Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Regulation of
Cryptocurrencies
and Blockchain
Technologies
National and
International Perspectives
Second Edition
Rosario Girasa
Palgrave Studies in Financial Services Technology
Series Editor
Bernardo Nicoletti, Rome, Roma, Italy
The Palgrave Studies in Financial Services Technology series features orig-
inal research from leading and emerging scholars on contemporary issues
and developments in financial services technology. Falling into 4 broad
categories: channels, payments, credit, and governance; topics covered
include payments, mobile payments, trading and foreign transactions, big
data, risk, compliance, and business intelligence to support consumer and
commercial financial services. Covering all topics within the life cycle of
financial services, from channels to risk management, from security to
advanced applications, from information systems to automation, the series
also covers the full range of sectors: retail banking, private banking, corpo-
rate banking, custody and brokerage, wholesale banking, and insurance
companies. Titles within the series will be of value to both academics and
those working in the management of financial services.
Rosario Girasa
Regulation
of Cryptocurrencies
and Blockchain
Technologies
National and International Perspectives
Second Edition
Rosario Girasa
Lubin School of Business
Pace University
Pleasantville, NY, USA
This Palgrave Macmillan imprint is published by the registered company Springer Nature
Switzerland AG
The registered company address is: Gewerbestrasse 11, 6330 Cham, Switzerland
Also, by author under the name of Rosario Girasa or Roy J. Girasa
Cyberlaw: National and International Perspectives (Prentice-Hall, 2002)
Corporate Governance in Finance Law (Palgrave Macmillan, 2013)
Laws and Regulations in Global Financial Markets Palgrave Macmillan,
(2013)
Shadow Banking: Rise, Risks, and Rewards of Non-Bank Financial
Services (Palgrave Macmillan, 2016)
Regulation of Cryptocurrencies and Blockchain Technologies: National
and International Perspectives (Palgrave Macmillan, 2018)
Artificial Intelligence as a Disruptive Technology (Palgrave Macmillan,
2020)
Regulation of Innovative Technologies (with Gino J. Scalabrini) (Palgrave
Macmillan, 2022)
Bartlett Family—George, Carol, Susan, Karen, and Laura
and
Marie Manganelli
Preface
This study reflects the remarkable changes that have occurred over the
past four years. Few topics are as exciting and interesting as witnessing the
major ongoing efforts to create alternate modes of payments presented by
cryptocurrencies and the innumerable other possible uses that are offered
by blockchain technology. Reading many other studies on diverse topics,
this author often queries what sources of data are used by those scholars.
For my studies, there are several invaluable sources that I examine daily.
The reader need to only examine the endnotes of this work to note that
there were hundreds of sources but, in fact, the most useful were those of
MIT Technology Review, Wired Magazine, The Economist for up-to-date
news related to the subject-matter, Fried Frank Regulatory Intelligence,
Mondaq which offers short essays on the latest legal occurrences, and
other sources. Being in my mid-eighties, I have never been so engrossed
as at the present time when each day presents new possibilities and a
shadowy view of what the future holds for humanity. In discussion with
scientists and other persons with great insight, it has become obvious that
predictions beyond a five-year time frame is fraught with possible errors
and are merely guesswork. This work does not presume to offer a future
insight beyond what has occurred up to the date of the submission of the
volume. Notwithstanding the risk, the conclusion speculates occurrences
that may greatly affect technological outcomes concerning the materials in
the text. Look forward to the future which requires a constantly learning
process which has made life immensely worthwhile.
ix
x PREFACE
The volume could not have been written without the input, advice,
and encouragement of Tula Weis of Palgrave Macmillan who made the
initial suggestion of a follow-up volume to the first edition. She has been
responsible in part or in whole for the other Palgrave Macmillan publica-
tions by me. Naveen Dass managed the practical aspects to be readied for
publication. Thank you to Mahesh Meiyazhagan who edited this text.
I researched alone all of the materials indicated therein and thus any
errors are mine alone.
xi
xii TABLE OF CASES
U.S. v. Vasinskyi, No. 3:21:-cr-0366-s (D.C. N.D. Tx, Aug. 11, 2021).
West Virginia v. EPA, 136 S.Ct. 1000 (2016).
Zippo Mfr. Co. v. Zippo Dot Com, Inc., 952 F. Supp. 1119 (W.D. Pa.
1997).
Contents
xv
xvi CONTENTS
Wrapped Assets 64
Stablecoins, Wrapped Assets, and NFTS Comparison 64
Decentralized Finance 65
3 Federal Regulation of Virtual Currencies 81
Introduction 81
Jurisdiction 83
SEC v. Shavers 86
Gordon v. Dailey 87
Alibaba Group Holding v Alibabacoin Foundation 87
Virtual Currencies as Money 88
Audet v. Fraser 90
US Government Agencies Concerned with Virtual
Currencies 91
Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) 91
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) 106
US Department of Justice Attorney General’s
Cyber-Digital Task Force 116
Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) 117
Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) 124
Federal Reserve Board (FED) 126
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) 128
Office of Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) 129
Federal Trade Commission 130
4 Alternatives to Traditional Virtual Currencies:
Stablecoins and Central Banks Digital Currencies 147
Stablecoins 147
Models of Stablecoins 148
Advantages and Risks of Stablecoins 149
US Government Regulation of Stablecoins 150
Stablecoin Cases 152
International Regulation of Stablecoins 154
US Senate Proposed Bills 158
Central Banks and Cryptocurrencies 159
Central Banks’ Role and Mission 159
Central Bank Digital Currency (CBDC) 161
Reasons for Rise of CBDC 161
xviii CONTENTS
Connecticut 241
Delaware 242
District of Columbia 242
Florida 242
Georgia 243
Idaho 243
Illinois 243
Nevada 244
New York 244
North Carolina 246
Texas 246
Vermont 247
Virginia 248
Washington 248
West Virginia 248
Wyoming 248
Miscellaneous States Giving Recognition to Virtual
Currencies 249
Hawaii 249
Massachusetts 249
New Jersey 251
States That Have Not Enacted Legislation Concerning
Virtual Currencies 251
California 252
Colorado 252
Kansas 253
Maryland 253
Missouri 254
Miscellaneous States 254
7 Taxation of Virtual Currencies; Environmental,
Social and Governance Considerations; Protection
of Intellectual Property Rights; Antitrust;
and Cybersecurity 261
Taxation of Virtual Currencies 261
Virtual Currency as Property for Tax Purposes 262
Internal Revenue Service Guidance on Crowdfunding
and Virtual Currency 269
The Foreign Account Tax Compliance Act (FATCA) 273
xx CONTENTS
xxiii
xxiv ABBREVIATIONS
Introduction
The advent of the internet and the technological advancements related
thereto have inaugurated a transformation in how we think and act
that exceeds any of the prior historical inventions and discoveries. We
speak to each other instantaneously, spend endless quanta of time on
cell phones, computers, and other devices, and have created totally new
ways of communication with one another. Industries, often reluctantly,
have undergone digital transformations and disruptions in an endeavor to
modernize and not become bankrupt by failure to upgrade and innovate
as the oft-cited lessons of Kodak and Polaroid have imparted.1 Digital
transformation is occurring at an exponential pace without parallel in
human history causing new innovations to rise rapidly fed by venture
capital, crowdfunding, and other monetary investments. These enhance-
ments are creating entirely new workforces but also are causing displace-
ments of workers unable to adapt to the new technologies. Valuations of
new enterprises above $1 billion literally are generated almost overnight
which rival entire economies of many nations, e. g., Apple ($3 trillion),
Google’s parent company Alphabet ($1927 trillion), Microsoft ($2513
trillion), and Amazon ($1728 trillion).2
Successful companies have or are adopting new business models to
meet the technological revolution. IBM has transformed its mainframe
business to technology and consulting business services; Microsoft from
related financial instruments with the use of the then current technolo-
gies, it appears that money itself will likely diminish in its current form to
be replaced or added to by a virtual currency in a form known as “cryp-
tocurrency”. In this study, we will discuss the nature of digital currencies,
specifically, cryptocurrencies such as Bitcoin, and the latest emanations of
stablecoins; non-fungible tokens; wrapped assets; the technology under-
lying the currencies; and the regulatory enactments either proposed or
already enacted by federal and state governing authorities.
extensively in Greece and Rome soon thereafter.12 Barter has never totally
been banished completely to history’s dustbin but has continued in some
form, including among nations, to the present time.
A form of barter used extensively in the twentieth century is counter-
trade. At various times, countries or entities within nations have engaged
in countertrade whereby large quantities of products or services have been
exchanged without use of money, particularly when a nation’s currency
has lost credibility. During World War II and thereafter, nations found
countertrade to be beneficial due to the decimation of the industrial plants
destroyed during the war. Companies and individuals in countries that
had a trustworthy currency at times chose countertrade in order to avoid
imposition of taxes on goods or services exchanged. Nations participated
in countertrade also to offset trade imbalances and protect local indus-
tries. Usually, such trade concerns sellers who desired to convey goods
to a country that lacked or had severe limits on the use of hard currency
such as some nations in sub-Sahara Africa and on the Indian continent.
There are many types of countertrade, exemplified by barter (exchange
of goods or services): counter purchase (party selling goods or services to
another party agrees to buy back a specific product in exchange there-
from in the future); compensation (part of payment is in hard currency);
buyback (generally, a company may invest in constructions of a plant or
other facility and agrees to purchase products manufactured from the
said facility); clearing arrangement (exemplified by the trade between
West and East Germany before unification whereby companies in both
nations sold goods and services and registered the sales in clearing banks
in the respective countries which were then settled at the end of a
designated time frame and any balances became the obligation of the
obligor country); switch trade (one party provides goods and/or services
in exchange for an arrangement to purchase goods from the buying
nation); and offsets (company may construct plants or provide other
services in another country in order to diminish costs due and owing
to the supplier).13
Money, in its many emanations, became a substitute for the exchange
or barter of goods and services. It is based on the perception of persons
using currency that it has equivalent value for such items. The Interna-
tional Monetary Fund (IMF) defines “money” as anything that may act
as a (a) store of value that persons in possession may keep and use it at a
later time; (b) as a unit of account providing a common base for prices;
or (c) as a medium of exchange that people use and exchange with one
1 THE DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION 5
another.14 Historically, the IMF has used a form of digital currency by its
creation and distribution of “special drawing rights” (SDRs) commencing
in 1969 as an international reserve asset which supplemented a member
state’s official reserves and which may be exchanged for usable currencies.
Although the IMF states SDRs are not a form of currency, neverthe-
less, they may be used by member states as a voluntary exchange for
existing currencies and as units of account of the IMF and other interna-
tional organizations. SDRs are issued in accordance with a member state’s
quotas, i.e., required depository amount assigned by the IMF to a nation
dependent on its financial status. Interest is paid or charged for borrowing
on such holdings. As of August 2021, a total of SDR 660.7 billion (equiv-
alent to about US $943 billion) have been allocated to member states
including approximately SDR 456 billion approved on August 2, 2021,
to contribute to the long-term global need for reserves, and assist coun-
tries to cope with the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic. The value of
the SDR is based on a basket of five currencies—the US dollar, the euro,
the Chinese renminbi, the Japanese yen, and the British pound sterling.15
Digital services are a response and means to greatly lower costs both
to financial institutions and to their customers. Digital technology has
extended to use of smart phones and computers to engage in deposits;
transactions in securities and other transactions; and, when coupled with
ATMs, has lessened the need for tellers and other banking personnel.22
The next anticipated innovations are expected to feature the substitu-
tion of greatly enhanced digital technology for the present technologies
that will be transformative in almost unimaginable ways. In the near
future, cash will be viewed as primitive as the Underwood typewriter
of old to students preparing research papers for class today. Credit
cards have already served comparable needs for consumers and may be
on the descent thereby deeply discounting the costs to merchants and
consumers. The latest modernization and its regulatory issues are the
focus of this paper.
Types of Currencies
Currency (real currency or fiat currency) is defined as “the coin and paper
money of the United States or of any other country that is designated
as legal tender and that circulates and is customarily used and accepted
as a medium of exchange in the country of issuance”.23 It includes US
notes and silver certificates, Federal Reserve notes, and official foreign
8 R. GIRASA
Digital Currencies
Digital currency is an intangible mode of currency in electronic format
whereby payments may be transferred between parties through the use of
current technologies of computers, the internet, and smart phones. It is
used for payments made person-to-person or with entities for common
purchases of goods and services both domestically and internationally or
may be confined to gaming or social networks.28 It may be either fiat
(real) currency, e.g., e-money, or non-fiat currency as virtual currency. It
is borderless and occurs instantaneously just as speedily as communica-
tion by email but may be dependent on governmental restrictions and
access. It may also include, under some definitions, as sovereign cryp-
tocurrency. The term is often used synonymously with virtual currencies
but encompasses all types of currencies that have an electronic format.
Virtual Currencies
Virtual currency is a digital representation of value that is not government
or central bank issued that can be digitally traded and functions as a (1)
medium of exchange; (2) unit of account; or (3) store of value.29 Rather
than possessing status like the legal tender of fiat currency, such as physical
coins or bills, it is generally not widely used or circulated and has no
government backing. A distinction should be made from e-money which
is fiat currency transferring value by electronic means and does possess the
characteristic of legal tender. Virtual currency may operate like so-called
real currency but lacks legal status in the US. Its value is what users or
traders ascribe to it.30
Convertible (or opened) virtual currency refers to unofficial convert-
ibility or exchangeability as proposed and accepted by the participants
thereof which may include exchange for fiat currency, property, or other
forms of value. The primary example is Bitcoin which can be used to
purchase goods, real property, or services from parties accepting the
10 R. GIRASA
Cryptocurrencies
The word crypto has many meanings dependent on its use as a noun,
adjective or used in connection with particular modes of study. When
applied in connection with currencies, we call it cryptocurrency defined
as “a digital decentralized convertible currency or medium of exchange
using encryption technology to verify its exchange and hinder counterfeit-
ing”.36 It is mined at a mathematically controlled rate, anonymous, reliant
on public and private keys to exchange value on a peer-to-peer basis, and
supply is based on free market demand.37 The term is often used inter-
changeably with convertible, decentralized virtual currency. Bitcoin and
Ethereum are leading examples of cryptocurrencies. In the context of
most commentaries, cryptocurrency is synonymous with virtual currency
although, theoretically, a distinction should be drawn between the two
types of currencies.
The discussion hereafter will focus on the generic terms of virtual
currencies and cryptocurrencies and their regulation.
• Verification of identity;
• Significant reduction in costs due to the removal of intermediaries
such as banks in the payment processes;
• Speed of money transfers by the elimination of clearing houses;
• Facilitation of micro-payments for low cost online goods and
services;
1 THE DIGITAL TRANSFORMATION 15
The uses which may have both positive and negative outcomes are:
The report further noted that investors and consumers have low levels of
understanding of the complexity of the sector which are subject to fraud,
money laundering, and ransomware. The FSB expressed its intent to care-
fully monitor future events as the crypto-asset markets grow competitive
to traditional finance and make high-level recommendations including
global stablecoin arrangements.
1 A b n o r m e S c h w e i n e - E c k z ä h n e 2–3 B a b i r u s a a l f u r u s Less.
n. Gr.
c. ⅔ n. Gr.
c. ¼ n. Gr.
⅓–¼ n. Gr.
c. ⅓ n. Gr.
[I]
[Inhalt]
Abhandlungen und Berichte des
Königlichen Zoologischen und
Anthropologisch-Ethnographischen
Museums zu Dresden Bd. VII 1898/99
Nr. 7
Säugethiere
vom
Celébes- und Philippinen-
Archipel
II
Celébes-Sammlungen der Herren
Sarasin
von
A. B. Meyer
Anhang
J. Jablonowski: D i e l ö f f e l f ö r m i g e n
Haare der Molossi
M i t 1 1 Ta f e l n , d a v o n 8
colorirt
Verlag von R. Friedländer & Sohn in
Berlin
1899
[III]
[Inhalt]
Inhaltsverzeichniss
Seite
Tafelerklärung V
Alphabetischer Index VII
Addenda VIII
Einleitung 1
Primates
1. M a c a c u s m a u r u s F. Cuv. Taf. I und II 2
M a c a c u s t o n k e a n u s n. sp. 3
2. C y n o p i t h e c u s n i g e r (Desm.) 4
3. C y n o p i t h e c u s n i g e r n i g r e s c e n s (Temm.) 4
4. Ta r s i u s f u s c u s Fisch.-Waldh. Taf. III Fig. 1–2 4
Chiroptera
5. P t e r o p u s w a l l a c e i G r . Taf. IV Fig. 1 5
6. P t e r o p u s a l e c t o Temm. 5
7. P t e r o p u s h y p o m e l a n u s Temm. 6
8. P t e r o p u s m a c k l o t i Temm. 6
9. X a n t h a r p y i a m i n o r (Dobs.) 6
10. C y n o p t e r u s l a t i d e n s Dobs. 7
C y n o p t e r u s b r a c h y o t i s (S. Müll.) 7
11. U r o n y c t e r i s c e p h a l o t e s (Pall.) 8
12. C e p h a l o t e s p e r o n i Geoffr. 9
13. C a r p o n y c t e r i s a u s t r a l i s (Ptrs.) 10
14. R h i n o l o p h u s m i n o r Horsf. 11
15. H i p p o s i d e r u s d i a d e m a (Geoffr.) 11
16. M e g a d e r m a s p a s m a (L.) 12
17. V e s p e r u s p a c h y p u s (Temm.) 12
18. V e s p e r u g o p e t e r s i n. sp. Taf. IV Fig. 2 13
V e s p e r u g o p a p u a n u s o r i e n t a l i s n. subsp. 14
19. V e s p e r u g o m i n a h a s s a e n. sp. Taf. IV Fig. 3 14
20. V e s p e r t i l i o m u r i c o l a Hdgs. 16
21. N y c t i n o m u s s a r a s i n o r u m n. sp. Taf. IV Fig. 4–6
und Taf. X Fig. 3, 4 und 28, und Taf. XI Fig. 2 und 2a 16
N y c t i n o m u s a s t r o l a b i e n s i s n. sp. Taf. X Fig.
19 und 30, und Taf. XI Fig. 6 19
Insectivora
22. C r o c i d u r a f u l i g i n o s a (Blyth) 20
Carnivora
23. V i v e r r a t a n g a l u n g a Gray 20
24. P a r a d o x u r u s h e r m a p h r o d i t u s (Schreb.) 20
25. P a r a d o x u r u s m u s s c h e n b r o e k i Schl. 20
Rodentia
26. S c i u r u s l e u c o m u s Müll. Schl. 21
27. S c i u r u s l e u c o m u s o c c i d e n t a l i s A. B. M. [IV] 21
28. S c i u r u s s a r a s i n o r u m A. B. M. Taf. V 21
29. S c i u r u s m u r i n u s Müll. Schl. 21
30. S c i u r u s r u b r i v e n t e r Müll. Schl. 22
31. M u s r a t t u s L. 22
32. M u s n e g l e c t u s Jent.(?) 22
33. M u s e p h i p p i u m Jent. 23
34. M u s m u s s c h e n b r o e k i Jent. Taf. VI Fig. 1 23
35. M u s c a l l i t r i c h u s Jent. Taf. VII Fig. 1 24
36. M u s h e l l w a l d i J e n t . Taf. VII Fig. 2–10 25
37. M u s x a n t h u r u s Gr. Taf. VI Fig. 2–10 25
38. L e n o m y s m e y e r i (Jent.) Taf. VIII 26
39. C r a u r o t h r i x l e u c u r a (Gr.) Taf. IX 27
Ungulata
40. S u s v e r r u c o s u s c e l e b e n s i s (Müll. Schl.) 27
41. B a b i r u s a a l f u r u s Less. 28
42. C e r v u s m o l u c c e n s i s Q. G. 29
Marsupialia
43. P h a l a n g e r u r s i n u s (Temm.) 31
44. P h a l a n g e r c e l e b e n s i s (Gr.) 31
Anhang: D i e l ö f f e l f ö r m i g e n H a a r e d e r M o l o s s i
von Dr. J. J a b l o n o w s k i , Assistenten am Museum. Hierzu
Taf. X und XI 32
[V]
[Inhalt]
Tafelerklärung
rechter
3 Vorderfuss von unten
rechter
4 Hinterfuss von unten
Schädel
5–6 in der norma lateralis
Schädel
7 in der norma verticalis
Schädel
8 in der norma basalis
linke obere
9 Zahnreihe in
derselben Orientirung wie der
Schädel
linke10
untere Zahnreihe,
desgleichen
rechter
3 Vorderfuss von unten
rechter
4 Hinterfuss von unten
Schädel
5–6 in der norma lateralis
Schädel
7 in der norma verticalis
Schädel
8 in der norma basalis
linke obere
9 Zahnreihe in
derselben Orientirung wie der
Schädel
linke10
untere Zahnreihe,
desgleichen
Tafel VIII L e n o m y s m e y e r i (Jent.) von Nord Seite 26
Celébes. Nat. Grösse.
[VII]
[Inhalt]