You are on page 1of 10

COVER STORY /EV BATTERY

SECURITY IN
RECYCLING
Electric vehicles are key to decarbonise
mobility. India’s ambitious electrification
programme supported by upscaled domestic
battery manufacturing will require a secured
supply of battery materials. But the country
does not have enough mineral reserves. At
present, its electric vehicle sector is almost
entirely dependent on imported battery cells.
Recycling retired batteries can help the sector
hedge geopolitical risks, build material
security, while minimising environmental
hazards from the e-waste and staying on the
path to net-zero emissions. India needs to
revamp its Battery Waste Management Rules of
2022 for efficient and economic extraction of
the critical minerals through recycling.
An analysis by
Anumita Roychowdhury
and Moushumi Mohanty

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 26 10/10/23 4:04 PM


R
AJAT VERMA is a new-age scrap merchant. In 2018, he set up a
facility in Greater Noida, 30 km south of Delhi, which collects
lithium-ion batteries that have reached the end of their useful
lives in everything from consumer electronics such as laptop
computers and mobile phones to electric vehicles. Engineers and
scientists at the facility, Lohum, then carefully dismantle the batteries and
extract a variety of valuable materials locked up inside the complex
electrical components. Verma says in 2018, when the facility was set up,
consumer electronics used to be a major source of lithium-ion batteries. But
since early 2022, they have started receiving a significant volume of electric
vehicle batteries. Exigo Recycling at its plant in Panipat, Haryana, has
also started receiving lithium-ion batteries from electric vehicles. In
Gurugram, Siddharth Banerji, general manager at Battery Smart, which
runs India’s largest network of battery swapping stations for electric two-
and three-wheelers, tells Down To Earth (dte) that several electric two- and
three-wheelers are beginning to experience quicker deterioration in
performance, requiring early battery replacement.
The trickle of spent batteries has started even though India’s electric
vehicle market is at a nascent stage—most of the 3 million electric vehicles

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 27 10/10/23 4:04 PM


COVER STORY /EV BATTERY
in the country have been introduced largely These batteries are actually packs of
in the past two to three years after the lithium-ion cells that provide electricity.
Union government increased consumer These cells have three essential compo-
subsidy under the second phase of Faster nents: two electrodes (an anode and a cath-
Adoption and Manufacturing of Electric ode) and a medium called electrolyte (that
Vehicles in India (fame-ii) in 2021, and their transports ions between these electrodes,
batteries are not expected to have ap- thereby generating current). Typically, the
proached end of life. anode is made from copper foil with graph-
Though no official data is available to ite on it, while the cathode is made up of alu-
gauge the quantum of electric vehicle minium foil coated with lithium metal ox-
batteries that have been retired so far, the ides (lithium along with other minerals such
volume is expected to explode with India’s as cobalt, manganese, iron and nickel, de-
rising ambition for electric mobility. pending on the cell chemistry). The electro-
Amitabh Kant, India’s G20 Sherpa, during lyte is a lithium salt solution such as lithium
the convenings around the recently hexafluorophosphate.
concluded G20 Summit, stated that the The problem is India does not have
country plans to achieve 100 per cent reserves of raw materials like lithium,
electrification of two- and three-wheelers cobalt or nickel to hedge against
and 65-70 per cent electrification of buses uncertainties in the battery supply chain.
by 2030. India is also one of the 130 Currently, most of India’s lithium-ion
signatories to the Zero Emissions Vehicle battery requirements are met through
Declaration made at a side event at the UN imports, especially from China. This makes
Climate Conference (cop26) in Glasgow in India’s electric vehicle sector vulnerable to
2021. Though not legally binding, geopolitical turmoil. For instance, the
signatories to the declaration will ensure Russia-Ukraine war have brought about
that only zero-emission cars and vans are uncertainties in the supply chain increasing
sold by 2040. costs. Even before the war started, battery
niti Aayog in its 2022 report, “Advanced metals experienced a fair amount of
Chemistry Cell Battery Reuse and Recycling volatility. Prices of nickel, cobalt and lithium
Market in India”, estimates that the increased by 37 per cent, 41 per cent and 48
cumulative potential of lithium-ion batteries per cent, between February 2021 and
in India during 2022-30 will be around 600 February 2022, says a policy brief,
GWh across all segments in the base case. “Recycling EV Battery Material: Towards
Of this, 128 GWh will be available for material security and sustainability”, by
recycling by 2030 with 46 per cent (59 GWh) Centre for Science and Environment, Delhi.
coming from electric vehicles alone. These For self-reliance in batteries, the indus-
retired batteries have enormous potential to try needs unbridled access to these critical
power India’s clean energy transition. minerals. India is already working towards
securing overseas access to lithium mines
TRASH TO TREASURE and global supply chains and is also devel-
Under its “Make in India” initiative, the oping its own new mines. In June this year,
country aims to become a manufacturing it joined the Minerals Security Partnership
hub for electric vehicles. Companies are al- of the Critical Mineral Club, to catalyse in-
ready scaling up their operations at home vestments from foreign governments and
and abroad. However, this ambition is private sector in the critical mineral supply
fraught with concerns, particularly around and value chain.
the battery supply chain. Most electric While considerable focus is on sourcing
vehicles use lithium-ion batteries because virgin raw material from mines, yet another
they are energy-dense and offer improved source of supply that is drawing significant
vehicle performance. attention globally is reusing the material

28 DOWN TO EARTH 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 28 10/10/23 4:04 PM


rers
u factu
m an
e ll
oc
e st
Go
CELL MANUFACTURERS
India currently does not have
cell manufacturers, though a few
companies are in the pipeline

CELL INGREDIENTS
Cathode active material, used
in cells, is manufactured.
Ideal loop of BATTERY MANUFACTURERS
Most Indian producers fall in this
Companies in India in the
process of setting up such plants
circularity category. They import the cells to
assemble batteries
The material locked inside a
lithium-ion battery can have

Usage
NON-BATTERY
SECTORS infinite life if it can be extracted,
separated and recycled

SPENT BATTERIES
Generated from various
sources, such as
MATERIAL consumer goods and
o
ct i
n

EXTRACTION electric vehicles


Using a chemical process, olle
C
lithium, cobalt, nickel,
manganese, graphite, copper
and aluminium present in cells Source: Based on interactions with lithium-ion
are extracted battery recyclers in India

that is already locked inside the batteries in DISMANTLING Those battery packs that do not pass the
use and recycling them. Studies have estab- Using a mechanical laboratory testing are dismantled to the cell
lished that these materials can have an infi- process, spent level. The cells are tested for capacity,
batteries are
nite life if they can be extracted, separated internal resistance and other vital electrical
discharged,
into battery-grade materials and recycled. dismantled, crushed properties, which are used to predict the
and shredded to remaining useful life of the cell. Those found
SECOND-LIFE OPTION create a black mass fit for reuse are put into second-life usage
In electric vehicles, a battery is retired once such as grid storage; others are sent for
its performance degrades to 70-80 per cent recycling. In this phase, the cells are first
of its original capacity. “These batteries can deep discharged using a salt solution and
still be reused for non-automotive then passed through a crusher and a
applications, such as stationary energy shredder after drying. The resultant
storage,” says Verma. At Lohum, the spent material, called black mass, is a mixture of
batteries are first inspected for any damage all the valuable materials contained in a
and then tested in the laboratory to assess if lithium-ion cell. The black mass is checked
they can be reused. Lohum has set up a for quality and relevant batches go through
solar charging station for electric vehicles at extraction, which is essentially a chemical
its entrance which uses retired batteries. process in which first graphite is recovered,

DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWN TO EARTH 29

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 29 10/10/23 4:04 PM


COVER STORY /EV BATTERY
Prime reserves
Around 45% of global copper, 80% of cobalt and 75% of lithium reserves are concentrated
in just three countries
Top three countries, by share of global production and reserves for selected metals (percentage points, 2020)
Chile Russia Peru China DR Congo Australia Cuba Argentina

100
90
80
70
60
50
40
30
20
10
0
Production Reserves Production Reserves Production Reserves

Copper Cobalt Lithium


Source: Perspectives of Global and Domestic Companies on Advanced Chemistry Cells Battery Reuse and Recycling released, NITI Aayog, July 2023

followed by lithium, nickel, cobalt and and finally to synthesise cathode material
manganese in that order. These materials that goes into making a battery. Of the
can then be used to manufacture anode and handful of companies involved in recycling
cathode and are ready to enter the supply of lithium-ion batteries in the country, only
chain again. seven, such as Exigo, Attero, Rubiman and
The International Council on Clean Lohum, have ultra-refining facilities (see
Transportation, a US-based non-profit, esti- ‘Limited footprint’). That is also because
mates that globally, 1.2 million electric vehi- lithium-ion battery recycling is capital in-
cle batteries are expected to reach their end tensive. “Setting up a unit requires an in-
of life in 2030, increasing to 50 million in vestment of `100-300 crore for end-to-end
2050. Reusing 50 per cent of these batteries processing. Every batch of processed black
and recycling them efficiently can reduce mass and extracted salts needs to be sam-
the annual demand for new lithium, cobalt, pled, which is expensive. Testing, grading,
nickel and manganese mining by 3 per cent and crushing each cell is also a laborious
in 2030, and 28 per cent in 2050. and expensive task,” says Shambhavi
There is no denying the fact that retired Srivastava, business development manager
lithium-ion batteries can help India of Reteck Envirotech, an e-waste recycler
strengthen its battery material security. in Mumbai.
But this requires its recycling and refining
capacity to increase manifold. Currently, MARKET AMISS
most lithium-ion battery recyclers in the What’s worse is that in the absence of a
country deal with pre-treatment of spent strong domestic market pull—currently
batteries to extract black mass. There is lit- India does not have cell manufacturing
tle capacity for high-end refining for separa- capacity and domestic battery manufactu-
tion and recovery of battery-grade materials rers import cells and assemble them—

30 DOWN TO EARTH 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 30 10/10/23 4:04 PM


recyclers face a double jeopardy. They Limited footprint
depend on the global market for buying India currently has just seven players who can recycle spent
feedstock as well as for selling their final lithium-ion batteries to extract metals that can be reused
products, which defeats the very purpose of Exigo Attero
strengthening battery material security Panipat, Haryana Roorkee, Uttarakhand
through recycling. 7,200 tonnes/year 4,000
Gaurav Dolwani, chief executive officer
of Lico Materials, a lithium-ion recycler Ziptrax
with a plant in Raigad, Maharashtra, says Lohum New Delhi
the country does not have enough battery Greater Noida, 350
Uttar Pradesh
scrap or black mass to run the plants at full
10,000
capacity. So recyclers rely on diversified
sources of batteries, such as consumer
electronics, and on imports, which is a
cheaper source. Verma of Lohum claims
that his company has a licence to import
battery scrap. Most recyclers however prefer
importing black mass as the cost of freight TATA Chemicals
Maharashtra Batx
for battery scrap is high. A L N Rao, chief
1,200-1,400 Sikandrabad,
executive officer of Exigo Recycling, says
Uttar Pradesh
that in a shipment, it is difficult to ascertain
4,000-5,000
whether the batteries are fully discharged
Eco Tantra
and that can add to safety concerns. Battery Pune, Maharashtra LICO Materials
scrap has to be thus transported in special Applied for Raigad, Maharashtra
containers meant for dangerous goods and lithium-ion recycling 10,000
only a certain kind of vessel can carry them.
This makes the freight cost about twice the Source: Compiled by Centre for
cost of normal freight. Science and Environment, Delhi

On the face of it, importing battery scrap


or black mass for recycling appears to help Cobalt, lithium and nickel retrieved through
lock in more resources for recovery and recycling can be used in domestic industries
reduce the requirements for virgin raw such as steel and paints, he adds.
material. However, given the current Dolwani of Lico Materials also says that
protectionist trends in the global market, his company is able to extract cobalt sul-
most countries are trying to restrain export phate, nickel sulphate or lithium carbonate
of black mass to build their own battery from recycled batteries. But in the absence
recycling industry. According to the UK- of domestic cathode and anode manufactur-
based analytics firm Fast Markets, Europe ers, he exports those to China or South Ko-
may stop black mass exports by 2025. rea. Lico Materials is working with a domes-
Besides, importing is not going to help tic player, Epsilon Advanced Materials, for
India as long as the recycling industry sends manufacturing anode materials. “Once the
the final products to other countries. “The entire ecosystem is built, it will be possible
black mass is mostly exported for refining to to keep minerals in India and keep reusing
the global market, where it is priced them,” he adds.
according to the international price index,” Several domestic battery manufacturers
says Srivastava. such as tdsg International, Reliance Indus-
“Our finished product basically caters to tries and Exide are also in the process of set-
two sets of customers, export customers in ting up cell manufacturing. These compa-
the battery industry and domestic custom- nies should be able to produce lithium-ion
ers in non-battery industry,” says Verma. cells in the next three to four years.

DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWN TO EARTH 31

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 31 10/10/23 4:04 PM


COVER STORY /EV BATTERY

REVAMP
RECYCLING
RULES
Battery Waste Rules,
2022, only ensure that
retired batteries reach
recyclers. The rules need to
be revamped to make
recycling more efficient
and economic

A
s electric mobility is set to overhaul will also be required to file an annual record
the transportation sector, it offers a of sales and buyback with the state pollution
rare chance to make the system sus- control board (spcb) and ensure safe collec-
tainable from the ground up—to maximise tion and transportation of batteries to au-
the recovery of battery material while en- thorised/registered recyclers.
suring that heavy metals and other problem- The Rules have for the first time defined
atic toxins from this e-waste do not end up in measurable targets for collection and recy-
a landfill and contaminate the environment. cling within a compliance timeframe. They
A big step in this direction has been the have set a target of 90 per cent recovery of
notification of the Battery Waste (Manage- the battery material—70 per cent by 2024-
ment and Handling) Rules, 2022, which ad- 25, then 80 per cent by 2026, and 90 per cent
dress concerns around lithium-ion batteries after 2026-27 onwards (see ‘Recovery tar-
from electric vehicles. The Rules bring with- gets’). Producers will also have to include 5
in its ambit all manufacturers, producers, per cent of recycled material in the total dry
collection centres, importers, re-condition- weight of a cell by 2027-28, expanding to 20
ers, refurbishers, dismantlers, assemblers, per cent by 2030-31. In case of imported
dealers, recyclers, auctioneers, vehicle ser- cells, the producer has to meet the obligation
vice centres, consumers and bulk consum- by getting the same amount of recycled ma-
ers. The Rules say producers, which include terials utilised by other businesses or by ex-
battery manufacturers, importers and au- porting a similar amount of materials (see
tomakers that produce products with batter- ‘Old meets new’).
ies, “shall have the obligation of Extended To ensure compliance with the obliga-
Producer Responsibility (epr) for the Battery tions as well as safe and formalised recy-
that they introduce in the market to ensure cling of batteries that are in use, the 2022
the attainment of the recycling or refurbish- Rules mandates that epr registration sys-
ing obligations”. This means they will have tem will be managed online on a portal by
to collect, either directly or through third- the Central Pollution Control Boards (cpcb).
party vendors, waste batteries from the The portal, which is yet to be operational,
market and ensure the collected batteries will enable producers to engage a third-par-
reach authourised recyclers and not end up ty or recycler to collect and process the
being landfilled or incinerated. Producers waste and will empower recyclers to issue

32 DOWN TO EARTH 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 32 10/10/23 4:04 PM


Old meets new
Starting 2027-28, domestic battery manufacturers will have to use
domestically recycled materials in new electric vehicle batteries

20%
15%
10%
5%

2027-28 2028-29 2029-30 2030-31 and onwards


Share of recycled materials to be used in manufacturing new
electric vehicle batteries (% of total dry weight of a battery)
Source: Battery Waste Management Rules, 2022

with other producers who have not fulfilled


Recovery their epr commitments.
targets The Rules require cpcb to lay down guide-
lines for imposition and collection of “envi-
Electric ronmental compensation” on producers and
vehicle battery
recyclers who are non-compliant. Currently,
manufacturers
are now bound 59 automakers and 11 battery recyclers have
by law to collect 90% registered for recycling battery waste.
70% 80%
spent batteries and
put them in the NEED FURTHER REJIG
recycling channel 2024-25 2025-26 2026-27 Though a step in the right direction, the
and onwards
Spent batteries producers need to recover as % share 2022 Rules suffer from a few critical gaps
of new batteries they release in the market in a year that unless addressed can impede efficient
Source: Battery Waste Management Rules, 2022 and effective recycling. The labels on batter-
ies in India currently require to carry an
epr certificates to producers based on the icon (a crossed bin) which indicates that the
quantity of battery they send for recycling. batteries cannot be disposed of in regular
“When producers file their returns, they bins. The labels should also provide informa-
will have to declare how many batteries tion on the metals in the lithium-ion battery
they released in the market and how many to help recyclers identify what all can be re-
were collected and recycled to obtain epr covered. Some of the recyclers that dte spoke
certificates. cpcb will charge a fee for the to said that they employ chemists to ascer-
upkeep of the portal management and reg- tain the chemical composition of the battery,
istration of producers. We are currently de- which is time- and resource-consuming.
veloping standard operating procedures There is also a need to tweak the current
about the entire process and guidelines on policy so that it allows recycling-friendly de-
labels. spcbs are expected to audit the recy- sign of cells and batteries. Battery packs, for
cling centres and also monitor compliance,” instance, are screwed, welded and have
a cpcb official told Down to Earth (dte). module pieces stuck together with adhesive.
The portal will even allow producers who This makes separation of parts difficult. If
have surplus epr certificates to trade them screw connections and other joining tech-

DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWN TO EARTH 33

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 33 10/10/23 4:04 PM


COVER STORY /EV BATTERY
niques are standardised, it will enable auto- teries at vehicle dealer networks. As the vol-
mated disassembly of cells. Materials could ume of spent batteries increases, the infor-
also be designed for easier end-of-life man- mal sector may directly approach dealers
agement. For example, a water-based binder handling multi-brand products by outpric-
for electrode materials can reduce the use of ing formal collectors. This may lead to haz-
toxic solvents to separate the current collec- ardous practices in recycling.
tor from the active material during recy- Recyclers are also worried about the
cling. There are other concerns among the changing chemical composition of lithium-
industry. The epr strategy does not talk of ion batteries. After a series of incidents of
the budget battery manufacturers should electric two- and three-wheelers catching
earmark for collecting and recycling spent fire, domestic electric vehicle manufacturers
batteries. In the absence of this, the price are migrating towards safer, but less energy-
that producers might end up paying to dense lithium iron phosphate (lfp) batteries.
recyclers under epr might be too low, as These batteries are cheaper because they do
has been seen in the case of other e-waste not contain expensive metals such as cobalt
streams. “epr is linked to the actual produc- and nickel. From a recycling perspective, it
tion and the numbers need to be verified and is only lithium in these cells that brings val-
audited. What is happening in other e-waste ue. But the proportion of lithium is also min-
streams is that epr rates have come down to imal. If the recycler is only capturing lithium
single digits per kg. This means they are not carbonate (the form in which lithium is in-
processing the e-waste. They are just show- cluded in the cell) from lfp cells, it will be-
ing documentation and moving the same come unviable for the recycler, says Verma.
shipments round and round. Such low epr It might be financially challenging for
rates are not feasible,” says Dolwani. He says recyclers to handle lfp in India until the
in the absence of a mandatory budget, man- government comes up with a framework that
ufacturers at most agree to pay the spot can encourage original equipment manufac-
price which is set by informal recyclers and turers to pay recyclers, says Srivastava. He
this leads to leakages in the waste collection adds that recyclers in the US and European
chain as they typically lack infrastructure to Union are paid by vehicle manufacturers to
manage battery waste. recycle lfp as it has negative value.
This might not be a problem with electric The industry is also concerned over the
vehicle batteries initially as the market is lack of rules for storage, transport and
largely formalised right now with vehicle handling of electric vehicle batteries that
owners typically replacing their spent bat- may lead to serious safety concerns,

A PASSPORT FOR BATTERIES


It is an electronic record that each battery will carry in order to assist battery producers,
users, and recyclers in making informed judgements about battery life and quality
IN JUNE 2023, the European durability characteristics and informa- decisions and reliable verification of
Parliament adopted the Digital Battery tion regarding recycling. The informa- environment, social and governance
Passport that mandates battery tion is collected all along the battery’s credentials of suppliers. For recyclers
passport deployment by 2027. lifecycle. The concept envisions a it will allow for more efficient
A battery passport is an electronic multi-stakeholder consensus on scope disassembly and higher material
record for each battery in the market of data collection, access rights and recovery through better process
which carries information such as data ownership. The batteries can be control. These are important steps,
supplier information, material stamped with a QR code which can considering 17 per cent of the global
composition, manufacturer lead users to this information. battery demand by 2030 is believed to
information, performance and It improves material sourcing be coming from the EU.

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 34 10/10/23 4:04 PM


especially if the informal The EU’s “Fit for 55”
sector becomes more active in
FROM TAX REBATES, package has further
this. The 2022 Rules allow FINANCIAL INCENTIVES TO promoted automakers’
informal collectors and STRICT ENFORCEMENT OF interest in recycling by
transporters to be registered
EXTENDED PRODUCER requiring the publication
on the central portal. But they of battery carbon foot-
need to be organised as an RESPONSIBILITY, COUNTRIES prints, as well as by set-
entity as well as audited for ARE INNOVATING WAYS TO ting collection and recy-
environmental safeguards. CREATE A ROBUST ECOSYSTEM cling targets including
The other challenge lies in minimum recycled con-
the fact that several state gov-
FOR RECYCLING ELECTRIC tent requirements for
ernments have released their VEHICLE BATTERIES newly built batteries.
electric vehicle policies that In December 2022,
also talk of battery recycling. There is little the EU introduced new regulatory reforms
clarity right now on how these state-level aimed at building a circular economy for
policies will work in tandem with the 2022 electric vehicle batteries. The European
Rules. Delhi’s electric vehicle policy, for in- Commission has introduced new reforms
stance, promotes the reuse of batteries through a digital tool called “battery pass-
through private sector participation and en- port”. The tool seeks a carbon footprint dec-
courages establishment of recycling busi- laration for batteries sold in Europe start-
nesses. Punjab is promoting automakers to ing 2024 (see ‘A Passport for batteries’ p34).
issue buyback schemes for used battery Meanwhile, China has heavily incentiv-
packs. The state is also creating an e-mar- ised battery recycling with the intention of
ketplace to encourage resale of used batter- using recycled raw material available within
ies along with incentives to promote resale. the country. The regulations encourage
Telangana’s electric vehicle policy focuses standardisation of battery design, produc-
on reuse of lithium-ion batteries in stationary tion and verification to improve assembly
energy storage applications and promotes and dismantling of used batteries. This also
collaborations between battery and vehicle makes a provision for repairing and repack-
manufacturers, recyclers and energy storage aging for second life utilisation. Considera-
operators. It also provides incentives to ble recycling scale has been attained. Fos-
recycling businesses for ultra-processing. han-based Guangdong Brunp in China has
a capacity of recycling 120,000 tonnes of bat-
TAP GLOBAL LEARNING CURVE teries per year. This is the equivalent of
The country can learn from the experiences what would be used in over 200,000 cars.
and interventions brought in other countries Thus, global research efforts are looking
globally. The US Inflation Reduction Act, at improving the process to make recycled
2022, allows recycled battery materials lithium economically attractive. As the tar-
(lithium, cobalt, and nickel) to qualify for get for zero-emission transition gets more
significant tax credits available through the ambitious, and domestic electric vehicle
domestic materials clause, even if those ma- manufacturing and market grow, more
terials were not originally mined in the US spent batteries will flood the recycling mar-
or in countries with which the country has ket. Recovering the valuable material locked
free-trade agreements. Additionally, Califor- inside the batteries has to be the priority to
nia is bringing about policy reforms for end- improve material security, minimise waste
of-life reuse and recycling of batteries and and control environmental hazards. Battery
very stringent labelling regulations. The EU waste material is the new oil. D T E
has also instituted its End-of-Life Vehicles @down2earthindia
Directive that mandates automakers to take (With inputs from Rohit Garg, Mrinal
back vehicle owners’ end-of-life batteries. Tripathi and Rohan Malhotra)

DOWNTOEARTH.ORG.IN 16-31 OCTOBER 2023 DOWN TO EARTH 35

26-35Cover story_EV battery.indd 35 10/10/23 4:04 PM

You might also like