Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Abstract—The use of batteries and other electrochemical Despite the impressive advancements in battery technology
devices in modern power systems is rapidly increasing, with in recent years, further improvements are still much needed
stricter requirements in terms of cost, efficiency and reliability. in key aspects for commercial applications, namely efficiency,
Innovative monitoring solutions are therefore urged to allow a
successful development of a wide range of emerging applications, reliability and cost. While most of the efforts toward such
including electric vehicles and large-scale energy storage to improvements are focused on battery design and material
support renewable energy generation. Presently, a huge gap technology, in-situ monitoring systems also play a very im-
still exists between the accurate and sophisticated monitoring portant role. In fact, a more accurate state estimation of the
techniques commonly employed in laboratory tests, on the one battery internal conditions would allow, on the one hand, a
hand, and the simple and rough solutions available in most
commercial applications, on the other hand. The objective of this better power management (therefore higher overall efficiency
paper is therefore to contribute to the development of low-cost but of the power system) and, on the other hand, a more accurate
accurate solutions for commercial battery condition monitoring, and prompter diagnosis of performance degradation processes
by proposing an embedded system that combines real-time digital (therefore a more reliable operation). If all this were achieved
signal processing with the high computational power and user at negligible additional instrumentation cost, the decrease in
friendly interface of a modern computer, at a cost comparable to
a simple micro-controller. In more detail, the paper focuses on the overall operation and maintenance costs would lead also
electrochemical impedance spectroscopy on a battery performed to large economic benefits.
by a DC-DC power converter, and it explains how the proposed Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy (EIS) is a very
low-cost off-the-shelf hardware can control the converter, acquire powerful non-invasive measurement technique, commonly em-
the measurement signals, accurately process them in the time and ployed in laboratory experiments, which provides a wealth
frequency domains, and estimate the result uncertainty in real-
time, which is necessary to promptly and reliably detect any of diagnostic information about electrochemical processes
variation in the battery condition. occurring within batteries (and fuel cells as well). The main
advantage compared to DC voltage and current measurements
Index Terms—Batteries, Battery management systems, Elec-
trochemical devices, Electrochemical impedance spectroscopy, alone is that EIS allows distinguishing between different
Condition monitoring, State estimation, DC-DC power converters processes and different causes of voltage drop, as they affect
the impedance spectrum in different frequency ranges, from
millihertz to kilohertz [2]. Several works in the literature
I. I NTRODUCTION have demonstrated how EIS can be effectively employed to
Batteries and more generally electrochemical power sources accurately estimate the battery state of charge (SOC) and
are playing an increasingly important role in modern power state of health (SOH) [2]–[6]. Nevertheless, the use of EIS
systems, driven by the wider use of renewable energy and in commercial applications is still hindered by the high in-
allowed by the recent developments in electrochemical tech- strumentation cost and the poor accuracy of results obtained
nology [1]. Battery use is no longer limited to low-power by low-cost solutions. Indeed, commercial applications cannot
devices, as many emerging applications nowadays include afford the expensive and sophisticated instrumentation used
large-scale energy storage for renewable energy generation and in the laboratory, such as frequency response analyzers, and
powertrain for electric or hybrid vehicles, just to mention a few as a result, in most cases only DC voltages and currents are
examples. monitored, on individual cells or on groups of cells, but in any
12.25 0.781 Hz
1.56 Hz
3.13 Hz
íIm(Z) [mΩ]
12.24 10
6.25 Hz
12.23
0 10 20 30 40 50 5
t [s]
3.2
0
3.1
í5
i [A]
3 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55
Re(Z) [mΩ]
2.9
Fig. 8. Battery impedance measured at 7 frequencies in the range from
2.8 98 mHz to 6.25 Hz, by using a multi-sine current perturbation. The uncertainty
0 10 20 30 40 50 of each impedance value (real and imaginary parts) is calculated in real-time
t [s] as standard deviation of 10 samples and is plotted as an ellipse around the
average value.
Fig. 7. Battery voltage (upper plot) and current (bottom plot) waveforms
with perturbations at 100 mHz, 1 Hz and 10 Hz, showing the linear drift of
the DC voltage while the battery is discharged. but also to monitor the changes of impedance values during
time.
An example of a transient showing a change in the battery
the amplitude of the AC voltage perturbation is usually very impedance is reported in Fig. 9, obtained again at a DC current
small, such a drift can give rise to significant errors in the level of 3.0 A; for sake of simplicity, only one impedance
signal frequency spectrum if not compensated. In the example value is reported, measured at 1.56 Hz. The upper plot shows
of Fig. 7, the current contains three sinusoidal components, at the significant voltage decrease during such a long transient,
100 mHz, 1 Hz and 10 Hz, each of them with an amplitude of corresponding to an overall charge variation ΔQ of more than
0.05 A which corresponds to a voltage oscillation amplitude of 2.5 Ah (the nominal battery capacity is 7.0 Ah), calculated by
approximately 3 mV; the linear drift in the voltage DC value is integrating the current. The voltage decrease is almost linear
-0.25 mV/s and is enough to create errors of approximately 2% during the first half of the transient, but then it becomes
and 30% in the impedance calculations at 1 Hz and 100 mHz, nonlinear. This slope change corresponds to a noticeable
respectively. Therefore a linear least-squares fitting in the time change in the real part of the impedance in the second half
domain is implemented in order to remove the linear trend in of the transient (as visible in the bottom plot), which creates
the voltage waveform before applying the FFT. an increasingly higher voltage drop. Such a variation can be
interpreted as an increase in the ohmic resistance, which is
IV. E XPERIMENTAL R ESULTS indeed expected to change with the SOC in lead-acid batteries
Fig. 8 shows part of the battery impedance spectrum, [6]. The impedance values reported in Fig. 9 are calculated
measured by using a multi-sine current perturbation containing on time windows of 5.12 s and averaged over 12 windows
7 frequency components from 98 mHz to 6.25 Hz, uniformly with a moving average filter. Similarly, the standard deviation
spaced on a logarithmic scale and each of them with an am- σ of the 12 samples is calculated to estimate the impedance
plitude of 0.1 A, superimposed to a DC current of 3.0 A. The uncertainty as described above. The uncertainty band plotted
impedance values are calculated on a time window of 40.96 s in Fig. 9 corresponds to an interval of ±2σ, which can be used
and then averaged over 10 windows. In addition to calculating to determine whether any observed change in the impedance
the average, also the standard deviation of the 10 samples is is significant or not, with a 95.45% confidence level (assuming
calculated in real-time, in order to have a type-A uncertainty Gaussian probability distributions). Based on this, it is possible
estimate, which in this case is the dominant contribution due to confirm that there is an actual change in the real part of the
to the large noise and random fluctuations affecting these impedance, whereas no significant variations are detected in
measurements. The standard deviation is calculated on the the imaginary part, in agreement with a variation of the ohmic
real and imaginary parts of the impedance separately, and the resistance alone.
results correspond to the semi-axes of the ellipses plotted in
V. C ONCLUSIONS
Fig. 8. Such uncertainty evaluation could be used, e.g., as
a weighting factor when fitting the measured data with an This paper described a low-cost hardware platform suitable
equivalent circuit model such as the one reported in Fig. 2, to perform in-situ electrochemical impedance spectroscopy
ΔQ [Ah] [3] W. Waag, S. Käbitz and D. U. Sauer, “Experimental investigation of
0 í0.5 í1 í1.5 í2 í2.5 the lithium-ion battery impedance characteristic at various conditions and
12.5 aging states and its influence on the application”, Applied Energy, vol.
102, pp. 885-897, 2013.
[4] D. Andre, M. Meiler, K. Steiner, Ch. Wimmer, T. Soczka-Guth and
12 D. U. Sauer, “Characterization of high-power lithium-ion batteries by
v [V]
íIm(Z) [mΩ]
[8] D. Depernet, O. Ba and A. Berthon, “Online impedance spectroscopy of
Re(Z) [mΩ]
R EFERENCES