Professional Documents
Culture Documents
net/publication/361073077
Exploring Between SHS Strand and College Course Mismatch: Bridging the Gap
Through School Policy on Intensified Career Guidance Program
CITATIONS READS
0 59,679
2 authors:
All content following this page was uploaded by Corazon Quintos on 04 June 2022.
Abstract---One of the salient features of the Senior High School aspect of every student's path is entering senior high school.
curriculum is that every student in this recent generation is prepared Senior high school learners struggle with transitions and make
for their future career and ready to face challenges. The success of this decisions on their own. The senior high school is introduced to
endeavor is believed to be measured by the graduates' alignment of the students offering different tracks and strands. Students in this
high school strand and the course they have to pursue in college. There
is however a noticeable situation in which students enroll in college
phase choose from available tracks and strands offered in senior
courses that are not associated with their track or strand of senior high high school centers [2]. Though not mandatory, senior high
school. One of the major reasons that some students lose interest in school students are advised to base their preference on the
college is the gap between their high school experiences and their result of the National Career Assessment Examination to align
college expectations which is the subject of this study. To determine their aptitude and skills. They are likewise encouraged to select
whether there was a mismatch between the enrolled strand of the track or strand concerning their college course preference.
students who graduated from SY 2017 – 2018 to SY 2018 – 2019 and
their enrolled courses in college, descriptive research methodology
However, there are some noticeable circumstances where
was utilized. The mismatch rate is high between the strand of the students enroll in college courses not aligned to their senior
learners during their senior high school and the course they enrolled in high school track or strand. A situation like this may cause a
college. It is revealed that for the school year 2017-2018 the rate of student to falter in college. Research suggests that one of the
mismatch is thirty-nine percent (39%) and thirty-one percent (31%) major reasons that some students lose interest in college is the
for the SY 2018-2019. Family pressure, accessibility of the program in gap between their high school experiences and their college
the nearby university, and friends and peer pressure are the topmost
among the reasons cited by students who did not take the college
expectations.
course align with their strand. Implementation of an enhanced career With the above problem, the researchers conducted this
guidance program, policy brief, and intensified monitoring and research to further explore the mismatch between the SHS
evaluation are recommended. strand and college course and be able to bridge the gap by
intensifying the career guidance program among students.
Keywords---College Course, SHS Strand, Mismatch, Intensified
Career Guidance Program
Aims
This study was conducted to explore if there is a mismatch
I. INTRODUCTION between the Senior High School Track and the course enrolled
in college of the Narra National High School students who
E DUCATION is vital in molding the future of every
individual. It is a common thought that one of the
foundations for a better life is education. It empowers a person
graduated from the school year 2017 – 2018 to 2018 – 2019.
Specifically, it sought answers to the following questions:
to deal with life. With this, one of the main targets of the 1. What is the strand enrolled by the NNHS students who
government is to serve society by providing relevant education graduated from SY 2017 – 2018 to SY 2018 – 2019?
for the students to become more prolific and globally 2. What is the rate of graduates enrolled in colleges and
competitive learners. universities from SY 2017 – 2018 to SY 2018 - 2019?
One of the objectives of the K to 12 curriculum in the 3. What is the rate of the graduates enrolled in courses
Philippine education system is to ensure that every grade 12 aligned with their Senior High School Strand?
graduate is prepared for tertiary education [1]. Entering senior 4. What is the rate of mismatch between the enrolled SHS
high school is a crucial part of every students’ journey. A vital strand of the graduates to the college course enrolled by
them?
5. What are the possible reasons for not taking a course in
Manuscript received on November 23, 2020, review completed on line with their strand enrolled in Senior High School?
November 23, 2020 and revised on November 30, 2020.
C. A. Quintos is with Narra National High School, Philippines. E-Mail:
corazon.quintos@deped.gov.ph II. LITERATURE REVIEW
D.G. Caballes is with the De La Salle-College of Saint Benilde Manila, The Department of Education has begun to introduce the new
Philippines. E-Mail: dennis.caballes@benilde.edu.ph
E. M. Gapad is with Sandoval National High School, Philippines. E-Mail: K-12 program, which in the current curriculum acts as a big
edheson.gapad0001@deped.gov.ph transformation. This reform involves enhancing basic
M. A. Valdez is with Narra National High School, Philippines. E-Mail: education and expanding the program for basic education to
mariannervaldez@gmail.com
Digital Object Identifier: DMKE102020003. cover 12 years by including kindergarten and two years in high
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology
CiiT International Journal of Data Mining and Knowledge Engineering, Vol 12, No 10 - 12, October - December 2020 157
school. The new program guarantees that graduates gain the seeking guideposts, but peso signs that would take them out of
skills required as the entrance for the professional world and hardship [8].
reach the requisite age for employment [3]. Graduates who Students who graduate from Senior High School's college
choose to pursue tertiary education, on the other side, are course choices are significantly influenced by a variety of
considered better prepared to study in college [4]. variables, including what strand they chose to take up between
With the latest K to 12 programs in the Philippines, separate their eleventh and twelfth grade, as it may lead them to continue
tracks are now being provided in the last two years of basic following the academic route they decided to take before
education [5]. There are lots of opportunities available to make college or move to a different academic field of study for their
it possible for students to find themselves ready for the courses undergraduate [9]. Also, their skills, potential career path, the
they need to pursue later in college. For example, a student who choice of their parents, peer pressure, and personal preferences
completes the accounting business management (ABM) strand are among these variables that will influence the choice of
in the senior high school academic track is now compelled to students on what college course they will take apart from their
take extra classes if the student wishes to enroll in a college Senior High School strand.
major in Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics Career guidance programs began in the Philippines when the
(STEM) [6]. These additional sessions, now referred to as Philippine government became concerned by the rising number
"bridging classes," are usually taken during the first year of of unemployed college graduates and those who were working
college or for a couple of weeks before college begins. Such in areas not relevant to their specialization [10]. The country's
additional senior years, however, will better prepare graduates unemployment rate is frequently associated with the misfit
for the job market, especially if the next stage of tertiary graduates generated by universities and colleges and the
education is not to be pursued. workforce required by various companies [8]. Many high
Senior High School will have track subjects intended to school students select the wrong course and add to the levels of
strengthen immediate work or entrepreneurship skills and core unemployment levels of recent college students [8].
subjects of college readiness. Students will also follow four The lack of career knowledge from the students and the
career tracks: academic, technical-vocational-livelihood, wrong choices were found to be the most significant contributor
sports, and art and design. This is intended to help them to the problem of unemployment and work mismatch and
determine what path they want to take after graduation, along underemployment in the country. The Labor Force Survey
with a greater knowledge of the needs of the community and report conducted in January 2012 reported, that there are
industry. approximately 7.1 million underemployed Filipinos, or 19.4
Mismatch is crucial because academic outcomes and later percent underemployment due to a congested basic education
job market and other life events can be affected. For example, system and unaided career decision-making [10]. There is a
an overmatched student could fall and drop out, or maybe they need for an improved educational system and career guidance
might face the challenge and do well then, they would have activities with the provided facts that will help students choose
done otherwise. More fundamentally, the effects of mismatch the right career obligation based on their interest and
(if any) inform our awareness of the role of human capital competence, as well as strengthening market demand.
development. Research also reveals that one of the main reasons why
By attending a college of much higher, or much lower, students falter in college is the disparity between their high
quality and indicated by her abilities, the ability of the students school experiences and college expectations. Many first-year
could indicate the mismatch. The literature applies to students find that their college courses differ drastically from
overmatching (think over-achieving) in the first case and their high school courses [11]. College teachers require
undermatching (think under-achieving) in the second case. students to conclude, analyze findings, examine inconsistent
More recently studies undermatch has come into the spotlight source papers, accept evidence statements, solve complex
[7]. problems that do not have a straightforward answer, draw
Various factors influence the undecidability of learners in conclusions, offer explanations, conduct research, and
making career choices. One of which is family-related generally think deeply about how they're being taught [12].
concerns. The study revealed that Filipino immigrants and College classes are now going at a quicker pace, often pressing
non-immigrants depend heavily on the decision-making of their students to read books in the same length of time it took them in
families [8]. There only several researches done to investigate high school to read just one.
the effectiveness of the career track used in Philippine students,
even the variables that influence Filipino students' career III. RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
choice [8]. This gives us an understanding of how to help our The purpose of this study was to determine whether there
students find the best choices for jobs and course options they was a mismatch between the enrolled strand of the students
need to pursue in the future. Because of their interests and who graduated from SY 2017 – 2018 to SY 2018 – 2019 and
skills, students are not sufficiently reliant on what course to their enrolled courses in college. This section highlighted the
choose, but because of the expectation that these courses will sample and sampling technique, population, sample and
include work in the future. Besides, students are selected to get sampling procedures, data collection, ethical issues, and data
a career that they hope in the future will have higher-paying analysis procedures that were used to gather information from
jobs. In other words, in a career route, their concern is not
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology
CiiT International Journal of Data Mining and Knowledge Engineering, Vol 12, No 10 - 12, October - December 2020 158
the samples. This study utilized a descriptive research is perfect. Under this track, you can select electives from the
methodology. various academic strands. These subjects include Humanities,
Social Sciences, Applied Economics, Disaster Preparedness,
Sample and Sampling Technique
Organization, and Management [13]. The strands that have
This research was carried out in Narra National High School. fewer (14, 14) graduates are Agri-Fishery Arts (TVL-AFA),
The respondents of the study were the graduates from SY 2017 Industrial Arts (TVL-IA)(8, 15), and Arts and Design (13, 20),
– 2018 to SY 2018 – 2020 except for those who have not as noted. The Arts and Design Track prepares learners who
enrolled in college. The complete enumeration sampling want to get a creative job from amongst the tracks offered in the
technique was used in this study. The percentage of responses, K12 curriculum [14]. This reason suggests why this strand
particularly those students who are untraceable, would not invites just a few enrollees since it allows you to have a passion
probably considered. Also, those who have not enrolled in for artistic endeavors. This track is for learners with a passion
college were not considered and were excluded from the for the arts [15]. The Technical-Vocational-Livelihood strand
number of samples as they do not meet the criteria to participate tends to have fewer enrollees. Likely, the choices of students to
in the study enroll in vocational or general high schools would be
Data Collection influenced by vocational preferences. Since the value structures
A letter of request from the school principal was obtained by and the interests of individuals reflect professional interests,
the researchers. The data necessary, such as the enrolled strand, certainly, enrolling in an educational path that is incompatible
and the course enrolled in college by graduates who graduated with one's professional interests imposes a greater degree of
from SY 2017-2018 to SY 2018-2019 was attained through the psychological costs on individuals than educational choice and
record of the school registrar. For question number five (5), professional interest are perfectly matched [16].
only those students who were not enrolled under their high
school strand of the chosen school were involved in the
Focused-Grouped Discussion.
Statistical Treatment and Data Analysis
Frequency counts were used to determine and describe the
student's strand and course enrolled. Raw data were grouped
into a frequency distribution, Mean was utilized to find out the
average or centrality of percentile scores. For the qualitative
part of the study, thematic coding and ranking were employed.
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology
CiiT International Journal of Data Mining and Knowledge Engineering, Vol 12, No 10 - 12, October - December 2020 159
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology
CiiT International Journal of Data Mining and Knowledge Engineering, Vol 12, No 10 - 12, October - December 2020 160
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology
CiiT International Journal of Data Mining and Knowledge Engineering, Vol 12, No 10 - 12, October - December 2020 161
[3] I. C. Grado, K-12 Educational Track, Slideshare, 2016. Corazon A. Quintos is presently enrolled at Centro
[4] SEAMOEO INNOTECH, "K to 12 Toolkit, Resource Guide for Teacher Escolar University, Manila, Philippines with the degree
Educators, School Administrators, and Teachers. Standards for Success," of doctor of philosophy in science education. Her
Southeast Asian Ministers of Education Organization (SEAMEO) and bachelor’s degree (Bachelor of Secondary Education
Regional Center for Educational Innovation and Training (INNOTECH), Major in General Science) was taken at the Western
2012. Philippines University at Aborlan, Palawan, and her
[5] Philippine Basic Education, "Philippine Basic Education," 12 July 2012. master’s degree (Master of Arts in Education, Major in
[Online]. Available: Teaching Science) at the Holy Trinity University, Puerto
https://www.philippinesbasiceducation.us/2012/07/tale-of-two-curricula. Princesa City, Palawan, Philippines. She is a Senior High School teacher in the
html. [Accessed 14 September 2020]. Narra National High School handling Physics and Practical Research II
[6] Philippine Basic Education, "Philippine Basic Education," Philippine subjects. Ms. Quintos is a research adviser of Science Investigatory Projects
Basic Education, 20 August 2018. [Online]. Available: (SIP) of varied studies that have been competing nationally and internationally.
https://www.philippinesbasiceducation.us/2018/08/wrong-track-in-senio She has published several studies in international journals. She also has
r-high-school.html. [Accessed 14 September 2020]. presented her research in different conferences locally, division colloquial,
[7] W. Bowen, M. Chingos and M. McPherson, "Crossing the Finish Line: regional summits, and even national research summit conferences.
Completing College at America’s Public Universities," Princeton
University Press, New Jersey, 2009. Dennis G. Caballes finished his bachelor’s degree in
[8] N. T. Pascual, "Factors Affecting High School Students’ Career education in March 2002 at Philippine Normal
Preference: A Basis for Career Planning Program," International Journal University, Philippines, and Master of Arts in Teaching
of Sciences: Basic and Applied Research (IJSBAR), vol. Volume 16, no. General Science and Doctor of Philosophy in Science
1, pp. pp 1-14, 2014. Education Major in Biology in March 2006 and 2009
[9] Jalcobia and e. al, "The comparison of senior high school track and respectively both from de la salle university,
college program preferences and the factors affecting college course Philippines. He acquired his postdoctoral course in
decisions of selected ABM Students of the polytechnic university of the Total Quality Management in Higher Education from
Philippines," Polytechnic University of the Philippines, 2018. Centro Escolar University, Manila, Philippines. He is a
[10] R. S. Braza and R. M. Guillo Jr., "Socio-Demographic Characteristics and faculty member of the graduate programs in various colleges and universities
Career Choice of Private Secondary School Students," Asia Pacific such as in De La Salle-College of Saint Benilde, Centro Escolar University, the
Journal of Multidisciplinary Research, vol. Vol. 3, no. No. 4, pp. 78-84, National Teachers College, Chiang Kai Shek College, and Ateneo De Manila
2015. University. He has published several books in science for senior high school
[11] D. Conley, K. Aspenren, O. Stout and D. Veach, "College Board and college students. His international publication entitled “Conceptual Change
Advanced Placement best practices course study report," Educational in Biology Education” is now being used and marketed in Germany and
Policy Improvement Center, 2006. Lithuania. Dr. Caballes is a member of the most prestigious research
[12] National Research Council, "Learning and understanding: Improving organization in the Philippines - the national research council where he serves
advanced study of mathematics and science in U.S. high schools," as membership director for cluster 1 under the division of governmental,
National Academies Press, Washington, DC, 2002. education, and international policy. He is also a lifetime member of the
[13] Edukasyon.ph, "Edukasyon.ph," [Online]. Available: Philippine Society for Microbiology, Philippine Astronomical Society,
https://edukasyon.ph.com. [Accessed 26 October 2020]. Philippine Association of Chemistry Teachers, and Philippine Physics Society
[14] CIIT: College of Arts and Technology, "CIIT: College of Arts and to name a few.
Technology," 24 February 2020. [Online]. Available:
https://www.ciit.edu.ph/arts-and-design-track. [Accessed 26 October Edheson M. Gapad is currently the Principal II of
2020]. Sandoval National High School, Narra, Palawan. He
[15] Endurun Colleges, "Endurun Colleges," [Online]. Available: obtained his Bachelor of Secondary Education Major In
https://www.enduruncolleges.com/senior-high-strand. [Accessed 5 General Science in April 2006 at Palawan State
November 2020]. University. He also acquired complete academic
[16] R. Monceda, "Academia," [Online]. Available: requirements in teaching science at holy trinity
https://www.academia.edu. [Accessed 4 November 2020]. university.
[17] J. Mateo, "Press Reader," 3 May 2018. [Online]. Available: Mr. Gapad attended several instructional and supervisory
https://www.pressreader.com/philippines/the-philippine-star/20180503/2 trainings and conferences. He has been joining research forums including the
81818579453032. [Accessed 4 November 2020]. Schools Division of Palawan research colloquial, DepEd-MIMAROPA
[18] M. Dimla, "A Case Study on the course mismatch on Accounting, regional research summit, and national conference of basic education
Business and Management Graduates," Academia, 2018. researchers.
[19] D. T. Conley, "The Challenge of College Readiness," Association for
Supervision and Curriculum Development, vol. 64, no. 7, pp. 23-29, Marianne R. Valdez, Teacher I of Narra national high
2007. school attained her Bachelor of Secondary Education
[20] J. Santos, L. C. Blas, A. J. Panganiban, K. M. Reyes and J. C. Sayo, Major In English in April 2006 at Western Philippines
"Alignment of Senior High School Strand in College Course," SSRN, University.
2019. Ms. Valdez already attended research forums including
[21] J. Punongbayan, "[Opinion] Why Senior High School Needs Urgent the school's division of Palawan research colloquial. For
Fising," Rappler, 2019. several years, she has been an English critic of
[22] J. C.-o. Moneva, "Preferences in Senior High School Tracks of the Grade researches and language editor which has been
10 Students," IRA International Journal of Education and presented nationally and internationally.
Multidisciplinary Studies, vol. 15, no. 5, p. 167, 2019.
[23] A. C. Gaurantz, O. M. Hurwitz and J. Smith, "Shifting college majors in
response to advanced placement exam sores," National Bureau of
Economic Research NBER Working Paper, vol. 22841, pp. 1-57, 2016.
[24] K. Witko, K. M. K. Bernes and A. and Bardick, " Senior high school
career planning: What students want," Journal of Educational Enquiry,
vol. 6, no. 1, pp. 34-49, 2005.
ISSN 0974-9683/CIIT–IJ-8102/06/$20/$100 © 2020 CiiT Published by the Coimbatore Institute of Information Technology