I think living in poverty is the most significant cause. This is because-
i) Children will be forced to work to get basic resources because of
poverty. ii) Poverty projects the idea that child labour is good, as a kid gets validation due to the money, they bring into a poverty ridden family, which will establish a cycle of child labour. Child labour is a prevailing issue thus it is an important issue for governments to look into. As of 2023,140 million children aged between 5-17 are child laborers.
Child Labour has many harmful consequences to the child, making it a
issue to be dealt with. These reasons make it a violation of human rights and it is a government’s duty to care for their citizens and give them human rights.
Physical and mental health problems for the child
Lower educational achievement Children becoming victims of crime social disorder community breakdown.
It also has damaging effects on the economy of a country due to slower
economic growth and damaging reputation of businesses. This will greatly slow down a country’s progress, making it an important issue for the governments to solve. This claim can be tested in many ways. Firstly, statistics have to be collected. Data on how many failed crops in a set time period (preferably a year) to be collected as well as the climate changes over a set time period. The data should be from different nations to get a more global perspective.
We could get this information from official websites such as
UN’s food and agriculture organization or Nation’s press reports as well as research reports in recent years. We could also bring in expert testimonies as well as interviews with local farmers, to get multiple perspectives.
Possible methods to collect the data could be through
interviewing relevant experts, in our case environmentalist’s farmers and agriculture scientists. We can also conduct surveys for a local perspective. I disagree with this statement. As mentioned in source 2 - Living in poverty, Climate change, disasters and conflict are some major causes of child labour. In such circumstances, a child may benefit from working in paid employment.
Earning money early on will help keep the family
together and in a financial position. It also teaches them self-discipline skills that will greatly benefit them in the future. Not allowing them to work in paid employment may put families further into poverty, leading them to turn towards violent crime.
Another perspective is of cultural importance. In some
cultures, working from an early age is seen as positive thing (mostly in fields of agriculture and family owned business) and is rooted in years worth of tradition. It is important to note here that often in these traditions, a safe working place is ensured and consent of family as well as kid is established.
Thirdly, in some region, education is simply not
affordable. Here, not only does paid employment teach them skills but also allow them to socialize as one would in a school. I acknowledge that this can have damaging effects on the child. As mentioned in source 2- children may suffer- Physical and mental health problems, Children become victims of crime. In this case, we should ensure safe working conditions and a relatively high pay. Children also tend to be extremely vulnerable, thus educating the child that physical or mental abuse at the workplace is wrong and must be reported is necessary to ensure a smooth sailing experience. Being transparent and treating the child with empathy is to be expected from the workplace. This is in addition to tightening the many laws already instilled regarding this topic.
Lastly, as mentioned in source 2- it may cause slower
economic development. Child labour in paid employment though, can increase gdp per capita for a short time
In conclusion, I disagree with this statement because
child labour can serve socializing skills, teach children important life skills, is rooted in cultural importance and may temporarily boost GDP per capita.