Professional Documents
Culture Documents
S
Guy B. Woodle
UOP LLC, Des Plaines, Illinois, U.S.A.
PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES The reaction is highly endothermic and conversion
is limited in extent by equilibrium. The reaction
Styrene is a colorless aromatic liquid. It is only very equilibrium constant is defined as:
slightly soluble in water, but infinitely soluble in
alcohol and ether. Additional properties are listed in
Keq ¼ ðPsty # Ph2Þ=Peb
Table 1.
Styrene is chemically reactive with the most
important reaction being its polymerization to form where Psty is the partial pressure of styrene, Ph2 is the
polystyrene. Styrene can also copolymerize with partial pressure of hydrogen; and Peb is the partial
other monomers, such as butadiene and acrylo- pressure of ethylbenzene.
nitrile, to produce a variety of industrially important High temperature, steam dilution, and low system
copolymers. pressure produce an equilibrium more favorable to
In addition to polymerization, styrene can undergo styrene. For endothermic vapor-phase reactions, the
other types of reactions due to the chemical nature of equilibrium constant increases with temperature and
Encyclopedia of Chemical Processing DOI: 10.1081/E-ECHP-120007970
Copyright # 2006 by Taylor & Francis. All rights reserved. 2859
2860 Styrene
can be determined according to the following The key dealkylation reactions can be described by
equation:[2] the following equations:
Typically, there is less methane and ethylene present equilibrium conversion to styrene. Reaction pressure
in the effluent of a reactor than would be expected from is established during the plant design at the lowest
the benzene and toluene formation. Carbon monoxide practical level. Modern commercial reactors operate S
is generally about 10 mol% of the total carbon oxides. below atmospheric pressure. Pressures as low as
The critical operating and design parameters for EB 300 mm Hg or lower are common. The key side reac-
dehydrogenation are discussed in the following tions are largely independent of reaction pressure;
paragraphs. hence, operating at lower pressures also provides
higher styrene yield.
Reaction temperature
Steam dilution or steam-to-oil ratio
Because the dehydrogenation reaction is endothermic,
the reaction mixture temperature decreases as the The main functions of steam dilution are to act as a
reaction proceeds. The reaction rate slows because of diluent to reduce the hydrocarbon partial pressures,
the closer approach to equilibrium and the decrease providing heat for the endothermic dehydrogenation
in kinetic reaction rate with the decreasing tempera- reaction, and maintaining the catalyst’s active surface
ture. Furthermore, the equilibrium constant is less in a desirable state. Increasing the steam-to-oil ratio
favorable at lower temperature. Therefore, in a normal has the net effect of improving the EB conversion
design, about 80% of the temperature drop occurs in and styrene yield. However, costs associated with
approximately the first third of the catalyst bed. generating and superheating the dilution steam also
As a result, a high inlet catalyst temperature is increase and eventually offset the reaction advantages.
required. However, high temperature also increases
the rates of nonselective thermal reactions and dealky- Catalyst type and properties
lation reactions, which form benzene and toluene
by-products. In particular, as temperature is increased, Ethylbenzene dehydrogenation is generally catalyzed
the rate of benzene formation increases significantly by a potassium-promoted iron oxide catalyst. The
relative to the rate of styrene formation. This means most widely used catalysts are composed of iron oxide,
there is an effective upper limit to the inlet temperature potassium carbonate, and various metal oxide promo-
if high styrene selectivity is a required criterion. Reac- ters. Examples of metal oxide promoters include
tion temperature is generally adjusted by changing chromium oxide, cerium oxide, molybdenum oxide,
either the steam temperature or the steam-to-oil ratio. and vanadium oxide.[4] The potassium component
substantially increases catalyst activity relative to an
unpromoted iron oxide catalyst. Potassium has been
Catalyst quantity shown to provide other benefits. In particular, it
reduces the formation of carbonaceous deposits on
The amount of catalyst relative to EB feed is an the catalyst surface, which prolongs catalyst life.
important parameter for optimum reactor perfor- Properties such as catalyst size and shape also
mance. Too little catalyst will prevent a close approach impact performance. In theory, smaller sized catalyst
to equilibrium. If EB conversion is low, then distilla- will increase reaction rates by providing more available
tion costs associated with recovery and recycle of the catalyst surface area than larger sized catalyst. Small
unconverted EB can become significant. With too catalyst particles, however, have a disadvantage in that
much catalyst, the EB conversion reaches equilibrium they result in greater pressure drop through a reactor
before the outlet of the catalyst bed, while the side and higher overall reaction pressures. To address this,
reactions continue leading to loss of selectivity. catalyst developers have used specialized shapes, such
The optimum catalyst quantity is achieved by as ribbed extrudates, to gain the advantage of
balancing the EB conversion level and the styrene increased surface area without incurring the penalty
yield. Catalysts typically lose activity with time on- of increased pressure drop and reaction pressure.
stream, which has the effect of decreasing the effective The Sud-Chemie Group and Criterion Catalysts are
active catalyst quantity for reaction. Compensation for the major catalyst developers and manufacturers for
aging catalyst is achieved by adjusting other operating the styrene industry. Both companies offer a wide
parameters, in particular, the reaction temperature. range of catalysts to suit individual processing needs.
Ethylbenzene conversion, styrene selectivity, catalyst
Reaction pressure activity, and catalyst stability can be optimized by
selecting the best catalyst or a combination of catalysts
Ethylbenzene dehydrogenation results in a significant for a particular application. Dow and BASF manufac-
increase in the volume of reactants due to the reac- ture proprietary catalysts, which have been mainly for
tion stoichiometry. Lower pressure favors higher use in their own respective technologies.
2862 Styrene
Commercial adiabatic reactors are typically of radial reactors are highly engineered. Designers use specia-
flow construction with the flow path moving from in lized computational fluid dynamics programs to study
to out. This radial outflow geometry requires a much flow characteristics throughout a reactor. S
lower inlet volume to obtain proper distribution of
the feed vapor through the catalyst bed than either
an axial flow or a radial inflow reactor configuration. Commercial Adiabatic Dehydrogenation
The radial flow reactor design also provides the advan- Processes
tage of low pressure drop since the flow path through
the catalyst is much shorter relative to an axial flow Most commercial styrene plants are based on either the
reactor. To minimize thermal reactions, the reactor Lummus=UOP technology or the Fina=Badger technol-
centerpipe diameter should be as small as possible to ogy. Dow Chemical is a major styrene producer and uses
minimize residence time at the highest temperature its own technology. These technologies are generally
throughout the reactor. However, too small a diameter similar, but there are key differences in the details.
will produce a high pressure drop through the center-
pipe, potentially causing flow maldistribution and
causing the feed vapor to enter the catalyst bed with Lummus/UOP Classic SMTM Process
a velocity that can result in erosion and attrition of cat-
alyst particles. The first commercial plant based on the Lummus=
A single-stage reactor with practical limits of Monsanto technology, which later became the Lummus=
temperature, pressure, and steam dilution is limited UOP technology, was commissioned in 1972. Since that
to 40–50% per pass conversion of EB. If the single- time, more than 50 projects have been licensed with more
stage reactor effluent is reheated, the reaction mixture than 40 plants in commercial operation as of 2004.
moves away from equilibrium allowing for higher EB A typical Lummus=UOP Classic SM process flow
conversion. When the reheated reaction mixture is diagram is shown in Fig. 2. Fresh and recycled EB
fed to a second stage of catalyst, then total EB conver- are combined with steam and fed to the dehydrogena-
sions of 60–75% per pass can be achieved. This process tion reaction section of the plant. The reactor effluent
of reheating and adding catalyst stages can be repeated is condensed and separated into off-gas, process
as frequently as economically feasible. With each addi- condensate, and a dehydrogenated mixture. The hydro-
tional reaction stage, however, a progressively smaller gen rich off-gas stream is recovered through an off-gas
incremental EB conversion is achieved, generally with compressor for use as a fuel gas. The process conden-
a corresponding decrease in styrene selectivity. sate is stripped of organics and either recycled for use
To obtain high EB conversions, typically two or within the styrene plant or exported. The dehydro-
three reactors are used in series with some type of genated mixture, consisting mainly of unconverted
reheating between the reactors to raise the temperature EB, styrene product, benzene, and toluene, is fed to
of the reaction mixture. Modern day commercial the distillation section of the plant.
The main equipment in the dehydrogenation reac- column in the sequence splits the EB and the lighter
tion section of a Lummus=UOP Classic SM plant components from styrene. The EB=styrene monomer
includes a steam superheater, two dehydrogenation (EB=SM) splitter is operated under vacuum and uses
reactors, a series of waste heat exchangers, and an structured packing, such as Sulzer Mellapak Plus
off-gas compressor (Fig. 3). The equipment is designed packing, to minimize temperature and polymer forma-
to minimize pressure drop from the dehydrogenation tion.[7] Polymerization inhibitors are injected into the
reactors inlet to the off-gas compressor. splitter to restrict polymer formation, in particular into
The main steam is superheated and used to reheat the bottom section of the column.
the reaction mixture for the second stage dehydrogena- The overhead product from the EB=SM splitter is
tor. The reaction mixture is reheated in a specially fed to an EB recovery column. The EB recovery
designed interchanger located inside the second stage column net bottoms’ stream is recycled to the dehydro-
dehydrogenator vessel shell. The cooled steam exiting genation section. Benzene and toluene by-products in
the interchanger is reheated in the steam superheater the recovery column overhead stream are separated
prior to being fed to the first stage dehydrogenator. in a benzene=toluene splitter. Oftentimes, the benzene
The superheated steam can range from 700% C to as recovered in this scheme is recycled as feed to the
high as approximately 850% C to achieve the desired upstream EB plant.
inlet temperature for the first stage dehydrogenator. The EB=SM splitter bottoms’ stream is fed to the
Superheated main steam is mixed with the EB and the SM column where the styrene is purified by removal
primary steam immediately before entering the first stage of any heavy residual tars. Tertiary-butyl catechol
dehydrogenator. The reactor is designed to provide a uni- (TBC) is injected into the overhead of the SM column,
form reaction mixture while minimizing residence time in and the column is operated under vacuum to minimize
the centerpipe to avoid thermal reactions. The reactor polymer formation.
effluent is cooled in a series of three waste heat exchan- A unique feature of the Lummus=UOP Classic SM
gers before final cooling and condensing. process is the noncompressive azeotropic heat recovery
The first stage of waste heat recovery is used to super- option.[8] In this option, the EB=SM splitter overhead
heat the EB and the primary steam. Subsequent stages vapor is used to boil an EB–water azeotrope mixture,
are used to generate steam at different pressures. Typi- which is then fed to the dehydrogenation reactors.
cally intermediate pressure steam and low pressure The condensation of the splitter overhead vapor
steam are generated, which are directed for use else- produces approximately 500 kcal=kg styrene. This
where in the styrene plant or larger EB–styrene complex. energy savings potential makes the azeotropic heat
Hydrogen and light hydrocarbons removed from recovery option economically attractive, in particular,
the condensed reactor effluent are compressed and in regions with moderate to high steam costs.
used as fuel gas in the steam superheater. The process
steam from the reactor effluent stream is condensed
and separated by gravity from the liquid hydrocarbon Lummus/UOP Smart SMTM Process
components. The condensate is stripped of hydrocar-
bons and revaporized for use as process steam. The Lummus=UOP Smart SM process is based on an
The distillation section of a Lummus=UOP Classic oxidative reheat technology invented by UOP.[9]
SM plant consists of four distillation columns. The first Although this technology can be used in the design of
Styrene 2865
a grassroots plant, it is most commonly used in a revamp The Lummus=UOP Smart SM technology was first
of an existing plant to increase styrene production by as commercialized in 1995 at Mitsubishi Chemical in
much as 60% with minimal capital investment cost. Kashima, Japan. The Mitsubishi Chemical plant was
The Lummus=UOP Smart SM technology uses designed with a dehydrogenation section containing
a specially designed reactor that contains two two combination oxidation–dehydrogenation reactors
concentric catalyst zones. A cross-sectional view of as shown in Fig. 4.
the concentric oxidation and dehydrogenation The temperature rise in the oxidation zone is
catalyst beds is also shown in Fig. 4. In the first zone, proportional to the amount of oxygen reacted across
hydrogen is selectively oxidized across a noble metal- the catalyst bed. The oxygen is diluted in steam and
containing catalyst. The direct combustion of hydro- the oxygen=steam mixture is well mixed to ensure the
gen reheats the reaction mixture, which is directly fed reaction mixture remains outside the flammability
into the second zone where the standard EB dehydro- envelope at all times.
genation reaction occurs. In addition to providing the
full reheating requirement, another benefit of this
technology is it shifts the reaction equilibrium in a Fina/Badger Styrene Process
favorable direction by removing the hydrogen by-
product. This shift in equilibrium allows for higher The Fina=Badger styrene process has evolved through
EB conversion without a corresponding decrease in many generations. The most recent design uses a flow
styrene yield. diagram as shown in Fig. 5. Recycled and fresh EB
are mixed with steam and fed to the primary and the The EB recycle column separates the unconverted EB
secondary dehydrogenation reactors. The reactor efflu- for recycle to the dehydrogenation reactors. Recent EB
ent is condensed and separated into vent gas, conden- recovery columns use high efficiency packing to obtain
sate, and hydrocarbon. The vent gas, the majority of minimum pressure drop through the column. This
which is hydrogen, is used as fuel gas. The condensate allows the column bottoms’ temperature to be main-
is stripped and used as feed water for steam generation. tained below 100% C. This is an important aspect of the
The hydrocarbon portion of the reactor effluent is fed design as styrene polymerization becomes significant at
to the distillation section of the plant, which consists of temperatures higher than approximately 100% C.
three distillation columns. The EB recovery column bottoms’ stream is fed to a
The main types of equipment in the dehydrogena- finishing column where the styrene is purified by the
tion section of the plant are the steam superheater, removal of any heavy residue. Tertiary-butyl catechol
the primary and secondary dehydrogenation reactors, is injected into the overhead of the finishing column
and a series of feed=effluent exchangers (Fig. 6). High to prevent polymerization. Tertiary-butyl catechol is
pressure steam is also generated by the recovery of heat widely used to prevent styrene polymerization during
from the reactor effluent stream. storage.
The major portion of steam is superheated and In 1997, Fina=Badger joined with Shell Technology
used to reheat the reaction mixture for the secondary Ventures, a subsidiary of Shell Oil Company, to develop
dehydrogenation reactor. As the cooled steam exits a reheating technology called Flameless Distributed
the reheater it is superheated again in the steam Combustion (FDC) for application in EB dehydrogena-
superheater, prior to being fed to the primary tion.[10] Flameless Distributed Combustion technology is
dehydrogenation reactor. The dehydrogenation reac- patented by Shell Oil Company and was originally used
tors are designed to provide low pressure drop and as a heat injector for enhanced recovery of hydrocarbons
uniform flow distribution. The reactor effluent is from subterranean formations.
cooled in a series of three heat exchangers that heat Flameless Distributed Combustion technology
the EB and steam feed to the reactors and generate enables specific constraints in the conventional dehy-
steam. drogenation system to be overcome, in particular
The Fina=Badger distillation section consists of designing for low steam-to-oil ratios. A low steam-to-
three distillation columns. All the columns are oil ratio is desirable because of the substantial energy
designed to operate under vacuum to minimize tem- savings associated with superheating less steam. How-
perature and polymer formation. The first column ever, a practical lower steam-to-oil ratio limit exists
in the sequence splits the benzene and toluene by- due to the metallurgy of the steam superheater, steam
products from the unconverted EB and styrene pro- transfer lines, and interstage reheater. Flameless
duct. The benzene and toluene mixture is typically sent Distributed Combustion allows for operation at molar
to an integrated EB plant where it is further fractio- steam-to-oil ratios less than 7 : 1 without a costly
nated. In this case, the benzene by-product is ulti- metallurgy upgrade. This is accomplished by heating
mately consumed in the EB unit and the toluene the reaction mixture more directly through a combus-
becomes a by-product stream from the EB plant. tion and convective heat transfer process.
Styrene 2867
Flameless Distributed Combustion technology, identified catalyst formulations that provide more
unlike the Lummus=UOP Smart SM technology, does than 90% conversion of 4-vinylcyclohexene with
not directly combust hydrogen from the reaction approximately 92% selectivity to styrene.[11] S
mixture; hence it does not obtain the benefit of a favor-
able shift in equilibrium. Storage
operate the plant. The major cost components for total cost of production. The benzene cost is the largest
styrene production using conventional adiabatic cost component; hence, the economics of styrene
dehydrogenation process are listed in Table 2. The major production are highly dependent on benzene price.
cost of production is for the ethylene and benzene raw The raw materials cost has two components—one
materials, which account for approximately 80% of the dictated by the stoichiometry and the other caused by
yield losses occurring as a result of the process technol- efforts are aimed at further improvements in existing
ogy. If the unalterable stoichiometric raw material con- technologies and identification of new technologies
sumption is removed from the cost of production, the for styrene production opportunities. S
resultant distribution of cost components appears very
different, as shown in Fig. 7. From this perspective, the
raw materials’ cost is only about 15% of the incremen-
tal cost of production and the utilities and fixed costs REFERENCES
become dominant. Recent catalyst and process design
improvements have reduced the variable costs of styr- 1. Lidback, A. Styrene—This is Not a Drill, 2004
ene production, while ever-increasing complexity and World Petrochemical Conference, Chemical
more stringent regulations have greatly increased the Marketing Associates, Inc.: Houston: TX, March
fixed costs. Other recent trends, such as larger plant 23–25, 2004.
capacities and globalization of the styrene market, have 2. Carra, S.; Forni, L. Kinetics of catalytic dehydro-
also resulted in higher fixed costs.[13] genation of ethylbenzene to styrene. Ind Eng
The result of the shift of focus from variable to fixed Chem Process Des. Dev. 1965, 4 (3), 281–285.
costs is that plants are being designed for larger capa- 3. Matsui, J.; Sodesawa, T.; Nozaki, F. Influence of
cities. For example in 2003, typical new styrene plants carbon dioxide addition upon decay of activity of
in the Asia Pacific Region produced an average of 350 a potassium-promoted iron oxide catalyst for
KMTA styrene per year, nearly double the capacity of dehydrogenation of ethylbenzene. Appl. Catal.
typical plants started up just 5 years earlier. The drive 1991, 67, 179–188.
to reduce fixed costs has led to numerous revamps of 4. Hirano, T. Roles of potassium in potassium-pro-
existing plants to substantially increase capacity. In moted iron oxide catalyst for dehydrogenation of
many cases, capacity expansions on the order of 50% ethylbenzene. Appl. Catal. 1986, 26, 65–79.
are being implemented. 5. Kollar, J. Epoxidation Process. US Patent
The propylene oxide=styrene process, the only other 3,351,635, November 7, 1967.
commercial process for production of styrene, is a grow- 6. Chem Systems, Propylene Oxide 97=98–7,
ing influence on the overall styrene market economics. Tarrytown, New York, 1998.
When viewed from the perspective that styrene is the 7. Mullen, P. Enhancements in EB=SM technology.
primary product and propylene oxide is a by-product, In AIChE 2003 Spring Meeting Proceedings;
the economics of this process appear encouraging (Table AIChE Spring National Meeting. Houston: TX,
3). Depending on the credit value assigned to the propy- April 22–26, 2001.
lene oxide coproduct, the total cost of styrene produc- 8. Sardina, H. Dehydrogenation Process for
tion can be approximately 50% of conventional EB Production of Styrene from Ethylbenzene Com-
dehydrogenation technology. Approximately 33% of prising Low Temperature Heat Recovery and
the styrene capacity added between 1998 and 2003 was Modification of the Ethylbenzene–Styrene Feed
produced using propylene oxide=styrene technology. therewith. US Patent 4,628,136, December 9, 1986.
More recently, the trend appears to be reversing and 9. Imai, T. Dehydrogenation of Dehydrogenatable
propylene oxide=styrene processes are accounting for Hydrocarbons. US Patent 4,435,607, March 6,
less of newly installed capacity. Although propylene 1984.
oxide=styrene plants are built to produce propylene 10. Welch, V. Advanced styrene dehydrogenation
oxide, there is a profound impact on the styrene market with flameless distributed combustion. In AIChE
supply=demand balance. 2003 Spring Meeting Proceedings; AIChE Spring
National Meeting. Houston: TX, April 22–26,
2001.
CONCLUSIONS 11. Chem Systems PERP Report, Styrene from Buta-
diene, 93S3, Tarrytown, New York, 1995.
Since the first commercial-scale production in the 12. Technical Bulletin on Safe Handling & Storage of
1930s, styrene, mainly through its derivatives, has Styrene Monomer http:==www.sterlingchemicals.
become an integral part of life. Most people come in com=SCI=WEBSITE=scihome.nsf=(WebContent-
contact with numerous styrene-based products ByDocID)=0AF6F53F1881D0AA8626CD90082
throughout the course of a normal day. Demand for E36A?OpenDocument.
styrene is expected to continue growing at a rate com- 13. Ram, S. EB-SM splitter energy recovery options.
parable to the gross domestic product growth rate. In Styrene Conference General Session, Styrene
The chemical processing technologies that have been Conference, Prague, Czech Republic, June 22–
developed are sophisticated, producing styrene to meet 25, 2003; ABB Lummus Global, Sud-Chemie
the demand at low cost. Research and development AG, and UOP LLC, 2003.