Professional Documents
Culture Documents
ABSTRACT
This research aims to examine whether 1) green perceived value and green perceived risk can
influence green trust 2) green perceived value and green perceived risk can influence green purchase
intention 3) green trust can influence green purchase intention 4) green trust mediates the effect on
green perceived value anda green perceived risk on green purchase intention Sample was selected
using convenience sampling method amounted to 150 respondents at Jakarta. Data was processed
with structural equation modeling using SmartPLS.3.2.7 program. The results indicate green
perceived value and green perceived risk have significant effect to predict green trust and green
purchase intention, green trust have significant influence to predict green purchase intention, and
green trust partially mediates the effect on green perceived value as well as green perceived risk on
green purchase intention.
Keywords: Green perceived value (GPV), Green Perceived Risk (GPR), Green Trust (GT), Green
Purchase Intention (GPI)
Beneficial products are more likely to be Alessandro, Girardi and Tiangsoongnern [11].
purchased. Green perceived value refers to the In the research of Chen and Chang [1] green
consumers’ overall assessment of the net trust mediates the effect of green perceived
benefits of products or services comparing risk and green perceived value on green
what is received with what is given according purchase intention.
to the desires of the consumer's environment, This study aims to determine whether
sustainable expectations of consumers, and the green perceived value as well as green
need for environmental friendliness. Today, perceived risk can be used to predict green
more people are beginning to see the value of trust, along with whether green perceived
environmental friendliness in a product. value and green perceived risk can be used to
According to Chen and Chang [1] if a product predict green purchase intention, whether
has good green perceived value, it will green trust can be used to predict green
increase green purchase intention. This is purchase intention, and whether brand love
validated by previous studies, such as of Putra can mediate brand image and self-expressive
and Suryani [7], who found that green towards word of mouth. The results of this
perceived value positively influenced green study are expected to provide information to
purchase intention. Wu and Chen [8] companies to consider the opinions and
discovered that if perceived value increases, ratings of their consumers about the internal
then purchase intention will also increase. aspects of the company to develop its
Green perceived risk is important in products. Besides, this research can be taken
generating green purchase intentions. As into consideration in making appropriate
discussed by Chen and Chang [1], green decisions related to the use of green perceived
perceived risk is a negative expectation that value, green perceived risk, and green trust
can have an impact on the environment related factors on consumers' green purchase
to buying behavior. Chen and Chang [1] found intentions so that companies can continue to
that green perceived risk has negative survive in global competition.
influence on green purchase intention. Similar Chen and Chang [1] explained that green
results were also obtained in the research of perceived value directly and positively
Kim and Lennon [6] who found that perceived influence green trust. With an increase in
risk has a negative impact on purchase consumers’ perceived value of an item, the
intention. This is also supported by Chang and level of consumer confidence will increase.
Chen's research [9] that the greater the risk This is also supported by Chen's research [10]
that can be perceived from a product, the less suggesting that green perceived value directly
the consumer's intention to buy the product. and positively influence green trust in
Another factor that can explain green electronic consumers in Taiwan. Furthermore,
purchase intention is green trust. Green trust is Cheung, Lam, and Lau [12] proposed that
a will to reply on a service, a product or brand green perceived value has positive relationship
according to beliefs or expectations due to with green trust in Bonaqua consumers in
credibility, good deeds, and how Hong Kong.
environmentally friendly it is [10]. Strong Chen and Chang [1] [3] [13] suggested
trust in a product will increase consumer that reducing green perceived risk increases
purchase intentions for said product. This is green trust. This means that green perceived
supported by research by Chen and Chang [1] risk has a negative impact on green trust.
which discovered that green trust has a direct When companies reduce the perceived risk felt
positively influences green purchase intention by consumers, consumer confidence in these
on electronic products in Taiwan. These products will increase. The level of
results were also found in the study of consumers’ perceived risk will influence the
1016
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
consumer's decision to trust or mistrust. H2b: Green perceived risk can negatively
Further research by Alessandro, Girardi, and influence green purchase intention.
Tiangsoongnern [11] found that perceived risk Consumer confidence is the main
has a negative impact on trust. Based on the determinant of long-term consumer behavior.
description above, the first hypothesis is as In a research by Chen and Chang [1], it was
follows: found that green trust has a direct positive
H1a: Green perceived value can positively impact on green purchase intentions on
influence green trust. electronic products in Taiwan. Furthermore,
H1b: Green perceived risk can negatively Chang and Chen's [9] study uncovered that
influence green trust. green trust has a direct positive influence on
Weisstein, Asgari, and Siew [4] found green purchase intentions for consumers who
perceived value positively influenced purchase shop online. Alessandro, Girardi, and
intention on green products. When the benefit Tiangsoongnern [11] also discovered trust
felt by consumers increases, the intention to positively influence purchase intention. When
buy a product will also increase. Chen and consumer confidence increases, consumers’
Chang [1] discovered green perceived value purchase intention increases. Hence, this study
positively influenced green purchase intention. hypothesizes that:
Chen and Chang [1] stated that consumers H3: Green trust can influence green purchase
must be given knowledge about green intention positively.
products to increase green perceived value, in Chen and Chang [1] found that green
order to increase consumers' purchase perceived risk significantly influences green
intentions on green products. Cheung, Lam, trust and green purchase intention directly.
and Lau [12] found that green perceived value Companies must understand the effects of
has a positive impact on green purchase green perceived risk and green trust on green
intentions on bottled mineral water products in purchase intentions. A product with low green
Hong Kong. Furthermore, the study by Wu perceived risk will be able to win consumer
and Chen [8] found that if perceived value preferences in a purchasing decision compared
increases, then green products purchase to those with high green perceived risk.
intention will also increase. However, before consumers decide to make a
Chen and Chang [1] found that green purchase, consumers will consider whether
perceived risk negatively impacts green this product can be trusted before buying the
purchase intention. When consumers’ product. The above statement is supported by
perceived risk increases, the intention to buy research by Alessandro, Girardi, and
the product decreases. Similar results were Tiangsoongnern [11] which stated that trust
obtained in the study by Alessandro, Girardi mediates the perceived risk relationship to
and Tiangsoongnern [11] in which perceived consumers' purchase intentions on jewelry
risk negatively influenced purchase intention. products in Thailand. Before having purchase
Purchase intention increases if consumers’ intentions, consumers will first consider the
perceived risk decreases. Furthermore, perceived risk, then consumers will trust said
Bhukya and Singh [14] found that perceived product resulting in an increase of consumers'
risk negatively impacts purchase intention. purchase intentions of said product will
Consumer confidence can be gained by the increase.
company by minimizing perceived risk in Based on the result of research conducted
every aspect. As per the discussions above, by Chen and Chang [1], green trust can
this study posits that: mediate green perceived value to one's
H2a: Green perceived value can positively purchase intention. Consumers feel confident
influence green purchase intention. about a product if they have felt the value of
1017
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
1018
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
The result of testing the first hypothesis positively. Trust or subjective assumptions of
showed that green perceived value positively consumers often arise in the minds of
influences green trust. Consumers generally consumers when choosing a product in a
view products as an environmentally friendly purchasing situation, where consumers prefer
international skin care products that are valued products with more perceivable benefits,
and trusted. Research conducted by Chen [10] because they believe that products with
suggests that green perceived value has a benefits equal to the trade-off are more
direct positive effect on green trust due to trustworthy than products with benefits that
subjective differences in the value of a product are unequal to the trade-off value.
perceived by one consumer to another. Furthermore, H1b hypothesis testing
Company continues to increase the value proved that green perceived risk significantly
consumers perceive in order to maximize net influence green trust. In line with previous
profit. This opinion is supported by research research by Chen and Chang [2], Chen and
conducted by Chen and Chang [1], explaining Chang [1], Chen and Chang [3] and
that green perceived value directly and Alessandro, Girardi, and Tiangsoongnern [11]
positively influences green trust. With an where green perceived risk can negatively and
increase in consumers’ perceived value of an significantly affect consumer green trust.
item, the level of consumer confidence will When companies reduce the perceived risk of
increase. Further research conducted by consumers, consumer confidence in their
Chang, Lam, and Lau [12] suggests that green products will increase. Green campaign
perceived value and green trust are related programs created by company such as "eco-
1019
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
handkerchief", "recycle", and "clean earth" product was tested on animals, contains
have formed a good paradigm in the minds of colourant and alcohol, and not recycleable.
consumers where consumers are more Futhermore, study by Chen and Chang [1];
confident with products, because they Bhukya and Singh [14] found that green
minimize the risks that affect the environment perceived risk negatively impacts green
compared to other products that neglect the purchase intention. When the risk felt by
environment. This implies that green consumers increases, their purchase intention
perceived risk negatively influences green decreases. Consumer confidence can be
trust. gained by the company by minimizing the
Green perceived value is proven to be perceived risk in all aspects, such as product
able to positively influence green purchase ingredients, packaging, green campaigns and
intention, and therefore, H2a is not rejected. many others.
This is coherent with studies conducted by Green trust can positively influence green
Weisstein, Asgari, and Siew [4], Chen and purchase intention and therefore, H3 is not
Chang [1] Cheung, Lam, and Lau [12] and rejected. Similar with the study by Chen and
Wu and Chen [8] that green perceived value Chang [1], Chang and Chen [9] and
has a positive and significant impact on green Alessandro, Girardi, and Tiangsoongnern [11]
purchase intention. When the benefit felt by that green trust has a significant influence on
consumers increases, so does the intention to green purchase intention. Consumers' personal
purchase a product. The many steps taken by consideration about a product that they plan to
company to show consumers the benefit of buy can affect their thoughts. Consumers will
supporting their products, such as animal-free judge a product based on intrinsic and
testing, fragrance-free and colorant-free, extrinsic information they found regarding the
piqued consumers’ interest, generating product, where it will form trust that
purchase intention for equal trade-off. This ultimately affects the consumer's purchase
finding shows that in a purchase situation, intention.
consumers usually pay attention to all aspects The result of testing the H4a hypothesis
related to the product, and if there is a good indicates that green trust can positively
correlation between consumers and the mediate green perceived value to green
product, consumers’ purchase intention will purchase intention. This is in accordance with
increase subconsciously. the findings of Chen and Chang [1] and Lam,
The result of testing the H2b hypothesis Lau, and Cheung [15] in which green
indicates that green perceived risk is proven to perceived value significantly impacts green
be able to negatively influence green purchase trust while having an influence on green
intention. This hypothesis is supported by purchase intention as well. Consumers feel
Alessandro, Girardi and Tiangsoongnern [11], confident about a product if they have felt the
stating that perceived risk negatively value of an environmentally friendly product.
influenced purchase intention. Purchase When consumers are confident in the
intention increases if the perceived risk environmental performance of a product, their
experienced by consumer decreases. This purchase intention increases. To continue
supports the perception of the researchers that maintaining relationship with green
in choosing skin care products, consumers consumers, companies must continue to
must already have known the ingredients and enhance the green perceived value of a
be highly involved enough with the product. product and increase green trust.
This is due to consumers considering the risks Lastly, the result of H4b hypothesis
that might occur when using skin care testing indicates that green trust can
products, for example whether or not the negatively mediate green perceived risk to
1020
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
green purchase intentions. This is similar to trust a product, the consumer will have the
the study by Chen and Chang [1] and intention to purchase.
Alessandro, Girardi, and Tiangsoongnern [11] The results of this study are expected to
that green perceived value significantly serve as a consideration in decision making
influences green trust and has an influence on for companies related to green perceived value
green purchase intention. Before having and green perceived risk factors, where
purchase intentions, consumers will consider collaboration with various groups can support
the perceived risk first, and then they will trust product research and development, and
and consequently increase consumers' innovate by adjusting to current fashion trends
purchase intentions on a product. Companies without eliminating the uniqueness of
must understand the impact of green perceived previous designs can help product marketing
risk and green trust on green purchase activities. In addition, for academics it is
intention. A product with low green perceived hoped that this research can be a reference for
risk will be able to win consumer preferences further research with a greater scope and range
in a purchasing decision compared to those of samples so that it can strengthen and
with high green perceived risk. However, complement previous research, and is
before consumers decide to make a purchase, expected to add other variables such as green
they will first consider whether or not this satisfaction, green perceived quality, green
product can be trusted. product knowledge and green product
innovation.
4. CONCLUSION
One key to success for most businesses is to REFERENCES
maintain a positive green value felt by [1] Chen, Y., & Chang, C. (2012). Enhance
consumers, because consumers are more green purchase intentions. Management
confident in products with good green values, Decision, 50(3), 502-520.
leading to higher purchase intentions. Another
key to success in green products is by paying [2] Berkman, H. W., & Gilson, C. C. (1978).
attention to the risks posed to the Consumer Behaviour: Concepts and
environment. Smaller risk can convince Strategies. Dickenson Publishing Company.
consumers to buy and trust these products.
Therefore, green perceived risk as well as [3] Chen, Y., & Chang, C. (2013). Greenwash
green perceived value factors are certainly and Green Trust: The Mediation Effects of
important strategies to consider in corporate Green Consumer Confusion and Green
decision making. Perceived Risk. Journal of Business Ethics,
The analysis conducted proves that green 114(3), 489-500.
perceived risk and green perceived value
impact green trust, because consumers’ [4] Lee Weisstein, F., Asgari, M., & Siew, S.
decision will be influenced by how (2014). Price presentation effects on green
consumers’ green perceived value and green purchase intentions. Journal of Product &
perceived risk. How consumers perceive a Brand Management, 23(3), 230-239.
green product will reflect how the product
actually is, and when the product reflects the [5] Huang, Y. C., Yang, M., & Wang, Y. C.
consumers when used, consumers will be (2014). Effects of green brand on green
more inclined to trust said product. purchase intention. Marketing Intelligence &
Furthermore, this research also verifies that Planning, 32(3), 250-268.
green trust factor positively influences green
purchase intention, because when consumers
1021
Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 478
[6] Kim, J., & Lennon, S. J. (2013). Effects of [12] Cheung, R., Lam, A. Y., & Lau, M. M.
reputation and website quality on online (2015). Drivers of green product adoption: the
consumers' emotion, perceived risk and role of green perceived value, green trust and
purchase intention. Journal of Research in perceived quality. Journal of Global Scholars
Interactive Marketing, 7(1), 33-56. of Marketing Science, 25(3), 232-245.
[7] Putra., Suryani. (2015). Peran Green Trust [13] Chen, Y., & Chang, C. (2013). Towards
dalam memediasi Green Perceived Value green trust. Management Decision, 51(1), 63-
terhadap Green Trust terhadap Green 82.
Purchase Intention Lampu Philips LED di
Surabaya. Jurnal Ilmiah Mahasiswa [14] Bhukya, R., & Singh, S. (2015). The
Universitas Surabaya, 3(10), 1-20. effect of perceived risk dimensions on
purchase intention. American Journal of
[8] Wu, S., & Chen, Y. (2014). The Impact of Business, 30(4), 218-230.
Green Marketing and Perceived Innovation on
Purchase Intention for Green Products. [15] Lam, A. Y., Lau, M. M., & Cheung, R.
International Journal of Marketing Studies, (2016). Modelling the Relationship among
6(5). Green Perceived Value, Green Trust,
Satisfaction, and Repurchase Intention of
[9] Hsin Chang, H., & Wen Chen, S. (2008). Green Products. Contemporary Management
The impact of online store environment cues Research, 12(1), 47-60.
on purchase intention. Online Information
Review, 32(6), 818-841. [16] Hair, J., Ringle, C., & Sarstedt, M.
(2011). PLS-SEM: Indeed A Silver Bullet. The
[10] Chen, Y. (2010). Towards green loyalty: Journal of Marketing Theory and
driving from green perceived value, green Practice, 19(2), 139-151.
satisfaction, and green trust. Sustainable
Development, 21(5), 294-308. [17] Henseler, J., Ringle, C., & Sinkovics, R.
(2009). The Use of Partial Least Square Path
[11] D'Alessandro, S., Girardi, A., & Modeling in International Marketing.
Tiangsoongnern, L. (2012). Perceived risk Advances in International Marketing, 20, 277-
and trust as antecedents of online purchasing 319.
behavior in the USA gemstone industry. Asia
Pacific Journal of Marketing and Logistics, [18] Nunnally, J. C., & Bernstein, I. H.
24(3), 433-460. (1994). The Assessment of Reability.
Psychometric Theory, 3, 248-292.
1022