Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Civil Engineers
Bridge Engineering 161
June 2008 Issue BE2
Pages 79–87
doi: 10.1680/bren.2008.161.2.79
Paper 800018
Received 27/10/2006
Accepted 25/04/2008
Keywords: Yew Wah Leung Jon Skipworth Button Andrew Yong Yiow Yap Kee Nam Ng
bridges/concrete structures/railway Director, YWL Engineering Director, Gammon Project Director Director, Circle Line
systems Pte Ltd, Singapore Construction, Singapore (Boon Lay MRT Extension), Stage 2 (C821/C822),
Land Transport Authority, Land Transport Authority,
Singapore Singapore
design, the prime objectives were to maximise separation from The selected superstructure form of a single-cell box girder for
buildings, minimise utility diversions, integrate with the both tracks of the guideway imposed a constraint to the
topography, maintain a high standard of passenger ride quality alignment design. The superelevation for individual tracks was
and ensure constructability by the proposed segmental method. made the same wherever possible, if other design criteria such as
These criteria could come into conflict and there were numerous train speed and passenger comfort allowed. If required, minor
consultative meetings between the owner, various authorities differences in the cant were fine-tuned by in situ topping of the
and partners. The process to finalise the 7$8 km alignment was running track (Fig. 5).
progressive and with many iterations; it took a period of
approximately eight months including determination of the span The proposed segmental method also played a part in the
layouts and all associative utility information. alignment design. Although the train can physically handle a
minimum horizontal radius of 22$8 m (at 11 km/h), it is not
The design of rail alignment is largely governed by the riding considered desirable for the segmental construction. According
comfort of passengers, which is defined by limiting perceived to specifications of the construction equipment such as the
acceleration and jerk in a journey. In this project, horizontal casting cell and launching girder, the smallest horizontal radius
curves were designed with a limiting value of 0$075 g acceleration in the deck was limited to 60 m and the maximum rate of twist
in the transition areas to
0$25% per metre.
80
Outer loop
track
Inner loop
track A11
A12
A13
Guideway length 8·3 km
Stations A1 – A14
Depot
A2
A14
A9
A3 A5
Outbound A6
track A7
A4
A8
0 50 100 250 500 meters
Inbound
Scale 1:1000 track
was readily adaptable to suit situations of utility obstruction structural system resulted in the final selection of a single-
and offered a relatively higher speed of installation. cell spine beam box girder combining both tracks to a double
guideway section (Fig. 5). The guideway spans are simply
Different structural forms were considered for the standard supported structures ranging from 15 to 34 m resting on
guideway superstructure. A dual 1$5 m deep U-shaped box pot bearings.
section supporting a five-span continuous single-track guideway
was initially considered. A critical review focusing on aesthetics, The advantages of the twin-tracked box girder section over the
functionality, stability and constructability of the integrated U-shaped single are
200
330
all piers, two bearings were
employed at the ends of the
2330
continuous deck so as to
1370
290
ensure rotational compatibility
with the neighbouring simply
supported spans. In addition,
180
internal single bearings were
1171 445 3300 445 1171 offset in order to avoid bearing
uplifts at the ends for all load
Fig. 5. Precast segmental double-track section (dimensions in mm) scenarios7 (Fig. 7).
A precast segmental deck with glued joints and internally The standard guideway section
prestressed tendons was adopted for the majority of the guideway is not suitable for accommodating the crossover or turnout
superstructure. In situ structures were adopted where there was a switches as these mechanical devices are deeper than the bogie
particularly complex geometry. The segmental guideway was guide beam. A number of multi-cell box girder sections were thus
designed in accordance with BS 5400,1–4 supplemented by the derived for these special structures. The external shapes of these
AASHTO specifications5 and system supplier design criteria6 for box sections are similar to those of the standard guideway as far
live loading and other system-specific details. as possible for form consistency. These spans are designed as
simply supported segmental post-tensioning structures.
Based on the characteristics of the horizontal alignment, the
spans are divided into two main categories—‘structurally straight’ 3. GUIDEWAY CONSTRUCTION
and ‘curved’ decks. The demarcation is at a radius of 120 m
governed by stability considerations. All ‘straight’ decks 3.1. Substructure and foundation
(R O120 m) are simply supported. Construction of the foundations for the guideway, being located
within a densely populated area and obstructed by many buried
For a number of curved spans at road junctions (Fig. 6), the span services, posed particular problems for the contractor. During
lengths were fixed based on topographical constraints and construction, many of the generic foundation designs had to be
stability limits. In order to allow the same launching method to modified to suit specific site conditions, which reflected the
be used, these spans were initially erected as simply supported flexibility of this fast-track design-and-build project.
structures with temporary tie-downs that were removed when
continuity was achieved. After passing of the girder, an in situ Noise and vibration were monitored carefully and, while the
stitch was formed at each pier location by connecting adjacent noise during pile driving was significant, this was accepted by
local residents due to the
relatively short installation
period. A driving rate of six to
eight piles per rig per day was
achieved, so that piling at each
cap location would generally
only take three days
including mobilisation.
82
All reinforcement cages were
prefabricated in the contractor’s
works area and installed by lorry
cranes operating alongside the
sidewalk. Special column
shutters were designed to
incorporate the crossheads,
allowing one monolithic casting,
in sections up to 12 m high.
These shutters also incorporated
access platforms so that easy safe
access was guaranteed. From
commencement of the
substructure caps to completion
of the columns took 50 weeks
and was sequenced to ensure
that the launch girders were
never delayed.
(a)
3.2.1. Casting yard. During
the design of the casting yard,
CL Deck due consideration was given
to the logistics and layout of
S.O.P. various facilities such that
efficient interaction between
them could be ensured. Special
50
50
150
segments and raw materials
450 mm diameter such as prestressing strands
and accessories; reinforcement
cutting and bending
at CL column
550 min
equipment; maintenance
Varies
L Column
of the casting yard is shown
in Fig. 8.
Bridge Engineering 161 Issue BE2 Design and construction of Bukit Panjang LRT, Singapore Leung et al. 83
N
84
Substation
and switchroom
gantry 28 mt
Ø50 mm Vertical pipe Downpipe Downpipe
Ø50 mm Ø25 mm Downpipe Downpipe Ø20 mm
Wash-Bay
35 t
Ø25 mm Ø25 mm
Long line storage
Ø50 mm
Incoming
1 Overhead pipe
Ø32 mm Ø4”
Jig
Jig
Jig
Cage Downpipe
Ø25 mm Overhead
Cage pipe
Rebar Ø40 mm Store Workshop
Cage
Jig
Jig
Jig
Pipe Ø50 mm
cutting Ø20 mm
Rebar
storage and bending
Ø20 mm Ø25 mm
Cage
Jig
Jig
Jig
Ø20mm Ø20 mm
Ø20 mm Ø20 mm
Ø20 mm Ø20 mm
Down pipe
Ø20 mm
Cage
Ø20 mm Ø20 mm
Ø25 mm Overhead Downpipe
Ø25 mm
Storage area
pipeØ40 mm
Storage area
Cage
Jig
Jig
Jig
Downpipe
Cage Ø25 mm Downpipe
Ø25 mm
1 Overhead
pipe
Ø32 mm
gantry 28 mt
Segment storage
35 t
Legend:
User point
0 5 10 20 50 meters Underground pipe
External pipe
Stop-cock
Water meter
Scale 1:1000
Weekly actual 79
80
54 54
52 52 53 53
50 49
50 48 48
4646 46 46
43 42 44
43 1500
40 41
38 39
40 37
32 33
31 32
30 1000
26
24 25
22
20
15
500
10
6
3 3
1
0 0
97
24
97
Ap 4
7
21
97
Ju 9
97
16
30
97
Au 8
97
Se 5
97
22
97
20
97
17
97
15
Ja 9
98
Fe 6
98
23
98
23
2
r9
2
b
ar
ay
ct
ov
ec
ar
Ju
Fe
O
M
M
M
D
14
6
7
5
10
9
10
9
11
3
8
1
5
transformed to the local reference frame of the casting cell. 3.3. Segmental deck erection
Geometric errors that occurred during a casting operation
3.3.1. Launching girder. Two overhead launching girders,
were controlled and adjusted in subsequent casting operations.
designed specifically for erecting the 60 m curved spans,8 were
Control points were fixed to the wet-cast segment before
tailor-made for this project. Overhead launching girders were
hardening of concrete for geometry control purposes.
selected because they minimise interference with other activities,
Surveys were carried out before and after casting a pair of conjugate
particularly in an urban environment characterised by site
segments and specialised computer software was used for
constraints and numerous road crossings for which closure is
automating the geometry control exercise.
difficult, if not impossible.
Traditionally, a bridge is segmented into units with the spatial
During erection of a curved span with a horizontal radius of
relationship described by orthogonal reference frames for ease
60 m, the maximum eccentricity that the launching girder had to
of control and computation. In this project, two types of
handle was about 2 m. Therefore, both the loading and kinematic
segments were employed for spans with different radii—3$1 m
requirements on the girder design were very demanding. Fig. 10
for the ‘straights’ (R O 120 m) and 2$4 m for curves with tight radii.
An approach using non-orthogonal frames was adopted to reduce shows the girder in use.
the break angles at the match-cast face for the short segments. This
geometry control method required a special feature in the mould to In a typical erection cycle, segments were fed from the rear end of the
provide a bulkhead that could be rotated. girder, picked up by the winch and moved to the designated position
in a span. Epoxy was applied to the segment match-cast face prior to
In addition to the short-line casting cells, a long-line mould was joint closure with temporary prestressing. The spans were supported
also employed for the production of segments that varied in on temporary jacks during load transfer when permanent
width (e.g. tapered spans). Although the long-line casting prestressing was applied. After completion of a span, the main girder
approach offers flexibility in span width, it cannot accommodate launched itself forward following the front support beam. The main
vertical curves. In areas with the coexistence of both variables, an girder and the support beam were linked by a turntable. After the
in situ construction method was adopted. main girder reached its final position for erecting the next span,
the support beam would launch forward, guided and supported by
3.2.3. Segment production characteristics. After a relatively the turntable that allowed three-dimensional movements of the
short learning curve, a steady production rate for each short-line beam to suit the required span length, horizontal and vertical curves.
mould was one segment per day, including the diaphragm. The This special feature gave the required manoeuvrability of this
long-line mould eventually also achieved the same rate but with equipment for handling both straight and curved spans. Fig. 11
certain difficulties and a much longer learning curve. All segments shows a typical launching sequence.
were produced in a period of 13 months. Due to storage and erection
logistics, individual moulds were operational during different 3.3.2. Special spans. Proper standardisation of construction
periods. The achieved production curve is shown in Fig. 9. schemes is synonymous with the economic viability of a large-
85
crane with segments produced
in either short-line or
long-line moulds.
N N +1
N –1 N N +1 N +2
N –1
N N +1
N –1 N N +1 N +2
N –1
N N +1
N –1 N N +1 N +2
N –1 N +2
N N +1
N –1 N N +1 N +2 N –1 N +2
86
11 250
10 1010
10
Weekly actual
9 9 9
9
Weekly cumulative 200
8
8
Weekly span erection LG1 and LG2
7 7 7 7 7 7 7
5 5 5 5
5
4 4 4 4 4 4 4 4 100
4
3 3 3 3
3
2 2 2 2 2 50
2
1
1
0 0
97
24
97
Ap 4
7
21
97
19
97
16
30
97
28
97
25
97
22
7
20
97
17
97
15
29
98
26
98
23
98
23
2
r9
9
b
ar
ay
ct
ov
ec
ar
Ju
Fe
Ju
Au
Se
Ja
Fe
O
M
M
M
D
14
7
6
2
5
10
10
9
11
1
5
87