapman and Hall, New York, 1996, p. 655.
Chapman and Hall, New York, 1996, p. 479. w57x R.G. Davies, Trans AIME 227 Ž1963. 22.
w48x N.S. Stoloff, Iron Steel Inst. J. Japan 37 Ž1997. 1197. w58x C.G. McKamey, P.J. Maziasz, J.W. Jones, J. Mat. Res. 7
w49x R.A. Buchanan, J.G. Kim, Proceedings of the Sixth Annual Ž1992. 2089.
Conference On Fossil Energy Materials, Oak Ridge Natl.
w59x V.K. Sikka, B.G. Gieseke, R.H. Baldwin, in: K. Natesan, D.J.
Lab., 1992, p. 315.
w50x R.S. Buchanan, J.G. Kim, R.E. Ricker, L.A. Heldt, in: N.S. Tillack ŽEds.., Heat Resistant Materials, ASM, Materials
Park, OH, 1991, p. 363.
Stoloff, V.K. Sikka ŽEds.., Physical Metallurgy and Processing
of Intermetallic Compounds, Chapman and Hall, 1996, p. w60x R.S. Sundar, D.H. Sastry, Indian Inst. of Science, Bangalore,
517. unpublished, 1996.
w51x D.B. Kasul, L.S. Heldt, in: R.H. Jones, R.E. Ricker ŽEds.., w61x B.K. Kad, J.A. Horton, Mater. Sci. Eng., 1997;A239-240:118.

You might also like