Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Structures
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/structures
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Keywords: Corrosion significantly influences the mechanical performance of steel, and the accurate prediction of stress-
Q345 steel strain curves (S-SC) for steel after corrosion is crucial for the safety evaluation of in-service steel structures in
Corrosion engineering. This study focuses on assessing the degradation performance of Q345 steel following corrosion.
Mechanical properties
Copper accelerated acetic acid salt spray testing (CASS) is employed to corrode Q345 specimens, and a power
Microstructure
Constitutive model
model is established to relate the mass loss rate to the corrosion time of Q345 steel. Uniaxial tension tests are
then conducted to observe the mechanical behavior of corroded Q345 steel. Results indicate that the strength and
ductility of Q345 steel decrease with an increase in the mass loss rate, and the yield plateau of the S-SC gradually
shortens until it disappears. With the increase of corrosion time, the microstructure of the steel surface is
transformed from spherical structure to needle-like structure. Two constitutive models are developed, incorpo
rating the S-SC with and without the yield plateau, based on existing models. These models demonstrate good
agreement with various test data, providing valuable insights into the mechanical behavior of corroded Q345
steel.
* Corresponding author at: Laboratory for Computational Civil Engineering, Institute for Computational Science and Artificial Intelligence, Van Lang University,
Ho Chi Minh City, Vietnam.
E-mail addresses: Z.Kong@hw.ac.uk (Z. Kong), g.vasdravellis@hw.ac.uk (G. Vasdravellis), ba.dinhhuu@vlu.edu.vn (H.-B. Dinh).
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.istruc.2024.106264
Received 11 July 2023; Received in revised form 8 January 2024; Accepted 20 March 2024
Available online 23 March 2024
2352-0124/© 2024 Institution of Structural Engineers. Published by Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
Table1
Mechanical properties of steel after corrosion.
Specimen Corrosion time mass loss rate Modulus of elasticity E Yield strength fy Ultimate strength fu Elongation at break A Strength-to- yield ratio
ID (h) (%) (MPa) (MPa) (MPa) (%) fu/fy
Note: Specimen ID: XY-Z, X indicates the type of corrosion including sing-side corrosion (S) and double-side corrosion (D), Y shows corrosion time, and Z represents
specimen number, respectively.
of steel. Additionally, Kong et al. [11] identified two distinct micro constitutive models for Q235 and Q345 steel, underlining the dissimilar
structures on the surface of corroded mild steel: the flower-like micro mechanical behavior of corroded Q345 steel when compared to
structure (observed in Q235 steel) and the honeycomb microstructure corroded Q235 steel. Given that Q345 steel is widely employed in global
(observed in Q355 steel). The differing microstructures result in distinct construction projects as a medium-strength low-alloy steel, it is imper
mechanical behaviors for mild steel. ative to assess the safety of in-service corroded Q345 steel, which is
A constitutive model serves as a crucial tool for representing S-SC, critical to prevent engineering accidents and ensure the structural
and the accurate prediction of the constitutive relation is essential. integrity of constructions utilizing Q345 steel. In the safety assessment
Historically, various models have been developed by researchers such as process, a thorough examination of the mechanical performance of
Ramberg and Osgood [12], Hill [13], and Zener and Hollomon [14] to corroded Q345 steel is essential. Furthermore, the development of an
accurately estimate the S-SC for different grades of mild steel. However, accurate constitutive model is crucial for estimating the S-SC in corroded
limited research has been conducted on constitutive models for steel Q345 steel, providing a comprehensive understanding of its material
after corrosion. behavior and ensuring precise predictions for the reliability of safety
To date, Li et al. [15] have proposed a bilinear elastic-plastic assessments in structures incorporating corroded Q345 steel. This study
constitutive model to predict the S-SC of corroded mild steel. Addi aims to investigate the mechanical performance of corroded Q345 steel,
tionally, Xu et al. [4] and Wang et al. [16] developed a constitutive with a specific focus on developing constitutive models to accurately
model for corroded mild steel based on the quadratic plastic flow model. represent the S-SC. In addition to assessing the macroscopic mechanical
Notably, these previous works focused on Q235 steel, and there is a properties, the research includes microscopic analysis to elucidate the
scarcity of research on constitutive models for corroded Q345 steel. degradation behavior of Q345 steel after corrosion. This comprehensive
Q345 steel, characterized by medium-strength and cost-effectiveness, is approach will provide insights into the material’s behavior at both
extensively used in engineering structures, such as the National Stadium macroscopic and microscopic levels, contributing to a more thorough
"Bird’s Nest" in China and the Jinan Fenghuang Road Yellow River understanding of the mechanical performance of corroded Q345 steel.
Bridge in China. The chemical compositions of Q345 steel differ from
those of Q235 steel. Previous studies [3] have established distinct
2
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
2. Experimental program strengths of the specimen treated without de-rusting and the specimen
treated with manual de-rusting (brushes) is only 4.63%, 1.18%, and
In this study, a total of 21 Q345 specimens are designed, organized 2.70%, respectively. As a result, the impact of the physical de-rusting
into seven groups as outlined in Table 1. Two distinct corrosion sche method on the tensile properties of steel is deemed negligible and,
mes—single-side corrosion and double-side corrosion of steel spec consequently, has not been taken into consideration in this study. The
imens—are implemented, considering four different corrosion durations dimensions, including width and thickness, are measured using a Ver
(i.e., 0 h, 1440 h, 2880 h, and 4320 h). Standard samples are prepared nier caliper. Following these preparations, a uniaxial tension test is
for all specimens following the guidelines outlined in GB/T 228.1–2021 performed using a Z150 Tensile Testing Machine in accordance with
[17], as illustrated in Fig. 1. Prior to the Copper Accelerated Acetic Acid GB/T 228.1–2021[18].
Salt Spray (CASS) testing, the initial mass of each specimen is recorded.
Similar to the authors’ previous work [11], the CASS testing is 3. Analysis of corrosion results
employed in accordance with GB/T 10125–2021 [18], as illustrated in
Fig. 2. A copper chloride solution with a concentration of 0.26 g/L 3.1. Mass loss rate
± 0.02 g/L is prepared, and glacial acetic acid is added to achieve a
solution pH in the range of 3.1 to 3.3. The testing adopts an intermittent Similar with Xu et al.’s [21] method, the mass loss rate can be ob
spraying method with a spraying time of 6 h followed by a stopping time tained from Eq. (1).
of 6 h. The entire testing period spans 4320 h, incorporating four
m0 − m1
different corrosion durations. Fig. 3 illustrates Q345 specimens with η= × 100% (1)
m0
varying corrosion times.
After removing the Q345 steel specimens from the salt-spray cham where m0 and m1 represent the mass of specimens before and after
ber, brushes are utilized as physical de-rusting method to remove rust corrosion, and η represents the mass loss rate.
[19,20]. According to Liu et al.’s study [5], the differences between the Previously, Liang and Hou [22,23] introduced a power model for
initial axial tensile stiffness, the yield strength, and the ultimate predicting the mass loss rate, as shown in Eq. (2).
3
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
D is the density of the sample material in g/cm3; and Tis the corrosion
time in hours.
According to Eq. (4), the annual mass loss rate of Q345 steel is
determined to be 1.91 mm/y. Based on Liang and Hou’s investigations
[23] and the findings in this study, it can be inferred that the mass loss
rate of samples in the CASS for one month is comparable to that in the
natural outdoor environment in Shanghai, China, over a span of 13
years.
Fig. 5. XRD spectra of corrosion products. 3.3. Mechanical properties of corroded steel
4
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
corroded Q345 steel from sources such as Chen [29], Shi et al. [30], Wei
A′
[31], Feng [32], Qiao et al. [33], Wang [34], Gao et al. [35], and Hong’s RA = = 1.00 − 2.42 × 10− 2 η0.83 (8)
A
work [36], as illustrated in Fig. 8. The trends reveal that the strength,
modulus of elasticity, and elongation at break of Q345 steel decrease as Wherefy and f ′y are the yield strength of specimens with and without
the mass loss rate increases, as depicted in Fig. 8. Adopting a method
ology similar to Yu et al. [37] and Akbarian and Barghian [38], reduc corrosion, respectively; fu and f ′u are the ultimate strength of specimens
tion factors for mechanical parameters—such as the yield strength (Ry), with and without corrosion, respectively; Eand E′ are the modulus of
ultimate strength (Ru), modulus of elasticity (RE), and elongation at elasticity of specimens with and without corrosion, respectively;Aand
break (RA)—are introduced to account for the impact of corrosion, as A′are the elongation at break of specimens with and without corrosion,
shown in Eqs. (5)–(8). respectively; and η is the mass loss rate of steel. Note that yield strength,
ultimate strength and modulus of elasticity are all in MPa in this work.
f ′y
Ry = = 1.00 − 7.31 × 10− 3 η − 7.80 × 10− 5 η2 (5)
fy 5. Constitutive model of corroded Q345 steel
5
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
⎧
⎪
⎪ Es ε
⎪
⎪ ( )
⎪
⎪ ε ≤ εy )
⎪
⎨ σy (
εy ≤ ε ≤ k1 εy )
σ= Es (1 − k3 ) (
(
)2 k ε ≤ ε ≤ k ε (9)
⎪
⎪ k3 σ y + ε − k2 εy 1 (y )2 y
⎪
⎪ 2
⎪
⎪ εy (k 2 − k 1 ) ε ≥ k2 εy
⎪
⎩
σu
6
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
k2 = 110 (13)
k3 = 1.47 (14)
As depicted in Fig. 10, Xu et al.’s model [40] is not good for the S-SC
of corroded Q345 steel. Thus, a new constitutive model for the S-SC of
corroded Q345 steel is necessary to be developed.
Two different types of S-SC (i.e., S-SC with yield plateau (Type I) and
S-SC without yield plateau (Type II)) are found in this work, as discussed
in Section 3.3.
5.2.1. Type I
To accurately estimate the S-SC of corroded Q345 steel with yield
Fig. 9. Comparison of S-SC between Esmaeily and Xiao’s model [39] and
plateau (Type I), the control parameters of the S-SC in Xu et al.’s model
test data. [40] is modified according to the experimental results [36,41], as shown
in Eqs. (15)-(17) and Fig. 11.
( )
k1 = 10.92 − 31.47η R2 = 0.96 (15)
k2 = 64.34 (16)
k3 = 1.58 (17)
Fig. 10. Comparison of S-SC between various models and test data.
7
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
8
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
9
Z. Kong et al. Structures 62 (2024) 106264
(2) Corrosion has a significant impact on the mechanical perfor [14] Zener C, Hollomon JH. Effect of strain rate upon plastic flow of steel. J Appl Phys
1944;15:22–32.
mance of Q345 steel. When the mass loss rate reaches 15.31%,
[15] Li D, Xiong C, Huang T, Wei R, Han N, Xing F. A simplified constitutive model for
the yield strength and ultimate strength experience decreases by corroded steel bars. Constr Build Mater 2018;186:11–9.
18.67% and 13.32%, respectively. [16] Wang Y, Zhou X, Wang H, Kong D, Xu S. Stochastic constitutive model of structural
(3) The yield plateau of the S-SC of Q345 steel gradually shortens steel based on random field of corrosion depth. Case Stud Constr Mater 2022;16:
00972.
with increasing corrosion time, disappearing entirely when the [17] GB/T 228. Metallic materials—tensile testing—part 1:method of test at room
mass loss rate reaches 15.31%. temperature. 1-. Peking: Standards Press of China; 2021.
(4) Constitutive models are proposed to accurately predict the S-SC [18] GB/T 10125. Corrosion tests in artificial atmospheres—salt spray tests (-). Peking:
Standards Press of China; 2021.
of corroded Q345 steel, accounting for scenarios both with and [19] GB/T 16545-2015, Corrosion of metals and alloys—removal of corrosion products
without the yield plateau. from corrosion test specimens. (In Chinese).
[20] Liu H, Chen H, Chen Z. Residual behaviour of welded hollow spherical joints under
corrosion and de-rustin. J Constr Steel Res 2020;167:105977.
Declaration of Competing Interest [21] Xu S, Zhang H, Wang Y. Estimation of the properties of corroded steel plates
exposed to salt-spray atmosphere, Corrosion Engineering. Sci Technol 2019;54:
431–43.
We declare that we have no conflict of interest. [22] Liang C, Hou W. Atmospheric corrosion of carbon steels and low alloy steels.
Corros Sci Prot Tech 1995;7:183–6.
[23] Liang C, Hou W. Atmospheric exposure corrosion of carbon steel and low alloy
Acknowledgements steel in 16 years. J Chin Soc Corros Prot 2005;25:1–6.
[24] Li J, Du C. Corrosion test methods and monitoring techniques. China Petrochemical
This work was supported by the Horizon 2020 - Marie Skłodowska - Press; 2007.
[25] Hu J, Cao S, Yin L, Liang Q, Xie J. Study on the corrosion behavior of Q235A
Curie Individual Fellowship of European Commission (No. SS-DSC carbon steel in RO product water of seawater. Anti Corros Methods Mater 2012;59:
01107320) and EPSRC Fellowship award (No. EP/Y020278/1), Excel 305–10.
lent Young Talents Fund Program of Higher Education Institutions of [26] Wu H, Luo Y, and, Zhou G. Corrosion behaviors and mechanical properties of Q235
steel pipes collapsing due to corrosion after 25-year service in urban industrial
Anhui Province, China (No. gxyq2022015), Postdoctoral Research Fund atmospheric environment. Constr Build Mater 2023;395:132342.
of Anhui Province, China (No. 2021B525), and Natural Science Foun [27] Dong J, Ke W. The accelerated test of simulated atmospheric corrosion and the rust
dation of Anhui Province, China (No. 1908085ME171). evolution of low carbon steel. J Electrochem 2009;15:170.
[28] GB 50011. Code for seismic design of buildings (-). Peking: Standards Press of
China; 2010.
References [29] Chen Y. Research on the degradation of steel structures for the needs of structural
life-cycle design and time-dependent reliability in corrosive environment.
[1] Hui Y, Lin Z, Li R. Experimental study and analysis on the property of corroded Southeast University; 2021 (In Chinese).
rebar. Ind Constr 1997;06:11–4. [30] Shi W, Tong L, Chen Y, Li Z, Shen K. Experimental study on influence of corrosion
[2] An L, Ouyang P, Zheng Y. Effect of stress concen tration on mechanical properties on behavior of steel material and steel beams. J Build Struct 2012;33:53–60.
of corroded reinforcing steel bars. J Southeast Univ(Nat Sci Ed) 2005;06:940–4. [31] Wei T. Study on the local bucking behavior of corroded h-shape steel short column
[3] Xu S, Ren S. The calculation model of elastic modulus and yield strength for under axial compression. Xi’an University of Architecture and Technology; 2019
corroded steel. Mater Mech Eng 2015;10:74–8. (In Chinese).
[4] Xu S, Zhang Z, He Y, Qin G. Experimental study on monotonic tensile behavior of [32] Feng D. Study on fatigue properties of Q345B steel after neutral salt spray
corroded steel in neutral salt spray environment. J Xi’ Univ Archit Technol 2017; corrosion. China University of Mining and Technology; 2019.
49:164–71 (In Chinese). [33] Qiao W, Yang F, Hu Q, Zhang H, Jiao X. Experiment on mechanical property
[5] Moreno E, Cobo A, Palomo G, González MN. Mathematical models to predict the degradation of Q345 steel after strong corrosion. J Traffic Transp Eng 2022;22:
mechanical behavior of reinforcements depending on their degree of corrosion and 231–46.
the diameter of the rebars. Constr Build Mater 2014;61:156–63. [34] Wang Y. Research on mechanical behavior of end-plate semi-rigid connection of
[6] Huang H, Jia C, Zhao O, Guo L. Local corrosion morphology analysis and hybrid steel frame. Harbin: Harbin Institute of Technology; 2018.
simplification of low carbon steel plates. Ocean Eng 2023;268:113372. [35] Gao S, Peng Z, Guo L. Experimental study on axial performance of concrete-filled
[7] Jin L, Zhang X, Liang X, Wang Z, Wu Q. Mechanical properties of corroded carbon steel tubular stub column under salt spray corrosion. J Build Struct 2019;40:214–9.
steel based on random pit corrosion in marine environment. Ocean Eng 2022;260: [36] Hong S. Research on carrying capacity of corroded high-strength bolt shear
111759. connections. Ma’anshan: Anhui university of Technology; 2021.
[8] Xu S, Zhang Z, Li R, Wang H. Effect of cleaned corrosion surface topography on [37] Yu QB, Zhao XP, Sun B, Yu AM, Chen B. Yield-strength ratio of steel plate for high-
mechanical properties of cold-formed thin-walled steel. Constr Build Mater 2019; rise building. Iron Steel 2007;42:74–8.
222:1–14. [38] Akbarian B, Barghian M. The effect of post-yield stiffness ratio on strength
[9] Cinitha A, Umesha P, Iyer NR. An overview of corrosion and experimental studies reduction factors due to ductility with an emphasis on iran’s strong ground
on corroded mild steel compression members. KSCE J Civ Eng 2014;18:1735–44. motions. J Civ Eng Urban 2013;3:310–6.
[10] Li L, Mahmoodian M, Li C-Q, Robert D. Effect of corrosion and hydrogen [39] Esmaeily A, Xiao Y. Behavior of reinforced concrete columns under variable axial
embrittlement on microstructure and mechanical properties of mild steel. Constr loads: analysis. Acids Struct J 2005;102:736.
Build Mater 2018;170:78–90. [40] Xu S, Wang H, Su L. Degradation law of mechanical properties of Q235 steel plate
[11] Kong Z, Jin Y, Hossen GMS, Hong S, Wang Y, Vu Q-V, et al. Experimental and in neutral salt spray corrosion environment. Mater Mech Eng 2016;40:86–91.
theoretical study on mechanical properties of mild steel after corrosion. Ocean Eng [41] Zhang H, Qiao W, Yang F, Zhu H. Tensile finite element simulation of q345 bridge
2022;246:110652. steel with strong corrosion based on J-C model. J Zhengzhou Univ(Eng Sci) 2021;
[12] W. Ramberg, W.R. Osgood, Description of stress-strain curves by three parameters; 42:99–104.
1943. [42] Ban H, Shi G, Shi Y. Research on design method for overall buckling behavior of
[13] Hill H. Determination of stress-strain relations from" offset" yield strength values. welded box columns fabricated from high-strength steels. J Build Struct 2014;35:
Pittsburgh Pa: Aluminum Co of America; 1944. 57–64.
10