OSBL Comparison labors and 2 generators for rent

A B C A-B A-C
Delta Delta
Manpower EL Gindy Proposal Petrojet MD Brauns GS ElGindy-PJT ElGindy-Brauns
S.No. Description UOM No. of Months Qty Monthly Rate /EGP Total Amount Monthly Rate /EGP OT Rate Total Amount Monthly Rate /EGP OT Rate Total Amount
1 Labor (12 Hours) Monthly 2 16 9,000 288,000 47,099 272 2,376,698 4,261 21 203,480 (2,088,698) 84,520
2 General Supervisor Monthly 2 1 28,148 56,296 47,099 272 148,544 20,183 99 60,237 (92,248) (3,941)
3 Engineer Monthly 2 1 35,000 70,000 58,968 340 185,976 28,256 139 84,331 (115,976) (14,331)
Sub-Total EGP 414,296 EGP 2,711,217 EGP 348,048 (EGP 2,296,921) EGP 66,248

Delta Delta
Equipment EL Gindy Proposal Petrojet MD Brauns GS ElGindy-PJT ElGindy-Brauns
S.No. Description UOM No. of Months Qty Monthly Rate /EGP Total Amount Monthly Rate /EGP OT Rate Total Amount Monthly Rate /EGP Mob/De-Mob Total Amount
Electric Generators 50 KW
1 each works12 Hours Monthly 2 2 90,000 360,000 99,190 396,760 41,400 4,370 174,340 (36,760) 185,660

Total Offers EGP 774,296 EGP 3,107,977 EGP 522,388 (EGP 2,333,681) EGP 251,908

Notes and basis:

* The rate of superintendent is used instead of the Engineer position for Brauns GS.
* The rate of electric generator used within PTJ MD is for (75-150 KW).
* Generator rate includes fuel and maintenance cost
* Assume that the working hours 24/7
* Brauns and Petrojet manpower monthly rate based on 10 working hours as per Subcontracts
* Brauns and Petrojet manpower cost include 2 hours overtime per day +12 hours for Fridays per person
* in case of purchasing the generator the expected delivery time will be 4 Months as per the feedback from the procurement Dep.
* PTJ units rates including MOU factor