Professional Documents
Culture Documents
O 6048/CT/RC
C
Your ref: EastMabrur/Bina(KLIA)
Date: 29.2.2024
Dear Sirs,
Re: P
etaling Jaya Sessions Court Civil No. BB-B52NCvC-12-02/2023
Mohd Jumaadilakhir Bin Mohd. Yusoff … Plaintiff
Binalite Electrical Engineering Sdn Bhd … Defendant
We refer to the above matter and to our letter dated 28.2.2024.
2. lease find attached a copy of the sealed Notice of Application (Enclosure33)dated28.2.2024by
P
way of service on you as the solicitors for the Plaintiff.
Thank you.
Y ours faithfully,
Christine Toh & Co
yan Cheong
R
Associate
Page1of1
BB-B52NCvC-12-02/2023
Encl No. 33
ANTARA
OHD. JUMAADILAKHIR BIN MOHD. YUSOFF
M
(No K/P.:830318-11-5397) … PLAINTIF
DAN
NOTIS PERMOHONAN
(Permohonan Pemindaan Defendan)
BENARKAN SEMUA PIHAK berkenaan hadir di hadapan Hakim (atau Pendaftar)
dalam Kamar pada ………………., pada …………. haribulan
…………………………., 2024 pada jam ………… pagi/petang untukpendengaran
satu permohonan menurut Aturan 20 Kaedah 5 Kaedah-Kaedah Mahkamah 2012
dan/atau atas bidang kuasasediaadaMahkamahinimenurutAturan92Kaedah4
Kaedah-kaedah Mahkamah 2012 bagi pihak Defendan untuk Perintah-Perintah
yang berikut:
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
Notis Permohonan (Permohonan Pemindaan Defendan) 2
4. Relif-relif lain dan/atau lanjut yang dianggap sesuai dan patut oleh
Mahkamah yang Mulia ini.
1. Pindaan tersebut adalah bona fide dan diperlukan untuk mencerminkan
semua fakta-fakta kes tersebut.
3. PindaantersebuttidakakanmemprejudiskanpihakPlaintifdalamcarayang
tidak dapat dipampas dengan kos.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
Notis Permohonan (Permohonan Pemindaan Defendan) 3
4. Prejudis terhadap pihak Defendan adalah lebih teruk sekiranya pindaan
tidak dibenarkan oleh kerana fakta-fakta kes ini tidak akan dicerminkan
dengan betul.
………………………………
endaftar
P
Mahkamah Sesyen
Petaling Jaya
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
LAMPIRAN A
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
DALAM MAHKAMAH SESYEN DI PETALING JAYA
DALAM NEGERI SELANGOR DARUL EHSAN
GUAMAN SIVIL NO.: BB-B52NCvC-12-02/2023
ANTARA
OHD. JUMAADILAKHIR BIN MOHD. YUSOFF
M
(No K/P.:830318-11-5397) … PLAINTIF
DAN
PEMBELAANTERPINDA DICADANG
Pengenalan
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
PembelaanTerpinda Dicadang 2
Pembelaan
4. Defendan telah mengarahkan peguamcaranya, Christine Toh & Co, untuk
menghantar satu surat bertarikh 25.7.2023 kepada Plaintif untuk
memperolehi dokumen-dokumen yang dirujuk oleh Plaintif dalam
plidingnya. Defendan merizabkan hak untuk meminda Pembelaan tersebut
selepas menerima dokumen-dokumen tersebut.
7. Perenggan3PernyataanTuntutanadalahdinafikandanPlaintifdiletakkandi
atas beban bukti yang kukuh.
8. Perenggan4PernyataanTuntutanadalahdinafikandanPlaintifdiletakkandi
atas beban bukti yang kukuh. Defendan menyatakan bahawaPlaintifgagal,
enggan dan/atau abai untuk menyelesaikan kerja-kerja menurut
syarat-syarat perjanjian antara pihak-pihak dan/atau arahan Defendan.
9. Kecuali dan melainkan bahawa Plaintif telah menghantar satu inbois
bertarikh 25.10.2017 kepada Defendan, perenggan 5 Pernyataan Tuntutan
adalah dinafikan dan Plaintif diletakkan di atas beban bukti yang kukuh.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
PembelaanTerpinda Dicadang 3
10. Perenggan-perenggan6dan7PernyataanTuntutanadalahdinafikandengan
setegas-tegasnya dan Plaintif diletakkan di atas beban bukti yang kukuh.
11. Perenggan8PernyataanTuntutanadalahdinafikandanPlaintifdiletakkandi
atas beban bukti yang kukuh. Defendan mengulangi perenggan 9 di atas.
12. Kecuali dan melainkan bahawa Plaintif menghantar satu notis tuntutan
bertarikh 9.1.2023 kepada Defendan, pPerenggan 9 Pernyataan Tuntutan
adalah dinafikan dan Plaintif diletakkan di atas beban bukti yang kukuh.
13. Berdasarkan alasan di atas, perenggan-perenggan 10 dan 11 Pernyataan
Tuntutanadalahdinafikansecarasetegas-tegasnyadanPlaintifdiletakkandi
atas beban bukti yang kukuh.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
TRANSLATION
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
IN THE SESSIONS COURT OF PETALING JAYA
IN THE STATE OF SELANGOR DARUL EHSAN
CIVIL SUIT NO: BB-B52NCvC-12-02/2023
BETWEEN
OHD. JUMAADILAKHIR BIN MOHD. YUSOFF
M
(NRIC No.:830318-11-5397) … PLAINTIFF
AND
PROPOSED AMENDEDDEFENCE
Introduction
1. This is the Defendant’s Defence to the Plaintiff’s Statement of Claim dated
8.2.2023 (“Statement of Claim”).
2. The Defendant states that the Statement of Claim discloses no reasonable
cause of action, is scandalous, frivolous or vexatious, may prejudice,
embarrass and/or delay the fair trial of this action and/or otherwise is an
abuse of the process of this Honourable Court.
3. TheDefendantstatesthatthisDefenceisfiledwithoutprejudicetotherights
of the Defendant to initiate anyproceedingsand/ortofileanyinterlocutory
applications against the Plaintiff.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
Proposed AmendedDefence 2
Defence
4. The Defendant has instructed its solicitors, Christine Toh & Co, to issue a
letterdated25.7.2023tothePlaintiffrequestingfordiscoveryofsomeofthe
documents referred to by the Plaintiff in its pleadings and/or affidavit. The
Defendant reserves its rights to amend the Defence upon receipt of the
documents.
6. Save and except for the Defendant’s registered address, paragraph 2 of the
StatementofClaimisdenied.Atallmaterialtimes,theDefendant’sbusiness
address,No.100-1,JalanPJU3/8,TamanPuncakJalil,BandarPutraPermai,
Seri Kembangan, 43300 Selangor Darul Ehsan.
8. Paragraph 4 of the Statement of Claim is denied and the Plaintiff is put to
strict proof thereof. The Defendant states that the Plaintiff failed, refused
and/orneglectedtocompletetheworksinaccordancewiththetermsofthe
parties’ agreement and/or the Defendant’s instructions.
9. Save and except for the fact that the Plaintiff had issued an invoice dated
25.10.2017totheDefendant,paragraph5oftheStatementofClaimisdenied
and the Plaintiff is put to strict proof thereof.
10. Paragraphs6and7oftheStatementofClaimarevehementlydeniedandthe
Plaintiff is put to strict proof thereof.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal
Proposed AmendedDefence 3
11. Paragraph 8 of the Statement of Claim is denied and the Plaintiff is put to
strict proof thereof. The Defendant reiterates paragraph 9 above.
12. SaveandexceptforthefactthatthePlaintiffissuedaletterofdemanddated
9.1.2023totheDefendant,pParagraph9oftheStatementofClaimisdenied
and the Plaintiff is put to strict proof thereof.
13. Basedonthereasonsabove,paragraphs10and11oftheStatementofClaim
are vehemently denied and the Plaintiff is put to strict proof thereof.
14. Save insofar as expressly admitted hereinafter, the Defendant denies each
and every allegation of the Plaintiffs as if the same were set forth herein
seriatim and specifically denied.
This Proposed Amended Defence is filed by Christine Toh & Co,solicitorsforthe
DefendantwithanaddressforserviceatA-10-3,MenaraUOABangsar,No.5,Jalan
Bangsar Utama 1, 59000 Kuala Lumpur.
S/N QLAkKQZyWkKsfZOY92TwZA
**Note : Serial number will be used to verify the originality of this document via eFILING portal