Professional Documents
Culture Documents
CHAPTER I
This chapter gives a concise overview of the study and focuses primarily on the
problems that brought by the researchers to the idea of conducting further studies
Introduction
some of the worst fire incidents in history. It is a calamity that can harm lives and affect
the economic status of community. Also, it is a man-made disaster that can cause a lot
of destructing and loss of lives. Its incidence in an area causes alarm to the people. In
terms of human related incidence, there are two major causes of it, either accidental or
intentional. On the other hand, there is only one effect of fire incidence which is damaged
that can be classified as property damaged. Thousands of people have been made
In the Philippines, thousands of lives and billions worth of property are lost every
year because of seemingly inescapable fires, often caused by negligence and sheer
often marking some of the worst fire incidents in history. As stated in International Fire
and Security Exhibition and Conference (IFSEC) Philippines, on May 13, 2015, a fire
broke out at the Kentex Manufacturing factory in Valenzuela City, wherein 74 people
were killed after being trapped inside the burning shoes-and-slippers factory. It is the
third worst fire incident in the Philippines after the 1996 Ozone Disco Club fire that killed
2
162 and the 2001 Manor Hotel fire that led to the death of 75 people. There's a lot of
possible causes that can lead to a disastrous fire. In concordance with Republic Act No.
9514. Section 1. This Act shall be known as the “Fire Code of the Philippines of 2008”.It
is the policy of the State to ensure public safety, promote economic development through
the prevention and suppression of all kinds, of destructive fires, and promote the
No. 9514 Section 4. Applicability of the Code. The provisions of the Fire Code shall apply
to all persons and all private and public buildings, facilities or structures erected or
constructed before and after its effectivity. As stated by Real living, the eight (8) common
causes of fire in the Philippines are the following: Dried leaves; Faulty electrical wiring;
Faulty electrical equipment; unattended stoves and ovens; unattended candles; Children
Furthermore, Republic Act No. 9514 section 7 states the inspections, safety
measures, fire safety, constructions and protective and warning systems. This includes
that the owners of structures, buildings, premises or facilities shall prepare a fire safety
emergency directions and evacuation plan. This republic act also discussed about having
protective and warning systems. Thus, every occupants shall provide a fire protection
features such as sprinkler systems, hose, and other fire-fighting equipment such as fire
extinguishers.
According to the Bureau of Fire Protection (2018), the top three causes of fires are
electrical connection, lighted cigarette and open flame. On April 06, 2019, a fire incident
occurr in Barangay Sta. Clara, Batangas City. According to the Department of Social
3
Welfare and Development (2019), two hundred and four (204) families were affected by
the fire incident. For now, the affected families are currently staying inside an evacuation
center.
There are common practices of eliminating fires. One of those practices is the usage
of water. As the world faces a water crisis due to overpopulation, urbanization and
environmental degradation, most of the residents are experiencing water shortage which
results to hindering the residents to use water in eliminating fires. Another practice is the
use of fire extinguisher. Fire extinguisher is one of the most effective fire protection
devices but not all can have it. One of the reasons why some people are unable to have
fire extinguisher at home is because of its price and most of the residents do not afford
Though many studies have conducted to verify the effectiveness of the alternative
fire extinguisher, there is still a need to conduct more studies on how the alternative fire
(2019), the main components of the alternative fire extinguisher are vinegar and baking
soda and showed the chemical reaction between a vinegar and baking soda that
produces a sodium acetate, the sodium bicarbonate present suffocates the fire and emits
it. However, this study will use of three main components which are the vinegar, baking
soda and dish washing liquid. The researchers added the dish washing liquid as one of
the three components because it helps to cover the surface of the burning oil, starving
the fire of oxygen and putting it out. The temperature has been reduced because the oil
extinguisher to handle type A fires without the use of fire extinguisher. Thus, this research
study will help the residents to become aware about the alternative fire extinguisher to
eliminate fires. Being aware of the alternative fire extinguisher, the residents could share
their knowledge to those who also does not have fire extinguisher at home. Also, the
possible solution will help the residents who cannot afford the expensive price of a fire
extinguisher.
Conceptual Framework
Figure 1 presents the Input-Process-Output (IPO) model of the study. The first box
includes the input of the statement of the problem. It is the advantages and
disadvantages of the alternative fire extinguisher, and the difference between the
commercial and alternative fire extinguisher. The process, which is presented on the
second box is concerned with the survey using questionnaires, the process outcome and
Lastly, proposing an action plan to implement the use of alternative fire extinguisher
Advantages and
disadvantages of the
alternative fire
commercial and
alternative fire
extinguisher
Figure 1
Research Paradigm
6
This study aims to determine the effectiveness of the alternative fire extinguisher for
type A fires.
1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using the alternative fire
extinguisher?
2. How does the alternative fire extinguisher differ from the commercial fire
2.1. Contents;
2.3. Convenience?
4. Based on the findings, what action plan could be proposed to implement the use
Hypothesis
The research focuses on the effectiveness of the alternative fire extinguisher. This
study also included the differences between the commercial fire extinguisher and the
7
alternative fire extinguisher. It was further delimited to the detergent, sodium bicarbonate
and vinegar as alternative fire extinguisher and does not include other substances.
At the end of the study, the researchers will determine an action plan that will be
This study focuses on the perception of the fire fighters in Batangas City. However,
this study did not further tackle the personal information of the residents.
information on how to address fire without using fire extinguisher. They will be aware of
Students. The result may serve as a basis to their investigatory projects and
experiments, regarding about fires. It could stimulate their minds by having awareness
Teachers. This study will help the science teachers give experiments related on this
study on how to make an alternative fire extinguisher and how it works through science.
Future Researchers. The findings also serve as a guide to future researchers when
they conduct similar or related studies. They could also use this study as the basis of
Definition of Terms
For the readers to have a better understanding and clearer view of the terms that will
be used in the study, researchers defined the following terms conceptually and
operationally.
Dishwashing liquid. One of the most adaptable staples in your household stash.
In this study, it helps to eliminate fires by covering the surface of the burning oil that
Fire. It is one of the biggest threats. A fire can destroy in a matter of minutes a home
In this study, it refers to a calamity that can harm lives and affect the economic status
of community.
Type A fires. Class A fires are the most common type of fire and the kind that most
In this study, type a fires involve solid combustible materials such as wood, paper,
Fire Extinguisher. It is used as a first aid in defending one's self from getting harmed
through extinguishing fires. This device can be a major component in keeping people
producing carbon dioxide. Aside from cooking, baking soda has a variety of additional
In this study, it refers to one to the main components of the alternative fire
extinguisher.
Vinegar. A solution typically consisting of 4–7% acetic acid and 93–96% water,
though types with higher acetic acid content are available for agricultural or cleaning
In this study, it also refers to one to the main components of the alternative fire
extinguisher.
10
CHAPTER II
This chapter presents the variety of reviews on related literature and related
studies concerning the topic. Consequently, it provides the researchers with a better and
Related Literature
Many types of fire extinguishers are currently available and these are the contents of
fire extinguishers. The carbon dioxide (CO2) extinguisher contains carbon dioxide forced
into its liquid state by the pressure they can be used in class B or C and since carbon
dioxide does not leave a residue, cleanup is not a problem. Halon extinguisher contains
a halogenated hydrocarbon agent forced into a liquid state by pressure, the most
the dry powdered extinguisher, this is available in stored pressure and cartridge operated
unit containing one several available dry powder agents this is suitable for class D fires
and are only effective fire control agents for this type of fire. (Schroll, 2016)
(2018) based in fire protection industry are inert agent cylinders have a bigger footprint
than an equivalent ODS and SGG system. Additional resources, such as the cost and
labor, would be required for replacing cylinders after discharge or during the 10-year
maintenance period. Greater need for pressure relief venting of the enclosures. Can
Bromann (2016) explained that the public protection from fire is one of the many
responsibilities of a building management. Any fire protection programs has its integral
part which is the fire extinguishers. These are seen as a first line of defense against all
visible location, most preferably near the door or entrance, so that the person will not
have to pass across the flames and smoke just to reach an extinguishing equipment.
Portable fire extinguishers are to be used according to the instructions found on the unit’s
label and only contain a limited quantity of an extinguishing material. The typical duration
of use for 5 lb is about 20 seconds only and 40 seconds for 10 lb fire extinguishers.
intentional fire setting. Natural Disasters like earthquakes and volcanic eruptions can also
lead to big fires. Fires in a controlled environment are helpful and constructive society
while uncontrolled fires are dangerous and may result to loss of lives and properties in a
short period of time. Fires are considered as threats to the communities, destroying
on how to prevent these destructive phenomena from occurring to ensure the safety of
each individual.
Furthermore, Meacham, et al. (2016) discussed that fires are dangerous events that
results to destruction of properties and loss of lives. In addition to their physical costs,
fires have a range of less immediate and obvious dangerous consequences on the
natural environment. These include contamination of air and contamination from water
runoff which consists of toxic or hazardous materials and products and other
environmental discharges.
12
Fire is a chemical reaction that contains three elements which are heat, air and fuel.
Those three elements are represented as a triangle which is called fire tetrahedron or fire
triangle. Eliminating fires requires removal of one or more of its components. Fire is a
useful element and force of nature because it can produce heat and light. However, fire
can also turn an entire house and buildings completely to ashes in a few hours. It can
In addition, Serapio (2016) states that fire is considered as the fourth main
broken gas lines and power lines, or tripped over wood or coal stoves. Fires can be a
serious problem especially when water lines which can help in eliminating fires are also
broken. Most hazards are because of the people which are commonly known as human
Based on Parena (2016), the number of fire accidents or fire cases around the city is
increasing every year. More and more destructive fire are documented each year
especially for the month of March despite the efforts of the government to inform public.
Its shows the significant number of live lost and injury and properties damaged. There
are many source of fire and majority of it is preventable. There are three main categories
Fire extinguishers are important for the safety and convenience of each individual. It
must contain a relevant extinguishing agent for the type of fire that is most likely to occur.
Furthermore, Fire extinguisher must also be mounted so that it is not hidden or obscured
from the view. Fire extinguishers are need to be always readily available and absolutely
13
must work properly when needed to prevent the fire from spreading and to reduce the
Furthermore, Luna (2016) added that the management of fire hazards is best done
during disaster risk reduction management. This means that the risk may be reduced by
preparedness consists of having a fire contingency plan and a warning system, practicing
and conducting fire education seminars and fire drills, following safety tips at home,
schools and other establishments, setting evacuation areas and protocols for evacuation,
and the most important is having an available fire extinguisher at any establishments.
As stated from the article written by Lee (2019), a home single use fire extinguisher
that can fight against type A, B, or C fire costs $15-$20 (Php758.10-Php1010.80) while
the multi-use home and office fire extinguisher ranges with the cost of $35-$75
can extinguish, mark that indicates that it meets the safety guidelines, plastic or metal
valve and head are all included in most of the commercial fire extinguisher. Multi use fire
extinguisher needing a refill or recharge usually in fire station or in other services typically
inspected yearly.
Related Studies
Based on the research conducted by Wang (2018), fire extinguisher agents are
being used in the world extensively for suppression and control of fire. Each year, fire
control agencies utilize millions of mixtures on a wide array of ecosystem. On the other
14
side, the application may contain danger, plants and animal species are significantly
aquatic and land life. It has also less information was available when it comes in impacts
A study conducted by Ragnar (2017) found out that light foam can be the best
extinguishing method. Light foam makes limited property damage in general and might
also reduce smoke damage. However, Ragnar also stated some disadvantages of using
foam. Heavy foam increases the damage with longer exposure and does not easily
penetrate electronics.
Martin, et al. (2019) stated that fire extinguishers are pressure devices that requires
maintenance operations that will ensure its capability to function during the disaster. Due
depending on the surface area of the establishment. Also, fire extinguishers has their
respective places which are always close to the points that are mostly likely to be affected
by fire and where the extinguishers are visible and accessible to use. Each fire
extinguisher has labels to verify that the labeling, installation, and conditions comply in
accordance with its standards. It is important to have a fire protection device to ensure a
greater safety of an individual's life and reduce economic destruction caused by the fire.
As stated in the study conducted by Fireline (2017), fire extinguishers turns out to be
very important in terms of fire protection in case of fire emergencies. It is used as a first
aid in defending one's self from getting harmed through extinguishing fires. This device
can be a major component in keeping people safe during fire emergency situations. Along
15
with this, out of eighty percent fire incidents, sixty percent was not notified to the fire
combinations of water, froth, gas, or other materials to put out a fire. It is a functioning
Ordinarily, a fire extinguishers comprises a hand held round and hallowed weight vessel
containing a specialists which can be released to put the fire down (Aristo et al., 2018).
Fires gives a great impact to people, property, and environment. In some cases, the
property and contents, and significant impacts on the environment. In addition, fire may
cause casualty or affect a single home, even though the effects are still highly significant
Kihila (2017) stated in his study that fire disasters are considered as man-made
disasters accompanied with the most devastating impact which can affect both lives and
properties. The levels of the impacts has been severe in places in which has low level of
considering different factors which are the availability and condition of firefighting facilities
as well as the knowledge on fire disaster. According on his study, there were no enough
equipment that could be used during fire disasters such as water and firefighting facilities.
However, there are no fire assembly points that will considered as a safe area. Most
people were also unaware of the things that should be done in order to extinguish a fire.
Also, people are not well prepared to handle and manage fire outbreaks.
16
According to Glauberman, et al. (2018), when it comes to disasters like fire, evacuees
has low level of knowledge when it comes to the location of building fire stairs, how to
enter the stairwell, or where the stairs lead. Evacuees were also unfamiliar with building
evacuation plans, were not confident evacuating the building without instruction, or
lacked knowledge regarding evacuation routes. The increase of the population in urban
areas is also one of the cause of increasing number of urban disasters. Engaging in drills
and emergency preparedness is an effective way to reduce risk of death and injury during
crises.
Fire is one of the major disasters in rural communities but evidence of the
effectiveness of education interventions against fire risks is limited. The study was
knowledge among the villagers about how to reduce general- and electrical-fire risks.
The knowledge of using fire blanket, recalling the correct emergency telephone number,
unplugging unused electrical appliances, and not using water to extinguish electrical fires
understanding that fire blankets can fight a blaze if used appropriately, and that
knowledge was sustained for 17 months. The interventions were effective in improving
Voelkert (2015) states that others such as dry chemical, halon, halogenated agents
and foam can be used effectively. The primary advantage of halogenated agents has
17
been the lack of clean up required after using the agent. In some environments (such as
electronics, data processing, jet engines and high tech optical equipment), discharging
other extinguishing agents such as dry chemical or water could cause more property
damage than the fire itself. Halogenated agents as used in hand portable extinguishers
were never as effective as more common agents on typical class B and class A fires.
Here are Halon Alternatives, since the ratification of the Montreal Protocol, alternatives
to Halon 1301 and Halon 1211 have been sought. Various proprietary blends of gases
are available on the market. Having the correct equipment and proper maintenance
equipment in the hands of trained personnel will not be effective if the equipment has not
been maintained and either fails or performs poorly in an incident. There are four
elements to be present in order for fire to exist. Fire was thought of as a triangle with the
three sides represented by heat, fuel, and oxygen. If any one of the three sides were to
be taken away, the fire would cease to exist. A class “A” fire can involve any material that
has a burning ember or leaves an ash. Common examples of class “A” fires would be
wood, paper, or pulp. The preferred method for extinguishing class “A” fires is to remove
the heat.
Synthesis
Wang (2018) and Ragnar (2017) has the same concepts. Both studies stated that
the application of fire extinguisher agents may contain danger, and plants and animals
are significantly threatened due to the chemicals. However, Ragnar also stated the
advantages of a foam extinguishing equipment. Light foam can be the best extinguishing
18
method. Light foam makes limited property damage in general and might also reduce
smoke damage.
Schroll (2016), and Aristo et al. (2018) discusses the contents of fire extinguisher.
A commercial fire extinguisher contains carbon dioxide forced into its liquid state by the
pressure and does not leave residue. It also contains halogenated hydrocarbon agent
and other dry powdered agents. However, Bromann (2016) stated that the typical
duration of use for 5 lb is about 20 seconds only and 40 seconds for 10 lb fire
extinguishers.
Pareña (2016), and Milke (2019) states that fires occurs either because of natural
disasters or human accidents. Broken gas lines, power lines, coal stoves are dangerous
materials that can start a fire. Uncontrolled fires may result to loss of lives and properties
However, Luna (2016), and Fireline (2017) discusses that fire extinguishers is important
for safety. It is used as first aid in defending one’s life from getting harmed. Also, it must
contain a relevant extinguishing agent for type pf fire that most likely occur. As stated by
Luna (2016), and Martin et al. (2019) the risk maybe reduced by doing proper prevention,
mitigation, preparedness, response, and recovery. Fire extinguishers must be visible and
accessible to use and follow the instructions in accordance to the labels to ensure a
greater safety.
evacuees has low level of knowledge when it comes to the location of building fire stairs
and were unfamiliar with building evacuation plan. Also, the study found put that some
19
establishment are no fire assembly points that will considered as an safe areas. However,
Chan et al. (2018) added that the evidence of the effectiveness pf education interventions
However, the studies conducted differ in some ways. Voelkert (2015) states other
contents of a fire extinguisher such as dry chemical, halon, halogenated agents and foam
can be used effectively while Ragnar (2017) states that it should be a light foam to lessen
the property damage because heavy foam increases the exposure and does not easily
Also, Fireline (2017) states that fire extinguishers turns out to be the most important
thing to protect one's lives from a fire. On the other side, Wang (2018) states the opposite
side which is application of the fire extinguishers. The application contains danger which
To summarize, this study has its similarities and differences with the related studies
mentioned. This study is a quantitative research and requires product. In relation to the
alternative fire extinguisher, the statement of Broman (2016) is the same point that the
management for fire safety. The alternative fire extinguisher contains CO2 that is found
in class A and B in liquid state as well. It is different from the dry chemicals that is a bit
messy to clean and also with the halon extinguisher. A commercial fire extinguisher has
a cost of labour for replacing cylinder after a duration of 10-years while the alternative
Even though there are many studies conducted related to fire and fire extinguishers,
there is a must to conduct this study for the people to have their knowledge about the
importance of having a fire protection device and about the alternative fire extinguisher
which is the aim of this study. Wherein the alternative fire extinguisher will be a great help
CHAPTER III
METHODOLOGY
This chapter presents the methodology of the study that contains the following:
research design, population and sampling, data gathering instrument, data gathering
Research Design
soda, vinegar and dishwashing liquid as an alternative fire extinguisher is the purpose of
the study.
The researchers use an experimental type of research design. On the other hand,
Ojmarrh (2017) states that experimental research designs is centrally concerned with
constructing research that is highly causal validity. Causal Validity concerns the accuracy
of the statements regarding cause and effect relationship. Thus, the researchers use
The subjects of the study are the fire fighters from Bureau of fire protection in
Batangas City, San Pascual and Bauan since they are responsible for any fire disasters
in a respective areas.
The researchers gathered the total number of fire fighters in every station which
are twenty seven (27) in Bauan, twenty five (25) in San Pascual, thirty (30) in Batangas
22
which results to a total of eighty two (82) fire fighters. Due to a big number of population,
the researchers determined the sample size using the formula given by the National
Education Association in United States to compute for the need sample size to have a
The researchers arrived at sixty eight (68) number of respondents in this study.
However, due to financial problem. The researchers selected fifty (50) respondents:
fifteen (15) respondents in each stations in Bauan and San Pascual, and twenty (20)
the questionnaire. Simple random sampling (SRS) is a sampling method in which all the
element in population and, consequently, all of the units in the sampling frame have same
Research Instruments
The research used survey questionnaire as the main research instruments of this
study. Also, they used survey questionnaire in consolidating the needed information that
would serve as a basis to answer specific problems of the study which will be given to
the respondents. A survey is a data gathering method that is utilized to collect, analyze
and interpret the views of a group of people from a target population. Survey have been
used in various fields of research, such as sociology, marketing research, politics and
psychology.
The research prepared survey follows the two specific sets of questions. The first
extinguisher. The second part is the difference between commercial fire extinguisher and
alternative fire extinguisher. Reading books and published materials that that relate to
the recording of knowledge. Collecting the related data and information, understanding
the principles, and steps on making and developing the collected set of data are
The first step is randomly picking some respondents from the fire fighters from
Bureau of Fire Protection in Batangas City, San Pascual and Bauan and informing about
the research that the researchers are conducting The second step is asking for the
permission to be a respondent and will assure them confidentiality. The third is the
summarization of the information gathered and will analyze it for the improvement of the
The data and information are gathered through the use of the survey questions.
The survey questions are composed of several questions which are related to the
Statistical Treatment
The data were collected, tallied, analyzed, and statistically treated to come up with
the accurate findings and results the researchers use weighted mean, ranking and
anova.
24
Weighted Mean. This was used to measure the average extent of the data
provided by the respondents. It is the summing up of all the values divided by the total
number of respondents.
CHAPTER IV
This chapter deals with the presentation, analysis, and interpretation of data gathered
in the study about sodium bicarbonate, detergent, and acetic acid as alternative fire
extinguisher.
Agree 4
1. It is easy and convenient to use. 3.28
Strongly Agree 1
2. It is more affordable. 3.7
Agree 5
3. It is a good substitute for 3.22
commercial fire extinguisher
Strongly Agree 2
4. It does not affect the environment 3.66
Strongly Agree 3
5. It is lighter than the commercial fire 3.56
extinguisher.
Composite Mean 3.48 Agree
On the first rank, the statement the alternative fire extinguisher is more affordable
with the weighted mean of 3.7 and a verbal interpretation of strongly agree. And on the
fifth rank is the statement that the alternative fire extinguisher is a good substitute for
commercial fire extinguisher has the weighted mean of 3.22 and has the verbal
interpretation of agree.
26
Lyman (2018) states that having fire extinguisher is important for the safety and
convenient of everyone during a fire disaster. Also, Wang (2018) stated that the
chemicals mixed in the commercial fire extinguisher threatened the environment unlike
the contents of alternative fire extinguisher which does not harmed the environment.
Table 2
3.18 Agree 2
1. It cannot terminate heavy fires.
3.06 Agree 4
2. It consumes a short period of time
to be prepared.
3.2 Agree 1
3. It has low pressure when sprayed.
3.14 Agree 3
4. It drains immediately.
2.9 Agree 5
5. It has a stinky smell.
Composite Mean 3.74 Agree
For the disadvantages of using an alternative fire extinguisher, the top on ranking
states that it has a low pressure when sprayed, with a 3.2 weighted mean and a verbal
this result, the greater need for pressure relief venting of the enclosures, and the pressure
created by the alternative fire extinguisher is due to the carbon dioxide it produced. The
last on ranking states that the alternative fire extinguisher has a stinky smell with a
27
weighted mean of 2.9, which means most respondents strongly agreed with it. The smell
of the liquid soap fought with the smell of the vinegar that made the stinky smell vanish.
The respondents assessed the Differences between alternative fire extinguisher and
commercial fire extinguisher in terms of contents, price, and convenience. These were
Table 3.1
Differences between alternative fire extinguisher and commercial fire
extinguisher in terms of contents
Table 3.1 shows the difference between Alternative Fire Extinguisher and
Commercial Fire Extinguisher. The first rank states that the respondents revealed that
28
the contents of Alternative Fire Extinguisher can be found at home with a weighted mean
of 3.38 and a verbal interpretation of Agree. This is supported by Marin (2015) by stating
that Sodium Bicarbonate or known as Baking Soda serves a variety of purposes, ranging
from household uses such as baking and cleaning, to treating minor medical ailments
like sunburn and insect bites. Also, Woodford (2019) states that detergent is a chemical
substance you use to break up and remove grease and grime, while soap is simply one
kind of detergent. The most important ingredients in detergents are chemicals called
surfactants. That will make the fire extinguisher to release foam. And lastly the vinegar
which is usually used as an ingredient to different dishes. Also, It states that the
alternative fire extinguisher terminates fire faster than the commercial fire extinguisher
ranked fifth weighted with an average of 2.38 and a verbal interpretation of disagree. Fire
extinguishers are important for the safety and convenience of each individual. It must
contain a relevant extinguishing agent for the type of fire that is most likely to occur.
(Lyman, 2018)
29
Table 3.2
Differences between alternative fire extinguisher and commercial fire
extinguisher in terms of price
The alternative fire extinguisher is much cheaper than the commercial fire
extinguisher was being consider as rank 1 and strongly agreeable by the respondents
with the weighted mean of 3.58. The materials used for the alternative fire extinguisher
is far cheaper than the commercial fire extinguisher. This was supported by Ed Lee, a
home single use fire extinguisher that can fight against type A, B, or C fire costs $15-$20
(Php758.10-Php1010.80) while the multi-use home and office fire extinguisher ranges
with the cost of $35-$75 (Php1769.25-Php3791.25). On the other hand, the last on the
ranking states that the alternative fire extinguisher has almost the same price to the
commercial fire extinguisher of the table 4 with a 2.4 weighted mean and disagree verbal
interpretation.
30
Table 3.3
Differences between alternative fire extinguisher and commercial fire
extinguisher in terms of its conveniency
the top of the line with a weighted mean of 3.18 and a verbal interpretation of agree. Thus
will be implemented. However, the last of ranking states that the alternative fire
Martin et al. (2019) supported this by stating that fire extinguishers are pressure
devices that requires maintenance operations that will ensure its capability to function
during the disaster, this fact lessens the conveniency of the commercial fire extinguisher
31
especially during fire emergency wherein the alternative fire extinguisher is more
There is a
significant
Significant Reject Null Difference
between
Difference 8.23 2.41 Hypothesis commercial
fire
extinguisher
and alternative
fire
extinguisher.
Table 6 reveals the difference between the commercial fire extinguisher and
alternative fire extinguisher. According to the data, the F-value of the significant
difference is 8.23 while the critical value is 2.41. This means that the F-Value is higher
than the critical value, hence rejecting the null hypothesis. Therefore, there is a significant
difference between the commercial fire extinguisher and alternative fire extinguisher.
In connection with this, Martin, et al. (2019) stated that fire extinguishers requires
maintenance operations that will ensure its capability to function. A fire extinguishers
have a fire protection device to ensure the safety of an individual and reduce economic
destruction.
32
With this, with the help of the statistical tool, the researchers manage to determine
the significant difference between the alternative fire extinguisher to the commercial fire
extinguisher.
All of the data are tallied and interpreted by the researchers to come up with a
conclusion. The data interpreted by the researchers proposed that the sodium
bicarbonate, detergent, and acetic acid as an alternative fire extinguisher can be used.
Based on the study, the alternative fire extinguisher is recommended for all especially
those who does not afford having a commercial fire extinguisher. The alternative fire
extinguisher cost less because the materials used are cheaper and is mostly found at
home. Meanwhile, the alternative fire extinguisher has low pressure when sprayed. On
the other hand, There is a significant difference between commercial fire extinguisher
and alternative fire extinguisher. Overall, this means that the alternative fire extinguisher
is better in terms of its contents, cost, and conveniency. With regards to this, the
researchers came up with a possible action plan that will promote the practice of using
Table 5
Action Plan
KEY OBJECTIVES PERFORMANCE TIMEABLE
STRATTIGIES INDICATOR
AND ACTIONS
Strategy 1: Providing seminars and orientations in the community.
Strategy 2: Releasing the information about the alternative fire extinguisher to inform
the community.
2.1 Through online To inform the
community about
the proposed Every summer and
alternative fire Every March (Fire
extinguisher Individuals Prevention Month)
through social concerned will have
medias such as easy access to the
Facebook, Twitter, information about
and YouTube the alternative fire
extinguisher that is
2.2 Flyers or To inform them vital knowledge to
Pamphlets about the several the individuals
information about Every summer and
the proposed Every March (Fire
alternative fire Prevention Month)
extinguisher and its
effectiveness
against fire.
34
CHAPTER V
the study that were gathered from the results of the observations conducted by the
researchers.
Summary
dishwashing liquid and acetic acid as an alternative fire extinguisher for type A fires.
1. What are the advantages and disadvantages of using the alternative fire
extinguisher?
2. How does the alternative fire extinguisher differ from the commercial fire
a. Contents;
b. Price; and
c. Convenience?
The study utilized the experimental research design in order to gather more data.
the other hand, the respondents of the study are fifty (50) fire fighters from different
stations in Batangas. To interpret the data collected, ranking and weighted mean were
Findings
Based from the study conducted, several findings were derived. They are as
follows:
Based on the results, using an alternative fire extinguisher has its advantages and
firefighters on the survey. On the other hand, it has its disadvantage such as having low
commercial one because of its contents which can be found at home. Its
everyone.
With the aim of identifying the Significant difference between alternative fire
extinguisher and commercial fire extinguisher for type A fires, the researchers
gathered the data from a thorough observation. Furthermore, the F-value of the
significant difference is 8.23 and the critical value is 2.41 which means that the F-
value is greater than the critical value. With this, the sample being tested falls
higher than critical areas, the null hypothesis should be rejected. It only means
4. Actions that are being proposed to implement the use of the alternative fire
extinguisher.
Seminars and orientations about the alternative fire extinguisher are the proposed
action plan by the researchers to implement the use of the alternative fire
widely spread the information about sodium bicarbonate, detergent, and acetic
Conclusions
In accordance to the findings of the research study has provided, the following
to the commercial fire extinguisher and the disadvantages of using the alternative
2. The difference between the alternative fire extinguisher and commercial fire
2.2. The alternative fire extinguisher is much cheaper than the commercial fire
extinguisher.
2.3. The alternative fire extinguisher is easy to use because it does not require
complicated steps.
4. The activities proposed aim to inform and persuade the activities, to improve the
programs, and to fulfill the desired outcome regarding implementing the use of
Recommendations
From the findings and conclusions of the study, the following recommendations are being
1. The alternative fire extinguisher will be used by the small establishments for their
facilities.
2. That the purpose of the product will be utilized to extinguish type A fire in case of
emergency.
38
4. Similar studies may be conducted by adding water for cheaper price and adding
5. The future researchers may conduct further studies to improve the effectiveness
6. The researchers highly recommend that the future researchers should expound
BIBLIOGRAPHY
A. BOOKS
De Guzman, F.R. (2016). Disaster Readiness and Risk Reduction. Quezon City: Vibal
Group Inc.
Lanada, M.I.B. et al., 2016. Building Resilient Communities Disaster Readiness and Risk
Luna, E.M. 2016. Protecting Lives, Saving Communities. Quezon City. C & E Publishing,
Inc.
Parena Jr. J.S. 2016. Exploring Life through Science Series Disaster Readiness and Risk
Serapio, M.P.A. 2016. Disaster Readiness and Risk Reduction. Intramuros, Manila.
Aristo C.M.S. et al., 2018. Combining Vinegar and Baking Soda. Published Thesis.
C. ONLINE SOURCES
https://l.facebook.com/l.php0.
40
https://books.google.com.ph/bookslse
Chan, E. Y. et al. (2018). Risk Perception and Knowledge in Fire Risk Reduction in Dong
from: https://scinapse.io/papers/2891436280
https://www.fireline.com/blog/importance-fire-extinguishers/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6128701/
Hill, A. (2018). White vinegar: Ingredients, Uses and Benefits. Retrieved from:
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/white-vinegar
Kahila, J. 2017. Fire Disaster Prepared and Situational Analysis in Higher Learning
Institutions.
Retrievedfrom: https://www.researchgate.netFiredisasterpreparednessandsituationalan
alysis
https://home.costhelper.com/fire-extinguishers.html
Lyman, D. (2018). Portable Fire Extinguisher. Chapter 5, Pages 23-26. Retrieved from:
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780128498897000054
41
from: https://firesciencereviews.springeropen.com/articles/10.1186/s40038-016-0014-1
Martin, R.G. 2019. SmartFire: Intelligent Platform for Monitoring Fire Extinguisher and
Milke, J. PhD. 2019. The Effects of Fires on People, Properties, and the Environment.
https://www.netquest.com/blog/en/random-sampling-simple-random-sampling
Raman, R. (2017). 23 Benefits and Uses for baking soda. Retrieved from:
https://www.healthline.com/nutrition/baking-soda-benefits-usesE
https://books.google.com.ph/books?contents+of+fire+extinguisher&hl
https://biohomecares.com/discover-biohomekeeping/many-uses-dishwashing-liquid
fire.com/upl/downloads/educational-documents/fire-and-fire-extinguishment
https://www.explainthatstuff.com/fireextinguisher.html
42
APPENDIX A
COVER LETTER
Dear respondents,
Good Day!
We are G12 students in the Practical Research II and currently writing a paper
entitled, "Sodium Bicarbonate, Dishwashing Liquid, and Acetic Acid: An Alternative
Fire Protection for Type A Fires"
Accordingly, we have prepared this survey questionnaire to gather the data we
need in our research.
The following items must be completed in full. We make sure your answer is
confidential. Thank you very much!
Researchers,
Andales, Alessandra
Casas, Mateus
APPENDIX B
QUESTIONNAIRE
Direction: Kindly put a checkmark (√) on the box which corresponds to your answer about
the alternative fire extinguisher. Be guided on the given option with its equivalent verbal
interpretation.
4 3 2 1
1. It is easy and convenient to use.
2. It is more affordable.
3. It is a good substitute for commercial
fire extinguisher
4. It does not affect the environment
5. It is lighter than the commercial fire
extinguisher.
4 3 2 1
1. It cannot terminate heavy fires.
2. It consumes a short period of time to
be prepared.
3. It has low pressure when sprayed.
4. It drains immediately.
5. It has a stinky smell.
44
III. Differences between the alternative fire extinguisher and commercial fire
extinguisher.
3.1 Contents 4 3 2 1
1. The Alternative Fire Extinguisher has
a harmless chemical content
compared to the commercial fire
extinguisher.
2. The contents of the alternative fire
extinguisher creates more efficient
terminating effect.
3. The contents of the alternative fire
extinguisher may be found at home.
4. The Alternative fire extinguisher
terminates fire faster than the
commercial fire extinguisher.
5. The alternative fire extinguisher is
almost the same to the commercial
fire extinguisher
3.2 Price 4 3 2 1
1. The alternative fire extinguisher is
much cheaper than the commercial
fire extinguisher.
2. The fire extinguishers has different
prices but has the same effects.
3. The cost of an alternative fire
extinguisher is affordable for people
in a low class state.
4. The cost of a commercial fire
extinguisher is nothing compared to
the safety it can provide.
5. The alternative fire extinguisher has
almost the same price to the
commercial fire extinguisher.
45
3.3 Convenience 4 3 2 1
1. The alternative fire extinguisher is
recommended for everyone.
2. The Alternative fire extinguisher has
a higher level of conveniency
compared to the commercial fire
extinguisher.
3. The alternative fire extinguisher is
easy to use because it does not
require any complicated steps.
4. The alternative fire extinguisher
terminates fire faster than the
commercial fire extinguisher.
5. The alternative fire extinguisher is
convenient as commercial fire
extinguisher.
46
APPENDIX C
DOCUMENTATION
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Alessandra M. Andales
Age: 17 years old
Gender: Female
Status: Single
Birthdate: September 03, 2002
Birthplace: Wawa, Batangas City
Nationality: Filipino
Address: Brgy. Sirang Lupa, Batangas City
Email Address: Alessandra.andales@Gmail.com
Contact Number: 09063238361
Mother: Juvy Andales
Father: Ariel Andales
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: Sirang Lupa Elementary School
Brgy. Sirang Lupa, Batangas City
Junior High School: Golden Gate Colleges
P.Prieto St., Batangas City
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: BS Architecture
School: Batangas State University
49
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Bryven Jyrone A. Borbon
Age: 17 years old
Gender: Male
Status: Single
Birthdate: August 23, 2002
Birthplace: Batangas Regional Hospital
Nationality: Filipino
Address: San Isidro, Batangas City
Email Address: borbonbryven@gmail.com
Contact Number: 09672970754
Mother: Lovelyn A. Borbon
Father: Byrone U. Borbon
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: San Isidro Elementary School
San Isidro, Batangas City
Junior High School: Carmel School of Batangas
Potenciana Village Pallocan West Batangas
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Aircraft Maintenance Engineering
School: Philippine State College of Aeronautics
50
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Rexine Anne L. Caringal
Age: 18 years old
Gender: Female
Status: Single
Birthdate: February 05, 2002
Birthplace: Golden Gate General Hospital
Nationality: Filipino
Address: Brgy. As-is Bauan, Batangas
Email Address: rexineannecaringal@gmail.com
Contact Number: 09386661774
Mother: Regina L. Caringal
Father: Anatalio R. Caringal
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: Sta. Teresa College
Kapitan Ponso St. Poblacion 2 Bauan Batangas
Junior High School: Sta. Teresa College
Kapitan Ponso St. Poblacion 2 Bauan Batangas
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Computer Engineering
School: Batangas State University
51
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Mateus N. Casas
Age: 18 years old
Gender: Male
Status: Single
Birthdate: August 05, 2001
Birthplace: Tinga Labac Batangas City
Nationality: Filipino
Address: Tinga Labac Batangas City
Email Address: casasmateus0@gmail.com
Contact Number: 0454611818
Mother: Nellie G. Nullas
Father: Generoso A. Casas
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: Alangilan Central Elementary School
Alangilan Batangas City
Junior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Instrumentation and Control Engineering
School: Batangas State University
52
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Glydel Lala S. Marquez
Age: 17 years old
Gender: Female
Status: Single
Birthdate: May 17, 2002
Birthplace: San Felipe, Padre Garcia Batangas
Nationality: Filipino
Address: San Felipe, Padre Garcia Batangas
Email Address: glydellala@gmail.com
Contact Number: 09297581944
Mother: Gregoria Marquez
Father: Severino Rodel Marquez
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: San Felipe Elementary School
San Felipe, Padre Garcia Batangas
Junior High School: Holy Family Academy
Banaba, Padre Garcia Batangas
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Industrial Engineering
School: Batangas State University
53
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Aeron Christian M. Saligao
Age: 17 years old
Gender: Male
Status: Single
Birthdate: December 27, 2001
Birthplace: Batangas City
Nationality: Filipino
Address: Delas Alas Drive Batangas City
Email Address: acsaligao@yahoo.com
Contact Number: N/A
Mother: Ethel M. Saligao
Father: Ranato M. Saligao
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: University of Batangas
P. Burgos St. Batangas City
Junior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Aeronautical Engineering
School: Philippine State College of Aeronautics
54
CURRICULUM VITAE
_____________________________________________________________________
I. PERSONAL INFORMATION
Name: Christine Joy V. Tolentino
Age: 18 years old
Gender: Female
Status: Single
Birthdate: December 29, 2001
Birthplace: Pasay City, Gentlehands Clinic
Nationality: Filipino
Address: Padre Castillo, San Pascual Batangas
Email Address: Christinetolentino4@gmail.com
Contact Number: 09196325947
Mother: Annalyn Volante
Father: Ricardo Tolentino
_____________________________________________________________________
II. EDUCATIONAL ATTAINMENT
Elementary: Padre Castillo Elementary School
Padre Castillo San Pascual Batangas
Junior High School: Bayanan National High School
Bayanan San Pascual Batangas
Senior High School: University of Batangas
Hilltop Kumintang Ibaba, Batangas City
_____________________________________________________________________
III. COLLEGE PREFERENCES
Course: Electronics Engineering
School: Batangas State University