Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Service Management Model Based On Lean Service Tools To Increase The Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian Smes in The Sports Sector
Service Management Model Based On Lean Service Tools To Increase The Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian Smes in The Sports Sector
Facultad de Ingeniería
Carrera de Ingeniería Industrial
Asesor
Alberto Enrique Flores Pérez
Lima – Perú
Julio de 2023
ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy Santiago Andres et al.
115
Service Management Model based on Lean Service Tools to Increase the Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian
SMEs in the Sports Sector ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy
study shows that, in order to reduce this abandonment rate, the 2.2 Systematic Layout Planning
behavior of the customers must be analyzed, considering the study The Systematic Layout Planning tool has been used to design the
of strategies of loyalty and personalization of the service. These best layout alternative and minimize the material transfer time that
kinds of problems lead us to thinking that there are shared occurs in a production plant [14]. Despite this, it is observed that in
problems within the customers of the sports industry. Increasing a service process, there are activities that do not add value, such as
the effectiveness of the processes, and reducing the service waste, waiting time, over processing, unnecessary movements, and
can lead to greater customer satisfaction, and as a consequence unnecessary transportation [15]. Not having a standard layout
increase the level of productivity of the company. planned is identified as one of the main causes of the mentioned
For this research, a case study was chosen based on a sports problem, considering that an effective layout can decrease
industry Peruvian SME, which reflects the problem of low operating costs by 10-30% [16]. To successfully achieve the
productivity and high service waste, demonstrated in the application of this tool, the current layout must be evaluated,
percentage of productive time related to the rental of football however, this is a challenging task considering subjective objectives
fields. The largest waste identified is the circuit assembly time, of quantitative and qualitative nature [17]. Implementing standard
which refers to the number of minutes it takes for the workers to layouts through this tool, will allow fast flow of materials with the
set-up the circuits and leave the field ready for training to begin. least amount of handling [18]. However, it should be noted that this
This research will offer a service model, where the set-up times are tool cannot be applied to all contexts in the same way, since each
arranged, and a standard layout is established, to reduce service layout design has its own characteristics and limitations [19]. On
waste, and as a consequence increase the number of shifts the other hand, some success cases such as Ruiz et al. [20], mention
available per day from five to seven. Although there is research that that the use of this SLP tool reduced the cycle time from 33.64
relates Lean Service practices with companies belonging to the minutes to 25.32 minutes. Furthermore, in a Peruvian footwear
sports industry, it is considered pertinent to apply knowledge of production company, the main problem was the delivery of orders
set-up time and standard work to increase the productivity of a and by implementing SLP it was fulfilled by 100%, in addition to
SME belonging to this sector. increasing production capacity, reducing defective products by 3%
Considering that there is no scientific literature in the Peruvian and increasing productivity by 8% [21].
context regarding this economic sector, a need was identified to
conduct research in this field of study. The scientific article will be
divided in six parts: Introduction, State of the Art, Contribution, 2.3 5S Methodology for Work Area Organization
Validation, Discussion, and Bibliography. The implementation of 5S brings the plant to an orderly, organized
state and results in improved overall product productivity [7].
2 STATE OF THE ART However, some companies find it difficult to assimilate the 5S
principles and believe that it is only a cleaning process [22]. This
2.1 Standard Work in Service Industry methodology follows five essential steps: classify, sort, clean,
Standard work seeks to identify appropriate ways of executing a standardize, and maintain [23]. For the first step, unnecessary
job, that guarantees good results, and that generates satisfaction items in the warehouse must be sorted and separated, second, the
to the worker who performs this work [6]. The goal of necessary materials are organized to be available quickly. The third
standardization is to create best practices and get every team step seeks to have a clean work area and the fourth step
member to use the established best practices in the same way [7]. standardizes the previous three steps by repetition. Finally, the fifth
Moreover, according to Mogaramendi et al [8], if the step maintains what was established in the previous four steps [24].
implementation is executed correctly, the benefits are visible, and Thus, in the case study conducted by Gupta & Jain [7], quite a few
the creativity of workers can be increased. In addition, this tool improvements were achieved. It was observed that workers used
gives the freedom to work teams to organize themselves and to spend on average 30 minutes a day looking for a tool, after
implement standardization as they see fit [9]. On the other hand, applying the 5S, the average time was only five minutes a day, thus
according to Ribeiro et al. [10], this tool generates stability and saving a significant amount of money. In addition, standard
autonomy in workers. Furthermore, it is observed that non- operating procedures (SOPs) were used to specify which materials
standardized work increases processing time and process waste, as and tools are needed to perform the job. With these, workers can
well as the proportion of defective products [11]. On the other monitor work efficiency and improve their performance. On the
hand, the case study of standardized work implementation by other hand, León-Enrique et al [24], the implementation of tools
Aisyah et al. [12], obtained a time 2 seconds faster than the managed to increase productivity in the unloading and storage
required takt time and thus was able to meet the customer’s needs processes by 40%.
of 1200 pieces/day, evidencing the success of the tool. In addition,
in a case of improvement by Canales-Jeri, et al. [13], a remarkable
3 PROPOSED MODEL
improvement can be evidenced regarding the out-of-time
deliveries that represented 60% of the deliveries made and were For the model proposal, a literature review was carried through,
reduced to 29.9%. and Table 1 below shows the authors who have contributed the
most to identify the tools required for the model.
116
ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy Santiago Andres et al.
Figure 1 shows the proposal for the redesign of the assembly Systematic Layout Planning will redefine where the boxes will be
process for the circuits, focusing on a productivity improvement. placed for the circuit set-up process. The integration of these three
The innovation of this model lies in the fact that the use of these tools should decrease the set-up time, allowing the case study
tools to improve the productivity of a company belonging to the company to add two shifts to the regular schedule, increasing the
sports industry had not been found before. The model seeks to total capacity of the service provided.
decrease the setup time from 30 to 10 minutes, in order to allow 3.1 Model Components
two new shifts to be added to the regular schedule. Standardized The model is divided into three components, which will be
work will be used for the set-up times, while 5s will be applied for explained below.
the redistribution of boxes and sport instruments in these.
Table 1: Comparative Matrix of the Proposal’s Components vs. State of the Art
Authors/ Causes Decrease of set-up process Standard Layout Work Area Organization
time
Supriyanto, H., & Saputra, Y. A. Lean Service
(2019).
Alfiansyah, N. , Awibowo, S. , Time study Systematic Layout Planning DMAIC
Saraswati T. 2020.
Tarigan U., Ishak A., Hutauruk Y.O., Lean Service Systematic Layout Planning
Siregar K., Sari R.M. 2020.
Ruiz, S., Simón, A., Sotelo, F., & Systematic Layout Planning 5S
Raymundo, C. (2019).
Ke Yang. 2021. Systematic Layout Planning
117
Service Management Model based on Lean Service Tools to Increase the Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian
SMEs in the Sports Sector ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy
3.1.1 Component 1: Problem Analysis. The first phase is composed indicators, which will be observed later, and demonstrate if it is
of the diagnosis of the company. This allowed us to build a problem really possible to achieve a substantial change in the productivity
tree of the causes that may be generating the problem identified of “Pro Amateur Fútbol” company. The results are controlled by the
118
ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy Santiago Andres et al.
objective of revisiting key performance indicators established the service. Figure 3 shows the simulation of the circuit set-up
before the implementation. process.
The second scenario simulates the proposed model, where the
4.3 Improvement - Simulation Proposal three tools are already applied. The simulation of the proposed
model also represents a full working day. It begins with the arrival
Prior to the simulation, field data was collected regarding set-up
of a group of clients with a constant frequency of 1.5 hours
process time on multiple occasions. This data was used for the
between groups. During visits to the company, it was observed that
validation of two different simulations, in which we compared the
119
Service Management Model based on Lean Service Tools to Increase the Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian
SMEs in the Sports Sector ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy
120
ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy Santiago Andres et al.
publishing company from the SMEs sector,” Processes, vol. 7, no. 10, 2019, doi:
10.3390/pr7100646.
[12] S. Aisyah, H. H. Purba, and S. Dwi Setiaji, “Analysis Work Standardization Using
the Standardized Work Combination Table on CNC of Mission Case Line Process
at PT Astra Otoparts, Tbk-Nusametal Division,” in IOP Conference Series:
Materials Science and Engineering, 2020, vol. 1003, no. 1. doi:
10.1088/1757899X/1003/1/012044.
[13] L. Canales-Jeri, V. Rondinel-Oviedo, A. Flores-Perez, and M. Collao-Diaz, “Lean
model applying JIT, Kanban, and Standardized work to increase the productivity
and management in a textile SME.,” in ACM International Conference Proceeding
Series, Jan. 2022, pp. 79–84. doi: 10.1145/3524338.3524351.
[14] Sunardi, J. Ananda Esya, and B. Santoso, “Redesign of the Production Facility
Layout by Using Systematic Layout Planning Method at Cahaya Bintang Mas
Company Surabaya,” in Journal of Physics: Conference Series, 2020, vol. 1569, no.
3. doi: 10.1088/1742-6596/1569/3/032007.
[15] U. Tarigan, A. Ishak, Y. O. Hutauruk, K. Siregar, R. M. Sari, and U. P. P. Tarigan,
“Implementation of Lean Services and Facility Layout to Improve Health Clinical
Service Processes,” in IOP Conference Series: Materials Science and
Engineering, 2020, vol. 1003, no. 1. doi: 10.1088/1757-899X/1003/1/012031.
[16] D. Suhardini, W. Septiani, and S. Fauziah, “Design and Simulation Plant Layout
Using Systematic Layout Planning,” in IOP Conference Series: Materials Science
and Engineering, 2017, vol. 277, no. 1. doi: 10.1088/1757-899X/277/1/012051.
[17] E. C. Maina, P. N. Muchiri, and J. N. Keraita, “Improvement of Facility Layout Using
Systematic Layout Planning,” IOSR Journal of Engineering (IOSRJEN), vol. 8, no.
5, May 2018.
[18] A. Nagi and S. Altarazi, “Integration of value stream map and strategic layout
planning into DMAIC approach to improve carpeting process,” Journal of
Industrial Engineering and Management, vol. 10, no. 1, pp. 74–97, 2017, doi:
10.3926/jiem.2040.
[19] A. P. Lista, G. L. Tortorella, M. Bouzona, S. Mostafad, and D. Romeroe, “Lean
layout design: a case study applied to the textile industry,” Production, vol. 31,
2021, doi: 10.1590/0103-6513.20210090.
[20] S. Ruiz, A. Simón, F. Sotelo, and C. Raymundo, “Optimized plant distribution and
5S model that allows SMEs to increase productivity in textiles,” in Proceedings
of the LACCEI international Multi-conference for Engineering, Education and
Technology, 2019, vol. 2019-July. doi: 10.18687/LACCEI2019.1.1.59.
[21] S. E. M. Silvestre, V. D. P. Chaicha, J. C. A. Merino, and S. Nallusamy,
“Implementation of a Lean Manufacturing and SLP-based system for a footwear
company,” Production, vol. 32, 2022, doi: 10.1590/0103-6513.20210072.
[22] J. S. Randhawa and I. S. Ahuja, “Evaluating impact of 5S implementation on
business performance,” International Journal of Productivity and Performance
Management, vol. 66, no. 7, pp. 948–978, 2017, doi: 10.1108/IJPPM-08-2016-
0154.
[23] V. Chero-Alvarado and A. Panchana, “Application of the 5S methodology in line
number # 1 of classification and packaging of a shrimp packing company located
in Duran,” Journal of Asia Pacific Studies, vol. 5, no. 3, pp. 598–610, Jan. 2019.
[24] E. Leon-Enrique, V. Torres-Calvo, M. Collao-Diaz, and A. Flores-Perez,
“Improvement model applying SLP and 5S to increase productivity of storaging
process in a SME automotive sector in Peru.,” in ACM International Conference
Proceeding Series, 2022, pp. 219–225. doi: 10.1145/3524338.3524372.
[25] T. K. Kamma, N. V. S. Shankar, S. Jajimogala, S. Rama Krishna, and Shabana, “A
case study of service firm to optimize the cycle time – advanced lean techniques
to design plant layout,” in Proceedings of the International Conference on
Industrial Engineering and Operations Management, 2020, vol. 59, pp. 1609–
1634.
121
Service Management Model based on Lean Service Tools to Increase the Productivity Level of Operations in Peruvian
SMEs in the Sports Sector ICIEA-EU 2023, January 09–11, 2023, Rome, Italy
122