Professional Documents
Culture Documents
tLGJVcVn gSJ
I
I
'llq '
'.dl
-.-ju:l
*At- n., it Ii ,,. I
.t/ I
I
I
: 6&prrltr ll,i!$l Aa&u ig*1a111611 "-.1:J! JLq: _.-, ;|-l.*ri i!-r
1:r$.1
ie e*:.Il y' Jr{ t .' r:Q ,4' .rlfL t{j' J,r l-r- fl pt-J t 1r+itr JJ
."-l- y' C-jJl djJi.!I,-i-i-:- & Ll+!' q,, J+-J,t{-- J.Li,jiJ i-Lj.jl
y' 6Liif l i.,l,rl C Utrl_iJl JEiyl J{-ltr C.,F-Jt rL:.jj'l C-r .Lrt -:jVl
d- J|ljltdl: J-:_ b JJ L-...- i:r !{,ri. r:F, .jl trJ +t ,Jrajt JrJ. ,,::
ct-:.iJl:JIJJ !..JL-l ;l ellr.rlur-i i4i-LrJlrr-i l.r1 dJ3.r*L.It .lr!t.5 rS.iJl
r/ dlJJyl lin Jlj tr.iJ!I.(iJsll sli iJ-:.is.:,t.rt 'G t/ nr<i- +L.,ut
j_
I
;* ..rr*J ,"til {+!Lr t_L;r,5t*_
-*,* {* c.i n;r *r.rir .rr. qrrL+r
l:-
d:;ffi fl':X
(r) *e-'lr!I 'l-ijJl E{ll I l".| rlJJ gr}J -r-$ !lt.:d, Lij JS. 1+:* J=tJ *jL.J
"A:
i*.; ,r ,riJA;j j $iJJ*. {,lS jt_"*,lrJ ro,.,
;1 lcnoshila ,
suzumura ' ohno
r+i'l L'?-bIl el'le'1!13 ;e-Gll
!l*Jl ',rjJl lr^ Ai 6+i$ IJJ Yu' 'lol 'J"Gi"
'' '*"' Lr --5jl3 i'J-l=ll pl':'i-
- ":'-LJl "'J
{ll
-a"-.,--"i-'irr il rlJ-'i "r-' "-l :.-: ..* *,
r'l y'
.. ai'!'L
l'-'-+ alJi e'r ' ttJul t{jiul 1* 'aL-J
, "* lt,l*LJl LL.Jl v.L .;a.:t qeu +,q! y=!L,rt a,l! ,ai aaLJ,
f
-' d
tl 'L't': lrj;rl Juit - in - rJsll criJi d i
rtii, rilr
I,!, 'ol urr''*LL* Jujl !'r ir)-l+ i'r+-L'll J1 . .i 1i
't rl
,Zerc lnvenroD,
|JJ3*I, AJjjI,
"**_ll.'r,r"
** ,.A _,
I ft* t IPJ JliJ (J-:- L'-+' l) 1+lul q;+Jl ,J"*Jt !| l.i r*-L_,rl <_**, ,*ir.
Jrr,.t
v-'l-1l
iiIJrc'l $u !+rj''r J+iu vJr iJr''':r!
.*.rj,:,!.1:.r,J:'!'J;1 'lrJr'J
a' *---*J ,r-'r.! e.ti, JE;4 ,U.i
.::;, *'r,'t i 'U
,..j!",6J-u *,+ irrJ, ,* .,,.o,
d Y:','", al+-*r *J* *-a
a t,*t-'+,-''.u' |
rf
r:- liL;ll 6rr:l .r1 ''l-J 'JL4
t&: **:5U ";fi :;ff: JJ+;p r*c^,. !" - :':,4o
:" ",'r-*i'''Lr:' *
,11'
.:'iiff ffT;:::
0) .rit"l ,4D l,y-.::*..
r i
"r-J _
JA; u,'i:l_ LrJAj u..j;- or _,*.rS .;.o: r,;4, :
J^+: t+ *.iai i-s*J-r,r 4r.r.,.rJlr l_rQLr.Jl
,E+-.tt
.:O*,.,.-.0 **,"a*,
-'-l''r y'tj'4; e--rJ I luriu":!!-J., "i$ t.l(:J, tA-ylr Jr.c,Jr I d!r- tvi Li,r+u
Jl
s+,Jr tia
.
J-Kl, J$_J, g4:4 , c.-L!,
c$ifl iJlJlErt!' ii- I
'
vJ' 'ra'jLfl+l
U.] or.,.--,* '* 'rlli JA"v:- 'l+?-ul"+lL-tlJ 'lSiJl
lt' 6' k-r'rl+r L*-Ul &b
..!t c/"
It{lJ flt JI J3.r e'+ C .l':'il rq glll6+!l I ,5!l,l .:r,ri- (,*: ;,rl
:r-.'Jr:J I lLjf r
uJl c*JlF'-ti
I e-l'iJ gl J 'rij 'd"'iJ e+j.l| ti.i tuJ;-:*l g_"Jt Li. q+Jt .:,tS$Jl
n,
/1. cjJjj1, ff*
v.i ciLij.jl l.t. .lr .
,
:lJl
:+L-tlJ -r'l L'
I
+g:Ies 6l-:'i! | i.)l'rY L'+ltljJ GiJF:l-r
<-J+-*'
c.r6-1r rirr-r
{L4:J-lt fiJjJ,
.rr.-rr, .,.,r--l;,i l-l],
JsrtSlt
Xf:; :J:
\r-i lJ+J_:.j.:jj-, {+S.,J-, I jJ$J_ J,Jjr} t.5J*"1-
I i1l'r!l JL:1| '?t+-t.''L:,jB tu|:j q+j e-"-+r'C(rj
iJh! (,.!+li! I eiJ^ll !'c i-'il-LJ "",
Jii.r,JyrJ JLJ- y,y'l ,Jr .Jer- &-nJjJr:
JlsJt {"U5: L": j r : :r .{:-JI ^
.nTl',.,,' sj ir* r.. y'l !J_ yy ;- .j.rjjJl JrrrJ J,!L
6riJ I JJJ;II e{j' .j't+-sr:\'!s
gd'rl lj'r ll!:.:*L .:a{Lj-l LJ*J-!tJLiy
tiJt ts.}_!r.l.t. tnJJ-!
-i:+-ul .'r811,:l''11.l e.!r*l t' !- (l-u GJJ- y', dJ:J i;, lf:'.l Jr;-- .-!lJ-, l.,LiJr
.5,.!-l | ,iJiJl a+l rJ6J o-j u.i..,i.J
e.^ j ll t-t; ,'u-u
(\).t ju pL-r nL-
/l
' l1l
I
,, .;,
.:L*:.J, iri-i_
J-t!l.:.j it |J.t^lti,.j ;e,- L:.:f I jsl+lt
l.'r .>S,J-ll :;;,-3,,:Tr'.* \=* j".,
,bl ..,:l+j _.
,_ {!i t" .tJ'+ _j.! 6E:/t.r*J.e;l i.r3q
3j L-S rF
-JlLl,su:.JtJ*i-:
,i;;;:::."'__J;::;;
JJ+ c-,..: iS lrf l ra J-.i-t.!tc,-i
G|n!'i-.its !Jii- ..r.., *, .r,-,- 'qrn! ;.r*tr J_iG.,
.!rL.jJJ UJs
JnlJ L-Ejt, rstJ j sj U.j.j, I Jrjr_t !g qljr .r-.- 4; 6etrl i-u erJ' eji; j-- :;.r*Jj
JJj! c".,- *". u,*:_:;::, -i
iJqjJ r+Gl
s-i^.r Jr.-,.J, +,d: $r4 +c.!4
:*
t J':'rI:Jl ;;. lli*: ",-
sJa .4rJ nL< t s:.Ld:Jr t.*LltAit|
+ .;l !!iJ ;.= o, *,,,, o..',il;;:il] * *; ;-r.1 i! | .;, r- gl
:er, L.-i eErJt .Jr c6l+jru-j.Lr
.si.,:JJ ;JG J -,LJK;J
:
d GEjyl iJ tJ, 'ljaii t-r"
,r. .-.,', ,,s-r'r{"tJuJ, .r iriJJr ,*
*' LIr- cr- cy-,r,*, ;.rrs,.jir*-i,
i-r-"--r ,.,.j-Jtt
F.-.J GEj ie+X; ir. .,J,.j.J I a.LtfJ ._.r. r..l _\ ui ac l, r'' - .ovr, ,, *,...,1-' .n,u'r'..;a
c-tr3';--, :
ctJlJl .r_LJ;- c..ttss .t.rjsll3 .,Luyl. i ;,,;;:-:L'+rrr *ar .! j* JJ .
I
JJ+J .-q:,
>.y, jLi dJ jJ,,*_;
Jsu- Jir+ sJr Jij *.-".,,*,
.l.l J?jr.J itl nrji.lt Jt e* .f+LJt
-',Jfii::;f;,:"-dl
.r*lr-3 i,r.', te: eLt;lt iJr*
;;.;::;j::ff;;
.(!+a:i/le-rj,
Jj-. iJ,ijs -r:,, . ..
s--j UJJ*
.Lu q+. .^r-;.:J,.; .-,JsL ,
pt JL.:-:-91 J-t-:4
_i.. r :li j-l t"_-._.r:,..rr
d* ,J:_rJd I C+-ra ll&., . t('J Jj. iJ-!LJ I J+ .+JlSiJt rrj_l l+l+dr:
- - -.
--rL&- arr+J e G:yi
?.&L1l rJL"L (:eLiJ:r.-i gjJt Jl+It J+ .j+l y'l JJI+| | ip r?lst, Jr*_; vJILJ jjL,,"t L-.r:_,.
.*i'ti;'r -L** c"ir,-k:
.F- -" .-r' ,.*, '
-",-.r., J'.Tr ".;;
.
":+lia.. ,,.i.,r.:
d{ ..ru; ;;;:,,* jtl : ;T
,, ,,., L*J-j
^
1l:',,._
sr a*-,!^"11. +rl<!Jt-L.-L- .-..:, *:J I LrL,yt *ir,a.l| ;l _1 .+ qr.sj j
."_.
_.a .
€,LJ;J
r
*:L: lJ,::,'.:;"" ,-_*1,; tr-l_j_' ;l _.
.'.i..-],",],:.Ta.,-''
r
lJjJ.q ",1-l
Jj E|jjtl iJlJlr .rtJ-iLJJ JL.^Jl ut !rt- (jU :.* 1t, .o,, +, -'',.,r;s,j,.,-
v_i f-: !t_r .ej-l I dJi & wl' -"r' Pr,
Jr'J_--:Jl-r.dj.l;_ N..j.: l:jL< 1rj'+Jt$Jt ,:.t^+:J r ,l ,JtgJyti/. -,.t,t .kr ** *-0".. ."
\J4 "!uj -/ [* . - - .
;l
]t ;'' *,", ***,Lr,.l
JdJru . r.kLi q.i{r;
J+:,lr- rl # iJigl ?3!l lst*, !}i;.:
vJt13JJi it &5'- JtS.:_ ,! fr-L-r
.r
-!/o .,, *ll'
'rra'i., u.r-./ k;,
; ;; ;j.,_f_ rr' r rr,,,",:*r
;o*. "u,-_. r:
. i!,J{-JJ .-i+l tsjJ l
r.rr
* i Jt. ral.: !
(1) .-*-t - ..--* 'J
i,5 L.lJj.j*l .l ..J i,l d'<-:: JLrL: .: rl c,Ujl.rJt ** *"- q*'ll,"ti
luij it_v ,-," d.i**
,rL f*.'.,u .sLtl rJtJfl & GEltt c,{+IdJ i-a_r.: ,:sr cL:jylr }J- .tr,! gj_..J, L*,ar c..;ts L;.; ,.
& Jjl "Jl,!ri Ji-i.:j'l drJ !r iJJJtletJ: sJ- na+-:,: ,, n<a c,UjtJltt L*i l* :l-'.*,.,.,...,,.*;**;::T' n'* ji* ar, -,
f ,** u--rr ;,--1L11f* :**&j+) >-d .r*a+ c L:jrr ;-L
.r.
vJl dtli rrJr.tr .r tr j: -r ftJ. J.4 r+! F{J f-titl <'+1a:f r ..t+,g-1 l+L,
.6E:f l.rrt3- ; 1;.:Li Jsls., .rt-,1 J-,:Tl'* * 1o*' r,, ., - F'r'LrqJr:ir<:
"* t;:':-t;;:
,:,1-q:t-,ir* -+.-';Yr l*Lq4J, r-+a rl *LL*) ,,-t.9
drj e+l: ! 95Ltt rj-r *_' ctt,Lir.JLrl Jr+r a- u*e.lr .
LFJJjJ I ie iAJJ,L?JU I F: JJ-lJtJ .t_rJKjJ I c,tj I ,']'
t:*u .,,.-', *4r-o *;
;, "5;I-*' td *LLr;-i-rt(!,; Jr-s,-,, **
: i 1..r-i:J L_t-I I
nsJJ.6+,U:J| kLS,l; gt-::1t irt.rl a(i -<1*L_l r +;Ls -' -
.:"i '""-', G(!y, vJJ.i* r* ,.
J-)U d fiJ-l-ll+-rJ' Ljir.r,J+ijJ c,tJ trJL;
rlJr r:r ril r3
EElf t iJtJrdu n, vr ts.:.f I
,rv,.-i. ; -J,
4, .:".--l|;t' * .* .,.*L, .
* -; ;il;;;;"l)*,:'
.c..-.lt!- liJU,Jl .Jj*r,o.
* ;;::.:,
.
-r{..,"!, /Jy, r.Jrij
e-i+ t^S .r-ijJ tJ J*:Jt dJ'] "
1 Y 4- G-r I 6Ju'
kL4;!/ .
,,",,;::;:;,:;,:lf L.u,,r
rui ;, _,
*q-:i r-'{j -:,r-r, .,-** ilrl,
** "*,J'
"&r
** f '"--:*vL
+,..;l ,*--a._a, *r*-.*ff
-., .
I
_.t
j ' .i I . " ,{,..ilA il !i}*.t i t--!L! | (4i.!6 '.:c*'! :L.r ' r<_.rt :r.-.r
,_"r
', J"!"a! *Jjj ,ii ,:..:.. ., ji ,
.)L.i,.1,,,,..."r',i,.Ji..,-.ir.3,.t*:i".la-tra-;L.rt+_Jt, jj!,f-:-1i,..",,
;;:;3;:H:itr;;;:ffff
*- dJt .5J"t*Jt ;, j-!dt, i..-rl *..,, r
""
.i,' :,
v. .;;; -,jrs',.e+_^:Jr
i,r+.! 'u+r:**;, i"- dt{ ;!r+Jr
i,. ,i.a- i.r3 Jl .r*-- i_.
,"$+_u .*;l<; ..r+r;.r,
gJr*rr Jar, ,J.,.:-
*-,'*"i1,IT ,...,- rJ,-LL.n,
.:,L;*rJ- ;jg !J' !5 +,j* r.tjjy,
v" LL.;_:Jt llJl .rlf ! ir3a _\ f o, *"-al i lr..,L: 'ior ,,
i=**J | .;,u*;.*-U ,U*;t ?'.*l $, ;3r,, L* tiU- .i-:;!
.cL*".r,aljJr rt-.. ;".r"i:,U nJj_-
iJJJt f tiJ, JtJ-i, (^).,,,:,';Ttr,,fi:;;Tj
$J't-(J, fJ'. vJ,(FJjl q,JAJL.,.ta.l ir.,-Il
. ri-L!.J.tl I
,,,nntE:r ,Jlji.t.jjl .:.*t cujy, 6_,j.; d*,i;j ,l
"rLglt ;t-; ,1+.!r:Jl r.* *l .:,uLi.r.l
,,1"*$ ull(3r.',i+r..l1I{i*ll .!tr;J.iJ rn tL1lf/l+!l gjj,l I ir3__ *r '*'u -u-, *l)
o, + v a t-sr.*.]"i
;;::3 ^'.uoo *,o u, kut' I ?-e
++rI u+:t or;' *o.i,,
,-" *Ji;! **o,,*--"
;;r:: . -yI
.
.l:,",;i -,,1,. ; "i"';:.;I
..i';.:.] ;Jj;r i -,*"- _i ,;.^,",.13
::-:l;i:;; ::"_fi; *1lr,J{,hj.rr
'fu-ll 5 E-:vl ;"-.,a-
,
i_,+
^.*
.-
*U ._1;i.:; t++t. g"r-1.r .,L,s-_-J t r ;L+I^i:-:J ,
,
k=J- 1U,^, g*rt ;r<. ;,*r.
..r ,,.i_jN
;., i-..j"",'-* +I: s-F, j i:!h Ai.J,y, ;JtJi uGr/..+,": .;*Li,
e'*
*fl] ': r,'
.JJL,
v-i d+:r .,J+i;_i ,,," e-. - vi^
"!j,. ''-'1og[-r
O* a-**L*r.l
: n"!r Gtiiy,;,r- ..-=*, .el,Lorr
i L.rx
_t^t'5-ti; 6t':;yr 1,F
. , f. rll.-iJ i,i.,i;,_,,.j; riurli:j.jl
r"',.'rt*;"l4sr F !Lr"^:'r
j
qj I ct;yl !f wr*ll pui: -i
L"dJ =*]'*"-
'Jr"iJI -ri,.Ll L.+j ._,-iL+-
', clJr {.r*j sJ. irsi'
irL-i*rrLt_Jr
,11...,--. J-'"! j-Lr- ,.J.,1 ,*. ll
;- riL;lt C-jJ r,rtrj) $i**!t ,*j *L..t,J+i*u.*:.; y'J rt l.rr,.,3.r,
..,,,;1,lT.i.l--^ * J-= c li J v r
a;;i , ;., LJ.jh . LrJ i_4r,i,i.:,t!-*Jt"L_;1,,.s.:g_:r_-.Jt;:iJJer;rslr ^L ; u JLir Q.,
--- i
otor'.r,, rrrrr,
-.,].r; ;; +*. ; .**- i,L",
i_ q^{ (!i L-""; , J,-"lJ i.*i,i, ;l {,<, .e-dt
'.4"-t"i.rl
J.t,}. ,, o*",_, _*, _,
:;; .
.s-r1!r
';**" i*; *",-:*:Jt .!.1J.- vj *-n.__ll, vj \J r+trl d.jJtL,ti
:.lrl.d ,J.",J i t*r"; !jj!u
;rs: sj6
c Lu)rr eF"+:, ;l *;_i5 g1
ni r_$K.l v.;.-j euj nG t"jlnr.t+j_ ,=,,-*r.,*; :ri+ rrA-: .gi.::yr
. ,r,6 ,-.,.,
;-.s..I-rl ,.J.u-J
"rai_.JL* e_-tL::. Lljr ,.!_t L.l-:,.J t,q_ti.-.r ., 1 ,,..., .-.-, ; j .i,J_ay,
:..:,.i..r-,"
r.,,!"i, l;*. ;sr, .;n,.,, :"lrHr:il5,.,fr5 5 5,*,,-'
*-' t'-, *r,"-;;.,,*, Lrrll v- s'-,r hYr,':-!; ,..:v, G .
J,',,.Jt.:,$rj ;i .r*,,,Jtkci ,r,rpg
5.
;rJ: .o-L;.: -* Lii.i--vi
c
i.rL-Jr,JL"ji ui'l'" if_,!lJ' fe Sd.:9-!13 iJL.JI .elrg_ ,,r-.i:j 6,, ;",;:,: '
e+r r
Jro_ ,,.,",
Jr; "j -irqvr iF .ur,l,*J ...€ i-.*'t'^-r vJ .uL.-J,r
=',-rt,, .!yyr
:i:rJ-,, i,j L.l.;-t{:.,r-;i
.rr^", ,*--:l-";; il ::T ff vJl L6'i- .l( .r.,jl f-.] Lli .r- r-_
*
!l---1j., e-L"J'LiLt ir,.:*
e*r kj +fr-.lJJ JtJJ:rtJ* j oi+L; e*"'; .:,Jxl -Fnu J{il
{:*lL---,1) _,.--t,.r<_! U13l
6,, ,)r.,1 ,_1_l iJ-.i.., J+n:.jJ, .p,rl ,_ ,a.3 ;-u (r.):6_/-Jr
r:'*'
si*' '
,:;* tr.l"; n- j !LG..
vJ (-i..u; "e;;l Jt,kll ;_j.,+.ijj r-iuL.rr .'L*1i 'JJi:Jlc{- E , cryl ;rt"J ,(:,)
.>"5i i-u:j ,.j.t_l"tr . (\\Xt_+L.Fyt .:,L{rJJ :,1,* q.
i,*J (J;#*ij Jl 6r.ra dS .d_1j3 .ev1l ljrr-'
*j LL:L.IJ G,qt*JtJ.:,fjl .rGt-
l* roFrx-.i, dr+,jr ;,<r L._
i.r,.,.'*.,
,r:,*iJj e*J-u (jJ" irri-li
iJLj A ;.F..rtiL+Jl
:,- r., v't *.6.,!,r.
Ij,:lt, 1!*r.,;-J,
A*.;JjjJI L"i*;"ij: L:Jt,_, .ri_r..gj.I, 'l*!'ai, J,, - -,' .*., " -L-Jr
f ,.r. .,+, ._L_,. I i1ti.:!t.a
1-'* .
9".$ *.=.- (U u.., .'Jir ;,..";*l*u !raLi-:r,J J-E:,
t*
e*rrr ':b:s-
- ot .L' * J-'+t
]l ' :gJ-{-i:J .-a:*"u;,"L-rr a.6..
;-,- i_.utl
I
;;:..,, r* o.
.,,
...t-.j ,.., ...,.^.*,_a_..,
::;..*;;,:.:-;-;:,
E(-r j.r'q\ L"L; "-'.. jr,.:,,,
"
.
J_.1-_:, L -,1:....-
^, ,** **' d+:it-; $-i'-i L' 1*_--r._- .
;,:.*"*
"t'rr'c",o*t"'"'l-'-"j-l]
i;r'i., .,: |JiJ ;J;- q5i,.,-: :;F,l; i-ll ;*
ri JLr-t, rl "u*i,v' .5rr* ;*
.Ti*-*',-LG-rsrr$
Sf ;;;
r_41".,_
n."
; :-',ifi",:t
+i tr,a J,.1
'rLi'yt J-1" j-.i.-;*,.Erl;-' .,iu*,Tit
_';,,jfll,j _
!-rl.+tJ I
uj .:-Ujr,r;JLjr dtt-:yI}i* ; JJ q+j** i,S.l3 !L L1;r 'u.* .4* '- ,J, rr..,,.,,,,*,;: v'f *- 'v. J*rr._*,-;.:
6.',.".o.or, -'+r ru,J i..r{, .:,Li-
cL*Jl 1li;;,'i
J-Jj r]l ll
.','.,' *',rjj],,I$::J.,i
".-.r, .,.,"", .
;;; .;
u.r.^ -,-+:i; .", l.t
itr-r! nS ,er.r:l *Orr[I]r-*' ;'] vr,i.,. -,.-"-
'.4:J, JIrj ..,J i-" r'.,jl.J .d s t J,,,r-, .* *.,lX Ifi::;-* il:: ,:;--# J, T :*.-'l 15; :: : -*':;
"
Lr,Lr,ldil .,,rJ
- I . j iU A.iLbt J.r+: "!l+la ,*-_
,,r1 -, .,,. ,,_ -".llgO'
-F.':.j ii."JiJ .- .',, **
I t* '.., -*-,
.:;* JL - L_.i! Lit".,
!i;._: / rqLr, _ ,t::\r I I ,, l
.l "-,*.r,
uur!.,**rs-,,
- .....,
uJ- {jlj djiJr.J.:l li1g1J - d(-! JtI-l .:,831 .J.]Jtii J+i tJ - sJ-Ji.:.Jt
vr L,Jr- yJl . r 1 :<: eurlLiyr
i,J.-4J I i,Lis !,Jl /r; r{J-+ l?trl !FL+j a-iJt-l i,4 ...^+i &l *L^rl
.,,!'*'- r-.e v.r",+r s, lT,' *r ,;":'-tjr.F',v,
q! & 'J6-ii .J*,s
e:--: Jri:r' q-i" J-lr
Jt-4lr JtL3l .rLisl ;lj L-l;,,rlrjJ rl jSrJ-:,LrS i- i., il- lS t-L:jyl
. rj'tSjJlf i;Jiii !ii! rJ.!l! J+ JL.l .r-,! i* .ur. J* "*;r;: J: L+r arLc Lr-,., ...r.-Jr g,-
vJ 11!d i,r$ Jl r.< r .:rFt+t I
L L!r.r=.r ..:
-;;:;" qtjJr F:-d I pr-r-
,:51 .1,*4
.
r r
.- 1r1 .-r, .r-,r-1, _Tr
'rL- C+.... '{+if! f,t ,jl * --1, *JtlJL,,,
I
I
I
I
- :r.,rt' {*-: I .:!(,i
dlcrjstl;- e"* Lrr-i*l I drF(l e{!' L!il 6-.r J+;'!-: 'rl'rl u-.'i3 g:L!i
,*r&r E ; ;,- -la',SJt f L:;Yl ":,tl- !,.i J"ii !!J "Jir-tl LtS Lrj r'Lr;'J'
lir C+i :.+iuYQ ri:! L,r;;*i,r ejJ_.jJj .::LlJl
e
..lrg;
[* j*"/ l**+. ei _v
6"t"L-i*; ,u:Jl€l ?'-rrl .F iJr+S Ll,15*l Elx r-"Jl':'L::tl ",.''-:i ,jSl r a,r,**^,,o*
o,..,;8,,,I, ;::,= r.,/ {_..J-ur!
r
.r..Vl dL"l oJ* ,l-lLrJlj ol-l;Ji;- fr,i'i*tl €lai;: !+Jj
i+:'|.j.-l- Et':jl rr*: *, *, :
,..*+
qr
,.lJ<, La;+,!': $! iJla-:;'r-li .rl;-3jl .r.u 3l 'LiJ:-^- d'l/; I lr'il"fjY
I
'+Jlj FrL l-u- ,-"--. _rt!rr,, .," *.,i.**ri"**l
''&'j:i '?iJt "l' ,r." , G;--j T,*
j,(.j .,:tJ. r!_,J
f uJ t3 .r-rrlr
.:r'rJ*yr.J,- lJrcr- - *; ,-rJd
'-'.4 qr_j {* r,;:*r *:
L rG:.
JLrr- & ,,,. -.-", ...-_ L's , .*1",y'.ilrjJr
r..* ,k r,Jlt t*-r,i.nlt4l -r+ *nJ'6iJ I Ar-a;'l '*;lL -tr
rri +* 'r, uJl ,r.,,*;,,:;fi'"''s': t',' t .q*u,,., "-.'r*i 1"4
t,"r*t ;. JLrsiJ | ,l.J'!l ;G "raJ. {^Jl ellk- g-'-.r k-.rt+r ,r:+s JL.:J J-'i-};J
I a,r"r r,,i- e+r ; r,,,;L_*rf"'':
i+;{-.--;.:-*jl;:n:g -.u r ;:1 il,,-1*1,
.l"13*:* {--! i:.1* ei-: ,:,{l | ,La .rt L-.11 .1j4tl;l r-.rL,Il JL-J I eUL-
-*:-J ) -ui?| |!J ur-" us Lri J:.;, 'a J.:'--JJ |i- JJ. -t"s riu Liilr .J.r*
r:nr.irn l; lElrC6itl t$.J"1*l !/t iJ-:,L-(l J+ -l+ltgJ'lLii iiLliill .:.L LiJ, rij , -+ i*u, i_t
(JjJr
bsj, c,t,,'t?!J {.,-*_iJL
LJ-i! | I *l.. !is-:l e:+ Cj.J | !]ld->:.ii Idl
-."ts:-js d,q^!,.:.L-.r-rllu, .FiJui e-ri r, dJi JLL,r+r- _.L^J -a
i="-*;s- ":u.k .
!- ;Js- iS &L:"3Jn u"i )l-.Ld- u,ri .lj 6J,i-J | 'jJjJl E+i.| ei;I t e.:--l t .)5.l.r
ar .," r,,-r-rr *.L;;;il'::*,rk *,"*,
*",i"'r--'.-, Jr.*,,
e lllyll+!$ $u, eL.U ,JJLj'! Jjd
l l ule tliL-j c,?--r
F* dnJr,.rGiill
r&, +nn E.,ir j- ,*,,-
.:Ln-d' ur..--., -.-*i1't-f
*,,],r*:'L.*tlri, f
. !J-.:rjtlJ:*i *+L(!tJ+*-:.| c,L.j!ll.i$.:,JJ! u,t-lLtiil Li! n5", *iJ ;; ;:: r*L,:,,:;,
kL LrJ J .ir.{l crljlJIL:Jlr iJlJtl .llJrv Li*li- rLa;Jl d-L-vl i)e! ;l .,.-ll
j.!..i iJ*,r:J_1
,*;,:;';;;l 'lill+,o,; JJ/r \''-,
.,. ernr dL L*r. l
A-;JS,r;c,t.'<11:rag!+---llu.L-l oj! 6ri-11 i' ,- .e'a ;.#l .]ts liLi
t ( pr;:Lrr r't,li'.to'' :- '*
."r* ;o,,r.r .>-rL'; t*"-- ,ur,fiG <*" &r,oJr,,;rLg
r-YJ {*i;, t,Jl ig! | J,^ |J.t-t oJs- rjl-jl | .!*
I lJ- lLl'i, J'r -ird I clL< lilJ
{r.L*l vJ. J:*-.rl+ 6l ..J31G l;c1L- ct*vl ..irl !ts 6l ,,S-, d ,lr tjJl uj * $ .ri,. rdi,e,yv, uL! Jeii-v
jr j^
:tt_::
uJ* ,-A.i' - ! r.*i. ;*"1., _,
.rl- c.r":i k-Ll-t" &!--jJlJ, i.lls; J-"i4 pl er-: lrj'L.i- r.JjtJI.tl3ll JJS-J .j .Uj, ..
.:4L', u,.i !,Ju.,LJ r
e+* .A .," ,1i.:*
,:;,;;::.:ll|'f .4i.o
l eid-l| JrLi' Cu.jllJj,t: J,JrJ.: uf. i+r-Jl Uyl J-:Ji J-f : !li- (,rjl i+r. .,.',",+,, ;,.".,, I
UYI ,-r-.{=:J Jl.l+] ci-i J'rL- r 4-"Ji:- fq- .l.rJ:.r-.r-Jl Utl (]JJ- rlr- J'rL lr-' J-, /L- ur- .!*, ; ;;;,TH:t#:
l;i-*.j-il_, ltky'(-Fr LA.i: jEi l.'t-tJ.;;-
-"-,
i'*i {.r+,;-n
sJI
rJ*<".!
CL:jY l 1*U.
.,iJ, r.r-r-,,-, J'jH ; -1,
};;1 ;""
JFL!. l.|l.i- q.L i,J | :+JJ:J d,t1,l dJJ- -, .l JLJI c,tJq-3 oeliJt .!ry, r- tr:;l;
JLj dJt'Jr Edl lJ.a cro_ r-lU' r _..t r
.,-i 1,.,.uJ13 g;::Jt JJU: sL lLli:Jl iJJ-il !,.+rU- Jrrtrj,1 i+*t-l L+{i djt.ir I L{-ai,;; !iJ*
a.irJ.l' ,- nijhj' l.J.Jl i*-, Jiui- ull-rj.LrJ, .ir J'JjJ.:.rLr LIi<;:Jt
ir"ilJ-", l{fl4 -iri:J | .Jhylf+, s:,1l,{aJl JL t e+-i JlJjllj.rtfl .,-i
'r,Jl
.k"i- .rllrj lr L!S:JJ : L'r-: J{:i 1.?)
l.: Ll,j I ,*l1i
.i+I- !b-{ {ju gdl rir !a ; s,JlJil I lLjt -{-jJt' -o ;- @Lj, j JjlJ n, La$. lj,r(_- .* -t+LjjiJ, .J.; jr-i t'
.:.1.5.rt
.j"|JJJ i
{.J -\
E{-i.11 li!^; *Lll !lf-+6 J+i+ rlr.! y lsLjJl liiljJ.l(Jr+ttjJl fJ{.ilLi -t" {+.,"r-,J l r, f+"r.Jt Jdj }Ju-ijl djj Jt]_..t{j€ *rri:t, ftl :r*-*;
urJ-r iJdl ,;.!;J .[tJlj UA:JlJii].i, li.!r.U!t .rdt-tU, eJ.tj*,t u-!, ;L5r I cjJ I r,- J U.:.l;' lr rt!;l,
Eu.iy, _"0* ; *{lJ, ., _, *'']jou,
.
JL4L iJ-.:.l*.ll UL.nl 1[:.r .:,9Jl j+r+]r Jl*l c,l.e,i+i-J3 etflr UL^.JI '*.yj- n4 .i, ns- i*Lt J' J.,a .--ii:,+-r ljr.r- f:.r*. *,-.l.o_;
n"!q lj,ttr J 4Jj nti ici.LJt c,- (,jlsji JJ_.j j JJ+r ";,t.:*.
-,lliy' vJ4 t{- .j+ vr - ti,^ l*Ull .5UJ.-IU .#tLrt .!tiJt l{j iJ-.t L- *"; e_ ;Li t ,l_j .r.^g ;f J;
r, ,-v-^!l sLJ-t ilt-ij J_j,Ur
elj3 i--iir .=ljrlj eLlL-3 ^r-L-l y'l ,r* ;la *l-11 d,Lj ,rl.liJr , Ul- J+. EGjl,JjJj C .r+J JSL:., J,F+r (,L Jr-r,i_"
a.:".*l-tl F:lJjJl r,!J t{j+, f+r ,l * t' -.!LJ,-lt iju u. Li J+i5: ...-l-ll foL": ,l ., .r : l;-,J . g{jf l ,!r l+*Uf
d i,Ls Vj ,* I frg ,.^, . oi f.f l-.rrl
.vul JL*.I .ai_-.d .:JJL.I-.:J ,C,:j_.! &l;.;,lt rl J.tr.J ..iiJ ts!
iF*. .:,j+; .r,J.L
Jt ll . ;.'t(iJ,J!+_ J1& ;i.r iLLi. u15-tr
€tiiytlil.sj lJL t^J-:,.r,.iJ,J1
dJal s, +r5ll eriltJ r-:.:i .iJ* v:Jl c,l JJJiJI jt-i: | ,:,trJt1.r I i- -1 .;t4"^ll,rj {Lii,jt,:lJrf,!, ;; j
C-.r,.,L,'",,
q!
'il .t{.LJ.j-iJl .luJg sJi e-i, gl iJr-..,+r-l .r.,i .i--'iJ I i*Jfa
q,13 dJ,GJr ri i^+i-:4.in*JJ 1+ arrj,j*Il cJL.ti! 1L.6 L,|JJ 6l3j.r.:,t.r-r- ra:tJ.r'F.rl nJSj ntis_
C--i3i d"f*U t!. u_e LU!l L$JJ;, _r
.!UJs- .L-i i!.:J e*ill .L+-.+ d!*l ol c6 l&L-l .JijJ | : jjr .L.i,.--jJJ c.J':-I .:,, Jj-J j-*+.iJ,J ,Jtkyl {,-i,, JiiirJt
Ll+:.-r | .*l.ijt L$; {Jt US .Lul"J, i..ijJ,.,J;,r*,":.-i Ei.rjy,(,J.:*-J c]JiJl
eJ ,il ..*lJlJ,J,r .i.rj;llLjJj ds d{is: J:L-J r.ln- Ji:!r l.i.LtjJt .:,ti,-:ill
&!" !E u.rr_Jl ,rJ-t l.LJr .Jr-el ll+ {lt , l-+iJtltil^J d ?sJtdI e!:4 erll L:>- ud a"--t, *1I l* GGjy,,*,J.,r.,o, ,.*,, J]rr_,
,.,r_:;,,,,-,.1
-,
..))t:.Ul Jl,-t GUJIJ <jt:J-: -yr ;i. t,lj ,:,lj,JAjy t._-*_: ;t!,Aij+,,
J-dJi ll.jp:"J l*--.j.r ,jL5 si,ll'Mikiya Kinoshita',olJ jlJ ,''kiluo Suzumum.JJ *..,,,.,.;;-.r.
6nr}.:J rr-L*tJS,,j,. J4.r, LJt,r'| .:,teL::-,9J ti.i lirsJ.U-t_ .:tijJJ:sjJJ hl ri lJ{rf: J,i.; t
,.Jt.:,J"lr+y,r il*,Jyi,lgj i;} L.,*Jl ,rr_r, r,r1"..
llr L,:,J q..-GJl dlr.lj ;,
t-'! U.r.r- c! lJLl-f-dU iL:.:. Dl ,,. g,r-!l JJjjJt Jl Jusl-in-Trrne e+i- \,_.\J J,J-*i_.1. t4;"
.
I *- ;1;;-1t ;M ,....;i\.
,;*,!t*;"-*;n, *t-Itsau, ",,Jj;l
.New I'roducdon Sys@rns Resear'ch Association(Nps group) "ii-, nlr.+l- ra; u,aLL" _, ,^_" ,i.* ,"n
:6-lJ
C.{i.t I lir
..rJt-J rt+ -i.
JKitJ .jJ^Jt
dra Ja JI-UIJJ ;r;5r di,,il3!J. -ri 1...] d*r;jl<;J,it,Fr et LiU J_rj:-tr
JL*l,L,h^s
-Shinohare,I., "NPSj New hoduclion Syslem", Productivily hess, USA. l9g5
.q,i, i*,;.* -
-ibid, PP. 34,36. (Y)
-c-iJ+d
-Johnson, H.T.and Kaplan, R.S, "Relevance Losl", Harvard Business School _l:e-lJ(t) ,ri JLii J:* d'6lr t* ,.^l ftleir-e J;!.j
press, USA , 1987,pp.212 -216. tr.q:"e
lLl-!
iJr,l.iJli.:*:.J c*LJi tr,r,Jj
-Drury, C., "Menagemenl and cosl Accounring", Vl,lR, UK, 2nd.€d .,1988, pp. 665-666 _e v.!t14J*.t, 6lr oG JLJ| i*.-r-;r-
+rr5/ Lid !L&!ii,! +.i ;l Jrt_ .:^t_rJr L"S
c .JJ .arJ.;,l ,et c,r.".t r-;t_
-Homgren. C-T. and Fosler. G., "Cost Acaoundng: A Mamgerial Emphasis", _+ st"-l LJJ J.rj: rrl .j* -. : t+i- *i.r ul LJ-,:
Prenric - Hil. USA,61L ed., I98?, Pp. 588 - 93
aV.:t,r+ul.s .",ll, *-*jJ L j_!
.
t.{.:lc.:,-.;'iJt .iL,L(*Li.1r,1
JrL-r ti{J 6rj;J LJL--:jylli_.SJtUJt- eJ.j..j*:r (o)
.JrjJL tu.:- t -riJK:J rt.Efl._LJrs: cjtJ- ,--"l.Jl d3l. nl ,.,-r b e.6 L.j I t+J | ;qr
-Drury C.. op.cit., P.666.
*t' *!tilL*J, id-1r
4:. ,?.JLl, rJJt sj r+."iiJ, 15.r-.
e+l., (1)
| , f ,,: ._- j{;t_r
.l .rl;ijJ I
;lI: ' J tJjr.t .:*1.! (*'JJ :FlJ (V)
li.ls: -L^1.::LlrJl.-LJt<:
kl flat*i ;t J.-rl-+ AlJ,.ri;ild *,Lig.l3 ll*.1 ;;a;il
"
I ; l; a,. J L-i)
,'""-,,".--i','l].:-:-l: =**
*'urcra, i. 1-l1r,p"{-!L:.JtJ*&i.it.t
" *i-j I Lp r-. ;! L iJ, i-.q
rub ."-*1r,.]g l^r
'.4gga!\r.al, op. cir., pp.9_10 *;rt ;;d r4:,? ft)
i "-___: ', ;+ ,i tL;____-J rF r!. , ;1i,|1 r J.r-J l ,v:-- s -Shinoftard,
op. cL, .t
L -.,.i r , Lra-.r ,_s:.-.' ,-V\ \.*-., ) 6 \r--r lo;., ) ;r.r.r.; \.;,, '!rr .l,ra';rex,B.,
Tus;ti:;r:eManufacruring,,,Ia:
(ar1 .'" IJ".t
j\4a"r"",.",o**i"*lfrOrlil_:
ri t.,:l-;f1 ;i...;rt-- -,.1t \-.r _r " L--ij Lr--..;J L:J I
;:-..;.: lu,!lj . ;--:-t!'JlJ -tirllJ :JUJL u-Ol, J f :1.-ll L*:",Jf
.rl - ;r-5i ^-r-*L l..--_: iaF .r-J a,";-f I - rirr. Jl 'lJ'Jlui! Gr,
,C..,., (1")
. J-* j rLrlll J-i j ;---Lii \.-i,; J tll-.ll u-+;I..:-Jllaf -r,-:rl -4ggaik'al, op.
cir., p.9
-Shinoha.a,
i -,.nL.,* * L 6- - -Lr)l !"i J ;-,-tti.ll-i.;Jiu;urf "lrt t;fa op.cir.. pp.68-60"
t54_155
,onnson & Kapian, op.cil.., pp.?12-216.
**---J I Lr.- r , I LJ 1; I ,, K-'J 1 , .rrlrJl; rJJiJlJa lja,:JJ>nn -ivtaskeli, 8.,
0p. cit.- 26-28
irl, , Lj,, j ;.tr- rlr:- JL-,"^jlJ L( ,:-tctl i-lf---
,^;li; "-*jr l -Ilomgren &
Fosrer, op. cit... p58g.
;'.-;\l;- $-: a:-L.ll :"1, i, I J,j-dli J lJ. d,---.i ;iL ^--iil.i ,lJL
;*L J. $-j I \-".-, g ;r=r! t u)l-i-J I it)t 1 ":-1-.," Jll-.ll J ilrUi)l _3
-Johnson& KapJnn, op.cir.. p214.
- Aggarwal
; l--ril- I .Jj- L- 6 '*.jJ L -*J I -.::L L.-:-r i;,- ,:- 6r- I s . ;; i: , op cir.., p.9.
n".,, ,.fr:
d[J1;LiJlj L< i-t-Jt t *4to- Le.r tn- ,o ., J',]r li:o,i:r^: :osr.tccoun,inc:y:re: ro ius. in- rime Manufa.,*^",1i:l