You are on page 1of 10

Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562 – 571

www.elsevier.com/locate/wsif

Quantitative and qualitative dimensions of gender equity


in Sri Lankan Higher Education
Chandra Gunawardena a,⁎, Yoga Rasanayagam b , Tressie Leitan b ,
Kanchana Bulumulle c , Asha Abeyasekera-Van Dort b
a
Faculty of Education Open University of Sri Lanka, Nawala, Nugegoda, Sri Lanka
b
University of Colombo, Sri Lanka
c
Open University of Sri Lanka, Sri Lanka

Synopsis

In Sri Lanka, the impetus for gender equity came from a commitment to a liberal-democratic philosophy that led to a better
representation of girls and women in general and University education. With the exception of Engineering disciplines, young
women perform as well or better than their male peers in higher education. However, this quantitative change has not been
accompanied by a change in the quality of education. Overall participation in teaching and learning, engagement in extra-curricular
activities including politics, and engagement in decision-making bodies by women is negligible. Numerical parity is not
accompanied by equity in outcomes. This article attempts to explore the reasons why increased access in numerical terms has not
succeeded in empowering women in university education, both as students and as staff. It is based on documentary analysis,
interviews and observations undertaken under the auspices of the Gender Equality in Commonwealth Higher Education (2004–5)
research project.
© 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.

Introduction tion has not always been accompanied by a change in


the qualitative dimensions of the outcomes of education.
Women's low representation in certain disciplinary Sri Lanka with a human development index of 0.751
areas and especially at professorial grades and in posi- and a gender development index of 0.747 is often cited
tions of power and decision-making is a recurring theme as a success story (UNDP, 2005). Sri Lanka, in fact, has
in higher education research (Jackson, 2002; Suther- reached a high degree of success in ensuring equal
land, 1994). In recent decades, higher percentages of access to educational opportunity—the cumulative re-
women have enrolled and performed highly in univer- sult of the long-term vision of policymakers and their
sity education, but academic women's career progres- commitment to liberal-democratic policies in the early
sion has been much less evident across the globe. In Sri years of independence (Jayawardene, 1985; Jayaweera,
Lanka, while numerical parity is often shown as an 1985). The system of free education from kindergarten
achievement of gender equality, the quantitative change to university level introduced in 1945 was complemen-
indicated by greater access of women to higher educa- ted by a number of incentives and services like sub-
sidized transport, free text books, free mid-day meals
and free school uniforms that contributed towards re-
⁎ Corresponding author. ducing social and economic disparities. As explained by
0277-5395/$ - see front matter © 2006 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.
doi:10.1016/j.wsif.2006.10.005
C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571 563

the National Education Commission (NEC) (2003). structure (Bond, 1996). Women can succeed in higher
Report of the Special Committee on Education, Ceylon. education, but they do so at a price (Thomas, 1990). The
Sessional Paper XXIV of 1943: implications of combining an academic career with
family life are that they may be viewed as a liability to
projected a vision of social change from the inequal-
departments in terms of research contribution and thus
ities created by colonial education policy to recogni-
perpetuate and strengthen the discrimination against
tion of the universal right to education, the need for
women. Raddon (2002) points out that it becomes
free education as a prerequisite of a democratic so-
necessary for women academics to develop the ability to
ciety, and the role of education as an agent of upward
resolve the contradiction between the ‘successful aca-
socio-economic mobility for all individuals. This
demic’ and the ‘good mother’. Morley (1999) explains
vision became embedded in public consciousness so
further about micropolitics, that is, how power is relayed
that any curtailment of this right became a politically
through everyday practices and contributes to our
explosive issue for successive governments.
understanding of the obstacles to women's professional
At the level of the family, parents did not have to efficiency and advancement. Morley points out how
weigh the cost or the opportunity cost of sending their power-laden micro-processes are notoriously difficult to
sons or daughters to school resulting in a gender neutral challenge through policies for equality.
demand for education. In 2001, literacy rates were The male culture of the universities discriminates
92.3% among males and 89.2% among females heavily against women, with a lack of women mentors
(Department of Census and Statistics, 2002, p18). and role models for both students and academics. Walsh
As facilities for secondary education expanded, there (2002) refers to institutions where women (and other
was a corresponding increase in the demand for uni- non-traditional members) are still ‘new’ and ‘different’.
versity education. The University College established in “Though some individual staff members may have been
1921 became a fully-fledged university—the University there for many years, they remain ‘other’, intruders in a
of Ceylon—only in 1942. However, in the space of six place whose historical purpose has specifically worked
decades the number of universities has now increased to to construct and defend the difference and differentials
15, mainly as a result of a demand to provide an op- which render us ‘woman’ to the ‘man of reason’.”
portunity for higher education for the increasing number (Walsh, 2002). Seymour and Hewitt (1997) referred to a
of secondary school graduates who became eligible for a fear of visibility that could silence women even when
university education and also as a result of the demand they wish to articulate their viewpoints.
for the establishment of a university per administrative The culture-centered approach links the person-
province. centered and organizational structure perspective in the
social construction of gender and the assignment of
Pertinent theoretical and empirical literature specific roles and responsibilities and expectations to
men and women. Gender relations are kept in place
Among the theoretical perspectives that attempt to between the actors, both the dominant and the sub-
explain gender equity, the person-centred perspective ordinate to social and organizational reality (Smulders,
links women's characteristics to the psycho-social at- 1998). The gendered division of domestic labour is
tributes, including personality characteristics, attitudes often mirrored in the academic workplace, where
and behaviour skills of women themselves. Third World women academics carry disproportionately high teach-
researchers have argued that as far as women are con- ing, pastoral and administrative loads, circumscribing
cerned, access (to education) is ‘culturally defined’ and their participation in research (Bagilhole, 1993). Women
the relevance of formal education is determined by the are also typically concentrated on departmental and
societal expectations of what is ‘feminine’ (UNESCO, faculty committees which are not decision-making
1987). bodies (Brooks, 1997). The kind of ‘cultural annexation’
A structure-centered paradigm argues that the behav- (Spurling, 1996) is sometimes referred to as a ‘glass
iour of women is defined by the disadvantaged position wall’ rather than a ‘glass ceiling’.
of women in the organization—discriminatory appoint- Researchers have also pointed out that women have
ment and promotion practices, male resistance to less access to the formal and informal networks in the
women in management positions, absence of policies research community (O'Leary & Mitchell, 1990). Suther-
and legislation to ensure participation of women and land claimed that the university is a ‘man's world’
limited opportunities for leadership training and for and the ‘old boy network is influential’ (Sutherland,
development of competencies as a result of the power 1985:25). Women lack sponsors or mentors, supportive
564 C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571

relationships where older and experienced academics Table 1


contribute to younger colleagues' career development. Female representation in university admissions by discipline: selected
years

The study Discipline 1990/ 1995/ 1998/ 1999/ 2000/ 2001/


91 96 99 00 01 02

This article presents the findings of the study con- Arts 63.3 64.4 69.7 69.8 71.4 73.03
Management 43.6 41.3 50.9 51.9 46.6 53.2
ducted on Gender Equity in Commonwealth Higher
Studies
Education (GECHE) in Sri Lanka with sponsorship from Commerce 47.6 49.5 50.8 51.6 52.8 54.4
the Department for International Development in UK, as a Law 59.5 61.1 68.1 78.7 7.6 79.5
part of the project in five Commonwealth countries. The Science 42.6 44.8 39.1 35.9 37.6 38.3
University of Colombo was selected as the research site Medicine 43.1 40.9 44.0 51.1 47.6 53.3
Agriculture 46.4 47.9 54.5 52.8 54.9 50.5
and three interventions on access, curriculum trans-
Engineering 10.5 0.2 17.7 14.7 16.3 18.1
formation and staff development were selected for Total no. (%) 7238 8464 11,896 11,805 11,962 12,144
study. Under access, the District Quota Scheme and the (47.7) (48.1) (52.4) (51.5) (52.1) (53.8)
Mahapola Scholarships, which are equity interventions, Source: University Grants Commission, University Statistical Hand-
were studied while the Master of Women's Studies books (1990/91 to 2001/02).
Programme and the gender courses in the Arts Faculty and Disciplines of Dental Science, Veterinary Medicine, Architecture,
the activities of the Staff Development Centre were Quantity Surveying, and Computer Science with low students numbers
are not included.
studied under curriculum transformation and staff devel-
opment. International, national and the selected Universi-
ty's policy documents on gender equity were reviewed to as qualified teachers at secondary school level, to gain
provide a backdrop to the study in hand. An analysis of admission to prestigious courses for which keen compe-
national level statistics on admission, enrolment, achieve- tition exists. The Mahapola Scholarships provide a basic
ment, output in university education, employment of stipend to students to pay for their living expenses during
women graduates and the career progression of women the period of university education. This assists students
academics into managerial and leadership positions was coming from deprived socio-economic backgrounds who
carried out to understand the context within which the are unable to afford the various costs of university educa-
University functioned. This analysis was replicated on tion. Scholarships are available for both men and women
statistics related to the above aspects in the University, and students.
supplemented by interviews of a sample of representa- The Master of Arts in Women's Studies (MAWS)
tives from different stakeholder groups (18 students, 21 was one of the first two programmes to be offered by the
staff and 18 policymakers) and observation of classes and Faculty of Graduate Studies when it was established in
meetings. Under access, five classes: Computer Science, the mid-1980s. Courses with a specific gender perspec-
Botany, Physics, Financial Management, and Accounting tive were introduced by the Departments of Economics,
and two meetings were observed — Faculty Boards of English, Political Science and Public Policy, Sinhala,
Education and Arts, under curriculum, six classes — and Sociology. The Staff Development Centre had been
Human Rights Law, Journalism (3), Humanitarian Law established for the purpose of improving the quality of
and Family Law and under Staff Development, two academic work in the institution. There was no gender
workshops and four meetings — Council (2), Senate and component in the Staff Development course.
Faculty Board of Graduate Studies. The article attempts to interpret the data collected
The two affirmative action interventions—the District through documents, interviews and observations to
Quota Scheme and the Mahapola Scholarships—do not understand how and why increased access in numerical
specifically target gender equality but were introduced to terms has not succeeded in empowering women in
ensure that students from rural and poor families gained university education, both as students and as staff. The
access to higher education. The District Quota Scheme findings are viewed from the three perspectives de-
was put into effect fully from 1975 in deciding on the scribed above to explain the situation prevalent in Sri
university admissions. At present, 40% of the places are Lankan higher education with regard to gender equity.
decided on merit, 55% on District Quotas and the balance
allocated to students from extremely disadvantaged dis- Women in education—a quantitative overview
tricts (University Grants Commission, 2002:5). District
quotas give an advantage to students from rural districts Overall admission of women to university education
that have less access to schools with good resources such has improved from 47.7 in 1990/91 to 53.8% in 2001/02
C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571 565

(see Table 2). Yet when admission to different disci- Table 3


plines is examined, variations are discernible. In 1990/ Graduate output of universities by academic stream and sex: selected
years
91, the percentage of women admitted to the Arts
Faculty was 63.3%, however, only 10.5% gained ad- Discipline 2000 2001
mission to Engineering. Eleven years later in 2001/02, T %F T %F
the percentage of women entering the Arts Faculty fur- Arts 3656 71.4 2980 73.0
ther increased to 73.3% but their admission to Management 1646 49.8 1559 53.2
Engineering had only marginally improved to 18.1%. Commerce 802 52.9 1060 33.9
Law 173 76.9 182 79.7
Table 1 presents some achievements, with a few excep-
Science 1264 37.5 922 38.3
tions: more admission to some professional disciplines Medicine 904 48.1 801 53.3
such as Management, Commerce, Law and Medicine Agriculture 249 53.4 242 28.9
is evident but not in technological spheres, namely Engineering 548 16.2 653 18.1
Engineering. Total 9374 57.0 8224 55.8
Table 2 indicates that women are well-represented in Source: University Grants Commission, University Statistical Hand-
most of the academic programmes. In 2001, the percent- books (2001; 2002).
Courses with low enrolment are not indicated.
age of women in total student enrolment was 53.8
(University Grants Commission, 2001).
The above figures indicate that the majority of to motivate women into Engineering (Gunawardena,
women are mainly enrolled in Arts-oriented disciplines. 1994).
The area in which women are in a low minority is The success of women gaining admission to univer-
Engineering. Table 3 gives the output of Sri Lankan sities is due to a widespread faith in higher education as
universities by academic stream and sex that reiterates a means of social mobility by all social strata and the
the trend emerging from the earlier two tables. equal value that is accorded by parents to the education
It is clear that women's access to secondary and of both sons and daughters (CENWOR, 1987; Guna-
higher education has considerably improved over the wardena, Jalmert, Lekamge, Dissanayake, & Bulumulla,
years. The only major area in which access has not been 2005), which could also be linked to the high level of
guaranteed to the same extent so far is Engineering literacy (91.1%) in the general population (Department
which could be linked to such factors as traditional social of Census and Statistics, 2005, p76). District quotas
perception of Engineering to be a male domain, lack of a benefit the women candidates from under-developed
sufficient number of Physical Science female teachers rural areas. Moreover, the Mahapola Scholarships
at senior secondary level, and an absence of efforts enable women students with financial difficulties not
to depend only for parental sponsorship.
Table 2
University undergraduate enrolment—(% female): selected years From access to equity
Discipline 1990/91 1995/96 2001 2002
Merit as a criterion has achieved positive results for
Arts 52.3 59.7 77.4 69.8
women's access. Overt discrimination in relation to
Commerce/Management 44.5 43.4 50.1 50.1
Studies access does not seem to exist. Our interview informants
Law 52.9 58.9 48.4 47.3 affirmed that families play an important role in moti-
Science 41.6 37.1 48.4 48.1 vating and encouraging girls to pursue education. Belief
Medicine 42.1 41.6 47.1 46.9 in the value of education extends to extended family
Dental Science 48.2 52.5 53.5 53.5
members and communities as well. The interviews with
Veterinary Medicine 45.2 50.7 51.3 51.3
Agriculture 41.5 42.8 51.7 51.8 students seemed to indicate that parental socio-econom-
Engineering 11.9 11.7 16.4 11 ic background does not seem to obstruct students' entry
Architecture and 35.2 38.1 43.7 43.7 into a university or their choice of academic stream as
Quantity Surveying the students came from varied backgrounds and had
Total no. (%) 31,447 36,797 58,035 58,205
parents with varying levels of educational qualifications
(42.9) (45.4) (53.5) (53.6)
and occupations. Even the three students who faced
Source: University Grants Commission, University Statistical Hand- financial difficulties were encouraged to study by their
books (1990/91 to 2001/02).
Courses with low enrolment such as Education. Mass Media,
parents who had made personal sacrifices to enable their
Performing Arts, Indigenous Medicine, Labour Education are not daughters to attend university. Economic and social
included. aspirations that motivate families to invest in their
566 C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571

daughters' education, the need to have job security Thus the Higher Education Sector Survey Part 1 (Task
through higher education, and the perception that edu- Force and Working Committees, Ministry of Education
cation will serve as an alternative to dowry for girls in and Higher Education, 1995) reiterated the state's pri-
the marriage market were the reasons given by infor- mary responsibility for the provision of free education to
mants for the value placed on education. The logic the first degree level to be recognized as a right in the Sri
envisages a young woman with higher education quali- Lankan democratic society despite its economic impli-
fications as someone with future potential to be an cations and increasing state investment in higher edu-
income earner even though the parents may lack cation. Yet what was emphasized was quality through
material assets to bestow at the time of marriage. the introduction of measures such as flexibility in the
curriculum, learner-centered education, staff training,
Higher education can provide opportunities for up-
comprehensive assessment, development of communi-
ward social mobility, a career path and improved life
cation skills, introduction of computer literacy, curricula
chances make higher education a kind of “family
to match employment needs, establishment of an Em-
survival” strategy for the majority of middle and low
ployment Advisory and Liaison Units, interaction with
income Sri Lankans. (Faculty Member)
employers and short-term graduate training.
Interviews revealed that both women staff and stu- The ratification of the UN Convention on the Elimi-
dents believe that women are more committed to their nation of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW) has
academic studies. Behavioural traits considered as facil- had an impact on the national level policies that enacted
itating high academic achievement—diligence, dedica- necessary legislation, and instituted certain organiza-
tion, and perseverance—were perceived to be feminine tional mechanisms to put into implementation the policy
traits as they were more often found in females. decisions. But higher education appears to have swerved
away from the concerns with equity matters, including
I also think that it is by the very fact that women
gender equity, towards aspects of relevance, quality and
have persevered. I don't know, we find that women
efficiency, which emerge as priority issues in the context
are much more committed to what they do. It is the
of globalisation and privatisation (Asian Development
same in the Medical Faculty. (Faculty Member)
Bank, 2000; Presidential Task Force on University
Pursuing higher education and staying on in acade- Education, Sri Lanka, 1997; University Grants Com-
mia were the future career plans of more than half of the mission, Sri Lanka, 2003).
students interviewed. National level data (Gunawar- Gender is considered as a non-issue in higher edu-
dena, Rasanayagam, Leitan, Abeaysekera-Van Dort, cational policies at the national as well as organisational
& Bulumulle, 2004) as well as at the research site, level due to the belief that numerical access is tanta-
(Gunawardena, Rasanayagam, Leitan, Abeyasekera- mount to ensuring equity. There is no discernible interest
Van Dort, & Bulumulle, 2005) showed more women in promoting any form of equity or addressing problems
were joining as academics. of those groups of undergraduates/graduates, including
women through increased support or affirmative action.
Political commitment
Curriculum transformation
The early achievement of equality in educational op-
portunities, however, has led to State complacency and Policy emphasis on quality and relevance of higher
subsequent educational policies and programmes do not education has not included a discussion on incorporat-
adequately challenge and attempt to address existing ing gender into the curriculum. It is interesting, how-
social inequalities. This is, perhaps, most evident in the ever, that although there has been neither national policy
absence of a discussion on gender in policies and nor formal discussions initiated at the overall institu-
programmes. Education is seen as a gender-neutral tional or faculty levels regarding curriculum transfor-
arena, and policymakers have ignored, or perhaps failed mation, a few influential women have made significant
to understand, not only the impact socialization in gender contributions to the process. With the exception of the
roles and norms has on how women experience educa- Faculties of Science and Management, a gender dimen-
tional opportunities, but also the role education plays in sion has been incorporated into curricula at both the
perpetuating these roles and norms. undergraduate and post-graduate levels. The integration
From the perusal of recent policy documents on of gender courses into the university curriculum has
higher education in Sri Lanka it was clear that at policy mostly been driven by individuals, who were personally
level the emphasis is on quality rather than on equity. interested in feminist scholarship and have occupied
C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571 567

positions of influence such as Deanships, Headships or introducing not only an alternative perspective, but
as Professors and Programme Coordinators. Not sur- providing the language with which to understand and
prisingly, in most cases these individuals happen to be describe issues of identity. One student related how
women. following gender courses challenged homophobia
While the curriculum transformation process can be by raising her awareness of sexuality and alternative
described as being driven by women, due to the signifi- lifestyles:
cant influence these courses have exerted on the in-
I have become much more aware of issues of identity
tellectual and professional lives of mainly women
and sexuality. Before I would notice certain things,
students, one could argue that the curriculum transfor-
but perhaps didn't have the language to talk about
mation process be also described as for women. A stu-
issues like lesbianism. Now I feel issues of sexuality
dent who was following the Master of Arts in Women's
should be discussed more in the open-people are
Studies in 2004 described how it had helped her pro-
entitled to different lifestyles.
fessional development:
It is noteworthy that while there has been no overt
I have become much more proficient in under-
discouragement from any of the faculties to the incor-
standing development and gender issues in my work.
poration of gender into the curriculum, gender discrim-
I am able to deal with my work better. The
ination can take place formally through structures due to
assignments have really helped me improve my
the lack of facilities and resources that undermine the
writing and I have noticed that I write much more
impact and sustainability of the interventions.
critically—I am able to critique the information I am
dealing with. I feel it has also really contributed to my Well, the barriers were really that there was no
personal development. adequate support for actually mainstreaming the
courses in a much broader and more meaningful
Women's Studies has also made a significant impact
way. That was all. It's not that anybody actually
on career aspirations and achievements. The three
stood in our way but when we had to take the sort of
former students interviewed included a freelance con-
entire syllabus in to account…there wasn't that much
sultant on gender, a gender specialist at a bi-lateral
room to maneuver and mainstream gender studies.
donor agency, and a manager at a UN organization. Of
(Faculty Member)
the current students interviewed, all of them wanted to
pursue further studies in gender issues, to get more A lack of policy initiatives and a more universal
involved in gender related programmes, and to think dialogue on curriculum transformation has also under-
more progressively about gender and its influence on mined the impact of these courses on women's lives at
programming. The course has also built the confidence the under-graduate level. As the organizational struc-
of one student to apply for prestigious jobs: tures, mechanisms and societal expectations have con-
tinued to uphold the traditional, i.e. male modes of
…all these UN vacancies that ask for qualifications
thinking and acting, mere participation in these courses
in the area of gender…I feel much more confident to
may not be sufficient to bring about a significant trans-
apply for these kinds of jobs.
formation of attitudes. As one student remarked:
At the personal level, the Master of Arts in Women's
My friend was telling me recently, that ‘it's well and
Studies has helped students to interrogate gender norms
good we learn about these things at university, but
and expectations. Interviewees described how they were
I'm going to zip it up in my purse and leave it with
able to question gender roles and understand them as
my mother when I get married.’ They think about
social constructions:
gender issues as they've been exposed to it, but a
I feel it has also really contributed to my personal majority of them think its very impractical; there is
development. In terms of my personal life, I have no way they can incorporate it into their daily lives.
become more conscious, maybe I am not directly
practicing these things as yet, but I am more “in-
The university as a gendered space
tune”.I have become more aware of how society
defines our roles and how we as individuals accept
Despite parity in numbers in many of the faculties
them without any hesitation.
and gender in the curriculum, the University is a highly
Students who had followed gender courses at the gendered space. Women's overall involvement in uni-
undergraduate level talked about the course material versity life was severely limited by social constraints.
568 C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571

All students interviewed had hardly participated in exclusively male domain. Nor did they challenge the
extra-curricular activities as they felt it was not safe for institution, but accepted it as a social reality. Some of
them to travel alone in the evening. The social reality of them felt politics was not for women and did not want to
a woman's safety at night augmented by ideological be involved and said they kept away due to fear and
notions that women who stay late will be viewed as perception that politics was a male domain. Others
deviant prevented women from participating fully in acknowledged the lack of access to the Student Union
university life. Women feel helpless to fight a system was limiting their social life and hampering access to
that perpetuates the culture of fear and shame for those wider social networks.
who deviate. One student remarked: This situation was vividly described by one staff
member:
I can't spend time in the library after 5 and we have
classes till 5. But I am too scared to stay late whereas There are no women students who are giving leader-
the boys stay till late and study in the library. Just ship to the unions or any organizations. They don't
getting around is so difficult for women. We are because student politics is so dirty, so violent and so
always fenced in. tied up with outside politics. Very few women sur-
vive and one of the tactics men use to scare away the
Similarly, another student explained her reluctance to
women, even those who are keen on coming “this is
work in the computer laboratory:
not for you women because your name will get
You know the computer lab is always dominated by spoiled”.
men, so it's a little uncomfortable for us to go in
The interviewees reported that there is no focused
sometimes. Also, it's very noisy, so it's difficult to
mentoring of women students by the faculty. As women
get work done
perform well, the involvement of the lecturer in the life
Student led initiation rituals known as ‘ragging’ to of the students seemed minimal. The students saw
which both men and women are subjected, already teachers as available for extra academic assistance if
declared as a criminal activity through the Anti-Ragging required, but not as role models.
Act, have gender implications as young women are
frequently subjected to humiliating and highly sexua- More women, no role models
lised bullying as a type of endurance test (Jayasena,
2002). One student explained: The tendency to view education as a gender-neutral
arena has also resulted in the absence of a dynamic
Ragging was an obstacle in my first year. It was
dialogue on how gender interfaces with the expected
quite bad…I think ragging is so much about the class
outcomes of education both for students and members of
and economic differences amongst students. The
faculty. The efforts to introduce feminist pedagogy at the
ragging went on for one month. During that time I
University have been limited, and where attempts have
didn't feel like coming for classes.
been made, there has been no significant impact. This is
Students mentioned the subtle discriminatory behav- perhaps due to the cultural construction of the student–
iour of some male lecturers: teacher relationship as a strictly hierarchical one. In Sri
Lanka teachers are the “knowledge bearers” and are,
There are some who try to put the women down by
therefore, given the utmost respect. This rigid structure
asking a question and then laughing at us when we
resists dismantling and, therefore, perpetuates the tradi-
can't answer it, or ask something just to put us down.
tional transmission pedagogy. While research mainly
Some male lecturers look at the women in an odd from the West points to male dominance in the class-
kind of way. Sometimes you catch them staring at room, in Sri Lanka gender relations in the classroom is
you in an odd way and when you catch their eye, compounded by the rigid power structures between
they laugh to themselves. We feel quite uncomfor- teachers and students.
table. We can't say what's going in their minds, what In observing classroom behaviour both in terms of
kind of thoughts, vulgar or what, but it happens. student interactions and class participation, it was dif-
ficult to draw clear distinctions between the behaviour
Sri Lankan women's poor participation in politics, an of men and women. In general, both sexes are quiet and
essentially masculine space, is also mirrored within the their interaction with the lecturer is at best tentative.
University system. None of the women students inter- Male students usually speak softly, answer questions
viewed had joined the Student Union as it was seen as an tentatively, are seemingly mild mannered, and do not
C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571 569

display any overt aggressive behaviour. It is only in the Democratic institutions such as Faculties, Senate and
way the men were seated in the middle aisle, directly in Council exist, but they do not function democrati-
the line of vision of the lecturer and also the relatively cally because members, including women members
more interaction they had with their peers that one do not actively participate to make these institutions
could infer that male students were marginally more function democratically.
dominant in the classroom than the women. No overt
gender discrimination was discernible from any of the The veracity of these perceptions was confirmed by
male lecturers, who tended to ask rhetorical questions the observations. In all three board meetings observed,
from the class in general rather than attempting to the chairperson was described as being receptive to
genuinely interact with students. However, subtle signs the views expressed by participants, inviting members
of gender discrimination were apparent in the way to express their views, and appreciative of the inputs
male lecturers did not make eye contact with female given by members on various issues. They had in all
students and excluded women from even the minimal cases not displayed any partiality towards members of
class discussions. It is noteworthy that attempts at their own sex and worked with collegiality towards
transforming the classroom into a more interactive one members of the other sex. Participation of junior
have been made, once again, by women faculty female members in discussions and certain boards was
members and have made some difference to women's less. It was thus clear that covert processes appear to
participation. These changes, however, cannot be operate which make the environment less conducive
analyzed as including women's voices in male for women to participate actively in discussion or in
dominated classrooms, but rather as the opening of decision-making.
hitherto closed structures for student voices to be On being asked for suggestions on how gender equi-
included. It is significant then that these voices are ty in higher education can be promoted, one participant
mainly women's. pointed out that ‘if we promote the gender approach, of
In terms of representation of women in the course, we can change all these issues and we can sort
academia, the University appears as a model institu- out all these issues’. Another felt “we need to change our
tion, with high percentages of women occupying mind-set, attitude” supported by a colleague “I suppose
positions of academic leadership. A staff member if we can have a standard gender program in school at
commented, however, even though women are numer- least we can try to balance out because a lot of people
ically more, their participation in decision-making is don't know about these things and all that we have are
less visible. The organizational culture in universities is traditional. They become so timid.”
such that women are not adequately represented in Another identified a basic need:
elected posts (e.g. Deans) or appointed posts (Heads of
May be sort of like how to speak at meetings and
Departments, Directors of Centers or Institutes) or on
those types of things because they are so quiet. So
Boards and Councils. Even when equal opportunities
that kind of leadership training; To stand up for their
are available for women, due to a variety of reasons,
own like gender or what ever rights, to stand up for
women do not seem to avail themselves of these
them.
opportunities.
In the absence of any specific gender training for As one senior faculty member argued:
professional development and a lack of guidance and
Gender equity cannot be realized without creating a
mentorship little facilitation of women's academic and
general environment within the university for effec-
management careers seems to occur. It was clear that
tive democratic participation, discussion and deci-
proactive affirmative action is required to support
sion making. A university that has an intellectually
women's training and development, instead of the “gender
lively community, committed to democratic values is
neutral policies” to provide greater opportunities for
an essential prerequisite to realizing gender equity. I
women for career advancement.
do not believe that this environment exists in this
The interviews revealed a dichotomy of perceptions
University.
that underlay the views expressed by the staff. On one
hand there was a feeling of lack of agency among
women themselves while at other times what was Conclusion
hinted at was a hidden force that prevented the women
from asserting themselves or standing up for their It has been more than 50 years since Sri Lanka
rights. achieved numerical gender equality in education and
570 C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571

access to most areas of higher education. As such, References


gender is considered as non-issue in the higher educa-
tion policy at national as well as organizational levels. Asian Development Bank (2000). Advancing knowledge and skills for
development and competitiveness: The tertiary educations Strat-
Sri Lanka thus presents a good example of the operation
egy. Paris: Asian Development Bank.
of politics of representation in which policy activity Bagilhole, Barbara (1993). Survivors in a male preserve: A study of
ceases once quantitative targets have been met as British women academics' experiences and perceptions of discrim-
pointed out by Louise Morley (2004). ination in a UK University. Higher Education, 26(4), 431−447.
However, the attainment of the expected outcomes of Bond, Sheryl (1996). Academic leadership in South Asia. Trainers'
module provided for the Commonwealth Secretariat. London.
education—the development of human capabilities and
Brooks, Ann (1997). Academic women. Milton Keynes: SRHE/Open
an improvement in the quality of life through social and University Press.
economic empowerment—has been diluted by the wide CENWOR (1987). Women's work and family strategies. Colombo:
socio-economic inequalities within the population and Centre for Women's Research.
the socialization process. The realities of a stagnant Department of Census and Statistics (Sri Lanka) (2002). Statistical
pocket book, (pp. 18). Colombo: Department of Census &
economy characterised by high unemployment among
Statistics.
youth and the demand for low-skill low-paid workers Department of Census and Statistics (Sri Lanka) (2005). Statistical
fuelled by globalization have also undermined wider pocket book, (pp. 76). Colombo: Department of Census &
access to employment opportunities and upward occu- Statistics.
pational mobility (Gunawardena, 2003). Gunawardena, Chandra (1994). Early socialization of women and their
entry into scientific and technical courses in higher education. Sri
The study clearly brings out the multiplicity of
Lanka Journal of Educational Research, 4(1), 35−51.
forces that impact on the achievement of gender Gunawardena, Chandra (2003). Gender equity in higher education in
equity in higher education in a developing country. On Sri Lanka: A mismatch between access and outcomes. McGill
the one hand, progressive educational policies have Journal of Education, 38(3), 437−451.
ensured access to higher education for women rarely Gunawardena, Chandra, Jalmert, Lars, Lekamge, Dayalatha, Dissa-
nayake, Samudra, & Bulumulla, Kanchana (2005). Child-rearing
seen in the developing world. On the other, traditional
practices in selected communities in Sri Lanka. Report to SIDA
socialization processes which give primacy to males in and Swedish research council. Department of Education, Interna-
society, especially in the family, impose limits on tional Series, Stockholm University.
career aspirations of women who are caught between Gunawardena, Chandra, Rasanayagam, Yoga, Leitan, Tressie, Abeay-
their dual roles as professionals and home makers. In sekera-Van Dort, Asha, & Bulumulle, Kanchana (2004). Working
Paper 3: Gender equity in the University of Colombo. www.ioe.ac.uk/
addition, interviews clearly bring out how micropo-
efps/GenderEqComHE.
litics of the institution, its structures, process and the Gunawardena, Chandra, Rasanayagam, Yoga, Leitan, Tressie, Abeya-
culture impinge upon women's status and participation sekera-Van Dort, Asha, & Bulumulle, Kanchana (2005). Working
(Morley, 1999). Paper 4: Setting the scene — Sri Lanka. Gender equity in higher
It is clear that educational policies and programmes education study. www.ioe.ac.uk/efps/GenderEqComHE.
Jackson, Sue (2002). Transcending boundaries: Women, research and
formulated and enacted without a long-term vision for
teaching in the academy. In Gillian Howie & Ashley Tauchert
the country's development as a whole can only result in (Eds.), Gender, teaching and research in higher education:
frustrated aspirations and a perpetuation of the existing Challenges for the 21st century, (pp. 21−33). Burlington: Ashgate
socio-economic inequalities. Most importantly, ig- Publishing Limited.
noring the social dimensions of gender inequality Jayasena, Asoka (2002). Ragging and the female students in the
universities. In Proceedings of the 8th National Convention on
and the role education can play in challenging it will
Women's Studies, 23–26 March, Colombo: Centre for Women's
only result in the attainment of qualifications but not Research.
empowerment. Jayawardene, Kumari (1985). Some aspects of feminist consciousness
in the decade 1975–1985. UN decade for women progress and
Acknowledgements achievements of women in Sri Lanka, (pp. 171−180). Colombo:
Centre for Women's Research.
Jayaweera, Swarna (1985). Women and education. UN decade for
The authors wish to acknowledge the assistance women. Progress and achievements of women in Sri Lanka,
received from the UK Department for International (pp. 47−68). Colombo: Centre for Women's Research.
Development (DFID) for conducting the study in Sri Morley, Louise (1999). Organizing feminisms: The micropolitics of
Lanka, Professor Louise Morley of the University of the academy. London: Macmillan.
Morley, Louise (2004). Gender equity in commonwealth higher
Sussex, the Coordinator of the research project for
education: Emerging themes. Learning by comparison: Interna-
continuous guidance and the lead researchers and the tional experiences in education and trainingResearch Report
teams in participating countries at different stages of the CR2003, (pp. 68–82). Nottingham: Department for Education and
project. Skills Publications.
C. Gunawardena et al. / Women's Studies International Forum 29 (2006) 562–571 571

National Education Commission (2003). Envisioning education for Gap. In S. Stiver Lie, L. Malik, & D. Harris (Eds.), World
human development: Proposals for a national policy framework Yearbook of Education 1994 (pp. 171−181). London: Kogan
on general education in Sri Lanka. Colombo: National Education Page Ltd.
Commission. Task Force and Working Committees, Ministry of Education and
O'Leary, Virginia, & Mitchell, Judith (1990). Women connecting with Higher Education, (1995). Ministry of Education and Higher
women networks and mentors in the United States. In Stiver Lie & Education (1995). Higher education sector survey: Sri Lanka part
Virginia O'Leary (Eds.), Storming the tower: Women in the I, report.
academic world, (pp. 58−73). London: Kogan Page. Thomas, Kim (1990). Gender and subject in higher education. Milton
Presidential Task Force on University Education, Sri Lanka (1997). Keynes: Open University Press.
National education reforms. Colombo: GOSL. UNESCO (1987). Promoting participation of women in science,
Raddon, Arwen (2002). Mothers in the academy: Positioned and technology and professional courses in higher education. Confer-
positioning within discourses of the ‘successful academic’ and the ence on women in science and technology and professional
‘good mother’. Studies in Higher Education, 27(4), 387−403. courses, Manila, Philippines, 7–12 December.
Seymour, Elaine, & Hewitt, Nancy M. (1997). Talking about leaving: UNDP (2005). Human development report. New York: United
Why undergraduates leave the sciences. Oxford: West View Press. Nations.
Smulders, Anna (1998). Creating space for women: Gender linked University Grants Commission (2001/02). Sri Lanka University statistics
faculties in management in higher education institutions. Paris: 2002. Colombo: UGC.
UNESCO IIEP. University Grants Commission (2002). Admission to undergraduate
Spurling, Andrea (1996). Women and change in higher education. In courses of the universities in Sri Lanka. Academic year 2002/2003.
H. Eggins (Ed.), Women as leaders and managers in higher Colombo: UGC.
education, (pp. 37−48). Milton Keynes: SRHE/ Open University University Grants Commission, Sri Lanka (2003). Corporate plan,
Press. 2003–2008. Colombo: UGC.
Sutherland, Margaret (1985). Women who teach in universities. Stoke- Walsh, Val (2002). ‘Equal opportunities without equality’: Redeeming
on-Trent: Trentham Books. the irredeemable. In Gillian Howie & Ashley Tauchert (Eds.),
Sutherland, Margaret (1994). “Two steps forward and one step back: Gender, teaching and research in higher education: Challenges for
Women in higher education in the United Kingdom” In the Gender the 21st century, (pp. 34). Burlington: Ashgate Publishing Limited.

You might also like