Professional Documents
Culture Documents
update
Spring 2024 Issue 5
Contents:
BIG IDEAS IN ECONOMICS – EQUILIBRIUM
EXAM TECHNIQUE – ADDRESSING SUBTLETIES IN QUESTIONS
LAST WORD – ANITA SUMMERS AND ROBERT SOLOW
QUANTITATIVE SKILLS – ELASTICITY
THE BABY FORMULA MARKET
REVISION STRATEGIES
ALTERNATIVES TO UNI – APPRENTICESHIPS
UK AND WORLD ECONOMY UPDATES
GDP – A BRIEF BUT AFFECTIONATE HISTORY
INDIA AND CASH
TAYLOR SWIFT – THE BUSINESS BEHIND THE MUSIC
ARGENTINA’S NEW PRESIDENT
www.tutor2u.net/economics
WELCOME
TO THE SPRING 2024 EDITION OF
THE TUTOR2U UPDATE MAGAZINE!
Let’s start with the fantastic response we received to the competition we ran last edition. The tutor2u team
had a great time reading your entries and a tough time choosing the winners. Congratulations to everyone
who took part. You can read about the winners on page 19 and our new competition.
As exam season approaches this issue has a particular focus on how to prepare and how to make sure your
economic knowledge translates into as many marks as possible.
Do make sure to check out our top tips on revision. One of the things students find the hardest is knowing where
to start and finding the motivation to get going. Our top tips give you a clear and easy starting point along with
suggestions to make sure every single minute you spend on revision achieves the most benefit. We have a double
Economy Update this time – one on the UK economy and one on the world – by our leading expert Geoff. Each
year examiners stress the importance of a good real-world knowledge in getting top marks. Finally, to make sure
you are not throwing away easy marks, make sure to read the article on elasticities. Elasticities have to be one of
the most common short questions.
For those of you thinking about next steps after Sixth Form we have an article on alternatives to university and
specifically apprenticeships. If your mind is made up on university don’t forget that the last edition gave you loads
of fantastic information on the options available and how to make a great application. You might want to look at
the book review in this edition for another idea of what to read. This comes from one of our fabulous poster sets if
you want a wider range of recommendations.
Finally, we have our usual range of interesting stories in the news. These are great for general interest and building
real world knowledge but also allow you to try out your application skills.
Keep an eye on the adverts for all the resources and upcoming events that will make your study of Economics fun
and effective.
Team tutor2u
Find us on X (formerly Twitter) and Instagram @tutor2uEcon
www.tutor2u.net/economics 3
FOCUS ON - EXAM TECHNIQUE
Addressing the subtleties of questions by Isobel Cafferty
It’s not unusual for students to miss out on marks because their response simply doesn’t answer the
question. This might be because they misread the question or drift off-topic. Sometimes students even
answer the question they wish had been asked!
A more frequent scenario, however, is that the student understands the general gist of the question but
doesn't pick up on the subtle details that make the question specific. The good news is that these details
tend to follow certain patterns. Learning to spot these allows you to address the nuances of the question,
elevating your answer from 'good' to 'great'.
Explain that the view given is Find a less extreme word to use Justify your view by explaining
reductionist. This means it over instead. For example, you might the circumstances when such an
looks small but important details. replace ‘inevitable’ with ‘highly extreme view wouldn't hold.
likely’.
Discuss the view that demand-side policies are ineffective Evaluate the extent to which there are information gaps for
and dangerous in times of stagflation both consumers and producers in the insurance market.
Evaluate the significance of rising petrol prices on the growth in demand for electric cars.
Task:
Identify any nuances in the following questions and
note how you would address these in your answer:
1 To what extent are behavioural policies the most
effective way to reduce congestion in the UK’s
cities?
2 Evaluate the view that governments of all
countries can and must do more to tackle
climate change.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 5
LAST WORDS… by Cathy Williams
Each week in a series called “Last Words” BBC Radio 4
tells the life story of people who have died recently. In this
edition of the Update Magazine, tutor2u has decided to do
the same for the world of Economics.
ANITA SUMMERS
First is Anita Summers who died in October 2023 at the age of 98. According to the University
of Pennsylvania (where she was an emeritus professor of Economics) she “was an intellectual
giant” who embarked on a career in Economics when “few women dared and even fewer
could”. She faced gender discrimination in a male-dominated industry, but she never gave up.
When she landed a job as an economic analyst for Standard Oil in New York City, the hiring
manager said they had hired her to get the same brains for less money. At that time women
were not allowed into meetings with top executives, but she fought (successfully) for the right.
Although she spent much of her career in academia, Her views on education that good teachers should
Summers should perhaps be best remembered for be rewarded and very poor teachers should go drew
her contribution to policy making at the federal, state, headlines making her husband worry that she should
and local level. She encouraged city and state have an armed guard. Summers said she thought
governing bodies to work together on issues such as about education from a financial standpoint.
education and urban development. She insisted that Education costs were the biggest cause of debt to
policymaking would be strengthened by economic city budgets. Furthermore, her work found that
analysis and that business and finance would benefit the most disadvantaged students were taught by
from a greater understanding of policymaking. At the teachers with the lowest grades on the National
heart of all she did lay the goal of fairness, equity, and Teacher Exam, the highest absences, and the
social justice but she was pragmatic about declining lowest student outcomes.
industries and instead encouraged focus on new Anita Summers came from a family of Economists.
and expanding sectors. After working at the Federal Her brother, Kenneth Arrow, won the Nobel Prize for
Reserve Bank of Philadelphia she was the founding Economics in 1972. Her brother-in-law Paul Samuelson
chairwoman of the public policy and management won the Nobel Prize in 1970. Her son Lawrence H.
department at Wharton Business School – the first Summers is an economist and former secretary of
of its kind. the US Treasury.
Summers believed that:
• policy should be based on evidence and not
values
• public policy should remember the stakeholders
who are most directly affected If you would like to hear
• government can learn from the private sector an interview with Anita
• companies should push for corporate social Summers scan the QR code:
responsibility
Solow made a huge contribution to our understanding as a topic that cannot be ignored. Inequality he says
of the factors that determine the rate of economic has created a self-reinforcing loop in which money
growth for different countries. Solow was awarded shapes government policies that favour the rich, thus
the Nobel Prize in 1987 for his contributions to the causing more inequality.
theory of economic growth. One of his original works Even at the age of 95 Solow continued to work, looking
presented a mathematical model that was a version at drafts of “The Work of the Future” – an MIT report
of the Harrod-Domar growth model (a model typically about technology, jobs, and economic growth. The
taught as part of Development Economics). He report emphasised social realities that technology has
followed this with a pioneering paper on the benefitted some and hurt others.
importance of technological innovation on growth,
questioning the belief at the time that capital and For six decades Solow shared an office with Paul
labour were the main causes of economic growth. Samuelson. His PhD students included Akerlof,
Solow’s work prompted governments to focus more Nordhaus and Stiglitz – all of whom went on to win
of their funding into technological research and a Nobel prize themselves. He commented that one of
development. the things of which he was proudest was building the
Economics Department at MIT so that it would pay
Back in 1962 Solow was a staff economist for the
attention to students. The result was for the MIT
White House’s Council of Economic Advisers and he Technology Review to comment “Sure, he won a
reported that occasionally the phone would ring, and Nobel for his research on technology, productivity,
John F. Kennedy would be on the line wanting to talk and growth. But his legacy as a mentor is equally
Economics. At that time the top 1% of earners in the remarkable.”
US accounted for 12.6% of national income while the
bottom 50% of earners had 19.5%. That position has
now reversed prompting Solow to describe inequality
www.tutor2u.net/economics 7
FOCUS ON - QUANTITATIVE SKILLS
Elasticity by Ruth Tarrant
Elasticity essentially means ‘sensitivity’ or ‘responsiveness’. When you first study demand and supply, you explore
the basic relationship between price and quantity demanded/supplied. Elasticity is the next step in developing
our understanding, for example, if price changes then by how much does quantity demanded change?
There are four elasticities that you need to know about for A Level Economics:
• Price Elasticity of Demand (PED) – the responsiveness of quantity demanded to a change in price
• Income Elasticity of Demand (YED) – the responsiveness of demand to a change in income
• Cross (Price) Elasticity of Demand (XED) – the responsiveness of demand for one good to a change in the
price of another good
• Price Elasticity of Supply (PES) –the responsiveness of quantity supplied to a change in price
Top Tip! Note that all the above definitions show demand/supply changing in response to a change in price/
income. This gives us information about the formulae: the % change in price/income is always the denominator.
2 Average income in a small town rises by 2%, and as a result, demand for meals out at restaurants in that
town rise by 4%. Calculate the income elasticity of demand for restaurant meals.
3 The price of olive oil rises from 80p per litre to £1.20 per litre due to climate change. As a result, the number
of bottles of olive oil sold at a local supermarket falls from 200 per week to 160 per week. Calculate the
price elasticity of demand of olive oil.
4 The price for 1 hour of golf at a driving range rises from £10 per hour to £12 per hour owing to rising staff
costs. As a result, demand for coffee from the on-site coffee shop falls from 30 cups per day to 25 cups
per day. Calculate the cross elasticity of demand between driving range golf and coffee shop drinks.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 9
Now, have a go at answering the following questions:
5 The cross price elasticity of demand between gym memberships and road-bike prices is estimated to be 0.2.
If the average price of road-bikes rises by £400 from £2000, calculate the percentage change in the demand
for gym memberships.
6 Suppose that the income elasticity of demand for cinema tickets is known to be +1.2. If demand for
cinema tickets falls by 36% during a strong recession, determine the percentage change in income that
must have occurred.
BIGGER
= more than 1
SMALLER
When the number on the bottom changes i.e. the % change When the number on the bottom changes i.e. the % change
in P or the % change in Y, it leads to a MORE THAN in P or the % change in Y, it leads to a LESS THAN
PROPORTIONATE change in the number on the top. i.e. the % PROPORTIONATE change in the number on the top i.e. the %
change in Qd or % change in Qs is HIGHLY RESPONSIVE... change in Qd or % change in QS is HIGHLY UNRESPONSIVE...
this means the relationship is ELASTIC this means the relationship is INELASTIC
7 The price of a bottle of Wild and Free shampoo rises from £3 to £3.30, causing the number of bottles bought
each week to fall by 15%. Calculate the PED for Wild and Free shampoo and interpret the value.
8 In recent years, many sports equipment manufacturers have recognised that there is lots of profit to be
had in the paddleboarding industry. As the price of paddleboards has risen by 30% in the last 2 years, the
quantity of paddleboards supplied has risen from 75,000 per year to 125,000 per year. Calculate the PES
for paddleboards and interpret the value.
–∞ ∞
-1 0 1
Big / Small i.e. elastic Big / Small i.e. elastic
Inferior goods – as income rises demand falls Normal goods – as income rises demand rises
–∞ ∞
-1 0 1
Big / Small i.e. a strong relationship Big / Small i.e. a strong relationship
9 When a hairdresser’s salon raised the price of a blow-dry service from £15 to £20, the manager noticed that
demand for their boutique Finishing Spray actually rose from 30 bottles per week to 40 bottles per week.
Calculate the XED between blow-dry services and Finishing Spray, and comment on the value that you
calculate.
10 A medium-sized US city experiences an increase in income per head from $2000 per month to $2100 per
month. The city government notices that demand for parking spaces rises by 10%. Determine the YED of
parking spaces, and comment on the value that you calculate.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 11
MARKET CONCENTRATION IN THE BABY
FORMULA MILK MARKET by Liz Veal
What is market concentration? Market concentration refers to the extent to which a relatively small number of
firms dominate the total market for a particular product or service. Here we are going to apply this concept to
the baby formula milk market.
The Concentration Ratio The baby formula milk market has a high two-firm A combination of early
expresses the percentage concentration ratio with Danone and Nestlé collectively brand choice, effective
of total market sales or marketing strategies,
production accounted for holding 85% of the market share in the UK. The reasons emotional attachment,
by a specified number of for this concentration include the tendency for parents and limited competition
the largest firms in the to stick with their chosen formula and the marketing contributes to parents
industry. For example, a tactics by the multinational companies emphasising their sticking with their chosen
four-firm concentration baby formula and being
ratio considers the product's similarity to breast milk. less likely to switch
combined market share to other brands. There
of the top four companies.
Advantages of this high market concentration include is some behavioural
Find out what the potential economies of scale, efficiency, and increased economics in this.
Herfindahl-Hirschman innovation. Firms in an oligopoly (where there are a
Index (HHI) is. handful of large firms) can often earn supernormal
profit into the long run and re-invest it in the business to
improve the quality of the formula and/or the method
The types of economies
of scale contributing of production, so the end product is better value.
to the cost advantages
enjoyed by larger-scale
However, the disadvantages are more apparent. The The Competition and
Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has raised Markets Authority (CMA)
producers of baby formula
is responsible for consumer
milk include technical, concerns about limited consumer choice, higher prices protection. It enforces
purchasing, marketing, than input costs, and the possibility of misleading competition and market
financial, risk-spreading;
they also can use R&D to marketing by dominant firms. The CMA plans to regulation by investigating
investigate and consider some regulatory changes cases, making rulings
support more innovation.
and issuing penalties.
Economies of scale to tackle these issues. According to the Institute
can act as a barrier to
of Government the CMA
entry, increasing market A 25% rise in infant formula prices over the past valued its direct financial
concentration over time. two years in the UK and weak competition prevented benefit to consumers at £2
What types of efficiency
may increase in an
consumers from opting for cheaper alternatives. The billion per year between
high gross margins in the infant formula market, 2019 and 2022. What sort
oligopoly?
of regulations might make
coupled with emotional attachment and limited brand the formula market work
switching, contributing to the concentration. The CMA better?
found significant price variations within the market, with
Danone's cheapest product priced at 13p per 100ml
and its most expensive at 35p.
The baby formula milk market does seem to be one that needs some government or regulatory intervention given
there are several market failures apparent. These include excessive prices for a necessity, a lack of competition,
information gaps, irrational consumers, and income inequality issues.
It is always good to think about what type of market failures exist in a specific
market/industry because this helps inform you about what the most appropriate
policies to address the failures could be. TRY THIS APPROACH FOR OTHER
MARKETS/INDUSTRIES – think about what market failures might be present
in each market/industry and choose the best interventions to address these
failures specifically.
Year 12 question:
Explain why consumers in the baby formula market may not be rational.
Year 13 question:
Assess whether the CMA should aim to introduce more contestability
into the baby formula market.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 13
EFFECTIVE REVISION IN ECONOMICS by Ruth Tarrant
It’s never too early to make a start on revising for your A Level exams. In this article, we explore three highly effective
Economics revision strategies. It’s really important to note that we don’t recommend highly passive revision strategies
e.g. highlighting notes, skim-reading textbooks etc. We DO recommend a number of active revision strategies.
2 Break the specification down into smaller, more manageable chunks – this is pretty straightforward if you have it printed off!
4 Check that you have notes for every bullet point on the specification – make sure you look carefully at any “command” words
in the specification eg explain, calculate, state, evaluate etc, and ensure that your notes match those command words.
5 See if you can find a relevant video for each topic – tutor2u has revision videos for virtually every topic. Create a document with
links, and a way to indicate when you have watched it.
6 Where relevant, ensure that you have an example for every bullet point on the specification – you can reuse examples to help
you! We suggest that you have a UK-based example for each point and, where relevant, an overseas or alternative example.
7 Revisit each bullet point and see what you can write down for each point – the writing bit is really important, as this is what
you will need to do in an exam. You don’t need full sentences at this point, and you can be flexible about how you write down
what you know…mind maps are fine!
8 Compare your ‘notes from memory’ with your class notes, textbook and revision videos – use a different colour to add in
anything that you missed. Use yet another different colour or highlighter to indicate any sections that you are unsure of –
find a relevant video or textbook or ask your teacher.
9 Use the tutor2u Exam Paper Topic Trackers to help you find past paper questions for each topic so that you can check whether
you are ‘exam ready’.
10 Do this for every part of the spec – keep everything in a folder together so that you know exactly how you are getting on with
your revision.
Give Explain
Theories Diagrams advantages / it to a
CONCEPT disadvantages
Task beginner
CARDS CARDS
www.tutor2u.net/economics 15
ARE YOU CONSIDERING AN
APPRENTICESHIP? by Penny Brooks
What are apprenticeships?
An apprenticeship is an opportunity to work and be paid, and to study at the same time. They are offered in a huge
variety of roles, from nursing to architecture to marketing, and in organisations of all sizes, from banking to the arts to
teaching. They usually take between 1 and 5 years to complete, depending on their level.
Apprentices become part of a work team, learning on-the-job from experienced colleagues, as well as developing skills
such as problem solving, communication and time management. They also study one or two days per week, or in short
blocks, such as a week at a time, either in college or online. Overall, about 20% of the time is spent studying and 80%
of the time working.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 17
Other Economics-related Apprenticeships
Examples of Business and Management Finance and accounting Sales, marketing and
sectors apprentices apprentices procurement apprentices
Popularity of 77,000 people started a Over 1 million people are Over 250,000 people
the sector business and administration currently working in the are working in sales and
apprenticeship in 2021/22 finance sector in the UK marketing in the UK
You might • are interested in the ways • are interested in finance and • like the idea of marketing
suit this businesses work how it works for big brands
apprenticeship • like the idea of managing • are passionate about maths • enjoy working with and
if you: projects or people talking to people
• enjoy working with numbers
• are entrepreneurial and are • are interested in how
interested in starting your businesses work and make
own business profit
www.tutor2u.net/economics 19
THE UK ECONOMY AN UPDATE
by Geoff Riley
When will UK monetary policy interest rates start to fall? By Geo8 Riley
Having reached a sixteen-year high of 5.25% last Autumn, there is now a robust, live
When willdebate
UK among
monetary policy
economists interest
and market rates
participants start
about to fall?
the timing of a relaxation of
Having reached a sixteen-year
UK monetary policy.high of 5.25%
Will policy last rates
interest Autumn, there
fall in is now
the late a robust,
Spring? Or willlive debate
relief for among
heavily indebted consumers and businesses be delayed to the Autumn?
economists and market participants about the timing of a relaxation of UK monetary policy. At their January
Will policy
meeting, members of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) voted 6-3 to keep
interest rates fall in the late Spring? Or will relief for heavily indebted consumers and businesses be rates on
hold. One person on the MPC actually voted to raise rates higher, two to lower them. But
delayed to the Autumn? At their January meeting, members of the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) voted
Andrew Bailey, Governor of the Bank of England hinted that he and his committee were
6-3 to keep rates onfor
looking hold.
moreOne personthat
evidence on the MPCwill
inflation actually voted the
fall towards to raise
2 per rates higher,
cent target andtwo to lower them.
settle
But Andrew Bailey, Governor of the Bank of England
there before rate cuts would be actioned. hinted that he and his committee were looking for
more evidence that inflation will fall towards the 2 per cent target and settle there before rate cuts would
be actioned. Chart 1:
Average inflation rate and central bank interest rate in the UK from January 2018 to
Chart 1: December 2023
Average inflation rate and central bank interest rate in the UK from January 2018 to December 2023
Central bank interest rate Inflation rate
12.0%
10.0%
8.0%
6.0%
4.0%
2.0%
0.0%
Jan 2018
Sep 2018
Mar 2018
Jan 2019
Sep 2019
Mar 2019
Jan 2020
Sep 2020
Mar 2020
Jan 2021
Sep 2021
Mar 2021
Jan 2022
Sep 2022
Mar 2022
Jan 2023
Sep 2023
Mar 2023
May 2018
Jul 2018
Nov 2018
May 2019
Jul 2019
Nov 2019
May 2020
Jul 2020
Nov 2020
May 2021
Jul 2021
Nov 2021
May 2022
Jul 2022
Nov 2022
May 2023
Jul 2023
Nov 2023
Our chart shows the path of inflation and interest rates in the UK over the last four years. Inflation began to
Our chart shows the path of inflation and interest rates in the UK over the last four years.
accelerate in Inflation
Autumn began
2021 and peaked a in
to accelerate year later. 2021
Autumn The Bank of England
and peaked started
a year tightening
later. The Bank ofmonetary policy in
early 2022 and raisedstarted
England interesttightening
rates fourteen times
monetary in succession
policy in early 2022to aand
current
raisedhigh of 5.25%.
interest rates The last two years
has been a severe
fourteen times in succession to a current high of 5.25%. The last two years has real
phase of deflationary monetary policy, and the financial pain has been beenfora households
on mortgages,severe
consumers with
phase of expensivemonetary
deflationary credit card bills and
policy, andthe
businesses
financial that
pain have borrowed
has been real forheavily pre and
post-pandemic.households
Consider on
themortgages,
data in theconsumers withwhich
second chart expensive
trackscredit card mortgage
average bills and businesses
interest rates in the UK.
that have borrowed heavily pre and post-pandemic. Consider the data in the second
chart which tracks average mortgage interest rates in the UK.
Chart 2:
Average mortgage
Chart 2:interest rate in the UK from 1st quarter 2010 to 2nd quarter 2023
Average
5.0% mortgage interest rate in the UK from 1st quarter 2010 to 2nd quarter 2023
4.5%
Mortgage interest rate
4.0%
3.5%
3.0%
2.5%
2.0%
1.5%
1.0%
Q1 2010
Q3 2010
Q1 2011
Q3 2011
Q1 2012
Q3 2012
Q1 2013
Q3 2013
Q1 2014
Q3 2014
Q1 2015
Q3 2015
Q1 2016
Q3 2016
Q1 2017
Q3 2017
Q1 2018
Q3 2018
Q1 2019
Q3 2019
Q1 2020
Q3 2020
Q1 2021
Q3 2021
Q1 2022
Q3 2022
Q1 2023
1.3
1.3
1.2
1.2
1.1
1.1
1.0
Apr 5, 2020
May 14, 2020
Apr 5, 2021
Feb 24, 2021
Apr 5, 2022
Feb 24, 2022
Apr 5, 2023
Feb 24, 2023
The Bank’s caution is underlined by worries that inflation has remained high and
“sticky” in some sectors, notably service industries. Pay growth has slowed a little but is
now above inflation (welcome news for people wanting a real wage rise!) and the Bank
may fret that inflation expectations have become embedded at a level inconsistent with
meeting the 2% inflation target. New data on the labour market suggests that
unemployment measured by the Labour Force Survey is now 3.9% and, whilst job
vacancies are declining, many businesses continue to experience shortages of skilled
workers that push wages higher to recruit and retain employees. You can see from our
chart below that inflation in services is running well ahead of goods. The Bank of
England is also worried that the 10 per cent rise in the national minimum wage due in
April will ramp up costs and perhaps prices. And there is some concern within the MPC
about the possible inflationary e]ects of a pre-election tax giveaway by the Chancellor.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 21
The case for delaying a cut in interest rates
The Bank’s caution is underlined by worries that inflation has remained high and “sticky” in some sectors,
notably service industries. Pay growth has slowed a little but is now above inflation (welcome news for people
wanting a real wage rise!) and the Bank may fret that inflation expectations have become embedded at a level
inconsistent with meeting the 2% inflation target. New data on the labour market suggests that unemployment
measured by the Labour Force Survey is now 3.9% and, whilst job vacancies are declining, many businesses
continue to experience shortages of skilled workers that push wages higher to recruit and retain employees.
You can see from our chart below that inflation in services is running well ahead of goods. The Bank of England
is also worried that the 10 per cent rise in the national minimum wage due in April will ramp up costs and
perhaps prices. And there is some concern within the MPC about the possible inflationary effects of a pre-
election tax giveaway by the Chancellor.
Core Goods and Services Price Inflation in the UK (Annual % Change)
9.0
8.0
7.0
6.0
5.0
4.0
3.0
2.0
1.0
0.0
Jan 2017
Apr 2017
Jul 2017
Jan 2018
Oct 2017
Apr 2018
Jul 2018
Jan 2019
Oct 2018
Apr 2019
Jul 2019
Jan 2020
Jan 2021
Jan 2022
Oct 2019
Apr 2020
Jul 2020
Oct 2020
Apr 2021
Jul 2021
Oct 2021
Apr 2022
Jul 2022
Jan 2023
Oct 2022
Apr 2023
Jul 2023
Oct 2023
UK CPI core goods inflation UK CPI services inflation
Is the Bank of England being too cautious in holding off reducing interest rates? The Governor and the Chief
Economist areIskeen
the Bank of England
to dampen being too cautious
expectations in holding
that borrowing o]will
costs reducing interestsoon.
fall anytime rates? The point to much
They
Governorboth
economic uncertainty and the
homeChief
andEconomist
abroad. Thearelatest
keen to dampen
risk expectations
to inflation flows from thatevents
borrowing
in the Red Sea
where attacks on commercial vessels have started to disrupt key shipping routes, increasing and
costs will fall anytime soon. They point to much economic uncertainty both home transportation
abroad. The
costs which eventually arelatest risk onto
passed to inflation flows from
consumers. eventsisincertain.
One thing the RedInflation
Sea where attacksback
dropping on to 2% might
commercial vessels have started to disrupt key shipping routes, increasing
happen by the time you read this article and before the exams. But it is not automatic that interest rates have
transportation costs which eventually are passed onto consumers. One thing is certain.
to fall in response. Thedropping
Inflation UK economy is 2%
back to having
mightto happen
adjust tobyathe
higher
time“normal” levelarticle
you read this of policy
andinterest
before rates – and
that normal isthecloser to 5% than 2%. We will leave the debate about the 2% inflation
exams. But it is not automatic that interest rates have to fall in response. The UKtarget to another time!
economy is having to adjust to a higher “normal” level of policy interest rates – and that
normal is close to 5% than 2%. We will leave the debate about the 2% inflation target to
another time!
www.tutor2u.net/economics 23
INDIA – WILL CASH EVER GO AWAY?
by Cathy Williams
Money has 4 functions In 2016 India announced that two bank notes which accounted for Legal tender are notes
in Economics. It is a 86% of the currency in circulation would no longer be legal tender. and coins that must
medium of exchange, There was little warning, and the result was scenes of chaos outside be accepted to settle
a store of value, a a debt.
banks and cash machines as people tried to deposit these notes in a
unit of account and a
standard of deferred bank account or exchange them for new currency. Many were unable The ban was called
payment. For those to obtain supplies of legal cash in the short run leaving them with no demonetisation. If
reliant on cash, the means of payment. Critics said the policy hurt those on low incomes economic agents
sudden reduction of and in the informal economy where people mainly dealt in cash. One make transactions
cash in circulation estimate said 90% of all transactions at that time were in cash with through a bank
made paying for 85% of workers paid in cash. The Prime Minister Narendra Modi said account it is much
goods and services easier to track illegal
the aim of the move was to reduce undeclared wealth, increase tax
very difficult. activity and the tax
compliance and reduce corruption. It would help rid India of counterfeit base for example
notes used by terrorists, for example. Professor Basu from New York’s increases.
Cornell University said the damage was likely to exceed the benefits.
The IMF think that a Any benefits in reducing corruption are likely to be one off and The informal economy
better measure of the corruption will return as soon as new currency is issued. is where activities
importance of cash is have value, but they
cash withdrawals from Some seven years later and cash is still important in India, leading are not recorded.
ATMs or as a share of some to question if the demonetisation policy was necessary. Cash in Examples include
all payments. On these circulation as a share of GDP peaked at over 14% in 2020-21. subsistence farming or
measures the trend a workman asking to
in cash use is falling At the same time digital transactions are growing in India. This is driven be paid in cash.
for half the world’s by smartphone and debit card usage and the widespread delivery
population. of welfare benefits using digital means. The increase is in large part When a policy leads
explained by the Unified Payments Interface. This platform allows rapid to an overall reduction
The velocity of account-to-account transfers. Some economists call the growth of in welfare economists
circulation means call this government
the number of times
both cash AND digital payments a “currency demand” paradox. Part of
failure.
cash is used in a the reason for the dual growth in cash and digital is that the velocity
certain period. If of circulation of money has slowed. Another reason is that for many Cash and digital
velocity slows then households in India cash is often used for precautionary savings. A payment methods
any given amount of recent survey found that people still prefer cash for food purchases and should be substitutes
cash is used for less home repairs. A further factor is falling interest rates on bank deposits. – meaning as demand
transactions. for one goes up then
Another currency experiencing growth in digital and physical cash is demand for the other
Falling interest rates the euro. The number of banknotes in circulation has risen consistently should go down.
reduce the opportunity while more and more retail payments are made digitally. In Sweden the
cost of holding cash. opposite is happening – people prefer digital while policy makers are Precautionary savings
trying to keep cash. are “just in case
savings” e.g. a period
Source: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-india-67674453 of unemployment
or a breakdown of
an expensive item.
If you want to know more on the In this case cash is
comparison between India and performing a “store of
Sweden then scan this QR code: value” function.
Year 12 question
Explain the importance of money in allowing economic agents to specialise.
Year 13 question
Explain why a country such as India wishes to reduce the size of its informal economy.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 25
GLOBAL ECONOMY by Geoff Riley
800
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024
Source: World Bank
So what are some of the main economic and social benefits of remittance inflows?
1 Supplementary Income: Remittances can be a vital reforms and development strategies. Moreover,
source of extra income for millions of households fluctuations in remittance flows can expose economies
in recipient countries. The funds received contribute to vulnerabilities, particularly in times of global
significantly to improving income per capita by downturns or unexpected changes in migration policies.
covering essential expenses such as food, housing, Consider for example, the flux in UK migration policy
education, and healthcare. This contributes to a and rules in the last few years since the UK left the
reduction in absolute poverty. Remittances can also European Union.
help counter malnutrition among the young which is a 2 Potential Dutch Disease: A sudden and very large
fundamental cause of persistent poverty. An UNCTAD influx of remittances can lead to a phenomenon
report in 2011 found that a 10 per cent increase in known as "Dutch Disease," where an over-reliance
the share of remittances in a country's GDP, led to a on remittances can cause a currency appreciation
reduction of 1.6 per cent of people living in poverty. in the foreign exchange market thereby making
2 Enhanced Financial Stability: Remittance inflows exports less price competitive. This can negatively
act as a buffer against economic shocks, such as impact other sectors of the economy, leading to a
recession-induced unemployment or the impact of lack of diversification and long-term economic
natural disasters, providing a safety net that mitigates growth constraints.
poverty and vulnerability. This is especially true 3 Brain Drain: While remittances provide immediate
for countries where the poor are largely excluded financial benefits, they may also exacerbate the brain
from basic financial services such as insurance. drain phenomenon, where skilled workers migrate to
Remittances can bolster a country’s US dollar reserves seek better economic opportunities abroad. This brain
and increase the foreign exchange available to the drain can result in a loss of human capital and talent,
banking system which in turn might lead to a rise in hindering the long-term development prospects and
commercial bank lending to businesses including supply-side potential of recipient countries.
start-ups.
3 Macroeconomic Stability: Remittances contribute to One of the underlying issues with remittances is the very
stabilising national economies by providing a steady high cost of making money transfers across national
source of foreign exchange inflows. This helps in borders. Cutting this cost towards 3% by the year 2030
improving a nation’s current account on the Balance is one of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) but
of Payments, maintaining currency stability, and we are a long way from achieving it. The most expensive
supporting overall economic growth. There is some countries in the world to send remittances to largely
evidence – including from the IMF - that remittance consist of countries in Sub-Saharan Africa. Average costs
flows into poorer countries are counter-cyclical, of sending remittances in 2023 were highest in Sub-
meaning that they often rise at times when incomes Saharan Africa (7.9 percent) and the lowest in South Asia
in the domestic economy are falling or flat, helping to (4.3 percent).
moderate the economic cycle at times when other Given the significance of labour migration as a
flows of private money into an economy such as FDI dominant political issue in the UK, Europe and beyond,
might be declining. it is definitely worth being aware of the importance of
However, remittance flows are not without potential risks remittance flows in the growth and development debate.
and drawbacks: A key takeaway point is that remittances flow now
dominates overseas aid and FDI across borders and that
1 Dependency and Fragility: Heavy reliance on is unlikely to change anytime soon.
remittances can create a sense of dependency among
recipient countries, perhaps leading to complacency
in implementing necessary structural economic
www.tutor2u.net/economics 27
TAYLOR SWIFT: THE BUSINESS BEHIND THE MUSIC
by Nicky King
Understanding how Taylor Swift has rewritten the rules of pop stardom. She has
Swift operated amassed a net worth of an estimated $1.1 billion as CEO and
her business is executive manager of the brand Taylor Swift. Swift has carved out a
‘application’. remarkable career in the business side of the music industry using
clever marketing strategies and savvy brand partnerships, becoming
one of the wealthiest musicians of our time. This is how:
• Music and streaming: Swift skyrocketed to fame with her
transition from country music to pop. Both physical and digital
album sales soared.
• World tours and concerts: Swift is renowned for her Live performances
are a complement
spectacular live performances, with sold out shows around the
to Swift’s music.
world. Concerts are a major income stream.
Heavy branding and
brand proliferation
• Endorsements and brand partnerships: Swift aligns with
makes the Taylor brands like Coke, Keds, and Apple Music, extending her brand
Swift products more beyond music.
price inelastic in • Merchandising: branded clothing and collectibles earn Swift
demand. considerable income from fans. This is testament to her ability
to connect with her audience on a personal level with
clever use of social media.
• Songwriting and publishing: Swift’s talent as a songwriter is
key to her success. Signing deals with Republic Records and Diversifying assets
Universal Music Group showcased her business acumen. It also means spreading
retained control over her work and earnings. the risk of those
assets. If one area of
It is important to • Property: Swift has made high profile property investments in assets falls in value,
distinguish between Rhode Island and New York City. This has diversified her wealth it may not impact
‘income’ and portfolio. overall wealth very
‘wealth’. Income is • Entrepreneurial ventures: Swift’s own fragrance and app “The much.
a stream of money Swift Life” demonstrates her ability to explore new avenues of
over time. Wealth income and be innovative.
is a stock of assets,
they are already Taylor Swift tours are highly anticipated and draw fans from around World tours are
owned. the globe. The excitement of the Eras tour drew overwhelming exports – the
demand for tickets. The surge in demand for tickets caused many money streams into
platforms to crash, leaving thousands of fans unable to purchase the US as export
tickets. revenue.
Added to this, bots and ticket touts quickly purchased large batches
of tickets, then resold them at highly inflated prices on the secondary
markets. This drove up the price of tickets for genuine fans.
Year 12 question
a Draw a demand and supply diagram showing a price inelastic demand curve for Taylor Swift merchandise.
b Show the effect of a reduction in the supply of merchandise due to the global supply chain problems.
c On the diagram, indicate the area representing:
• the loss of total revenue resulting from the shift in supply
• the increase in total revenue resulting from the shift in supply
Year 13 question
Draw a cost and revenue diagram showing the impact on supernormal profit of a rise in production costs resulting
from the technical glitches in the platforms when selling concert tickets. (Hint: variable costs will rise).
www.tutor2u.net/economics
www.tutor2u.net/economics 29
29
ARGENTINA An opinion piece by George Vlachonikolis
For as long as I have been a teacher, Argentina has been used as the case-study of how not to run an economy. Despite
being a G20 country with a GDP of around half a trillion US dollars, statistics don’t lie:
• 40% of the population lives below the poverty line.
• Current inflation rates lie at somewhere between 150% and 250% depending on your source of information.
• Argentina has defaulted on its international debt nine times, including three times during the past two decades.
• It is the largest debtor in the world to the IMF (over $100bn to the IMF; over $400bn in total).
• At the turn of the millennium, the Argentinian Peso was pegged to the dollar at 1 USD to 1 Peso. After a series of currency
crises (2014, 2018, 2019), the exchange rate in early 2024 was1 USD to 822 Peso. The Peso has lost 99.3% of its value in
20 years.
Understandably, the people of Argentina are looking for some In his first few months in power, Milei has already tried to take
economic stability in the future management of their country. a chainsaw to the old regime. In barely any time at all, he has
In December 2023, they elected Javier Milei to be their new initiated proposals to:
President. From his Wikipedia page, you might assume that • end automatic pension increases
Milei is the perfect fit: a data-driven technocrat with an • decrease transfer payments from the welfare state,
expert level of economic understanding. For example: he
• cut worker protections
has an undergraduate degree and two postgraduate degrees
in Economics, he has spent 20 years as a professor of • eliminate price controls on medicines and cut public
macroeconomics (with, we are told, 50 academic papers to his spending on healthcare,
name) and he has worked as the Chief Economist for a private • slash energy and transport subsidies
pension company. Type his name into Google though, and you • deregulate industries and privatise state companies
might be surprised. He has unruly hair, often dresses up for • … and, perhaps most controversially of all, abolish the
campaign speeches (sometimes wearing a batman costume, country’s central bank so that Argentina can start using
sometimes wielding a chainsaw) and describes himself as the US dollar instead of the Peso (so-called ‘Dollarisation’)
an anarcho-capitalist. Right now, he’s probably most famous
This type of shock therapy will not come without its challenges.
for a viral internet video, in which he is seen ripping off and
The proposals will obviously need to be ratified by the political
throwing away the labels of various government ministries; a
system and Milei’s party only holds only a tiny minority of
clear signal that he wants to completely gut the public sector.
seats in the legislature. In addition, Argentinian trade unions
“Ministerio de Cultura: fora! Ministerio do Meio Ambiente have already begun calling for nationwide strikes in opposition
e Desenvolvimento Sustentavel: fora! Ministerio das to his labour market reforms. Analysts have warned that the
mulhares, genero e diversidade: fora! Ministerio de government’s ability to limit disruptive protests will be critical
Educacao: fora!” to determining the long-term viability of any new proposals.
Translation: Ministry of Culture: Out! Ministry of the On the flip-side, there is some suggestion that foreign direct
Environment and Sustainable Development: Out! Ministry investment into Argentina has begun to spark into life. A
of Women, Gender and Diversity: Out! Ministry of cynic might suggest that this is a sign of the vultures circling,
Education: Out!” waiting to pick off any potentially lucrative industries once
they are sold off by the State. But there are others who may
Mileinomics, it seems, will put the free market above all other well argue that Mileinomics is exactly
things. It is a bold plan, largely inspired by the Austrian school what Argentina’s economy needs
of thought (which boasts economists such as Hayek and von and it’s better to invest early
Mises), and ultimately leaves the government with as little before this sleeping giant
role in society as possible. A good example is Milei’s plan to awakens.
privatise the Ministries for Science, Technology and Innovation.
This would effectively hand over control to large business and
financial groups that, in his words, “will decide which sciences
are useful for their profits”. You can make up your own mind
about whether profit is likely to be the best judge of which
sciences are useful or not.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 31
SUGGESTED ANSWERS TO ACTIVITIES
EXAM TECHNIQUE
Extent-o-meter Possible oversimplification Scope: Not towns, motorways
No/small/some/great Are there more effective policies? or rural areas
1 To what extent are behavioural policies the most effective way to reduce congestion in the UK’s cities?
Scope: Not conventional Scope: including England,
or paternalistic policy Wales and Norther Ireland
Double-Dimension
Can and should Should but can't
Scope: Not individuals Can't but Cannot and
or firms should not should not
2 Evaluate the view that governments of all countries can and must do more to tackle climate change.
Scope: Developed Possible oversimplification
and developing Must or should?
QUANTITATIVE SKILLS
Question Set 1: Question Set 2:
1 0.4 1 -20/+50 = -0.4
2 2 2 -16.7/+20 = -0.835
Question Set 3:
Rearrange the PED formula to %∆Qd = PED x %∆P Rearrange the PED formula to %∆P = %∆Qd/ PED
make %∆Qd the subject. make %∆P the subject.
Rearrange the PES formula to %∆Qs = PES x %∆P Rearrange the PES formula to %∆P = %∆Qs/ PES
make %∆Qs the subject. make %∆P the subject.
Rearrange the YED formula to %∆D = YED x %∆Y Rearrange the YED formula to %∆Y = %∆ D/ YED
make %∆D the subject. make %∆Y the subject.
Rearrange the XED formula to %∆QdA = XED x %∆PB Rearrange the XED formula to %∆PB = %∆QdA / XED
make %∆QdA the subject. make %∆PB the subject.
TAYLOR SWIFT
Year 12 question Suggested outline:
a Draw a demand and supply diagram showing a price inelastic Here we need a price inelastic demand curve diagram
demand curve for Taylor Swift merchandise. with the total revenue areas marked on.
b Show the effect of a reduction in the supply of merchandise
due to the global supply chain problems.
c On the diagram, indicate the area representing:
• the loss of total revenue resulting from the shift in supply
• the increase in total revenue resulting from the shift in
supply
Year 13 question
Suggested outline:
Draw a cost and revenue diagram showing the impact on Need a costs and revenue diagram showing the
supernormal profit of a rise in production costs resulting from reduction in supernormal profit.
the technical glitches in the platforms when selling concert
tickets. (Hint: variable costs will rise)
www.tutor2u.net/economics 33
JOIN THE TUTOR2U ECONOMICS
STUDENT COLLECTIVE FOR 2024!
Our regular A Level Economics livestreamed
revision sessions are the place to be if you
want to smash your exams in summer 2024.
Don’t wait until it's too late. Our programme of free livestreams runs from
October 2023 all the way to the day before your last A Level Economics
paper!
You can catch the livestreams on YouTube and the tutor2u Economics
channel. Every session is recorded too; but be there live for the best
experience.
www.tutor2u.net/economics 35
Join the tutor2u Economics team for an