You are on page 1of 9

Understanding parenting occupations in

Critical review
neonatal intensive care: application of the
Person-Environment-Occupation Model
Deanna Gibbs,1 Kobie Boshoff 2 and Alison Lane 3

Key words: The adoption of family-centred care principles within neonatal intensive care,
Neonatology, parenting, including support for the development of the parental role, has been increasing
occupation. in profile over the past decade. During this period, occupational therapy has also
had an emerging role in the provision of services within neonatal intensive care.
However, there has been limited exploration of the concept of parenting as an
occupation as a means of supporting parental role development within the neonatal
intensive care unit (NICU). In accordance with the philosophy of family-centred
care, opportunities exist to determine how the occupational efforts of parents
and preterm infants can best be supported.
This paper provides a review of the current literature and its application to the
Person-Environment-Occupation (PEO) Model as a framework for illuminating the
acquisition of parenting occupations in the NICU. Illustration is provided of how
the application of the PEO Model can be used to direct occupational therapy
practice to incorporate a focus on family-centred care and the development of an
occupation-based approach through which practice can be enhanced, ensuring
that both the infant’s and the family’s needs are recognised and addressed.

Introduction
Increasing survival rates for infants born preterm and recognition of the
importance of parent-infant attachment in this vulnerable client group has
1 Bartsand the London NHS Trust, London. resulted in a growing profile of the benefits of adopting family-centred
2 University of South Australia, Adelaide,
care principles in the neonatal intensive care unit (NICU). However, a
Australia.
3 The Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio, range of barriers continues to have an impact on the uptake of family-centred
United States. care in this highly complex setting. The aim of this literature review was
to consider this ongoing issue from an occupational performance
Corresponding author: Deanna Gibbs, perspective, through a description of the application of the Person-
Research Consultant – Nursing, Midwifery Environment-Occupation (PEO) Model (Law et al 1996) to support the
and AHP, Healthcare Governance,
provision of family-centred care in the NICU. A significant amount of
Barts and the London NHS Trust, 4th Floor,
John Harrison House, Royal London Hospital, neonatal intensive care research and practice literature is focused on the
London E11BB. viability and survival of the premature infant and on decreasing the
Email: Deanna.Gibbs@bartsandthelondon.nhs.uk potential for neurodevelopmental sequelae. This paper considers the
issues surrounding the admission of an infant to an NICU from a new
Reference: Gibbs D, Boshoff K, Lane A (2010)
occupation-based context and seeks to promote improved understanding of
Understanding parenting occupations in
neonatal intensive care: application of the parental involvement in neonatal intensive care through the consideration
Person-Environment-Occupation Model. of parenting occupations.
British Journal of Occupational Therapy,
73(2), 55-63.

DOI: 10.4276/030802210X12658062793762
Background context
Occupational therapy services in NICU
© The College of Occupational Therapists Ltd.
Occupational therapy has had an emerging role in service provision to
Submitted: 3 December 2008.
premature infants and their families for over 10 years (American Occupational
Accepted: 15 September 2009.
Therapy Association [AOTA] 1993, Gorga 1994, Vergara et al 2006). However,

British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2) 55

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Understanding parenting occupations in neonatal intensive care: application of the Person-Environment-Occupation Model

the specific role attributes of occupational therapists working their families. This period has also seen an increasing
within NICUs often differ between facilities and also differ focus on understanding the implications for parents of
between countries. These geographical and facility-based preterm infants during the intensive care admission
inconsistencies in service delivery make this an area of (Lawhon 2002, Browne 2003, Gavey 2007, Howland 2007,
practice within which the occupational therapy role and Thomas 2008), which has served to give more prominence
unique contributions are difficult to articulate to other to the consideration of parental role and support require-
professions in this highly complex setting. ments. Therefore, in addition to knowledge of application
Over the past decade, occupational therapy services and theory regarding infant neurodevelopment, there is
within NICUs in the United States and parts of the United also an opportunity to consider occupational performance
Kingdom have become increasingly established, with as a means of identifying how both parents’ and infants’
clearly defined roles and competencies forming part of the occupational efforts can be supported.
professional literature (Vergara et al 2006). The specific To date, there has been limited exploration of the concept
occupational therapy role attributes within NICUs vary, but of parenting as an occupation as a means of supporting
service provision may include: parental role development within the NICU. Although the
■ Guidance on positioning of infants to support neuro- birth of a preterm infant that requires admission to an NICU
behavioural regulation (for example, habituation to represents a major crisis for parents that may influence the
external stimuli, motor responses and consolidation of acquisition of their parental role and engagement in parent-
and transition between sleep/wake states) and prevent ing occupations, only one study from within the field of
postural sequelae. Supportive positioning helps to occupational therapy has specifically investigated parental
promote infants’ self-regulation of their autonomic and stress within the NICU and the potential influence on
motor systems and reduces the risk of muscle imbalance parent and infant characteristics (Dudek-Shriber 2004).
leading to, for example, shoulder retraction and hip With the study results indicating that the most stressful
external rotation. aspect of having an infant in an NICU is related to altered
■ Assessment and guidance regarding the infant’s neuro- parental role and relationship with their infant, recommen-
behavioural state – this includes key working with parents dations were made for an ongoing focus of the occupational
in understanding their infant’s neurobehavioural cues therapy profession in facilitating a positive parent-infant
and preparing parents for interaction with their infant relationship and providing intervention that focuses on
■ Early identification and implementation of supportive supporting the parents’ occupational role (Dudek-Shriber
practice and /or intervention for infants identified as 2004). Although this research highlights the contribution
at risk of significant neurodevelopmental sequelae (for that supporting parental occupational role performance may
example, intraventricular haemorrhage and periven- have in reducing stress, and facilitating engagement in
tricular leukomalacia, which may lead to motor, sensory their infant’s care, there is still limited understanding and
and cognitive dysfunction) research on how the concept of occupation may be used to
■ Assessment and support of feeding development (within explore and understand parental experiences in the NICU
North America) and what implications this may have for occupational
■ Follow-up assessment and /or intervention for infants therapy practice in this setting.
born below 1000 grams birth weight, before 29 weeks’
gestation or the presence of other risk factors for neuro- Family-centred care
developmental sequelae. In recognition of the importance of parent-infant attachment,
The type and frequency of services provided is often dependent there has been increasing advocacy for the adoption of
on the multidisciplinary team structure within individual principles of family-centred care in the NICU environment
NICUs and on historical role delineation for individual (Harrison 1993, McGrath and Conliffe-Torres 1996, Sweeney
professions within the team. 1997, Hurst 2001, Moore et al 2003). Many neonatal units
During this period, there has also been ongoing discus- have adopted a family-centred approach to caregiving, in
sion in the literature regarding the skills and competencies which promotion of the parent-infant relationship and family
required by therapists working in this area (AOTA 1993, involvement in the infant’s care are of central importance
Hyde and Jonkey 1994, Dewire et al 1996, Hunter 1996, (Franck and Spencer 2003). Johnson et al (1992) have defined
Gorga et al 2000, Vergara et al 2006), resulting in the family-centred care as a philosophy of care, which:
publication of position papers detailing the knowledge and ■ Recognises and respects the crucial role of the family
skills requirements for occupational therapists in neonatal in relation to the infant’s care
intensive care (Vergara et al 2006). For occupational therapists ■ Supports families by building on their strengths and
providing services in an NICU, this suggests the need to encouraging them to make the best choices
establish a balance between acquiring detailed knowledge ■ Promotes normal patterns of living during a child’s
and skills regarding specific assessment and intervention illness and recovery.
practices, gaining an understanding of neonatal health The philosophy of family-centred care provides a contextual
issues and their required management, and consideration base to the increasing focus within the NICU on supporting
of the underlying occupational issues for these infants and the acquisition of parental occupations.

56 British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2)

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Deanna Gibbs, Kobie Boshoff and Alison Lane

To facilitate the implementation of family-centred family-centred care principles in the provision of neonatal
care within the NICU, a number of principles have been care. While the barriers to family-centred care provision
identified (Harrison 1993, Hurst 2001). First, family-centred exist, it remains difficult for all NICU-based staff to support
care promotes the encouragement of families to participate parents adequately in the acquisition of the role of parent-
as fully as possible in caring for and making decisions ing. Consideration of this issue through a means that allows
about their hospitalised infants. Second, it ensures respect the multifactorial components to be considered in relation
for the diversity of families and their values and beliefs. to each other is required given the complexity of the factors,
This aims to facilitate the development of supportive care which may constrain or enable the provision of family-centred
partnerships in the NICU and beyond (Hurst 2001, care. Occupational therapists, with their understanding of
Malusky 2005, Griffin 2006). core philosophies regarding occupational performance, are
Despite the adoption of care philosophies that recommend in a key position to explore these multifactorial barriers
the use of family-centred care within the NICU, however, and consider how parental occupational performance can
there are still barriers that limit its uptake. Peterson et al be maximised within this setting.
(2004), in a survey of nurses working in NICUs and pae-
diatric intensive care units (PICUs), identified a discrepancy
between the elements of family-centred care that have Understanding parenting
been acknowledged as essential and the reality of what is
executed in practice. The respondents to this survey
occupations: the Person-
employed in PICUs rated the importance and implemen- Environment-Occupation
tation of elements of family-centred care more highly than
those working in NICUs. However, it was also acknowl-
(PEO) Model
edged that this response is influenced by the realisation The consideration of parenting as an occupational role
that infants are typically admitted to an NICU shortly acquired by the parents of preterm infants within an NICU
after birth and there is a perception that there is, provides a context for exploring the complexities of the
therefore, limited time for them to be integrated into the implementation of family-centred care in this environment.
family structure (Peterson et al 2004). Further, the study Occupation is a core domain for the occupational therapy
recognised that the amount of time that NICU nurses profession. As a result, a number of theoretical paradigms
spend with these fragile infants and the relationships that and frames of reference are in use within the profession to
develop over prolonged lengths of hospitalisation may delineate the complex processes that exist between individuals,
pose a conflict to the implementation of family-centred their roles and occupations, and the environments in which
care (Peterson et al 2004). they take place. The Person-Environment-Occupation (PEO)
Qualitative studies that have explored parental percep- Model (Law et al 1996) was developed as a framework
tions of NICU have also served to identify the inconsistencies within which to examine person-environment processes in
in the adoption of family-centred care practices. Cescuti- the context of occupational therapy practice.
Butler and Galvin (2003), in a grounded theory study, The PEO Model has been used as a tool to examine
determined that parents felt that they had failed to integrate complex occupational performance issues in hospital,
into the NICU during their infant’s admission. They were community, academic and research settings (Strong et al
conscious of an implied burden on staff, identifying feel- 1999). Because of the significant impact that the physical
ings of not belonging in the unit and being especially and social NICU environment has had on the provision
careful of staff and staff routines (Cescuti-Butler and Galvin of family-centred care, the PEO Model was selected for
2003). Sweeney (1997), in a personal reflection on an NICU use to explore parental occupational performance in this
and PICU experience, identified factors through which the environment. Strong et al (1999) described the PEO Model
presence or absence of a family-centred care approach had as providing therapists with a practical, analytical tool to
a significant impact on the family experience. Issues such assist in the analysis of problems in occupational perfor-
as involvement in decision making, the provision of infor- mance, to guide intervention planning and evaluation and
mation to orient families to new environments, experiences to communicate clearly occupational therapy practice.
or available supports, the necessity of a two-way information The PEO Model (Law et al 1996) considers human
exchange, consistency of caregiving (both caregivers and care functioning and learning as a product of complex person,
plans) and basic courtesy were experienced as either enabling environment and occupation interactions. The model is
or constraining, based on the attitudes and actions of the conceptualised as the person and his or her environments
health professionals involved (Sweeney 1997). and occupations interacting dynamically over time (Fig. 1,
There has been significant research on and industry Law et al 1996). Law et al (1996) defined occupations as
acknowledgement of the barriers to the implementation clusters of activities in which individuals engage in order
of family-centred care, and subsequently the support of to meet their intrinsic needs for self-maintenance,
the acquisition of the parental role. However, it remains expression and fulfilment. Occupations are then carried
a multifaceted problem that needs to be addressed in order out within the context of individual roles and capacities,
to ensure greater consistency in the implementation of and multiple environments (Law et al 1996). Occupational

British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2) 57

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Understanding parenting occupations in neonatal intensive care: application of the Person-Environment-Occupation Model

Fig. 1. Person-Environment-Occupation (PEO) Model.* when considering the parents of


preterm infants experiencing care
in an NICU. Person in this context
may relate to both the infant and
the family caregivers, which can
include the mother and father of
the preterm infant, both individ-
ually and as a dyad, in addition
to wider extended family contexts
(for example, the involvement of
siblings or grandparents).
In general terms, preterm
infants have limited capabilities
to tolerate stressful or overstimu-
lating environments and they
typically respond in a disorganised
manner (McGrath and Conliffe-
Torres 1996). In infancy, Whitfield
(2003) described preterm infants
as being generally more difficult
to settle, more irritable, and
having less predictable sleep
patterns and poorer emotional
regulation. They have difficulty
*Source: Law M, Cooper B, Strong S, Stewart D, Rigby P, Letts L (1996) The Person-Environment-Occupation in focusing attention selectively
Model: a transactive approach to occupational performance. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 63(1), and are less likely to orient to or
9-23. Reprinted with kind permission of CAOT Publications ACE. spend time exploring novel
stimuli, habituate less efficiently
to visual stimuli, and encode
performance is the outcome of the transaction between the information less efficiently when compared with term-born
person, the environment and the occupation. The extent infants (Whitfield 2003). Therefore, the NICU experience
of the congruence of this transaction is represented by the may be a significant factor disrupting the development of
degree of overlap between the three spheres of the model the infant’s ability to self-regulate his or her autonomic, motor
(Strong et al 1999). and state systems. For example, preterm infants may exhibit
The PEO Model can therefore provide a framework physiological disorganisation (for example, colour change,
within which to consider the acquisition of parenting increased respiratory effort, poor temperature regulation and
occupations in the NICU by understanding the person- disturbed visceral and digestive functioning), difficulties
environment congruence (Law et al 1996). There are a with sustaining relaxed tone and posture, and difficulties
number of interrelated barriers identified in the literature in habituating to their environment (Brazelton and Nugent
that can influence the uptake of family-centred care within 1995). The disruption of self-regulation may result in
the NICU. From these it can be determined that varying subsequent difficulties for parents when trying to establish
factors within an NICU admission may have a constraining opportunities for engaging with their infant.
effect on occupational performance, resulting instead in a Previous studies have also indicated that an infant’s
person-environment incongruence. admission to an NICU can be a period of intense stress for
parents arising from the premature birth and medical
sequelae. Hughes et al (1994), in a phenomenological study,
Occupational analysis of identified common stressors for parents of preterm infants,
including infant appearance, health and course of hospital-
parenting occupations isation, separation from their infant and not feeling like a
From a review of the literature that has explored the uptake of parent, and communication with staff. A qualitative study
family-centred care in NICU, it is apparent that the issues iden- by Wereszczak et al (1997) enabled further identification that
tified within the current body of knowledge can be attributed stress experienced by parents during an NICU admission is
to either a person, environment or occupation factor. attributed to varying sources. These included environmental
stressors such as the infant’s appearance and behaviour,
Person staff behaviour and communication, the sights and sounds
The grounding of the PEO Model in the tenets of client- of the environment and alteration in parental role. Situational
centred care (Strong et al 1999) supports its applicability stressors such as uncertainty, the perception of severity of

58 British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2)

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Deanna Gibbs, Kobie Boshoff and Alison Lane

their infant’s illness and prenatal events also contributed Beginning shortly after conception and continuing into
to parent-identified stress within the NICU. childhood, the brain and nervous system experiences a
Dudek-Shriber (2004), in a quantitative study using a period of rapid growth and maturation between 25 and
parental self-report instrument with 162 parents, confirmed 40 weeks’ gestation. For preterm infants, this period of
that the stress experienced by parents during their infant’s development coincides with a time when the infant is
NICU admission may often be diffuse, with a range of factors likely to be exposed to various environmental stressors
contributing to it. However, the results also indicated that that are developmentally inappropriate and potentially
the subscale in which they reported the greatest stress was harmful to the infant’s sensory systems (McGrath and
related to an altered parental role and relationship with Conliffe-Torres 1996).
their baby. In addition, the degree of stress experienced Families also experience the stress of the highly tech-
by parents needs to be considered. For some parents, their nological environment. They encounter life-sustaining
response in the NICU situation has been aligned with post- equipment, monitors, multiple tubes and intravenous lines,
traumatic stress reactions (Holditch-Davis et al 2003). intrusions by multiple caregivers and an overwhelming
Contributing to experiences of parental stress are the limita- fear of the unknown, which can serve to create physical and
tions to the development of situational control, with parents emotional barriers between a preterm infant and his or
wanting and needing to be given opportunities to experience her family (McGrath and Conliffe-Torres 1996, Miles and
a sense of ownership and control within the intensive care Holditch-Davis 1997, Byers 2003). These environmental
unit in relation to their infant rather than remaining on stressors can prove an immediate barrier in enabling
the periphery of his or her care (Fenwick et al 2001). parents to engage readily with their infants.
The parents of preterm infants all present with individ- Supporting parental involvement and promoting family-
ualised experiences, which bring them to a common point centred care approaches can also be significantly influenced
of their infant’s admission to an NICU. So, although by the social environment that exists within the NICU,
guidelines for the implementation of family-centred care particularly in consideration of the relationships between
have been developed, they may not take into account the parents and health care providers in the NICU. Fenwick
journey that these individuals have experienced in becoming et al (2001), in their study involving 28 mothers of pre-
the parent of a preterm infant and, therefore, the need for term infants, described parent-staff interactions as either
the implementation of a care model that supports their facilitative or inhibitive. Staff that provided facilitative
individualised needs as parents and a family. interaction were perceived by mothers as collaborators in
their infant’s care, who provided enhanced opportunities
Environment for them to be with their infants in a meaningful way,
The PEO Model considers the environment as the context such as through participation in routine caregiving and
within which the occupational performance of an individual opportunities for holding their infant; however, staff who
takes place. Environmental contexts are not static and can were perceived as inhibitive displayed behaviours that
have an enabling or constraining effect on occupational restricted maternal efforts to achieve a sense of physical
performance (Law et al 1996). Therefore, the addition of closeness with their infants (Fenwick et al 2001). Conflict
an unanticipated technological environment such as the between parents and staff can result in a variety of parental
NICU, in which occupational role development occurs behaviours as they attempt to regain some control over
may have a significant influence on how the occupation of parenting their infant. These may include vigilance in
parenting is acquired and performed. In this context, the watching over their baby, safeguarding him or her from
environment may include not only the physical aspects of harm, feelings of disaffection as a result of the communi-
the environment, including the design of the unit, lighting cation with staff, a guarding of communication style and a
and medical equipment, but also the staff with which parents fear of reprisals or recrimination if they speak out about
may interact as a key component of that environment. their infant’s care (Lasby et al 1994, Fenwick et al 2001).
The physical environment of the NICU is a significant These studies have begun to explore and articulate commu-
source of stress for preterm infants and their families. The nication styles that facilitate the development of parent-
NICU is a milieu in which infants consistently encounter infant attachment. However, the strategies and recommen-
overwhelming stimuli, including bright lights, loud noises, dations aimed at increasing facilitative interaction are
excessive handling by multiple caregivers and intrusive reported in generalist terms. The transfer of these recom-
and uncomfortable treatment interventions (McGrath and mendations into clear guidelines for practice is not yet
Conliffe-Torres 1996). It involves a barrage of factors for evident (Beveridge et al 2001, Peterson et al 2004).
which the preterm infant is not developmentally prepared. Although research to date has focused predominantly
Factors influencing the infant’s status include illness on parental perceptions of their communication with staff,
severity, noise, light, repetitive pain, exposure to analgesia, a study has also been conducted which investigated health
sedation and other drugs, and separation from normal care staff’s perceptions of the dyadic relationships that are
maternal interaction, including touch, smell, sucking and formed between staff and parents in the NICU. Walker
voice (Whitfield 2003). Prematurity disrupts the normal (1998), in a survey of 298 neonatal nurses, determined that
growth and development of the brain and nervous system. 90% of respondents did not believe that any of the care

British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2) 59

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Understanding parenting occupations in neonatal intensive care: application of the Person-Environment-Occupation Model

practices or policies/procedures of the NICU contributed Christiansen (1999) supported the facilitatory influence
to the barriers that confronted parents in the acquisition of occupation on the person, with the suggestion that the
of parenting roles and skills. This indicates that there is performance of occupations is a means of creating and
potential for limitations in understanding the implications maintaining identities. This, therefore, is an important
of staff caregiving practices on parental role acquisition, component to consider in relation to parenting within an
since the aforementioned studies have indicated clearly that NICU. Difficulties exist for parents attempting to consolidate
such an influence exists from the perspective of parents. their self-identity, resulting from limitations in access to
Given that health care staff act as gatekeepers in parents’ their infant and the restrictions that they encounter in
access to their infants in the NICU, the development of a engaging in activities that they anticipated and identified
positive collaborative relationship between parents and as being a parent. Christiansen (1999) introduced the
staff is important in supporting family-centred care. concept of ‘possible selves’. Possible selves are imagined
views of our future identities and give meaning and
Occupation structure to an individual’s thoughts about the future.
Occupation is defined as ‘groups of self-directed, functional This is congruent with parental perceptions of their
tasks and activities in which a person engages over the NICU experience, where they identify the loss of their
lifespan … clusters of activities as tasks in which the person anticipated parenting role (Wereszczak et al 1997); that is,
engages in order to meet his/ her intrinsic needs for self- activities such as feeding, bathing and dressing their
maintenance, expression and fulfilment’ (Law et al 1996, infant that they identified throughout their pregnancy,
p16). The ability to engage in a cluster of activities that are which supported their imagined identity of being a parent,
identifiable as parenting occupations in the NICU may be were not available to them. Hammell (2004) suggested
necessarily limited due to the infant’s fragility and the nature that the loss of the ability to participate in occupations
of the highly intensive care support that he or she is receiving. that are important to individuals can erase perceptions of
The contrast between actual and anticipated parenting capability and competence.
experiences is an additional constraining factor to parental
involvement in the care of an infant. The parents of pre-
term infants have lost many of the usual rituals that are Person-environment-occupation
associated with the birth of a new baby, such as leaving
hospital with the baby and receiving congratulations on transactions in an NICU:
the baby’s birth. Lasby et al (1994) identified that the loss implications for practice
of these expected maternal events make it difficult to gain
acknowledgement of motherhood, which creates difficulty In considering the rich information currently available
in the establishment of meaningful moments between that delineates the person, environment and occupation
parent and infant. Findlay (1997), in her discussion of aspects of the NICU experience for preterm infants and
the adaptation process experienced by parents of preterm their families, the PEO Model can be used to consider
infants, includes descriptions of parental experience of how the development of occupational performance can
pregnancies ending prematurely and the commencement of be facilitated. By exploring the transactions that may
a process of adjusting to unanticipated situations. Parents of occur between each aspect of the model, focusing on the
preterm infants are subsequently required to develop their person-occupation, occupation-environment and person-
parenting skills in the very public domain of the NICU. This, environment relationships (Strong et al 1999), it may be
in itself, may be problematic due to the acknowledged possible for occupational therapists to identify strategies
barriers that exist to parenting in the NICU, such as the that could serve to overcome the barriers and support
physical environment, the mismatch between parents and optimal occupational performance when working with
their infant in terms of readiness for interaction, the individual families.
inability to provide all of their infant’s caregiving, and Occupational therapy as a profession is concerned with
the support of staff regarding parental competence in assisting individuals to participate in the chosen occupations
caregiving (Gale and Franck 1998). that are necessary for health, development and quality of
Miles and Holditch-Davis (1997), in their development life (Parham and Primeau 1997). In the critical care
of a conceptual framework relating to the needs of parents context of an NICU, this perspective can be diminished in
in an NICU, identified that the loss of the anticipated importance owing to the primary focus on components of
parental or caregiving role can leave parents with feelings infant functioning and survival. Opportunities exist to
of helplessness, struggling for opportunities in which to determine how both the infants’ and parents’ occupational
exert their parental role. This framework was confirmed efforts can be enabled and supported (Holloway 1998).
in a subsequent study, in which 25 of 31 mothers who The areas of PEO transactions would serve as a starting
participated in the study reported that their loss of the point for exploring how parental occupational performance
anticipated role contributed to difficulties in developing within the NICU context may be enabled.
positions as advocates and decision makers on behalf of The application of the PEO Model in relation to the
their children (Holditch-Davis and Miles 2000). context of parenting in the NICU is illustrated in Fig. 2.

60 British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2)

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Deanna Gibbs, Kobie Boshoff and Alison Lane

Fig. 2. Analysis of the potential person-environment-occupation transactions in NICU.* can be a significant barrier to
occupational engagement. When
planning care, consideration
also needs to be given to:
■ The availability of opportuni-
ties for parents to be engaged
in caregiving activities
■ Parents’ fear about being
involved in the care of their
infant and not wishing to
harm their baby
■ Parents’ previous experience
and confidence in the perfor-
mance of caregiving activities,
such as bathing and feeding,
and how these can be best
enabled.

Supporting parental
occupational adaptation
Within each of the elements of
person, environment and occupa-
tion, barriers exist that are diffi-
cult to remediate. For example,
NICU = neonatal intensive care unit. depending on the structure and
*Source: Adapted from: Strong S, Rigby P, Stewart D, Law M, Letts L, Cooper B (1999) Application of operational functioning of an
the Person-Environment-Occupation Model: a practical tool. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, NICU, the moderation of some
66(3), 122-33. Adapted and reprinted with kind permission from CAOT Publications ACE. environment factors, such as
unit design and lighting policies,
may be limited. However, bedside
Occupation-environment transactions factors, such as the management of incubator covers, alarms
Within the NICU, occupation-environment transactions are and voice level, are able to be moderated through collaborative
clearly evident. As a result of the intensive medical support staff efforts. Similarly, the types of medical and technological
required by the infant, occupational engagement will be intervention required to support the infant are beyond the
limited by the physical barriers of medical equipment in control of the occupational therapist. However, what can
the unit, such as the infant being ventilated or nursed in be considered is how best to support parents’ occupational
an incubator. As outlined earlier, the social environment adaptation to this environment. Providing an intervention
of the NICU may also have an impact on the fluency of approach that includes consistent and understandable
occupation-environment transactions. explanations regarding equipment function, clearly identifying
and making available opportunities for parents to participate
Person-environment transactions in safe but meaningful contact with their infants, and
Person-environment transactions can also be present. equipping parents to interpret their infants’ state regulation
These can include the local visiting hours and regulations in relation to timeliness of interaction can all have a positive
for the unit that may inhibit parents’ participation in care- effect on the person-environment transaction and, ultimately,
giving activities. Owing to the tertiary nature of NICUs, the parents’ occupational role development.
many infants are admitted to units that are geographically The development of evidence-based neonatal care
distant to their parents’ home, making regular visiting approaches, such as the Newborn Individualised Develop-
difficult. Within the social environment, consideration mental Care and Assessment Programme (NIDCAP) (Lawhon
needs to be given to the support provided by NICU staff 2002, Als 2008), has been key in supporting multidiscipli-
for parents to assume a caregiving role for their infants. nary NICU-based staff in the provision of a highly individ-
This includes the communication style undertaken by ualised developmentally supportive care approach for
health care providers and whether this is perceived by preterm infants. The aim of individualised developmentally
parents as facilitative or inhibitive. supportive care models, such as NIDCAP, is to alter the
focus of neonatal care from the traditional task-oriented or
Person-occupation transactions procedure-oriented approach to a focus on processes and
Within the person-occupation transactional area, the manage- relationships, including the increased involvement of
ment of the infant’s fragile medical status during caregiving families (Westrup 2007). The NIDCAP approach is based

British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2) 61

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Understanding parenting occupations in neonatal intensive care: application of the Person-Environment-Occupation Model

on the premise that infants’ own behaviour provides the


necessary information in order to determine their current Key findings
capabilities. It is a comprehensive programme, involving ■ The PEO Model provides a structure for considering parenting
structured behavioural observation of the infant and the occupations in the NICU.
provision of individualised caregiving support of the infant’s ■ The use of an occupation-focused approach in the NICU ensures that
developmental goals (VandenBerg 2007). The ongoing both the preterm infant and his or her family’s needs are recognised
process of NIDCAP supports continual adjustment of the and addressed.
environment and caregiving practices in light of the infant’s
and parents’ developmental needs (VandenBerg 2007). What the study has added
NICUs that have adopted a NIDCAP approach are more This review provides an understanding of parental occupations in NICUs
able not only to be truly responsive to the needs of infants and supports occupational therapists in their promotion of family-centred
with a resulting impact on developmental outcome but also care in this setting.
to centralise the role of an infant’s family and address the
PEO transactions inherent in the NICU admission. Successful
implementation of individualised developmental care requires AOTA. Neonatal Intensive Care Unit Taskforce (1993) Knowledge and skills
the full commitment of NICU staff at all levels and provides for occupational therapy practice in the neonatal intensive care unit.
a significant shift in how health services address the needs of American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 47(12), 1100-05.
this client group (VandenBerg 2007, Westrup 2007). However, Beveridge J, Bodnaryk K, Ramahandran C (2001) Family-centred care in
like family-centred care, the uptake of NIDCAP and other the NICU. Canadian Nurse, 97(3), 14-18.
developmental care approaches has remained inconsistent. Brazelton TB, Nugent JK (1995) The Neonatal Behavioural Assessment Scale.
The PEO Model provides a structure through which an 3rd ed. Clinics in Developmental Medicine No. 137. London: Mac Keith Press.
understanding of how each infant and his or her family Browne JV (2003) New perspectives on premature infants and their parents.
accommodates to the NICU experience can be achieved Zero to Three, November, 4-12.
and, more specifically, can be used to direct occupational Byers JF (2003) Components of developmental care and the evidence for their
therapy practice in focusing on family-centred care and use in the NICU. American Journal of Maternal Child Nursing, 28(3), 174-82.
the development of occupational performance. Therefore, Cescuti-Butler L, Galvin K (2003) Parents’ perceptions of staff competency in
although the types of occupational therapy intervention a neonatal intensive care unit. Journal of Clinical Nursing, 12, 752-61.
outlined at the beginning of this paper are a key element of Christiansen C (1999) Defining lives: occupation as identity: an essay on
neonatal service provision, the use of an occupation-based competence, coherence and the creation of meaning. American Journal
approach can provide a means through which practice can of Occupational Therapy, 53(6), 547-58.
be enhanced by ensuring that both the infant’s and the Dewire A, White D, Kanny E, Glass R (1996) Education and training of
family’s needs are recognised and addressed. occupational therapists for neonatal intensive care units. American
Journal of Occupational Therrapy, 50(7), 486-94.
Dudek-Shriber L (2004) Parent stress in the neonatal intensive care unit
and the influence of parent and infant characteristics. American Journal
Conclusion of Occupational Therapy, 58(5), 509-20.
The consideration of parenting as an occupational role for Fenwick J, Barclay L, Schmied V (2001) Struggling to mother: a consequence
the parents of preterm infants within an NICU would appear of inhibitive nursing interactions in the neonatal nursery. Journal of
to allow the emergence of an understanding of the person- Perinatal and Neonatal Nursing, 15(2), 49-64.
environment influences on occupational performance. By Findlay MP (1997) Parenting a hospitalised preterm infant: a phenomenological
improving understanding of the parental occupations in study. (Unpublished PhD thesis.) Birmingham, AL: University of Alabama
the NICU, the provision of facilitatory or enabling service at Birmingham.
frameworks may be considered. As outlined, the PEO Model Franck LS, Spencer C (2003) Parent visiting and participation in infant
may therefore provide a new and systematic means of caregiving activities in a neonatal unit. Birth, 30(1), 31-35.
addressing an ongoing issue in the care of preterm infants Gale G, Franck LS (1998) Toward a standard of care for parents of infants
and their families. Through the use of this approach, in the neonatal intensive care unit. Critical Care Nurse, 18(5), 62-74.
occupational therapists working within NICU environments Gavey N (2007) Parental perceptions of neonatal care. Journal of Neonatal
have the potential both to support significantly the use of Nursing, 13, 199-206.
family-centred care approaches and to promote occupational Gorga D (1994) The evolution of occupational therapy practice for infants
adaptation with the parents of preterm infants. in the neonatal intensive care unit. American Journal of Occupational
Therapy, 48(6), 487-89.
References Gorga D, Anzalone M, Holloway E, Bigsby R, Hunter J, Strzyzewski S,
Als H (2008) Assessing preterm infants’ behaviour and providing individualised Vergara E (2000) Specialised knowledge and skills for occupational
developmental care: introduction to APIB and NIDCAP. In: Contemporary therapy practice in the neonatal intensive care unit. American Journal
Forums. Developmental Interventions in Neonatal Care. 24th annual of Occupational Therapy, 54(6), 641-48.
conference. 2-4 October 2008, Denver, USA. Conference Guide. Dublin, Griffin T (2006) Family-centred care in the NICU. Journal of Perinatal and
CA: Contemporary Forums, 54. Neonatal Nursing, 20(1), 98-102.

62 British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2)

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016


Deanna Gibbs, Kobie Boshoff and Alison Lane

Hammell KW (2004) Dimensions of meaning in the occupations of daily life. Malusky SK (2005) A concept analysis of family-centred care in the NICU.
Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, 71(5), 296-305. Neonatal Network, 24(6), 25-32.
Harrison H (1993) The principles of family-centred neonatal care. Pediatrics, McGrath JM, Conliffe-Torres S (1996) Integrating family-centred developmental
92(5), 643-50. assessment and intervention into routine care in the neonatal intensive
Holditch-Davis D, Miles MS (2000) Mothers’ stories about their experiences care unit. Nursing Clinics of North America, 31(2), 367-86.
in the neonatal intensive care unit. Neonatal Network, 19(3), 13-21. Miles MS, Holditch-Davis D (1997) Parenting the prematurely born infant:
Holditch-Davis D, Bartlett R, Blickman AK, Miles MS (2003) Post-traumatic pathways of influence. Seminars in Perinatology, 21(3), 254-66.
stress symptoms on mothers of premature infants. Journal of Obstetric, Moore KAC, Coker K, DuBuisson AB, Swett B, Edwards WH (2003) Implementing
Gynaecological and Neonatal Nursing, 32(2), 161-71. potentially better practices for improving family-centred care in neonatal
Holloway E (1998) Relationship-based occupational therapy in the neonatal intensive care units: successes and challenges. Pediatrics, 111(4), 450-60.
intensive care unit. In: J Case-Smith, ed. Paediatric occupational therapy Parham LD, Primeau L (1997) Play and occupational therapy. In: LD Parham,
and early intervention. Boston: Butterworth-Heinemann, 111-26. LS Fazio, eds. Play in occupational therapy. New York: Mosby, 2-21.
Howland LC (2007) Preterm birth: implications for family stress and coping. Peterson MF, Cohen J, Parsons V (2004) Family-centred care: do we practice
Newborn and Infant Nursing Reviews, 7(1), 14-19. what we preach? Journal of Obstetric, Gynaecological and Neonatal
Hughes M, McCollum J, Sheftel D, Sanchez G (1994) How parents cope Nursing, 33, 421-27.
with the experience of neonatal intensive care. Children’s Health Care, Strong S, Rigby P, Stewart D, Law M, Letts L, Cooper B (1999) Application
23(1), 1-14. of the Person-Environment-Occupation Model: a practical tool. Canadian
Hunter J (1996) Clinical interpretation of ‘education and training of Journal of Occupational Therapy, 66(3), 122-33.
occupational therapists for neonatal intensive care units’. American Sweeney MM (1997) The value of a family-centred approach in the NICU
Journal of Occupational Therapy, 50(7), 495-503. and PICU: one family’s perspective. Pediatric Nursing, 23(1), 64-66.
Hurst I (2001) Vigilant watching over: mother’s actions to safeguard their Thomas LM (2008) The changing role of parents in neonatal care: a historical
premature babies in the newborn intensive care nursery. Journal of review. Neonatal Network, 27(2), 91-100.
Perinatal and Neonatal Nursing, 15(3), 39-57. VandenBerg KA (2007) Individualised developmental care for high risk
Hyde AS, Jonkey BW (1994) Developing competency in the neonatal intensive newborns in the NICU: a practice guideline. Early Human Development,
care unit: a hospital training program. American Journal of Occupational 83(7), 433-42.
Therapy, 48(6), 539-45. Vergara E, Anzalone M, Bigsby R, Gorga D, Holloway E, Hunter J, Laadt G,
Johnson BH, Jeppson ES, Redburn L (1992) Caring for children and families: Strzyewski S, 2005 Neonatal Intensive Care Unit Taskforce (2006) Specialized
guidelines for hospitals. Bethesda, MD: Association for the Care of knowledge and skills for occupational therapy practice in the neonatal
Children’s Health. intensive care unit. American Journal of Occupational Therapy, 60(6), 659-68.
Lasby K, Newton S, Sherrow T, Stainton MC, McNeill D (1994) Maternal work Walker SB (1998) Neonatal nurses’ views on the barriers to parenting in the
in the NICU: a case-study of an ‘NICU-experienced’ mother. Issues in intensive care nursery – a national study. Australian Critical Care, 11(3),
Comprehensive Pediatric Nursing, 17, 147-60. 86-91.
Law M, Cooper B, Strong S, Stewart D, Rigby P, Letts L (1996) The Wereszczak J, Miles MS, Holditch-Davis D (1997) Maternal recall of the
Person-Environment-Occupation Model: a transactive approach to neonatal intensive care unit. Neonatal Network, 16(4), 33-40.
occupational performance. Canadian Journal of Occupational Therapy, Westrup B (2007) Newborn Individualised Developmental Care and
63(1), 9-23. Assessment Program (NIDCAP) – family-centered developmentally
Lawhon G (2002) Facilitation of parenting the premature infant within the supportive care. Early Human Development, 83(7), 443-49.
newborn intensive care unit. Journal of Perinatal and Neonatal Nursing, Whitfield MF (2003) Psychosocial effects of intensive care on infants and
16(1), 71-82. families after discharge. Seminars in Neonatology, 8, 185-93.

British Journal of Occupational Therapy February 2010 73(2) 63

Downloaded from bjo.sagepub.com at UNIVERSITE LAVAL on May 4, 2016

You might also like