Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/366386152
CITATIONS READS
0 1,638
6 authors, including:
All content following this page was uploaded by Shivangi Singh Parmar on 31 January 2023.
1
Centre of Excellence for Indian Knowledge Systems, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, India
2
Department of Architecture and Regional Planning, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, India
3
RCG School of Infrastructure Design and Management, Indian Institute of Technology Kharagpur, India
Abstract
Cities have witnessed rapid growth, and smaller towns rapidly grow into cities. In India, Udaipur is a city of rich
cultural heritage and has been a political power with a strategic topographical location in the Mewar region of
Rajasthan state. Primarily renowned as a tourist destination for its lake water system and built heritage interface
depicting the exemplary creations of the rulers of Mewar. The region's ancient history is contemporary with the
Indus Valley Civilisation with the archaeological discovery of towns belonging to the Ahar-Banas Culture tradition.
However, in recent years with a rise in heritage tourism, the city has been experiencing adverse effects of rapid
urbanisation and gentrification. The paper attempts to outline the city's evolution and understand the interplay of
the Aravalli Ranges, the water system formed by linking seven lakes, the traditional socio-cultural systems, and
how the urban fabric has resulted in the present-day form and aided the expansion of Udaipur. The paper also
assesses the formal indicators of the city in the context of the present legislative framework. Finally, it infers that
sustainable, smart, and resilient infrastructure with a sensitive eye to the details of rich cultural heritage is the
future of historic towns and cities like Udaipur, not only to add value to the citizens but also to help conserve its
rich heritage.
1. Introduction
Cities, around the world, possess distinctive characteristics and uniqueness in their origin, growth, and
development trajectories. Owing to diversity in their natural setting, size, physical form, and functions, cities
represent dynamics of urban evolution with a unique identity and urban image which can be seen in the city’s past,
present, and future as well (Salehi et al., 2012). India, with a long history of urbanization, shows a complex and
diversified form of urban system where the establishment, evolution, and historical trajectories of each urban
center is distinctive, evolved through successive phases of the historical past by profound human interaction with
the society, culture, economy and political environment. Hence in order to understand the evolving nature of the
city, it must be contextualized in the light of history and in reference to the resultant complex relationship among
socio-economic, environmental processes, and practices (Tonkiss, 2013).
Indian cities have evolved over time witnessing kingship, invasions, urban centers, architectural marvels, socio-
economic development, and many more. The present study focuses on the city of Udaipur, which was once an
important Indian medieval historic city that emerged in the middle of the 16th century. It was also a dominant
centre of political power and administration in the Mewar region. It has now grown into a multi-functional city
acting as a major mining, educational, recreational, and tourism hub. The picturesque landscape has made this
small city possible to grow into a popular tourist destination that boasts over 244 hotels and 941 restaurants of
various sizes, leading tourism as a prime industry (The Hindu, 2016). In 2016, Udaipur was taken under the
‘Smart City Mission’ with an aim to make the city smart, sustainable and to preserve and restore the deep cultural
and natural heritage that the city is associated with.
The city represents a unique urban fabric having a co-existence of the built landscape and natural infrastructure.
The built form in Udaipur is “a result of evolution that has been guided by dominant determinants such as
socioeconomic hierarchy/structure, political and religious factors, climate, availability of material and
technology” (Quoted Jain, 1998). Owing to this co-existence of built and natural heritage, the image of the city has
been formed by two dominant identities that the city is known for and hence, commonly referred to as a ‘historic
city’ and ‘The City of Lakes. The historic identity can easily be visible in the symbolic architecture and royal
heritage of dynasties in the forms of royal palaces, havelis (large residences), temples and the natural identity lies
over the spectacular beauty of inter-connected lake systems and waterfront developments.
Drawing over the formal characteristics (topography and physiography) of the city and its region, the paper
reflects on the evolution of Udaipur from the historical and ecological context because any understanding of the
city related to growth and development dynamics would not be possible without considering the long-past history
of political influences of Rajput dynasty and its connection with broader ecological and hydrological importance
of the Aravallis and major lakes systems. The paper first outlines the broader physiographic setting of the region,
followed by the analysis of the historical backdrop under political and development dynamics, development of
water infrastructure, and environmental significance, and finally looks at the present context from sustainability.
2. Physiographic Setting
The city of Udaipur in the Udaipur District is located in southeast Rajasthan, India (see Figure 1). It is surrounded
by the Aravalli Ranges and is located in a saucer-shaped valley in the Mewar Region amongst the other districts
like Chittorgarh, Rajsamand, Dungarpur, Banswara, and Bhilwara districts. The Mewar region has a “dendritic”
form of drainage pattern which spreads throughout the region catering to different parts of the area (Singh et al.,
2018). The River Ayad (Ahar River) is one of the major rivers that flow through the city in the southeast direction
and it is a non-perenial river. It is a tributary of the Berach River and ends in the Udaisagar Lake situated in the
southeast part of the city. The city is known for its various lakes that were built throughout time for consumption
and agricultural activities stored for the dry season primarily. However, in present times apart from the
aforementioned functions, the lake system has many more sectors to cater to like tourism, industries, etc. The
lakes comprise the Fateh Sagar Lake, Lake Pichola and many more. The geological makeup of the region includes
rocks like “schist, phyllite, quartzite, and granite gneiss”, known as hard rocks and the porosity of these rocks is
lacking. The water system of the area is fed primarily through rainwater during the monsoon periods.
Groundwater resources are therefore dependent on the type of rocks present in the area thereby dictating the
hydrogeological character of the region (Machiwal et al., 2010). The climate of Udaipur is that of a “warm semi-
arid type” which can be defined by its humid conditions during the monsoon season which distinguishes it from
the arid climate of east Rajasthan. The highest temperatures in the Udaipur District vary (Meteorological Center,
2013) from 35 Degree Celsius to 42 Degree Celsius whereas the lowest temperatures vary from 5 Degree Celsius
to 10 Degree Celsius. The average rainfall of the district is approximately 587 mm. High variability in the number
of days and the amount of rainfall can be observed in the Udaipur District.
4. Ecological Evolution
The ecological characteristics of Udaipur and its surrounding regions have contributed to a great extent
concerning the location and its establishment as the capital of the Mewar Region. The sprawl of the city can be
attributed to the plain terrain in the aforementioned directions against the undulating terrain in the other directions
for agricultural purposes, the presence of the Ayad (Ahar) River for water resources, and the construction of the
National Highways for connectivity within and outside the region. Presently, due to easier access to other regions
and improvements in infrastructural facilities the city has started growing in the southern regions of the lakes as
well (Gangani et al., 2017). However before the advent of major urbanisation consequences on the city fabric,
majorly, two characteristics of the region that is the Aravalli Ranges and the elaborate Lake System have aided in
the evolution of the city to current times and they still do.
The city is cradled in a saucer-shaped valley surrounded by the Aravalli. Additionally one of the most pivotal
reasons for establishing Udaipur as the capital of the Mewar Region was due to the Pichola Lake, which was seen
as a source of water for the inhabitants. Consequently, artificial lakes were constructed by various rulers of the
region, which now defines the city as having an elaborate water system. The lakes were built to initially support
the populace during times of water shortage and for agriculture. However, with the rapid evolution in the
economic realm, other sectors are presently highly dependent on the water system, hence the water ecology of the
region has been evolving throughout the years (see Figure 3). Udaipur is also renowned for its well-established
water resource management system. The idea of watershed management can be seen to have been applied by Rana
Udai Singh II in Udai Sagar Lake. Fateh Sagar and Swaroop Sagar can also be described as small watershed areas
that were constructed by following rulers for usage.
Source: Authors and Base map of Udaipur used: Urban Improvement Trust,
https://urban.rajasthan.gov.in/content/raj/udh/uit-udaipur/en/town-planning/key-maps-.htm
Due to the high variability of rainfall in the region, sustainable measures were taken up to store water for the
population of the Mewar Region. The waters of the Ayad (Ahar) River were channelised to Fateh Sagar Lake by
Maharana Fateh Singh and similarly, the waters of Ubeshwar River were drained through the Morvani River by
Rana Raj Singh I, both depicting the ideas of linking rivers to lakes and river diversion technique respectively
(Rathore, 2010). From the 6th century, the rulers of the Mewar Region have been very mindful of the needs of the
people and these interventions have enabled Udaipur to stand the test of time in the following years.
The ripple effect of urbanisation in the regions of Mewar is negatively affecting the precious and well-preserved
water system in various ways. The thriving tourism population is now increasing the water demand against the
stipulated water supply for the population. Policies and interventions have been set in place, to increase the water
supply by bringing water from the rural areas which are otherwise using the water for agricultural purposes.
Additionally, various industries are disposing untreated water in the Ayad (Ahar) River which feeds various lakes,
therefore degrading the quality of the water (Heinrich Boll Foundation, 2018). It has been noted that in recent
years the Pichola Lake dries up, and also the lakes in Udaipur are shrinking in size due to the anthropogenic
activities, which serves as an important harbinger of the consequences of the degrading Aravalli Range on the
Mewar region including Udaipur city.
The ecological dynamics of the Udaipur region have played and continue to play an important role in the
evolution of the city as an entity and as a part of the Mewar region. The consequences of rapid urbanisation have
started to materialise in the form of threats to the ecological mechanism of the city and its people. It is therefore
still important for authorities and the people to take into consideration the region and its biodiversity in the pursuit
of a smart and sustainable city or region. The interplay of the Aravalli Ranges, the water system of the city, the
traditional systems, and the way the urban and rural fabric is developing have to be dutifully pursued for a
sustainable future for Udaipur.
• Traditional water system infrastructure including man-made lakes, water tanks/baolis for rainwater
harvesting, and its connection with the existing river systems are present.
• The city is strategically located in terms of topography like the natural fortification of the Aravalli Hills in
the west and on its windward side of the Thar desert.
• The historic city has witnessed power struggles but managed to continue its lineage and protection from
the Mughals and the Marathas.
Weakness
• Due to non-functional traditional water infrastructure, piped city-wide water distribution system was
introduced to meet the needs of the population explosion and growth of the city.
• There is a lack of heritage-sensitive modern development in the historic city. Modern construction/
restoration does not reflect the traditional Mewari architectural character of the old city.
• Heritage tourism and its ancillary expansions are on a verge of transforming the identity/character of the
old city.
Opportunities
• Rich cultural heritage like forts, palaces, walled city, bazaars (markets), havelis (large residences), lakes
in the city, and also the Mewar region gives the opportunity for the promotion of heritage tourism circuit
and revenue generation, thereby boosting the local economy.
• Promotion of ancient Ahar civilization for tourist attraction can be propagated.
• A better water interface development for the tourist through improvement in sewage and sanitation
network can be encouraged.
Threats
• The rise in water pollution in the lakes is due to the traditional systems being gradually non-functional.
• The rivers like Ahar, once the main source of water supply to the old city is slowly getting converted into
a Nala (drain) with improper sewage and solid waste management.
• Loss of traditional Mewari architectural character in the old city can be observed.
• The desertification of the Aravalli is impacting the climate of the city.
• Natural rainwater harvesting measures like the step-wells/baolis are on the verge of depletion.
In order to understand the evolution of the city, from its functionality in the historic context to its operation in
contemporary times it is significant to draw a comparison of the city in terms of design, ecology, and
sustainability. A comparative chart showing the evolution of the city in terms of its historic planning, modern
interventions – the Government schemes and policies, and its impact on a sustainable future has been provided
below.
Sl. The historic city as designed Govt. Schemes and policies Impact on the Sustainable
No. future
1. The walled city of Udaipur was AMRUT Mission has looked into An integrated water
designed by the Mewar Kings the improvement of water supply, management plan for the city
with water infrastructures like sewerage and drainage systems of will cater to the future needs of
lakes, baolis/water tanks the historic city. the city and make it sustainable.
(rainwater harvesting), and a
drainage system in line with the
natural terrain/slope.
2. A historic city with built and Udaipur Smart City Mission The preservation and
natural heritage like City Palace, includes projects like rejuvenation sustainability of a historic city
the bazaars (market), and the of nalas (drains), restoration of city taking into account the local
Lake Pichola is the major gates, lakefront development, and community is a significant step.
components of the walled city. façade improvement in the historic
bazaars (markets).
3. Udaipur is known as the city of National Lake Conservation Plan Rejuvenation of the water
lakes, a lake water ecosystem. (NLCP) includes improvement of infrastructure and biodiversity
water quality, biodiversity conservation is an important
conservation and ecosystem step towards a sustainable
rejuvenation. future.
4. Udaipur is a historic city in the Inclusive revitalization of Udaipur, Revitalization of the historic
Mewar Region and is Strategic Framework, Govt. of city and connecting it with the
surrounded by the Aravalli Hills Rajasthan. important cities in the region
in the western side. through a tourist circuit will
re-establish the glory of the
Mewar region. There should be
policies for regulating
uncontrolled developments like
mining activities etc in the
Aravalli Ranges on a regional
level.
5. Udaipur is a city rich in cultural The vision and mission of Udaipur Comprehensive solid waste
infrastructure with its tangible Municipal Corporation include management, conservation of
and intangible attributes lake conservation, preservation of cultural identity, and efficient
depicting the glorious age of the the old city, efficient citizen-centric urban governance are
Kings of Mewar. governance, smart resilient significant.
infrastructure, and tourism boost
for revenue.
The threats to the city of Udaipur in context to rapid urbanization, tourism boom, economic development and
accommodating the population explosion have been taken into consideration in the present Government schemes
and policies. It looks into the preservation of the identity of the city with a sustainable approach. A revitalization
framework of Government of Rajasthan also takes into account the prominent historic towns and villages in the
Mewar region and connecting the dots of the thread through a tourism circuit.
5. Way Forward
The development of the city of Udaipur was always of a sustainable kind where the rulers of the region were
aware of its ecological importance, thereby influencing the historical evolution through time. The traditional
techniques of sustainably catering to the population without harming the ecology like the water system of the
region have been forgotten down the line as urbanisation followed. Government authorities and organisations are
now able to notice the pressures of the same and policies are being implemented to tackle them. However doing
this without the participation of the traditional systems and lessons would disregard the historical and the
ecological importance of the city with which it started off. It would be beneficial to identify areas of intervention
where there is a need for immediate action and also integrate the traditional and newer mechanisms from a
bottom-up approach where the identity of Udaipur remains intact and true to its roots. Historic towns like Udaipur
are cyclic in nature in context to evolution and functionality. It originated with formal indicators (topography and
physiography of the region) dictating the nature of the city, and now the functional indicators (economy,
demography, culture etc) play an important role in defining the development of the city. However, we are again
moving toward preserving the formal indicators amidst improving the functional ones for a sustainable future.
Sustainable, smart, and resilient infrastructure with a sensitive eye to the details of rich cultural heritage is the
future of historic towns and cities like Udaipur.
References
1) Salehi, F., Samani, A. E., Jafari, E., & Irani Behbahani, H. Urban landscape planning and design for
the interface conflict between urban development and landscape in historic cities–a case study:
Isfahan city in Iran. International Journal of. Technical and Physical Problems in Engineering. 2012,
pp. 122-127.
2) Tonkiss, F. Cities by design. Cambridge: Polity Press, 2013
3) The Hindu. Udaipur: Heritage city has a tryst with modernity.
2016,
https://www.thehindubusinessline.com/specials/udaipur-heritage-city-has-a-tryst-with-modernity/-article8
314685.ece,accessed on 24th march, 2022
4) Jain, K.B. Udaipur: The City and its Elements Monograph One, School of Architecture, CEPT,
Ahmedabad, India. 1998.
5) Singh, N., Parthasarathy, D., Narayanan, N. C.; Contested Urban Waterscape of Udaipur, Sustainable
Urbanization in India, Springer Nature, Singapore. 2018, 259-317
6) Machiwal, D., Jha, M. K., & Mal, B. C.; Assessment of Groundwater Potential in a Semi-Arid
Region of India Using Remote Sensing, GIS and MCDM Techniques, Water Resource Mangagement ,
2010, 1359-1386.
7) Meteorological Centre. Rainfall Profile of Udaipur, Ministry of Earth Science, Government of India,
India Meteorological Department, New Delhi, 2013.
8) Thelen, M. Elizabeth. Intersected Communities: Urban Histories of Rajasthan, c. 1500 – 1800.
Unpublished Ph.D thesis, University of California, Berkeley. 2018.
https://escholarship.org/uc/item/-3h963831, accessed on 22nd march, 2022.
9) Tod, J. Annals and antiquities of Rajasthan. Vol. I. 1829,
https://ia902707.us.archive.org/7/items/-annalsantiquitie01todj/annalsantiquitie01todj.pdf, accessed
on 20th march, 2022.
10) Chaplot, B. Spatio-temporal land use change: a case study of Udaipur city. Journal of Global
Resources. 2017, pp. 99-107.
11) Census of India. Udaipur City Population, 2011,
https://archive.org/details/UdaipurDistrict2011CensusHandbook-B, accessed on March 25, 2022
12) Chobisa, P., Bedi, P. Revitalization of Walled City Case of Udaipur, India. 57th ISOCARP World
Planning Congress, Qatar. 2021
13) Gangani, V. K., Gandhi, S. R.; Predicting urban growth for Udaipur using SLEUTH model, Cygwin
and GIS techniques, 7th Esri India User Conference, ESRI India, 2017, p1-14
14) Habib, B., Talukdar, G., Jain, P., & Bhasin, A. D. G.; Mapping Landuse/ Landcover Patterns in
Aravallis Haryana with Reference to Status of Key Wildlife Species, Dehradun and Haryana Forest
Department. 2017,
https://imgs.mongabay.com/wp-content/uploads/sites/30/2019/10/18024637/Aravallis-Report-WII-M
ay-2017-1-min_compressed.pdf
15) Parihar, R.; Ahar culture provides clues to links between Harappans and their predecessors, India
Today, English,
https://www.indiatoday.in/magazine/heritage-/story/20010312-ahar-culture-provides-clues-to-links-be
tween-harappans-and-their-predecessors-775569-2001-03-11, accessed on March 30, 2022
16) Forest Survey of India. India State of Forest Report Volume II, , The Ministry for Environment,
Forests and Climate Change, Dehradun, 2019, 225, https://fsi.nic.in/forest-report-2019.
17) Forest Department, Government of Rajasthan, Annual Reports 2021-2022,
https://forest.rajasthan.gov.in/content/raj/forest/en/downloads/annual-reports0.html
18) Verma, N. S.; Impact of Climate Change in the Southern Rajasthan, India, 5th International
Conference on Water Resources and Arid Environments (ICWRAE 5) Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 2013,
362-3
19) Kumar, P., 31 dead as dust storm hits Rajasthan, Gujarat, Madhya Pradesh, India Today, English,
https://www.indiatoday.in/india/story/31-dead-as-dust-storm-hits-rajasthan-gujarat-madhya-pradesh-1
503764-2019-04-17, accessed on March 31, 2022
20) NIUA. Inclusive Revitilization of Historic Towns and Cities Strategic Framework for Rajasthan State
Heritage Programme, New Delhi, 2018,
https://documents1.worldbank.org/curated/en/179761563443651430/pdf/Inclusive-Revitalisation-of-
Historic-Towns-and-Cities-Strategic-Framework-for-Rajasthan-State-Heritage-Programme.pdf
21) Panchal, A., Rai, N., & Sharma, N. K.; Assessment of forest land degradation by remote Sensing and
GIS: A case study of Jaisamand Wildlife Sanctuary, Udaipur (Rajasthan), Ecology, Environment and
Conservation, 2020, 447-454.
22) Rathore, N. S. Water Resource Management, A study of the World's first man-made river links, river
diversion and micro watershed of Udaipur basin, Pacific Business Review. 2010, 76-82.
23) Heinrich Boll Foundation, Berlin, Germany and Development Alternatives, New Delhi, India,
Understanding Water Flows in Udaipur, Heinrich Boll Foundation, Berlin, Germany and
Development Alternatives, New Delhi, India. 2018,
https://www.devalt.org/images/L2_ProjectPdfs/Understanding_Waterflows_In_Udaipur_HBF.pdf?Oi
d=209, accessed on March 31, 2022.