You are on page 1of 5

916699

research-article2020
AJLXXX10.1177/1559827620916699American Journal of Lifestyle MedicineAmerican Journal of Lifestyle Medicine

vol. 14 • no. 4 American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine

Michelle E. Hauser, MD, MS, MPA, FACLM, Chef,


Julia R. Nordgren, MD, FNLA, Chef, Maya Adam,
MD, Christopher D. Gardner, PhD, FAHA,
Tracy Rydel, MD, Alaina M. Bever, BS, BA,
and Emma Steinberg, MD, FAAP, Chef

The First, Comprehensive,


Open-Source Culinary Medicine
Curriculum for Health Professional
Training Programs: A Global
Reach
Abstract: Providing a strong a CM course. The CMC highlights a of CM courses and expanding the
foundation in culinary medicine predominantly whole food, plant- reach of CM and counseling on dietary
(CM)—including what constitutes a based diet as seen through the lenses behavior changes into patient care.
healthy diet and how to find, obtain, of different world flavors and culinary
and prepare healthy and delicious traditions. It was developed, published, Keywords: culinary medicine; medical
food—is a cornerstone of educating and distributed with the aim of education; health professional education;
health professionals to support patients expanding CM by reducing barriers nutrition; diet; teaching kitchen
in achieving better health outcomes.
The Culinary Medicine Curriculum
(CMC), published in collaboration Diet has been identified as the most
with the American College of Lifestyle
Medicine, is the first, comprehensive,
important risk factor for morbidity
open-source guide created to support and mortality in the United States.
the implementation of CM at health
professional training programs (HPTPs)

C
worldwide. The CMC is modeled after to creating CM courses within most ulinary medicine (CM) is an
the successful CM elective course types of HPTPs and practice settings. emerging, evidence-based field
for Stanford University School of During the first 2 months the CMC was that integrates nutrition
Medicine students. Key goals of the available, it was downloaded 2379 education with culinary knowledge and
CMC include presenting healthy food times in 83 countries by a wide variety skills to assist patients in maintaining
as unapologetically delicious, quick, of health care professionals interested in health and preventing and treating food-
and inexpensive; translating lessons teaching CM. The global interest in this related diseases by choosing high-quality,
learned to healthy eating on-the-go; first, freely available, evidence-based healthy food in conjunction with
practicing motivational interviewing CMC underscores the demand for CM appropriate medical care.1,2 Diet has
on healthy dietary behavior changes; resources. Such resources could prove been identified as the most important
and demonstrating how to launch foundational in expediting development risk factor for morbidity and mortality in

DOI: 10.1177/1559827620916699. From the Primary Care and Population Health, Department of Medicine, Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California
https://doi.org/

(MEH, TR); Internal Medicine-Obesity Medicine, Palo Alto Veterans Affairs Health Care System, Palo Alto, California (MEH); Internal Medicine-Primary Care, San Mateo County
Health System, San Mateo, California (MEH); Pediatric Lipid and Weight Management, Palo Alto Medical Foundation, Palo Alto, California (JRN); Department of Pediatrics,
Stanford University School of Medicine, Stanford, California (MA); Stanford Prevention Research Center, Department of Medicine, Stanford University Medical School, Stanford,
California (CDG); Harvard Medical School, Boston, Massachusetts (AMB); and Department of Pediatrics, Kaiser Permanente, Northern California, San Francisco, California
(ES). Address correspondence to: Michelle E. Hauser, MD, MS, MPA, FACLM, Chef, Internal Medicine-Obesity Medicine, Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System, 3801
Miranda Ave, MC 111A, Palo Alto, CA 94304; e-mail: mehauser@stanford.edu.
For reprints and permissions queries, please visit SAGE’s Web site at www.sagepub.com/journals-permissions.
Copyright © 2020 The Author(s)

369
American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine Jul • Aug 2020

the United States3 and is associated with reach of this curriculum beyond includes detailed instructions and
11 million deaths across the globe Stanford’s campus. content needed to accomplish these
annually,4 yet most health care providers The Stanford CM course was taught by goals and suggestions for modifications
fail to meet the recommended number of dually trained physician-chefs with to adapt content to alternative CM
hours studying nutrition during their nutrition expertise. Understanding that session or course formats such as
training.5,6 The majority of nutrition this combination of training is rare one-time or limited-session classes (Table
education offered is didactic and focused among health professionals, the CMC 1).
on the biochemistry of nutrients and was adapted to enable a wide variety of This open-source curriculum was
health consequences of deficiency health professionals to teach CM in their developed to be used as a foundation for
states—content that is of limited use in training programs. Examples of the creation of elective CM courses
clinical settings where the risk of combinations of instructors likely to be within most types of health professional
overnutrition looms far greater due to successful in teaching a CM course using training programs. As written, student
high intake of ultra-processed, calorie- the CMC include (a) a professional with time commitment includes 9 class
dense foods. CM fills this educational training in culinary arts, nutrition, and sessions, each of 2 hours duration, with
gap by focusing on practical dietary the same health profession as students an average of approximately 30 minutes
behavior changes, nutrition knowledge, taking the course (eg, a nutrition-savvy of preparatory work for each session.
and cooking skills needed to make food physician-chef); (b) a clinician-educator This can be done weekly for those on
that is delicious, healthy, and accessible. who is knowledgeable about nutrition the quarter system. Class sessions
Consideration of time availability, and cooking; or (c) 2 or more instructors encompassing more than 1 topic—Soups
financial resources, and cultural food trained in complementary fields that and Salads, for example—can be divided
traditions are also important parts of any cover formal or informal culinary into 2 sessions to give more time to
successful CM program. training, nutrition expertise, and direct cover the material in detail while sticking
In recent years, understanding of the patient care experience (eg, a chef, with a weekly class schedule for those
importance of the CM approach to dietitian, and physician). For the example on the semester system. Instructor
nutrition education in health professional class size of 12 students, it is preparation for each session varies and is
training programs (HPTPs) has increased. recommended to include at least 2 indicated in the Instructor’s Outline—a
However, the lack of an easily accessible, instructors per session to divide the detailed guide to leading each course
evidence-based guide to implementing workload and ensure adequate student session (Table 2). Topics and techniques
CM has constituted a major barrier at oversight; however, this number can be covered include common and high-yield
most institutions. The Culinary Medicine increased or decreased proportionally healthy cooking techniques that can be
Curriculum (CMC),7 published in according to actual class size and kitchen easily incorporated into the repertoires
collaboration with the American College or classroom space. To increase the of families from a variety of cultural food
of Lifestyle Medicine in December 2019, generalizability of the content, lead traditions that are common in the United
is the first, comprehensive, open-source instructors can invite other faculty States.
guide created to support the members from a variety of specialties or
While CM does not endorse a single
implementation of CM at academic focus areas to join on a rotating basis.
dietary philosophy, the CMC has been
institutions worldwide. This helps students understand how CM
designed to focus on whole food,
The CMC is modeled after the content is applicable broadly in medicine
plant-based (WFPB) nutrition. It
successful CM elective course for medical and other health professions. Class
and physician assistant students at sessions can also be taught individually, highlights the dietary principles
Stanford University School of Medicine.2 rather than as a full course, and can be supported by the ACLM as outlined in
Both the Stanford CM course and the customized, if desired. the official position statement: “For the
CMC were developed by a group of The CMC incorporates lessons learned treatment, reversal, and prevention of
experts whose training includes internal in medical practice caring for diverse lifestyle-related chronic disease, the
medicine, family medicine, pediatrics, patients of all ages and with varying ACLM recommends an eating plan based
obesity medicine, lipidology, integrative levels of education and resources. Key predominantly on a variety of minimally
medicine, lifestyle medicine, nutrition goals of the curriculum include processed vegetables, fruits, whole
science, epidemiology, public policy, presenting healthy food as grains, legumes, nuts, and seeds.”8,9
medical school curriculum design, and unapologetically delicious, simple, filling, Because patients come from a variety of
culinary arts. The success of the course and inexpensive; translating lessons backgrounds and food traditions, the
and many requests for dissemination of learned to healthy eating on-the-go; curriculum introduces a predominantly
the curriculum, prompted author, practicing motivational interviewing on WFPB diet through the lenses of different
physician-chef Michelle Hauser, to healthy dietary behavior changes; and world flavors and culinary traditions
partner with the American College of discovering how to set up and run a CM while keeping in mind resource
Lifestyle Medicine (ACLM) to expand the course from the ground up. The CMC constraints.

370
vol. 14 • no. 4 American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine

Table 1.
Contents of the Culinary Medicine Curriculum.

• Descriptions of personnel and equipment needed for nine, 2-hour, in-person class sessions
• Suggestions for modifying curriculum content for use in one-time or limited-session CM classes
• Example course syllabus
• Explanations of faculty expertise required to teach a course
• Draft email invitations to invite faculty to join CM sessions
• A detailed Instructor’s Outline with all content needed for each session
• Goals and objectives for students for each class session
• Suggestion for class pre-work (in lieu of homework)
• Selected nutrition content to highlight during sessions
• Suggestions for supplemental materials, videos, references, and other resources
• Flow and content of each hands-on teaching kitchen session
• Menus, recipes, and handouts for each class session
• Discussion starters and patient-provider role play examples for interactive dinner discussions
• Health and safety considerations for CM courses
• Financial considerations in starting a CM course
• Equipment list for stocking a pop-up teaching kitchen

Abbreviations: CM, culinary medicine.

Table 2.
Instructor’s Outline.

Sessions Each Session Includes


1. Introduction to Kitchen Basics • Goals (for students)
2. Sauté, Stir-fry, Simmer, Braise • Objectives (for students)
3. Roasting • Materials to Review Before Class Session (Required and Optional
4. Soups & Salads Materials)
5. Beans & Whole Grains • Meal Description
6. Healthy Breakfasts • Recipes
7. Pastas and Sauces • Class Session Outline (ie, timing, instructor preparation, content, session
8. The Dessert Flip & Healthy Desserts flow)
9. Final Potluck • Key Points for Instructors/Faculty Volunteers to Discuss with Students
• Dinner Discussion (with patient motivational interviewing role play
activity)
• Related Nutrition/Clinical Correlates in the Curriculum
• Optional References

Western diets fall short of the major and most people find it difficult to patterns. Commonly cited challenges
goals of a predominantly WFPB diet10 abruptly change engrained eating include lack of nutrition knowledge and

371
American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine Jul • Aug 2020

food preparation skills, existing taste to analyze self-reported data for those who of CM courses and, by extension,
preferences for less healthy foods, downloaded the curriculum during the first expanding the urgently needed reach of
limited availability of healthier options, month it was available (December 2019 to CM and counseling on dietary behavior
family demands, financial resources, and January 2020). For this initial analysis, total changes into patient care. Future
time constraints. Given that any level of downloads, total number of countries in research is needed to determine
behavior change can potentially yield which downloads occurred, proportion of frequency of use of curricular materials,
improved health and well-being,11,12 the those downloading who had targeted impact on clinical practice for those who
CMC focuses on meeting individuals credentials, and proportion who planned have taken related CM courses, and
where they are and using motivational to teach CM within 2 years were effects on patient health outcomes.
interviewing to tailor dietary assessment, calculated. Those listing credentials were
recommendations, and interventions allowed to list more than one applicable
according to a patient’s personal goals credential. A follow-up analysis was Acknowledgments
and readiness for change.13-15 Concrete conducted for data collected during the This article includes numerous directly quoted excerpts and
strategies are given for health care first 2 months the CMC was available summarized sections of the Culinary Medicine Curriculum
(CMC), an open-source guide to running culinary medicine
providers who wish to partner with their (December 2019 to February 2020) and
(CM) courses in health professional training programs, that
patients on improving dietary choices, included total downloads and total number was published and distributed online by the American College
thereby assisting them in transitioning of countries in which downloads occurred. of Lifestyle Medicine in 2019. Because this content
along a spectrum toward more plant- During the first month the CMC was comprises the majority of the manuscript, quotation marks
centric diets emphasizing the available, it was downloaded 1481 times are not used to designate directly quoted material. The
authors thank Chef David Iott for his assistance in preparing
consumption of whole foods. in 63 countries. Of those listing targeted
for and teaching the CM sessions at the Teaching Kitchen @
Though the CMC was created for health credentials (N = 1226; 82.8%), the most Stanford University Dining Services, all of the Stanford
professional training programs (eg, frequently reported included physicians University School of Medicine students who took the Teaching
medical schools, nursing, psychology, (N = 711; 58.0%), registered dietitians (N Kitchen Elective for Medical Students, and all of the faculty
and dietetic programs), it is easily = 130; 10.6%), public health professionals who volunteered as session facilitators. Funding for the
course was provided by the Stanford Teaching and Mentoring
adaptable to a variety of other (N = 102; 8.3%), nurses (N = 78; 6.4%),
Academy Innovations Grant Program and Dr Jeanne Rosner
educational environments, including nurse practitioners (N = 60; 4.9%), and via SOUL Food Salon. Dr Hauser received support from the
residency programs, health and wellness health coaches (N = 60; 4.9%), with National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute via Training Grant
coaching, and master’s-level courses. To smaller numbers in the categories of 5T32HL007034-39 while teaching the course. Thanks also
adapt for patient care, patient education, doctors of philosophy or psychology, to our diverse patients and research subjects who have
public-facing education, or taught us so much about the complexities of making dietary
physician assistants, and physical or
changes; ACLM Executive Director, Susan Benigas, for her
undergraduate studies, one can simply occupational therapists. More than two support of the CMC and expanding the reach of food as
omit the portions of the curriculum thirds planned to teach CM within 2 medicine; Paulina Shetty for her assistance in producing and
focused on teaching providers to coach years either in a HPTP or patient care reviewing the CMC; Brenda Rea and Kayli Dice for reviewing
patients on making dietary lifestyle context. At 2 months, the CMC had been the contents of the CMC and providing feedback; Jason
changes. The majority of the curriculum Wimmert for his support in expanding the reach of CM; and
downloaded 2379 times in 83 countries.
Beth Frates for her mentorship in lifestyle medicine.
is broadly applicable. Providing health care professionals
The CMC was written, published, and with a strong foundation in CM—
distributed with the aim of expanding including what constitutes a healthy diet Author Contributions
CM by reducing barriers to creating CM and how to find, obtain, and prepare Dr Hauser was the primary author of the Culinary Medicine
courses (e.g., financial, knowledge, etc) healthy and delicious food—is a Curriculum from which this article was created; Drs Nordgren,
within most types of HPTPs and practice cornerstone of educating health Adam, Gardner, Rydel, and Steinberg, along with Ms Bever,
settings. Permission to use the materials professionals to support patients in were key contributors. Dr Hauser conducted data analysis. All
authors made critical revisions to the content and assisted in
can be obtained simply by emailing a achieving better health outcomes. Based
drafting manuscript content.
request to the address indicated in the on the analysis of data from the first 2
copyright statement, following months during which the Culinary
downloading of the CMC from https:// Medicine Curriculum was available, Declaration of
lifestylemedicine.org/culinary-medicine. evidence of substantial global interest Conflicting Interests
Use permission is granted on the emerged. This interest included the The author(s) declared no potential conflicts of interest with
condition that appropriate attribution development of CM courses across the respect to the research, authorship, and/or publication of this
accompanies all materials whether used spectrum of HPTPs and for patient care. article.
as-is or in edited form. There is no The global interest in this first, freely
charge. available, evidence-based CMC
To evaluate the reach of the CMC and underscores the demand for CM Funding
demand for evidence-based, open-source, resources. Such resources could prove The author(s) received no financial support for the research,
CM content, descriptive statistics were used foundational in expediting development authorship, and/or publication of this article.

372
vol. 14 • no. 4 American Journal of Lifestyle Medicine

Global Burden of Disease Study 2017. 10. US Department of Agriculture, Food


Ethical Approval Lancet. 2019;393:1958-1972. doi:10.1016/ and Nutrition Service. HEI Scores for
Not applicable, because this article does not contain any s0140-6736(19)30041-8 Americans: average Healthy Eating Index-
studies with human or animal subjects. 5. National Research Council Committee 2015 scores for Americans by age group.
on Nutrition in Medical Education. https://www.fns.usda.gov/hei-scores-
Nutrition Education in US Medical Schools. americans. Accessed September 17, 2019.
Informed Consent Washington DC: National Academy Press; 11. Wang X, Ouyang Y, Liu J, et al. Fruit and
Not applicable, because this article does not contain any 1985. vegetable consumption and mortality
studies with human or animal subjects.
from all causes, cardiovascular disease,
6. Adams KM, Kohlmeier M, Zeisel SH.
and cancer: systematic review and dose-
Nutrition education in US medical schools: response meta-analysis of prospective
latest update of a national survey. Acad cohort studies. BMJ. 2014;349:g4490.
Trial Registration Med. 2010;85:1537-1542. doi:10.1097/ doi:10.1136/bmj.g4490
Not applicable, because this article does not contain any ACM.0b013e3181eab71b
12. Bertoia ML, Mukamal KJ, Cahill LE, et al.
clinical trials. AJLM 7. Hauser ME. Culinary Medicine Curriculum. Changes in intake of fruits and vegetables
St Louis, MO: American College of Lifestyle and weight change in United States men
Medicine; 2019. and women followed for up to 24 years:
References analysis from three prospective cohort
8. American College of Lifestyle Medicine
1. La Puma J. What is culinary medicine and announces dietary lifestyle position studies. PLoS Med. 2015;12:e1001878.
what does it do? Popul Health Manag. statement for treatment and potential doi:10.1371/journal.pmed.1001878
2016;19:1-3. doi:10.1089/pop.2015.0003 reversal of disease [press release]. St. 13. Frates B. Collaborating, motivating, goal-
2. Hauser ME. A novel culinary medicine Louis, MO: Cision; September 25, 2018. setting, and tracking. In: Frates B, Bonnet
course for undergraduate medical https://www.prweb.com/releases/ JP, Joseph R, eds. Lifestyle Medicine
education. Am J Lifestyle Med. 2019;13:262- american_college_of_lifestyle_medicine_ Handbook: An Introduction to the Power
264. doi:10.1177/1559827619825553 announces_dietary_lifestyle_position_ of Healthy Habits. Monterey, CA: Healthy
3. US Burden of Disease Collaborators; statement_for_treatment_and_potential_ Learning; 2019.
Mokdad AH, Ballestros K, et al. The reversal_of_disease/prweb15786205.htm. 14. Bandura A. Health promotion from
State of US Health, 1990-2016: burden of Accessed March 18, 2020. the perspective of social cognitive
diseases, injuries, and risk factors among 9. Frates B. The nutrition-health connection. theory. Psychol Health. 1998;13:623-649.
US States. JAMA. 2018;319:1444-1472. In: Frates B, Bonnet JP, Joseph R, doi:10.1080/08870449808407422
doi:10.1001/jama.2018.0158 eds. Lifestyle Medicine Handbook: an 15. Prochaska JO, Velicer WF. The
4. GBD 2017 Diet Collaborators. Health Introduction to the Power of Healthy transtheoretical model of health behavior
effects of dietary risks in 195 countries, Habits. Monterey, CA: Healthy Learning; change. Am J Health Promot. 1997;12:38-48.
1990-2017: a systematic analysis for the 2019. doi:10.4278/0890-1171-12.1.38

373

You might also like