You are on page 1of 8

J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.

R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 1

The Effect of Marine Sediments on the


Mechanical Properties and Thermal Stability of
Proteinic Biopolymer

AQ6 Ines Zarrad,1,2 Nicolas Montrelay,1 Justin Houessou,1 Rose-Marie Dheilly,1 Jamel Bouaziz,2
AQ1 Michèle Queneudec1
1
University of Picardie Jules Verne, SFR Condorcet CNRS 3417, Research Unit EPROAD, EA 4669,
Engineering of Materials and Process (IMaP), 80000 Amiens, France

2
University of Sfax, Ecole Nationale d’Ingenieurs de Sfax, Laboratoire Chimie Industrielle Il, BP 1173, Sfax,
Tunisia

This article focuses on the valorization of marine sedi- rides as well as those synthesized chemically from
ments (MS) in proteinic biopolymer (HE) that will gener- naturally derived monomers [3]. The incorporation of an
ate HEMS biocomposites. These biocomposites were
developed with various percentages of marine sedi-
inorganic filler into an organic matrix leads to the modifi-
ments (0, 5, 15, and 20%) and characterized. Mechanical cation of strengths and stiffness [4], and to the increase
properties were examined as a function of the contents of physical and thermal properties too [5]. Previous works
of used marine sediments. The flexural and compressive show that the incorporation of marine sediments as inor-
modulus increase with the rise of the MS percentage in ganic fillers in a matrix derived from hemoglobin protein
the composite. The compressive strength increases
while the flexural and tensile strengths decrease. Fur-
effectively improved the stiffness, compressive strength
thermore, the HEMS composite was characterized using and thermal properties (TGA) of the HEMS biocomposite
Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy and by using [6]. However, the tensile and flexural strengths decreased.
scanning electron microscopy. And the thermal degra- A multiphase model has been developed, which is able to
dation behavior of the composite was investigated by reproduce the compressive behavior of HEMS [6].
thermogravimetric analysis coupled with differential
scanning calorimetry. POLYM. COMPOS., 00:000–000, 2015.
It was necessary to study the morphological properties
C 2015 Society of Plastics Engineers
V of composites to understand the evolution of these proper-
ties. The primary purpose of this research is to establish
the correlation between Fourier transform infrared spec-
troscopy (FTIR), the mechanical properties of the compo-
INTRODUCTION sites and their microstructure. The thermal properties
Over the last few years, numerous research projects were also investigated by thermogravimetric analysis
have focused on material recovery in the context of sus- coupled with differential scanning calorimetry (TGA/
tainable development. The growing demand to substitute DSC) to show the effect of marine sediments on the ther-
petroleum-based products has increased the focus on bio- mal stability of HEMS biocomposites and to study the
based resources among which biopolymers which are mechanism of their thermal degradation.
gaining increasing popularity [1]. Indeed the increase in
fossil energy costs and the environmental concerns have
resulted in new opportunities for the industrial production EXPERIMENTAL
of the biodegradable materials based on natural renewable
resources [2]. In addition, the use of biopolymer can Materials
solve the waste disposal problem to a certain extent. Such
biopolymers include those derived from naturally pro- In this work, in order to elaborate the biosourced
duced protein, cellulose, starches and other polysaccha- matrix, a protein of atomized beef blood has been used. It
was obtained from the French company “Vapran” (vepro
95 BHF). Its bulk density is about 1370 kg/m3. The
Correspondence to: Ines Zarrad; e-mail: inesss_zarrad@yahoo.fr
DOI 10.1002/pc.23730
marine sediments used in this study are extracted from
Published online in Wiley Online Library (wileyonlinelibrary.com). Dunkirk Harbour. Their bulk density is about 2780 kg/m3
C 2015 Society of Plastics Engineers
V and their particle sizes ranges from 0,08 to 2000 mm. The

POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:09 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 2

HESM biocomposite was produced by using the thermo-


compression process reported in previous research [6].
Samples of composites were prepared by adding various
amounts (0, 5, 15, and 20%) of (MS) marine sediments.
The names of these composites are, respectively, HESM
0, HESM 5, HESM 15, and HESM 20%.

Mechanical Testing
Tensile Testing. The tensile experiments were carried
out using ISO 527-1 on a Shimadzu AGX tensile testing
machine with an extensometer type SSG50-
10SHIMADZU. Trapezium software was used for the
machine control and data acquisition. Tensile tests were
performed at a constant cross-head speed of 2 mm/min.
FIG. 1. FTIR of Marine sediment (MS), Protein, HEMS 0% and
Three point Bending Testing. Flexural properties of HEMS 15%. [Color figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is
available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
composites were measured by ISO 14125 at a cross-head
speed of 3 mm/min using the same machine as for the Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) Analysis
tensile tests.
FT-IR spectra of marine sediments, protein, pure bio-
polymer, and HESM composites were recorded in the
Compressive Tests. Compressive tests were conducted wave number range of 648–4000 cm21 using FTIR Ana-
using WDW-10E Microcomputer-controlled electronic lyser (Pestige 21 Shimadzu) with a spectral resolution of
universal testing at a cross-head speed of 3 mm/min. 4 cm21 and scan times of 100. FTIR analysis requires the
mixing of 1 mg of composite with 100 mg of KBr.
Hardness. The Hardness test of the composites was
done with Hardmatic Mitutoyo shore D long leg type.
Thermal Analysis
The hardness measurement can determine the relative
resistance that opposes a surface to the penetration of a The TGA/DSC measurement was conducted by using
cone with a rounded tip (D scale). a SETERAM Ligne 96 TGA apparatus to investigate the

FIG. 2. Scanning electron microscope of marine sediments.

2 POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 DOI 10.1002/pc

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:09 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 3

TABLE 1. Mechanical test results of HESM composites as a function of MS percentage.

MS Tensile Young’s Flexural Flexural Compressive Compressive


Percentage Strength (MPa) modulus (MPa) strength (MPa) modulus (MPa) yield stress (MPa) modulus (MPa) Hardness

0 13,9 6 2,3 1600 6 61 30,61 6 4,24 1402 6 110 32 6 2,82 667 6 61 60 6 2


5 8,14 6 2,52 1450 6 164 19,16 6 1,3 1625 6 41 32,055 6 1,25 773,80 6 84 63,33 6 0,57
15 7,04 6 1,71 1580 6 125 19,19 6 1,21 1619 6 131 38,66 6 4,71 953,79 6 45 69,66 6 1,52
20 3,21 6 1,27 2120 6 296 16,47 6 1,22 1805 6 55 36,43 6 0,32 954,54 6 64 73 6 2

thermal degradation behavior. Samples were heated from stretching of these groups are assigned to bands at 1032
25 to 8008C at a heating rate of 108C/min and under a and 1008 cm21 [8–10]. The 690 cm21 peak is due to SiO
helium flow at 80 ml/min. perpendicular deformation [8]. The 3616 cm21 peak
belongs to OAH stretching of the inner hydroxyl related to
kaolinite and MMT [8, 10]. The 3693 cm21 peak is attrib-
Scanning Electron Microscopy
uted to the stretching vibration mode of inner surface
The morphology of various samples, which were hydroxyls located at the surface of octahedral oxygen of
obtained after flexural tests, was studied by means of scan- the adjacent kaolinite layer [11]. The 3437 cm21 band and
ning electron microscopy. To make observation easier, the the 1645 cm21 peak are due to HAOH bending [12]. The
samples were initially dried and then covered with a thin peaks observed at 910 and 792 cm211 are due to the bend-
layer of vacuum-sputtered gold, which acted as a conductor. ing and translation modes of inner surface hydroxyls of
Micrographs were derived using a PHILIPS FEG XL 30 kaolinite [8]. The peaks observed at 792, 690, 775, and
microscope, which exhibited the particularity of being 1078 cm21 can be attributed to quartz [13]. The bands
coupled to an X-ray spectrometer; this set-up enabled, by observed at 1427 and 871 cm21 are attributed to asymmet-
means of EDX analysis, determining the atomic composi- ric stretching of CO22
3 [14]. The peaks observed at 2953,
tion of a sample. 2920, and 2850 cm21 are attributed to CAH stretching.
The symmetric stretching of CH2 is assigned to the peak at
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2850 cm21, while the antisymmetric stretching of CH3 and
CH2 are assigned to peaks at 2953 and 2920 cm21, respec-
tively. While standard HE biopolymer shows a band at
Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FTIR) Analysis 1616–1693 cm21 This band is centred at 1640 cm21 and it
F1 Figure 1 shows the FTIR spectra of samples of the can be attributed to C@O vibration of amide I [2]. The
marine sediment, the protein, the HE biopolymer and band at 1489–1570 cm21 is centered at 1542 cm21 and it
HEMS 5% and HESM 15% biocomposites. is due to NAH bending of amide II[ [2]. The peak
Marine sediments (MS) have a complex composition observed at 1400 cm21 belongs to CAN stretching of
F2 as shown in Fig. 2. They contain clays (smectite, illite, amide III [4]. Observed peaks at 667, 692, and 783 cm21
kaolinite, and chlorite) and quartz [7]. can be attributed to NAH vibration in the polymer [10]. A
The MS spectrum shows characteristic peaks 1078, broad band observed at 3282–3520 cm21 centred at 3400
1029, and 1008 cm21 due to the SiO stretching of Kaolin- cm21 may be attributed to hydrogen bridges between the
ite and Montmorillonite (MMT). The anti symmetric oxygen atoms of the carbonyl C@O and the hydrogen
atoms of the amine NAH [15]. The peak observed at 2960
cm21 belongs to CAH stretching [16].
The infrared spectra of HESM biocomposite showed a
shift of band corresponding to hydrogen bridges of 3400
cm21 to 3410, and 3444 cm21 for HEMS 0%, HEMS 5%
and HEMS 15% respectively. In addition, the peak of
AOH at 3616 cm21 disappeared from the spectrum of
HEMS compared to the spectrum of MS. The HAOH
bending band of MS appeared in the spectrum of HEMS
and was broadened.
However, from the infrared spectra of the HEMS bio-
composite, no new chemical bond between (MS) marine
sediments and matrix is observed. Moreover, it is difficult
to deduct from these measurements the complete absence
of those chemical bonds, which can be hidden by the
complexity of infrared spectra of both the marine sedi-
FIG. 3. Scanning electron microscope of HEMS 15% composite ments and the matrix, which have a large number of func-
(1003). tions and linkages in their structure [2].

DOI 10.1002/pc POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 3

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:09 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 4

sediment particles which have much higher stiffness values


than the matrix [11, 17, 18] and which are in larger num-
bers and are well dispersed in the matrix (Fig. 3). F3
The compressive strengths of the Composite increases
with the rise of MS too. The addition of 15% MS
improves the compressive strength by about 20%, which
may be explained by the fact that the exerted vertical
load is supported by the matrix and the hardness of the
particles [6, 19]. This may also explain the improvement
of the shore hardness of the composites with the addition
of MS. Contrarily, the tensile strength of the composite
decreases with MS contents. For example the addition of
15% MS in the matrix, results in a decrease of 59 % with
regard to tensile strength of pure HE polymer. This
FIG. 4. Scanning electron microscope of HEMS 15% (5003).
decrease can be attributed to the existence of defects such
as voids [5, 20]. Indeed, with the increase of filler con-
Mechanical Test Results tents, the size of voids formed when the polymer matrix
The effects of marine sediments contents in the range becomes detached from the filler particles due to the
of 0, 5, 15, and 20% on the mechanical properties of deformation will become critically large and may initiate
T1 HEMS composites are given in Table 1. the main crack [21, 22] (Fig. 4). F4
It can be seen that when 20% of MS was added, the In addition Fig. 5 shows a slightly good adherence F5
young’s modulus increased by 32,5%. The flexural modu- between the matrix and the sediments. A specimen with
lus and compressive modulus increase with the addition of 5% of substitution reveals a better adhesion with a mini-
SM too. In fact, increased MS content causes modulus mum of voids in the interface between the matrix and the
growth. The presence of 20% of sediments in the compos- marine sediments. But with a substitution of about 15 and
ite causes a modulus increase: 28% for the flexural modu- 20%, SEM micrographs shows, in addition to the increase
lus and 43% for the compressive one respectively. The of number of interfaces, a weak adherence due to the pres-
modulus improvement can be explained by the hardness of ence of several voids in the interface and inside the

FIG. 5. Scanning electron micrographs of MS and matrix adhesion in HEMS composites (50003).

4 POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 DOI 10.1002/pc

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:09 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 5

FIG. 6. TGA and DTG curves of neat polymer HEMS 0%. [Color fig- FIG. 8. TGA and DTG curves of neat polymer HEMS 15%. [Color
ure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonline- figure can be viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonli-
library.com.] nelibrary.com.]

sediments, which can explain the decrease of the tensile ysis coupled with differential scanning calorimetry (TGA/
strength with the rise of marine sediments contents [23]. DSC). TGA curves and their corresponding DTG curves
The adherence observed by using SEM is considered as a of pure biopolymer (HEMS 0%) and of 5 and 15%
physical adherence due to nature of sediments (clay), char-
HEMS composites are respectively shown in Figs. 6–8. F6 F7
acterized by their cohesive properties. Moreover, all inter-
The detailed parameters to evaluate the degradation are F8
faces observed by using SEM confirm that no chemical
listed in Table 2. Three weight losses are observed for T2
bonds developed between the matrix and the sediments.
the pure polymer and its composites. The first weight loss
As expected, the flexural strength decreased by 37%
is related to the adsorbed ethanol, the second is the onset
when adding 15% MS, which is close to the expected
degradation of polymer which is related to thermal
value of 39% deduced from tensile and compressive
decomposition of weak linkages and impurities, and the
strength, since in the flexural testing the specimen was
third is the decomposition of the HE main chains [3, 16].
induced to uniaxial compression as well as tensile stress,
The three weight losses occurred at 61, 258, and 3218C in
acting simultaneously in the opposite directions [1]
the pure polymer HE, at 59, 259, and 3218C in the case
of the 5% HEMS biocomposite and at 93, 261, and
The Thermal Stability of the Biocomposite 3258C in the case of the 15% HEMS biocomposite. It
The behaviour of the thermal degradation of the Com- was found that, compared with pure polymer particles,
posites was investigated by using thermogravimetric anal- the HEMS biocomposite particles exhibited a better ther-
mal stability. Indeed the of total weight loss for neat
polymer, HEMS 5 and HEMS 15% were 75,9, 71,7, and
54%, respectively, instead of 72 and 64,6% (deducted by
linear interpolation based on the total weight losses at
100%) for HEMS 5 and HEMS15% [6]. In addition, the
onset degradation rates of HEMS 0, HEMS5, and HEMS
15% which are 0,05, 0,03, and 0,02% min21 8C21
decrease when the percentages of marine sediments rise
in the mixture. The limitation of degradation rates of
composites compared to the pure polymer can be
explained by impeding the diffusion of gaseous decompo-
sition products [24]. This improvement in the thermal sta-
bility of composites (Polymer and clay) has been reported
in several studies [4, 5].
The heat changes of the pure HE and its composites
HEMS 5% and HEMS15% were tested by TGA/DSC and
DSC curves are shown in Fig. 9. A main endothermic F9
FIG. 7. TGA and DTG curves of HEMS 5%. [Color figure can be peak appears in the DSC curves of the neat polymer and
viewed in the online issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.] its composites. This endothermic peak, corresponding to

DOI 10.1002/pc POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 5

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:09 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 6

TABLE 2. TGA and DSC results of the biocomposites.

The onset degradation DH


Samples Dm1 Dm2 Dm3 Tmax1 (8C) Tmax1 (8C) Tmax1 (8C) rate (% min218C) (mVs/mg)

HESM 0% 20,43% 15,20% 40,26% 61 258 321 0,05 15,88


HESM 5% 19,30% 14,13% 38,23% 59 259 321 0,03 13,35
HESM 15% 11,23% 5,80% 37,91% 93 262 325 0,02 3,124

in matrix was supported by FTIR and SEM analyses. The


addition of (MS) in the matrix increases the stiffness, hard-
ness and compressive strength of the composite, but the
flexural and tensile strengths decrease. The correlation
between the microstructure and the mechanical behaviour
was investigated. The results showed that when the per-
centage of substitution rises, adhesion becomes weaker due
to the presence of voids on the interface matrix/MS. SEM
micrographs also reveal a good dispersion of marine sedi-
ments in the matrix, which can explain the improvement
of the modulus. (TGA/DSC) showed a significant improve-
ment in the thermal stability of the composite.

REFERENCES

1. S. Singh, A.K. Mohanty, and M. Misra, Compos. A, 41, 304


(2010).
FIG. 9. DSC curves of neat polymer HEMS 0% and biocomposites 2. P. Muensri, T. Kunanoppart, P. Menut, and S.
HEMS 5% and HEMS 15%. [Color figure can be viewed in the online Siriwattanoyotin, Compos. A, 42, 173 (2011).
issue, which is available at wileyonlinelibrary.com.]
3. P. Kumar, K. Sandeep, S. Alavi, V. Truong, and R. Gorga,
Food. Eng., 100, 480 (2010).
15, 14, and 5.80% mass losses and 15.88, 13.35, and 3.124 4. M. Yadak and K.Y. Rhee, Carbohydr. Polym., 90, 165 (2012).
mVs/mg decomposition enthalpies for the pure polymer
5. Y. Seki, K. Sever, M. Sarikanat, A. Sakarya, and E. Elik,
HE, HEMS 5 and HEMS 15%, respectively, corresponding Compos. B, 45, 1534 (2013).
to the onset degradation of the composite indicates the
6. I. Zarrad, M. Jeridi, N. Montrelay, R.M. Dheilly, J.
chain scission process via hydrolysis [16]. The decrease of
Houesson, J. Bouaziz, M. Queneudec, and K. Sa€ı, Polym.
heat dissipation is due to the introduction of inorganic Environ., in press. AQ2
compounds into organic material, which improves the ther-
7. T.N. Thanh, Valorisation de s ediments marins et fluviaux en
mal stability [12] by impeding the diffusion of gaseous technique routie`re, Ph.D. Thesis, University of Artois (2009).
decomposition products [24]. Multiple endothermic peaks
8. O. Duman, S. Tunk, and A.C. Kaya, Colloids Surf. A: Phys-
appear in DSC curves centred at 3218C for both HEMS icochem. Eng. Aspects, 394, 23 (2012).
0% and HEMS 5% respectively, which can be attributed to
9. M. Rautureau, S. Caillère, and S. Henin, Les argiles, Spe-
the second composite degradation as a sequential degrada- tina (2004). AQ3
tion; but the peaks related to this degradation disappear in
10. F. Assasi and N. Benharrats, Amelioration de la stabilite ther-
the case of HEMS 15%. This can also be explained by the
mique de nanocomposites polypyrrole-montmorillonite, Pro-
presence of the clay particles, which limits the release of ceedings of the 5th International Symposium on rheology and
gases from decomposition. The endothermic peak showed applications, Oran, Algeria, November 22–23, 19 (2009).
in DSC curves of HEMS 5% and HEMS 15% at 527 and 11. J.K. Pandey and R.P. Singh. Starch/Starke, 57, 8 (2005).
5628C, respectively, can be attributed to the dehydroxyla-
12. E. Gunister, D. Pestreli, C.H. Unlu, O. Atici, and N.
tion of clays (kaolinite) and to the decomposition of calcite Gungor, Carbohydr. Polym., 67, 358 (2007).
of marine sediments. Putting all of TGA/DSC results
13. F. Bosh Reig, J.V.G. Adelantado, and M.C.M.M. Moreno,
together demonstrates that the HEMS biocomposite has a
Talanta, 58, 811 (2002).
better stability than the pure HE.
14. Available at: http://horizon.documentation.ird.fr/exl-doc/
pleins_textes/cahiers/geologie/20094.pdf. AQ4
CONCLUSION
15. S. Stein and B. Morrill, Identification spectroscopique des
The biocomposites HESM based on beef hemoglobin compos es organiques, Boeck (1998). AQ5
protein and marine sediments (MS) were prepared using 16. Y. Feng, B. Wang, F. Wang, Y. Zhao, C. Liu, J. Chen, and
thermo-compression molding. The presence of (MS) phases C. Shen, Polym. Degrad. Stab., 107, 129 (2014).

6 POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 DOI 10.1002/pc

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:10 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 7

17. S.Y. Fu, X.Q. Feng, B. Lauke, and Y.W. Mai. Compos. B, 21. D. Gan, S. Lu, C. Song, and Z. Wang. Eur. Polym. J., 37,
39, 933 (2008). 1359 (2001).
18. H.M. Wilhelm, M.R. Sierakowski, G.P. Souza, and F. 22. A.A. Berlin, S.A. Volfsol, N.S. Enikolopian, and S.S. Negnatov,
Wypych, Carbohydr. Polym., 52, 101 (2003). Principals of Polymer Composites, Springer, Berlin (1986).
19. R. Parenhos, R.B. Aigueira, and M. Filgueira, Mach. Mach. 23. M.S. Devi, V. Murugesan, K. Rengari, and P. Anand, Appl.
Mater., 1, 62 (2000). Polym. Sci., 69, 1385 (1998).
20. M. Tait, A. Pegoretti, A. Dorigato, and K. Kalaitzidou, Car- 24. S. Vyazovkin, I. Dranca, X.W. Fan, and R. Advincula,
bon, 49, 4280 (2011). Phys. Chem. B, 108, 11672 (2004).

DOI 10.1002/pc POLYMER COMPOSITES—2015 7

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:10 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368


J_ID: PC Customer A_ID: PC23730 Cadmus Art: PC23730 Ed. Ref. No.: 15-0453.R1 Date: 29-July-15 Stage: Page: 8

AQ1: Please confirm that all author names are OK and are set with first name first, surname last.

AQ2: Please update Ref. 6 (if possible).

AQ3: Please provide the publisher for Ref. 9.

AQ4: Please provide complete details for Refs. 14 and 15.

AQ5: Kindly provide the place of the publisher for Ref. 15.

AQ6: Please confirm that given names (red) and surnames/family names (green) have been identified correctly.

ID: senthilkumar.t Time: 17:10 I Path: //10.18.11.53/Home$/senthilkumar.t$/JW-PC##150368

You might also like