Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/344738348
CITATIONS READS
22 1,340
5 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Ruchi Tyagi on 19 October 2020.
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal,
Table 1 Terminology related to users’ behaviour (Source: IAEDSM Energy Efficiency Task 24)
Efficiency behavior vs These terms are referring to two of the many purposes of behavioral change, not
conservation behavior energy behavior itself aiming to achieve SDG 7
Investment behavior vs The first term is referring to acquisition of energy-related technologies (a behavior),
curtailment behavior the second to using less energy (a possible purpose of behavioral change)
Routine behavior vs intentional This dichotomy appears to be differentiating between the apparent degrees of
behavior conscious decision-making relating to a particular type of behavior. This is one way
(of many) to categorize types of behavior but does not define behavior. Furthermore,
degree of intentionality is more likely to be a continuum than a dichotomy (and
indeed a person’s specific behavior may alter over time along the continuum from
intentional to routine)
of terminology related to users’ behavior in line overall demand for energy. Table 2 shows a few
with the definitions stated above. examples of governmental and community efforts
to attain SDG 7.
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal,
Table 2 Examples of governmental and community efforts put to attain SDG 7
Country/agency Community efforts have been put to attain SDG 7
United Kingdom, Government of the United The United Kingdom has made remarkable progress with electricity
Kingdom generation decarbonized by 59% between 2008 and 2017.
A UK-based company has enabled almost one million small scale
solar installations (Skorupska 2019)
United Kingdom, The Climate Group RE100 of The Climate Group is a global corporate leadership
initiative bringing together influential businesses committed to 100%
renewable electricity. It aims to accelerate change toward zero carbon
grids at global scale. The initiative works to increase corporate
demand for – and in turn supply of – renewable energy
(theclimatechangegroup1)
United Kingdom, The Climate Group The Climate Group’s global EP100 initiative in partnership with
the Alliance to save energy brings together a growing group of
energy-smart companies committed to improving their energy
productivity and doing more with less. By integrating ambitious
energy targets into business strategy, leading companies are driving
innovation in energy efficiency and increasing competitiveness while
delivering on emissions reduction goals (theclimatechangegroup2)
Netherlands, Dutch Government The Dutch government has granted one of the first ever subsidy-free
offshore wind contracts to Swedish energy company. The 700–750
megawatts wind farm, called Hollandse Kust Zuid, will be located
14 miles off the Dutch coast and cover an area of 137 square miles. It
will increase offshore wind capacity in the Netherlands to 4,500 MW
by 2023 (Wentworth 2018)
Canada, Indigenous Communities Statistics collected by the University of Calgary researchers
confirmed more than 300 indigenous clean energy projects underway
across Canada, serving the needs of 190 communities. Nationally, the
clean energy sector is identified as an area of further prioritization,
with non-hydro renewables expanding from 2% to 11% over
2005–2015 and viewed as a major source of clean growth for future
generations (Segger and Harrington 2019)
Rep. of Seychelles Government’s environment Seychelles Energy Efficiency and Renewable Energy Program is
agencies and conservation NGOs encouraging the adoption of energy-efficient home appliances,
lighting consumables, and solar water heaters in the domestic
residential sector, made accessible to the public through an affordable
finance from the commercial banks. The project is expected to save
almost USD 30–40 million by the public electric utility to purchase
fossil fuels (Thande 2014)
and tentative paybacks of technical and behav- intensity is an indication of how much energy
ioral options. is used to produce one unit of economic output.
A lower ratio indicates that less energy is used
Why Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures to produce one unit of output. Energy conser-
Is an Inescapable Necessity to Attain SDG 7 vation measures across all sectors will greatly
Studies worldwide have underlined the significant contribute to achieving SDG 7. Users’ behav-
impact of user behavior on energy conservation: ior in each category has a collective impact on
energy conservation.
• UN’s SDG 7 vows to double the global rate of • Global emissions must peak in the next decade
improvement in energy efficiency. SDG Indi- and quickly decline for the world to stay below
cator 7.3.1 is the energy intensity measured in its Paris Agreement limits, according to the
terms of primary energy and GDP. Energy UN. As per the analysis carried out by
4 Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang...
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behav- energy consumption by 2040. (Source: Today in Energy,
ioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal, Published by Independent Statistics & Analysis, U.-
Fig. 1 World’s energy consumption by source S. Energy Information Administration, May 12, 2016)
(1990–2040). EIA projects 48% increase in the world’s
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal,
Fig. 2 Dimensions of Energy Management. (Source: Study material for CHC3160 Energy Engineering & Manage-
ment of Aligarh Muslim University, India)
Dr. Ben Caldecott at the University of Oxford, meaning young people will not have the luxury
younger generations will have to make do with of unmitigated emissions enjoyed by older
substantially smaller lifetime carbon budgets generations (Hausfather 2019).
than older generations if the Paris limits are to • User behavior has a significant impact on
be respected. This is because most of the allow- energy consumption in residential and com-
able emissions have already been used up, mercial buildings, and users can be influenced
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang... 5
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal,
Table 3 Technical and behavioral options of sustainable energy management
Tentative
Options Features Cost payback
Technical Technology change High cost More than
5 years
Technical supported with Addition and alterations Moderate 1 to 3 years
behavioral cost
Behavioral Administrative and corrective Low cost Less than 1 year
actions
(Source: based on authors’ interview with subject matter expert Energy Auditor, Shaikh Samsher Ali conducted on Jan 1,
2020)
to use less energy when exposed to feedback happy. Boots had recently shared that they
(Paone and Bacher 2018). succeeded in reaching their carbon reduction
• Most users who spent most of their working target 3 years early. They managed to curtail
days in the building were not familiar with the down emissions by 33%, exceeding a 30%
workings and benefits of the energy manage- reduction target set for 2020. This achievement
ment systems technology. There was no was the result, partly, of the implementation of
attempt by management to communicate and a behavioral change program. Another
support or reinforce what would have emerged manufacturing sector organization managed
as best practices working behavior that reduced to achieve an annual energy saving of 7%
energy consumption. Employees lacked the because of an extensive behavioral manage-
motivation to change their behavior to be ment program. Behavioral change programs
more energy-efficient (Onyango and Ciaran work in energy conservation. Even a small
2015). organization, without hiring any subject matter
• Utilities in the United States and EU expert to run a widespread campaign, can be
implemented behavior-focused programs in energy-efficient by having some clear struc-
the residential sector. A broader understanding ture, passionate co-workers, and a way of mea-
of consumer behavior can help utilities and suring the impact. At the end of the day, such
planning agencies align public policies that initiatives will have a positive impact on the
are suited to consumer needs and complement Earth’s ecosystems (Karlstrom 2018).
energy-saving technologies and practices. To • In his recent speech on June 12, 2020, the
realize maximum energy savings, technologi- Prime Minister of India mentioned that
cal interventions must be combined with Indians are saving a total of 1900 million
behavior-changing approaches in a utility’s Indian rupees every year due to the usage of
DSM program (Malaviya and Chandiwala LED bulbs. Carbon emissions have also
2018). reduced significantly due to that. Such planet-
• Nearly 25,000 MW can be saved by improving friendly development has always been the key
end-use energy efficiency and implementing priority of Indian governance.
DSM measures throughout India across all • There is a great influence of occupants’ behav-
sectors. Thumb rule is one unit of energy ior on energy use especially habitual and
saved at the consumption level reduces the purchase-related behavior. Barr et al. (2005)
need for fresh capacity creation by 2 to 2.5 examined the energy-saving behavior in
times (Tripathi and Powell 2020). home related to habitual-related and
• Behavioral change is the key to energy effi- purchase-related conservation behavior. They
ciency. Lower energy consumption results in a also considered the association between
reduced energy bill and will benefit the planet energy-saving behaviors and other environ-
with a reduced CO2 footprint making everyone mental actions. Their findings were used to
6 Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang...
investigate the characteristics of energy savers DSM by controlling morning and evening
as related to other environmental actions using peaks through lighting load. Such initiatives
cluster analysis. Among their findings, a range also have the potential to help save fuel bills
of energy saver personality and perceptual for power plants as well as reduce CO2 emis-
characteristics were identified including per- sion. This event has given a new perspective on
sonal comfort, concern for environmental and energy conservation.
energy-related issues, price concern, personal
responsibility to save energy, normative influ- Thus, the success of any policy or program that
ences on behavior, and self-presentation aims to conserve energy depends on users’
(Somuncu 2017). behavior.
• Behavioral impacts on energy savings, simula-
tions of building users’ adaptive behaviors,
Opportunities Identified in the Building
control systems for energy, and comfort man-
agement of buildings are among the critical Sector in Achieving SDG 7
By 2030, 60% of the world’s population will live
areas of research. Growing awareness about
in cities, up from about 50% today. Modern cities
how all these issues are interconnected is
required to significantly influence building account for 70% of global energy use and energy-
related GHG emissions. The building sector
energy use. Users’ behavior significantly
accounts for around one-third of the total final
impacts energy consumption in residential
and commercial buildings. Behavioral change energy consumption across the world and more
than half of electricity demand. Its energy demand
is also crucial to promote energy efficiency in
could be shrunk by, for instance, retrofitting
the building sector, and users can be influenced
to use less energy when shown the feedback. It existing buildings with more efficient heating
and cooling technology and switching to efficient
is difficult to quantify the impact of users’
lighting and other electrical appliances. This
behavior for methodological reasons. The
decision-making process of humans is com- energy efficiency initiative will potentially result
in an annual savings of US$ 555–770 billion (IEA
plex and multifactorial too. The factors
2013).
influencing behavior are also therefore numer-
40% of the global energy consumption and
ous and varied. Introducing energy conserva-
more than 30% of the global carbon dioxide
tion measures without factoring in users’
equivalent emissions are currently being attrib-
satisfaction may be a counterproductive exer-
uted to buildings. This makes the building sector
cise because users may try to adapt their envi-
the single most significant industry in terms of
ronment to obtain satisfying conditions.
carbon emissions (Goubran et al. 2019).
Emphasizing behavioral change would help
Various types of building material effects on its
in achieving higher energy efficiency (Paone
cooling load requirements. Taking conservation
and Bacher 2018).
measures to reduce cooling loads can have a sig-
• An appeal was made by the Prime Minister of
nificant impact on energy consumption. The win-
India to the citizens on April 3, 2020, for
dows, shading, wall structure, solar gains, and
switching off only lights at their respective
lights are all important factors that can be investi-
homes on April 5, 2020 at 9 pm for 9 min as
gated to achieve significant energy conservation
a mark of gesture for essential service workers
in buildings. The peak cooling load is a direct
during the pandemic. The total reduction in all
parameter for the level of energy consumption in
India demand recorded during the event was
buildings. Reducing load demand can reduce the
31,089 MW. That initiative indicated that the
operating electrical consumption and eventually
lighting load in the residential sector has the
promote energy savings. The best savings for each
potentials to help in managing demand-side
design depends on building’s location, orienta-
management (DSM) during peak hours. This
tion, window-to-wall ratio, type of lighting, and
initiative opened a window of opportunity for
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang... 7
people density schedules. There can be an oppor- in residential and public buildings. Energy saving
tunity for all existing buildings that are lacking lamps have lower energy consumption and longer
energy conservation measures to start optimizing service life. They additionally do not require any
the energy bills through the implementation of extra operational cost or maintenance. Inhabitants
feasible changes without having to change the in their houses can undertake installation of the
exterior walls. Designers can use building modi- energy-saving lighting appliances. Building
fications to save energy (Shehadi 2018). owners can install energy-saving lamps and mod-
Improving energy efficiency measures in ules in public areas, such as stairs, entrance tam-
building sector has received significant attention bours, and outdoor lighting systems (Dubey and
of researchers. Improving energy efficiency in Dodonov 2019).
buildings results in (a) less energy consumption
while maintaining comfort level, (b) saving Energy Conservation Measures for Home:
energy and money, and (c) minimizing harmful Example of Charles County in the United
emissions. A detailed simulation analyses States
performed to investigate the impact of various There is a need to remain focused on reducing
energy conservation measures focusing mainly carbon footprints within our areas of residence, to
on HVAC and lighting system in the residential include conservation of local and vital energy
buildings in Jordan confirmed reduced annual resources, as well the utility costs we each must
electricity consumption. The peak demand as pay for our utility services that are rendered at our
well as amount of carbon emission were also homes. Energy conservation measures can be
found reduced. The results of study confirmed implemented both at the workplace and at home
that combing the best strategy can significantly while ultimately achieving the individual demand
reduce the annual energy consumption of the and responsibilities we are challenged regularly.
buildings (Bataineh and Alrabee 2018). Several measures covering air conditioning, ven-
The building sector presents a unique opportu- tilation, water conservation, kitchen, leaks,
nity to improve energy efficiency substantially; energy-saving measures, cooking, cleaning,
both by retrofitting existing buildings and by etc. as indicated in Table 4 can assist at home
requiring higher energy efficiencies on newly and workplace in continued cost avoidance, as
constructed buildings. Countries can take several well in a reduction in excessive energy usage,
priority actions to increase the deployment of which is in most cases caused by wasteful behav-
technologies to enhance energy efficiency in iors and practices (Charles County’s website).
buildings. Regrettably, energy conservation is an
unnecessary expenditure and considered as a less Energy Efficiency Brings Investment
important operational activity in many third world Opportunity
countries (Ali et al. 2019). Achieving energy effi- Figure 3 shows the energy intensity in the New
ciency actually anticipates multiple perspectives Policies Scenario in different countries. Consider-
covering educational, technical, regulatory, finan- ing the example of India, (a) reduction in the
cial, institutional, technology adaptation, capacity Indian Energy scenario is expected to grow grad-
development, and private sector involvement. In ually International Energy Agency (IEA 2017).
countries where coal is still used for residential This analysis aims to inform governments,
heating, as it is the lowest cost fuel, the govern- businesses, and other stakeholders about the pros-
ment should promote the use of other fuels to pects for energy use in India and the role that
drive the adoption of cleaner technologies. Air- energy efficiency improvements offer in the
conditioning systems, lights, water heating sys- period from 2013 to 2040. It quantifies the poten-
tems, receptacle mount loads, etc. used in the tial energy savings and related carbon dioxide
building should be energy efficient (Ali and (CO2) emission reductions and the associated
Tyagi 2020). Heat from solar radiation can be costs and benefits of policies aimed at exploiting
used for domestic hot water and internal heating that potential. The report also includes energy
8 Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang...
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal, Table 4 Home
and workplace implementation of LCECM and energy usage (Source: Charles County)
Item Measure Outcome: possible energy savings
Toilet Not to use to flush tissues, gum wrappers, cigarette Avoid unnecessary flushing and save 7 gallons of
butts, spiders, diapers, or anything that can go to water each time
bin
Shower Not to spend too long in the shower Controls wastage of 5–10 gallons of water
pouring out per minute
Kitchen Load dishwasher fully before turning it on. Not to Controlling wastage of 15 gallons of water per run
let faucet run when scrubbing vegetables or of dishwasher. Controls unnecessary flow of water
preparing other food. Put stopper in the sink from the sink
instead
Leaks Seal and stop all leaks Saves 15–20 gallons of water daily
AC Select proper size unit. Have the dealer estimate Reduces operating costs as well as home cooling
your cooling load before you buy. Clean filter bills
regularly. Keep direct sunlight out of the room
Ventilation Use fan and other devices in summer economically. Improved efficiency, reduced energy use, reduced
A window fan pushing hot air out of one side of energy bills
room, but drawing cooler air from the steady side,
is particularly refreshing
Energy Use compact fluorescent light (CFL) or light- Reduced energy usage by 66%. 70% less heat is
emitting diode (LED) bulbs generated cutting cost associated with room
cooling
Cooking Not to open oven door which drops temperature by Improved efficiency, reduced energy use, reduced
25–300 every time. Use microwave ovens that use energy bills
70% less energy. Cook food in the morning so that
kitchen heat does not contribute as much to AC use
Clothes Dry loads of clothes back to back to take advantage Improved efficiency, reduced energy use, reduced
Dryer of stored heat. Clean filter after every load. During energy bills
cooling season, close the door to the room the dryer
is located. During heating season, leave door open
to allow more heat throughout the room
efficiency policy recommendations for each sec- affecting household use of energy (including
tor covered. (b) The opportunities for energy con- electricity) is limited:
servation in India exist both in industrial and
commercial sectors. As per the International 1. Energy usage behavior impacts energy
Energy Agency (IEA, 2017), it is projected to consumption with a saving potential of 72%
grow significantly in the next three decades in the domestic/commercial sector (Xiaoqi
(2013–2040) which will also create an investment Xu 2013).
opportunity in this field. Energy conservation 2. Energy Efficiency Service Sector will increase
measures will be applied in every possible sector twofold to fourfold by 2020 in Indian Power
like lighting, transportation, etc. Commercial Sector (Goldman et al. 2009).
3. Research on behavior affecting household use
Research Advocating “Energy Literacy” for of energy (including electricity) in India is
Behavioral Change in Energy Users limited (Residential Electricity Consumption
Energy usage behavior impacts energy consump- in India: What do we know? By Prayas –
tion with a saving potential of 72% in the Energy Group report 2016 for GoI).
domestic/commercial sector. Also, the Energy 4. Commercial Building Energy Audit by the
Efficiency Service Sector will increase twofold IAEMP recommended for behavioral training
to fourfold by 2020. Research on behavior for low-cost energy conservation (Indian
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang... 9
GJ per $1 000 (2014 PPP)
10 Reduction in the
India Efficiency
Scenario
8
Energhy intensity in
the New Policies
6 Scenario
0
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
2013
2020
2030
2040
India South Africa China Indonesia Southeast Mexico Brazil
Asia*
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal, Fig. 3 Energy
intensity in the New Policies Scenario. (Source: Energy Efficiency Outlook for India – Sizing up the opportunity,
International Energy Agency (IEA, 2017))
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Change for Sustainable Energy Goal,
Table 5 Examples of behavioral options for sustainable energy development in a few countries
Country Examples of sustainable energy development
Louisiana Results of a home energy performance study conducted in Louisiana showed that energy savings ranged
widely among homeowners who received and those who did not receive energy education. Homeowners
whose energy education was based on demonstration had 46% energy savings (Nahmens et al. 2012)
Seychelles Seychelles is implementing a USD one million project to equip homes with solar heaters. Piloting of
electric and hybrid cars is ongoing in Seychelles. At the University of Seychelles, in collaboration with
Tata Energy Research Institute, India, a course in renewable energy is being offered in Seychelles to train
middle managers in areas of energy management and planning for investments in renewable energy
technologies (National Report 2012)
Mauritius As part of strategy to achieve 35% self-sufficiency by 2025 in terms of electricity supply through the use
of renewable sources of energy, the government has developed relevant educational materials on
sustainable energy for use at schools, including primary and preprimary children. Appropriate training is
being given to build capacity and to develop a culture of sustainable development including energy
efficiency and energy conservation. Appropriate campaigns have been launched with the objective of
changing behavior at work and promoting practices aimed at rationalization of energy use in all big
buildings (Republic of Mauritius, Long-Term Energy Strategy, 2009–2025)
Fiji To increase renewable energy share in electricity generation and to decrease fossil fuel in Fiji’s energy
sector, efforts are on to change people’s behavior on how they use energy services or energy. Awareness
creation is going on. Fiji is preparing new building standards, minimum energy performance, standards,
and labelling programs, introducing hybrid vehicles, and planning for electric vehicles and other
programs to promote energy efficiency and conservation in a long run (Prasad and Raturi 2018)
Mexico Beliefs about consequences of adopting renewable energy technologies have significant influence in
shaping consumer’s attitudes in Mexico which were found to be an accurate predictor of the behavioral
intention to adopt these technologies. As an innovation attribute, a solar heater to be adopted should be
compatible with the social values of the consumer (Reyes-Mercado and Rajagopal 2017)
4. There is a need for a periodical study on resi- • Energy efficiency programs in India have
dential energy consumption along with the mostly focused on price and information.
training of its occupants for sustainable energy • Human behavior is a key factor that affects a
conservation (Biswas et al. 2008). It is found household’s decisions on buying and using
that the provision of comprehensive informa- appliances . . .. Understanding these behav-
tion about cost savings, payback period, and ioral tendencies can be useful to predict
emission reduction reduces the size of energy future consumption as well as inform policy
efficiency gap significantly from 10% to 2.72% interventions to curb it.
at the private level (Bhardwaj and Gupta 6. In industrialized countries, energy, transport,
2017). housing, and agro-food systems – which
5. Sustainability practices were learned habits between them deliver essential supplies and
due to the scarcity of resources (Vyas 2012). services to society – account for 70–80% of
For example, in India, residential electricity the negative environmental impacts of those
consumption has increased by 50 times since countries. Such systems can be described as
1971 and now constitutes about a quarter of “socio-technical” since they are comprised of
India’s total electricity consumption, up from technologies as well as social components
about 4% in 1971. including consumer practices. Socio-technical
• Various studies have projected a five to six research has been widely applied to the analy-
times increase in REC in India by 2030. sis of unfolding and future sustainability tran-
• In 2014, households accounted for about sitions, such as renewable electricity.
22% of the total of 883 billion units of Multilevel perspective (MLP) has been used
electricity consumed in India. to analyze both “green” technologies and
“social innovations” (T2S 2019).
Low-Cost Energy Conservation Measures and Behavioral Chang... 11
Conclusions Cross-References